The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
21. 01.2026, is misconceived. As noticed, the order dated 21.01.2026 records the statement/undertaking of the liquidator to the effect that it shall move the NCLAT seeking to set aside the e-auction already conducted and seeks permission for conduct of a re-auction of the concerned assets with a reserve price of Rs.54,00,00,000/- (Rs.54 Crores). The liquidator would be well within its right to move such an application given the facts and circumstances. The order dated 21.01.2026 merely reflects what has transpired in the present proceedings. It shall be for the NCLAT to consider the matter further and pass appropriate orders. Any objections that may be raised by the applicant in CM. APPL. 5867/2026 (or by any other party) shall necessarily be considered by the NCLAT.
21. During the course of hearing on 02.02.2026, the aforementioned bank draft of Rs. 54,00,00,000/- (Rupees Fifty Four Crores) was handed over to the liquidator. The utilisation/encashment of the same shall be subject to the orders of the NCLAT. While moving an application seeking conduct of a reauction, the liquidator shall apprise the NCLAT of the aforesaid bank draft furnished by the petitioner. In case it is not possible for the liquidator to deposit the said amount of Rs.54 Crores in an interest bearing FDR (and subject to further order/s of NCLAT), it shall be open for the petitioner to seek return of the Bank Draft with an undertaking to re-furnish the same as and when required and/or for the purpose of the re-auction process.
22. The present petition stands disposed of in the above terms. Pending application/s also stand disposed of.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Judgment pronounced on: 11.02.2026
+
CONT.CAS(C) 1819/2025, CM APPL. 5867/2026 & 6240/2026
JFC FINANCE (INDIA) LIMITED
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Jayant Mehta, Sr. Advocate with
Ms. Maneesha Dhir, Ms. Varsha
Banerjee & Ms. Udita Singh,
Advocates.
versus
ARVIND GARG LIQUIDATOR
OF MOSER BAER SOLAR LTD & ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Kamal Mehta, Mr. Syed Sumain
Ali, Mr. Mohnish Singh & Mr.
Jaismeen
Sharma,
Advocates
alongwith R-1/Liquidator.
Mr. Rajeev Mehra, Sr. Adv.
alongwith Mr. Shaunak Kashyap, Mr.
Kartikeya Gautam and Mr. Vikram
Kalra, Advs. for applicant in CM
APPL. 5867/2026 & 6240/2026.
Mr. Rudra Paliwal, Govt Pleader.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SACHIN DATTA
JUDGMENT
1.
The present petition has been filed by the petitioner alleging wilful
disobedience by respondent no.1 of the undertaking/statement made by the
said respondent before this Court, as recorded in the order dated 09.04.2025
passed in W.P.(C) 4634/2025. The said order dated 09.04.2025 records as
under:
“1. In the present petition, the petitioner entity seeks to participate in
the process of sale of M/s Moser Baer Solar Ltd. (hereinafter referred
KUMAR PATEL
15:29:59
CONT.CAS(C) 1819/2025
to as ‘MBSL’) as a going concern under the provisions of the
Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016.
2. It is submitted that the petitioner was one of the shortlisted
participant in the process of sale of MBSL as a going concern, but the
right of participation has been virtually taken away from the petitioner
on account of the fact that the petitioner did not receive any link or
instruction/notification for participating in the pre-qualification
proceedings.
3. It is further submitted that the petitioner had fulfilled all mandatory
requirements of registering as a buyer, including deposit of Earnest
Money Deposit (EMD) and uploading all relevant documents.
However, it is contended that it was only in the absence of any specific
instructions/notifications and/or a link to participate in the prequalification proceedings that the petitioner could not fulfil the alleged
requirements and has been, therefore, virtually rendered disqualified
on erroneous ground.
4. It is pointed out that the petitioner had e-filed an application before
the NCLT raising the aforesaid grievance and seeking appropriate
prayer/s. However, since the NCLT is under recess and shall be
reopening only on 15.04.2025, the present petition has been filed by
the petitioner seeking urgent relief.
5. Learned counsel for respondent no.1 (liquidator), while refuting the
contentions of the petitioner on merits, submits that since the NCLT
shall be reopening only on 15.04.2025 (whereupon the matter is
expected to be taken by the NCLT), the respondent no.1 shall not take
any further steps pursuant to the e-auction process for the sale of
MBSL (except for conducting internal meetings with the
banks/stakeholders) till 21.04.2025.
6. Respective counsels for the parties are in agreement that it shall be
for the NCLT to pass appropriate orders on the application already
filed by the petitioner before the NCLT.
7. Accordingly, taking the aforesaid statement of the respondent no.1
on record, the present petition is disposed of.”
2.
The concerned auction was conducted on 08.04.2025 and the
aforesaid order dated 09.04.2025, incorporating the consent undertaking,
came to be issued in the immediate aftermath thereof.
KUMAR PATEL
15:29:59
CONT.CAS(C) 1819/2025
3.
Vide order dated 21.04.2025, the National Company Law Tribunal
(NCLT) ordered as under:
KUMAR PATEL
15:29:59
CONT.CAS(C) 1819/2025
4.
On 19.11.2025, the petitioner’s application bearing no. IA-1746/2025
(seeking quashing of the e-auction proceedings and other prayers), came to
be dismissed by the NCLT. The NCLT found that the petitioner had not
adhered to the auction procedure/process specified by the auction platform,
M/s Baanknet.
5.
On 21.11.2025, in an appeal filed by the petitioner, the National
Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) directed that “Status quo as
existing today with regard to assets in question be maintained”.
6.
The present contempt petition came to be filed on 29.11.2025.
Essentially, the petitioner has sought to urge that the respondent/liquidator
has wilfully and deliberately disobeyed the undertaking incorporated in the
aforesaid order dated 09.04.2025 passed by this Court, inasmuch as he
allegedly acted in a partisan manner and took unwarranted steps in
contravention of the undertaking given to this Court.
7.
In the “process information document” issued by the liquidator for the
auction sale of the concerned assets, the following steps were delineated:
KUMAR PATEL
15:29:59
CONT.CAS(C) 1819/2025
8.
On a prima facie conspectus, this Court finds some credence in the
apprehension/s of the petitioner that the liquidator has acted with undue
haste in the matter, as evinced from the fact that one of the agenda items of
the 23rd Meeting of the “Consultative Committee of Stakeholders”
(hereinafter “CCS”),
convened on 15.04.2025, was “To Advise the
Liquidator in Accordance With Regulation 31(A)(I)(B) of IBBI (Liquidation
Process) Regulation, 2016 on Sale of Corporate Debtor as a Going Concern
KUMAR PATEL
15:29:59
CONT.CAS(C) 1819/2025
On As Is What, As Is How Is and Without Basis”. The relevant extract of
the said Minutes is as under:
“AGENDA ITEM no. 14–
to Advise the Liquidator in
accordance with Regulation 31A(1)(B) of IBBI (Liquidation
Process) regulations, 2016 on sale of corporate debtor as a ‘going
concern’ on ‘as is where is, as is what is, as is how is and without
recourse basis’.
14. Attention of the Committee was drawn towards Section 35(2) of
the Insolvency & Bankruptcy Code, 2016 Regulations 31A(1),
31A(9) and Schedule I under Regulation 33 of the Insolvency and
Bankruptcy Board of India (Liquidation Process) Regulations,
2016.
The Liquidator informed the Committee that at the E-auction held
on the Baanknet Auction platform, five bidders had bid for
acquisition of Liquidation estate. Consortium of Mr. Girish Jain
and Chemester Food Industry Private Limited had emerged as the
highest bidder with a bid of Rs.28.27 Crore (Twenty-eight Crore
Twenty-seven Lakh only).
In accordance with clause 12 of Schedule-I of IBBI (Liquidation
Process) Regulations, 2016, the highest bidder had been invited to
provide balance sale consideration within a period of ninety days,
provided that payments made after thirty days shall attract interest
at the rate of twelve per cent.
After declaring the highest bidder, the Liquidator had conducted
due diligence and had verified the eligibility of the highest bidder.
The Liquidator presented the auction results, details of highest
bidder, and the due diligence conducted on it to the Consultative
Committee of Stakeholders. The Committee was informed that the
liquidator shall declare the highest bidder as the successful bidder
or reject such bid, after consultation with the Consultative
Committee of Stakeholders, in accordance with the advice received
from the Committee.
The Committee is requested to advise the Liquidator on declaring
the highest bidder at the E-auction held on April 08, 2025, i.e. the
Consortium of Mr. Girish Jain and Chemester Food Industry
Private Limited as the Successful Bidder or to reject the Bid by
voting on the following resolution:
“Resolution:
KUMAR PATEL
15:29:59
CONT.CAS(C) 1819/2025
To consider and if found fit, to pass with or without
modification the following Resolution:
“The Consultative Committee of Stakeholders of corporate
debtor Moser Baer Solar Limited in liquidation, hereby
resolves to advise the Liquidator to declare ‘Consortium of
Mr. Girish Jain and Chemester Food Industry Private
Limited’; the highest bidder at e-auction held on April 08,
2025, for sale of corporate debtor Moser Baer Solar
Limited in liquidation as a ‘Going Concern’, on ‘as is
where is’, ‘as is what is’, ‘as is how is’ & ‘without
recourse’ basis; as the Successful Bidder.”
Upon voting on the Resolution all six members present at the
meeting, i.e., Punjab National Bank, State Bank of India, Indian
Overseas Bank, Central Bank of India, Bank of Baroda and Union
Bank of India, voted in favour of the Resolution. There was no vote
against the Resolution and no absentation. Thus, all six members
of the Committee present at the meeting, representing 100.00% of
the members present and voting, 82.74% of secured financial debt
and 82.28% of total admitted claims advised the Liquidator to
declare the highest bidder at the e-auction held on April 08, 2025
as the Successful Bidder.
The Liquidator accepted the Committee’s advice and agreed to
comply with directions of the Committee.”
9.
The liquidator proceeded to conclude the necessary regulatory
exercise and obtain the requisite approvals to clear the decks for declaring
the “successful bidder”. This was done without even waiting for the
outcome of the judicial proceedings then pending before the NCLT, and
despite the statement/undertaking recorded in the aforesaid order dated
08.04.2025. It appears, prima facie, that obtaining such regulatory
permissions/decisions and putting to vote the proposal of the liquidator to
declare a particular consortium as the “successful bidder” went way beyond
the mere conduct of “internal meetings”, and as such, ran afoul of the
statement/undertaking of the liquidator incorporated in the order dated
09.04.2025.
KUMAR PATEL
15:29:59
CONT.CAS(C) 1819/2025
10.
It also transpires that immediately after the NCLT passed the order
dated 19.11.2025, virtually before the ink was dry on the said order, the
liquidator purported to declare the “successful bidder”. This was done prior
to the matter being considered by the NCLAT on 21.11.2025, on which date
the NCLAT directed that status quo shall be maintained with regard to the
assets in question.
11.
It is in the above context that apprehension/s arise as to the undue
haste with which the liquidator allegedly acted. However, this Court is
refraining from rendering findings impinging upon the conduct of the
liquidator, in view of the developments that have taken place during the
pendency of the present petition.
12.
On 21.01.2026, the following order was passed by this Court:
“1. During the course of hearing, learned Senior Counsel for the
petitioner, inter-alia, submits, on instructions, that the petitioner is
willing to offer a sum of Rs.54 crores in respect of the very same assets
which have been sought to be e-auctioned by the respondent/
liquidator for a sum of Rs.28.27 crores.
2. Learned counsel for the Liquidator states, on instructions from the
liquidator (who is present in Court), that in the event of the petitioner
furnishing a bank draft for the aforesaid amount, the liquidator shall
request the NCLAT (in the pending proceedings), to set aside the eauction already conducted, and seek permission for conduct of reauction of the concerned assets with a reserve price of Rs.54 crores.
The said statement is taken on record.
3. This Court approves of the aforesaid course inasmuch as the same
will maximise the value of the ‘liquidation estate’.
4. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that a bank draft for a
sum of Rs.54 crores, drawn in favour of ‘Moser Baer Solar Limited-in
liquidation’ shall be furnished on the next date of hearing.
5. List on 29.01.2026 in the category of ‘supplementary matters’.
KUMAR PATEL
15:29:59
CONT.CAS(C) 1819/2025
6. Copy of this order be given dasti under the signature of Court
Master.”
13.
As can be seen, the aforesaid order records the statement/undertaking
of the liquidator that the petitioner is willing to offer a sum of Rs.54 Crores
(in respect of the very same assets which have been sought to be e-auctioned
for a sum of Rs.28.27 Crores). The said order further records the
unequivocal stand of the liquidator that in the event of the petitioner
furnishing a bank draft for the said amount, the liquidator shall request the
NCLAT (in the pending proceedings) to set aside the e-auction already
conducted and seek permission for the conduct of a re-auction of the
concerned assets with a reserve price of Rs.54 Crores.
14.
Pursuant to the above, on 02.02.2026, a bank draft of Rs.54 Crores
was furnished by the petitioner. The particulars of the same are reproduced
as under:
DD Sr. No. : 295813
Dated: 21.01.2026
Amount: 54,00,00,000/Drawn on: Axis Bank, New Delhi Branch (IFS Code: UTIB0000007)
15.
In the above context, although it has transpired in these proceedings
that the reserve price for the concerned asset/s was woefully inadequate and
the auction process was also riddled with controversy, considering that the
liquidator has sought to effect a course correction in terms of the statement
recorded in the order dated 21.01.2026, this Court does not find it necessary
to delve deeper into the aforementioned allegations of the petitioner.
16.
It is noticed that in terms of the ‘Process Information Document’
dated 06.03.2025 issued by the Liquidator for the e-auction held on
KUMAR PATEL
15:29:59
CONT.CAS(C) 1819/2025
08.04.2025, the Liquidator is duly empowered and reserves the right to
reject, at any stage, “all or any of the bidder or Bid” without assigning any
reason whatsoever. The relevant extracts of the ‘Process Information
Document’ are reproduced hereinbelow:
"1.8. The issue of this Process Information Document does not imply
that the Liquidator is bound to select a Bidder or to appoint the Bidder
with the highest Financial Proposal as Successful Bidder and the
Liquidator reserves the right to reject all or any of the Bidders or Bids
without assigning any reason whatsoever or assuming any cost"……
IX……(iv) It is clarified that the decision for selection of the
Successful Bidder(s) will be solely at the discretion of the Liquidator,
with the aim of maximizing the value received for the Corporate
Debtor/ the assets of the Corporate Debtor, through the Bid Process,
without any requirement to provide any reasoning or justification to
any Bidder(s).
4.2… (c) annul the Bid Process and reject any/all Bids for any reason,
at any point of time, including if considered unsatisfactory or
commercially unacceptable or below Reserve Price as determined by
the Liquidator, in its sole discretion, without any obligation to provide
reasons or justification, and if deemed fit move to other methods of
liquidation as per Regulation 32(a) to (f) of the Code.
(d) restart the Bid Process, and invite fresh bids either on the Auction
Date itself or any subsequent date with prior intimation of the same.
The Liquidator reserves the right to conduct subsequent rounds of the
E-Auction sale with reduction in Reserve Price, as per the Code and
Liquidation Regulations.”
17.
The aforesaid extracts of the ‘Process Information Document’
governing the auction process recognizes the rights and powers of the
Liquidator to annul the auction process and initiate a re-auction, inter-alia to
maximize the value received in the liquidation proceedings. Inherently, the
auction process is also within the regulatory purview of the NCLT and the
NCLAT. It appears that the offer of the petitioner to the tune of Rs. 54
Crores, for the very asset/s which have been sought to be e-auctioned for
KUMAR PATEL
15:29:59
CONT.CAS(C) 1819/2025
Rs.28.27 Crores, and the stand now taken by the liquidator that a re-auction
shall be conducted with reserve price of Rs.54 Crores, is in the interest of
maximization of the value of the liquidation estate. The same will also enure
to the benefit of the concerned public sector banks that constitute the
“Consultative Committee of Stakeholders”.
18.
Needless to say, it shall be for the NCLAT to consider the matter
further in the above conspectus, and pass appropriate orders in the pending
appeal. Further, the previous stand/decision/s taken by the liquidator (in the
circumstances enumerated hereinabove) shall not come in the way of the
liquidator pursuing the course set out in the order dated 21.01.2026, nor
shall the same preclude or come in the way of the NCLAT taking an
appropriate decision in the matter.
19.
Certain objections have been raised by the applicant in CM.APPL.
5867/2026 (filed on behalf of M/s Chemester Food Industry Limited), which
is part of the consortium that emerged as the highest bidder during the
auction process conducted on 08.04.2025. The same entity has also filed
CM. APPL. 6240/2026 seeking recall of the aforesaid order dated
21.01.2026 passed by this Court.
20.
This Court is not inclined to entertain either of the aforesaid
applications. In these proceedings, this Court has only taken on record the
statement made by the liquidator that it seeks to make an appropriate
application before the NCLAT seeking conduct of re-auction. It shall be
necessarily for the NCLAT to pass further consequential orders in this
regards and also deal with the objections raised by the applicant in CM.
APPL. 5867/2026. Likewise, the application for the recall of the order dated
21.01.2026, is misconceived. As noticed, the order dated 21.01.2026 records
KUMAR PATEL
15:29:59
CONT.CAS(C) 1819/2025
the statement/undertaking of the liquidator to the effect that it shall move the
NCLAT seeking to set aside the e-auction already conducted and seeks
permission for conduct of a re-auction of the concerned assets with a reserve
price of Rs.54,00,00,000/- (Rs.54 Crores). The liquidator would be well
within its right to move such an application given the facts and
circumstances. The order dated 21.01.2026 merely reflects what has
transpired in the present proceedings. It shall be for the NCLAT to consider
the matter further and pass appropriate orders. Any objections that may be
raised by the applicant in CM. APPL. 5867/2026 (or by any other party)
shall necessarily be considered by the NCLAT.
21.
During the course of hearing on 02.02.2026, the aforementioned bank
draft of Rs. 54,00,00,000/- (Rupees Fifty Four Crores) was handed over to
the liquidator. The utilisation/encashment of the same shall be subject to the
orders of the NCLAT. While moving an application seeking conduct of a reauction, the liquidator shall apprise the NCLAT of the aforesaid bank draft
furnished by the petitioner. In case it is not possible for the liquidator to
deposit the said amount of Rs.54 Crores in an interest bearing FDR (and
subject to further order/s of NCLAT), it shall be open for the petitioner to
seek return of the Bank Draft with an undertaking to re-furnish the same as
and when required and/or for the purpose of the re-auction process.
22.
The present petition stands disposed of in the above terms. Pending
application/s also stand disposed of.
FEBRUARY 11, 2026/at
SACHIN DATTA, J
KUMAR PATEL
15:29:59
CONT.CAS(C) 1819/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review