Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
.\
t 3486 I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
WEDNESDAY, THE TWELFTH DAY OF AUGUST
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE VAKITI RAMAKRISHNA REDDY
WRIT PETITION NO: 28275 OF 2019
Between:
1. Joginipally Sudhakar Rao, S/o. Venkat Rao, aged about 69 years, Manwada
Village, Boinpalle Mandal, Rajanna Siricilla District,
2. Joginipally Umapathi, S/o. Sudhakar Rao, aged about 38 years, [\t'lanwada
Village, Boinpalle Mandal, Rajanna Siricilla District.
...PETITIONERS
AND
1. The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary, (Revenue) Land
Acquisition, Secretariat Buildings, Hyderabad.
2. The District Collector, Siricilla, Siricilla District.
3. The Executive Engineer (lrrigation), Division ll, IFFC Circle, LIr4D Colony,
Karimnagar.
4. The Special Deputy Collector-cum-Revenue Divisional Officer, Siricilla.
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased
to issue a writ or order or direction more particularly in the nature of Writ of
lVandamus declaring the in action on the part of the respondents in not include the
petitioners 1 and 2 in the list of Beneficiaries Published in the Gazette Notification,
and not paying the financial assistance @ Rs.4.50 lakhs project affected families
under Mid [Vlanair project in manwada village in the form of Ex-gratia as per the
G.O.Ms.No.1'10 Dated 61912018 to the house.No.l-'1 '1 owned by the first petitioner
and H.No.4-54 owned by the 2nd petitioner situated at Manuwada Village,Boinpalli
Mandal,Rajanna sircilla District in lieu of all the hampered development of village in
accordance with Law irr respect of H.No.1-'1 1 and H.No.4-54 of Manuwada Village,
Boinpalli Mandal, Rajanna Sircilla District.
l.A. NO: 1 OF 2019
Petition under Sect,on 151 cpc praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pleased to consider
the recommendations o'M.R.o. dated 411l2o1g include the petitioners 1 and 2 in the
list of Beneficiaries and direct the respondents to pay financial assistance
@ Rs.4,50
lakhs to each petitioner being the project affected families under mid IVIaair project in
lvlanwada village in the form of Ex-gratia as per the G,o.t\Is.No.1 .10 Dated 6tgt2o1B
to H.No.1-1 1 owned by rhe first petitioner and H.No.4-s4 owned by the 2nd petitioner
situated at l\rlanuwada village, Boinpalli IVandal, Rajanna sircilla District pending
disposal of the above said writ petition.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI B. ARJUN RAO
Counsel for the Respondents: AGp FOR LAND ACOUISITION (TG)
'Ihe Court made
the following: ORDER
I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF. TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAI)
THE HONOI'RABLT SRI JUSTICE VAIilTI RAMA KRISHNA REDDY (
W.P.No,28275 of 2019
Date: L2.O8.2O26
Between:
Joginipally Sudhakar Rao and another
Petitioners
AND
The State of Telangala and 3 others
...Respondents
:ORDER:
This Writ Petition is filed under Article 226 of Constitution
of India seeking the following relief:" ...to issue a writ or ()rder or clitection more particltlarly in the nqture ofwrit
of mandamus decloring the oction on the Pqrt of the respondents in not include
the petitioner Nos.I and 2 in the list af Benefciaries Published in the Gazette
Notilication, and not paying the financial \ssistance or Rs 1.50 lakhs propct
affected fanilies under Mid Manait projecl in Manwada illage in the form of
-gratia a.s per the G.O.Ms.Ntt.1l0 Dated 6/9/2018 to the house'No'1-ll
owned by the Jirst petitioner qnd H.N(,.1-51 otvned by the 2tu petitioner sitttated
qt Manuwadi Village, Boinpalli Mandal, Rojanna Sircillq Districl in lieu of all
the hampered clevelopment of village in uccotdance with L ' in respect of
H.No.t-11 and H.No.4-51 of Manmada Village, Boinpalli Mandal, Raianna
Sircilla District.... "
2.
Heard Sri Heard Sri B. Arjun Rao, learned counsel
appearing for the petitioners, and Sri B. Vrj ay Kumar, learned
Assistant Government Pleader for Land Acquisition, appearing
for the respondents.
FACTS
3.
The case of the petitioners is that petitioner No' 1 is the
owner of House No. 1- 1 1 and petitioner No.2 is the owner of
House No.4-54, both situated at Manwada Village, Boinpalli
VRKR,J
W.P. No.28275 of 2019
Mandal, Rajanna Sircilla District (hereinafter referred
to as "the
subject propertios") Manwada Village came to be submerged
on
account of the Mid Manair Reservoir Project' and by
dated
G.O.Ms.No.17, I&CAD (PW:LA'IV-P&R) Department'
03.03.2010, the village was declared as fully submerged
For
the said purpose, a notification was issued and the subject
properties were acquired. At the time of initiation of the
acquisition pro,:eedings, estimates in respect of the subject
properties \,vere prepared upon inspection thereof'
4.
Subsequerrtly, the Government issued G'O'Ms'No'110'
Irrigation ancl CAD (LA'R&R/A2) Department' dated
06.09.2018, according permission to provide financial
assistance of Rs.25.84 crore, at the rate of Rs'4 25 lakhs each'
to 608 Project Affected Families under the Mid Manair Project
in Manwada Vi1lage, in the form of ex-gratia, in lieu of all the
hampered deve:opment of the village'
5.
According, to the petitioners, their names were not
included in the list of beneficraries at the time of preparation of
the said list try the Deputy Executive Engineer, R&B SubDivision. The petitioners therefore approached respondent No.6
seeking inclusirrn of their names in the beneficiaries
list. The
-)
I/RKR,J
It/.P. No.28275 of 2019
then Tahsildar, Boinpalli Mandal, after conducting an enquiry,
recommended the names of the petitioners for inclusion in the
beneficiaries list and issued proceedings No'C/1005-3 12018,
dated 04.01.2019. The grievance of the petitioners is that,
notwithstanding the said recommendation, their names have
not been included in the beneficiaries list. Hence, the present
Writ Petition.
ST'BMISSIONS
A. Submtssions on beha{ of the petltioners
6.
Learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that the
petitioners are the owners of the subject properties, which were
acquired for the Mid Manair Project, and that the Government,
under G.O.Ms.No.11O, dated O6'09.2018, sanctioned financial
assistance in the form of ex-gratia to the project a-ffected
families of Manwada Village. It was submitted that, after
conducting the necessarJi enquiry, the Tahsildar recommended
inclusion of the names of the petitioners in the beneficiaries list
by proceedings dated 04.Ol.2Ol9.
.
Learned counsel further submitted that the claim of the
petitioners is required to be considered with reference to the
relevalt Resettlement and Rehabilitation policy and the
"''\ <\
.t
VRKR.J
W.P. No.28275 of2019
definitions of "Family", "Project Affected Family' and "Project
Displaced Family", besides the other Government Orders relied
upon b1- the petitioners. It was contended that the
recommendatior-r made bv the Tahsildar could not have been
ignored r.,',ithout properiv considering the material placed by the
petitioners.
B. Szbmissions on behalt of the respondents
8.
Learned Assistant Government Pleader, relying upon the
counter-affidavjt filed on behalf of respondent No'4, submitted
that, pursuant to the recommendation of the Tahsildar dated
04.U,.2olg, 's'LLich rvas based on the Ration Cards standing in
the names of tre petitioners and issued in the year 2006, the
Revenue Divisional Officer, Sircilla, directed the Tahsildar to
conduct an encluirv- and submit a detailed report as to vi'hether
the petitioners had been residing in Manwada Village during
the three years preceding Notification No.52, dated 13'06 2006'
g.
It was submitted that, pursuant to the said direction, the
Tahsildar, Boinpalli, submitted a report dated O1'02'2020
stating that tht: petitioners had not resided in Manwada Village
at the time of ..he Socio Economic Survey, or during the three
years precedinpl G azette Notification
No.52, dated 13.06.2006.
VRKR,J
ll.P. No.28275 of 2019
Therefore, according to the respondents, the petitioners do not
fall within the category of Project Affected Families and are not
entitled to the R&R benelits claimed by them.
10. Learned Assistant Government Pleader further submitted
that, according to the clarification issued vide Government of
Andhra Pradesh Memo No.16697lReR/ A.2l2OlI-1, dated
O2.O8.2O11, read with Clause 5.4(a) of the State R&R Policy,
2OO5, issued in G.O.Ms.No.68, I&CAD (PW'LA'IV R&R)
Department, dated 08.04.20O5, members of families who are
permanently residing, or practising any trade, occupation or
vocation, in the Project Affected Area are eligible for the benefits
under the R&R Policy; and that persons who are not
permanently residing in the Project Affected Area are,
accordingly, not eligible for the other benefits under the R&R
Policy, except the value of their structures. It was also
contended that the Writ Petition is hit by laches.
POINT FOR DETERIUINATION
11. In view of the rival submissions and having regard to the
material placed on record, the following point arises for
determination:
VRKR,,J
Il.P. No.28275 of 2019
Whether the claim of tLrc petitioners to ex-gratia
unde" G.C).Ms.No.110, dated O6.09.2018, can be
adjucl.icate d in these proceedings?
ANALYSIS
12. At the rrutset, the controversy involved in the present case
revolves around the entitlement of the petitioners to payment of
ex-gratia un<ler G.O.Ms.No.l i0, dated O6.09.201g, issued by
the Irrigation and CAD (LA.R&R/A2) Department. To consider
the issue involved in the present Writ petition. it is appropriate
to refer to tLLe said Government Order, the relevant portions
whereof are ertracted hereunder:
"2. In the reference 2nd read aboue, the District Collector,
Rajanna Sircilla ho's informed that in G.O.Ms.No. j 7,
I&CAD (PW:LA.IV-P&R) Dept., dt.03.03.2o10 uas issued
declaing tt4anutada uilLage as fully submerged und.er Mid.
Manair Reseruoir. Afier issuing the said G.O. there is no
deuelopme'nt in the uillage i.e., roads. drains etc. He has
,Pr:fZr: requested to prouicle cash compensation in lieu of
R&R Colorry. After examining the matter, it utas requestedto direct the members o.f the Three Men Committee
constituted in the reference Sth read aboue to inspect the
Manutada uillage and_ submit their report to Gottemment on
the
.subject matter through Commissioner, R&R for taking
further acti.on in the matter.
3. In the re feren.ce 6th reod aboue, the Commissioner, R&R
& LA has furnished the report of the 3 men committee,
tuhich amcng other recommend.ed that a considerable
financial ossistance upto 4.25 lakhs in the Jorm of ex_
gratia mat, be extended to the affected. families utith the
condition t,iat theg shall not approach ang legal
enhancemt,nt of propose-d ex_gratia in - tiei fon_tm for
of all the
hampered ,teuelopment of the uilage
t".i'g
fo,
i'ears. fnis
tuill help fi enharrcemei,t
socio economic conditions
,o!
the affectea,
of
Jamilies.
YRKR,J
W.P. No.28275 of 2019
4. Gouentment afier careful examination of the aboue
proposal, hereby accord pennission to prouide financiol
assistance for an amount of Rs.25.84/ - Crore @ Rs.4.25/'
LakLts to 608 Project Affected Families under Mid Manair
Project in Maruada Village of Boinpalli Mandal, Rajanna
Sircilla District in the fonn of ex-gratia in lieu of all the
hampered deuelopment of uilloge for the last 8 gears
subject to condition ttnt theg shall not approach ang legal
forum for enhancement of ex-gratia".
13. A perusal of the above Government Order makes it clear
that the Government intended to extend hnancial assistance to
the Project Affected Families under the Mid Manair Project. The
entitlement of the petitioners, therefore, turns upon whether
tJley satisfy the requirements applicable to such families under
the relevant Resettlement and Rehabilitation policy
a
question which is essentially factual in character
14. It is the specific contention of the petitioners that the
Tahsildar, after conducting the necessary enquiry,
recommended their narnes for inclusion in the beneficiaries list
vide proceedings dated O4.Ol.2Ol9. However, a-fter the filing of
the present Writ Petition, a counter-affidavit came to be filed
stating that the Revenue Divisional Officer had directed the
Tahsildar to conduct a further enquiry into the question
whether the petitioners had been residing in Manwada Village
during the three years preceding Notification No.52, dated
.-'d
VRKR,J
W.P. No.28275 of 2019
13.06.2006, and that, pursuant thereto, the Tahsildar
submitted a report dated Ol'O2'2O2O stating that the
petitionershadnotresidedinthevillageatthetimeoftheSocio
Economic Survey or during the said three-year period'
15. Though le arned counsel for the petitioners has extensivetry
argued with regard to the entitiement of the petitioners to the
benefit under the said Government Order, by drawing the
attention of ttris Court to the relevant Government Orders'
including the rlefinitions of "Family", "Project Affected Family"
and "Project I)isplaced Family" contained in the Policy on
Resettlement;aldRehabilitationforProjectAffectedAreas'
2005, as n'el1 as to various factual aspects relating to the
petitioners' residence in the viilage at the relevant point of time,
this Court is of the considered opinion that these disputed
questions of fact cannot appropriately be adjudicated in the
present proceedings.
16. In particrrlar, there are two reports of the Tahsildar which
take divergent vieu,s on the very szune factual question' The
earlier proceedings
dated 04.01.2019 resulted in
recommendation in favour of the petitioners,
whereas
a
the
subsequent report dated Ol.O2.2O2O
records a contrary
VRKR,J
W.P. No.28275 of 2019
position. The material placed before this Court does not
disclose the reasons for which the subsequent report departed
from the earlier recommendation, nor does it disclose that the
petitioners were heard before the said report came to be
submitted. In such circumstalces, it would neither be
appropriate nor permissible for this Court to adjudicate upon
the disputed questions of fact relating to the petitioners'
entitlement in exercise of jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India.
17. In so far as the plea of laches is concerned, it is to be
noticed that G.O.Ms.No.1 1O was issued on 06.O9.2018, that the
proceedings recommending the inclusion of the petitioners were
issued on O4.Ol.2Ol9, and that the present Writ Petition came
to be filed in the year 2Ol9.In any event, since this Court is not
adjudicating the claim of the petitioners on merits, but is
remitting the matter for a fresh enquiry, it is open to
respondent No.2 to consider the said objection also, along with
the other contentions of the parties.
18. It is also to be noticed that, on the own showing of the
respondents, persons who are not permanently residing in the
Project Affected Area, though ineligible for the other benefits
VRKR,J
W.P. No.28275 of 20)9
under the R&R Policy, nevertheiess remain entitled to the value
of their structures. Since the petitioners assert ownership of the
acquired houses, that limb of the claim shall also be examined
by respondent No.2, independently of the claim to ex-gratia
under G.O.Ms.I{o.110.
19. In the cir:umstances, this Court considers it appropriate
to direct respor,.dent No.2 to conduct an enquiry by affording an
opportunity of 1-rearing to the petitioners and by considering the
entirety of the relevant material, including the earlier
recommendation of the Tahsildar and the subsequent report.
CONCLUSION AND RESULT
20. Accordingly, this Writ Petition is disposed of, directing
respondent No 2 to conduct an enquiry afresh with regard to
the entitlement of the petitioners to the R&R benefits/ ex-gratia
as provided utrder G.O.Ms.No.11O, dated 06.09.2018, in the
follou'ing terms:
(i)
The petitioners sha11 submit a representation, along with
all relevalt documents, before respondent No.2 within a period
of two (02) r,r,.eel<s from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.
1l
TRKR,J
lI/.P. No.28275 of 2019
(ii) Upon receiPt of such representation, resPondent No'2
shall conduct a detailed enquiry aJter affording
an opportunity
of hearing to the Petitioners
(iii) While conducting the enquiry' respondent No'2 shall
considerthedocumentsliledalongwiththepresentWrit
Petition,theearlierrecommendation/proceedingsdated
the
O4.01.2O19, the subsequent report dated O1'02 '2020'
applicable Resettlement and Rehabilitation policy
and the
Government Orders on the subject, the entitlement
of the
other
petitioners to the value of their structures, and anY
Ielevantdocumentsthatmaybesubmittedbythepetitioners.
(iv) Respondent No.2 shall pass a reasoned order' in
accordancewithlaw,withinaperiodoftwo(02)monthsfrom
the date of receipt of the representation, and shall communicate
the decision to the Petitioners'
It is made clear that this Court has not expressed any
petrtroners'
oplnlon on the merits of the claim of the
21,.
Respondent No.2 shall consider the matter independently
pass an appropriate order in accordance with law'
22. There shall be no order as to costs
and
VRKR,J
W P No.28275 of20l9
23. As a sequel, the misceilaneous petitions pending, if any,
shail stand closed
s D I - r srtErEA[Y
A:I'EiRRX
//TRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER
To,
1 The Principal
Land Acquisition'
Secretary' (Revenue)
Secretariat Buildings'
il: ii;i;;ireransana HYderabad'
FFC crce LrvrD coonv
I i[*:*.':: ?il;:"l"li1,iffli'J;l::i'
- fi ::t"*'''"ru"
B
;6 ;;";;sr
tc the
Two
collector-cum-Revenue
ArPn
CCs
' +;;";;
TKS
\+
i:: ,-:::"'ffJ:[|:'-.^
at HYderabad[oUr]
7. Two CD CoPies
TJ
GP
D-ivision al Officer,
Siricilla
Court for the State
of
HIGH COURT
CC TODAY
DATED: 1210812026
1 Y\ E 5TA If
ORDER
/J
WP.No.28275 of 2019
L)
c
P2
? 2 AUlj
* DFsp
DISPOSING OF THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
\D
,64
Yi_
Lb \.8 126
o
\
*
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review