The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
2. Shri Hijam Nutanchandra Singh, aged about 55 years, S/o Shri Hijam Gunachandra Sigh, resident of Thangmeiband Thingel Leikai, P.O. Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur – 795001. … Respondents MC(El. Petn.) No. 110 of 2022 Contd…/- [2] HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE AHANTHEM BIMOL SINGH For the Applicant :: Mr. Ajoy Pebam, Advocate For the respondents :: Mr. N. Ibotombi, Senior Advocate asstd. by Mr. A. Rommel, Advocate Date of Hearing :: 23-02-2023 Date of Judgment & Order :: 27-02-2023 JUDGMENT & ORDER [1] Heard Mr. Ajoy Pebam, learned counsel appearing for the applicant and Mr. N. Ibotombi, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. A. Rommel, learned counsel appearing for the respondent No 1. None appeared for the respondent No 2. The present application had been filed under Order VI Rule 17 of the CPC, 1908 with a prayer for allowing to delete the letter "h" from the name of the respondent No. 1 appeared at the Index, List of Date and Synopsis, Cause Title at page No. 4, para No. 14(I) at page No. 17, para No. 14 (II) at page No. 19, para No. 22 at page No. 29 and para No. 1(II) at page No. 44 of the connected Election Petition No. 12 of 2022. [2] In the present application, it has been pleaded that in El. Petn. No 8 of 2017 filed by the present applicant in connection with the previous election, the present respondent No. 1 wrote his name as "Khumukcham Joykishan Singh" in the cause tit…
2. (2003) 1 SCC 289 “Ram Prasad Sarma v. Mani Kumar Subba & ors.” “24. It may be noted that in Paragraph 1 of the election petition it has been mentioned that the respondents were the contesting candidates from 9-Tezpur Parliamentary Constituency, that is to say, that Respondent No. 11 was also impleaded as one who had contested the election from the said constituency. There was every intention to implead such a person as a respondent. It may then be noted that along with the election petition, copy of return of election is required to be filed in Form 21-E under Rule 64 of the Conduct of Election Rules, 1961. It contains the result of the election as well as the list of candidates. The said list is on record as Annexure I to the election petition filed by the petitioner and the name of Abul Khayer is indicated at MC(El. Petn.) No. 110 of 2022 Contd…/- [8] Serial No. 7 having contested as an independent candidate. It is thus evident that it is not as if the correct name is not available on the record of the case. Apparently, it seems to be a case of spelling mistake. Instead of Abul letter `d' got added extra hence typed as Abdul in the array of parties and the spelling of Khayer as `Khyer' omitting `a' after `kh'. It is to be noted that address of Respondent No.11 is also indicated in the petition. It is not disputed that it is the address of the person who contested the election…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[1]
signed
SHOUGR Digitally
by
AKPAM SHOUGRAKPAM
DEVANANDA
DEVANAN SINGH
Date: 2023.02.27
DA SINGH 13:48:55 +05'30'
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
MC(El. Petn.) No. 110 of 2022
(Ref:- El. Petn. No. 12 of2022)
Shri Jotin Waikhom, aged about 37 years, S/o (L) Waikhom
Surendra Singh, resident of Thangmeiband Hijam Leikai, P.O.
Lamphel, Imphal West District, Manipur – 795004.
…Applicant
-Versus –
1. Shri Khumukcham Joykisan Singh, aged about 57 years, S/o
Late Kh. Ingocha Singh, resident of Thangmeiband Khuyathong
Polem Leikai, P.O. Lamphel, Imphal West District, Manipur795004 and
2. Shri Hijam Nutanchandra Singh, aged about 55 years, S/o Shri
Hijam Gunachandra Sigh, resident of Thangmeiband Thingel
Leikai, P.O. Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur – 795001.
…. Respondents
-ANDIN THE MATTER OF:
(In Election Petition No. 12 of 2022)
Shri Jotin Waikhom, aged about 37 years, S/o (L) Waikhom
Surendra Singh, resident of Thangmeiband Hijam Leikai, P.O.
Lamphel, Imphal West District, Manipur – 795004.
… Petitioner
-Versus1. Shri Khumukcham Joykisan Singh, aged about 57 years, S/o
Late Kh. Ingocha Singh, resident of Thangmeiband Khuyathong
Polem Leikai, P.O. Lamphel, Imphal West District, Manipur795004 and
2. Shri Hijam Nutanchandra Singh, aged about 55 years, S/o Shri
Hijam Gunachandra Sigh, resident of Thangmeiband Thingel
Leikai, P.O. Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur – 795001.
… Respondents
MC(El. Petn.) No. 110 of 2022
Contd…/-
[2]
B E F O R E
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE AHANTHEM BIMOL SINGH
For the Applicant
::
Mr. Ajoy Pebam, Advocate
For the respondents
::
Mr. N. Ibotombi, Senior Advocate
asstd. by Mr. A. Rommel, Advocate
Date of Hearing
::
23-02-2023
Date of Judgment & Order ::
27-02-2023
JUDGMENT & ORDER
[1]
Heard Mr. Ajoy Pebam, learned counsel appearing for the
applicant and Mr. N. Ibotombi, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. A.
Rommel, learned counsel appearing for the respondent No 1. None appeared
for the respondent No 2.
The present application had been filed under Order VI Rule 17 of the
CPC, 1908 with a prayer for allowing to delete the letter "h" from the name of
the respondent No. 1 appeared at the Index, List of Date and Synopsis, Cause
Title at page No. 4, para No. 14(I) at page No. 17, para No. 14 (II) at page No.
19, para No. 22 at page No. 29 and para No. 1(II) at page No. 44 of the
connected Election Petition No. 12 of 2022.
[2]
In the present application, it has been pleaded that in El. Petn. No
8 of 2017 filed by the present applicant in connection with the previous
election, the present respondent No. 1 wrote his name as "Khumukcham
Joykishan Singh" in the cause title of his written statement as well as in the
affidavit filed in support of his written statement. It has also been pleaded that
while executing and registering a Sale Deed dated 02-06-2017, the name of
the respondent No. 1 was written as "Khumukcham Joykishan Singh" and that
in Revenue Receipt No. 0935 in respect of his land issued by the Revenue
Department, the name of the respondent No. 1 is written as "Joykishan" and
MC(El. Petn.) No. 110 of 2022
Contd…/-
[3]
that before the Sub-Divisional Officer, Lamphel, Imphal West, the respondent
No. 1 presented himself as “Joykishan” as the appellant in Revenue Appeal
Case No. 5 of 2017 and Revenue Appeal Case No. 7 of 2017.
[3]
It is the case of the applicant that the name of the respondent No.
1 is some time written as “Khumukcham Joykishan Singh” and some time as
“Khumukcham Joykisan Singh” in some of his important/ official documents
and accordingly, at the time of drafting the present Election Petition No. 12 of
2022, the learned counsel for the applicant committed a mistake in writing the
name of the respondent No. 1, in that he added the letter “h” in between the
letters “s” and “a” in writing the name of the respondent No. 1, which appeared
at the Index, List of Date and Synopsis, Cause Title at page No. 4, para No.
14(I) at page No. 17, para No. 14 (II) at page No. 19, para 22 at page No. 29
and para No. 1(II) at page No. 44 of the election Petition No. 12 of 2022.
The applicant also pleaded that the respondent No. 1 wrote his
name as “Joykisan” in filing his nomination paper in connection with the 12th
Manipur Legislative Assembly Election, 2022, however, being a time bound
matter, the applicant did not perused properly the spelling of the name of the
respondent No. 1 mentioned in the said election petition and consequently the
applicant failed to write the name of the respondent No. 1 as “Joykisan” in
some pages of the election petition during the preparation of the said election
petition.
[4]
Mr Ajoy Pebam, learned counsel appearing for the applicant
submitted that while drafting the said Election Petition No. 12 of 2022, the
learned counsel for the applicant through bona fide mistake and oversight
wrote the name of the respondent No. 1 as "Joykishan" in some pages of the
election petition, however, the name of the respondent No. 1 is also written
MC(El. Petn.) No. 110 of 2022
Contd…/-
[4]
as "Joykisan" in some pages of the election petition. It has also been
submitted that the respondent No. 1 had accepted service of notice of the said
election petition, which was sent under the name "Khumukcham Joykishan
Singh" and the respondent No. 1 has knowledge about the pendency of the
said election petition and contested the same by filing his written statement.
The learned counsel further submitted that while deleting the letter "h" from
the name of the respondent No. 1 by way of amendment as sought for will not
change the nature and character of the election petition but it would rather
assist this court to give justice to the applicant and that if the connected
election petition is heard and disposed of without allowing the present
application, it will cause great loss and irreparable damage to the applicant.
The learned counsel accordingly submitted that it will be just and appropriate
to grant leave of this court to delete the letter "h" from the name of the
respondent No. 1 as prayed for in the present application for proper
adjudication of the said election petition.
[5]
Mr. N. Ibotombi, learned senior counsel appearing for the
respondent No. 1 submitted that through bona fide mistake on the part of the
respondent No. 1, he wrongly typed his name as “Khumukcham Joykishan
Singh” in the written statement filed by him in connection with the earlier
El. Petn. No. 8 of 2017 though the respondent No. 1 clearly mentioned his
name as “Khumukcham Joykisan Singh” in the nomination paper and Form26 affidavits and that though the respondent No. 1 wrongly typed his name as
“Khumukcham Joykishan Singh”, he signed his written statement and other
connected papers as “Khumukcham Joykisan Singh”. The learned senior
MC(El. Petn.) No. 110 of 2022
Contd…/-
[5]
counsel further submitted that any bona fide mistake regarding the correct
name of the respondent No. 1 on the earlier occasion, i.e., at the time of filing
his written statement in the earlier election petition has nothing to do in the
present case and that the applicant cannot take advantage of the said bona
fide mistake in the present election petition and that such mistake cannot cure
the defect committed by the applicant in his election petition.
[6]
The learned senior counsel for the respondent No. 1 submitted that
the name of the returned candidate from 9-Thangmeiband Assembly
Constituency in the 12th Manipur Legislative Assembly Election is
“Khumukcham Joykisan Singh” and not “Khumukcham Joykishan Singh” and
that there is no person called and known as “Khumukcham Joykishan Singh”,
s/o (L) Kh. Ingocha Singh at Thameiband Khoyathong Polem Leikai, Imphal,
Manipur. It has also been submitted that the petitioner did not implead
“Khumukcham
Joykisan
Singh”,
the
returned
candidate
from
9-
Thangmeiband Assembly Constituency in the 12th Manipur Legislative
Assembly Election in El. Petn. No. 12 of 2022 and accordingly, the said
election petition is hit by principle of non-joinder of necessary parties and the
said election petition is liable to be dismissed.
[7]
It has also been submitted on behalf of the respondent No. 1 that
the amendment as sought for by the present applicant is not sustainable in
the eye of law and also not permitted by law and that if the amendment as
prayed for is allowed, it will change the entire character of the connected
election petition and that the amendment to the election petition cannot be
permitted to cure inherent defect after the expiry of limitation period. The
MC(El. Petn.) No. 110 of 2022
Contd…/-
[6]
learned senior counsel accordingly submitted that the present application is
liable to be dismissed as being not maintainable.
[8]
I have heard the rival submissions advanced by the learned
counsel appearing for the parties at length and also examined the materials
available on record. It is undeniably found on record that the name of the
returned candidate is written as "Khumukcham Joykishan Singh" in some
pages of the Election Petition No. 12 of 2022 as mentioned hereinabove and
his name is also written as “Khumukcham Joykisan Singh” in some pages of
the election petition. After hearing the arguments advanced by the learned
counsel appearing for the parties and on careful examination of the pleadings
made in the said election petition, this Court is of the considered view that the
insertion of the letter “h” in between the letters “s” and “a” while writing the
name of the returned candidate is purely a typographical mistake and a simple
case of spelling mistake and nothing more. In my considered view, the said
mistake is only a mis-description of the respondent No. 1’s name and that a
mistake in spelling the name is merely a typographical error and is
preeminently a curable defect and that if the correction is allowed, it would not
amount to adding any new party and it would not alter the cause of action or
bring any substantive change in the complexion of the petition which would
remain the same in content and so long as there is substantial compliance of
section 82 of the RP Act, that should be sufficient to support the amendment
sought. It is also not the case where the identity and address of the
respondent No. 1 is in dispute. Moreover, the returned candidate has
knowledge about filing of the said election petition challenging his election and
MC(El. Petn.) No. 110 of 2022
Contd…/-
[7]
contested the said election petition by filing his written statement. In view of
the above, this Court is of the considered view that the objection raised by the
respondent No. 1 is purely on minor technical ground and that the election
petition cannot be invalidated by this insignificant typographical error. In this
connection, we can gainfully relied on the following judgments:1. 1995 Supp (3) SCC 407 “Gore Lal Shakya v. Maharaj Singh
Yadav & ors.”
“8. Learned counsel for Respondent 1 in support of his
submission that the averments in the election petition
should be in strict compliance of Section 86(1) of the Act,
relied upon the decision in Rajendra Singh v. Usha Rani.
But in the same decision the learned Judges have
observed: (SCC p. 345, para 15)
“The mandate contained in Section 81(3) enjoins that
there should be no difference of any kind whatsoever
barring some typographical or insignificant omissions
between the petitions filed and the copy served on the
respondent.”
“9. In the present case we are of the firm view that the
mentioning of the name of the 10th respondent as “Sanjai
Kumar” in the array of parties is nothing but only a
typographical error which is insignificant. Under these
circumstances we are unable to agree with the High Court
that this typographical error has invalidated the election
petition under Section 86(1) of the Act.”
2. (2003) 1 SCC 289 “Ram Prasad Sarma v. Mani Kumar Subba
& ors.”
“24. It may be noted that in Paragraph 1 of the election
petition it has been mentioned that the respondents
were the contesting candidates from 9-Tezpur
Parliamentary Constituency, that is to say, that
Respondent No. 11 was also impleaded as one who had
contested the election from the said constituency. There
was every intention to implead such a person as a
respondent. It may then be noted that along with the
election petition, copy of return of election is required to
be filed in Form 21-E under Rule 64 of the Conduct of
Election Rules, 1961. It contains the result of the election
as well as the list of candidates. The said list is on record
as Annexure I to the election petition filed by the
petitioner and the name of Abul Khayer is indicated at
MC(El. Petn.) No. 110 of 2022
Contd…/-
[8]
Serial No. 7 having contested as an independent
candidate. It is thus evident that it is not as if the correct
name is not available on the record of the case.
Apparently, it seems to be a case of spelling mistake.
Instead of Abul letter `d' got added extra hence typed as
Abdul in the array of parties and the spelling of Khayer
as `Khyer' omitting `a' after `kh'. It is to be noted that
address of Respondent No.11 is also indicated in the
petition. It is not disputed that it is the address of the
person who contested the election. In this Court there is
an office report of service of notice on respondent No. 8
prepared on the basis of the report received from the
Gauhati High Court. So far as the wrong spelling of
Khyer is concerned, it is of little consequence. Both
words "Khyer" and "Khayer" would produce almost the
same sound. Technically there may be difference but by
way of example some may spell `Banerjee' as `Banerji'
or `Saksena' as `Saxena' or the like. Therefore such
difference in spelling of Khayar is but to be ignored.
There is certainly some difference in `Abul' and `Abdul'
but there is ample material on record to indicate that the
same person who had contested election was meant to
be impleaded e.g. the address of the person, the
averment that the Respondents 7 to 18 had contested
the election as well as the form of election return
indicating names of all those who had contested the
election and the names with correct spelling is on the
record, namely, `Abul Khayer'. The respondent therefore
gets no advantage out of above-noted point sought to be
made out. The parties have however placed reliance on
certain decisions on the point. On behalf of Respondent
No.1 reliance has been placed on Gore Lal Shakya v.
Maharaj Singh Yadav wherein Respondent No.10 was
shown as Sanjay Kumar whereas the correct name
should have been Sanjiv Kumar. Similar arguments
seems to have been advanced that notice was not
served on the correct respondent and the person who
ought to have been impleaded, has not been impleaded.
The High Court dismissed the petition for noncompliance with Section 82(a) of the Act. This Court
upset the decision of the High Court observing that High
Court had made a mountain out of a molehill as it was a
mere typographical mistake. Then this Court noted that
in the body of the petition at one place his name was
indicated as Sanjiv Kumar and at another place his
name was indicated as Sanjay Kumar. It is submitted
that in the present case no application for correcting the
MC(El. Petn.) No. 110 of 2022
Contd…/-
[9]
name was moved nor was any written objection filed to
indicate that it was a typing error. We feel that absence
of any such application will not adversely affect the
petition for the reasons we have already indicated
earlier. Another case relied upon by the learned counsel
for the respondent is reported in K. Kamaraja Nadar v.
Kunju Thevar. This is a case relating to non-joinder of
necessary parties. We are not concerned here with such
a point. This case therefore would be of no help to the
respondent. The learned counsel for the appellant relies
upon a case reported in Shiv Chand v. Ujagar Singh to
indicate the approach which the Court may adopt while
dealing with a case under Section 86 (1) of the Act. It is
observed that the test is whether the election petition
complies with provisions of Section 82, not whether the
election petitioner has failed to comply with Section 82.
The substance of the matter must govern, because
hypertechnicality when the public policy of the statute is
fulfilled, cannot be permitted to play the procedural
tyrant to defeat the vital judicial process, namely,
investigation into the merits of the case. We find no force
in this point too raised by Respondent No. 1. No other
point has been urged.
[9]
The Hon’ble High Court of Punjab and Haryana considered
similar amendment applications and allowed the said amendment in its
judgment dated 29-10-2014 passed in MCs No. 3-E & 4-E of 2013 (El.
Petn. No. 3 of 2012) with the following directions:“For the foregoing reasons, the application is allowed and
the amendment is permitted to be carried out. The amended
petition is taken on record. The respondent is at liberty to file
afresh written statement or adopt the written statement already
filed by her. Four weeks time is granted to the respondent to do
so or to omit to do so.
However, a challenge to a small mistake in typing ‘r’ for ‘n’
has led to a gross waste of Court time in hearing this matter
and passing judgment even when there was sufficient case
law in command for the proposition in issue. Besides, the
respondent has been put to unnecessary expense of Court
hearings, counsel fee etc. on the application for amendment for
which she deserves to be compensated. Therefore, it is deemed
fir that the applications will be allowed subject to payment of
MC(El. Petn.) No. 110 of 2022
Contd…/-
[10]
₹ 25,000/- as costs, half payable to the respondent and the ret
to the Medication & Conciliation Centre of this Court.”
[10]
For the reasons and findings given hereinabove and in view of
the judgments quoted hereinabove, the present application is allowed and
the amendment sought for is permitted to be carried out subject to payment
of cost of Rs. 25,000/- (rupees twenty five thousand) to be paid to the High
Court Bar Association of Manipur. The counsel for the applicant is directed
to carry out the necessary amendments in the presence of the Registrar
(Judl.) of this High Court and the counsel for the respondent No. 1. The
correction is to be carried out within a period of one week from today. The
respondent No. 1 is at liberty to file a fresh written statement or adopt the
written statement already filed by him, if so advised for which, four weeks’
time is granted for doing the needful.
With the aforesaid directions, the present application is disposed
of.
JUDGE
FR/NFR
Devananda
MC(El. Petn.) No. 110 of 2022
Contd…/-
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review