Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CMPMO Nos. 588,of 2025
Reserved on
27.02.2026
Date of decision : 12.03.2026.
Smt. Kamla & Ors
...Petitioners.
Versus
Ajay Sautha & another
...Respondents
Coram:
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Romesh Verma, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?1
For the petitioners
:
Mr. B.S. Chauhan, Sr. Advocate,
with Mr. Sahil Sharma, Advocate.
For respondent No.1
:
Mr. Adarsh Sharma, Advocate.
For respondent No.2.
Mr. Raman Sethi, Advocate,
________________________________________
Romesh Verma, Judge
The present petition arises out of the order dated
28.08.2025, as passed by the learned Additional District Judge(II),
Shimla,
H.P.,
whereby
the
application
filed
by
the
claimants/petitioners for the amendment of the petition has been
ordered to be dismissed.
2.
Brief facts of the case are that the claimants/petitioners
filed petition before the learned Motor Accident Claim Tribunal,
Rohru, District Shimla, H.P. by filing Claim Petition bearing case No.
M.A.C.T/2/2024, titled as Kamla & others vs. Ajay Sauhta & another.
It was claimed in the Claim Petition that Smt. Khali Budha alias
Whether reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
-2- ( 2026:HHC:6968 )
Khimla, wife of Sh. Jai Bahadur Budha (mother of the petitioners)
died in an accident on 10.09.2023 at about 6.00 p.m when she was
returning back to her home after completing her work in a vehicle
bearing No. HP63-7198 (Truck-Tipper). It was stated that driver of
the truck namely Dinesh son of Sh. Ramesh,r/o Sukeda, Nepal, c/o
Ajay Sauhta, r/o VPO Dhar, Tehsil Jubbal, District Shimla, H.P. was
driving the vehicle in a rash and negligent manner and he could not
control it and as a result of which truck fell down from the road in a
ditch. The deceased received serious and grievous injuries on her
head and neck. The successors of deceased Sh. Khali Budha alias
Khimla filed the Claim Petition for the grant of compensation to the
tune of Rs.50,00,000/- (Fifty lacs) alongwith interest at the rate of
9% per annum from the date of the accident till its realization.
3.
The petition was contested by the present respondent
No.2- The New India Assurance Company Ltd. through its Deputy
Manager, Divisional OfÏce, 3rd Floor, Block No.7,SDA Complex,
Shimla,HP. It was categorically submitted by the New India
Assurance Company(Respondent No.2) that the Claim Petition is not
maintainable in its present form. It was stated that the deceased
Driver, who was driving the vehicle No. HP-63-7198 at the time of
accident on 10.09.2023, was not holding any valid and effective
driving licence. It was averred that since driver of the vehicle was not
having any valid and effective driving licence, therefore, there is
-3- ( 2026:HHC:6968 )
gross violation of conditions of insurance policy. It was stated that
the insured vehicle being a heavy goods vehicle (Truck-Tipper)
which was carrying unauthorized gratuitous passengers, was empty
at the time of accident and no goods whatsoever were found loaded
in it at the time of accident. Seven persons including driver were
travelling in this vehicle at the time of accident. Amongst them,
three had died while four other have received injuries.
4.
It is further submitted that this vehicle being heavy
goods vehicle (Tipper) is specifically meant for carrying construction
material like sand and stone etc. and not designed for carrying
passengers and having seating capacity of three person only. It was
further submitted that the owner
had allowed all these persons
being his labourers to travel in this vehicle and has thus knowingly
and willfully disobeyed the terms and conditions of the insurance
policy. Therefore, this is a fundamental breach of the terms and
conditions of the insurance policy, thus liability for payment of
compensation, if any is of the respondent/owner only.
5.
Pursuant to the filing of the reply by the Assurance
Company, the claimants /petitioners
filed an application under
Order 6 Rule 17 C.P.C for the amendment of the claim petition. By
virtue of this application, the petitioners intended to incorporate
para 10 of the claim petition in place of existing para as under:
-4- ( 2026:HHC:6968 )
“Yes, the deceased was employed with the respondent No.1 and
was working as labourer at the site, engaged for the construction
of retaining wall at Khera Kenchi just beneath the main road
alongwith his co-labourers on the fateful day, a vehicle bearing
registration No. HP63-7198, being driven by Dinesh in rash and
negligent manner and as such, could not negotiate the curb and
consequently lost control over the vehicle and rolled down by
crushing the labourers on the spot and rolled down in the deep
gorge about 400-500 mtrs. from the main road. The factum of
accident was reported at Police Station Chirgaon by informant
but his statement under section 154 Cr. P.C. was not recorded as
per his narration. The factum of occurrence was also witnessed
by one Sh. Ashish Sharma who was supervising the construction
work of the retaining wall, but he was not interrogated and
associated by the investigating ofÏcer despite his oral requests
as made to the investigating ofÏcer by him.”
6.
Similarly, applicants/petitioners also intended to
incorporate in place of existing para 23 in the following manner
“The deceased was engaged for the construction of
retaining wall at Khera Kenchi just beneath the main road
alongwith his co-labourers on the fateful day, a vehicle
bearing registration No. HP63-7198, being driven by Dinesh
in rash and negligent manner and as such, could not
negotiate the curb and consequently lost control over the
vehicle and rolled down by crushing the labourers on the
spot and rolled down in the deep gorge about 400-500 mtrs.
from the main road. The factum of accident was reported at
Police Station Chirgaon by informant but his statement
under section 154 Cr. P.C. was not recorded as per his
narration. The factum of occurrence was also witnessed by
one
Sh.
Ashish
Sharma
who
was
supervising
the
-5- ( 2026:HHC:6968 )
construction work of the retaining wall, but he was not
interrogated and associated by the investigating ofÏcer
despite his oral requests as made to the investigating ofÏcer
by him. It is apt to mention here that the deceased sustained
multiple injuries in his entire body and consequently died on
the spot. Postmortem of the deceased was conducted at CHC
Chirgaon, by the doctor concerned. The deceased was hale
and hearty and able bodied person the entire family was
totally depended upon him. Now there is independent source
of income of the petitioners because he was the only earning
hand in the family. After his death the petitioners have
become high and dry and debarred from his love and
affection. The petitioners have spent about 50,000/- to
perform the last rites of the deceased.”
7.
It
was
averred
in
the
application
that
the
applicants/petitioners are rustic labourers and were unable to
understand the language of the court and the contents of the
petition
were
not
read
over
and
explained
to
the
applicants/petitioners at the time of appending their signature
on the claim petition. It is relevant to mention here that the
petition so filed before this learned Tribunal was on the basis of
case FIR, whereas the deceased including co-labourers were
not occupants of the ill-fated vehicle. On the fateful day,
whereas, they were deployed for the construction of retaining
wall beneath the main road, who were crushed by the ill-fated
vehicle, when the same rolled down from the main road. The
factum of accident was witnessed by one Sh. Ashish Sharma
-6- ( 2026:HHC:6968 )
who was present at the place of accident for the purpose of
supervision of the construction work of the retaining wall. It is
apt to mention here that the applicants/petitioners alongwith
co-petitioners were apprised by Sh. Ashish Sharma that the
petitions so filed by applicants/petitioners and their copetitioners have been filed on the basis of case FIR, whereas,
the deceased and co-labourers were not at all occupants in the
vehicle in question, but were crushed under the ill-fated
vehicle.
8.
By the said amendment,the petitioners intended to
incorporate that at the time of the accident, they were not
travelling in the vehicle, however, the deceased including other
co-labourers were deployed for the construction of retaining
wall and they were crushed by ill fated vehicle when the same
rolled down from the main road.
9.
Respondent No.2, Assurance Company filed reply
to the application for the amendment of the claim petition
whereby various objections were taken by the Assurance
Company.
It
was
averred
that
the
application
is
not
maintainable as the trial of the case has already commenced .
The petitioners did not exercise due diligence while seeking the
amendment. Further, it was averred that by means of this
application, the basic structure of the petition shall be changed
-7- ( 2026:HHC:6968 )
and the same shall change the entire nature, cause and
character of the petition. It was further stated in the reply that
the petitioners have instituted the present application in
connivance with the owner of the vehicle in order to save him
from the liability to pay the compensation on the facts and
grounds as mentioned in the claim petition.
10.
The Assurance Company submitted in the reply
that one of the eye witnesses /injured namely Karan, who has
filed claim petition on account of injuries in case MACT No.
4/2024, had lodged an FIR, wherein he has categorically
mentioned that on 10.09.2023 while working on Khashdar road
they were working on Crate Wall in the day time. After finishing
the job at around 6 p.m., in the said tipper Mohamad Tamanna
sat with driver Dinesh in his cabin and rest of all namely Khali
Buda, Padam Thapa, Tilak, Jai Bahadur and Dil Bahadur sat in
the backside body of Tipper. While Dinesh was driving the
tipper rashly and negligently, it steered towards right side and
went down the road about 400-500 meters and they all fell
along with tipper in the ditch. Therefore, the Assurance
Company stated that when the eye witness and claimant
himself had lodged the FIR and filed the Claim Petition and had
disclosed the true and real facts
before the Investigating
-8- ( 2026:HHC:6968 )
Agency, therefore, the story as projected by the Claimants with
respect to Aashish is wrong incorrect and false.
11.
It was averred that the intended amendment
sought to be incorporated and brought by way of amendment in
the claim petition was in their knowledge at the initial stage
when the claim petition was filed. The applicants failed
to
exercise the due diligence and now when the proceedings have
already commenced and respondent No.2 has disclosed its
defence by way of filing the reply, applicants in connivance
with respondent No.1/owner in order to fill up the lacuna and
save him from liability of payment of compensation , has
moved the present application.
12.
Learned Additional District Judge(II) Shimla, H.P.
vide its order dated 28.08.2025, dismissed the application filed
by the claimants/petitioners for the amendment of the claim
petition.
13.
Feeling dissatisfied, the claimants/petitioners have
preferred the present
Constitution
petition Under Article 227
of the
of India for setting aside the order dated
28.08.2025, passed by the learned Additional District Judge(II),
Shimla.H.P.
14.
I have heard the learned counsel for the parties and
have gone through the case file.
-9- ( 2026:HHC:6968 )
15.
It is submitted by Mr. B.S. Chauhan, Sr. Advocate,
assisted by Mr. Sahil Sharma, Advocate that impugned order as
passed by the learned Additional District Judge-II, Shimla is
bad in the eyes of law. Since the case in hand is at the initial
stage and the trial has not commenced, therefore, no prejudice
would be caused to the opposite side in case the proposed
amendment is allowed to be effected. He further submitted that
in case the present amendment is allowed to be incorporated,
the respondents shall get an opportunity to rebut those
averments and parties have yet to prove their case in
accordance with law by leading evidence.
16.
On the other hand, Mr. Raman Sethi, learned
counsel appearing for the Assurance Company has defended
the order as passed by the learned Additional District Judge-II,
Shimla and he has submitted that since prayer sought by the
claimants changes the basic structure of the petition which
goes to the root of the case and there is no due diligence on
behalf of the petitioners and the said amendment is contrary to
the spirit of Order 6 Rule 17 C.PC, therefore, order as passed by
the learned Additional District Judge-II, Shimla is valid in the
eyes of law.
17.
Mr. Adarsh Sharma, Advocate, appearing
respondent No.1 has supported the case of the petitioners.
for
-10- ( 2026:HHC:6968 )
18.
The case of the petitioners/ claimants before the
learned MACT, whereby Claim petition for
the grant of
compensation has been filed is that the mother of the
petitioners died in an accident while travelling in a vehicle
bearing No. HP63-7198 Truck (Tipper), which was being driven
rashly and negligently by its driver Dinesh.
19.
In the claim petition, it has been stated that the
deceased on account of the accident, sustained serious and
grievous injuries on her entire body including injuries on head
and neck and she died on account of said accident and they
sought compensation to the tune of Rs. 50,00,000/- (Rupees
fifty lacs).
20.
The Assurance Company has specifically taken
defence of maintainability of the claim petition on the ground
that insured vehicle was heavy goods vehicle
Truck/Tipper
which was carrying unauthorised gratuitous passengers. Since,
there is breach of the terms and conditions of insurance policy,
therefore, liability for the payment of compensation is of the
owner.
21.
The perusal of the application reveals that now by
way of proposed amendment, the petitioners intend to
incorporate the plea that they were not travelling in the tipper,
however, they were deployed for the construction of retaining
-11- ( 2026:HHC:6968 )
wall beneath the main road where they were crushed by the
illfated vehicle when the same rolled down from the main road.
The provisions of order 6 Rule 17 C.P.C reads as follows:
“Amendment of pleadings.- The Court may at any
stage of the proceedings allow either party to alter or
amend his pleadings in such manner and on such
terms as may be just, and all such amendments shall
be made as may be necessary for the purpose of
determining
the
real
questions
in
controversy
between the parties:
Provided that no application for amendment shall be
allowed after the trial has commenced, unless the
Court comes to the conclusion that in spite of due
diligence, the party could not have raised the matter
before the commencement of trial.”
22.
The provisions provide that no application for
amendment shall be allowed after the trial has commenced
unless the Court comes to the conclusion that inspite of due
deligence, the parties could have raised the matters before the
commencement of the trial.
23.
This Court is of the opinion that in the present
case, the proposed amendment
shall change the very basic
structure of the claim petition. The nature and claim of the
claim petition is being tried to be changed and the admission
which is there in the claim petition is tried to be withdrawn.
-12- ( 2026:HHC:6968 )
24.
The Hon’ble Apex Courts in Civil Appeal No. 2886
of 2012, titled as Basavaraj vs. Indira and others, dated
29.02.2024 while dealing with the amendment application has
held as follows:
“9.
This Court in M. Revanna v. Anjanamma (Dead)
by legal representatives and others11 opined that an
application for amendment may be rejected if it seeks to
introduce totally different, new and inconsistent case or
changes the fundamental character of the suit. Order VI
Rule 17 C.P.C. prevents an application for amendment
after the trial has commenced unless the Court comes to
the conclusion that despite due diligence the party could
not have raised the issue. The burden is on the party
seeking amendment after commencement of trial to
show that in spite of due diligence such amendment
could not be sought earlier. It is not a matter of right.
Paragraph No. 7 thereof is extracted below: “7. Leave to
amend may be refused if it introduces a totally different,
new and inconsistent case, or challenges the
fundamental character of the suit. The proviso to Order 6
Rule 17 CPC virtually prevents an application for
amendment of pleadings from being allowed after the 11
(2019) 4 SCC 332 Page 12 of 15 trial has commenced,
unless the court comes to the conclusion that in spite of
due diligence, the party could not have raised the matter
before the commencement of the trial. The proviso, to an
extent, curtails absolute discretion to allow amendment
at any stage. Therefore, the burden is on the person who
seeks an amendment after commencement of the trial to
show that in spite of due diligence, such an amendment
could not have been sought earlier. There cannot be any
dispute that an amendment cannot be claimed as a
matter of right, and under all circumstances. Though
normally amendments are allowed in the pleadings to
avoid multiplicity of litigation, the court needs to take
into consideration whether the application for
amendment is bona fide or mala fide and whether the
amendment causes such prejudice to the other side
which cannot be compensated adequately in terms of
money.”
-13- ( 2026:HHC:6968 )
10. Initially, the suit was filed for partition and separate
possession. By way of amendment, relief of declaration
of the compromise decree being null and void was also
sought. The same would certainly change the nature of
the suit, which may be impermissible.
12.1 In the case in hand, the compromise decree was
passed on 14.10.2004 in which the plaintiffs were party.
The application for amendment of the plaint was filed on
08.02.2010 i.e. 5 years and 03 Page 14 of 15 months after
passing of the compromise decree, which is sought to be
challenged by way of amendment. The limitation for
challenging any decree is three years (Reference can be
made to Article 59 in Part-IV of the Schedule attached to
the Limitation Act, 1963). A fresh suit to challenge the
same may not be maintainable. Meaning thereby, the
relief sought by way of amendment was time barred. As
with the passage of time, right had accrued in favour of
the appellant with reference to challenge to the
compromise decree, the same cannot be taken away. In
case the amendment in the plaint is allowed, this will
certainly cause prejudice to the appellant. What cannot
be done directly, cannot be allowed to be done indirectly.
14. For the reasons mentioned above, the present appeal
is allowed. The impugned order passed by the High Court
is set aside. The application filed for amendment of the
plaint is dismissed. The appellant shall be entitled to
cost of the proceedings, which are assessed at
₹1,00,000/- to be paid jointly or severally by
respondents No. 1 and 2. The appellant shall be paid the
amount of cost on the next date of hearing before the
Trial Court by way of demand draft.”
25.
The petitioners have failed to prove the due
diligence which is essential while determining and adjudicating
the application for amendment. There is no whisper in the
pleadings that there is any due
deligence on the part of the
petitioners for filing of the application. More so the petitioner
-14- ( 2026:HHC:6968 )
by way of proposed amendment intends to bring new facts
which will certainly change the very basic structure of the claim
petition and will prejudice the rights of the respondent.
26.
The application for amendment is falsified on
account of the fact that one of the injured/claimant, who has
filed claim petition bearing claim petition No. 4/24, titled Karan
Singh and Ajay Sautha
had lodged an FIR, which speaks
contrary to the stand which the petitioners intends to
incorporate in the claim petition. Once the surviving claimant,
who was the witness to the accident has himself filed the claim
petition, had lodged an FIR stating that the claimants were
travelling in the vehicle, therefore, the stand which is being
tried to be taken can not be permitted in order to defeat the
rights of the respondents. The impugned order does not suffer
from any error, therefore, the same does not require
interference.
27.
It will be pertinent to mention here that six claim
petitions have been preferred before the MACT Rohru, District
Shimla and arising out of those proceedings, six CMPMOs were
filed on account of rejection of applications for amendment in
the following manner:
Sr. No.
1.
Claim Petition No. at CMPMO No.
MACT Rohru, District
Shimla
MACT/1/2024
CMPMO No.
Titled
Decided
on/Reserved on
Manisha vs.
Reserved on
-15- ( 2026:HHC:6968 )
2.
MACT/2/2024
3.
MACT/3/2024
4.
MACT/4/2024
5.
MACT/5/2025
6.
MACT/6/2024
28.
In
all
589 of 2025
Ajay Sauhta
27.02.2026
CMPMO 588 of Kamla vs. Ajay Reserved on
Sauhta
27.02.2026
CMPMO No. Kamla vs. Ajay Decided on
590 of 2025
Sauhta
27.02.2026
CMPMO No. Karan Singh vs Decided on
586 of 2025
Ajay Sauhta
29.12.2025
CMPMO
Tilak Kumar
Decided on
No.591 of 2025 Budha vs. Ajay 29.12.2025
Sauhta
CMPMO No. Padam vs. Ajay Decided on
587 of 2025
Sauhta
29.12.2025.
the
claim
petitions,
the
amendment
application was filed by the claimants, however, the learned
MACT rejected the applications in all the cases.
29.
In
MACT Case Nos. 4/24 5/24, 6/24 /CMPMO
586/2025, CMPMO 591 of 2025 and CMPMO No. 587 of 2025
were filed before this Court and the said petitions were
dismissed by the co-ordinate Bench of this Court vide order
dated 29.12.2025.
30.
The Co-ordinate Bench in its order has held as
follows:
“11. I have heard learned Senior Counsel for the
petitioners and also learned counsel for the
respondents and have also carefully gone through
the impugned orders as well as the documents
appended with the petition(s).
12. It is a matter of record that in all the claim
petitions which stand preferred before the learned
Tribunal, the stand of the claimants therein
originally was that they were travelling in the illfated Tipper, which fell down on account of the rash
and negligent driving of the driver, resulting in
-16- ( 2026:HHC:6968 )
grievous injuries to the petitioners. In this backdrop,
if one peruses the application filed under Order VI,
Rule 17 of the Civil Procedure Code, as I have already
observed hereinabove, the prayer of the petitioners
therein was that they should be allowed to change 11
their version and be allowed to introduce the version
that they were not sitting in the Tipper, when the
Tipper fell down, but, they were working at the site
performing their duty and were crushed by the
Tipper, which fell down on account of the rash and
negligent driving of its driver.
13. Order VI, Rule 17 of the Civil Procedure Code,
inter alia, provides that the Court may at any stage
of the proceedings allow either party to alter or
amend his pleadings in such manner and on such
terms as may be just, and such amendment shall be
made as may be necessary for the purpose of
determining the real questions in controversy
between the parties. It is further provided in this
Section that no application for amendment shall be
allowed after the trial has commenced, unless the
Court comes to the conclusion that in spite of due
diligence, the party could not have raised the matter
before the commencement of trial. It is not in
dispute that in the present cases, the applications
for amendment of the claim petitions were filed
before the commencement of Trial after response
was filed by the respondent, more so, the Insurance
Company to the claim petitions.
14. What weighed with the learned Tribunal while
dismissing the application(s) filed by the petitioners
herein was that the proposed amendment would not
only change the nature of the pleadings, but, also its
character, which amounted to withdrawing material
facts and admissions. Learned Tribunal also held
that the same would change the cause of action and
though the Motor Vehicles Act was a beneficial
legislation, but, as the manner, in which, the
incident took place, was material and germane and
had to be proved by the party which alleged it, the
factum of the applicants trying to introduce a new
-17- ( 2026:HHC:6968 )
case and a totally new cause of action would be
detrimental to the contesting respondent and would
cause prejudice to them.
15. This Court does not find any infirmity with the
reasoning given by the learned Tribunal, in terms
whereof, the application(s) filed under Order VI,
Rule 17 of the Civil Procedure Code were dismissed.
16. It is a matter of record that in terms of the
applications filed for amendment of the claim
petitions, the petitioners intended to withdraw the
earlier factual narration with regard to the
occurrence of the incident by altering it from 13 the
factum of them being seated in the ill-fated tipper to
working at the site and being crushed by a tipper.
17. This Court does not concur with the submissions
of the learned Senior Counsel that, merely because,
the petitioners are illiterate labourers, therefore,
they were not able to gauge as to whether the
incident took place on account of the petitioners
being passengers in the tipper or on account of the
petitioners being crushed by the tipper. According to
this Court, even a child, who has some sense, can
very easily infer and narrate these facts.
18. As far as the arguments qua lodging of the two
FIRs is concerned, it is completely irrelevant and
immaterial for the adjudication of the application
filed under Order VI, Rule 17 of the Civil Procedure
Code in the present case.
19. Herein, it is not the case of the petitioners that
the claim petitions were filed by them on the
strength of the FIRs. Even otherwise, there was no
occasion for the petitioners to have filed the claim
petitions on the strength of the FIRs. for the reason
that they were the first parties to the incident and it
is not as if they were the legal heirs of someone else,
who had 14 met with an accident.
20.
The petitioners, thus being the party to the
incident, obviously have to be believed as the
persons having narrated the correct facts which are
mentioned originally in the claim petitions.
-18- ( 2026:HHC:6968 )
21. Obviously, for some reason, there was a change
in heart subsequently and this prompted them to file
the application under Order VI, Rule 17 of the Civil
Procedure Code, which has been rejected by the
learned Tribunal. This change in heart was on
account of the fact that the application for
amendment was filed, after the Insurance Company
had filed its response to the claim petitions,
wherein, the Insurance Company took the stand of
the petitioners were gratuitous passengers.
22. All this demonstrates that the filing of the
applications under Order VI, Rule 17 was not a
bonafide act but the petitioners intended to
introduce a completely different story in the claim
petitions as from the one, with which they had
earlier approached the Court.
23.
In this backdrop, this Court holds that the
learned Tribunal has correctly dismissed the
applications filed by the petitioners under Order VI,
Rule 17 of the Civil Procedure Code, as the said
applications did not meet the parameters of the
statutory provisions of Order VI, Rule 17 of the Code
of Civil Procedure and the intent of the petitioners
was nothing but to fill up the lacunas in the cases.
24.
Accordingly, in light of the above
observations, these petitions are dismissed.”
31.
Since, the co-ordinate Bench of this Court while
dealing with the same issue arising out of the same accident
has already dismissed the CMPMOs filed by the claim
petitioners, therefore, this Court does not find any infirmity in
the impugned order, as passed by the learned Additional
District Judge,-II, Shimla. The present petition being devoid of
-19- ( 2026:HHC:6968 )
any merit, deserves to be dismissed and is accordingly
dismissed.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
12th March, 2026
(Veena)
(Romesh Verma)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review