The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
9. Thus, the order passed by Chairperson alone cannot be said to be passed by the Authority. It is illegal per se and deserves to be quashed only on this sole ground. The argument of learned counsel for respondent No.4 regarding the fact that there is no quorum specified for functioning of the police complaints authority also holds no water as then what is the use of appointing 5 members in the complaints authority. This finding of the court is also supported by the case of M/s Dasauni (Supra), wherein, it has been categorically held by a co-ordinate bench of this court that when there are multiple members in the police complaints authority the order passed by Chairperson only is non est in the eyes of law.
10. In view of the above, the writ petition is allowed. Accordingly, impugned order dated 30.06.2011 passed by respondent No.2 (Annexure No.8 to the writ petition) as well as consequential order dated 09.09.2012 issued by respondent No.3 (Annexure No.9 to the writ petition), are hereby set aside. (Pankaj Purohit, J.)
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
UKHC010125502012
2026:UHC:7161
HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND AT NAINITAL
Writ Petition Service Single No.1355 of 2012
12 August, 2026
Kamal Kumar Lunthi
--Petitioner
Versus
State Of Uttarakhand and Ors.
--Respondents
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Presence:-
Mr. Parikshit Saini, learned counsel for petitioner.
Mr. N.S. Pundir, learned D.A.G. for the State of Uttarakhand/
respondent Nos.1 to 4.
Mr. Ajay Joshi, learned counsel for respondent No.5.
Hon’ble Pankaj Purohit, J. (Oral)
By means of the present writ petition, petitioner has
challenged the impugned order dated 30.06.2011 passed by
respondent No.2 (Annexure No.8 to the writ petition) as well as
consequential order dated 09.09.2012 issued by respondent
No.3 (Annexure No.9 to the writ petition).
2.
The brief facts of the case are that, in the year 2010,
petitioner was posted as Sub-Inspector In-charge, Lakhi Bagh
Chowki, Police Station Kotwali Dehradun. On 25.05.2010, an
FIR was lodged by Sanjay Mittal at Police Station Kotwali
against Bharat Bhushan Gupta and Naveen Nagar, as Case
Crime No.196 of 2010, u/s 323, 504 and 506 IPC, with certain
allegations and the Station Officer marked the said FIR for
investigation to the petitioner. After investigation, recording of
the statement of victim, site visit, the case diary was prepared
and accused-Bharat Bhushan Gupta and Naveen Nagar were
arrested on 26.05.2010 and charge-sheet was submitted by the
petitioner against them on 06.06.2010 and on 11.06.2010.
Learned Chief Judicial Magistrate had taken the cognizance
against the accused persons and thereafter issued summons
against them. Respondent No.4-Bharat Bhushan Gupta moved
a complaint on 05.06.2010 to respondent No.2 with certain
allegations that Kailash Pawar (S.O.) and Ajay Singh (S.P.) were
biased against him and his arrest was made by petitioner in
unconstitutional manner. On the said complaint, respondent
UKHC010125502012
2026:UHC:7161
No.2 asked written reply from petitioner which was submitted
by him on 15.07.2010 along with copy of Govt. Order dated
15.12.2006, whereby, it was specified that Section 506 IPC is
cognizable and non-bailable. Respondent No.2 passed impugned
order dated 30.06.2011 holding Section 506 IPC as noncognizable and bailable, thus, according to respondent No.2, no
arrest could be made without the order of court, and further
passed an order that as the FIR was not lodged with correct
version, thus, petitioner, who made the arrest, committed
misconduct, for which a suitable action against the petitioner
should be taken and directed the police authorities to take
action and exonerated all other police officers. Thereafter,
respondent No.3 pursuant to order dated 30.06.2011, issued a
show cause notice against the petitioner on 07.09.2012, seeking
reply within 15 days. Thus, petitioner is before this Court,
challenging both the orders dated 30.06.2011 and 07.09.2012.
3.
Learned
counsel
for
petitioner
submits
that
respondent No.2-State Police Complaint Authority, has no
powers under the law as per the Police Act of 2007 to adjudicate
upon the matter, which is under investigation or pending before
the court as per the order impugned, whereupon number of
findings relating to trial has been passed, which is completely
illegal. He further submits that order impugned passed by
respondent No.2 is completely illegal, as the petitioner was
discharging his duties as given by Station Officer for doing
investigation, thus, after recording of evidence, the accused was
arrested, thus the order is per se illegal and thus, the
consequential order is also illegal.
4.
Learned counsel for petitioner contends that the
“State Police Complaint Authority” is defined under Section 64
of the Police Act, wherein, authority consists of Chairperson and
maximum four other members. However, in present case,
impugned order dated 30.06.2011 was passed by Chairperson
only and it did not bear signature of any other member. He
further contends that whether the order has to be passed by
Chairperson only or by Chairperson and Members together,
UKHC010125502012
2026:UHC:7161
came up for consideration before this Court in the case of M/s
Dasauni Vs. State of Uttarakhand, as reported in 2015 SCC
OnLine Utt 2625, wherein, it has categorically held that the
order passed by Chairperson only is non est in the eyes of law.
Thus, he contends that Chairperson alone cannot pass an order
under Chapter 8 of the Police Act of 2007.
5.
Per contra, learned counsel for respondent No.4
submits that a first information report bearing FIR No.196 of
2010 was registered against respondent No.4 u/s 323, 504 and
506 IPC on 25.05.2010, which was investigated by petitioner.
However, petitioner illegally arrested the respondent No.4 for the
commission of alleged offences which are bailable and noncognizable and on a mere allegation of commission of offences
without
investigating
the
genuineness
of
the
complaint
aggrieved with his illegal arrest, respondent No.4 approached
the respondent No.2-State Police Complaints Authority, by filing
a
complaint
against
petitioner
for
committing
serious
misconduct under Section 74 of Uttarakhand Police Act, 2007
(hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act of 2007’).
6.
He further submits that respondent No.4 was
eventually acquitted of the trial initiated in connection with the
aforesaid FIR, vide judgment and order dated 05.09.2017. It is
contended by learned counsel for respondent No.4 that conjoint
reading of Sections 64 and 65 of the Act of 2007 makes it clear
that State Police Complaints Authority can have maximum five
members and no minimum number of members is prescribed
and there may be a case, where at a time, there is only one, two,
three, four or five members in the Authority. It is further
contended by him that when the Act of 2007 does not provide
any quorum of Authority for conduct of its business or prescribe
any minimum number of members in the Authority to hear the
complaint, the argument of the petitioner that complaint ought
to have been heard by the Authority consisting of five members
is unsustainable.
7.
Having heard the contentions of learned counsel for
the parties and having gone through written submissions and
UKHC010125502012
2026:UHC:7161
case law supplied by them and after perusal of material
available
on
record,
particularly
the
instruction
dated
25.07.2026 supplied by learned state counsel which was taken
on record, clearly shows that on the date of passing of the
impugned order the Police complaints authority had 5 working
members including the Chairperson himself. The extract of
letter dated 25.07.2026 is quoted below:“mRrjk[k.M iqfyl vf/kfu;e 2007 ;Fkk la”kksf/kr 2018 dh /kkjk 65 esa
mfYyf[kr izkfo/kkuksa ds vuqlkj jkT; iqfyl f”kdk;r izkf/kdj.k esa ek0 v/;{k ,oa vf/kdre pkj
ek0 lnL;ksa dh fu;qfDr dk izkfo/kku gS rFkk fnukad 30-06-2011 dks izkf/kdj.k esa fuEuor ek0
v/;{k ,oa ek0 lnL;x.k fu;qDr Fks%&
Ø0la0 Ukke
in uke
dc ls
11&9&2008
dk;kZof/k
dc rd
10&09&2011
1-
U;k;ewfrZ “kEHkw ukFk JhokLro Ekk0 v/;{k
2-
Jh enu flag
vkbZ0,0,l0½
¼ls0fu0 ek0 lnL;
11&9&2008
10&09&2011
3-
Jh ih0ds0 tks”kh ¼ls0fu0 ek0 lnL;
vkbZ0ih0,l0½
11&9&2008
10&09&2011
4-
ls0fu0 fczxsfM;j Jh oh0ds0 ek0 lnL;
vxzoky
11&9&2008
10&09&2011
5-
Mk0 dqlqe uksfV;ky
11&9&2008
10&09&2011
8.
ek0 lnL;
This Court is of the view that it is hard to fathom the
reason as to why only the chairperson passed the impugned
order. As per Section 64 and 65 of the Uttarakhand Police Act of
2007, there is no doubt that the State Police Complaint
Authority consists of Chairperson and four other members and
one of the independent members, the Chairperson shall be
appointed by the State Government. Thus, in all five members
shall be there including chairperson. For ready reference section
64 and 65 is quoted below:“64. State Police Complaints Authority:The State Government shall, within six months of the
coming into effect of this Act, establish a State Police
Complaints Authority (hereinafter referred to as the
‘Authority’), consisting of a Chairperson and maximum
four other Members to inquire into public complaints
against the police personnel for serious misconduct and
to perform such other functions, as stipulated in this
chapter.
65. Composition of the Authority.—
(1) The Authority shall consist of maximum five
members, to be appointed by the State Government, with
UKHC010125502012
2026:UHC:7161
a credible record of integrity and commitment to human
rights. The Authority shall consist of the following—
(a) four persons of eminence with experience in
public dealing and having credible record of
integrity and commitment to human rights as
independent members;
(b) a Police Officer superannuated in the rank not
below the rank of Inspector General of Police.
(2) At least one member of the Authority shall be a
woman and not more than one member shall be a police
officer.
(3) Out of the four independent members, at least one
member of the Authority shall be from amongst persons,
having a good knowledge of law.
(4) The State Government shall appoint one of the
independent members, as Chairman of the Authority.”
9.
Thus, the order passed by Chairperson alone cannot
be said to be passed by the Authority. It is illegal per se and
deserves to be quashed only on this sole ground. The argument
of learned counsel for respondent No.4 regarding the fact that
there is no quorum specified for
functioning of the police
complaints authority also holds no water as then what is the
use of appointing 5 members in the complaints authority. This
finding of the court is also supported by the case of M/s
Dasauni (Supra), wherein, it has been categorically held by a
co-ordinate bench of this court that when there are multiple
members in the police complaints authority the order passed by
Chairperson only is non est in the eyes of law.
10.
In view of the above, the writ petition is allowed.
Accordingly, impugned order dated 30.06.2011 passed by
respondent No.2 (Annexure No.8 to the writ petition) as well as
consequential order dated 09.09.2012 issued by respondent
No.3 (Annexure No.9 to the writ petition), are hereby set aside.
(Pankaj Purohit, J.)
12.08.2026
PN
PREETI
NEGI
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND,
ou=HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND,
2.5.4.20=63c75a8c4765581180a58d7478fadb
e38331bac55c78b5f9f0276c16432f6aab,
postalCode=263001, st=UTTARAKHAND,
serialNumber=2BA53171893B3C3CB3CCCAE
81FAE064498483A83D84BDB0F9229D5BF08
D959AC, cn=PREETI NEGI
Date: 2026.08.19 18:03:00 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review