Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
1 ( 2026:HHC:5578 )
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CMPMO No.538 of 2025
Date of Decision : 26.02.2026
Jyoti
...Petitioner
Versus
Rakesh Dhiman
...Respondent
Coram:
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Romesh Verma. Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?1
For the petitioner
:
Mr. Praveen Chauhan, Advocate.
For the respondent
:
Mr. Rajesh Kashyap, Advoate.
Romesh Verma, Judge(oral
The present petition has been filed by the
petitioner wife for the transfer of the case petition No. 117 of
2025 filed by the respondent for the restitution of conjugal
rights under Section 9 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, which is
pending before the learned Principal Judgde Family Court,
Kinnaur Division
learned
at Rampur Bushahr, H.P.
Additional
Principal
Judge
to the Court of
(Family
Court),
Nalagarh,Solan H.P.
2.
It has been contended and averred in the petition
that the petitioner filed a formal complaint before the Women
Police Station, Baddi against the respondent, however, in
Whether reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
2 ( 2026:HHC:5578 )
counterblast to the said petition, respondent has
filed the
petition bearing No. 117 of 2025 for Restitution of Conjugal
Rights under Section 9 of the Hindu Marriage Act. The copy of
the petition has been appended with the present case. It has
been averred that the respondent in order to harass the
petitioner
has filed the said petition The petitioner has
contended in the petition that it is very difÏcult to the petitioner
to contest the said proceedings. Since the distance between
Rampur Bushahr to Nalagarh is more than 230 k.m. It has been
averred that presently she is residing at Nalagarh, therefore,
keeping in view the family circumstances and the distance, it
will be in the fitness of the things that the petition filed by the
respondent under Section 9 of the Hindu Marriage Act
is
transferred to the Court of learned Family Court,Nalagarh.
3.
On the other hand, the prayer of the present
petitioner has been vehemently opposed by Mr. Rajesh Kashyap,
learned counsel for the respondent by contending that the
present proceeding have been filed by the petitioner by
concealing the facts. He submits that his wife the present
petitioner is a respectable lady and she has got all the mean and
facilities in life and she can certainly travel from Nalagarh to
Rampur Bushahr to attend proceedings filed by him under
3 ( 2026:HHC:5578 )
Section 9 of Hindu Marriage Act. He further submits that he is
ready to arrange residence and bear the travel expenses of the
petitioner from Nalagarh to Rampur Bushahr.
4.
The present petitioner has approached this Court
for the transfer of the petition under Section 9 of the Hindu
Marriage Act filed by the respondent from the Court of learned
Principal Judge Family Court Kinnaur Division at Rampur
Bushahr to the learned Family Court at Nalagarh.
5.
Since, the present petition is primarily filed for the
transfer of the petition, therefore, without touching the merits
of the case, this Court shall proceed further to examine whether
the prayer of the petitioner can be accepted.
6.
While dealing with the issue of transfer of
proceedings from one Court to another in matrimonial matters,
the convenience of the wife is ordinarily to be preferred, in view
of the mandate of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Sumita Singh
v. Kumar Sanjay and another (2001) 10 Supreme Court Cases
41, wherein it was held by the Hon’ble Apex Court that in case
where wife seeks transfer of the petition then as against the
husband, convenience of wife must be looked at.
7.
In Rajani Kishor Pardeshi vs. Kishor Babulal
Pardeshi (2005) 12 Supreme Court Cases 237, it has been held
4 ( 2026:HHC:5578 )
that in a case seeking transfer of the case at the instance of the
wife, it was specifically held by the Hon’ble Supreme Court that
the convenience of the wife was the prime consideration.
8.
While dealing with the application for transfer of
the proceedings in Kulwindere Kaur alias Kulwinder vs. Kandi
Friends Education Trust and others (2008) 3
SCC 659, the
Hon’ble Supreme Court after analyzing the provisions of
Section 24 and 25 of C.P.C laid down certain parameters for
transfer of the case and it was held as under:
“23 Reading Sections 24and 25of the Code together
and keeping in view various judicial pronouncements,
certain broad propositions as to what may constitute a
ground for transfer have been laid down by Courts.
They are balance of convenience or inconvenience to
plaintiff or defendant or witnesses; convenience or
inconvenience of a particular place of trial having
regard to the nature of evidence on the points involved
in the suit; issues raised by the parties; reasonable
apprehension in the mind of the litigant that he might
not get justice in the court in which the suit is
pending; important questions of law involved or a
considerable section of public interested in the
litigation; interest of justice demanding for transfer of
suit, appeal or other proceeding, etc. Above are some
of the instances which are germane in considering the
question of transfer of a suit, appeal or other
proceeding. They are, however, illustrative in nature
and by no means be treated as exhaustive. If on the
above or other relevant considerations, the Court feels
that the plaintiff or the defendant is not likely to have
a fair trial in the Court from which he seeks to transfer
a case, it is not only the power, but the duty of the
Court to make such order.”
5 ( 2026:HHC:5578 )
9.
In Aarti Rani @ Pinki Devi and another vs.
Dharmendra Kumar Gupta (2008)
9 SCC
353, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court while dealing with a case where the wife has
sought transfer of the proceedings on the ground that it is
difÏcult for her to attend the Court on Palamu, Daltonganj
which is within the State of Jharkhand and is at a quite distance
from Patna where she was residing with her child. Taking into
consideration the convenience of the wife proceedings were
ordered to be transferred.
10.
Similarly in Anjali Ashok
Kishan Chand Sadhwani AIR
2009 SC
Sadhwani vs. Ashok
1374, whereby she
sought the transfer of the case to Bombay from Indore in M.P.
on the ground of inconvenience as there was none in the family
to escort her to Indore and on this ground the proceedings
were ordered to be transferred.
11.
In Civil Appeal No (s)4894 of 2022 arising out SLP
(C) No(s). 16465 of 2021, titled as NCV Aishwarya vs. AS
Saravana Karthik Sha, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has out line
the cardinal principle for considering prayer for transfer of the
proceedings from one Court to another in matrimonial matters
in following terms:
“8. It is not disputed that the appellant is the
resident of Chennai and that the appellant’s
6 ( 2026:HHC:5578 )
husband-respondent herein is the resident of
Vellore and he is employed. The appellant who is
21 years old does not have any source of income
of her own as she is not employed and is totally
dependent on her parents for her livelihood. In
order to attend the court proceedings of the case
filed by her husband at Vellore she has to travel
alone all the way from Chennai to Vellore as her
parents are not in a position to accompany her
on account of their old age. Secondly, the
appellant has also filed a petition, H.M.O.P.
No.1741 of 2021, for restitution of conjugal
rights and another petition, M.C. Sr. No.672 of
2021, for her maintenance before the Family
Court at Chennai”
12.
Taking into consideration, the entirety of the
facts and circumstances of the case and the cardinal principle
out lined by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Sumita Singh and
Rajani Kishor Pardeshi NCV Aishwarya cases, this Court is of
the considered
view that present
petition deserves to be
allowed for the reasons that the present petitioner is a
permanent resident of Nalagarh and the respondent has filed
proceedings for restitution of conjugal
right at Rampur
Bushahr, which is at a considerable distance of more than 230
k.m.
13.
The petitioner has averred that it is difÏcult for her
to travel at such a distant place and she is having financial
constraints. It is the case of the petitioner that the husband has
initiated the proceedings at Rampur Bushahr to harass her.
7 ( 2026:HHC:5578 )
Similar
issue
praying
for
the
transfer
of
proceedings from one Court to another Court, has been dealt
with by this Court in CMPMO No. 466 of 2020, titled Monu vs
Rakesh Kumar dated 26.07.2020 and other matters i.e CMPMO
No. 604 of 2023, titled Manisha Thakur vs. Aakash Chauhan,
decided on 05.12.2023 and in CMPMO No. 688 of 2023, titled as
Sumita Chandel
Parvesh
dated 10.01.2024 in the following
manner.
“ 6. In view of the mandate of law referred to above,
and the no objection accorded by the learned counsel for
the respondent herein; the present petition is allowed
and H.M. Misc. Petition No. 351 of 2023, titled as
Parvesh 5 Singh Vs Sumiti Chandel, pending before the
Additional Principal Judge Family Court Hamirpur,
Himachal Pradesh is ordered to be transferred to the
Principal Judge, Family Court, Solan, Himachal
Pradesh.”
15.
In the matter having similar facts and situation, this
Court has
allowed the transfer of the proceedings on the
request of the wife in CMPMO No. 706/2023, titled as Chandni
Versus Rajeev Pathik, decided on 04.11.2024.
16.
In view of the above discussion and the exposition of law
as laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court, the present petition is
allowed and the proceedings pending in petition No. 117 of 2025
filed by the respondent under Section 9 of Hindu Marriage Act
1955 in the Court of Learned Principal Judge, Family Court at
8 ( 2026:HHC:5578 )
Kinnaur, Division at Rampur Bushahr are ordered to be
transferred to the Court of learned Additional Principal Judge
Family Court Nalagarh, Solan, H.P. The parties shall appear
before the family Court Nalagarh on 30.03.2026.
17.
It is made clear that the learned Family Court shall
not issue any notice to the parties and they shall remain present
on the date fixed before the Family Court, Nalagarh. The learned
Family Court shall proceed in the matter from the stage learned
Family Court at Kinnaur Division at Rampur Bushahr was
dealing with the case.
18.
Consequently, the present petition is allowed and
disposed off.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed
of.
(Romesh Verma),
Judge
26.02.2026 (veena)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review