Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:16498
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE C. JAYACHANDRAN
TUESDAY, THE 25TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025 / 6TH PHALGUNA, 1946
CRL.MC NO. 8816 OF 2023
CRIME NO.888/2022 OF VADAKARA POLICE STATION, KOZHIKODE
IN CC NO.354 OF 2023 OF JUDICIAL MAGISTRATE OF FIRST CLASS,
VADAKARA
PETITIONERS/ACCUSED NO.6 & 7:
JUHNA N T
AGED 32 YEARS
W/O AJEESH C V, ELEGANCE HOUSE, ICE PLANT ROAD,
KOYILANDY, KOZHIKODE, PIN - 673305
SHARBINA
AGED 30 YEARS
W/O HAMNAS C V, PALLIPPURAYIL VEEDU, KOTTAKKAL,
IRINGAL,MALAPPURAM, PIN - 676503
BY ADVS.
A.RANJITH NARAYANAN
A.SIMI
RESPONDENTS/STATE AND DE FACTO COMPLAINANT:
STATE OF KERALA
REPRESENTED BY PUBLIC PROSECUTOR, HIGH COURT OF
KERALAREPRESENTING SI OF POLICE, VATAKARA POLICE
STATION, KOZHIKODE RURAL, KOZHIKODE, PIN - 682031
AYSHA HANNA
D/O K P ABDUL NAJEEB, VAZHAYIL HOUSE, J T ROAD, P.O.
VATAKARA, KOZHIKODE, PIN - 673101
BY ADVS.
SRI. E.C BINEESH, PUBLIC PROSECUTOR
Crl.M.C.No.8816 of 2023
2025:KER:16498
-2-
SMT.R.SHABANA FOR R2
THIS CRIMINAL MISC. CASE HAVING COME UP FOR ORDERS ON
13.02.2025, THE COURT ON 25.02.2025 PASSED THE FOLLOWING:
Crl.M.C.No.8816 of 2023
2025:KER:16498
-3-
C. JAYACHANDRAN, J.
-----------------------------------Crl.M.C.No.8816 of 2023
-----------------------------------Dated, this the 25th day of February, 2025
ORDER
This matter was heard and reserved for orders on 13.02.2025
on the premise that the offences alleged is one under
Section 498 A of the Penal Code. However, it was pointed
out by the learned Counsel for the 2 nd respondent today,
that the offences under Sections 406 and 415 are also
alleged, in respect of which, the parties were not heard.
2.
The matter was again heard and records perused.
3.
The prosecution allegation going by Annexure-A2 final
report is as follows:
The 2nd respondent herein married the 1st accused in Crime
no.888/2022 of Vatakara Police Station on 07.03.2021 and
while they were living as husband and wife in the residence
of the 1st accused, accused nos.1 to 7 have physically and
mentally harassed the 2nd respondent/defacto complainant
Crl.M.C.No.8816 of 2023
2025:KER:16498
-4-
seeking
more
gold
ornaments
and
money,
besides
misappropriating 75 sovereigns of gold ornaments and Rupees
three lakhs given to the defacto complainant at the time of
her marriage, thereby committing criminal breach of trust.
The 1st accused was suffering from the disease Multiple
Sclerosis, which was suppressed by accused nos.1 to 7, thus
committing the offences under Section 498 A, 406 and 415 of
the Penal Code.
4.
This Court will straight away peruse the statement of
the
defacto
complainant/2nd
respondent,
available
at
running page no.33 of the paper book. She would state that
when
the
marriage
proposal
came,
she
was
given
to
understand that the 1st accused (proposed husband) is an
Engineer
in
Electronics
and
Communication
and
he
is
employed at Saudi as an officer having family status visa.
After
the
marriage,
the
elder
brother
of
the
1 st
accused/husband by name Hamnas and also, the father and
mother of the 1st accused demanded 50 sovereigns of gold
ornaments for being pledged, for the purpose of a shopping
complex being constructed by them. The said gold ornaments
Crl.M.C.No.8816 of 2023
2025:KER:16498
-5-
have not been released so far. Pursuant to the marriage,
the defacto complainant was harassed alleging that she is
black in colour and that the 1 st accused/husband could have
got
better
bride.
The
details
of
the
harassment
are
narrated in detail. However, there is no necessity to refer
to the same, except insofar as the allegations against the
present petitioners (accused nos.6 and 7) are concerned.
The solitary allegation is contained in paragraph no.3 of
her statement to the effect that along with the father and
mother of her husband, the brothers of the husband and
their wives used to harass her by saying various things.
The defacto complainant was accused that she is going for
studies to flirt with boys. There is also an allegation
that
the
petitioners
along
suppressed
the
fact
that
suffering
from
a
serious
with
the
1st
disease
other
persons
have
accused/husband
was
by
name
Multiple
Sclerosis.
5.
It could thus be seen that there is no specific
allegation against the petitioners (accused nos.6 and 7) in
the crime in question, except a passing reference that they
Crl.M.C.No.8816 of 2023
2025:KER:16498
-6-
used to cause difficulties to the defacto complainant/2 nd
respondent by making allegation against her. The allegation
is not specific. It is not clear as regards the specific
overt act, if any, committed by the petitioners. All what
is available is a vague and omnibus allegation that they
have caused difficulties to the defacto complainant and
that they have alleged that the defacto complainant is
pursuing her studies to flirt with boys.
6.
This Court has also perused the complaint preferred by
the defacto complainant, produced at Annexure-A1. There, in
paragraph
no.7,
the
allegation
against
the
petitioners
(accused nos.6 and 7) is that, they used to tease her body
as dwarf and fat, thus committing body shaming. There also
the allegation is there against the petitioners as well,
along with others, in the matter of alleged suppression of
disease for the purpose of extracting her gold ornaments
and money.
7.
In Achin Gupta v. State of Haryana [2024 KHC 6257],
the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that, if a person is made to
Crl.M.C.No.8816 of 2023
2025:KER:16498
-7-
face a trial on some general, sweeping allegations, without
bringing
on
record
any
specific
instances
of
criminal
conduct, it is nothing, but abuse of a process of Court. In
Digambar v. State of Maharashtra [2024 KHC Online 6737],
the Supreme Court held that vague and omnibus allegations
in the F.I.R., without specific instances of harassment or
cruelty, are not sufficient to constitute the offences
under Section 498 A. It was also held that the allegations
must reveal the existence of cruelty with the intention to
cause
grave
injury
or
to
drive
the
victim
to
commit
suicide. The Hon'ble Supreme Court also cautioned about the
practise of roping in family members into the matrimonial
dispute without specific allegations. It was held that
generalised
and
sweeping
accusations
unsupported
by
concrete evidence or particularised allegations cannot form
the
basis
of
criminal
prosecution.
Courts
have
been
directed to scrutinise such cases carefully and to prevent
misuse of legal processes and avoid unnecessary harassment
of innocent family members.
Crl.M.C.No.8816 of 2023
2025:KER:16498
-8-
8.
Gauged
in
the
touchstone
of
the
above
referred
judgments of the Hon'ble Supreme Court, this Court finds
that
the
allegations
against
the
present
petitioners
(accused nos.6 and 7) falls short of the legal requirements
so as to constitute the offence under Section 498 A.
Accordingly, this Court finds that offence under Section
498 A is not attracted against the petitioners. Rather, the
allegations
statement
raised
given
in
by
the
the
complaint,
defacto
as
also,
complainant
in
the
are
not
sufficient to implicate the petitioners to that offence.
9.
415,
Now, coming to the offences under Sections 406 and
learned
Counsel
for
2 nd
the
respondent/defacto
complainant would invite the attention of this Court to the
complaint
preferred
before
the
learned
Magistrate,
specifically to paragraph no.2 therein. It is alleged that,
on 02.01.2021, accused nos.1 to 3 (husband, father and
mother) have come to see the girl and thereafter, on
11.01.2021, accused nos.2, 3, 6 and 7, along with other
relatives,
have
come
to
the
house
of
the
defacto
complainant with sweets and dress. Upon being informed that
Crl.M.C.No.8816 of 2023
2025:KER:16498
-9-
the groom has liked the bride, the marriage was fixed
thereafter.
These
are
the
allegations
contained
in
paragraph no.2. Based on the above allegations, it is the
submission
made
by
the
learned
Counsel
for
the
2 nd
respondent that accused nos.6 and 7 were instrumental in
getting the marriage fixed and they were also aware of the
serious
disease
of
the
husband/A1,
for
which,
he
was
undergoing treatment. In support of the disease, learned
Counsel
would
invite
this
Court’s
attention
to
the
statement under Section 161 of CW10, Dr.V.G.Pradeep Kumar,
which would state that the 1 st accused was suffering from
Demyelinatiang Disorder-Multiple Sclerosis. The Doctor has
also opined that the disease can only be treated, but
cannot be cured. It is in that sense that the offence under
Section 415 is alleged against the petitioners herein.
Learned Counsel, thereafter, invited the attention of this
Court
to
wherein
the
last
allegations
paragraph
are
made
in
Annexure-A1
against
complaint,
accused
persons
generally that the factum of the serious disease has been
suppressed and had it been revealed, the marriage could not
Crl.M.C.No.8816 of 2023
2025:KER:16498
- 10 -
have taken place at all. The above conduct of the accused
persons amounts to breach of trust and cheating, is the
allegation leveled in the last paragraph. Thus, according
to the learned Counsel, the petitioners are liable to face
the charges under the above Sections of the Penal Code.
10.
The above submissions were seriously refuted by the
learned Counsel for the petitioners. It is argued that the
petitioners are wives of brothers of the husband/A1 and
they owe no responsibility. It was then submitted that the
allegations are not correct and that the petitioners had no
knowledge
of
accused/husband.
the
disease,
if
any,
Mere
participation
of
of
the
the
1 st
petitioners
cannot be an event which can be taken stock of to find them
liable for offences under Section 415, or for that matter,
Section 406 of the Penal Code, is the final submission
made.
11.
Having heard the learned Counsel appearing for the
respective
parties,
this
Court
finds
merit
in
the
submission made by the learned Counsel for the petitioners.
Crl.M.C.No.8816 of 2023
2025:KER:16498
- 11 -
Even
going
by
the
allegations
in
paragraph
no.2
of
Annexure-A1 complaint, all what is decipherable is that,
the present petitioners (accused nos.6 and 7) were also
present, along with accused nos.2 and 3 and with other
relatives, on 11.01.2021, on which date, dress and sweets
were
given
as
gifts
to
the
defacto
complainant.
The
marriage was fixed thereafter, going by the averments in
paragraph no.2. Merely because the petitioners (accused
nos.6 and 7) were also present on a date before the date of
fixing the marriage, along with other relatives, for the
purpose of giving sweets, dress etc will not make them
liable for the offences under Sections 415 and 406 of the
Penal Code, in the context of the alleged suppression of
disease. Apart from the above allegation in Annexure-A1
complaint, there is not even a specific allegation to the
effect that the petitioners (accused nos.6 and 7) were
aware of the alleged disease of the 1 st accused/husband.
What is contained in the concluding paragraph no.13 is a
general, omnibus allegation that accused nos.1 to 7 have
acted in such a manner, so as to grab the gold ornaments
Crl.M.C.No.8816 of 2023
2025:KER:16498
- 12 -
and
money
of
the
defacto
complainant.
Such
vague
and
general allegations are not sufficient to mulct criminal
liability
on
the
petitioners,
in
the
context
of
the
offences under Sections 406 and 415 of the Penal Code. In
the circumstances, the charge on the basis of the said
offences will also stand quashed.
In the circumstances, this Crl.M.C. is allowed and all
further proceedings in Crime no.888/2023 of Vatakara Police
Station
will
stand
quashed
as
against
the
petitioners
(accused nos.6 and 7).
Sd/C. JAYACHANDRAN
JUDGE
SKP/27-02
Crl.M.C.No.8816 of 2023
2025:KER:16498
- 13 -
APPENDIX OF CRL.MC 8816/2023
PETITIONER’S ANNEXURES:
ANNEXURE A1
CERTIFIED COPY OF THE FIR ALONG WITH FIS
DATED 18/11/2022IN CRIME NO.888/2022 OF
VATAKARA POLICE STATION, KOZHIKODE RURAL
ANNEXURE A2
CERTIFIED COPY OF THE FINAL REPORT
NO.241/2023 IN CRIME NO.888/2022 OF
VATAKARA POLICE STATION, KOZHIKODE RURAL
RESPONDENTS’ ANNEXURES:
ANNEXURE R2(A)
ANNEXURE R2(B)
ANNEXURE R2(C)
ANNEXURE R2(D)
ANNEXURE R2(E)
ANNEXURE R2(F)
ANNEXURE R2(G)
ANNEXURE R2(H)
A TRUE COPY OF THE DEPOSITION GIVEN BY DR.
UMMER.K, SENIOR CONSULTANT AND CHIEF
DEPARTMENT OF NEUROLOGY, BABY MEMORIAL
HOSPITAL, KOZHIKODE BEFORE THE 1ST
RESPONDENT
A TRUE COPY OF THE DEPOSITION GIVEN BY DR.
V.G PRADEEP KUMAR, SENIOR CONSULTANT AND
DEPUTY CHIEF , DEPARTMENT OF NEUROLOGY,
BABY MEMORIAL HOSPITAL, KOZHIKODE
A TRUE COPY OF THE ADVOCATE NOTICE DATED
07.11.2022 RECEIVED TO THE DEFACTO
COMPLAINANT
A TRUE COPY OF THE REPLY NOTICE DATED
10.11.2022 SENT BY THE DEFACTO COMPLAINANT
TRUE COPY OF THE GIFT DEED NO 2188/1/2022
DATED 11.11.2022 EXECUTED BY THE 2ND
ACCUSED IN FAVOUR OF 4TH ACCUSED
TRUE COPY OF THE GIFT DEED 2189/1/2022
DATED 11.11.2022 EXECUTED BY THE 2ND
ACCUSED IN FAVOUR OF 5TH ACCUSED
A TRUE COPY OF THE DEATH CERTIFICATE DATED
06.11.2023
A TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT IN CRL MC 9443
OF 2022 DATED 15.11.2024 OF THIS COURT
TRUE COPY
P.A. TO JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review