Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
%
+
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 25th February, 2026
Pronounced on:1st June, 2026
W.P(C) 7796/2008, CM APPL. 46598/2022
KALI RAM KAUSHIK
S/o Late Sh. Subh Ram Kaushik
R/o A/35, Shiv Enclave, Near Udaseen Ashram,
Nangloi Road, Nazaf Garh,
New Delhi-110043.
Through:
1.
2.
.....Petitioner
Mr. Gaurav Serawat, Mr. U.
Srivastava and Mr. M.K. Gaur,
Advocates.
Versus
UNION OF INDIA THROUGH
The Secretary,
Ministry of Human Resource Development,
Department of Education, Shastri Bhawan,
New Delhi.
THE INDIAN INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY DELHI
Through its Director
Hauz Khas, New Delhi-110016.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. T. P. Singh, SPC for R-1/UOI.
Mr. Arjun Mitra and Ms. Jayanti Jha,
Advs. for IIT, Delhi.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
W.P(C) 7796/2008
E N T
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
1.
The present Writ Petition has been preferred under Article 226 of
the Constitution of India seeking issuance of appropriate writs/directions for
grant of pay scale of Rs.8000-13500 in place of Rs.7500-12000, allegedly
arising from the Petitioner’s promotion/ upgradation under the Recruitment
& Career Development Scheme (R&CDS), along with consequential
financial benefits.
2.
The brief facts are that the Petitioner was initially working in the
Technical Cadre in the Respondent Institute, namely Indian Institute of
Technology Delhi. He was granted promotional advancement from the post
of Senior Technical Assistant (STA) in the pay scale of Rs.2000-3200 to the
post of Senior Technical Assistant (Selection Grade) [STA (SG)] in the
higher pre-revised pay scale of Rs.2000-3500, under the Recruitment &
Career Development Scheme (R&CDS), notified by IIT Delhi, vide
Notification dated 06.12.1994. The promotion was granted after completion
of 8 years in service in terms of Office Order No. IITD/Estt.II/98/644 dated
18.02.1998, with retrospective effect from 01.08.1996.
3.
The Recruitment & Career Development Scheme (R&CDS),
notified by IIT Delhi vide Notification dated 06.12.1994, governed
recruitment, promotion and career progression of non-academic technical
and administrative staff. Under this Scheme, the Petitioner progressed
through the technical hierarchy, to the post of Senior Technical
Assistant (Selection Grade) [STA (SG)]. This post was higher than
Technical Assistant, and the post of Senior Technical Assistant, which
constituted a higher promotional grade, within the same cadre structure.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
W.P(C) 7796/2008
4.
Pursuant to the implementation of the recommendations of the Fifth
Central Pay Commission and the directions issued by the Ministry of Human
Resource Development [MHRD] vide Letter No. F.No.19-7/98-TS.1, dated
29.04.1998, regarding revision of pay scales of non-faculty employees of
IITs, the pre-revised pay scales, underwent restructuring and revision.
5.
Consequently, vide Office Order No. IITD/Estt.II/98/3982 dated
30.06.1998, the pay of the Petitioner, who had already been promoted as
STA (SG) in the pre-revised scale of Rs.2000-3500, was revised and fixed in
the corresponding revised pay scale of Rs.7500-12000 with effect from
01.01.1996, along with consequential increments admissible thereunder.
6.
Subsequently, IIT Delhi issued Office Order dated 12.06.2001
pursuant to Board Resolution No. BG/43/2000, whereby employees who
were earlier in the pre-revised scale of Rs.2000-3500, were extended the
revised scale of Rs.7500-12000 to remove anomalies arising from merger of
the scales Rs.2000-3200 and Rs.2000-3500, after implementation of the
Fifth Central Pay Commission. The benefit was granted notionally from
01.01.1996 and financially from 01.07.2000. However, the Office Order
specifically stipulated that the grant of the revised scale of Rs.7500-12000
was purely provisional and subject to the final decision of the Standing
Committee on Executive Matters (SCEM) of the IIT Council.
7.
The Petitioner exercised the requisite option/undertaking and
accepted the said revised scale, subject to the aforesaid condition. The
Petitioner also accepted the revised fixation with actual monetary benefits,
restricted to 01.07.2000.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
W.P(C) 7796/2008
8.
The Petitioner stated that once the revised scale of Rs.7500-
12000 had been granted to him after his promotion/ upgradation as
STA (SG), he became entitled to the next higher promotional scale of
Rs.8000-13500.
The
Petitioner
thereafter,
continued
to
submit
representations, claiming entitlement to the higher pay scale of Rs.800013500 on the premise that the revised scale of Rs.7500-12000 ought to be
treated as a promotional scale and that similarly situated employees in other
IITs, had been granted the higher replacement scale.
9.
The Petitioner contended that the anomaly created due to merger of
the scales Rs.2000-3200 and Rs. 2000-3500, was only partially rectified and
that employees like him who were granted the revised scale of Rs.750012000 became entitled to movement into the higher scale of Rs.8000-13500.
10.
The Petitioner claims that his grievance has been continuing since
01.08.1996 despite repeated representations were submitted by him from
time to time, including representations dated 16.09.1998, 08.03.2000 and
14.05.2008. The Respondents failed to take a final and reasoned decision for
several years, and the impugned reply dated 29.08.2008, was issued only
after the Petitioner sought information under the Right to Information Act.
11.
It has further been contended that the cause of action is recurring
and continuing in nature since the dispute pertains to fixation of pay and
consequential service benefits.
12.
The Petitioner has accordingly, sought issuance of an
appropriate writ, order or direction directing the Respondents to grant
the higher pay scale of Rs.8000-13500 in place of Rs.7500-12000, along
with all consequential benefits including arrears, retrospective financial
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
W.P(C) 7796/2008
benefits and corresponding higher designation with effect from
01.08.1996.
13.
The Respondents filed a Counter Affidavit contending inter alia,
that the Petitioner was never appointed/ promoted to any distinct cadre/post
of “Technical Officer” and the Petitioner remained within the hierarchy of
STA/STA (SG), under the R&CDS framework.
14.
The Respondents explained that pursuant to implementation of the
recommendations of the Fifth Central Pay Commission, the Government of
India, Ministry of Human Resource Development, vide Letter No. F.No.197/98-TS.1 dated 29.04.1998, it specifically directed discontinuance of the
Recruitment &Career Development Scheme (R&CDS) and implemented the
Recruitment &Career Progression Scheme (RCPS) with the approval from
the MHRD, vide their Letter dated 22/24.2.2006, but in the said RCP
Scheme, there was no designation as 'Technical Officer'.
15.
Further, the Respondents relied upon the Minutes of the 35th
Meeting of the IIT Council held on 20.02.1999, wherein it was recorded that
R&CDS stood discontinued following implementation of the Fifth Central
Pay Commission and that IITs should await implementation of the Assured
Career Progression Scheme, in line with Central Government policy.
16.
Reliance has also been placed upon the Minutes of the 36th and 37th
Meetings of the Council of IITs, wherein the Council specifically observed
that Boards of Governors of IITs, were not competent to independently alter
pay scales, service conditions or promotional structures involving financial
implications, without prior approval of the Government of India, Ministry of
Finance and DoPT.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
W.P(C) 7796/2008
17.
The Respondents further submit that the grant of scale Rs.7500-
12000 itself was only a provisional anomaly-removal measure, subject to
approval by competent authorities and could not confer any vested right
upon the Petitioner to claim a further higher scale of Rs.8000-13500.
18.
Reliance has been placed upon the clarification issued by the
Ministry of Human Resource Development dated 04.03.2008, wherein it was
specifically observed that grant of scale Rs.7500-12000 to employees
holding the pre-revised scale of Rs.2000-3500, had been made “in violation
of Government orders” and that the correct revised scale ought to have been
Rs.6500-10500. The said clarification further stated that such higher scales
granted by IITs, could be reversed while implementing the Recruitment &
Career Progression Scheme (RCPS).
19.
On the basis of the aforesaid clarification and institutional decisions,
the Respondents rejected the representation of the Petitioner, vide
communication dated 29.08.2008, holding that the grant of scale Rs.750012000 and the date from which financial benefits had been granted, were
already “in order” and that the claim for higher scale of Rs.8000-13500, was
untenable .
20.
In this regard, reliance may also be placed upon State of U.P. v. J.P.
Chaurasia (AIR 1989 SC 19) wherein the Supreme Court held that matters
relating to pay fixation, equation of posts and determination of service
conditions, primarily fall within the domain of the Executive Government
and expert bodies, such as Pay Commissions. It was further observed that
where such determination has been undertaken by an expert body, the Court
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
W.P(C) 7796/2008
should normally refrain from interfering unless the decision is shown to
have been made on extraneous considerations.
21.
Similarly, in Union of India v. P.V. Hariharan (1997) 3 SCC 568,
the Supreme Court reiterated that fixation of pay scales is primarily the
function of the Government acting upon the recommendations of expert
bodies, such as Pay Commissions, and that judicial forums should exercise
restraint in interfering with such matters unless a clear case of hostile
discrimination is made out.
22.
The Petitioner filed his Rejoinder controverting the stand of the
Respondents and contended that the clarification dated 04.03.2008 was not
applicable to his case and that the Respondents themselves had repeatedly
acknowledged and implemented the scale of Rs.7500-12000, through Office
Orders, Board Resolutions and Council deliberations .
23.
It was further contended that the Minutes of the 38th Meeting of the
Council of IITs dated 07.09.2003, clearly acknowledged that the scale of Rs.
7500-12000 had already been granted notionally from 01.01.1996 with
financial benefits from 01.07.2000 and that the Council only declined antedating of actual financial benefits. According to the Petitioner, this
demonstrates institutional recognition of the revised scale itself.
24.
Reliance was also placed by the Petitioner upon the judgment in
Manjit Singh &Ors. V. UOI &Anr. W. P. (C) 2764/2001wherein this Court
had observed that denial of already recognized pay benefits to similarly
situated employees, despite extension of such benefits in other IITs, may
amount to hostile discrimination, violative of Article 14 of the Constitution
of India. It was contended that employees similarly situated to the Petitioner
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
W.P(C) 7796/2008
in other IITs, had been granted higher replacement benefits and therefore
denial of the same to the Petitioner was arbitrary and discriminatory.
Submissions heard and record perused.
25.
The core issue arising for consideration in the present Writ Petition
is, “Whether the Petitioner was merely granted promotional advancement
from the post of Senior Technical Assistant (STA) to Senior Technical
Assistant (Selection Grade) [STA (SG)] within the same technical cadre
under the Recruitment & Career Development Scheme (R&CDS), or
whether he had been promoted to any distinct higher post/cadre so as to
entitle him to claim the higher pay scale of Rs.8000-13500?”
26.
The principal contention of the Petitioner is that once the revised
scale of Rs.7500-12000 was granted to him after implementation of the Fifth
Central Pay Commission, he automatically became entitled to the next
higher scale of Rs.8000-13500 along with corresponding designation and
consequential financial benefits.
27.
Per contra, the Respondents have contended that the Petitioner was
never promoted to any separate cadre or post carrying the pay scale of
Rs.8000-13500. It has been submitted that the Petitioner’s promotional
advancement under the Recruitment & Career Development Scheme
(R&CDS) culminated at the stage of Senior Technical Assistant (Selection
Grade) [STA (SG)] in the pre-revised scale of Rs.2000-3500 and that the
subsequent placement in the scale of Rs.7500-12000 was only a
consequence of pay revision and anomaly removal after implementation of
the Fifth Central Pay Commission.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
W.P(C) 7796/2008
28.
However, this contention proceeds on a misconception between a
promotional advancement and a pay-fixation/anomaly-removal measure.
29.
The Petitioner was on the post of Senior Technical Assistant (STA)
who was granted salary advancement, under the Recruitment & Career
Development Scheme (R&CDS) from the pre-revised pay scale of Rs.20003200 to the Senior Technical Assistant (Selection Grade) [STA (SG)], in the
higher pre-revised scale of Rs.2000-3500, vide Office Order dated
18.02.1998 with effect from 01.08.1996.
30.
It is further undisputed that pursuant to implementation of the
recommendations of the Fifth Central Pay Commission, the Petitioner’s pay
was revised and fixed at the scale of Rs.7500-12000.However, from the
material placed on record, particularly the R&CDS Notification dated
06.12.1994, it is evident that no distinct cadre or post of “Technical Officer”
existed, insofar as the Petitioner’s channel of promotion under the technical
hierarchy, was concerned. The hierarchy under the Scheme only
contemplated progression from Technical Assistant to Senior Technical
Assistant and thereafter, to Senior Technical Assistant (Selection Grade).
Thus, while the Petitioner undoubtedly received the salary advancement to
Selection Grade, within the cadre structure, the record does not support the
contention that he was ever appointed or promoted to any separate higher
post/cadre carrying an independent replacement scale of Rs.8000-13500.
31.
This is also clear from Notification of the Ministry of Human
Resource Development which directed discontinuance of the Recruitment &
Career Development Scheme and restrained IITs from independently
altering pay structures or creating higher scales without approval of the
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
W.P(C) 7796/2008
Government of India. The Minutes of the 35th Meeting of the IIT Council
held on 20.02.1999 further recorded that R&CDS already stood
discontinued after implementation of the Fifth Central Pay Commission and
that IITs should await implementation of the ACP Scheme, in line with
Central Government policy.
32.
Significantly, no material has been placed on record before this
Court demonstrating specific approval by the Government of India
sanctioning grant of the scale Rs.8000-13500 to employees situated
similarly to the Petitioner under the R&CDS framework.
33.
Thus, it is established that the Petitioner wasever promoted to any
distinct higher cadre/post carrying the pay scale of Rs.8000-13500, so as to
claim any consequential higher designation or retrospective monetary
benefits with effect from 01.08.1996.
34.
The next question which emerges is, “Whether the revised pay scale
of Rs.7500-12000 granted to the Petitioner was only a provisional payfixation/anomaly-removal measure, subject to approval of the Standing
Committee on Executive Matters (SCEM), IIT Council and Government
authorities, thereby disentitling the Petitioner from claiming the higher
scale of Rs.8000-13500 as a matter of right?”
35.
The Petitioner has contended that once the scale of Rs.7500-12000
was granted and continued in his favour, the same attained finality and could
not be treated as provisional in nature. Reliance has also been placed upon
the Minutes of the 38th Meeting of the Council of IITs dated 07.09.2003, to
claim that the scale stood recognized by the IIT Council itself.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
W.P(C) 7796/2008
36.
On the other hand, the Respondents have contended that the grant of
the scale of Rs.7500-12000 was always provisional and subject to
approval of the competent authorities including SCEM/IIT Council and
the Government of India. It has further been contended that the said scale
itself was granted contrary to Government Orders and could not create any
vested right in favour of the Petitioner.
37.
The Office Order dated 12.06.2001 itself specifically stipulated that
the grant of the revised scale of Rs.7500-12000 was provisional and
subject to the final decision of the Standing Committee on Executive
Matters (SCEM)/IIT Council. However, as already discussed hereinabove,
the material on record clearly demonstrates that the Petitioner never
acquired any substantive promotional entitlement beyond the post of
STA (SG).
38.
The record further reflects that the Petitioner himself exercised the
option/undertaking accepting the aforesaid condition and also accepted
the revised fixation with actual financial benefits restricted to
01.07.2000. Once the Petitioner accepted the benefit subject to such express
conditions, he cannot subsequently contend that the said scale conferred
upon him a vested right to claim a still higher scale of Rs.8000-13500.
39.
The Minutes of the 38th Meeting of the Council of IITs dated
07.09.2003 recorded that the scale of Rs.7500-12000 had already been
granted notionally from 01.01.1996 with financial benefits from 01.07.2000
and that only the request for ante-dating of actual financial benefits was
declined. However, the said deliberations merely indicate that the issue
remained
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
under
W.P(C) 7796/2008
consideration
owing
to
anomalies
arising
after
implementation of the Fifth Central Pay Commission. The same cannot be
construed as conferring final and unconditional approval by the Government
of India, for grant of the higher scale of Rs.8000-13500.
40.
Further, the Minutes of the 36th and 37th Meetings of the IIT
Council clearly emphasized that the Boards of Governors of IITs, were not
competent to independently alter service conditions, pay scales or
promotional structures involving financial implications without concurrence
of the competent Government authorities, including the Ministry of Finance
and DoPT.
41.
In this regard, reference may also be made to Section 31and 33(2)
(b) of the Institutes of Technology Act, 1961, which provides for the
establishment of the IIT Council as the central statutory body overseeing the
functioning of the Institutes. It reads as under:
“31. Establishment of Council.—
(1) With effect from such date as the Central
Government may, by notification in the Official Gazette,
specify in this behalf, there shall be established a central
body to be called the Council.”
“33. Functions of Council.—
(1)…
(2) Without prejudice to the provisions of sub-section(1),
the Council shall perform the following functions,
namely:(a)…
(b) to lay down policy regarding cadres, methods of
recruitment and conditions of service of employees,
institution of scholarships and freeships, levying of fees
and other matters of common interest…”
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
W.P(C) 7796/2008
42.
A conjoint reading of the aforesaid statutory provisions makes it
evident that matters pertaining to cadre structure, methods of recruitment,
service conditions and allied policy decisions concerning employees of the
Institutes are vested within the statutory domain of the IIT Council.
Consequently, individual IITs or their respective Boards of Governors could
not have independently altered pay structures, created higher promotional
avenues or granted financial upgradations involving policy and financial
implications outside the approval mechanism contemplated under the
statutory framework and the policy directions of the Central Government.
43.
At this stage, reference may also be made to State Fisheries Officers
Association, West Bengal v. State of West Bengal (1997) 9 SCC 65, wherein
the
Supreme Court declined to direct grant of retrospective monetary
benefits contrary to the policy decision of the Government and held that no
direction can be issued compelling the Government to extend financial
benefits inconsistent with its approved policy framework, particularly in
matters involving financial implications and executive discretion.
44.
The aforesaid principle assumes significance in the present case
inasmuch as the Petitioner seeks grant of a higher pay scale and
consequential monetary benefits, despite the absence of approval by the
competent Government authorities and contrary to the policy framework
reflected in the decisions of the IIT Council and the Ministry of Human
Resource Development.
45.
The clarification issued by the Ministry of Human Resource
Development dated 04.03.2008, also assumes significance. The Ministry
specifically observed that grant of the scale of Rs.7500-12000 to employees
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
W.P(C) 7796/2008
holding the pre-revised scale of Rs.2000-3500, had been made contrary to
Government Orders and that the correct revised scale ought to have been
Rs.6500-10500. The clarification further stated that such higher scales
granted by IITs could be reversed, while implementing the Recruitment &
Career Progression Scheme (RCPS).
46.
Thus, the entire framework emerging from the institutional record
clearly demonstrates that the scale of Rs.7500-12000 was only an interim
anomaly-removal/pay-fixation measure arising out of revision and merger of
pre-revised scales and did not constitute any substantive promotional scale
carrying further replacement benefits.
47.
It has been next contended on behalf of the Petitioner that once the
revised scale of Rs.7500-12000 stood granted notionally with effect from
01.01.1996 and financially from 01.07.2000, the Petitioner became entitled
to all consequential benefits flowing therefrom, including placement in the
higher scale of Rs.8000-13500, arrears, retrospective monetary benefits and
corresponding higher designation with effect from 01.08.1996.
48.
This Court finds that the foundation of the Petitioner’s claim for
consequential benefits rests entirely upon the assumption that the revised
scale of Rs.7500-12000 constituted a substantive promotional scale carrying
further replacement benefits. However, as already discussed hereinabove,
the material on record clearly demonstrates that the Petitioner never
acquired any substantive promotional entitlement beyond the post of
STA (SG).
49.
Admittedly, the Minutes of the 38th Meeting of the Council of IITs
dated 07.09.2003 recorded grant of the scale of Rs.7500-12000 notionally
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
W.P(C) 7796/2008
from 01.01.1996 with financial benefits from 01.07.2000. However, the said
deliberations did not amount to final approval by the Government of India
for grant of the higher scale of Rs.8000-13500 or consequential retrospective
monetary benefits.
50.
Further, as already discussed, the clarification issued by the Ministry
of Human Resource Development dated 04.03.2008 specifically observed
that the grant of the scale of Rs. 7500-12000 itself was contrary to
Government Orders and that the appropriate revised scale ought to have
been Rs.6500-10500.
51.
Significantly, no material has been placed on record to establish that
the Government of India ever approved a grant of the scale of Rs.800013500 or a corresponding higher designation and consequential arrears, to
employees situated similarly to the Petitioner under the R&CDS framework.
52.
Insofar as the challenge to the impugned communication dated
29.08.2008 is concerned, this Court finds that the said decision was taken
after consideration of the Petitioner’s representations, the applicable policy
framework, the Minutes of the IIT Council Meetings and the clarification
issued by the Ministry of Human Resource Development. The impugned
communication, therefore, cannot be said to suffer from arbitrariness,
irrationality or jurisdictional infirmity warranting interference under Article
226 of the Constitution of India.
53.
At the same time, this Court cannot overlook that although the
Petitioner was granted the revised scale of Rs.7500-12000 pursuant to
institutional decisions taken by IIT Delhi, the Respondents never withdrew
the said benefit and continued the same throughout. There is nothing on
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
W.P(C) 7796/2008
record to show that the said benefit was ever formally cancelled or
withdrawn in accordance with due process of law.
54.
To sum up, the Petitioner was granted Selection Grade Scale under
Recruitment & Career Development Scheme (R&CDS), but it was subject to
approval from competent authorities. This
Scheme got replaced by
Recruitment & Career Progression Scheme (R&CPS), and the fitment of
pay scales was accordingly, done in the light of Fifth Pay Commission
recommendations and the Notifications issued by Govt. of India, thereof.
55.
In view of the aforesaid discussion, it is held that the Petitioner has
failed to establish any legal or vested right to claim the higher pay scale of
Rs.8000-13500
or
consequential
designation/post
and
retrospective
monetary benefits, with effect from 01.08.1996.
56.
The Writ Petition is accordingly, dismissed along with pending
Application(s), if any.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
JUNE 01, 2026
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:32:43
W.P(C) 7796/2008
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review