The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
13. Resultantly, we are of the considered opinion that these appeals are not liable to be considered on merits, and the view taken by the learned Single Judge does not suffer from any infirmity. Accordingly, the present appeals stand dismissed accordingly.
14. The appellants-State shall necessarily quantify the amount and ask the retired employees to deposit the required amount within a stipulated period of two months. If the amount is not deposited within the specified time period, the appellants-State may pass fresh orders. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the petitioner has submitted representations at Annexure P-6 to the competent authorities for the redressal of his grievances, however, the same has not been decided till date. Learned counsel also submits that the petitioner would be content in case the respondents/competent authority(s) are directed to decide the aforesaid representation in accordance with law within a fixed time schedule. Learned counsel appearing for the respondents is not averse to this prayer.
4. In view of above, this writ petition is disposed of with direction to the respondents to consider and decide the aforesaid representation of the petitioner (Annexure P-6) seeking pension as per the Old Pension Scheme in accordance with law keeping in view the aforesaid decisions, within a period of three weeks from today. In case the petitioner is held entitled to pension under the Old Pension Scheme, the same be remitted in his favour alongwith admissible arrears from the due date within a period of three weeks thereafter. The decision so arrived at shall also be communicated to the petitioner. The writ petition stand disposed of in the above terms, so also the pending miscellaneous application(s), if any. September 24, 2026 rohit Jyotsna Rewal Dua Judge
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CWP No. 16606/2026
Decided on: 24.09.2026
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Joginder Singh
…..Petitioner
Versus
Himachal Road Transport Corporation
and others
.....Respondents
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Coram
Ms. Justice Jyotsna Rewal Dua
Whether approved for reporting? 1
For the Petitioners:
Mr. Vikas Rajput, Advocate.
For the Respondents: Ms. Shrutika Chauhan, Advocate.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------Jyotsna Rewal Dua, Judge
Notice. Ms. Shrutika Chauhan, learned counsel,
appears and waives service of notice on behalf of the
respondents.
2.
Petitioner is the retired Class-III employees of
the respondent-Himachal Road Transport Corporation. HIs
grievance is that he is not being released pension under the
Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1972-Old Pension
Scheme by the respondents presumably on the ground of
failure on his part to exercise option within the time
stipulated in office memorandum dated 04.05.2023.
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that
the case of the petitioner and the issue raised by them has
Whether reporters of print and electronic media may be allowed to see the order? Yes.
already been adjudicated upon in Reshmo Devi Versus
State of Himachal Pradesh & Ors.2, relevant portion of
which reads as under:“It is well settled that pension is not a bounty. In
R.C. Gupta & Ors. vs. Regional Provident Fund
Commissioner, EPFO & Ors.3 the appellant-employees’
employer had contributed 12% of their actual salary (not
restricted to the statutory ceiling) to the Provident Fund,
and the employees sought pension benefits on this
higher salary. The authorities denied this, citing a cutoff date under the proviso to Clause 11(3) of the Pension
Scheme. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in paragraph 7,
clarified that the dates mentioned in the proviso – such
as the scheme’s commencement or when salary exceeds
the ceiling – are only for calculating pensionable salary,
not as cut-off dates for exercising the option to
contribute on a higher salary. The Court emphasized
that a beneficial social welfare scheme should not be
defeated by technicalities, especially where actual
salary contributions had already been made, thereby
upholding the welfare intent of the scheme. The Court
held as under:“7. Reading the proviso, we find that the reference to
the date of commencement of the Scheme or the
date on which the salary exceeds the ceiling limit
are dates from which the option exercised are to be
reckoned with for calculation of pensionable salary.
The said dates are not cut-off dates to determine
the eligibility of the employer-employee to indicate
their option under the proviso to Clause 11(3) of the
Pension Scheme. A somewhat similar view that has
been taken by this Court in a matter coming from
the Kerala High Court4, wherein the Special Leave
Petition (C) No.7074 of 2014 filed by the Regional
Provident Fund Commissioner was rejected by this
Court by order dated 31.03.20165 . A beneficial
Scheme, in our considered view, ought not to be
allowed to be defeated by reference to a cut-off
CWP No.11004 of 2025, decided alongwith connected matters on 10.07.2025
(2018) 14 SCC 809
Union of India vs. A. Majeed Kunju, Writ Appeal No.1135 of 2012, order dated 5.3.2013
(Ker)
Regl. Provident Fund Commr. Vs. A. Majeed Kunju, 2016 SCC OnLine SC 1744
date, particularly, in a situation where (as in the
present case) the employer had deposited 12% of
the actual salary and not 12% of the ceiling limit of
Rs.5,000/- or Rs.6,500/- per month, as the case
may be.
8.
A further argument has been made on behalf of the
Provident Fund Commissioner that the appellantemployees had already exercised their option under
paragraph 26(6) of the Employees' Provident Funds
Scheme. Paragraph 26(6) is in the following terms:
26. Classes of employees entitled and required to
join the fund . – (1) – (5)
xxx
xxx
xxx
(6) Notwithstanding anything contained in this
paragraph, an officer not below the rank of an
Assistant Provident Fund Commissioner may, on
the joint request in writing, of any employee of a
factory or other establishment to which this Scheme
applies and his employer, enroll such employee as
a member or allow him to contribute more than six
thousand five hundred rupees of his pay per month
if he is already a member of the fund and
thereupon such employee shall be entitled to the
benefits and shall be subject to the conditions of the
fund, provided that the employer gives an
undertaking in writing that he shall pay the
administrative charges payable and shall comply
with all statutory provisions in respect of such
employee.
9. We do not see how exercise of option under
paragraph 26 of the Provident Fund Scheme can be
construed to estop the employees from exercising a
similar option under paragraph 11(3). If both the
employer and the employee opt for deposit against
the actual salary and not the ceiling amount,
exercise of option under paragraph 26 of the
Provident Scheme is inevitable. Exercise of the
option under paragraph 26(6) is a necessary
precursor to the exercise of option under Clause
11(3). Exercise of such option, therefore, would not
foreclose the exercise of a further option under
Clause 11(3) of the Pension Scheme unless the
circumstances warranting such foreclosure are
clearly indicated.
10. The above apart in a situation where the deposit of
the employer's share at 12% has been on the actual
salary and not the ceiling amount, we do not see
how the Provident Fund Commissioner could have
been aggrieved to file the L.P.A. before the Division
Bench of the High Court. All that the Provident Fund
Commissioner is required to do in the case is an
adjustment of accounts which in turn would have
benefitted some of the employees. At best what the
Provident Commissioner could do and which we
permit him to do under the present order is to seek
a return of all such amounts that the concerned
employees may have taken or withdrawn from their
Provident Fund Account before granting them the
benefit of the proviso to Clause 11(3) of the Pension
Scheme. Once such a return is made in whichever
cases such return is due, consequential benefits in
terms of this order will be granted to the said
employees.”
5.
In view of above, this petition is disposed of by directing
the respondents to consider the case of the petitioner for
grant of pension under the Old Pension Scheme and the
CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 in terms of Notification dated
04.05.2023 and Office Memorandum dated 04.05.2023
within a period of four weeks. While considering the
case, observations made above shall be kept in view.
The case of the petitioner for grant of pension under the
Old Pension Scheme shall not be rejected only for the
reason that she could not exercise her option within the
cut-off period mentioned in the Office Memorandum
dated 04.05.2023. Copy of decision so taken be
communicated to the petitioner.”
Learned
counsel
further
submits
that
the
aforesaid decision has been affirmed by the Hon’ble
Principal Division Bench in CMP(M) No.346 of 2026 (State
of Himachal Pradesh and Others Versus Reshmo Devi
and Another), decided alongwith connected matters with
lead case LPA No. 2017 of 2026 (State of Himachal
Pradesh
and
Others
Versus
Baldev
Singh)
on
09.07.2026. Relevant portion of the decision is as under:“6.
From the perusal of LPA No.217 of 2026, titled as State
of Himachal Pradesh and Others Vs. Baldev Singh, it is
clear that representation of the petitioner regarding the
option was received vide Diary No. 6003 on
19.09.2023. However, it was rejected on the grounds
that he had failed to exercise his option before the
expiry of the 60-days’ period from the date the
Government instructions were issued. Consequently,
because he submitted his option late, his request had
not been favorably considered. Resultantly, he had filed
CWP No. 948 of 2025, titled Baldev Singh Vs. State of
Himachal Pradesh and Others, which culminated in the
filing of LPA No.217 of 2026.
7.
Counsel for the appellants-State has submitted that as
per the notification dated 04.05.2023 (Annexure R-I) as
such, the cut-off period was 60 days from the date of
issuance of these instructions and the Government
servants, who had opted for the Central Civil Services
(Pension) Rules, 1972, i.e. Old Pension Scheme were
entitled to pensionary benefits only subject to depositing
of
the
Government’s
contribution
and
the
dividend/return
earned thereon to
the State
Government’s account. Because the respondents had
failed to make this deposit, the issued directions are
unjustified.
8.
The learned Single Judge had relied upon the basic
principle that the beneficial social welfare scheme could
not be defeated by technicalities, while placing reliance
upon the judgment of the Apex Court in R.C. Gupta &
Others Vs. Regional Provident Fund Commissioner,
EPFO & Others (2018) 14 SCC 80.
9.
Reliance was also placed upon the judgment passed on
an earlier occasion in CWP No. 7097 of 2024, titled as
Phoolmati Vs. State of Himachal Pradesh & Others,
dated 31.12.2024, wherein the view was taken that the
Department was required to inform Class-III and ClassIV employees of the memorandum and seek their
options within a reasonable time. If the employee failed
to do so within a reasonable time, the Department could
then proceed with the matter in accordance with law .
10. It is not disputed that the said judgment was the
subject matter of challenge by the appellants-State in
LPA No. 791 of 2025, titled State of Himachal Pradesh
and Others Vs. Phoolmati and Another, before us,
wherein we had noticed that the petitioner had
exercised her option only on 04.11.2023, though the
said exercise was required to be completed by
03.07.2023. Resultantly, we had come to the conclusion
that the cut-off date could not, as such, be strictly
applied to retired government employees who were no
longer in touch with their employer. The relevant part
read as under:“6.
7.
8.
9.
It is not disputed that even as per the terms of the
Notification dated 04.05.2023 (Annexure P-2),
whereby the Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules,
1972, were amended by the State w.e.f.
01.04.2023, certain benefits were given to
Government servants, who had already retired or
died in harness during the period w.e.f.
15.05.2003 to 31.03.2023, if such retired
Government servants or eligible family members
exercise their option to get the pensionary benefits
under the Rules from prospective date i.e. w.e.f.
01.04.2023, subject to deposit of Government
contribution and dividend return earned thereon
under the National Pension System to the State
Government. Thus, apparently, it was a beneficial
amendment as such which was also applicable to
the persons who had retired at the prior point of
time for over a period of 20 years.
In such circumstances, we are in agreement with
the view taken by the learned Single Judge that a
Class-IV employee, who had already retired as
such at the time of issuance of the Memorandum
dated 04.05.2023, who could not give an option
within the prescribed period of 60 days, as she
was not aware of the strict provisions as such of
the cut-off date, not being in touch with her
employer.
In such circumstances, we do not find any
infirmity or illegality in the order passed by the
learned Single Judge and are not inclined to
interfere in the same.
Accordingly, the appeal is dismissed alongwith
pending application(s), if any.”
11. In the present set of cases, it is to be noticed that
applications were filed in July, August, September,
2023 and by Gokal Ram on 10.02.2025. Since by that
time, the employees had already retired: Baldev Singh
on 28.02.2022, Sudershna Devi on 31.07.2017,
Reshmo Devi on 17.06.2016, Gokal Ram on
31.03.2018, and Rasan Devi on 28.02.2022 and the
Scheme was introduced later, in the year 2023.
12. It was in such circumstances that the employees had
already superannuated long time back. Therefore, it
becomes obvious that such employees were no longer in
touch with their employer, as even monthly pension
was not being paid. Consequently, taking a strict view
regarding the non-consideration on the principle of cut
off date, would not be justified in the facts and
circumstances of these cases and can be considered
arbitrary.
13. Resultantly, we are of the considered opinion that these
appeals are not liable to be considered on merits, and
the view taken by the learned Single Judge does not
suffer from any infirmity. Accordingly, the present
appeals stand dismissed accordingly.
14. The appellants-State shall necessarily quantify the
amount and ask the retired employees to deposit the
required amount within a stipulated period of two
months. If the amount is not deposited within the
specified time period, the appellants-State may pass
fresh orders.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that
the petitioner has submitted representations at Annexure
P-6 to the competent authorities for the redressal of his
grievances, however, the same has not been decided till
date. Learned counsel also submits that the petitioner
would be content in case the respondents/competent
authority(s)
are
directed
to
decide
the
aforesaid
representation in accordance with law within a fixed time
schedule. Learned counsel appearing for the respondents is
not averse to this prayer.
4.
In view of above, this writ petition is disposed of
with direction to the respondents to consider and decide the
aforesaid representation of the petitioner (Annexure P-6)
seeking pension as per the Old Pension Scheme in
accordance
with
law
keeping
in
view
the
aforesaid
decisions, within a period of three weeks from today. In
case the petitioner is held entitled to pension under the Old
Pension Scheme, the same be remitted in his favour
alongwith admissible arrears from the due date within a
period of three weeks thereafter. The decision so arrived at
shall also be communicated to the petitioner.
The writ petition stand disposed of in the above
terms, so also the pending miscellaneous application(s), if
any.
September 24, 2026
rohit
Jyotsna Rewal Dua
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review