The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
19. In the circumstances, the writ petition is allowed. The order dated 26.09.2025 passed by the learned Appellate Authority and the consequential eviction order dated 03.03.2025 passed by the District Magistrate (West) are set aside.
20. It clarified that this Court is not commenting upon or determining the title to the property in these proceedings, nor is this Court adjudicating upon the validity of the relinquishment deed. Those disputed questions, are to be determined in appropriate civil proceedings. All such questions, pertaining the title to the property, the validity or legal effect of the relinquishment deed, or the rights of the parties in the pending matrimonial, civil or proceedings under the DV Act are left open to be determined by the competent forum in accordance with law.
21. The petition stands disposed of in the above terms. Pending applications, if any, also stand disposed of.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Date of Decision: September 28th, 2026
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010826622025
W.P.(C) 16295/2025 & CM APPL. 66628/2025
JYOTI
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Satosh Paul, Sr. Adv. With
Mr. Vedant Mishra, Ms. Aditi
Rai, Mr. Mohd. Owais & Mr.
Shivendu Sharma, Advs.
Mr. Amitesh Gaurav & Mr.
Vikas Kumar, Advs.
versus
THE STATE NCT OF DELHI
AND ORS
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Sharad Bansal & Ms.
Ashmeet Kaur, Adv. for R2
Mr. Balvinder Ralhan &
Mr. Aditya Ralhan, Advs. for
R3
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT MAHAJAN
AMIT MAHAJAN, J. (Oral)
1.
The present petition under Articles 226/227 of the Constitution
of India assails the order dated 26.09.2025 passed by the learned
Appellate Authority, Divisional Commissioner, whereby the appeal
preferred by the Petitioner/Smt. Jyoti against the Order of eviction
dated 03.03.2025 passed by the District Magistrate (West), came to be
dismissed.
2.
Succinctly stated, the petitioner/Smt. Jyoti got married to
Respondent No. 3/Sh. Amit Kumar on 05.12.2021 and is the daughterin-law of Respondent No.2/Smt. Sneh Lata Bhatia. She has been
Signed By:SHIKHA
SEHGAL
W.P.(C) 16295/2025
20:18:09
residing in the property bearing No. D-7, Block-D, Hari Nagar, New
Delhi, (“subject property/matrimonial house”) along with her minor
son/Master Aryaman (born out of the wedlock). It is alleged that her
father-in-law, died intestate, on 05.12.2018. Allegedly, on 10.04.2019,
the Respondent No. 3 and his brother, executed a registered
Relinquishment Deed, relinquishing their respective shares with
respect to the subject property, in favour of their mother i.e.
Respondent No 2. Thereafter, the Respondent No. 2 filed an Eviction
Petition against the Respondent No. 3 and Petitioner, and the Order of
eviction was passed by the District Magistrate (West) on 03.03.2025.
3.
The appeal filed by the Petitioner against the same, came to be
dismissed vide the Impugned Order dated 26.09.2025 on the ground
that firstly, both sons have already relinquished their rights in the
property in favour of Respondent No. 2 and the Petitioner cannot
claim any legal rights to reside in her in-laws residence; the right of
residence, if any, under the Protection of Women from Domestic
Violence Act, 2005 (“DV Act”) lies against her husband who is bound
to provide alternative arrangement/residence; secondly, the eviction
did not render her destitute as the husband is paying her maintenance
under orders passed by competent courts; and lastly, the advanced age,
illness i.e. Stage IV Cancer and acrimonious atmosphere discernible
from the pending litigations between the parties makes eviction a
proportionate measure to secure the Respondent No. 2’s Safety,
dignity and right to peaceful living.
4.
Aggrieved, the Petitioner has approached this Court.
5.
The principal grievance of the Petitioner is that, while directing
Signed By:SHIKHA
SEHGAL
W.P.(C) 16295/2025
20:18:09
her eviction, the authorities have proceeded essentially on the basis of
the “exclusive ownership” claimed by Respondent No. 2 and the
relinquishment said to have been executed by her sons, without
adequately considering the Petitioner's asserted right of residence and
the fact that the minor child is also residing in the premises. It has
been urged that their right of residence could not have been defeated
merely on the basis of a purported relinquishment deed executed by
the husband and his brother, particularly when the validity and effect
of the said document are disputed and the Petitioner has asserted that
the property is an ancestral property/formed part of the estate of her
deceased father-in-law.
6.
Per Contra, the learned Counsel for the Respondents have
essentially argued that the Petitioner cannot claim an absolute right to
remain in the self-acquired/exclusive property of a senior citizen,
particularly when her residence rights can be secured through suitable
alternative accommodation, and that the writ petition deserves
dismissal.
7.
Having considered the rival submissions and the material
placed on record, this Court is of the view that the impugned order
cannot be sustained.
8.
It is well-settled that the rights available to a senior citizen
under the Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens
Act, 2007, and the right of residence claimed under the Domestic
Violence Act, 2005, have to be harmoniously considered. The exercise
cannot proceed on the assumption that one statutory right
automatically eclipses the other. Right of a woman to secure a
Signed By:SHIKHA
SEHGAL
W.P.(C) 16295/2025
20:18:09
residence order in respect of a shared household cannot be defeated
by securing an order of eviction by adopting the summary procedure
under the Senior Citizens Act, 2007. Reference in this regard may be
made to the judgment passed by the Hon’ble Apex Court in S.
Vanitha v. Deputy Commissioner, Bengaluru Urban District, (2021)
15 SCC 730, whereby it has been held as under: “37. The above extract indicates that a significant object of the
legislation is to provide for and recognise the rights of women to
secure housing and to recognise the right of a woman to reside in a
matrimonial home or a shared household, whether or not she has
any title or right in the shared household. Allowing the Senior
Citizens Act, 2007 to have an overriding force and effect in all
situations, irrespective of competing entitlements of a woman to a
right in a shared household within the meaning of the PWDV Act,
2005, would defeat the object and purpose which Parliament
sought to achieve in enacting the latter legislation. The law
protecting the interest of senior citizens is intended to ensure that
they are not left destitute, or at the mercy of their children or
relatives. Equally, the purpose of the PWDV Act, 2005 cannot be
ignored by a sleight of statutory interpretation. Both sets of
legislations have to be harmoniously construed. Hence the right of a
woman to secure a residence order in respect of a shared
household cannot be defeated by the simple expedient of securing
an order of eviction by adopting the summary procedure under the
Senior Citizens Act, 2007.
39. …………………Even otherwise, we are clearly of the view that
recourse to the summary procedure contemplated by the Senior
Citizens Act, 2007 was not available for the purpose of facilitating
strategies that are designed to defeat the claim of the appellant in
respect of a shared household. A shared household would have to be
interpreted to include the residence where the appellant had been
jointly residing with her husband. Merely because the ownership of
the property has been subsequently transferred to her in-laws
(second and third respondents) or that her estranged spouse
(fourth respondent) is now residing separately, is no ground to
deprive the appellant of the protection that was envisaged under
the PWDV Act, 2005.”
(Emphasis supplied)
9.
Recently, relying upon the above judgment, the hon’ble
Division Bench of the Punjab and Haryana High Court, in judgment
Signed By:SHIKHA
SEHGAL
W.P.(C) 16295/2025
20:18:09
dated 07.09.2026 bearing L.P.A. No. 2464/2026 titled Anuradha
Bansal v. District Magistrate and Ors., while dismissing the Letter
Patent’s Appeal filed by a mother-in-law seeking eviction of her
daughter-in-law under the Senior Citizen’s Act, opined that the object
of the Act is to uphold the obligation of children and relatives to
provide for senior citizens and the provisions of this statute should not
be misused for adjudication of matrimonial disputes/property disputes
or to evict an estranged daughter-in-law who otherwise possesses a
right to reside therein.
10.
In the present case, the petitioner has specifically asserted that
the premises constituted her shared household and that she has been
residing therein since her marriage. The record reveals that vide order
dated 20.07.2021, the learned Mahila Court had restrained the in-laws
of the Petitioner from dispossessing her or creating any third-party
interests in the 1st floor of the subject property and it was recorded
therein that “it is an admitted position that the said property is the
shared household of the petitioner”.
11.
Subsequent thereto, the Order of eviction was passed by the
learned District Magistrate on 03.03.2025.
12.
Then, the Order dated 13.03.2025 was passed by the learned
Mahila Court, whereby the effect of Order dated 20.07.2021 (granting
protection from dispossession from 1st floor of the subject property)
was vacated after noting that it has been observed in the Order of
eviction dated 03.03.2025 that Respondent No. 2 is the absolute owner
of the subject property and the CCTV/video dated 24.12.2024
demonstrates that Petitioner is creating a ruckus outside the subject
Signed By:SHIKHA
SEHGAL
W.P.(C) 16295/2025
20:18:09
property and thus, Mother-in-law and Brother-in-law of the Petitioner
cannot be estopped from disposing the property.
13.
Subsequent thereto, the Impugned Order dated 26.09.2025 was
passed and vide Order dated 28.10.2025 this Court had stayed the
effect of the Impugned Order and directed parties to maintain status
quo.
14.
On 13.07.2026, the application for modification of the Order
dated 13.05.2025 was taken up and it was recorded therein that since
firstly, the Petitioner is still residing at the subject property; Secondly,
she is seeking right of residence in the property and not an alternate
accommodation from her husband as of then; Thirdly, is a matter of
record that Respondent No.2 is the exclusive owner of the subject
property, however, the challenge to the ownership is still pending
consideration before the Civil Courts; and Fourthly, the High Court is
seized of the matter; thus, no order of modification and securing the
right of residence can be passed as the same would render the
proceedings before the High Court infructuous.
15.
It is discernible from the conspectus of facts brought forth that
till date no order has been passed securing the right of residence of the
Petitioner. The learned Appellate Authority has principally proceeded
on the basis of the alleged ownership of Respondent No.2,
overlooking the specific assertions of the Petitioner that the document
was executed as a strategy only to curtail the rights of the Petitioner
owing to the ongoing matrimonial disputes between the parties and the
ownership of the property is in dispute/pending consideration as the
same is an ancestral property in which the minor son also has a right.
Signed By:SHIKHA
SEHGAL
W.P.(C) 16295/2025
20:18:09
16.
Admittedly the parties are embroiled in matrimonial litigations,
which as per the record placed before this Court, includes inter alia
Civil Suit for Injunction/Declaration/Partition by minor son, Divorce
Petition, Guardianship proceedings, DV proceedings, FIR No.
88/2021 under Section 498A/406/34 of the IPC etc.
17.
In such context, though the existence of a Relinquishment Deed
between the members of the family may undoubtedly have
consequences in the appropriate civil proceedings, however, in the
opinion of this Court, such a document, when its effect and validity
are themselves disputed by the Petitioner and there is also a civil
dispute pending, could not, have been treated as by itself conclusively
determining or extinguishing the Petitioner's asserted statutory right of
residence, that too when the residence of the minor child is also
involved.
18.
This Court is conscious that Respondent No. 2 is a senior
citizen and that her right to live peacefully and with dignity in her
property is required to be protected. At the same time, as discussed
above, the protection available under the Senior Citizens Act cannot
be used to deprive a daughter-in-law right of residence in a premises
which she claims to have occupied as her matrimonial/shared
household.
19.
In the circumstances, the writ petition is allowed. The order
dated 26.09.2025 passed by the learned Appellate Authority and the
consequential eviction order dated 03.03.2025 passed by the District
Magistrate (West) are set aside.
20.
It clarified that this Court is not commenting upon or
Signed By:SHIKHA
SEHGAL
W.P.(C) 16295/2025
20:18:09
determining the title to the property in these proceedings, nor is this
Court adjudicating upon the validity of the relinquishment deed.
Those disputed questions, are to be determined in appropriate civil
proceedings. All such questions, pertaining the title to the property,
the validity or legal effect of the relinquishment deed, or the rights of
the parties in the pending matrimonial, civil or proceedings under the
DV Act are left open to be determined by the competent forum in
accordance with law.
21.
The petition stands disposed of in the above terms. Pending
applications, if any, also stand disposed of.
AMIT MAHAJAN, J
SEPTEMBER 28, 2026/ “SS”
Signed By:SHIKHA
SEHGAL
W.P.(C) 16295/2025
20:18:09
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review