Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
C/FA/3207/2013(GJHC240399612013)
JUDGMENT DATED: 16/09/2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
R/FIRST APPEAL NO. 3207 of 2013
With
R/CROSS OBJECTION NO. 21 of 2015
In
R/FIRST APPEAL NO. 3207 of 2013
FOR APPROVAL AND SIGNATURE:
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ILESH J. VORA
Sd/-
and
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE R. T. VACHHANI
Sd/-
==========================================================
Approved for Reporting
Yes
✔
No
==========================================================
STATE OF GUJARAT & ORS.
Versus
JYOTIKABEN W-O MOHANLAL CHUNILAL PRAJAPATI & ORS.
==========================================================
Appearance:
MS SURBHI BHATI, AGP for the Appellant(s) No. 1,2,3
DECEASED LITIGANT THROUGH LEGAL HEIRS/ REPRESTENTATIVES
for the Defendant(s) No. 9
MR ANKIT SHAH(6371) for the Defendant(s) No. 1,2,3,4
MR.JAY S SHAH(7244) for the Defendant(s) No. 1,2,3,4
RULE SERVED for the Defendant(s) No. 10,11
SWAPNESHWAR GOUTAM(9051) WITH MR RAHIL P. JOSHI, ADVOCATE
for the Defendant(s) No. 5,6,7,8
==========================================================
CORAM:HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ILESH J. VORA
and
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE R. T. VACHHANI
Date : 16/09/2026
ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER : HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ILESH J. VORA)
1.
This first appeal, under Section 96 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
at the instance of original defendant no.1 and 2 – State of Gujarat and is
directed against the judgment and decree dated 31.01.2013, passed by the
C/FA/3207/2013(GJHC240399612013)
JUDGMENT DATED: 16/09/2026
learned Senior Civil Judge, Surendranagar in Special Civil Suit No.9 of
2008, whereby the suit filed by the respondents no.1 to 4 – original
plaintiffs, for compensation on account of death of Mohanlal Chunilal
Prajapati, was decreed and the appellant–defendant-State was directed to
pay a sum of Rs.12,79,372/- with interest @ 9% per annum from the date
of filing of suit, till realization besides cost.
2.
After filing of the first appeal, respondents no.1 to 4 – original
plaintiffs have filed their cross-objections being Cross-objection No.21 of
2025 under Order 41 Rule 22 of the CPC, inter alia, stating that the
amount of compensation having not been properly assessed and the
amount so awarded is not just and reasonable amount.
3.
For convenience, the parties shall be referred to as they were
before the learned trial court.
4.
Facts of the case:
4.1
The case of the plaintiffs, in brief is that, on 30.05.2006, the
deceased Mohanlal and his brother Hasmukh Chunilal had gone to the
Office of Narmada Water Resources, Water Supply and Kalpasar
Department at Village: Lakhtar, Dist: Surendranagar in connection with
the inspection of scrap materials, as by way of public auction, the
defendant no.2 and 3 intend to dispose of unserviceable machinery,
vehicles, steels and spare parts. It is the case of the plaintiffs that, at the
premises of the defendant, there was old gantry crane (hand operated
lifting arrangement) and the said crane suddenly crashed from its position
and fell upon the deceased and others, as a result, the deceased sustained
spinal and chest injuries. He was taken to Viramgam Civil Hospital and
C/FA/3207/2013(GJHC240399612013)
JUDGMENT DATED: 16/09/2026
then, he was advised to take treatment at Higher Centre i.e. Ahmedabad
Civil Hospital. There was a strike of the Doctors attached with the Civil
Hospital. The deceased was then transferred and admitted at Samved
Private Hospital and during the treatment, he died on the same day i.e.
30.05.2006 at about 5:40 p.m. It is the further case of the plaintiff that, on
the same day, the incident reported as accidental death with Lakhtar
Police Station. The deceased was cremated without the post-mortem. On
20.06.2006, again, the incident reported in the form of A.D. with Lakhtar
Police Station. A written complaint addressed to D.S.P., Surendranagar
was submitted on 07.12.2006 which was culminated into FIR on
18.01.2007.
It is further case of the plaintiffs that, at the place of incident, the
old dilapidated gantry was lying unused and was under control,
management and/or supervision of the defendant authority. The defendant
authority and its officers were negligent in maintaining the old gantry and
at the time of auction proceedings and/or inspection of the scraps, the
persons who permitted to enter premises, were entitled to expect that the
place will not contain a dangerous structure or equipment which is liable
to collapse and cause injury, unless appropriate warning, isolation or
other safety measures have been taken. In the facts of the present case,
the gantry which was under control of the defendant authority, fell upon
the deceased which itself shows the negligent act on the part of the
defendants and therefore, for the alleged tortious acts, the defendants
were liable for amount of compensation.
It is further case of the plaintiffs that, the deceased died at the age
of 34 and he was hale and hearty. He did graduation in B.Sc. He was
C/FA/3207/2013(GJHC240399612013)
JUDGMENT DATED: 16/09/2026
working with Tej Vasan & Metal Stores and Uttam Metal Industries and
was having other source of income from the Commodities Exchange
interest etc. The deceased was regularly paying income tax and his future
was bright and there was all prospects of increasing his income if the
incident would not have occurred. The deceased was married having a
minor son. The widow as well as the parents had lost love and affection
of the deceased. On sad demise of the deceased, they had spent huge
amount towards his treatment and also spent amount towards funeral
expenses etc.
In such circumstances referred to above, the widow, minor son and
parents being legal heirs and representatives instituted a civil suit to
recover the amount of compensation to the tune of Rs.50 lakhs from the
State as well as the Officers of the concerned Departments.
4.2
The defendants contested the suit and denied each and every
averment made in the plaint as well as the act of negligence and the
grounds raised in the plaint for compensation. It was inter alia, pleaded in
the written statement filed at Exh.15 that, the deceased and his brother did
not have participated in the tender process and they were not entitled to
inspect the scraps lying at the place of incident. On the contrary, they
trespassed the place of incident and unauthorizedly entered into the
premises. On the aspect of incident, it was inter alia, stated that, there was
huge crowd at the place and the deceased being a part of the crowd, did
not heed the request of the officers concerned and sat on the vertical
frames of the gantry, as a result, a horizontal beam supported by two
upright frames, collapsed and fell upon the deceased and others. Thus, it
is specifically contended that, the deceased himself had contributed to the
C/FA/3207/2013(GJHC240399612013)
JUDGMENT DATED: 16/09/2026
death and as such, the defendants were not responsible for the occurrence
and there was no negligence attributable to the defendant authority. It
was specifically stated that, due to delayed FIR and absence of postmortem, would create a suspicion on the true facts of the incident and on
this ground, no compensation can be awarded.
5.
On the basis of pleadings, the learned trial court framed the
following issues:
(i)
Do the plaintiffs prove that deceased Mohanlal died due to
injury sustained on account of falling of the gantry at the
place of incident?
(ii)
Do the plaintiffs prove that, the incident occurred due to
negligence and carelessness of the defendants and lack of
necessary precautions?
(iii)
Do the plaintiffs been able to prove the income of the
deceased? If yes, what was the annual income?
(iv)
What amount of compensation and rate of interest the
plaintiffs are entitled to get?
(v)
Do the defendants prove that, the plaintiffs’ claim is time
barred?
(vi)
Do the defendants prove that, the deceased himself was
negligent and they are not responsible for the alleged
incident?
(vii) Are the plaintiffs entitled to the relief sought?
C/FA/3207/2013(GJHC240399612013)
JUDGMENT DATED: 16/09/2026
(viii) What is the final order and decree?
6.
The issues framed by the trial court referred to above came to be
answered as under:
(i)
In affirmative;
(ii)
In affirmative;
(iii)
Partly in affirmative;
(iv)
As per the final order;
(v)
In the negative;
(vi)
In the negative;
(vii) Partly in affirmative;
(viii) As per final order.
7.
In support of their case, the plaintiffs have examined, widow
Jyotikaben at Exh.28, eye witness and brother of the deceased – Hasmukh
Chunilal at Exh.99, Dr. Mitesh Shah at Exh.116. The plaintiffs have
produced before the trial court the deposition of Dr. Bharat Patel recorded
in Criminal Case at Exh.128. The plaintiffs have relied upon the
voluminous documents. The relevant documents proved and produced at
Exh.59 to 61, 83 to 86, which are in the form of criminal case
proceedings, FIR, death certificate, medical certificate and ITR Returns.
In order to discharge their burden, the defendants have examined
Shailesh K. Patel (Defendant no.5 at Exh.133), eye witness Laljibhai
Jethva at Exh.149, Karimkhan Battumiya at Exh.152 and defendant no.8,
Rameshwar Taide at Exh.153.
C/FA/3207/2013(GJHC240399612013)
8.
JUDGMENT DATED: 16/09/2026
The trial court after hearing the parties and upon appreciation of
the evidence, held that, the defendants are liable for the death of the
deceased as the doctrine of Res ipsa loquitur is applicable to the facts of
the present case and the gantry which has caused the injury, was under
the ownership and control of the defendants and the defendants have
failed to maintain the gantry with its stability and safety. On the aspect of
contributory negligence of the deceased is concerned, the defendants
failed to prove the contributory negligence attributable on the part of the
deceased. The trial court on the aspect of limitation, held and observed
that, the suit filed within a period of two years from the date of cause of
action and limitation governed by Article 82 of the Limitation Act. The
trial court while awarding the compensation, had taken into account the
annual income of the deceased of Rs.1,18,000/- and after deducting 1/3 rd
and applying the multiplier of 16, Rs.12,61,872/- was the amount of
compensation awarded. The trial court relying on the case of Sarla
Verma & Ors. vs. Delhi Transport Corporation & Anr. [2010 (1) GLR
17], awarded Rs.5,000/- towards loss to the estate, Rs.2500 towards
funeral expenses and Rs.10,000/- under the head of loss of consortium
being awarded. In all, the amount of Rs.12,79,372/- with the interest @
9% being directed to be paid by the State – defendant nos.1 to 3. The
claim of the parents has not been considered and the suit qua them, came
to be dismissed.
9.
In such circumstances, being aggrieved and dissatisfied with the
impugned judgment and decree, the State is before this Court by
preferring the captioned appeal.
C/FA/3207/2013(GJHC240399612013)
10.
JUDGMENT DATED: 16/09/2026
Ms. Surbhi Bhati, learned Additional Government Pleader, while
assailing the impugned judgment and decree, made the following
submissions:
(i)
That, the impugned judgment and decree are bad in law and
against the settled principle of law, as the trial court failed to
appreciate the admitted facts that, the deceased was neither
invitee, nor had authority to enter into premises, as he
individually did not have participated in the auction
proceedings and thus, he was simply a trespasser and in that
case, there was no duty of care towards the trespasser and
having regard to the peculiar facts of the case, there was no
willful acts or deliberate intention of causing harm to the
deceased. The evidence on record produced by the State
before the trial court shows that, the deceased did not have
participated in the tender process and thus, as such there is
no contractual relation to permit him to enter into premises
for the purpose of inspection of the scraps. Thus, therefore,
the trial court miserably failed to appreciate that the
defendant authority being an occupier of the place of
incident, did not owe any duty of care to a trespasser. The
deceased being a trespasser, had entered the property at his
own risk and the occupier owes no duty to take any
responsibility for his protection and in absence of any willful
acts, the State and its departments cannot held liable for the
death of the deceased.
(ii)
That the entire incident create suspicion as after the incident,
C/FA/3207/2013(GJHC240399612013)
JUDGMENT DATED: 16/09/2026
the deceased was taken to Government Hospital at
Viramgam, where inspite of his consciousness he did not
disclose the incident to the doctor in form of history. On the
contrary, the history of fall injury being noted by the Doctor
- Mitesh Shah Exh. 116. The brother of the deceased failed
to lodge a complaint on the same day i.e. 30.05.2006 and
same was registered merely 6 months after the incident. The
postmortem to ascertain the cause of death was not
undertaken at the Government Hospital. There is sufficient
evidence to show that on the day of incident, despite of
strike of the doctors, the postmortem of the other dead
bodies was being conducted by the doctors of the
Government Hospital. The brother and other family
members of the deceased were prosecuted for not conducting
the postmortem. The officers of the department who have
been joined as defendants are acquitted by the Criminal
Court for the offence under Section 304A of the IPC, which
shows that, merely the incident occurred within the premises
of the State Government, the defendants cannot be held
liable to the alleged incident and under such circumstances,
the principle of Res ipsa loquitur cannot be applicable to the
case of the present case.
(iii)
That the suit itself is time barred as for the incident dated
30.05.2006, the suit was instituted on 08.02.2008 i.e. after
delay of 2 years. The trial Court failed to appreciate this
aspect while observing that the suit is filed within limitation.
C/FA/3207/2013(GJHC240399612013)
(iv)
JUDGMENT DATED: 16/09/2026
That the trial Court while deciding the issue of contributory
negligence, discarded the convincing and satisfactory
evidence led by the defendants. The witnesses Exh. 133, 149
and 152 have categorically stated that the deceased and
others despite of warning, sat on the support pipe of the
gantry. The gantry was lying not at the inspection place but
it was located from 200 feet away from the site. Thus, the
deceased himself was responsible for the incident. However,
the trial Court without any justification, discarded the cogent
and acceptable evidence on the aspect of negligence of the
deceased and therefore, having regard to the conduct of the
deceased, the defendants cannot be held liable for the death
of the deceased.
(v)
That the compensation having been awarded on higher side
and having regard to the evidence on record, the multiplier
and calculation of it, not in consonance with the record
because, the income of the deceased suddenly rise in the
year 2006 compare to 2005, without any justification, which
shows that, for the purpose of getting higher amount, the
evidence of income being prepared and produced without
proving the actual income of the deceased.
(vi)
So far as cross-objection filed by the original plaintiff for
enhancement of the compensation is concerned, it was
submitted that, when the income of the deceased is not
proved in accordance with law, then, question does not arise
to consider the future prospective income and other
C/FA/3207/2013(GJHC240399612013)
JUDGMENT DATED: 16/09/2026
compensation on different heads.
11.
Mr. Swapneshwar Gautam with Mr. Rahil Joshi, learned advocates
appearing for and on behalf of the officers of the Narmada and Water
Resources Department, have adopted the submissions made by the
learned AGP Ms. Bhati and in addition to that, they further added that the
deceased himself was responsible for the incident as there was no need
for him to enter into other division of the office, where the gentry was
lying and to prove this fact, the officers, who were present have
categorically deposed about the misdeeds of the crowd and conduct of the
deceased and despite of warning given to the deceased, they did not heed
the request and sat on the center pipe of the gentry and therefore, when
deceased himself acted negligently, no liability can be fastened upon the
defendants for the death of the deceased.
12.
In such circumstances, the learned counsels appearing for the
defendants have prayed that the trial Court while determining the issues,
has not properly considered the oral as well as documentary evidence in
its true prospective and therefore the conclusion arrived at are contrary to
the evidence and settled principle of law on the aspect of tortious liability
and therefore, it is prayed that the trial Court was not justified in holding
the defendants liable for the death of the deceased and it was further
prayed that, by setting aside the judgment and decree, the suit of the
plaintiffs may be dismissed with costs.
13.
On the other hand, Mr. Jay Shah, learned advocate appearing for
and on behalf of the plaintiffs, has supported the judgment and decree and
submitted that,:-
C/FA/3207/2013(GJHC240399612013)
JUDGMENT DATED: 16/09/2026
(1) That, the brother of the deceased had paid tender fees in the name
of ‘Tej Vasan & Metal Store’ on 29.05.2006 (Exh. 50) and on the
next day, the deceased along with his brother took visit for the
inspection of scrape materials. Thus, the contention with regard to
trespasser cannot be accepted, as being employee of the firm and
brother of Hasmukh Chunilal Exh. 99, who had applied in the
tender process, had all the right to enter to inspect the goods subject matter of auction. Thus, the defendants being occupier of
the premises, was under a general duty of care towards the visitors
for which, there was a breach of duty on their part because legally
they are duty bound to protect the visitors from unreasonable harm.
Admittedly, the old gentry lying at the place in a dangerous
condition and it was under the control, management and /or
supervision of the defendant authority. During the course of
auction proceedings, the old gentry suddenly fell from its position
and came upon the deceased. The defense with regard to selfnegligence of the deceased having not been proved and established,
as all the witnessed examined by the defendants have admitted in
cross-examination that, they have not personally seen the incident.
The factum of incident was reported to higher officers of the
defendant on the next day of incident, wherein, it was stated that,
the uncontrolled crowd sat on the center pipe of the gentry, despite
of warning. However, the fact remained that, no any complaint in
this regard being filed with any authority. Thus, the defense of selfnegligence and/or contributory negligence of the deceased having
not been proved and established. Thus, the trial Court on the basis
of available evidence has rightly invoked the principle of Res ipsa
C/FA/3207/2013(GJHC240399612013)
JUDGMENT DATED: 16/09/2026
loquitur and held that the thing causing the injury is under the
ownership and control of the defendants and the occurrence is
such, as would not ordinarily take place without negligence, the
circumstances themselves may rise the prima-facie inference of
negligence.
(2) That, the dispute with regard to non-conducting of the postmortem
report and delay in filing the complaint as raised by the defendants,
having been properly dealt by the trial Court. It is settled position
of law that, a person’s death can be proved by examining the
surrounding circumstances including the medical treatment etc. and
as such law does not say that the death only be proved by
conducting postmortem. In civil litigation, the findings on all
disputed question of facts including the time of death can be
arrived at from the evidence on record by applying principle of
preponderance of probability and in the case on hand, the treating
doctors have categorically opined the nature of injuries suffered by
the deceased and resultant cause of death. So far as, delay in filing
complaint is concerned, the police was informed on the same day,
which has been considered by the trial Court. On the basis of FIR,
the officers of the department were chargesheeted under Section
304 read with Section 114 of the IPC and the said evidence is a
strong corroborative circumstances in a civil action where standard
is preponderance of the probabilities and therefore, the failure to
conduct postmortem as well as delay in lodging the FIR can be
taken as a circumstances against the plaintiffs.
(3) On the aspect of limitation, the trial Court by taking into
C/FA/3207/2013(GJHC240399612013)
JUDGMENT DATED: 16/09/2026
consideration the limitation of 2 years, as provided under Article
82 of the Limitation Act, has rightly rejected the plea of limitation
raised by the defendants.
(4) So far as amount of compensation is concerned, it was submitted
that, the trial Court did not have awarded compensation
proportionate to the loss suffered by the plaintiffs, who are widow,
minor son and parents and therefore, trial court ought to have
considered future prospect while fixing the amount of dependency
loss and has not properly awarded the amount under the head of
consortium etc.
14.
In such circumstances as referred above, learned counsel Mr. Shah
submitted that the trial Court while determining the liability of the
respondent State has properly appreciated the evidence and assigned
proper and sufficient reasons for conclusion for the issues involved and
therefore, as such there is no perversity in the impugned judgment and
decree and same does not require any interference. However, on the
aspect of quantum, it was submitted that, same may be modified and
enhanced as per the Constitutional Bench judgment, (National Insurance
Company Limited vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors. [2017 (16) SCC 680].
15.
We have heard at length the learned counsels for the respective
parties. Perused the case records as well as the judgment impugned.
16.
Having regard to the pleadings, evidence and submissions of the
parties, the following points arise for determination of present appeal:
(1) Whether the learned trial Court was justified in holding the
C/FA/3207/2013(GJHC240399612013)
JUDGMENT DATED: 16/09/2026
appellate authority liable for the death of the deceased?
(2) Whether the doctrine of Res ipsa loquitur is applicable to the
case of the present case?
(3) Whether any contributory negligence on the part of the
deceased has been established?
(4) Whether the quantum of compensation awarded by the learned
trial Court calls for interference?
(5) What order.
17.
Discussions & findings : Point Nos. (1) (2) and (3):
All these points are interconnected and are therefore being
considered together.
18.
Before the trial Court, the widow Jyotikaben was being examined
at Exh. 28. She has produced the copy of the FIR and other criminal case
papers at Exh. 59 to 61 and also produced medical certificate as well as
death certificate of the deceased at Exh. 52 and 53. She has also produced
the receipt of fees at Exh. 50 to prove the fact that the deceased and his
brother were interested in purchasing the scrape materials in the auction
held at the place of incident. The witness has no personal knowledge
about the occurrence of the incident. The witness Exh. 116 – Dr. Mitesh
Shah and the copy of the deposition of Dr. Bharat Patel produced at Exh.
128 and OPD case papers of Viramgam Civil Hospital produced at Exh.
139 and 140 would go to show that on 30.05.2006, after 2-30 the
deceased was treated by Viramgam Civil Hospital for the spinal injury
and later on, deceased Mohanlal was shifted to Private Hospital at
C/FA/3207/2013(GJHC240399612013)
JUDGMENT DATED: 16/09/2026
Ahmedabad. Thus, the injury certificates as well as the death certificate
issued by Samved Hospital proves and established that, the deceased has
sustained serious injuries over his spine. The defendants have relied upon
internal communication made by the Section Officer of Charad Section,
addressed Deputy Engineer, Viramgar, wherein, it was disclosed that on
account of collapse of gentry, some of the persons, who has come to
inspect scrape materials had sustained injuries. It is no doubt true that, the
family of the deceased without informing the police about the death, have
cremated the deceased for which the action was taken by the police. In
such circumstances, having regard to the evidence on record, it is proved
and established that on 30.05.2006, the deceased Mohanlal and his
brother Hasmukhlal Exh. 99 had gone to the office of the defendant at
Lakhtar for inspection of scrape materials because the brother –
Hasmukhlal had applied to participate in the auction proceedings by
paying necessary fees (Exh. 50) and during the inspection, the deceased
had sustained injuries because the gentry suddenly fell from its position
and came upon the deceased, as a result, he succumbed to the injuries. In
such circumstances, in absence of autopsy report, there is sufficient
evidence to prove and establish that there is a reasonable connection with
the alleged death and injuries sustained by the deceased. It is no doubt
true that, on the same day, no complaint was filed by the family of the
deceased. However, the fact remains that, the information about the
incident was within the knowledge of Lakhtar Police Station as it was
noted by the police in form of accidental death about the alleged incident
and thereafter, a written complaint dated 07.12.2006 was submitted with
the higher police authority and accordingly, the offence under Section
304 came to be registered on 18.01.2007. Thus, having regard to the
C/FA/3207/2013(GJHC240399612013)
JUDGMENT DATED: 16/09/2026
factum of chargesheet and other attending circumstances, would clearly
establish that the incident in question being occurred at the place where
the auction proceedings of the scrap material being held and organized by
the defendants herein. It is not mandatory and precondition when the suit
is filed on the cause of action of civil wrong, that the FIR must be registered
and at the most, the evidence of criminal proceedings would be a
corroborative piece of evidence and cannot be admitted as substantial
evidence. Thus, we have no doubt in our mind about the incident as
alleged and resultant death of the deceased on account of falling of parts
of manual gantry at the place.
19.
Now the question is whether the appellant authority could be held
liable for the death of deceased. The plaintiffs being legal heirs and
dependents of the deceased Mohanlal, instituted the suit claiming
compensation on the ground that the accident occurred due to negligence
and failure of the defendant authority to maintain the premises and the
manual gantry in a reasonably safe condition and to take necessary
precautions despite the obvious age and dangerous condition of the crane.
In such tortious liability, usually falls under specific legal doctrines under
the Law of Torts and foundation of such cases would be principle of
negligence, strict liability and vicarious liability. In the present case, the
manual overhead gantry crane, composing a horizontal beam supported
on two vertical frames with centrally suspended hoisting mechanism and
same was parked and/or lying at the place where the public auction
proceedings were undertaken. The presence of the deceased and his
brother at the place is proved and established. The defendants-appellants
heavily argued that the deceased was unauthorized visitor and he would
termed as trespasser and therefore, they cannot be held negligent and
C/FA/3207/2013(GJHC240399612013)
JUDGMENT DATED: 16/09/2026
liable for the damages. We do not find any substance in the submissions
as advanced. The State and its Departments by public notice, invited
tender for selling the scrap materials lying at the place of incident. The
brother of the deceased Hasmukh Chunilal (Exh.99) by paying a
necessary fee of Rs.250/-, filled a form for taking participation in the bid
process and it was submitted in the name of firm “Tej Vasan & Metal
Stores” (Exh.50). As per the conditions of the bid, one person along with
the bidder was permitted to take part in the auction proceedings including
the inspection etc. Admittedly, on the next day of the incident, the fee of
Rs.250/- was refunded to Hasmukh Chunilal. In such circumstances, it
cannot be said that the deceased and his brother unlawfully entered into
the premises where the incident occurred and they were the invitee and in
such circumstances, the act of the deceased entering into premises cannot
in any manner said to be a trespass. In the facts of the present case, on the
ground of actionable negligence, the suit for recovery of damages is filed.
It is settled position of law that, the liability in tort arises when a person’s
act or omission, without lawful justification, causes harm to another in
violation of legal recognized duty of care or obligation. Thus, the essence
of tortious liability lies in the breach of duty imposed by law, independent
of any contractual or statutory relationship between the parties. Thus, the
foundation of tort of law is the protection of legal rights and the
maintenance of a standard of reasonable conduct so that every individual
and/or statutory authority must ensure that they do not cause unjust harm
to others. There are three categories tortious wrongs namely (i)
intentional torts; (ii) negligence and (iii) strict or absolute liability. In the
case of intentional torts, harm is caused deliberately, whereas, in the case
of negligence, there is a failure to exercise reasonable care, resulting in
C/FA/3207/2013(GJHC240399612013)
JUDGMENT DATED: 16/09/2026
untended harm to another person and in the third category i.e. strict or
absolute liability, imposes responsibility without proof of fault, in a
situation where inherently dangerous activities or substances are involved
and public safety demands a higher standard of accountability.
20.
The present case falls under the category “negligence” and in that
case, the fundamental principle of law is that every public authority or
body discharging public functions owes a duty of care towards every
citizen who may reasonably be affected by its acts or omissions. The duty
requires the authority to take reasonable and forceable precautions to
prevent injuries or harm.
21.
Applying the aforesaid settled principle of law to the facts of the
present case, the manual overhead gantry crane admittedly was found at
the place of incident and having regard to the photographs of it produced
before the trial court, it shows that, the crane composing a horizontal
beam supported on two vertical frames with centrally suspended hoisting
mechanism and as per the case of the plaintiffs, the supporting beam as
well as vertical frames suddenly crashed and fell upon the deceased and
others. The defense was set up to the effect that, the uncontrolled crowd,
wherein the deceased was one of the member, despite of warning, sat on
the gantry, as a result, the incident occurred. The defense as set up, is
prudently not believable because the framework of the gantry was such
that it is humanly impossible to climb on the vertical and horizontal
frames of the gantry. The oral evidence to this effect of the officers led
before the trial court would prove contrary to the defense set up as none
of the witnesses had seen the incident. The second defense was taken to
the effect that the manual gantry was parked in other division and there
C/FA/3207/2013(GJHC240399612013)
JUDGMENT DATED: 16/09/2026
was no reason for the deceased to take inspection of that division. In our
opinion, this defense cannot be accepted as once the person entered into
the premises control and supervision of the defendant, then, it is their
duty to take care and precautions to prevent injury and harm. It is not the
case of the defendants that, the fall was caused by unpredictable factors.
In such circumstances, when the gantry which was parked in the premises
where the visitors had access, than the defendant held liable for nonmaintaining the structure of the gantry in proper manner. The plaintiffs
have established and proved the factum of incident and resultant death of
the deceased. In such circumstances, the collapse of gantry on the
deceased would establish the prima-facie negligence on the part of the
defendant and in that view of the matter, the principle of Res ipsa
loquitur which is a Latin phrase meaning “the things speaks for itself”
would be applicable. In the legal terms, it allows the presumption of
negligence when the nature of an accident is such that it implies
negligence by the defendant and the doctrine is particularly useful when
the direct evidence of negligence is available. The explanation of the
defendants about the sole negligence of the deceased is not convincing
and acceptable and in absence of any rebuttal evidence, the collapse of
gantry on the deceased clearly establish and prove the negligence on the
part of the appellants-defendants. We may profitably refer the case of
Municipal Corporation of Delhi vs. Subhagwanti and Ors. (1966 AIR
1750). The case before the Supreme Court revolves around the tragic
collapse of clock tower owned by the Municipal Corporation of Delhi,
resulting in the untimely deaths of three individuals. The heirs of the
deceased filed a suit seeking damages ascertaining negligence on the part
of the corporation in maintaining the structural integrity of the clock
C/FA/3207/2013(GJHC240399612013)
JUDGMENT DATED: 16/09/2026
tower. The Supreme Court while applying the principle Res ipsa loquitur,
held that, the collapse of tower presented at prima-facie case of
negligence, as the corporation had exclusive control and ownership of the
clock tower and the structure was very old, exceeding its expected life
span and on account of lack of systematic inspection and maintenance,
would constitute the negligence. It is relevant to note that, the Supreme
Court in the said judgment had discussed the latent and patent defects. It
was said that, latent defects are hidden flaws or weaknesses in a structure
that are not discoverable by reasonable inspection. Unlike patent defects,
which are obvious and visible, latent defects require thorough
investigation to identify. The Supreme Court clarified that, the negligent
liability can arise even from latent defects if proper maintenance is not
conducted.
22.
Reverting back to the facts of the present case, the manual gantry
crane was old one and parked in the premises of the defendants. The
defendants failed to produce any cogent evidence to show that the gantry
was in a usable condition and regularly inspection was done and there
was no defect in its structure. In the present case, there is also no specific
satisfactory evidence showing that the deceased had been warned or that
access to the place where the gantry was parked had been effectively
restricted. The witnesses examined by the defendants have categorically
stated that the affidavit in chief examination was being prepared in the
office and they have not personally seen the incident. Thus, the theory of
giving warning to the deceased and others for not to sit on the manual
gantry, cannot be believed and accepted on the version of the witnesses
who belong to the office of the defendants. It is on record that, one
Mukeshbhai was also having sustained injuries in the said incident, but
C/FA/3207/2013(GJHC240399612013)
JUDGMENT DATED: 16/09/2026
somehow, he was not examined by the defendants to prove their defense.
It is relevant to note that, after the incident, no any complaint being filed
against the uncontrolled crowd, according to their case, they sat on the
gantry despite of warning given by the concerned officer. Thus, the
defense set up seems to be afterthought and in absence of any
independent, cogent and acceptable evidence, it cannot be believed that
the deceased was warned not to sit on the manual gantry and was
cautioned about the dangerous situation of it. So far as issue of
contributory negligence is concerned, in our opinion, the defendant failed
to prove that the deceased despite of warning given to him, carelessly sat
on the horizontal and vertical supporting beam of the gantry. Thus,
nothing on record to prove that it was the deceased who was responsible
in causing the incident.
23.
Thus, therefore, having regard to the facts of the present case, we
have no hesitation to held that the incident occurred due to negligence
and failure of the defendant authority to maintain the gantry in a
reasonably safe condition, for which the defendants no.1 to 3 were liable
for the death of the deceased and also for the damages claimed by the
plaintiffs.
24.
Accordingly, we answer the point no.1, 2 and 3, holding that the
trial court was justified in holding the appellants liable for death of the
deceased and having regard to the facts of the case and evidence on
record, the doctrine of “Res ipsa loquitur” would certainly applicable and
trial court has properly decided the issue of negligence as well as the
issue of contributory negligence.
C/FA/3207/2013(GJHC240399612013)
25.
JUDGMENT DATED: 16/09/2026
It was the contention of the appellants that, suit is not filed within
limitation. We are not agreed with the contention. The trial court has
rightly determined the issue of limitation as Article 82 of the Limitation
Act provides the time period of two years from the date of death of the
person wronged. In the present case, suit is filed on 08.02.2008. The
accident occurred on 30.05.2006. Thus, within limitation of two years,
suit was filed by the defendants.
26.
On the aspect of quantum, the appellants have raised the contention
that, the income of the deceased having been considered on higher side
and the amount of compensation is excessive. On this issue, before the
trial court, the plaintiffs have proved and produced the ITRs (Exh.83 to
86) to prove the annual income of the deceased. The deceased was
working with “Taj Vasan & Metal Store” and “Uttam Metal Industries”.
Both the business run by family. The trial court discarded the income
mentioned in the ITR which was filed after the death. Thus, in our
opinion, so far income is concerned, the trial court has rightly determined
the income of Rs.1,18,000/- annually. By Cross-objection, the plaintiffs
have raised the contention that, considering the age of the deceased, if
accident would not have occurred, there were all chances of increasing
his income and therefore, the future prospects require to be considered
while determining the amount of dependency loss which factors having
not been properly appreciated by the trial court. In support of this
submission, heavy reliance being placed on the judgment of
Constitutional Bench of the Supreme Court in case of Pranay Sethi
(supra). Against which, the State was having strong objection to consider
the amount of future prospects and it was contended that, the claim is
filed under the Fatal Accident Act and therefore, the amount as claimed,
C/FA/3207/2013(GJHC240399612013)
JUDGMENT DATED: 16/09/2026
cannot be awarded by adopting the methodology for awarding
compensation as settled by the Supreme Court for the cases filed under
the provisions of The Motor Vehicles Act, 1988.
27.
In the present case, the compensation sought by filing a suit under
The Fatal Accident Act and as per the statutory provision, the Court may
give such damages as it may think proportioned to the loss resulting from
such death to the parties respectively. However, the suit claiming
compensation under the provisions of Fatal Accident Act, in order to
determine the damages, proportionate to the loss, after the decision of the
Supreme Court in case of General Manager, Kerala S.R.T.C. vs.
Susamma Thomas & Ors. (AIR 1994 SC 1631), the multiplier method
became well established in the Indian Law. In Sarla Verma (supra), the
Supreme Court has attempted to standardize the determination of the
multiplication and multiplier to bring about uniformity in determination
of compensation payable in case of death and thereafter, Five Judge
Constitutional Bench in the case of Pranay Sethi (supra), issued further
directions following the decision of Sarla Verma (supra). In such
circumstances, in our opinion, the trial court while following the case of
Sarla Verma (supra), failed to appreciate the fact that, the deceased was
having a steady income from the family business and having regard to the
directions issued in the case of Pranay Sethi (supra), the Court and/or
Tribunal is duty bound to consider the addition of income for future
prospects. In the case of Pranay Sethi (supra), it was directed that while
determination of the income in the case of deceased, who was selfemployed or on a fixed salary, an addition of 40% of the established
income should be added where the deceased was below the age of 40
years. In the present case, the income of the deceased was Rs.1,18,000/Page 24 of 26
C/FA/3207/2013(GJHC240399612013)
JUDGMENT DATED: 16/09/2026
as held by the trial court. However, the future prospects of 40% was not
considered by the trial court.
28.
Thus, in order to determine compensation proportionate to the loss,
we are recalculating the total amount of compensation under the different
heads as under:
1. Established income
2. Addition of 40% towards future prospects
3. Less personal expenses-1/3rd
4. Applying multiplier of 16
(Rs.1,10,200 x 16)
5. Amount under the conventional heads
(Lost to estate – Rs.15,000/-,
loss of consortium – Rs.40,000/- &
funeral expenses – Rs.15,000/-)
29.
Rs.1,18,000/- per annum
Rs.47,200/Rs.1,65,200/Rs.55,000/Rs.1,10,200/Rs.17,63,200/Rs.70,000/Rs.18,33,200/- (Total)
In such circumstances, having regard to the facts and evidence on
record, the plaintiffs – respondents are entitled to recover the total amount
of compensation of Rs.18,33,200/-, instead of Rs.12,79,372/-. The claim
of the parents dismissed by the trial court observing that, the father was
having an independent income from the business. However, without
entering into merits of the contention on the aspect of dismissal of the
claim, we do not enter into right of the parents as considering the
enhanced amount of compensation as awarded, we do not deem it fit to
reconsider the claim of the parents.
30.
For the reasons aforementioned, the appeal filed by the appellant-
State stands dismissed. The Cross-objections is partly allowed in the
aforesaid terms as referred in para-29. The plaintiffs are entitled for the
interest @ 6% on the enhanced amount (Rs.5,53,828/-) from the date of
disposal of the suit i.e. 31.01.2013 till realization. The decree to this
C/FA/3207/2013(GJHC240399612013)
JUDGMENT DATED: 16/09/2026
effect is modified and to be drawn accordingly. The appellants are
directed to deposit the entire amount of compensation with interest and
proportionate cost within a period of three months. The plaintiffs are
permitted to withdraw the deposited amount with accrued interest, if any
and also permitted to withdraw the remaining amount including the
enhanced amount with interest. The R & P be transmitted back to the
trial court concerned.
Sd/(ILESH J. VORA,J)
Sd/-
(R. T. VACHHANI, J)
TAUSIF SAIYED
Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judges.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review