Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:39617
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH
AT SHIMLA
CMPMO No. 708 of 2023
Decided on: 14.9.2026
Kamla Devi
… Petitioner
Versus
Kiran Kumari
…Respondents
_____________________________ ______________
Coram
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Virender Singh, Judge
Whether approved for reporting?
___________________________________________________
For the Petitioner:
Mr. Sative Chauhan, Advocate.
For the Respondents :
Mr.
Narender
Advocate.
Virender Singh, Judge (oral)
Guleria,
Petitioner Kamla Devi has filed the present
petition, under Article 227 of the Constitution of India,
against the order dated 8.9.2023, passed by the Court of
learned
Civil
Judge,
Karsog,
District
Mandi,
H.P.
(hereinafter referred to as ‘the trial Court’), in Civil
Miscellaneous Application
No. 115 of 2023, titled as,
‘Kirna Kumari versus Kamla Devi’.
2.
By way of order dated 8.9.2023, the learned trial
Court has party allowed the application, under Section
2026:HHC:39617
151 CPC, moved by the present petitioner, who has been
arrayed as defendant, in the lis, by permitting the
petitioner to carry out necessary repair/construction, in
dwelling house, existing over the suit land.
3.
Vide order dated 8.9.2023, the learned trial
Court has partly allowed the application, to the extent of
making repair/construction,
in the ground floor and
slab of the septic tank, which is used as floor of kitchen.
The Trial Court has specifically declined the permission
to carry out the repair of shop.
4.
For the sake of convenience, parties to the lis are
hereinafter referred to, in the same manner, in which,
they were referred to, by the learned trial Court.
5.
Necessary
facts,
as
borne
out
from
the
documents, annexed with the petition, may be summed
up, as under:
Plaintiff Kiran Kumari
has filed a suit for
permanent prohibitory and mandatory injunction on the
ground
that
the
land
bearing
Khata/Khatoni
No.
291/375, Kitta No. 4, measuring 00-13-01 bigha,
situated in Mohal Churag/242, Tehsil Karsog, District
2026:HHC:39617
Mandi (hereinafter referred to as suit land) is recorded in
the ownership of the defendant and other co-sharers, as
per Jamabandi for the year 2018-19, and the same is in
the physical possession of the plaintiff, defendant, and
other co-sharers.
5.1
The plaintiff and defendant are daughters of late
Shri Keshav Ram, who has executed Will No. 128 on
21.6.2007. Thereafter, on 20.12.2012,
Keshav Ram
expired and the mutation of the land was not entered as
per the Will, as their brother had challenged the Will, by
way of Civil Suit No. 39 of 2013.
5.2
On the basis of the above facts, it has been
asserted that due to the said challenge, name of the
plaintiff could not be recorded in the column of
ownership of the revenue record, whereas, name of
defendant was recorded in the column of ownership and
possession, on the basis of family settlement, executed
by the father of the parties to the lis.
5.3
It is the further case of the plaintiff that over the
portion of the suit land, there is an old house
constructed by the father of the parties to the lis and
2026:HHC:39617
some portion of the same was lying vacant. From
25.4.2021, defendant has started the construction of her
house, over the vacant portion of the suit land, and on
30.4.2021, the plaintiff got vacated the shop from the
tenant, as she wants to run her own business, but
defendant had thrown her goods and proclaimed that
she will not allow her to do any business, in the said
premises.
5.4
On the basis of the above facts, the plaintiff has
sought the relief for permanent prohibitory injunction,
restraining the construction over the suit land, and in
addition to this, a relief of mandatory injunction has also
been sought, directing the defendant to demolish the
construction, if any, raised during the pendency of the
lis.
6.
When, put to notice, the suit has been contested
by the defendant, by pleading that the defendant is not
raising any fresh construction. According to her, a small
portion of the old structure was damaged and was in a
dilapidated condition, as such, the repair was necessary.
She has asserted that she is in settled possession of the
2026:HHC:39617
suit land, after the death and even during the lifetime of
Shri Keshav Ram, who had executed the Will dated
21/5/1995.
6.1
According to the defendant, suit of the plaintiff is
not maintainable; she has no cause of action to file the
suit; she is estopped to file the suit on account of her
own act and conduct; and suit is bad for want of better
particulars.
6.2
The possession of the plaintiff over the suit land
has been disputed by asserting that the entire suit land
is in possession of the defendant, and plaintiff is having
no right over any part of the suit land. However, it has
been admitted that the plaintiff and defendant are
daughters of Shri Keshav Ram.
6.3
It is further the case of the defendant that as per
the gift deed, executed by Shri Keshav Ram, in favour of
the plaintiff, on 21.5.1995, she is owner in possession of
land bearing 00-00-17 bighas of suit land. Other
allegations have been controverted. Thus, a prayer has
been made to dismiss the suit.
7.
2026:HHC:39617
Along with the suit, the plaintiff has also filed an
application under Order 39 Rules 1 and 2 of CPC, which
was dismissed by the learned trial Court.
8.
Thereafter, the said order was assailed by
plaintiff Kiran Kumari, before the court of learned
Additional District Judge-1, Mandi, District Mandi, H.P.
The said appeal was allowed by passing the order to
restrain the defendant from carrying out construction,
over the suit land.
8.
The said order was unsuccessfully assailed by
defendant Kamla Devi, before this Court, however, her
petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India,
was dismissed. The said order was, thereafter, assailed
by way of Special Leave Petition, before the Hon’ble
Supreme Court, but the same was again dismissed.
However, liberty has been provided to the defendant to
move the application, for carrying out repairs to the
existing structure, by passing the following orders:
“No case is made out to interfere with the impugned
orders which are interim orders. However, if the
petitioner wants to carry out repairs to the existing
structure
in
her
possession,
she
may
make
2026:HHC:39617
necessary application to the trial Court in that
behalf.
If such application is made, the trial Court shall
consider it in accordance with law as expeditiously
as possible.
Subject to the above clarification, Leave Petition is
dismissed.”
9.
Subsequently, the defendant has moved the
application, under Section 151 CPC, which was partly
allowed by the learned trial court, assailing which order,
the defendant Kamla Devi has filed the present petition,
before this Court, mainly on the ground that the learned
trial court has wrongly exercised the jurisdiction vested
in it, as the Hon’ble Supreme Court has also permitted
the defendant to carry out repairs to the existing
structure in her possession, asserting the need of urgent
repair. The impugned order has further been assailed on
the ground that the report of architect and the
photographs clearly demonstrate that urgent repair was
necessary, which was denied by the learned trial court.
11.
On the basis of the grounds taken in the petition,
Mr. Sative Chauhan, learned counsel, appearing for the
defendant, has prayed that the present petition may
2026:HHC:39617
kindly be allowed by allowing the application under
Section 151 of the CPC, filed by the defendant, before
the learned trial court, and the order dated 8.9.2023
may kindly be modified accordingly.
12.
Per contra,
Mr. Narender Guleria, learned
counsel, appearing for the plaintiff, has supported the
order passed by the learned trial court and highlighted
that the Hon’ble Supreme Court has also provided the
window to the defendant only to carry out the necessary
repair to the existing structure, which has been allowed
by the learned trial court, but under the garb of
application, under Section 151 CPC, the defendant
wants to raise further construction of the house. As
such, a prayer has been made to dismiss the petition.
13.
Heard.
14.
Perusal of the record shows that by way of
application, under Section 151 CPC, the defendant has
made a prayer before the learned trial court to permit
her to carry out repair/reconstruction. The said prayer
has been made on the ground that the dwelling
house/structure has outlived its life. The building in
2026:HHC:39617
question is two-storeyed, situated in front of bus stop,
Churag. The ground floor is being used as residence. On
the first floor, there are two shops abutting to the road
and on the back side of the RCC slab, columns have
been built recently by the defendant.
15.
According to the defendant, the walls of the
ground floor are made of mud and stone and are likely to
collapse. As such, she has sought the permission to
repair the said wall and to raise construction over the
existing structure.
16.
Along with the application, she has also annexed
the technical report of the architect, in which, it has
been mentioned that in case, the repair is not allowed,
the building may collapse.
17.
This application has been contested by the
defendant. The learned trial court thereafter, has
considered the application and partly allowed the same,
which has been assailed before this Court.
18.
In
this case,
this
Court
vide
order dated
21.7.2026, has directed the Executive Engineer (B&R),
HP PWD, Karsog to visit the spot and submit a report.
2026:HHC:39617
Relevant Para 7 of the said report is reproduced as
under:
“In compliance with the order dated 21.07.2026
passed by the Hon'ble High Court of Himachal
Pradesh, I visited and inspected the property in
dispute on 10.08.2026 at 2:30 p.m. in the presence of
both parties. On the basis of the spot inspection, it is
observed that approximately 75% of the disputed
property
has
been
reconstructed
with
an
RCC
structure, besides the repair/renovation works carried
out in the basement and the reconstruction of one
shop on the ground floor, as detailed hereinabove.
Only one shop on the ground floor was found to be in
the old/existing condition, with no substantial repair
or reconstruction work having been noticed therein.
The geo-tagged photographs taken during the spot
inspection are enclosed herewith as part of this report.
The report is accordingly submitted before the Hon'ble
High Court of Himachal Pradesh for kind perusal.”
19.
The relief, which has been granted to the
defendant, by the learned trial court, is confined only to
the
repair
or
reconstruction
of
the
walls,
which
developed cracks in the ground floor and the slab of the
septic tank, which is used as floor of the kitchen, and as
per the report submitted by the Executive Engineer,
HPPWD, the defendant has
reconstructed 75% of the
disputed property with RCC structure, which is in clear
2026:HHC:39617
violation of the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court,
as referred to above, as Hon’ble Supreme Court has
simply permitted the defendant to carry out repairs to
the existing structure in her possession.
20.
The term 'repair' and 'reconstruction' are not
synonyms. When, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has
specifically
directed
the
defendant
to
move
the
application to carry out repairs to the existing structure
in her possession, then, the window, which has been
provided to her, by the learned trial court, has cleverly
been misused by the defendant, as she has raised 75%
of new construction over the subject matter of the lis. As
such, she is not entitled for any relief.
21.
Considering the above facts, the present petition
is dismissed and the impugned order, passed by the
learned trial Court is upheld.
22.
It
is
further
clarified
that
whatsoever
reconstruction raised by the defendant, in violation of
the directions of the learned trial court, would be subject
to the final outcome of the lis, pending between the
parties.
23.
2026:HHC:39617
The pending application(s), if any, are also
disposed of.
24.
Any of the observations, made hereinabove, shall
not be taken as an expression of opinion, on the merits
of the case, as these observations, are confined, only, to
the disposal of the present application.
8.9.2026
Kalpana
(Virender Singh)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review