The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
22. In view of the aforesaid consensual arrangement, that has been arrived at in the connected proceedings, this Court is not inclined to pass any further orders in the present petitions at this stage. The respondents are directed to comply with the aforesaid consent order dated 06.05.2026.
23. However, it is made clear that if the aforesaid consensual arrangement falters, or if it is not implemented, or departed from, this Court shall examine and deal with the contempt allegations on merits, inter alia, in respect of the original default. In such situation, the petitioners shall be at liberty to revive the present petitions.
24. The petitions stand disposed of in the above terms. Pending applications also stand disposed of.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Judgment pronounced on: 01.07.2026
+
CONT.CAS(C) 740/2022 and CM APPLs.31626/2022, 9325/2024
KAMLESH PANWAR & ORS.
.....Petitioners
versus
SVR CHANDRA SHEKHAR & ORS.
.....Respondents
CONT.CAS(C) 1365/2022 and CM APPLs.53980/2022, 9322/2024
KAMLESH PANWAR AND ANR
.....Petitioners
versus
SH SVR CHANDRA SHEKAR CEO DELHI CANTONMENT
BOARD AND ANRT
.....Respondent
CONT.CAS(C) 1587/2023 and CM APPL.9328/2024
REENA KUMAR GAUR AND ORS
.....Petitioners
versus
SH KAPIL GOYAL AND ORS
.....Respondents
CONT.CAS(C) 191/2023 and CM APPL.9324/2024
AJIMOL JESTINE
.....Petitioner
versus
SHRI S.V.R. CHANDRA SHEKHAR & ANR.
.....Respondents
+
+
+
Presence:
Dr. Monika Arora, Advocate along with Mr. Subhrodeep Saha, Ms.
Anamika Thakur and Mr. Abhinav Verma, Advocates for Petitioners.
Mr. Nalin Kohli, Sr. Advocate along with Mr Ayuushman Aroraa,
Mr. Ankur Mishra, Mr. Gurpreet Singh and Mr. Gaurav Aggarwal,
Advocates for Respondent Nos.1 to 3.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SACHIN DATTA
JUDGMENT
KUMAR PATEL
18:59:54
CONT.CAS(C) 740/2022 and Connected Matters
1.
The present petitions have been filed by the petitioners alleging wilful
disobedience/ non-compliance of the directions contained in the order dated
29.06.2022 passed in W.P. (C) 9645/2022 and order dated 07.07.2022
passed in W.P. (C) 10290/2022. The operative direction therein reads as
under:
“it is made clear that the services of the Petitioners shall not be
disturbed during the pendency of the dispute before the Tribunal,
without compliance of Section 33 of the Industrial Dispute Act,
1947.”
2.
Although the factual conspectus is identical across the matters, for the
sake of convenience, CONT.CAS(C) 740/2022 is taken as the lead matter
for the purpose of reference to the factual conspectus and relevant
documents.
3.
The factual background as set forth by the petitioners, who were
employed as ‘nurses’ by respondent no.1/ Delhi Cantonment Board (DCB)
at respondent no.2/Cantonment General Hospital, is that the DCB issued
advertisements in leading newspapers inviting applications for recruitment
to the posts of Senior Nurse and Staff Nurse/ Nurse Grade A. The petitioners
applied pursuant thereto and underwent an open recruitment process. The
selection procedure comprised a written test and interview for the post of
Nurse Grade A and for the post of Senior Nurse, eligibility required five
years’ experience as Staff Nurse and an interview. Upon clearing the
recruitment process, the petitioners were appointed by the DCB on
contractual basis.
4.
The petitioners’ contracts of appointment were renewed from time to
time by the respondent Hospital, at times, with retrospective effect.
KUMAR PATEL
18:59:54
CONT.CAS(C) 740/2022 and Connected Matters
5.
Subsequently, the respondent/ DCB engaged workers of outsourced
contractor/s through the GeM portal to replace the petitioners, who are
stated to be direct contract employees of the respondent. According to the
petitioners, such replacement amounts to termination of their services.
Aggrieved thereby, the petitioners raised an industrial dispute seeking
regularization of their services, payment of salary differentials as per the
applicable pay scale and maintenance of status quo in their service
conditions.
6.
On 27.06.2022, the Assistant Labour Commissioner (Central),
Ministry of Labour and Employment, Union of India, issued a notice to the
DCB in context of the industrial dispute raised by the petitioners, advising
adherence to Section 33 of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 with regard to
service conditions of the petitioners/ workmen.
7.
Despite the pendency of the dispute, the petitioners were persuaded to
switch to engagement through contractors. Aggrieved, the petitioners filed
W.P. (C) 9645/2022, seeking, inter alia, directions to the DCB to maintain
status quo as regards the service conditions of the petitioners.
8.
W.P. (C) 9645/2022 was disposed of vide order dated 29.06.2022 (of
which contempt is alleged in the present proceedings), directing as under:
“9. The Court has perused the communication dated 27th June,
2022 therein the Government of India has clearly advised the
management i.e., Delhi Cantonment Board to adhere to the
provisions of Section 33 of the Industrial Dispute Act, 1947
[hereinafter, "the Act"] with respect to the service condition of
workmen involved in the dispute.
10. In light of the above, since the Petitioners have already
raised an industrial dispute, it is made clear that the services of
the Petitioners shall not be disturbed during the pendency of
the dispute before the Tribunal, without compliance of Section
KUMAR PATEL
18:59:54
CONT.CAS(C) 740/2022 and Connected Matters
33 of the Industrial Dispute Act, 1947.
11. With the above directions, the present petition is disposed
of.
12. Both the parties are free to make their submissions before
the Assistant Labour Commissioner on 30th June, 2022. All
rights and contentions of the parties are left open.”
9.
Further, during the course of proceedings on 30.06.2022, the
Assistant Labour Commissioner (Central) again observed:
“In the meantime, Management is advised to adhere to the
provision of Section 33 of the I.D.Act,1947 during pendency
of the present dispute.”
10.
Notwithstanding the above, on 14.07.2022, the petitioners were
informed via telephonic communication from respondent no.3/ Nursing-incharge, Cantonment General Hospital, of the termination of their services
and were directed not to report for duty. On 15.07.2022 the petitioners’
names were deleted from the attendance register by respondent no.3.
11.
It is against this backdrop that the present petitions have been filed.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE PARTIES
12.
It is the case of the petitioners that the termination of their services,
notwithstanding the categorical directions of this Court in the order dated
29.06.2022, amounts to deliberate and willful contempt.
13.
It is submitted that the petitioners were engaged against a vacant post
and had been continuously employed without interruption since their initial
appointment, with their contracts being extended from time to time, often
with retrospective effect. The petitioners continued to perform their duties
irrespective of the contractual period and the respondent consistently paid
their salaries.
KUMAR PATEL
18:59:54
CONT.CAS(C) 740/2022 and Connected Matters
14.
It is contended that the termination of services of the petitioners was
effected by the respondent in retaliation to the industrial dispute raised by
the petitioners.
15.
Relying upon the judgment rendered by the Supreme Court in Jaipur
Zila Sahakari Bhoomi Vikas Bank Ltd. v. Ram Gopal Sharma & Ors.,
2002, 2 SCC 244, it has been contended that the discharge of workmen
without prior permission of the Labour Court is in violation of Section 33 of
the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947. Such violation, it is submitted, in the
present case, amounts to contempt of the order dated 29.06.2022 passed in
W.P. (C) 9645/2022 and order dated 07.07.2022 passed in W.P. (C)
10290/2022.
16.
Per contra, learned counsel for the respondents submits that the
cessation of employment of the petitioners was automatic, arising from the
contractual stipulation. The expiry of a fixed-term contract cannot be
construed as an employer initiated action so as to attract the rigors of Section
33 of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947.
17.
Relying upon the judgments rendered in BA Security Agents
Employees Union v. Regional Labour Commissioner & Ors. [W.P.(C) No.
8372/2003] and Delhi Pradesh Rajdani Mazdoor Union (regd.) v. DDA
(CW (P) 1305/1991), it is submitted that where the employment ceases by
efflux of time, the protection under Section 33 of the Industrial Disputes
Act, 1947 is not attracted. It is further submitted that Section 33 does not
impose an absolute prohibition on the employer’s power to alter service
conditions.
18.
It is contended that the decision to engage an outsourcing agency for
paramedical staff at the respondent Hospital/ Cantonment General Hospital,
KUMAR PATEL
18:59:54
CONT.CAS(C) 740/2022 and Connected Matters
was an administrative decision, in accordance with the extant policy and in
the interest of the Institution. Staffing patterns and outsourcing decisions fall
within the discretion of the executive domain.
19.
In support of these contentions, learned counsel for the respondents
have relied upon the following judgments:
i. Parry & Co. Ltd vs P.C. Pal & Ors., 1968 SCC OnLine SC 16;
ii. Management of Apparel Export Promotion Council vs. Surya
Prakash, 2011 SCC OnLine Del 86; and
iii. Central Warehousing Corporation vs. Govt. of India and
Others, 2022 SCC OnLine Del 1663.
20.
It is important to take note of certain events that have transpired after
the present petitions were heard. The Delhi Cantonment Board/ respondent
in the present petitions, had filed W.P.(C) 5411/2024 and W.P.(C)
1293/2024, assailing the order dated 30.10.2023 passed by the Central
Government Industrial Tribunal cum Labour Court, Delhi-I in Misc.
Applications moved by the said respondent in ID Nos. 258/2022 and
116/2023, which pertain to the industrial disputes, as aforesaid, raised by the
present petitioners.
21.
On 06.05.2026, with the consent of the parties, the following order
came to be passed by this Court in W.P.(C) 5411/2024 and W.P.(C)
1293/2024:
“1. The present petitions have been filed by the petitioner
assailing order dated 30.10.2023, passed by the Central
Government Industrial Tribunal cum Labour Court, Delhi-I in
Misc. Applications moved by the petitioner in ID Nos.116/2023
and 258/2022.
2. When these petitions came up first time for hearing on
30.01.2024 [ in W.P(C) 1293/2024] and 16.04.2024 [in W.P(C)
KUMAR PATEL
18:59:54
CONT.CAS(C) 740/2022 and Connected Matters
5411/2024], this Court directed that the operation of the
impugned order dated 30.10.2023 shall be kept in abeyance till
the next date of hearing. The said order was passed considering
the matter requires further consideration and without
substantially hearing the respondents. Subsequently, this Court
has had the benefit of hearing the elaborate arguments addressed
by the respective parties.
3. In the backdrop of the same, after some hearing, learned
standing counsel for the petitioner (on instructions, as received on
behalf of the petitioner from Mr. Ankur Mishra i.e., legal
consultant of the petitioner) and learned counsel for the
respondents have agreed to the following arrangement: (i) As an interim measure, the respondents shall be inducted
into employment through the concerned contractor, at par
with similarly situated persons who were earlier working with
the petitioner, prior to the concerned contractor being
appointed by the Delhi Cantonment Board (DCB).
(ii) It is agreed that for all purposes, the respondents shall be
treated at par with the employees who have joined the
concerned contractor w.e.f. 01.07.2022, i.e., the date with
effect from which the concerned contractor was initially
appointed by DCB.
(iii) the aforesaid arrangement shall be without prejudice to
the rights and contentions in the present petition as also in the
pending labour dispute inter-alia as regards the claim of the
respondents on account of (a) regularization; (b) back-wages
and (c) continuity of service. All rights and contentions of the
respondents in this regard are expressly reserved.
(iv) The parties agree that proceedings pending before the
Regional Labour Commissioner (Central), Government of
India in ID Nos.116 of 2023 and 258/2022, respectively
(statement of claim with regard to which is filed as AnnexureB to the present petition) shall be expedited.
It is agreed that the parties shall not take any adjournment in
the said proceedings.
The concerned Regional Labour Commissioner is requested
to expedite the proceedings and make an endeavour to
conclude the same as expeditiously as possible and preferably
KUMAR PATEL
18:59:54
CONT.CAS(C) 740/2022 and Connected Matters
within a period of six months from today.
4. It is agreed that the above arrangement shall be implemented
within a period of 2 weeks from today. For this purpose, the
Petitioner shall coordinate between the respondents and the
concerned contractor.
5. Subject to the above arrangement being implemented, this Court
shall consider disposing of the present petition in terms thereof on
the next date of hearing. Again, all rights and contentions of the
respondents as regards their substantive entitlement inter-alia as
regards regularization back-wages and continuity of service shall
remain reserved even in such a situation. The rights and
contentions of the petitioner shall also stand reserved.
6. List for further consideration on 15.10.2026.”
22.
In view of the aforesaid consensual arrangement, that has been arrived
at in the connected proceedings, this Court is not inclined to pass any further
orders in the present petitions at this stage. The respondents are directed to
comply with the aforesaid consent order dated 06.05.2026.
23.
However, it is made clear that if the aforesaid consensual arrangement
falters, or if it is not implemented, or departed from, this Court shall
examine and deal with the contempt allegations on merits, inter alia, in
respect of the original default. In such situation, the petitioners shall be at
liberty to revive the present petitions.
24.
The petitions stand disposed of in the above terms. Pending
applications also stand disposed of.
SACHIN DATTA, J
JULY 1, 2026/ss
KUMAR PATEL
18:59:54
CONT.CAS(C) 740/2022 and Connected Matters
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review