Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3219 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FORTHE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAO
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
THURSDAY, THE FOURTEENTH DAY OF MAY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENW SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE T.MADHAVI DEVI
WRIT PETITION NO: t16381 OF 2022
Between:
A. Ramchandar, S/o Pochaiah, aged about 55 Years, Working as Public Health
Worker, Nizamabad Municipal Corporation, Nizamabad, Nizamabad District
...PETITIONER
AND
1. The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary, MA and UD
Department, Secretariat Buildings, Hyderabad.
2. The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary, Finance and
Planning Department, Secretariat Buildings, Hyderabad.
3. The Commissioner and Director of Municipal Administration AC Guards,
Hyderabad.
4. The Nizamabad Municipal Corporation, Nizamabad, Nizamabad District, rep.
by its Commissioner.
...RESPONDENTS
I
t
,
I
,
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased
to issue Writ Order or Direction more particularly one in the nature of Writ of
Mandamus by calling for the records relating to the impugned orders issued by the
3rd respondent vide Proc. Lr. No. C29618/2016, dt, 22.8.2024 and set aside the
same by declaring as illegal, arbitrary and voilative of the principles of natural justice
and also contrary to the law laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of
State of Punjab & others Vs. Jagjith Singh and others (Reported in 2017 (1) SCC
148 and consequently direct the respondents to extend the benefit of minimum time
scale as per law laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of State of
Punjab & others Vs. Jagjith Singh & others (Reported in 2017 (1) SCC 148 on par
with my juniors along with arrears and pass such other order or orders.
As per court ordet, dt.251912025 Vide lA 112025 in WP No.4638,1!2022. Prayer is
amended.
NO: 1 OF 2022
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated tn the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to direct the
respondents to consider the claim of the petitioner for extension of the benefit of
minimum time sczle as per law laid down by the Honble Supreme Court in State of
Punjab and ors Vs. Jagajith Singh and ors Reported in 2017 (1) SCC 149 forthwith,
pending final disposal of the writ petition.
Counsel for the Petitioner : Sri P.Raghavendra Reddy
Counsel for the Respondent No.1 : GP FOR MCPL ADMN URBAN DEV
Counsel for the Respondent No.2 : GP FOR FINANCE & PLANNING
Counsel for the Respondent No.3&4 : SMT.R.MADHAV| LATHA,
SC FOR SERVICES MATTERS OF MCs
The Court made the following: ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HONOURABLE SMT. JUSTICE T. MADHAVI DEVI
WRTT PETTTION NO.46381OF 2022
DATED:
.05.2026
Between:
A.Ramachandar
... Petitioner
AND
The State ofTelangana, rep. by its Principal
Secretary, MA & UD Department, Secretariat
Buildings, Hyderabad and 3 others
... Respondents
ORDER
In this Writ Petition, the petitioner is seeking a Writ of Mandamus
to call for the records relating to the impugned orders dt.22.08.2024 arrd
to set aside the same by declaring them as illegal, arbitrary and violative
of principles of natural justice and also contrary to the law laid down by
the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in the case of State of Punjab and
others Vs. Jagiith Singh and othersr and consequently to direct the
' lzorzy r scc tct
W.P.No.463E I ot2022
respondents to extend the benefit of minimum time scale as per the law
laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in rhe case ol State of punjab
and others Vs. Jagiith Singh and others (l supra) on par with the
petitioner's juniors and also to pay the arrears and to pass such other
order or orders.
2.
Brief facts leading to the filing of this Writ petition are that the
petitioner was appoinred as a Public Health Worker on 01.09.19g7 on
daily wage basis in respondent No.4 organization and when his services
were terminated orally on 01.05.1993 without assigning any reasons and
without any notice, the termination order was challenged in I.D.No. 163
ol 1996 before the Labour Court-II, Hyderabad and vde order
dt.3 1.07.1998, thc Labour court granted the relief of reinstatement with
continuity of service.but without back wages and the same was assailed
by respondent No.4 in W.P.No.2l392 of 2002 before this Courr. It is
submitted that despite being reinstated, the petitioner is receiving only
Rs. 10,000/- per month, while the juniors of the petitioner are receiving
the minimum time scale and regularisation status since 16.03.2009.
It is
submitted that the Hon,ble Supreme Court in the case of A.Manjula
Bhashini and others Vs. Managing Director, Andhra pradesh
i
a
W P'No 463E I of2022
Women's Co-operative Finance Corporation Limited and another2
citing G.O.Ms.No.2l2, Finance and Planning Department' dated
22.O4.lg94 directed the Govemment of Andhra Pradesh to regularise
all
eligible daily wage, temporary part time employees within four months
regardless of any prior dismissed legal claims lt is submitted
though respondent No.4, vide lettr'l. dt'28'02'2017, has addressed
that
to the
District Cotlector/Chairman, Nizamabad and confi rmed the availabitity
of 3 vacancies, the respondents have laited to regularise the services of
the petitioner. It is submitted that the petitioner has made a
representation dt.04'05.2015 for regularisation of his services'
but the
respondents have not taken any action thereon and therefore'
the
petitioner filed O.A.No.6320 of 2015 and due to the Tribunal's
I
abolition, the case was transferred to this Court and is pending
for
I
consideration before this Court and that the respondents have
I
I
not filed a
I
counter aflidavit in the said case till date' The petitioner is
i
seeking a direction to the respondents to pay minimum time
therefore
scale olpay
to the petitioner on the principle of 'equal pay lor equal work' as
laid
down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of State o[ Punjab
and
others Vs. Jagiith Singh and others (l supra)'
'(2009) E scc 4l I
a
W-P.No.46381 of 2022
3.
Respondent No.4 has filed a counter affidavit stating that pursuant
to the directions of rhe Labour court, the petitioner has been reinstated
into service on I l. | 2 -2002 and since the petitioner has already been
reinstated into service, the writ petition filed by the corporation has
been dismissed by this court on 20.03.2012. It is submitted that the
petil"ioner was appointed as a daily wage vehicre loader in March,
r990
and not in 1987 as claimed by the petitioner and that the said fact is
confirmed by the Municipar council records dt.l r.0l.l993 and that the
petitioner was reinstated into service vide order dt.rr.r2.2oo2 pursuant
to the interim order of this court in w.p.M.p.No.26g4r of 2002 in
W.P.No.2l392 of 20OZ dt.2O.1Z.ZOOZ and that the petitioner is
receiving wages as an outsourcing/daily wage employee rather than a
regular NMR worker. It is submitted that there are no similarry situated
persons as that o[ the petitioner for parity and that the reference
to one
N.Venkatesh and 60 others who were receiving wages by orders
dt.03.07.2007, 20.t2.2008 and 2j.tt.z}l}, is not applicable to the
petitioner. It is also stated that the petitioner is not having regular
attendance and therefore, the petitioner is not eligibre
par wyh other employees.
//
to be treated on
W.P.No.463E I of 2022
4.
Learned counsel for the petition€r as well as the learned counsel
for respondent No.4 Corporation advanced arguments in line with the
averments made in the writ affidavit and also the counter affidavit.
5.
Leamed counsel for the petitioner also placed reliance upon the
decision of this Court in G. Mangaiah and another Vs. The
Government of Andhra Pradesh rep. by its Principal Secretary,
School Education and others3, wherein a direction was given to make
the payment of minimum time scale attached to last grade employees of
the Govemment of Telangana to the petitioners therein from the date of
filing of the O.A. He is seeking similar direction to pay the minimum of
the time scale of pay.
6.
Having regard to the rival contentions and the material on record,
this Court finG that this case is not for regularisation of the services of
the petitioner, but is for payment of minimum time scale of pay of last
grade employees to the petitioner from the date of his appointment.
Similarly placed persons have already been considered by this Court in
the case of G. Mangaiah and another Vs. The Government of
Andhra Pradesh rep. by its Principal Secretary, School Education
' w.p.Gn)xo.6as3 of 2017 dr29.o1.2025
,.1
(W.P.No.4638l of 2022
and others (3 supra), following the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme
Corrrt of India in the case of State of Punjab and others Vs. Jagiith
Singh and others (1 supra) and this Court has observed as under:
"7.
Having regard lo lhe rival contentions and the moterial
on record, this tlourt finds that admi edb,, the petitioners have been
u,orking from 1992 and 1993 respectivety and the petitioners u,ere
being paid on par with the daily wagers ond their services hove not
been regulari:ed It is also a foct that lhe rcgularization of the sen,ices
can be made oniy if there existed sonctioned posts. As seen
fron the
details of the sanctioned post.t in the Government High School, Ricob
Bazor, Khommam, there are no posts of sweeper or the watchman. This
.fact itself sho+vs the apathy of the Government in making necessory
orrongements lor
the administration of the school. It is not
understandable as to how a school can function without o sweeper and
ii
a v)otchman. Tht' contentions of the Head Master that the petilioners
have been engaged on need basis also rhu they have been working in
the same continuously from lhe year 1992 and 1993 onwards shows
thal there was a need for o sweeper and a u,atchman. The respondents
are therefore directed to create the posts of sweeper and watchman
from the date of the engagement of the petilioners or subsequent thereto
and thereafter, consider regularizalion of the sertices of these
pelitioners with erfect from the date of their completion offive years of
service.
8.
Further, irrespective of lhe regularization of the
petilbners' servit'es, rhis Court f nds thtat Hon'ble Supreme Court in
F
i
!
t
I
the case oJ[ State of Punjab and Others Vs. Jagjit Singh and Others
(AlR 2016 SC 5176) as held that even remporory employees are
eligihle for the equal pay as thar ofregular employees i.e., the minimum
w.P.No.4638l of2022
time scale of pay attached to lhe post. Since there is no regular
sanctioned po$ ofa sweeper or a watchman in this school, this Court is
of the opinion that the scale atlached to the last grade employee of the
Covernmenl should at leasl be paid to the petitioners as per the
rationale laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Jagiit
Singh (cited supra).
9.
The judgments relied upon by the learned Sovernment
pleader in support of their conlenlions are distinguishable onfacts The
Government has to be a model employer and should not be permitted to
exploit the unemployed and exlract work from them wilhout making
payment of reasonable wages. Therefore' the respondents ttre directed
lo pay lhe minimum time scale of pay attached to the last grade
employee of the Government of Telangana to the petitioners from the
date offiling of the O.A. The resPondents are further directed to pass
necessary orders in this regard within a period ofthree (3) months from
the date ofreceipt ofa copy ofthis order.
t0
Accordingly, this writ petition is dispoied of There shall
be no order as to costs. "
7.
It is not in dispute that the petitioner has been working as a daily
wage worker lrom 1990 and after oral termination, the petitioner has
also been reinstated into service in the year 2002. The petitioner is
therefore eligible for minimum time scale of pay from the date of
reinstatement, i.e., ll.l2.2OO2 because the reinstatement was ordered by
the Labour Court without any back wages.
I
I
r.
W.P.No.4638l of 2022
8.
The respondents are therefore directed to fix the minimum time
scale ol pay to the pctitioner with effect from the date of his
reinstatement into service, i.e., 11.12.2002 and grant him all
the
consequential benefits. The fixation of the pay as wellas the payment
of
consequential benefits/arrcars to the petitioner shall be made within
a
period of tour (04) months lrom the date of receipt of a copy
of this
order
9.
The Writ Petition is accordingly allowed. No order as to
l0'
Pending miscerraneous petitions, if any, in this writ petition
costs.
shall
stand closed.
//TRUE GOPY//
\I
Sd/.K.BHAVANI SWAMY
ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
SECTION OFFICER
To,
1. The Principat Secretary, MA and UD Department, Secretariat,
Telangana
2. The principal Secretary, Finance and planning Department,
Secretariat,
State Buildings, Hyderabad.
Telangana State Buildings, Hyderabad.
I
3. The Commissioner and Director of Municipal Administration
Hyderabad.
4. The Commissioner, Nizamabad Municipal Corporation,
AC Guards,
Nizamabad,
Nizamabad District.
5. One CC ro SRt p.RAGHAVENDRA REDDY, Advocate.
6. Two CCs to Gp FOR M!?!.|_DMN URBAN DEV, HightOpUCl
Court for the Srate of
Telangana, at Hyderabad [OUT]
7. Two CCs to Gp FOR
itry1rygE & PLANN|NG, High Court for the State of
Telangana at Hyderabad.
[OUT]
8. One CC to SMT.R.MADHAV| LATHA, SC FOR
SC FOR SERVTCES
MATTERS oF MUNtctpAL conponniibr.ri
toiucl
f. 9. Two CD Copies.
BSK
!
I
HIGH COURT
DATED: 1410512026
VACATION COURT
1 6E 5I4
t
P
ORDER
WP.No.46381 of 2022
ALLOWING THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
t
1 5 ilAY 2025
J
*
o
b
I
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review