Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:1149
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
W.P.(S) No. 5165 of 2021
----Kameshwar Paswan, aged about 58 years, Son of Late Chandradeo
Dusadh, resident of Subhash Nagar, P.O- Ray, P.S.- Khelari, DistrictRanchi
....Petitioner(s).
Versus
1. Central Coalfields Limited (CCL), through its Chairman cum
Managing Director, having its office at Darbhanga House, Ranchi,
P.O. G.P.O., P.S. - Kotwali, District Ranchi, Jharkhand;
2. The Director (Personnel) Central Coalfields Limited, having its
office at Darbhanga House, Ranchi, P.O. G.P.O., P.S. - Kotwali,
District - Ranchi, Jharkhand;
3. General Manager (P. & IR), Central Coalfields Limited, having its
office at Darbhanga House, Ranchi, P.O. G.P.O., P.S. Kotwali,
District - Ranchi, Jharkhand.
4. General Manager, Piparwar Area, Central Coalfields Limited,
having its office at P.O Bachra, P.S.- Piparwar, District-Chatra.
5. Staff Officer (MM), Regional Stores, Piparwar Area, Central
Coalfields Limited having its office at P.O. Bachra, P.S.- Piparwar,
District-Chatra.
…Respondent(s).
-----CORAM :
SRI ANANDA SEN, J.
-----For the Petitioner(s) : Mr. Rahul Kumar, Advocate
For the Respondents : Mr. Rajesh Lala, Advocate
…......
19/ 15.01.2026: By way of filing this writ petition, the petitioner has sought for
the following reliefs:(i)
(ii)
For issuance of an appropriate writ(s)/ order(s)/direction(s)
particularly a writ in the nature of certiorari for quashing the
entire departmental proceeding including the charge-sheet dated
16.6.2021 contained in Letter no. 175 (Annexure-1) issued under
the signature of the General Manager, Piparwar Area, CCL
(Respondent No. 4) on the ground that the charge-sheet has been
issued by an incompetent authority.
For issuance of a further appropriate writ(s)/order(s)/direction(s)
particularly a writ in the nature of certiorari for quashing the
dismissal order dated 28.06.2021 as contained in Memo no. 218
(Annexure-14) issued under the signature of respondent no. 4,
whereby and whereunder the order of dismissal from service has
been imposed upon the petitioner with immediate effect.
2026:JHHC:1149
(iii)
(iv)
(v)
2.
For issuance of a further appropriate writ(s)/order(s)/direction(s)
particularly a writ in the nature of certiorari for quashing the
appellate order dated 01/10.11.2021 (Annexure-16) issued under
the signature of the Respondent No. 2, whereby and whereunder
the appeal preferred by the petitioner has been dismissed on
erroneous grounds.
For issuance of a further appropriate writ(s)/order(s)/direction(s)
particularly a writ in the nature of certiorari for quashing the
order dated 16.01.2021 contained in Memo as no. 371
(Annexure-16), whereby and whereunder it has been directed that
the petitioner will retire from service of Regional Stores,
Piparwar Area of CCL with effect from 30.06.2021 on
superannuation.
Consequently after quashing of the aforesaid impugned orders, a
direction may be given upon the respondents to reinstate the
petitioner in service with full back wages and all consequential
benefits thereupon be paid with immediate effect.
The petitioner was working as Chief Storekeeper at the Regional
Store, Piparwar Area, under M/s Central Coalfields Limited (C.C.L.).
He was issued a charge-sheet dated 16.06.2021 alleging suppression of
the fact that he had passed the Matriculation examination prior to
joining service on 08.07.1980. The petitioner denied the allegation and
submitted his reply on 18.06.2021. Finding the reply unsatisfactory, the
management
appointed
an
Enquiry
Officer
and
conducted a
departmental enquiry between 21.06.2021 and 23.06.2021. During the
enquiry, the petitioner sought permission to engage a co-worker to
defend his case. After enquiry, the enquiry officer submitted his report
dated 23.06.2021 finding him guilty. Thereafter, a second show cause
notice dated 24.06.2021 was issued granting only 24 hours to respond.
Despite the petitioner submitting his reply on 28.06.2021, the
disciplinary authority on the same date passed an order dismissing him
from service with immediate effect. The petitioner’s appeal dated
18.08.2021 was also dismissed and subsequently, vide order dated
16.01.2021, the petitioner was directed to retire from service w.e.f.
30.06.2021.
2026:JHHC:1149
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that no oral or formal
witness was examined by the management. The entire disciplinary
action was conducted without proper evidence, without granting
reasonable opportunity to defend, and without following mandatory
procedural requirements. He further submits that the management
relied on ME-1 Service Register in support of allegation. However, the
said document does not contain any column requiring disclosure of
educational qualification. Therefore, there was no obligation on the
petitioner to disclose his matriculation status at the time of
appointment. On the reverse side of the same document, the petitioner
had in fact declared himself as a matriculate, and the entry was made
by the management itself. He also submits that the Enquiry Officer
relied solely upon documents which were merely tendered, without
examining any competent person to prove the contents, authenticity, or
relevance.
4.
The learned counsel for respondents submits that the petitioner
did not submit his Matriculation Certificate at the time of his
appointment. According to the service register, his date of birth was
recorded as 25 June 1961, whereas his matriculation certificate shows
his date of birth as 12 January 1963 and no other age proof was produce
by him. He further submits that if the petitioner had submitted the
matriculation certificate at the time of appointment, he would have
been declared underage and therefore he became ineligible for
appointment, as the minimum age required for appointment was 18
years
which
shows
that
the
petitioner
obtained
employment
fraudulently with mala fide intention.
5.
After hearing both the parties and upon perusal of the records, I
find that no oral or formal witness was examined by the management to
prove the charges against the petitioner. The Enquiry Officer relied
solely upon documents which were merely tendered and not proved in
accordance with law. Such documents, without being proved through
2026:JHHC:1149
competent witnesses, cannot be treated as legal evidence. In a
Departmental Enquiry, the Enquiry Officer performs a quasi-judicial
function. It is true that in a Departmental Proceeding, in strict sense,
Evidence Act is not applied, but if a charge is sought to be proved, the
same has to be proved by oral evidence or any documentary evidence.
6.
The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of “State of U.P. vs. Saroj
Kumar Sinha” reported in (2010) 2 SCC 772 at paragraph 28 has held as
under. –
28. An inquiry officer acting in a quasi-judicial authority is in the position of
an independent adjudicator. He is not supposed to be a representative of the
department/disciplinary authority/Government. His function is to examine the
evidence presented by the Department, even in the absence of the delinquent
official to see as to whether the unrebutted evidence is sufficient to hold that the
charges are proved. In the present case the aforesaid procedure has not been
observed. Since no oral evidence has been examined the documents have not
been proved, and could not have been taken into consideration to conclude that
the charges have been proved against the respondents.
Further in the case of “Nagar Panchayat Umari vs. Shyam
Charan Chaturvedi” reported in (2023) 18 SCC 311, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court at paragraph 8 has held that8. A departmental proceeding against a delinquent is a serious matter as it has
its repercussions which can be far-reaching. It is trite law that the
departmental proceedings are quasi-judicial proceedings. The enquiry officer
functions in a quasi-judicial capacity. He has a neutral role to perform and
cannot act as a representative of the management. He has to act as an
independent and impartial officer to find out the truth……
Thus, the charge has to be proved in the inquiry proceeding
before the Enquiry Officer. In a quasi judicial proceeding before the
Enquiry Officer, there has to be evidence either oral or documentary or
both to prove the charge. If a charge is sought to be proved solely based
on documentary evidence, not only those documents are to be supplied
to the delinquent employee, but such documents along with their
contents must be proved before the Enquiry Officer during the
proceeding.
In the case of “Roop Singh Negi vs. Punjab National Bank”
reported in (2009) 2 SCC 570 it was held by the Hon'ble Supreme Court
2026:JHHC:1149
that an officer conducting an Enquiry must arrive at findings only after
considering the materials brought on record by the parties. Hon’ble
Supreme court has held in paragraph 1414. Indisputably, a departmental proceeding is a quasi-judicial proceeding. The
enquiry officer performs a quasi-judicial function. The charges levelled against
the delinquent officer must be found to have been proved. The enquiry officer
has a duty to arrive at a finding upon taking into consideration the materials
brought on record by the parties. The purported evidence collected during
investigation by the investigating officer against all the accused by itself could
not be treated to be evidence in the disciplinary proceeding. No witness was
examined to prove the said documents. The management witnesses merely
tendered the documents and did not prove the contents thereof. Reliance, inter
alia, was placed by the enquiry officer on the FIR which could not have been
treated as evidence.
Further in case of “State of U.P. vs. Ram Prakash Singh” reported
in 2025 SCC OnLine SC 891, the Hon’ble Supreme Court at paragraph
14 has held that14. What follows from a conjoint reading of the above two decisions is and
what applies here is that, ‘materials brought on record by the parties' (to which
consideration in the enquiry ought to be confined) mean only such materials
can be considered which are brought on record in a manner known to law.
Such materials can then be considered legal evidence, which can be acted upon.
Though the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 is not strictly applicable to
departmental enquiries, which are not judicial proceedings, nevertheless, the
principles flowing therefrom can be applied in specific cases. Evidence tendered
by witnesses must be recorded in the presence of the delinquent employee, he
should be given opportunity to cross-examine the witnesses and no document
should be relied on by the prosecution without giving copy thereof to the
delinquent - all these basic principles of fair play have their root in such Act. In
such light, the documents referred to in the list of documents forming part of
the annexures to the chargesheet, on which the department seeks to rely in the
enquiry, cannot be treated as legal evidence worthy of forming the basis for a
finding of guilt if the contents of such documents are not spoken to by persons
competent to speak about them. A document does not prove itself. In the
enquiry, therefore, the contents of the relied-on documents have to be proved by
examining a witness having knowledge of the contents of such document and
who can depose as regards its authenticity. In the present case, no such exercise
was undertaken by producing any witness.
7.
Taking into consideration the aforesaid judgments and observation
made herein above, the findings recorded by the Enquiry Officer are
based on no evidence, as admittedly no oral or formal witness was
examined and the documents relied upon were neither proved nor
brought on record in a manner known to law. Further, I find that at the
relevant time when he was appointed the minimum age for
2026:JHHC:1149
employment was 16 years and not 18 years as per section 40 of the
Mines Act, 1952.
8.
Thus, I am inclined to allow this writ petition. The impugned
order dated 28.06.2021 and appellate order dated 01/10.11.2021 are set
aside.
9.
Accordingly, the writ petition is allowed.
(ANANDA SEN, J.)
15.01.2026
Tanuj/CP-2
AFR
Uploaded on 28.01.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review