Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:30642
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CR No.82 of 2025
Decided on: 22.07.2026
____________________________________________________________
Kamal Jeet and others
...Petitioners
Versus
Jeevan Malik and another
...Respondents
_____________________________________________________________
Coram
Hon'ble Mr. Justice Jiya Lal Bhardwaj, Judge
Whether approved for reporting? 1Yes
For the petitioners:
Mr.
Sudhir
Thakur,
Senior
Advocate, with Mr. Karun Negi,
Advocate.
For the respondents:
Mr. Vipin Pandit and Mr. Parikshit
Sharma, Advocates.
Jiya Lal Bhardwaj, Judge (Oral)
The petitioners-defendants have assailed the
order dated 12.07.2024, passed in Civil Suit No.115/1 of
2015, titled, Smt. Jeevan Malik and another vs. Smt.
Nirmala Tanwer and others, whereby the issue framed
vide order dated 19.09.2015 as to whether the suit is barred
under Section 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure, has been
answered in negative.
2.
The challenge laid by the petitioners-defendants
is mainly on the ground that they have already filed a suit
Whether reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
2026:HHC:30642
for specific performance of contract, permanent prohibitory
injunction and in alternative for adverse possession of the
land comprised in khasra No. 67, which is depicted by new
khasra Nos. 91, 92 and 93, kita 3 measuring 1,887 sq.
meters and khasra No. 68, which is depicted by new khasra
Nos. 94, 95, kita 2, measuring 1,807 sq. meters, situated at
Mauza Dehun, Pargana Bharoli Khurd, Tehsil and District
Solan,
H.P.,
besides
other
reliefs,
which
is
pending
adjudication before the Court of learned Civil Judge (Senior
Division), Solan, District Solan, H.P. It has further been
averred that once the petitioners-defendants had already
instituted the suit, the subsequent suit instituted by the
respondents-plaintiffs for recovery of arrears of rent, mesne
profit and possession of the premises ought to have been
stayed in view of the provisions contained in Section 10 of
the Code of Civil Procedure (in short ‘CPC’). It has also been
averred in the petition that the learned trial Court has
wrongly held that the matter in the subsequent suit is not
directly and substantially in issue in the previous instituted
suit by the petitioners-defendants, which findings are wrong
and incorrect.
3.
Learned counsel representing the respondents-
2026:HHC:30642
plaintiffs has supported the order passed by the learned
trial Court, whereby the issue has been decided against the
petitioners-defendants, holding that the subsequent suit is
not barred under Section 10 of the CPC.
4.
I have heard the learned counsel for the parties
and also perused the record carefully.
5.
Learned
senior
counsel
representing
the
petitioners-defendants has vehemently argued that once
the previous suit instituted by the petitioners-defendants
was with respect to the specific performance of contract,
permanent prohibitory injunction and in the alternative for
adverse possession of the same land, the subsequent suit
instituted by the respondents-plaintiffs for recovery of
arrears of rent, mesne profit and possession of the premises
in respect of the same suit land is directly and substantially
the same with respect to the same parties and therefore,
the learned trial Court has wrongly answered the issue
under Section 10 of CPC holding that subsequent suit is not
the same.
6.
Before adverting to the submissions made by
learned senior counsel for the petitioners-defendants, it
would be relevant to quote the provision of Section 10 of
2026:HHC:30642
the CPC, which reads as under:“A perusal of the bare reading of the provisions of the
section clearly reveals that the Court shall not proceed
with the trial of any suit in which the matter in issue is
also directly and substantially in issue in a previously
instituted suit between the same parties or between
parties under whom they or any of them claiming
litigating under the same title where such suit is
pending.”
7.
If the earlier suit instituted by the petitioners-
defendants is perused, a copy whereof has been placed on
record as Annexure P-3, the suit is for specific performance
of
contract,
permanent
prohibitory
injunction
and
alternatively for adverse possession. The subsequent suit
instituted by the respondents-plaintiffs is with respect to
recovery of arrears of rent, mesne profit and possession of
the premises. In the subsequent suit, the respondentsplaintiffs have claimed the recovery of arrears of rent on the
ground that they are the owners of the suit property, which
fact is not even denied by the petitioners-defendants for the
reason that they have instituted the suit for specific
performance of contract on the basis of an agreement,
which has been executed by the predecessor-in-interest of
the
respondents-plaintiffs,
who
was
their
father,
on
27.10.1979 and thus, the claim raised in the subsequent
2026:HHC:30642
suit is neither directly nor substantially in issue in the
previous
suit
instituted
by
the
petitioners-defendants
against the respondents-plaintiffs.
8.
has
Learned counsel for the petitioners-defendants
vehemently
argued
that
since
the
petitioners-
defendants have already instituted a suit and the subject
matter of the said suit is similar to that of the subject
matter in the subsequent suit instituted by the respondentsplaintiffs, the learned trial Court has erred in deciding the
issue. He placed reliance upon the judgment of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in Aspi Jal and another vs. Khushroo
Rustom Dadyburjor, (2013) 4 SCC 333 and referred to
paras 9 to 11 of the judgment which read as under:
9. …….…..
From a plain reading of the aforesaid provision, it is
evident that where a suit is instituted in a Court to which
provisions of the Code apply, it shall not proceed with the
trial of another suit in which the matter in issue is also
directly and substantially in issue in a previously
instituted suit between the same parties. For application
of the provisions of Section 10 of the Code, it is further
required that the Court in which the previous suit is
pending is competent to grant the relief claimed. The use
of negative expression in Section 10, i.e. “no court shall
proceed with the trial of any suit” makes the provision
mandatory and the Court in which the subsequent suit
has been filed is prohibited from proceeding with the trial
of that suit if the conditions laid down in Section 10 of the
Code are satisfied. The basic purpose and the underlying
object of Section 10 of the Code is to prevent the Courts
of
concurrent
jurisdiction
from
simultaneously
entertaining and adjudicating upon two parallel litigations
2026:HHC:30642
in respect of same cause of action, same subject matter
and the same relief. This is to pin down the Plaintiff to one
litigation so as to avoid the possibility of contradictory
verdicts by two courts in respect of the same relief and is
aimed to protect the defendant from multiplicity of
proceeding.
10.
The view which we have taken finds support from a
decision of this Court in National Institute of Mental Health
and
Neuro
Sciences
v.
C.
Parameshwara,
MANI/SC/1063/2004(2005) : 2 SCC 256 in which it has
been held as follows:
“ 8. The object underlying Section 10 is to prevent
courts
of
concurrent
jurisdiction
from
simultaneously trying two parallel suits in respect
of the same matter in issue. The object underlying
Section 10 is to avoid two parallel trials on the
same issue by two courts and to avoid recording of
conflicting findings on issues which are directly and
substantially in issue in previously instituted suit.
The language of Section 10 suggests that it is
referable to a suit instituted in the civil court and it
cannot apply to proceedings of other nature
instituted under any other statute. The object of
Section 10 is to prevent courts of concurrent
jurisdiction from simultaneously trying two parallel
suits between the same parties in respect of the
same matter in issue. The fundamental test to
attract Section 10 is, whether on final decision
being reached in the previous suit, such decision
would operate as res-judicata in the subsequent
suit. Section 10 applies only in cases where the
whole of the subject-matter in both the suits is
identical. The key words in Section 10 are “the
matter in issue is directly and substantially in
issue” in the previous instituted suit. The words
“directly and substantially in issue” are used in
contradistinction to the words “incidentally or
collaterally in issue”. Therefore, Section 10 would
apply only if there is identity of the matter in issue
in both the suits, meaning thereby, that the whole
of the subject-matter in both the proceedings is
identical.”
2026:HHC:30642
11. In the present case, the parties in all the three suits
are one and the same and the court in which the first two
suits have been instituted is competent to grant the relief
claimed in the third suit. The only question which invites
our adjudication is as to whether “the matter in issue is
also directly and substantially in issue in previously
instituted suits”. The key words in Section 10 are “the
matter in issue is directly and substantially in issue in the
previously instituted suit”. The test for applicability of
Section 10 of the Code is whether on a final decision
being reached in the previously instituted suit, such
decision would operate as res-judicata in the subsequent
suit. To put it differently one may ask, can the plaintiff get
the same relief in the subsequent suit, if the earlier suit
has been dismissed? In our opinion, if the answer is in
affirmative, the subsequent suit is not fit to be stayed.
However, we hasten to add then when the matter in
controversy is the same, it is immaterial what further
relief is claimed in the subsequent suit. ”
9.
The
Hon'ble
Supreme
Court
in
the
aforementioned judgment has held that where the whole of
the subject matter in both the suits is identical and further,
if the subject matter of the subsequent civil suit is based on
the same cause of action as the earlier instituted suit and
same relief is prayed, the subsequent suit has to be stayed
for the reason that the purpose of engrafting Section 10 of
the CPC is to avoid the possibility of contradictory verdicts
by two courts in respect of the same relief. However, in the
present case, as already noted above, the earlier suit
instituted by the petitioners-defendants is for specific
performance of the suit land, whereas, the subsequent suit
2026:HHC:30642
instituted by the respondents-plaintiffs is for recovery of
arrears of rent, mesne profit and possession of the premises
and therefore, the judgment cited by learned senior counsel
is not attracted to the facts of the present case, since the
cause of action in both the civil suits is different and the
reliefs are not same and similar.
10.
Learned counsel representing the respondents-
plaintiffs has placed reliance upon the judgment of the High
Court of Patna in N.P. Tripathi vs. Dayamanti Devi, AIR
1988 Patna 123 and contended that since the prayer in the
subsequent suit instituted by the respondents-plaintiffs is
different from the prayer made in the earlier suit instituted
by the petitioners-defendants, the provisions of Section 10
CPC are not attracted. In this judgment, the High Court had
held that merely by instituting a suit for the specific
performance of contract;
or for that matter, by an
agreement of sale, it cannot be held that the subsequent
suit instituted for eviction is not maintainable.
In the
present case, the petitioners-defendants have based their
claim in the earlier suit on the basis of the agreement which
has been executed by the predecessor-in-interest of the
respondents-plaintiffs
on
27.10.1979
and
since
the
2026:HHC:30642
petitioners-defendants are not the owners of the suit
property till the time the suit filed by them for specific
performance is decreed, the respondents-plaintiffs, being
the owner of the suit property are admittedly entitled to
institute a suit for recovery of arrears of rent, mesne profit
and
possession
and
therefore,
the
subsequent
suit
instituted by them cannot be said to be hit by the provisions
of Section 10 of the CPC.
11.
Learned counsel representing the respondents-
plaintiffs has also placed reliance upon the judgment of the
Hon’ble Apex Court in Civil Appeal No. _______ of 2024
(arising out of SLP Civil No. 7617 of 2019), Usha & Anr. vs.
Shahjad Bi @ Sejad & Ors. In this judgment, it has been
held that the provisions of Section 10 of CPC shall apply
only in those cases where the whole of the subject matter in
both the suits is identical. As already discussed above, the
earlier suit instituted by the petitioners-defendants is for
specific performance of contract which has been allegedly
executed on 27.10.1979 and the subsequent suit instituted
by the respondents-plaintiffs is for recovery of arrears of
rent, mesne profit etc. and thus, it cannot be said that the
subject matter in the subsequent suit is directly and
2026:HHC:30642
substantially in issue and further the cause of action is
similar and identical in the subsequent suit instituted by the
respondents-defendants.
12.
The learned trial Court, after considering the
import of Section 10 of CPC, has rightly come to the
conclusion that the matter involved in both the suits is not
directly and substantially in issue and thus, no error has
been committed by the learned trial Court while answering
the issue in negative and this Court while exercising the
revisional jurisdiction is not interfering with the said order
passed by the learned trial Court, especially when there is
neither any perversity nor illegality having been committed
by the learned trial Court.
13.
Resultantly, I do not find any merit in the present
petition and the same is dismissed. However, there shall be
no order as to costs. Pending applications, if any, also stand
disposed of.
22nd July, 2026
(Anurag)
( Jiya Lal Bhardwaj )
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review