Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010575882005
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
Bench Sr.No:-28
[3506]
WRIT PETITION NO: 12861 of 2005
K.Suryaprakasharao, Conductor, E.455488, Eleswaram
APSRTC Depot.
...Petitioner
Vs.
The Regional Manager, APSRTC, Rajahmundry, East ...Respondent(s)
Godavari District & Ors.
**********
Advocate for Petitioner:
Sri S. A. RAZAK
Advocate(s) for Respondent(s):
Sri K. SRINIVASA PRASAD, SC
For APSRTC;
G.P. FOR LABOUR
CORAM : SRI JUSTICE CHALLA GUNARANJAN
DATE
: 6th March 2026
ORDER:
Present writ petition assails award, dated 04.05.2004, passed in
I.D.No.245 of 2002 on the file of the Industrial Tribunal-cum-Labour
Court, Visakhapatnam, and consequently, seeks to quash the same by
setting aside the order of punishment and to award the consequential
service benefits.
2.
Brief facts of the case are as follows:
(a) Petitioner worked as Conductor with the 1st respondent
Corporation.
When petitioner was on duty and en-route from
Pithapuram to Samarlakota, the TTIs conducted check at Samarlakota
CGR, J.
W.P.No.12861 of 2005
bus station. It was noticed that two of the passengers were found to be
travelling without tickets. The check revealed that though the said
passengers stated to have paid the requisite fare of Rs.6/-, the
Conductor did not issue the tickets. In that context, on the allegations
that the Conductor has not issued tickets, that he refused to record
statements of passengers, failed to maintain the S.R. properly, and
lastly, that he exhibited improper behaviour and abused TTIs with
unparliamentary language, charge memo, dated 25.08.1994, came to
be issued. The enquiry officer held that all charges came to be proved.
The same eventually resulted in petitioner being removed from service
vide orders, dated 07.03.1993. Even appeal preferred against the said
order got confirmed. On further review, though the reviewing authority
did not find any illegality in the orders of removal, as confirmed by the
appellate authority, considering the short span of service left out, lenient
view was taken and thereby the order of removal came to be modified
to that of reduction of pay to minimum scale of Conductor for a period
of two years with cumulative effect and the suspension period was
treated to be not on duty for the purpose of leave and increments.
(b) Being dissatisfied with the aforesaid order, dated 17.05.1995,
petitioner through the Union raised a dispute and sought for reference
in terms of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, (for short, “the I.D.Act”).
The Government had accordingly made a reference to the Tribunal to
CGR, J.
W.P.No.12861 of 2005
decide on the question whether the punishment imposed by reviewing
authority was justified and if not, what relief the workman entitled to.
(c) Before the Tribunal, petitioner did not examine anyone,
however, marked the statements of passengers, driver, and himself,
which were part of the enquiry report in the departmental enquiry. On
the other hand, the Management has exhibited Exs.M1 to M26, which
included enquiry report, marked under Ex.M20.
(d) The Tribunal having considered aforesaid evidence and also
the stand of petitioner that he was not disputing the validity of domestic
enquiry and the report marked under Ex.M20, ultimately, has come to
conclusion that the opinion and view expressed by reviewing authority
does not call for interference, inasmuch as though there were clear
findings in the domestic enquiry, supporting the order of removal as
confirmed by the appellate authority, still the reviewing authority has
taken a lenient view and modified punishment so imposed cannot be
said to be unjustified. Assailing the same, present writ petition is filed.
3.
Heard Sri S.A.Kalam Riyaz, learned counsel, representing
Sri S.A. Razzaq, learned counsel for the petitioner and Sri K. Srinivasa
Prasad, learned standing counsel for APSRTC, appearing for the 1st
respondent Corporation.
CGR, J.
W.P.No.12861 of 2005
4.
Learned counsel for the petitioner mainly contended that the
Tribunal failed to appreciate the evidence on record in proper
perspective, and important evidence of the passengers and driver, who
were introduced by the petitioner, was not at all discussed and merely
based on the ultimate findings of enquiry report, the reference came to
be answered, which is clearly perverse.
In elaboration of said
submission, learned counsel has taken this Court to the statements as
found in the enquiry report, to buttress that the findings arrived at by the
enquiry officer were clearly contrary to the evidence on record.
Therefore, the opinion of enquiry officer could not have been taken as
basis for answering the reference.
5.
Per contra, learned standing counsel for 1st respondent
Corporation tried to support the Award passed by the Tribunal. It is
contended that the domestic enquiry against petitioner was conducted
strictly in accordance with the applicable Regulations of the Corporation,
that petitioner has been given ample opportunity at every stage i.e.,
before the enquiry officer, and later before the Depot Manager, who
finally passed the order of removal, therefore, the entire exercise of
conducting enquiry was done strictly following the fair and transparent
procedure adhering to the principles of natural justice. The disciplinary
authority after analysing entire of evidence on record has come to
CGR, J.
W.P.No.12861 of 2005
conclusion that the charges levelled against petitioner since came to be
proved, imposed appropriate penalty of removal from service and the
same has later been confirmed by the appellate authority and even the
revisional authority also has concurred with the findings on the charges,
therefore, merely because revisional authority has taken a lenient view
in modifying the order of punishment, the same cannot be found fault
with, and hence, would urge to dismiss the writ petition.
6.
Perused the record and considered the rival submissions of both
the learned counsels.
7.
It is fairly well settled now that certiorari shall issue to correct
errors of jurisdiction, that is to say, absence, excess or failure to exercise
and also when in the exercise of undoubted jurisdiction, there has been
illegality. It shall also issue to correct an error in the decision or
determination itself, if it is an error manifest on the face of the
proceedings. By its exercise, only a patent error can be corrected, but
not a wrong decision. It should be well remembered at the cost of
repetition that certiorari is not appellate but only supervisory.
8.
Petitioner mainly tried to emphasize that the award suffers from
perversity on account of non-appreciation of evidence on record. In
order to test the said submission, it has to be seen that what evidence
CGR, J.
W.P.No.12861 of 2005
has been placed on record by the petitioner, inasmuch as it is for the
petitioner to establish his case based on the evidence that he has let in
to clearly demonstrate the order of removal as confirmed by appellate
authority and modified by the reviewing authority suffered from any
illegality.
9.
As can be seen from the impugned award, none were examined
for petitioner, however, the statements of passengers and driver, as
recorded before the enquiry officer in the course of disciplinary
proceedings, were marked without independently examining them
before the Tribunal. Whereas, the Management has got marked Exs.M1
to M26.
10.
Before the Tribunal, the petitioner has specifically pleaded that
petitioner was not disputing the validity of domestic enquiry, meaning
thereby, even the enquiry report was not under dispute. Merely because
some of the statements, which were made by the passengers and driver
spoke in favour of petitioner, the same cannot be considered in isolation
de hors the other overwhelming material on record and the ultimate
findings and conclusions drawn by the enquiry officer. Even the enquiry
officer’s findings and opinion would be only one piece of material
evidence, ultimately, it is the decision of disciplinary authority, as
confirmed by the appellate authority, matters for examining as to
CGR, J.
W.P.No.12861 of 2005
whether the conclusions so arrived at were based on no evidence at all.
Apparently, the orders of disciplinary authority, appellate authority and
as well as the reviewing authority, recorded reasons on appreciation of
evidence in coming to the decision of imposing the punishment against
petitioner, and even the Tribunal found such orders to be completely
justified.
11.
Therefore, merely because the evidence of passengers and the
driver as recorded in the process of domestic enquiry have some sort of
bearing on the proceedings to navigate in favour of petitioner, and the
decision arrived based on such evidence, even if amounted to a wrong
decision, this Court, exercising certiorari jurisdiction, cannot correct
such errors. Even otherwise, on a close look at the enquiry report and
the statements of passengers and driver recorded therein, the enquiry
officer has formed an opinion that there was a clear paradigm shift in
their initial versions. Initially, both of them stated to have spoken against
the petitioner and even signed the statements, however, later when they
were introduced on behalf of the Conductor in the course of enquiry
before the enquiry officer, they spoke otherwise, completely in
contradiction. The view expressed by the enquiry officer has been
evaluated by the disciplinary authority and other higher authorities in
coming to ultimate conclusion that the charges have been proved,
CGR, J.
W.P.No.12861 of 2005
therefore, this Court exercising certiorari jurisdiction would not
reappreciate the evidence on record sitting as an appellate authority.
Therefore, there are no merits in the writ petition.
12.
Accordingly, the writ petition stands dismissed. No order as to
costs.
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions pending consideration, if
any, in this case shall stand closed.
_____________________________
JUSTICE CHALLA GUNARANJAN
cs
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review