Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP (C) No.211/2023 with
MC (WPC) No.150/2023
Date of order: 13.07.2023
JMK Coke Industry Pvt Ltd
Vs.
State of Meghalaya & ors
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sanjib Banerjee, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner
:
For the Respondents :
Ms. B. Dixit, Adv
Mr. A. Kumar, Advocate General with
Mr. N.D. Chullai, AAG
Ms. R. Colney, GA
JUDGMENT: (per the Hon’ble, the Chief Justice) (Oral)
This is a petition which has been referred to the Full Bench by a
Single Bench upon noticing that matters pertaining to illegal operation
of coke plants in the State and illegal mining and transportation of
illegally-mined coal in the State were pending before this Bench.
2.
The challenge here is to an order dated July 7, 2023 passed by
the Deputy Commissioner, East Jaintia Hills district. By such order, the
Deputy Commissioner has required the demolition of unauthorised
illegal chimneys, unauthorised coke oven plants constructed without the
requisite consent to establish, beginning July 10, 2023.
3.
The petitioner claims that the relevant order is without previous
notice to the petitioner and, as such, in complete breach of the principles
of natural justice and, accordingly, not tenable. The petitioner claims
that pursuant to a single-window clearance issued by the Director of
Commerce and Industries of the State by an order dated April 5, 2021,
the petitioner undertook the process to establish the manufacturing
facility. However, the petitioner maintains that no manufacturing
activity has been undertaken at the relevant plant. The petitioner claims
that this is an admitted position and, according to the petitioner, even
the Deputy Commissioner of the relevant district has not alleged that the
petitioner has commenced operations or has undertaken any
manufacturing activity at the plant in question.
4.
The single-window clearance obtained by the petitioner on April
5, 2021 came with several caveats. In the second paragraph of the said
letter, it was clearly indicated that the approval as granted by the said
letter was “subject to … obtaining of Consent to Establish/Consent to
Operate from the Meghalaya State Pollution Control Board …” and
several other conditions. It is evident from the Water (Prevention and
Control of Pollution) Act, 1974 that the consent to establish a
manufacturing facility is quite distinct from the consent to operate the
same. There are two stages and permission is necessary prior to
establishing a manufacturing facility. Upon establishing the facility by
adhering to the conditions indicated in the consent to establish, an
application may be made for consent to operate which is a separate
permission that may come with a separate set of conditions. Since the
scheme of the said Act permits conditions to be imposed, depending on
the geographic, environmental and other relevant considerations, a
manufacturing facility cannot be willy-nilly set up without the previous
consent to establish being obtained. Any other interpretation would do
violence with the provision and purpose thereof. It is well-nigh
impossible for a person to anticipate the conditions that would be
indicated at a subsequent stage and build the manufacturing facility
without obtaining the consent to establish by assuming that such
consent would be unconditional.
5.
The conduct of the petitioner is akin to constructing a building
without obtaining sanction or approval of the plan therefor. The Court
does not have the authority to transgress the provisions of a valid statute
and condone illegality, for that would be opposed to public policy and
provide for a recipe for anarchy and disorder.
6.
Further, the approval dated April 5, 2021, in its penultimate
paragraph, provided as follows:
“You are to note that „effective steps for implementation of the
project‟ should not be initiated without obtaining prior „Consent
to Establish‟ from the Meghalaya State Pollution Control Board
and „commencement of production‟ should not be done without
obtaining prior „Consent to Operate‟ from the above said
Board.”
Thus, the relevant order of approval expressly prohibited the petitioner
herein from taking any effective steps for implementation of the project
without obtaining the prior consent to establish from the State Pollution
Control Board. In terms of such order read with Section 25(1) of the
said Act, not a brick could have been laid nor any stone cast to set up
any manufacturing facility without the State Pollution Control Board
according the consent to the petitioner to establish the manufacturing
unit.
7.
The petitioner suggests that since the relevant approval granted
by the letter of April 5, 2021 indicated categorically in its last paragraph
that the approval thereunder would be valid for a period of two years
and since the petitioner had applied to the appropriate authorities for
consent to establish the plant, the petitioner was left with no alternative
but to commence and complete the construction of the proposed unit in
anticipation that the consent to establish and, subsequently, the consent
to operate would be issued in due course upon the petitioner complying
with all formalities in such regard. The petitioner claims that the
application for consent to establish was filed as early as in July of 2021.
8.
Pursuant to certain orders passed in proceedings pertaining to
the illegal mining of coal in the State and the illegal operation of coke
oven plants by this Court, the petitioner claims to have questioned the
propriety of an order by which the demolition of certain coke oven
plants may have been directed. In such regard, the petitioner relies on an
order of the Supreme Court passed on June 27, 2022. Such order
required the petitioners before the Supreme Court to apply before this
Court for modification of the previous interim orders and for this Court
to hear such petitioners and pass appropriate orders thereupon. During
the interregnum, the direction apparently issued by this Court for
dismantling the coke plants was directed to remain stayed.
9.
Pursuant to such order of the Supreme Court, the applications of
several persons were taken up and dealt with by this Bench by an order
of August 25, 2022. It was noticed in such order that the single-member
committee appointed by this Court in the matter relating to illegal
mining of coal in the State had recommended in its third interim report
as follows at paragraph 3.19 thereof:
“3.19 In any case, in the absence of the CTE and CTO none of
the aforesaid 26 Coke Oven Plants can start its operation, which,
if done, would be in violation of the provisions of the
environmental laws.”
10.
The relevant applications of several interveners, who had
obtained leave from the Supreme Court, was disposed of without
granting any relief to them since no order had been passed in the
relevant proceedings that prejudicially affected such persons. Indeed, no
interim order was passed in the relevant proceedings affecting the rights
of any person who may have set up a coke plant upon obtaining the
consent to establish the same; nor was any order passed in the said
proceedings that could have affected any person who had started
operating a coke plant upon obtaining consent to operate the same from
the appropriate authorities.
11.
The petitioner‟s application for consent to establish was rejected
by an order dated January 6, 2022. There does not appear to be any
challenge to such order, whether directly or otherwise.
12.
However, the petitioner maintains that in view of Section 25(7)
of the said Act of 1974, the consent to the petitioner‟s application to
establish the coke plant should be deemed to have been given. The
relevant provision, indeed, recognises that in case consent sought under
Section 25(1) of the said Act is not refused earlier, it shall be deemed to
have been given unconditionally on the expiry of four months from the
making of an application in such behalf, complete in all respects.
13.
The admitted position is that the petitioner herein neither
attempted to operate the relevant unit nor challenged the order dated
January 6, 2022 before any appropriate forum. If it was the petitioner‟s
case that by virtue of sub-section (7) of Section 25 of the said Act, the
consent was deemed to have been given, the petitioner ought to have
commenced operations at the coke plant sometime towards the end of
the year 2021; or, at the very least, applied for consent to operate upon
having obtained, by a legal fiction, the consent to establish the unit. The
petitioner‟s avowed position, however, is that the relevant unit has not
commenced its manufacturing operations.
14.
Upon the order dated January 6, 2022 coming into effect, the
petitioner had ample opportunity to challenge the same or have it set
aside whether on the ground of Section 25(7) of the Act or otherwise.
No attempt in such regard has been made by the petitioner.
Accordingly, as on date, there is no consent to establish the
manufacturing unit for the production of coke that the petitioner is in
possession of.
15.
The petitioner points out that upon the State Pollution Control
Board changing the rules of the game pertaining to the parameters
necessary to be adhered to for obtaining consent to establish a coke
plant, a similarly-placed person challenged the same in WP (C) No.259
of 2022. The petitioner also claims that in course of such petition, there
was an express challenge to the order dated January 6, 2022 and a
prayer for cancellation or setting aside thereof. No copy of the writ
petition is, however, produced.
16.
The relevant writ petition was disposed of by a judgment and
order of March 7, 2023. Paragraph 13 of the order is of relevance:
“13. In conclusion therefore, looking into the totality of the
circumstances, especially the public interest and policy involved,
while setting aside the impugned notification dated 23.12.2020,
the statement that the respondent No.2 is in the process of review
of the same, is taken into consideration by this Court, and the
respondent No.2 is accorded 8(eight) weeks‟ time from the date
of this order to complete the same. it is further provided that
during this period, there shall be a status quo on all operations of
the petitioner at its project site, who nonetheless also, is not in
possession of any valid permissions to re-start the project, as per
the materials on record.”
17.
No order was issued in respect of the refusal of consent of
January 6, 2022. Indeed, the writ court also noticed that the petitioner in
the said proceedings was not in possession of any valid permission to
restart the project.
18.
It is elementary that when a prayer is made to a court by way of
a petition and such prayer is declined, whether expressly or otherwise, it
is open to the relevant petitioner to challenge the order. There is no
submission that the order dated March 7, 2023 has been challenged.
Accordingly, since the petitioner maintains that a prayer for setting
aside the refusal to consent of January 6, 2022 was incorporated in such
petition and such prayer was not granted, the petitioner can no longer
challenge the relevant refusal to consent.
19.
More importantly, it is evident that the relevant writ petition on
which the order dated March 7, 2023 was passed, was not instituted by
this petitioner. It is difficult to imagine how a refusal of consent sought
by a specific person could have been vicariously challenged by another.
It is apparent that this petitioner did not challenge the refusal of consent
of January 6, 2022 and, as such, has accepted the position, that by virtue
of Section 25(1) of the said Act of 1974 read with the preliminary
permission granted on April 5, 2021, it could not have set up the
manufacturing unit.
20.
Thus, as at present, it is the undisputed position that an
application that was made by the petitioner in July, 2021 for consent to
establish a coke plant, has been expressly rejected by a speaking order
of January 6, 2022 and there is no challenge to such refusal of consent
or the alleged vicarious challenge thereto has not been upheld and has
failed. In such circumstances, there was no impediment on the part of
the district authorities to require demolition of the coke plant set up by
the petitioner without obtaining any consent to establish the same.
21.
Section 25(1) of the said Act of 1974 provides that subject to the
provisions of such section, no person shall, without the previous consent
of the State Board, inter alia, establish or take any steps to establish any
industry, operation or process which is likely to discharge sewage or
trade effluent. In the absence of any consent to establish, the law places
an embargo on any individual or any entity for constructing any unit or
project. The necessary consequence of acting in derogation of the
express prohibition is that anything done contrary to such provision
would have to be demolished or dismantled.
22.
A completely fallacious argument is made on behalf of the
petitioner that since the relevant provision does not authorise the
authorities to dismantle or demolish a project or unit that has been set
up, the order impugned passed for demolition of the petitioner‟s unit,
amongst others, is without jurisdiction. As indicated, it is repeated that
when a thing is prohibited by law to be done, the consequence of doing
such thing is that it has to be undone by the appropriate authorities. As a
consequence, there does not appear to have been any impediment on the
part of the Deputy Commissioner, East Jaintia Hills to pass the order of
demolition nor is there any ground to interfere with such due process of
law. Since the petitioner recklessly proceeded to engage men and
machinery and incurred expenditure to set up the manufacturing unit
despite the express prohibition in Section 25(1) of the said Act, the
petitioner cannot now be heard to complain that the investment made by
the petitioner would go down the drain. The petitioner ought to have
been conscious of the consequences before it embarked on the
foolhardy exercise of setting up the manufacturing unit in derogation of
the mandate of the statute.
23.
It must be recorded at this stage that the illegal mining of coal in
the State was stopped by orders passed by the National Green Tribunal
as early as in 2014. Proceedings were instituted against the complete
prohibition before the Supreme Court and, finally, a quietus was given
to the matter in or about the year 2019 with the Supreme Court
upholding the ban imposed by the NGT and requiring the illegallymined coal to be disposed of within reasonable time.
24.
It was in or about March, 2022 that it was noticed by this Court
that despite the Supreme Court order of 2019 upholding the prohibition
on unscientific mining of coal in this State and requiring the previously
illegally-mined coal to be disposed of within a certain time-frame, fresh
mounds of recently mined coal had blossomed all over the State,
particularly in the district of East Jaintia Hills with Khliehriat and
Rymbai as the major hub therefor. Suo motu proceedings were
instituted by this Court since it was noticed that orders passed by the
Supreme Court had not been carried out by the State machinery. Over
the last 15 months, repeated orders have been passed in the suo motu
proceedings pertaining to illegal coal-mining and the ancillary illegal
business of its transportation and use.
25.
There have been several deaths in the State upon rat-hole mining
having been resorted to. This Court has passed orders to arrest the
transportation of the illegally-mined coal. Several other matters have
been instituted in public interest before this Bench pertaining to the
illegally-mined coal in the State being presented with fabricated
documents for the purpose of export thereof through land Customs
stations in Gasuapara and elsewhere with the connivance with local
officials.
26.
In some other independent proceedings which are pending, the
names of the kingpins involved in the industry of illegal mining and the
exploitation of the small-time miners have come out. Orders have been
issued requiring the State to dismantle the entire machinery of illegal
mining of coal, its transportation and the flourishing coke oven plants
that use the illegally-mined coal for its operations. No order has been
passed by this Court for dismantling any coke plant in the State which
has been constructed upon obtaining due consent to establish the same;
nor has any order has been passed to stop the operations at any coke
plant that has commenced its functioning upon obtaining due consent to
operate from the appropriate authorities. Since the petitioner proceeded
to construct its manufacturing unit without obtaining any previous
consent to establish the same and in violation of both Section 25(1) of
the Act of 1974 and the preliminary permission that it obtained on April
5, 2021, there is no equity in favour of the petitioner for its illegally
constructed manufacturing unit to be left standing.
27.
Indeed, if the petitioner‟s unreasonable request is acceded to, it
would be opposed to public interest and would amount to condoning an
illegality that the Court scarcely has the authority to do in the face of the
clear words of prohibition in Section 25(1) of the said Act.
28.
There is no merit in the petition and the same is dismissed with
costs assessed at Rs.1 lakh, payable to the State Pollution Control Board
within six weeks from date, failing which the Board will be entitled to
recover the same as in case of arrears of land revenue with interest
running thereon at 8 per cent per annum simple beginning six week
herefrom.
29.
MC (WPC) No.150 of 2023 is disposed of.
(W. Diengdoh)
Judge
(H. S. Thangkhiew)
Judge
(Sanjib Banerjee)
Chief Justice
Meghalaya
13.07.2023
“Lam DR-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review