Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
+
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
W.P.(C) 8212/2018, CM APPL. 13924/2023
KALYAN SINGH
.....Petitioner
Through: Appearance not given.
versus
LD. DISTRICT AND SESSION JUDGE, HQ DELHI .....Respondent
Through: Mrs. Avnish Ahlawat, SC for
GNCTD Services with Mr. N.K.
Singh, Ms. Aliza Alam and
Mr. Mohnish Sehrawat, Advocates.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV NARULA
%
1.
ORDER
16.02.2026
This petition under Article 226 of the Constitution questions only the
effective date of the Petitioner’s promotion to the post of Judicial Assistant
(Group ‘C’, Non-Gazetted). The Petitioner does not dispute that promotion
has been granted. The dispute is about whether the notional promotion
could, or should, be antedated to 18th December, 2008 (the date on which the
Petitioner claims eligibility matured), instead of 1st July, 2012 (the date from
which the promotion order extends effect).
Facts
2.
The Petitioner joined the Respondent establishment on 18th
December, 2003 as Junior Judicial Assistant. As per the Petitioner, the next
promotion to Judicial Assistant became due on completion of the prescribed
residency period, and therefore fell due on 18th December, 2008.
3.
Promotion in the cadre must be seen against the backdrop of
restructuring instructions issued by the Government of India. An Office
W.P.(C) 8212/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 23/02/2026 at 11:55:20
Memorandum dated 16th October, 1979 restructured the LDC and UDC
posts in a 40:60 ratio with effect from 1st October, 1979. That ratio was later
modified to 50:50 with effect from 1st April, 1994 by Office Memorandum
dated 20th March, 1994. A judgment of this Court dated 22 nd March, 2010 in
W.P.(C) No. 907/1996 directed the concerned authorities to sanction and
implement the upgradation of posts in terms of the said memoranda.
4.
Pursuant to the above directions, a Selection Committee was
constituted. A promotion order dated 23rd August, 2017 was issued, in which
the Petitioner’s name appeared (serial no. 284) and the promotion was made
effective from 1st July, 2012.
5.
The controversy turns materially on disciplinary proceedings initiated
against the Petitioner. A memorandum dated 19th August, 2006 was issued
to him relating to issuance of bailable warrants in a matter where he was
discharging the function of ‘Alhmad’. The proceedings culminated in an
order dated 23rd October, 2009 imposing the minor penalty of withholding
of two increments without cumulative effect. As a result, the Petitioner did
not receive the increments that fell due on 1st July, 2010 and 1st July, 2011.
Later, on 1st July, 2012, the Petitioner received three increments, including
restoration of the two withheld increments.
6.
The Respondent contend that the effective date of promotion must
necessarily follow the expiry of the penalty’s operative period. According to
them, although the penalty was minor in nature, its consequences continued
until 1st July, 2012, when the withheld increments stood restored. The
Petitioner, therefore, could not have been granted promotion with effect
from 18th December, 2008 so long as the penalty remained in currency. The
Petitioner disputes this position.
W.P.(C) 8212/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 23/02/2026 at 11:55:20
Petitioner’s submissions
7.
Counsel for the Petitioner makes the following submissions in support
of the reliefs sought:
7.1.
The grievance of the Petitioner is that the Respondent have
erroneously fixed the effective date to 1st July, 2012, although the Petitioner
had completed the qualifying service much earlier and, on the Respondent’
own case, the promotion flowed from a cadre restructuring exercise which
stood judicially mandated.
7.2.
As regards the Respondent’ justification founded on the imposition of
penalty, it is argued that the penalty was “withholding of two increments
without cumulative effect”. The punishment, by its own description, was
confined to increments. It did not contain any direction withholding
promotion, nor could a collateral “promotion embargo” be read into it when
the disciplinary authority did not impose such a consequence.
7.3.
A minor penalty does not, by itself, make an employee ineligible for
consideration for promotion. While the actual operation of promotion may
be regulated during the currency of a penalty, the penalty itself does not
extinguish the employee’s claim to placement in the promotional hierarchy
from the date of eligibility. In this context, reliance is placed on Ram Pal
Singh v Union of India & Ors.,1 D.H.B.V.N.L. & Ors. V. Yashvir Singh
Gulia2, Jagan Narain v. Food Corporation of India & Ors.3, and State
Bank of India & Ors. V. C.K. Karunakaran4 which accept that a minor
penalty cannot be treated as an automatic and rigid disqualification for
2011:DHC:4740-DB
(2013) 11 SCC 173
(2010) 4 SCC 558
CIVIL APPEAL NO.6821/2009 decided on 30th September, 2021
W.P.(C) 8212/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 23/02/2026 at 11:55:20
promotional progression, particularly where the post is non-selection and the
promotion is seniority-based. The Petitioner draws support from the
reasoning that where only a minor penalty is ultimately imposed, it ought
not to block promotion as a matter of course.
7.4.
Where an employee is denied promotion for reasons that do not
amount to a statutory bar, the corrective relief often involves restoration of
the proper placement and consequential benefits, subject to lawful
limitations.
7.5.
Even assuming that promotion could not operate during the currency
of the penalty, the punishment stood exhausted upon the withholding of the
second increment on 1st July, 2011. The grant of three increments on 1st July,
2012 merely restored the pay position and did not extend the life of the
penalty. Consequently, the Respondent could not have deferred the effective
date of promotion beyond 1st July, 2011, and fixation from 1st July, 2012 is
legally unsustainable.
7.6.
It is further contended that similarly situated employees, including
certain juniors, were granted promotion from an earlier effective date despite
the imposition of minor penalties. The Petitioner submits that denial of
similar treatment to him is arbitrary and violative of Articles 14 and 16 of
the Constitution.
Respondent submissions
8.
On the other hand, Counsel for the Respondent, opposes the petition
on the following grounds:
8.1.
The Petitioner has no vested right to promotion from a particular date.
At best, he has a right to be considered, and the timing and effect of
promotion depend upon the existence of vacancies, completion of the
W.P.(C) 8212/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 23/02/2026 at 11:55:20
selection process, and the outcome of suitability assessment as per the
applicable rules.
8.2.
The Petitioner’s name appeared at serial no. 284 in the promotion list
and the promotion was granted by order dated 28th August, 2017 with effect
from 1st July, 2012. The effective date was fixed on an objective application
of policy governing promotions and the impact of penalties, and not on any
ad hoc discretion.
8.3.
The Petitioner was issued a charge memorandum on 19th August,
2006, and upon culmination of the disciplinary process, a punishment of
withholding of two increments without cumulative effect was imposed by
order dated 23rd October, 2009. Although the penalty is described as
“minor”, it remains a punishment for misconduct, and the administration is
entitled, indeed obliged, to factor it into promotional decisions in order to
preserve discipline and institutional standards.
8.4.
Reliance is placed upon the DoPT Office Memorandum bearing no.
22011/4/2007-Estt.(D) dated 28th April, 2014, which consolidates the
approach towards promotions where penalties have been imposed. The
governing policy framework recognises two distinct propositions. First,
withholding of increment does not, by itself, make an employee ineligible
for consideration, because the specific penalty of withholding promotion has
not been imposed. Second, even where the DPC considers the officer fit, the
officer should not be actually promoted during the currency of the penalty.
This precisely answers the Petitioner’s claim for effect of promotion from
2008.
8.5.
The promotion having been given effect from 1st July, 2012 already
reflects a balanced approach, because it ensures the Petitioner receives
W.P.(C) 8212/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 23/02/2026 at 11:55:20
promotion after the penalty’s operative period, while respecting the
discipline-related implications of the misconduct.
Analysis and findings
9.
The Petitioner’s claim proceeds on the premise that mere completion
of the eligibility period confers an enforceable right to promotion from a
particular date. Such a premise is not supported by settled principles of
service jurisprudence. Eligibility is a threshold.
10.
The Petitioner suffered a minor penalty of withholding two
increments without cumulative effect by order dated 23 rd October, 2009.
That penalty did not remain confined to a paper entry. It operated through
the withholding of increments due on 1st July, 2010 and 1st July, 2011, and
the withheld increments were restored only when the next increment became
due on 1st July, 2012. The DoPT instructions on the working of such a
penalty treat the increment as restored after the period of withholding ends,
without carrying forward a lasting reduction in pay.
11.
In terms of Para 2 of the Office Memorandum dated 28 th April, 2014,
withholding of increment does not render an officer ineligible for
consideration for promotion, since the specific penalty of withholding
promotion has not been imposed. The same paragraph, read with Para 3
thereof, makes it explicit that even where the DPC finds the officer suitable,
the promotion is not to be given effect during the currency of the penalty
and may operate only upon its expiry.
12.
Once this principle is applied, the Petitioner’s prayer for an effective
date of 18th December, 2008 confronts an immediate difficulty. If promotion
were to be granted from 18th December, 2008, the Petitioner would be
treated as occupying the higher post throughout the period when the penalty
W.P.(C) 8212/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 23/02/2026 at 11:55:20
was operating in real terms on increments (2010 and 2011) and until
restoration (1st July, 2012). That is precisely what the instructions caution
against. The governing approach is not to deny promotion forever, but to
ensure that the promotion does not operate during the penalty’s currency.
13.
The principle reflected in the Office Memorandum also stands
judicially recognised. In Union of India v. K. Krishnan5 the Supreme Court
held that denial of promotion during the currency of a penalty is not a
second punishment but a logical and consequential effect of the disciplinary
action, and does not offend Articles 14 or 16. The Court observed that a
government servant suffering a penalty cannot, at the same time, claim
promotion to a higher cadre. Similarly, in Union of India v. A.N. Mohanan6
it was reiterated that where a penalty has been imposed, promotional
benefits cannot be given retrospective effect in disregard of the disciplinary
consequence. These authorities reinforce the policy that while consideration
may proceed, the actual operation of promotion must await the expiry of the
penalty’s currency.
14.
The Petitioner characterises the Respondent’ decision as an additional
punishment. That argument would have carried weight if the Respondent
had continued to deny promotion even after the penalty’s operative period
had ended. However, promotion has been granted with effect from 1 st July,
2012, which is the very date on which, on the Petitioner’s own case, the
withheld increments were restored and the penalty’s operative consequences
ceased.
15.
This Court is also mindful that courts have intervened where
1992 Supp (3) SCC 50
(2007) 5 SCC 425
W.P.(C) 8212/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 23/02/2026 at 11:55:20
administrative action denies promotional benefits in a manner inconsistent
with rules, especially when an employee stands cleared, or when the denial
flows from an unlawful continuation of adverse consequences. For instance,
in Ram Pal Singh, it was held that where the applicable Railway Board
instructions expressly provided that a minor penalty would not impede
promotion to a non-selection post, such penalty could not be treated as a bar.
However, that decision turned on the specific language of the governing
circular applicable in that case. The present matter is governed by the DoPT
Office Memorandum dated 28th April, 2014, which, while permitting
consideration despite withholding of increments, expressly stipulates that
promotion is not to take effect during the currency of the penalty. The
distinction in the governing policy framework is decisive.
16.
Similarly, in Jagan Narain, the Supreme Court was concerned with
cancellation of promotion on account of pendency of minor penalty
proceedings, in the context of specific FCI circulars which did not treat such
pendency as a bar. The decision turned on the interpretation of those
circulars. The factual and regulatory framework is thus materially distinct.
17.
Far from assisting the Petitioner, C.K. Karunakaran, affirms that
where disciplinary proceedings culminate in the imposition of a minor
penalty, the recommendation kept in sealed cover cannot be given effect
retrospectively, and the employee can only be considered for promotion
prospectively after conclusion of the proceedings. The principle that
promotional benefits do not operate during the subsistence of disciplinary
consequences stands reinforced therein.
18.
The alternative submission that the penalty stood exhausted upon the
withholding of the second increment on 1st July, 2011 also cannot be
W.P.(C) 8212/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 23/02/2026 at 11:55:20
accepted. The penalty imposed was not merely the act of withholding two
increments in isolation, but the consequence of operating with a depressed
pay position for the period during which those increments remained
withheld. The service record shows that the withheld increments were
restored only on 1st July, 2012. Until such restoration, the financial
consequences of the penalty continued to operate. The expression “currency
of the penalty” in the governing Office Memorandum must be understood in
this practical sense, namely, the period during which the penalty’s
consequences remain operative. On that understanding, the Respondent were
justified in giving effect to the promotion only from 1st July, 2012.
19.
The plea of discrimination also does not advance the Petitioner’s case.
Apart from a general assertion that certain other employees were granted
promotion from an earlier date despite the imposition of minor penalties, no
specific details have been placed on record regarding the identity of such
employees, the nature of the penalties imposed upon them, the duration of
their currency, or the circumstances in which their promotions were
effected. A claim of parity in service matters must rest on demonstrated
similarity in material particulars. In the absence of such foundational
material, the allegation of unequal treatment cannot be sustained.
20.
For the reasons recorded above, the writ petition is dismissed.
Pending applications, if any, also stand disposed of.
SANJEEV NARULA, J
FEBRUARY 16, 2026/nk
W.P.(C) 8212/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 23/02/2026 at 11:55:20
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review