Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT I N D O R E
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE VIVEK RUSIA
&
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE ANIL VERMA
CRIMINAL APPEAL No.439 of 2011
BETWEEN:1. JITENDRA S/O JAIRAM, AGED ABOUT 30
YEARS, OCCUPATION: LABOUR, R/O: VILL.
PIVWADYA,TEH.
&
DISTT.
INDORE
(MADHYA PRADESH)
2. DINESH S/O JAIRAM, AGED ABOUT 30
YEARS, OCCUPATION: LABOUR, R/O:
VILLAGE
PIVWADYA,
TEHSIL
AND
DISTRICT INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
3. SATISH S/O JAIRAM, AGED ABOUT 25
YEARS, OCCUPATION: LABOUR, R/O:
VILLAGE
PIVWADYA,
TEHSIL
AND
DISTRICT INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
4. RAMSINGH S/O BHILAJI, AGED ABOUT 58
YEARS, R/O: VILLAGE PIVWADYA, TEHSIL
AND
DISTRICT
INDORE
(MADHYA
PRADESH)
5. SHEKHAR S/O HARAKCHAND, AGED
ABOUT
YEARS,
OCCUPATION:
AGRICULTURE, R/O: VILLAGE PIVWADYA
TEHSIL AND DISTRICT INDORE (MADHYA
PRADESH)
.....APPELLANTS
(BY SHRI BRIJENDRA KUMAR MISHRA - ADVOCATE)
AND
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH GOVT.
THRU. P.S. KHUDEL, DISTT. INDORE
(MADHYA PRADESH)
Signed by: ANUSHREE
PANDEY
Signing time: 19-01-2024
17:29:23
.....RESPONDENT
(BY SHRI AMIT RAWAL – GOVERNMENT ADVOCATE)
Reserved on
:
11/01/2024
Pronounced on
:
18/01/2024
This appeal Coming on for admission this day, Justice Anil
Verma passed the following:
JUDGMENT
The appellants have preferred present criminal appeal under
Section 374 of Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (in short 'Cr.P.C.')
being aggrieved by the impugned judgment of conviction and sentence
dated 11/03/2011 passed by IX Additional Sessions Judge, Indore,
(M.P.) in Sessions Trial No.256/2008, whereby the appellants have been
convicted for the offence as mentioned herein below.
2. Appellant No.4 Ramsingh has been convicted for the offence:
Offence u/S
Sentence Awarded
Fine
In default of Fine
(RI)
147 of IPC
1 year R.I.
Rs.100.00
2 months
323/149 of IPC
6 moths R.I.
Rs.100.00
2 months
302/149 of IPC
Life Imprisonment
Rs.100.00
2 months
450 of IPC
5 years R.I.
Rs.100.00
2 months
365 of IPC
3 years R.I.
Rs.100.00
2 months
364 of IPC
5 years R.I.
Rs.100.00
2 months
201 of IPC
2 years R.I.
NIL
-
3. During the pendency of this appeal appellant Nos.1 Jitendra, 2
Dinesh, 3 Satish and 5 Shekhar have filed different applications that they
have completed their awarded jail sentence and does not wish to pursue
Signed by: ANUSHREE
PANDEY
Signing time: 19-01-2024
17:29:23
this appeal and prays for withdrawal of the same, therefore, their prayers
are allowed and appeal was dismissed as withdrawn in respect of
appellants Jitendra, Dinesh, Satish and Shekhar vide order dated
18.07.2022, 13.12.2022, 22.09.2022 and 20.03.2023 respectively.
4. The facts of the case in brief are that appellant on 24.12.2007, at
about 8:00 PM, complainant Gulab Bai alongwith her sons namely
Ashok, Rajesh, Brajesh, Bhim and Ajay were having their evening meal
inside the house, at that time, present appellant alongwith other coaccused persons entered into the house of complainant armed with Lathi
and sword and started assaulting upon Ashok and Rajesh. When
complainant Gulab Bai tried to intervene, then she was also assaulted by
elder son of Jairam by means of lathi, due to which she got injuries on
her right hand, head and legs. Thereafter, the accused persons took
Ashok in Maruti Van bearing registration No.MP-04-V-6000 and went
towards Indore. Complainant Gulab Bai lodged an FIR at P.S. Khudel
and on the next date dead body of the Ashok was found nearby Tincha
Phal (Fall). Dehati Nalishi was lodged by Siddu (PW-1) and merg was
registered. Dead body of the deceased was sent for postmortem, which
was conducted by Dr. A.K. Lanjewar. Dr. D.K. Sharma and Dr. Ashutosh
Verma conducted MLC of the victim Rajesh and Gulabbai. During the
investigation, a wooden stick was recovered from the possession of the
appellant Ramsingh and some other weapons have been recovered from
the possession of the other co-accused persons on the basis of the
discovery statement made by the appellant and other co-accused persons.
Accused persons were arrested and seized articles were sent to FSL for
its chemical analysis.
Signed by: ANUSHREE
PANDEY
Signing time: 19-01-2024
17:29:23
5. After completion of investigation, charge-sheet was filed
against the accused / appellant before the Additional Chief Judicial
Magistrate, Indore, who has committed the case to the Court of Sessions,
Indore, which was later on transferred to the IX Additional Sessions
Judge, Indore. Prosecution examined as many as 22 witnesses, while
defence examined only one witness namely Manohar Shailani (DW-1).
Learned trial Court after considering evidence available on record
convicted, the appellant for the offence and sentenced him as mentioned
herein above. Hence, appellant has preferred this appeal.
6. Learned counsel for the appellant submits that appellant
Ramsingh is innocent and he has been falsely implicated in this matter.
Appellant is neither named in the FIR nor in the statement of
complainant under Section 161 of Cr.P.C., but introduced first time in
the court statements. Body of the deceased was recovered from the
Tincha Fall at 12:00 PM, which is prior to recovery, which itself shows
that FIR in the instant case is ante times and doctored with deliberation
in order to implicate the appellant. Impugned judgment passed by the
trial Court is neither legal nor proper nor correct. No blood was found
inside the house of the appellant. Prosecution has failed to prove the case
beyond reasonable doubt against the appellant Ramsingh. There are
material contradictions, omissions and variations with regard to the
manner of incident including which accused was assaulted in what order
and by what weapon, therefore, on the basis of the aforesaid statement of
the Gulab Bai and other prosecution witnesses not appears to be
trustworthy. Hence, he prays that appeal be allowed and appellant be
acquitted from all the charges.
Signed by: ANUSHREE
PANDEY
Signing time: 19-01-2024
17:29:23
7. Per-contra, learned counsel for the respondent / State opposes
the prayer by supporting the impugned judgment by submitting that the
learned trial Court has rightly recorded the conviction of the appellant
Ramsingh on the basis of cogent evidence available on record and same
does not call for any interference.
8. Heard learned counsel for both the parties and perused the
entire record of trial Court with due care.
9. In the instant case first of all it should be considered as whether
the death of the deceased was homicidal in nature or not?
10. Dr. Anil Kumar Lanjewar (PW-19), who had performed the
postmortem of the deceased. According to him, total 12 injuries were
found all over the body of deceased. During the internal examination it
is found that there was fracture in Pelvic bone, second rib and liver was
found also ruptured. The postmortem report is (Ex.P-44) and as per
report, doctor's opinion death of the deceased was due to shock and
hemorrhage as a result of the injuries to the vital part and death of the
deceased was homicidal in nature.
11. Appellant Ramsingh and other co-accused persons did not ask
any question during the cross-examination of the Dr. Anil Kumar
Lanjewar. Therefore, in absence of any challenge to the postmortem
(Ex.P-44) and statement of Dr. Anil Kumar Lanjewar, we have no doubt
to accept the autopsy report and the statement of Dr. Anil Kumar
Lanjewar (PW-19) that death of the deceased was homicidal in nature.
So fat as the act of the appellant Ramsingh is concerned. Injured Gulab
Bai (PW-4) deposed in her statement that at the time of incident at about
7:30 to 7:40 PM when she was at her home alongwith Kumari Pooja,
Signed by: ANUSHREE
PANDEY
Signing time: 19-01-2024
17:29:23
Santosh, Rajesh and Vijay at that time appellant Ramsingh armed with
an axe alongwith the other co-accused Jitendra, Satish, Ramsingh and
Kalu entered into her house and started beating his son Ashok by using
sword, wooden stick and Faliya. She tried to save his son Ashok, then
co-accused Satish gave blow of wooden stick to her. Thereafter, accused
persons dragged the Ashok in their vehicle and fled away from the spot.
Rajesh (PW-5) also corroborated the statement of Gulab Bai (PW-4) by
stating that appellant alongwith other co-accused persons came there
armed with different weapons and started beating the complainant and
her sons and they also murdered the Ashok.
12. Injured Vijay (PW-6) categorically stated in his statement that
at the time of incident Ashok was beaten by Satish, Dinesh, Jairam,
Kalu. Rakesh was beaten by Jitendra and appellant Ramsingh was
beaten by means of wooden stick, due to which he sustained certain
injuries, then accused persons dragged the Ashok in their Maruti Van and
thrown his dead body nearby Tincha Fall. Santosh Parmar (PW-8) and
Leela Bai (PW-9) also deposed in the same manner.
13. Kumari Pooja (PW-10), who was the child witness at that time
categorically stated that accused persons came on a vehicle Maruti van
in the house of his uncle Ashok and took Ashok in their vehicle and
accused persons beaten the Ashok by means of Faliya and sword, due to
which he sustained various injuries over his neck and other parts of the
body.
14. It is remarkable that FIR (Ex.P-14) was lodged by the Gulab
Bai (PW-4) and statement of the Gulab Bai under Section 161 of Cr.P.C.
was also recorded, but appellant Ramsingh neither named in the FIR nor
Signed by: ANUSHREE
PANDEY
Signing time: 19-01-2024
17:29:23
in the statement of complainant Gulab Bai under Section 161 of Cr.P.C.
It is a serious lapse, on the basis of the aforesaid participation of the
appellant Ramsingh in the instant case appears to be very doubtful.
15. So far as the Court statement of the Gulab Bai (PW-4) is
concerned, she categorically stated that Ramsingh was armed with an
axe, but no axe was recovered from the possession of the appellant as
per the statement of Inspector Daulat Singh Ranawat (PW-22). Only
wooden stick has been recovered from the possession of the appellant
Ramsingh by seizure memo (Ex.P-4), therefore, statement of the Gulab
Bai (PW-4) appears to be doubtful and trial Court has committed error
on relying upon the statement of Gulab Bai.
16. So far as the other witnesses are concerned. Although Rajesh
(PW-5), Vijay (PW-6), Santosh (PW-8) Leela Bai (PW-9) and Ku. Pooja
(PW-10) made some omnibus allegations levelled against the appellant
Ramsingh, but they had not categorically stated what the actual act done
by the appellant Ramsingh, therefore, the statement of all these
witnesses against the appellant Ramsingh appears to be vague and very
doubtful.
17. It is also noteworthy that as per the prosecution story a
wooden stick was recovered from the possession of the appellant
Ramsingh which is sent for chemical examination, but FSL report (Ex.P59) is not supported the case of the prosecution. Apart from the above,
nothing is available on record that appellant Ramsingh has any previous
enmity with the deceased and other victim persons, therefore,
prosecution has also failed to prove the motive of crime in respect of the
appellant Ramsingh. Thus, in the law of the aforesaid discussions, we
Signed by: ANUSHREE
PANDEY
Signing time: 19-01-2024
17:29:23
are of the considered opinion that the entire foundation of the
prosecution has never established and the prosecution has failed to prove
the case beyond all reasonable doubts, therefore, the conviction of the
appellant Ramsingh cannot be sustained.
18. We, therefore, allow the appeal and set aside the conviction
and sentence recorded against the Ramsingh under Sections 147,
323/149, 302/149, 450, 365, 364 and 201 of IPC.
19. The appellant is in jail. He should be released forthwith, if not
required in any other case.
20. Disposal of the property shall be as per the order of the trial
Court.
21. Let a copy of this judgment be sent alongwith the record to the
concerned trial Court for information and necessary action.
Certified copy as per rules.
(VIVEK RUSIA)
J U D G E
Anushree
Signed by: ANUSHREE
PANDEY
Signing time: 19-01-2024
17:29:23
(ANIL VERMA)
J U D G E
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review