Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
+
RFA 591/2024, CM APPL. 4472/2025
KALAWATI DEVI
W/o Late Shiv Prasad Chaudhary
R/o H. No. RZL-200, Vijay Enclave, New Delhi.
.....Appellant
Through: Mr. Satyavan K. Advocate.
versus
1.
AJAY KUMAR THAKUR
S/o Late Budhram Thakur
R/o RZL-200, Vijay Enclave, New Delhi.
2.
SHRI MANOJ KUMAR THAKUR
S/O Late Budhram Thakur
R/O RZL-200, Vijay Enclave, New Delhi.
Through: None
.....Respondents
%
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
ORDER
17.03.2026
1.
An Appeal under Section 96 of The Code Of Civil Procedure, 1908,
(herein referred to as ‘CPC’) has been filed on behalf of the Appellant
challenging the Judgment/Decree dated 04.06.2024, whereby the learned
District Judge has decreed the Counter-claim of the Defendants/Respondents
against the Plaintiff/Appellant, under Order XII Rule 6 CPC, for the
Possession.
1A.
The facts in brief are that Appellant/Plaintiff-Kalawati had filed a
Suit for Recovery of Rs.5 lakhs along with interest @ 2% per annum and for
Permanent Injunction, in respect of the Suit property bearing No.RZL-200,
Vijay Enclave, New Delhi-110045 against the Respondent/Defendant Ajay
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 30/03/2026 at 17:37:17
Kumar Thakur and others.
2.
A Counterclaim No. 2/2020 seeking possession of the Suit Premises,
was filed by the Defendant/Respondent Ajay Kumar Thakur.
3.
It was the case of the counter claimant, Respondent-Ajay Thakur that
Budhram Thakur, his father was the owner of the Suit Property, by virtue of
GPA, Receipt and Possession Letter dated 02.02.1984.
4.
It was further averred that Kalawati, the Appellant who was living in
the vicinity, was a victim of wrongdoings of her husband. The father of Ajay
Thakur took mercy on her and permitted her to reside in the portion of the
Suit Property, on a nominal license fee of Rs.5,500/- per month.
5.
Sh. Budhram Thakur, father of Ajay Thakur expired on 23.02.2012
after which Smt. Kalawati stopped paying monthly license fee. The original
title documents of the Suit Property, were in the possession of Kalawati,
who refused to return the same. Hence, the Respondents filed a
Counterclaim for recovery of possession against Smt. Kalawati.
6.
Since Budhram failed to honour his commitment, and the Suit for
recovery of Rs.5 lakhs and Permanent Injunction, had been filed by Smt.
Kalawati.
7.
The Defendants contested the Suit for Recovery of the Plaintiff,
Kalawati by filing Written Statement and also filed a Counter-Claim
asserting that there was no document in writing given, about the loan of Rs.5
lakhs being taken by their father or that he ever agreed to transfer the Suit
property in lieu of payment of loan. It was further asserted that the Plaintiff
had been inducted as a Licensee for a License Fee of Rs.5,500/- per month.
However, she is neither paying the License Fee nor vacating the premises,
but has been implicating them in false cases. Hence, the claim of the
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 30/03/2026 at 17:37:17
Plaintiff was denied.
However, a Counter-claim was filed seeking
Possession/ Mesne Profits from the Plaintiff/Appellant.
8.
The Plaintiff contested the Counter-Claim by asserting that the
complete facts have not been disclosed by Sh. Ajay Thakur. She has been
residing in the property since 1995; all her documents, namely, Aadhaar
Card, Ration Card, Election ID Card, etc., are of the Suit Premises. All the
averments made in the Conter-Claim, were denied.
9.
The Respondents, filed the Application under Order XII Rule 6
CPC seeking the possession of the Suit Property, from Smt. Kalawati,
seeking Judgment of Admission qua the Possession of the Suit property.
10.
Smt. Kalawati in the Reply to Application under Order XII Rule 6
CPC, admitted that the Suit Property admeasuring 50 sq. yds. had been
purchased by Sh. Budhram Thakur, father of Ajay Thakur on 02.02.1984,
from one Jagdish, after which he came to reside in the Suit Property. Smt.
Kalawati further admitted that she and her family, was residing in a rented
accommodation, in the same locality. However, it was submitted that on
account of the marriage of the daughter and other requirements, Budhram
took Rs.5 lakhs from the husband of Smt. Kalawati and in order to secure
the loan, he gave in writing that loan of Rs.5 lakhs which he had taken,
would be returned by selling his own property and till then, the family of
Shiv Prashad Chaudhary, would have right to live in half part of the
property in question and also that till he fulfils his obligations, he would pay
interest @ 2%. Further, in order to secure the loan, the original documents
of the property were given to Shiv Prashad Chaudhary, husband of Kalawati.
Kalawati and her family, since then, have been residing in the portion of the
Suit Property. Her husband died on 24.12.2002.
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 30/03/2026 at 17:37:17
11.
Earlier, the Defendants were not residing with the father, but in the
year 2010, the Defendants came to Delhi from Gujarat and started residing
in the other half of the house along with the father. The father of the
Defendants died in the year 2012.
12.
After the demise of the father of the Defendants, Plaintiff demanded
Rs.5 lakhs from the Defendants or to transfer the Suit property in the name
of the Plaintiff, but the Defendants requested some time to return the amount
and kept on delaying the same on one pretext or the other and assured that in
any case the Plaintiff along with the family, was residing in the portion of
the Suit property.
13.
The Plaintiff gave a Complaint dated 29.01.2012 to the Police against
the Defendants who were threatening her to vacate the house and that she
had danger to her life from the Defendants and the anti-social elements.
Eventually, when the Defendants failed to returned the money, she filed a
Suit for Recovery of Rs.5 lakhs along with interest @ 2% per annum since
1995 and in the alternative sought the directions be given to the Defendants
to transfer the Suit property in the name of the Plaintiff and also for
Permanent Injunction.
14.
Smt. Kalawati though contested the Counterclaim of the Respondent,
and the Application under O.XII Rule 6 CPC, but admitted the ownership in
favour of Sh. Budhram, father of Ajay Thakur, but claimed that her husband
had advanced Rs.5 lakhs to Sh. Budhram Thakur, on account of which,
husband of Kalawati was permitted to reside on a small portion of the Suit
Property, under the assurance that either he would return Rs.5 lakhs or
transfer the Suit Property in favour of husband of Kalawati.
15.
The Application under Order XII Rule 6 CPC to seek possession by
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 30/03/2026 at 17:37:17
Ajay Thakur, is claimed to be an arm twisting tactic and mala fide and his
Counterclaim seeking possession, is liable to be dismissed.
16.
The learned District Judge referred to the admissions of Kalawati,
that in view of the loan of Rs.5 lakhs given by her husband to father of Ajay
Thakur, who was admittedly the owner of the property, they had been
permitted to live in the premises. Since the loan of Rs.5 lakhs has not been
repaid, they have a right to continue in the premises.
17.
Considering that all the ingredients of decree of possession stood
admitted, the Application under Order XII Rule 6 CPC was allowed and the
relief of recovery of possession in the Counterclaim filed by Ajay Thakur,
vide Judgment dated 04.06.2024, though the Counter-Claim for Mesne
Profits is still pending.
18.
Aggrieved by the said Judgment, the present Appeal has been
preferred by the Plaintiff/Non-Counter-Claimant.
19.
The grounds of challenge are that the impugned Judgment dated
04.06.2024, in contrary to law and facts of the case and is totally
unsustainable. There were no admissions made by the Plaintiff, either in the
Plaint or in the response to the Counter-Claim and, therefore the ingredients
of Application under Order XII Rule 6 CPC, were not met. The CounterClaim had been filed with the sole motive to harass the Plaintiff.
20.
It
has
not
been
considered
that
the
father
of
the
Respondents/Defendants had agreed to sell the property to the Appellants, as
mentioned in the Plaint. The actual dispute has not been considered in the
right perspective. Moreover, it has been admitted in the Counter-claim that
the Appellant is in Possession of the original documents of the property, but
it has not been explained that how the original documents came in the
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 30/03/2026 at 17:37:17
Possession of the Appellant. No documentary evidence has been brought on
record to show that the Appellant is a Licensee in the half portion of the Suit
property. Without recording of evidence in regard to their respective cases,
the impugned Order, in part decreeing the Counter-Claim, was not justified
It has resulted in a great miscarriage of justice to the Appellant and also
huge financial loss along with mental harassment. The Appellant cannot be
thrown out of the Suit property in the manner adopted by the Respondent,
which is gross misuse of the process of the Court.
21.
Reliance is placed on Ashok Kumar Bagga vs. Rajvinder Kaur AIR
OnLine 3021 Del 724 in RFA No.226/2020 decided on 07th April, 2021 by
the Co-ordinate Bench of this Court. Reliance is also placed on Himani
Alloys Limited vs. Tata Steel Limited (2011) 15 SCC 273, wherein the scope
of Order XII Rule 6 has been explained.
22.
It is submitted that the present Judgement is without merit and is
liable to be set aside.
23.
Learned Counsel for the Respondent submits that though there is a
reference made by the Plaintiff about the written document, but the same has
not been filed on record. From the averments made in the Plaint, it is
evident that her status was only that of a Licensee, who had been permitted
by the father of the Respondent to live in the property. It is submitted that
there is no infirmity in the impugned Judgment and the Appeal is liable to be
dismissed.
Submissions heard and record perused.
24.
The Appellant Kalawati has admitted that Budhram, father of the
Defendant was the owner of the Suit Property. She herself has explained that
her husband Shiv Prashad Chaudhary, along with his family, was permitted
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 30/03/2026 at 17:37:17
to reside in the Suit Property since 1995 in view of a loan of Rs.5 lakhs
which was given by her husband. Admittedly, to secure the loan of Rs.5
lakhs, original documents of paper were given to Shiv Prashad Chaudhary,
deceased husband of Smt. Kalawati.
25.
It is quite evident from the admissions of Smt. Kalawati herself, that
the possession was given only in lieu of loan of Rs.5 lakhs which had been
taken by late Sh. Budhram, father of the Defendant. Smt. Kalawati has
already sought the recovery of loan, by way of Suit for Recovery, in which
the present Counter-Claim has been filed for possession.
26.
Even if the case of the Appellant is admitted, her case is that Budhram
had undertaken that he would continue to pay interest @ 2% on the loan
amount and in case, he was unable to pay the loan, he would execute the
documents of title in favour of Shiv Prashad Chaudhary, deceased husband
of Kalawati.
27.
From her own contentions, it emerges that at best, this written
document can be considered as an Agreement to Sell whereby late Budhram
agreed to transfer the property in favour of Shiv Prashad Chaudhary,
deceased husband of Kalawati, but the Appellant herself never sought
execution of sale documents in her favour. She has only claimed the return
of Rs.5 lakhs for filing a Suit.
28.
In these circumstances, when admittedly, her occupation was
permissive as per her own submissions, she in the absence of any title
documents, which are admittedly in the name of Budhram, father of the
Respondents, cannot claim any right to continue in the possession of the Suit
Premises.
29.
The learned District Judge vide impugned Order dated 04.06.2024,
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 30/03/2026 at 17:37:17
has rightly observed that all the ingredients for passing an Order for
possession stood clearly admitted by Smt. Kalawati and therefore, passed a
decree for possession.
30.
The Appellant-Kalawati may have an independent right to seek the
recovery of loan of Rs.5 lakhs for which she has already filed a Suit, but it
does not entitle her to continue the possession in the Suit Property.
31.
There is no merit in the present Appeal, which is hereby, dismissed
along with pending Applications.
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
MARCH 17, 2026/VA/N
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 30/03/2026 at 17:37:17
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review