Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:3600-DB
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
L.P.A. No.201 of 2025
----1. Jharkhand Urja Utpadan Nigam Limited through its Managing
Director, officiating at Engineering Building, P.O. & P.S.
Dhurwa, District Ranchi.
2. The Managing Director, Jharkhand Urja Utpadan Nigam
Limited, officiating at Engineering Building, P.O. & P.S.
Dhurwa, District Ranchi.
3. The General Manager, Jharkhand Urja Utpadan Nigam
Limited, officiating at Engineering Building, P.O. & P.S.
Dhurwa, District Ranchi.
4. The Deputy General Manager, Jharkhand Urja Utpadan Nigam
Limited, officiating at Engineering Building, P.O. & P.S.
Dhurwa, District Ranchi.
5. The Senior Manager, (F & A), Jharkhand Urja Utpadan Nigam
Limited, officiating at Engineering Building, P.O. & P.S.
Dhurwa, District Ranchi.
.......... Appellants.
-VersusShakuntala Sharma, W/o. Late Raghav Sharma, resident of Flat
No.101, Om Vihar Apartment, Near Gas Godown, Amethia Nagar,
P.O. & P. S. Namkum, District Ranchi, Jharkhand.
.......... Respondent.
----CORAM :
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH SHANKAR
----For the Appellants :
Mr. Rajiv Ranjan, Sr. Advocate
Mr. Ashok Kumar Yadav, Sr. SC-I
For the Respondent:
Mr. Prabhat Singh, Advocate
----Order No.07
Date: 10.02.2026
1.
Heard Mr. Rajiv Ranjan, Senior Advocate who appears along with
Mr. Ashok Kumar Yadav, Senior Standing Counsel for the
appellants and Mr. Prabhat Singh, learned counsel for the
respondent.
2.
This appeal challenges the learned Single Judge’s order dated 5 th
July, 2024 allowing the respondent’s W.P.(S) No.220 of 2024 and
quashing the recovery notice in an amount of Rs.11,09,468/allegedly towards excess family pension received by the
respondent.
2026:JHHC:3600-DB
3.
Mr. Rajiv Ranjan, learned Sr. Advocate for the appellants
submitted that consequent upon the demise of the respondent’s
husband (Late Raghav Sharma), Assistant Executive Engineer,
PTPS, in harness, in terms of the then existing scheme, the
respondent was sanctioned and paid full pension. He submitted
that in terms of the scheme, this full pension was payable only
for ten years. After the expiry of ten years, the respondent would
be entitled to a normal family pension corresponding to
approximately about 40% of the full pension amount. He
submitted that in this case, post 2018, perhaps on account of
inadvertence or oversight, the respondent continued to be paid
the full pension until April 2023. He pointed out that in addition
to a full family pension, the respondent’s daughter was also given
a compassionate appointment.
4.
Mr Rajiv Ranjan submitted that, upon realisation in 2023, the
excess payments were immediately stopped and a notice was
issued for the recovery of the excess amount paid to the
respondent for the years 2018-2023, amounting to Rs.
11,09,468/-. He submitted that there was no dispute about the
excess payments. He relied on the indemnity bond furnished by
the respondent, at pages 95 to 97 of the paper book and
submitted that the same contained an undertaking by the
respondent that she would take the responsibility of settling
all/any claims. He submitted that the respondent was now bound
by the undertaking and could not resist the recovery of the excess
payments. He also pointed out that the appellants were not
2026:JHHC:3600-DB
recovering the entire excess payment in a lump sum, but by way
of easy instalments of Rs. 4,000/- per month.
5.
Mr. Rajiv Ranjan submitted that the learned Single Judge erred
in relying upon the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the
case of State of Punjab Vs. Rafiq Masih, (2015)4 SCC 334,
since this decision was later explained by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in the case of High Court of Punjab & Haryana & Ors.
Vs. Jagdev Singh, (2016)14 SCC 267. He submitted that in
terms of the latter decision, if the officer to whom payment was
made in the first instance was clearly placed on notice that any
payment found to have been made in excess would be required
to be refunded, then, such officer, was bound by such
undertaking and could not resist the recovery by relying upon the
decision rendered in the case of Rafiq Masih (Supra).
6.
Mr Prabhat Singh, learned counsel for the respondent, defended
the impugned order based on the reasoning reflected therein. He
submitted that this was not a case of payments made in
connection with any revised pay scales. He submitted that there
was no undertaking furnished by the respondent, and the
indemnity bond was only to indemnify the respondent against any
claims from any other heirs/descendants subsequently.
7.
Mr Prabhat Singh submitted that no fraud or misrepresentation
was alleged against the respondent. Therefore, he submitted that
it would be completely harsh and inequitable to sustain any
recoveries against the respondent-widow. He, therefore, urged
the dismissal of this appeal.
2026:JHHC:3600-DB
8.
Rival contentions now fall for our determination.
9.
In this case, the issue is whether the recovery of Rs.11,09,468/towards excess family pension paid to the respondent for the
period 2018-2023 should be allowed.
10.
Admittedly, there is no allegation of fraud or misrepresentation
against the respondent. Even the appellants submitted that the
excess payment for about five years was due to inadvertence or
oversight by the appellant’s employee. There is no record of any
action against the appellant’s employee responsible for this
inadvertence or oversight.
11.
Further, the error has been corrected post-2023, and the
respondent is receiving a family pension of approximately 40% of
the full pension.
12.
In Chandi Prasad Uniyal & Ors. Vs. State of Uttarakhand
& Ors., (2012)8 SCC 417 and in Rafiq Masih (Supra), it is
held that recovery from employees, when the excess payment
has been made for a period in excess of five years, before the
order or recovery is issued, would be impermissible in law.
Further, this decision also holds that in any other case, where the
Court concludes that the recovery is made from the employee, it
would be iniquitous, harsh or arbitrary to such an extent as would
far outweigh the equitable balance of the employer’s right to
recover.
13.
In this case, we are not directly concerned with the appellant’s
employee. The employee, who was the husband of the
respondent, died in harness. Under the scheme, the respondent
2026:JHHC:3600-DB
was paid the family pension. Therefore, the position of the widow
and her children must be considered when balancing the equities
in a situation of this nature. This is more so because there is no
allegation of any fraud or misrepresentation being practised by
the respondent-widow.
14.
In Jagdev Singh (Supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the
context of Rafiq Masih (Supra) explained that the proposition
that recovery from retired employees or employees who are due
to retired within one year, of the order of recovery will not apply
in case of an officer to whom the payment was made in the first
instance was clearly placed on notice that any payment found to
have been made in excess would be required to be refunded. The
Officer furnished an undertaking upon opting for the revised pay
scale and, therefore, was bound by it.
15.
In the present case, we are not concerned with any revision of
pay scales. But assuming that this distinction is irrelevant, this is
also not a case where the respondent has furnished any
undertaking comparable to that which was furnished by the
officer in the case of Jagdev Singh (Supra).
16.
Here, the respondent has merely furnished an indemnity bond,
the operative portion of which reads as follows:“AND WHEREAS the obligor is entitled for the best
interest and for the benefit of the said minors of
deceased employee of the Board and responsible for
the money for which payment to be truly and faithfully
made resultant after death of deceased employee of the
Board on account of terminal benefit. NOW THIS
CONDITION OF ABOVE INDEMNI BOND or obligation is
such that in the event of any claim being at any time
2026:JHHC:3600-DB
hereafter made to the proceeds of the said accounts by
any other person or persons whomsoever if, take the
responsibility of settling all/any claim referred against
Board (Patratu Thermal Power Station) by the any of
heir/descendant subsequently and the obligor shall
forthwith pay or cause to be paid to the Board the entire
amount with an interest applicable and further pay for
all losses, damages costs and expenses which the Board
reasonably incur or suffer.”
17.
The above indemnity bond can hardly be regarded as an
undertaking comparable to the undertaking considered in the
case of Jagdev Singh (Supra). This undertaking is a routine
undertaking to indemnify the employer should any claim be raised
by any other legal heirs/descendants subsequently. This
indemnity bond will not apply to the employer's payment of family
pension, even if excess payments were made due to inadvertence
not attributable to any fraud or misrepresentation by the
beneficiary. Therefore, based upon the above indemnity bond or
the undertaking contained therein, the principle in Jagdev Singh
(Supra) cannot be applied.
18.
This is a case where recovery is sought from the widow of the
employee who died in harness. This is also a case in which
recovery is sought for a period exceeding five years prior to the
issuance of the order of recovery. This is also a case where it
would be iniquitous and harsh to sustain the recovery. The
equitable considerations would far outweigh the equitable
balance of the appellants’ employer’s right to recover.
2026:JHHC:3600-DB
19.
For all the above reasons, we see no good grounds to interfere
with the view taken by the learned Single Judge and the direction
for quashing the recovery notice.
20.
As a consequence, we dismiss this appeal without any order for
costs.
(M. S. Sonak, C.J.)
(Rajesh Shankar, J.)
10th February, 2026
Sanjay/Rahul
N.A.F.R.
Uploaded on 12.02.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review