Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
ABLAPL No.13154 of 2024
An application under Section 438 of the Cr.P.C., read
with Section 482 of the BNSS, 2023.
Ippili Sanyasi Raju @ I. Sanyasi ….
Petitioner
Raju
Mr. Janmejaya Katikia, Advocate
-versusState of Odisha
….
Opposite Party
Mr. D. Sarangi, Advocate for Complainant
Mr. U.R. Jena, A.G.A.
ABLAPL No.12708 of 2024
Bhaskar Rao Nekkanti @ N. ….
Petitioner
Bhaskar Rao
Mr. Janmejaya Katikia, Advocate
-versusState of Odisha
….
Opposite Party
Mr. D. Sarangi, Advocate for Complainant
Mr. U.R. Jena, A.G.A.
ABLAPL No.13155 of 2024
Pedina Dilip Kumar @ Dillip ….
Petitioner
Kumar
Mr. Md. Riaz, Advocate
-versusState of Odisha
….
Opposite Party
Mr. D. Sarangi, Advocate for Complainant
Mr. U.R. Jena, A.G.A.
ABLAPL No.13820 of 2024
Neredupalli Adinarayana @ N. ….
Petitioner
Adinarayana
Ms. Susama Rani Sahoo, Advocate
-versusState of Odisha
….
Opposite Party
Mr. D. Sarangi, Advocate for Complainant
Mr. U.R. Jena, A.G.A.
ABLAPL No.13901 of 2024
K. Krishna Rao
….
Petitioner
Dr. Binoda Kumar Mishra, Advocate
-versusState of Odisha
….
Opposite Party
Mr. D. Sarangi, Advocate for Complainant
Mr. U.R. Jena, A.G.A.
CORAM:
JUSTICE A.K. MOHAPATRA
_____________________________________________________
Date of hearing : 11.11.2025 | Date of Order: 22.01.2026
______________________________________________________
A.K. Mohapatra, J. :
1.
The above noted batch of anticipatory bail applications
have been filed by the accused-Petitioners under Section 438 of
the Cr.P.C. for their release on pre-arrest bail in connection with
Rayagada P.S. Case No.208 of 2010, which was reregistered as
CID CB, Odisha, Cuttack FIR No.10 dated 05.04.2011, which
corresponds to G.R. Case No.132 of 2011, on a protest petition
being filed by the Informant against the final form the same has
been reregistered as 1CC No.06 of 2024 and now pending in the
file of learned S.D.J.M., Rayagada for commission of an offence
punishable under Section 120-B/ 302/ 201/ 34 of IPC.
2.
Since the above noted bail applications arise out of the
self-same occurrence and the Petitioners have been implicated
as accused in the self-same case and since the factual
background is common, all these applications have been taken
up together for hearing and the same are being disposed of by
the following order.
3.
Heard Mr. J. Katikia, learned counsel for the Petitioners
along with other counsels appearing in the connected matters
and Mr. Debasish Sarangi, learned counsel for the complainant
in all the bail applications as well as Mr. U.R. Jena, learned
Additional Government Advocate for the State-Opposite
Parties. Perused the case diary as well as the materials brought
on record in course of hearing.
4.
Since the bail applications involve a common set of
facts, the facts pleaded in ABLAPL No.13154 of 2024 is being
taken up for analysis of the factual background of the
prosecution case, which is common in all the bail applications.
5.
The prosecution story as culled out from the complaint
petition bearing 1CC No.06 of 2024, in brief, is that the
complainant, namely Jagannath Mandangi lodged a protest
against filing of the final form as insufficient evidence under
Sections 302/ 201 of IPC vide CID P.S. FF No.1 dated
19.01.2024 arising out of CID CB P.S. Case No.10 of 2011,
which corresponds to G.R. Case No.132 of 2011, now pending
in the file of the learned S.D.J.M., Rayagada. As per the
allegation made in the said protest petition, which was treated
as a complaint case as indicated hereinabove, one Bhagirathi
Mandangi (deceased), the brother of the complainant/Informant
went missing on 15.12.2012. Where after a missing report was
lodged before the Rayagada P.S. on 17.12.2010. Consequently,
the same was registered as Rayagada P.S. MMR No.10 of
2010.
6.
The gist of the complaint case, in short, is that on
19.12.2010 an unidentified male dead body was recovered from
Jhanjabati River Dam, Rajalaxmipuram, Komarada, Andhra
Pradesh. An autopsy was conducted on the dead body on
20.12.2010. The complainant and his relatives were called to
identify the dead body and to confirm as to whether the same is
the body of the missing person, namely Bhagirathi Mandangi.
The family members of the complainant including the
complainant initially failed to identify the said dead body as the
body of the missing Bhagirathi Mandangi. On 23.12.2010 an
FIR was lodged by the Informant, namely, Jagannath
Mandangi, which was registered as Rayagada P.S. Case No.208
of 2010 under Section 364 of IPC against unknown accused
persons. The local police took up the investigation. After
conclusion of the investigation a final form was submitted by
the Rayagada Police Station.
7.
Thereafter, the case was handed over to CID CB
pursuant to the direction of the Court. The CID CB registered
P.S. Case No.10 of 2011 under Section 364 of IPC. While this
was the position, several litigations were initiated either at the
instance of the complainant or his mother in different courts.
Eventually, the matter came to this Court in Criminal Revision
No.221 of 2024. Pursuant to order dated 05.08.2024 passed by
this Court, the learned S.D.J.M., Rayagada has taken
cognizance of the offences in 1CC No.06 of 2024, which arises
out of G.R. Case No.132 of 2011. The cognizance of the
offence was taken under Section 120-B/ 302/ 201/ 34 of IPC
and an NBW was issued against the present Petitioners by the
learned S.D.J.M., Rayagada.
8.
Mr. Katikia, learned counsel for the Petitioners at the
outset contended that when the dead body of the deceased
Bhagirathi Mandangi was not found or at least the dead body
which was recovered from the dam was not confirmed to be the
dead body of the deceased Bhagirathi Mandangi despite
autopsy being conducted on such unknown dead body and in
view of the statement of Dr. N.M.K. Tirumala Prasad, who has
been examined as complainant witness No. CW-8, no case is
made out or at least no cognizance could have been taken for
commission of an offence under Section 302 of IPC. He further
contended that the statement of CW-8 confirms the conclusion
drawn by the CID CB after investigation. He further submitted
that there exists no definite and conclusive material on record
to establish either the missing person is dead or that the present
Petitioners are involved in the alleged crime in any manner
whatsoever. Learned counsel for the Petitioners also supported
the submission of final report on the ground of insufficient
evidence under Section 302/ 201 of IPC submitted by the CID
P.S. in the shape of FF No.1 dated 19.01.2024.
9.
Learned counsel for the Petitioners further contended
that the dead body which was recovered from the dam is an
unknown dead body and that the same was subjected to
autopsy. Despite such post mortem being carried out by the
doctor, it was not established that the body which was
recovered from the dam is the body of the missing person,
namely Bhagirathi Mandangi. In view of the aforesaid position,
learned counsel for the Petitioners further contended that the
learned trial Court should have accepted the reasoning of the
investigating agency and that the examination of the CW-8,
who had conducted the post mortem, confirms the fact that the
dead body which was recovered from the Jhanjabati River Dam
is not the dead body of the missing person, namely Bhagirathi
Mandangi, and as such, no case should have been registered for
commission of an offence punishable under Section 302 of IPC
against the present Petitioners.
10.
Learned counsel for the Petitioner further emphatically
argued that when the body of the missing person has not been
recovered or at least such fact has not been established by
adducing cogent and reliable evidence, the very registration of
a case under Section 302 of IPC is bad in law. It was also
contended that without establishing the identity of an unknown
dead body no case under Section 302 of IPC could have been
registered and that the accused persons could not have been
implicated by registering a case against them despite the fact
that the investigation carried out earlier ended in submission of
the final form. As such, it was argued that there exists no prima
facie case at all against the present Petitioners.
11.
Mr. D. Sarangi, learned counsel for the complainant on
the other hand strongly objected to the release of the Petitioners
on pre-arrest bail. Mr. Sarangi, learned counsel for the
complainant at the outset contended that after taking
cognizance of the offence pursuant to the order passed by this
Court in a criminal revision, the learned trial Court has already
issued NBW against the accused persons. On such ground, Mr.
Sarangi, learned counsel for the complainant submitted that the
present anticipatory bail application is not maintainable. He
further contended that since cognizance has already been taken
for commission of an offence under Section 120-B/ 302/ 201/
34 of IPC, a strong prima facie case exist against the present
Petitioners. It was also contended that the application of the
Petitioners under Section 438 of Cr.P.C is to be adjudicated on
the basis of the material available or collected in the complaint
case and not basing upon the case record of the G.R. Case.
12.
Learned counsel for the complainant would further
argue that on the basis of the material collected in the
complaint case, it is well-established that the missing person
namely, Bhagirathi Mandangi’s death is homicidal in nature.
Which is established from the correct identification of the dead
body which was recovered from the Jhanjabati River Dam and
consequential post mortem report submitted by the doctor.
Further, laying emphasis on the autopsy report, learned counsel
for the complainant submitted that the cause of death was due
to head injury and that later the dead body was dropped in the
dam. In the aforesaid context, learned counsel for the
complainant referred to the evidence of CW-8. He further
contended that after the dead body was recovered on
19.12.2010, the Komoroda P.S. informed the Rayagada P.S.
about such facts. However, such information was given to the
complainant after two days on 21.12.2010. By then, the post
mortem was over and the body was totally decomposed. From
the mortal remains, which was nothing but the skeletal remains
of the dead body, the deceased person was not identifiable.
13.
Mr. Sarangi, learned counsel for the complainant
further contended that some photographs of the dead body were
taken on 20.12.2010 immediately after the body was recovered
from the dam. Such photographs were shown to the
complainant, who happens to be the brother of the deceased. It
was from such photographs that the complainant identified the
body of the missing person as none other than his brother,
Bhagirathi Mandangi. After that the complainant claimed the
body and performed the last rites of his deceased brother.
However, the same was refused by the police. Mr. Sarangi,
learned counsel for the complainant further argued that the
motive behind killing of the deceased was his objection to the
irregularity
committed
by
the
accused
persons
and
misappropriation of the fund of majhighariani temple. In
course of hearing, learned counsel for the complainant
highlighted the conspiracy that had taken place to terminate the
deceased which was carried out as per the direction of accused
N. Adinarayana, P. Dillip Kumar and others. He further alleged
that the deceased was murdered in the temple premises itself by
the accused persons and thereafter the body was disposed of in
the dam of Jhanjabati River.
14.
To further strengthen the case of the complainant,
learned counsel for the complainant also laid emphasis on the
fact that the deceased was last seen entering into the temple
office. By that time all the accused persons were present at the
temple office. After some time the accused persons came out of
the temple office, but the deceased never came out of the
temple. He further alleged that after committing the crime the
accused persons caused disappearance of evidence by dropping
the dead body in the river dam. In the aforesaid context, he also
referred to the evidence of the complainant witness Nos.4 & 5.
Further, referring to the evidence of CW-7, he alleged that the
accused persons were seen travelling towards Andhra side in a
Bolero vehicle. Referring to the aforesaid circumstances,
learned counsel for the complainant alleged that the deceased
has been murdered in a gruesome and brutal manner by the
accused persons and that almost all the circumstances taken
together establish the involvement of the present accused
persons in the alleged crime.
15.
Learned counsel for the State, referring to the records
and the statement of the witnesses as well as other relevant
documents, submitted before this Court that a case is well made
out against the accused persons, therefore, they are bound to
face the trial in the complaint case. He further submitted that
there are enough materials on record to frame charges against
the accused persons and on such basis the accused persons are
liable to face trial for commission of the alleged offences.
Referring to the gravity and seriousness of the allegation,
learned counsel for the State objected to the release of the
Petitioners on pre-arrest bail.
16.
Having heard the learned counsels appearing for the
respective parties, upon a close scrutiny of the prosecution case
as well as the materials placed on record in course of hearing,
this Court observed that although initially an investigation was
carried out and a final form was submitted, the investigating
agency submitted a final form indicating insufficiency of
evidence for the alleged charges. However, subsequently on the
basis of the protest petition, a complaint case was registered.
Thereafter, the learned S.D.J.M., Rayagada, after recording the
statement of the witnesses, has taken cognizance of the offence.
Examination of the record further reveals that earlier the
complainant approached this Court by filing W.P.(C) No.21412
of 2011 for issuance of a writ of habeas corpus. A Division
Bench of this Court, vide order dated 12.08.2011, disposed of
the application by taking note of the fact that a police case has
already been registered and the investigation is progressing.
Accordingly, the jurisdictional police was directed to proceed
with the matter in accordance with law. By virtue of order
dated 25.04.2013 passed in W.P.(CRL) No.513 of 2012 the
investigation of the case was handed over to the Crime Branch.
17.
Despite order dated 25.04.2013 directing the Crime
Branch to take up the investigation, the Crime Branch did not
take up the investigation work. As a result of which, the mother
of the deceased approached the Hon’ble Supreme Court by
filing Writ Petition (Crl) No.169 of 2013. The Hon’ble
Supreme Court vide order dated 25.10.2013 disposed of the
above noted Writ Petition by granting liberty to the Petitioners
to approach this Court and with a further request to this Court
to entertain the Petition and issue notice to the Crime Branch
and find out as to whether the investigation as directed by this
Court has been undertaken by the Crime Branch in accordance
with law. Finally, a Coordinate Bench in Criminal Revision
No.221 of 2024, filed at the instance of the complainant, was
allowed vide order dated 05.08.2024 and eventually the learned
Coordinate Bench, while setting aside the impugned order
passed in 1CC No.06 of 2024 by the learned S.D.J.M.,
Rayagada, directed the said Court to proceed with the disposal
of the complaint in accordance with law. It is not disputed by
both sides that in the meantime cognizance of the offence has
already been taken.
18.
In the aforesaid factual backdrop, this Court is of the
considered view that there are ample materials to establish the
fact that a crime, which is punishable under Sections 120-B,
302, 201, 34 of IPC, has taken place. However, the perpetrators
of such crime can only be identified once a full-fledged trial
takes place and after evidence is adduced from both sides.
Taking into consideration the severity, magnitude and gravity
of the allegation, this Court has no hesitation in coming to a
conclusion that the alleged crime is one of a most brutal and
gruesome nature. It is also evident from record that although
the alleged crime had taken place in the year 2010, till date the
trial has not commenced despite of the fact that cognizance of
the offence having being taken in the meantime. It is also not
disputed that the learned trial Court after taking cognizance of
the offence has issued an NBW against the accused-Petitioners.
In such factual backdrop, this Court is not inclined to grant prearrest bail to the accused-Petitioners.
19.
Further, taking into consideration the fact that in the
complaint case, the learned S.D.J.M., Rayagada, after recording
statement of the witnesses, has already taken cognizance of the
offences and that the case is now ready for trial, this Court
directs the accused-Petitioners to surrender before the learned
trial Court and move an application for bail within two weeks
from today. In such eventuality, the learned trial Court shall
release each of the Petitioners on bail subject to each of the
Petitioners furnishing a bail bond of Rs.50,000/- (Rupees Fifty
Thousand) each with two solvent sureties each of the like
amount to the satisfaction of the Court in seisin over the matter.
The release of the Petitioners shall also be subject to the
following terms and conditions;
i) shall not indulge in any criminal activity while they are
on bail;
ii) shall not harass, threaten or terrorize any of the
prosecution witnesses;
iii) shall not tamper with any prosecution evidence;
iv) shall appear before the learned trial Court on each and
every date fixed, unless their personal appearances are
dispensed with by the learned trial Court in accordance
with law;
v) shall not leave the jurisdiction of the learned trial Court
without seeking permission of the learned trial Court first;
20.
It is open to the learned trial Court to impose any other
conditions as would be deemed just and proper. It is further
made clear that violation of any of the aforesaid conditions
shall entail cancellation of the bail application.
21.
With the aforesaid observations/directions, the ABLAPL
applications stand disposed of.
(Aditya Kumar Mohapatra)
Judge
Orissa High Court, Cuttack
The 22nd Jan, 2026/ S.K. Rout, Jr. Stenographer
Digitally Signed
Signed by: SANTANU KUMAR ROUT
Reason: Authentication
Location: High Court of Orissa, Cuttack
Date: 22-Jan-2026 18:00:01
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review