The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
14. In view of the mandate as laid down by the Hon'ble Apex court, this Court has no other option but to quash and set aside the judgments and decrees as passed by the learned courts below by relegating the parties to the court of learned Civil Judge, Court No. 2, Paonta Sahib, District Sirmaur, H.P., with a direction to consider and decide the case afresh. Ordered accordingly.
15. The parties undertake to appear before the learned trial court on 18.11.2026. It is made clear that learned trial court shall issue notice to the respondents and grant them time for completion of pleadings. After the completion of the pleadings, learned trial court shall frame appropriate issues and afford an opportunity to the parties to lead evidence and thereafter shall proceed to decide the case finally. -916. With these observations, the present appeal stands disposed of along with pending application(s), if any. October 27, 2026 (vt) (Romesh Verma) Judge
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
RSA No. 28 of 2026
Date of decision:27.10. 2026
Jeevan Singh
...Appellant
Versus
Kaka Singh (deceased) through his LRs & others ...Respondents
Coram:
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Romesh Verma, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?1
For the appellant
For the respondents
:
Mr. Rahul Singh Verma, Advocate.
:
Mr. Surinder Saklani, Advocate, for
respondents No.1(a), 1(b)(i) to 1(b)(iii),
1(c), 2 and 3.
Romesh Verma, Judge(oral):
The instant Regular Second Appeal has been filed by the
plaintiff-appellant challenging the judgment as passed by the learned
Additional District Judge, Paonta Sahib, District Sirmaur, dated
28.08.2025, whereby the appeal as instituted by the plaintiff-appellant
came to be dismissed and the judgment and decree as passed by the
learned Civil Judge, Court No. 2, Paonta Sahib, District Sirmaur, H.P.,
dated 29.07.2021 was affirmed, whereby the suit filed by the plaintiffappellant for declaration was dismissed.
2.
The facts as emerges in the present case are that the
plaintiff-appellant filed suit for declaration to the effect that he is
exclusive owner in possession of the land as per sale deed dated
Whether reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see
the judgment?
-228.11.1977 to the extent of land measuring 06-07 bighas in Khata
Khatauni No. 81/109 to 113, Kite 5, measuring 19-2 bighas, situated in
Mauza Behrewala, Tehsil Paonta Sahib, District Sirmaur, H.P., and
oral sale by defendants on 04.09.1987, along with the consequential
relief restraining the defendants from alienating the suit land.
3.
As per the case as set up by the plaintiff, he had
purchased the land measuring 06-07 bighas out of the land comprised
in Khata Khatauni No. 81/109 to 113, Kitte 5, measuring 19-2 bighas,
situated in Mauza Behrewala, Tehsil Paonta Sahib, District Sirmaur,
H.P. The plaintiff and the defendants are real brothers and on the
asking of their father, the plaintiff purchased the land in his own name
and in the name of defendants in equal ratio. According to the plaintiff,
he paid the entire sale consideration to Shri Beni Prasad and Shri
Renuka Prasad and thereafter the sale deed was executed in favour of
the plaintiff and defendants in the year 1977. It is the case of the
plaintiff that the suit land was never cultivated and possessed by the
defendants and it is only the plaintiff who is in exclusive possession of
the suit land since 28.11.1977. After the death of the father of the
parties, the plaintiff requested the defendants to execute the sale deed
of the suit land in his name, but the defendants refused to do the same
on one pretext or the other. Therefore, under such circumstances, the
plaintiff filed the suit for declaration.
-34.
The suit came to be resisted by the defendants by filing
written statement and all the allegations and averments as made in the
plaint were specifically refuted and denied. The defendants prayed for
the dismissal of the suit as filed by the plaintiff.
5.
Interestingly, the record reveals that after the completion
of the pleadings, no issues were framed by the learned trial court and
vide its judgment and decree dated 29.07.2021 dismissed the suit as
filed by the plaintiff.
6.
Feeling dissatisfied, the plaintiff approached the court of
learned Additional District Judge, Paonta Sahib on 04.10.2021, who
affirmed the findings of the learned trial court and dismissed the
appeal as preferred by the plaintiff.
7.
Still feeling dissatisfied, the plaintiff has approached this
Court by invoking the provisions of Section 100 of the CPC.
8.
It is contended by Mr. Rahul Singh Verma, learned
counsel for the appellant-plaintiff, that the impugned judgments and
decrees as passed by the learned courts below are erroneous and
they are required to be quashed solely on the ground that the learned
trial court failed to frame the appropriate issues as per the mandate of
Order 14 of the CPC. It has been further contended by the learned
counsel for the appellant that since the requirement of the Code of
Civil Procedure by not framing the appropriate issues has been
violated by the learned trial court, therefore, great prejudice has been
-4caused to the rights of the appellant, as a result of which the findings
are required to be quashed and set aside.
9.
The learned counsel for the appellant has relied on the
judgment of Hon’ble Apex court titled as Pramod Shroff vs. Mohan
Singh Chopra, SLP (C) No. 20779 of 2025, dated 16.04.2026,
wherein the Hon'ble Apex court has discussed the point in issue
involved in the present case. The relevant extract of the same reads
as follows:
“16. Order XX Rule 4(2) states that judgments of Courts shall
contain a concise statement of the case, the points for
determination, the decision thereon, and the reasons for such
decision.
“ORDER XX
4. Judgments of Small Cause Courts.—(1) Judgments of a
Court of Small Causes need not contain more than the
points for determination and the decision thereon.
(2) Judgments of other Courts.—Judgments of other Courts
shall contain a concise statement of the case, the points for
determination, the decision thereon, and the reasons for
such decision.”
17. Though, the framing of issues where defendant does not
present a defense is not mandated, still the importance of
framing of issues cannot be underscored. This Court in the
case of Makhan Lal Bangal v. Manas Bhunia and Others1,
while stressing upon the importance of framing of issues held it
as an imperative stage in any civil proceedings as it narrows
down the scope of trial by separating wheat from the chaff.
Therefore, the real dispute between the parties is determined
and the conflict between the parties is narrowed. The petition
may be disposed of at the first hearing if it appears that the
parties are not at issue on any material question of law or of
fact and the Court may at once pronounce the judgment.
-518. Further, in Ramesh Chand Ardawatiya v.Anil Panjwani, it
has been opined that the burden of proof on the Plaintiff is not
too heavy in ex parte civil suits. The Plaintiff, however, must
show prima-facie proof qua the existence of relevant facts and
circumstances out of which the cause of action has arisen.
Therefore, evincing that the court proceeds to record evidence
of the Plaintiff qua the cause of action and accordingly decrees
the suit. Further, it held that in a case which has proceeded ex
parte, the court is not bound to frame issues under Order XIV
and deliver the judgment on every issue as required by Order
XX Rule 5. Yet the trial court should scrutinize the available
pleadings and documents, consider the evidence adduced, and
would do well to frame the “points for determination” and
proceed to construct the ex parte judgment dealing with the
points at issue one by one.
19. Furthermore, this Court in Maya Devi v. Lalta Prasad3, has
held that in case the Defendant has been proceeded against ex
parte, it is the duty of the court to pass the decree only after
ascertaining the factual and legal veracity of the claim of the
Plaintiff.
20. This Court while considering the essential requirements of
a judgment in Balraj Taneja and Another v. Sunil Madan and
Another4 has held that Judgment as defined in Section 2(9) of
the CPC means the statement given by the Judge of the
grounds for a decree or order. What a judgment should contain
is indicated in Order XX Rule 4(2) which says that a judgment
‘shall contain a concise statement of the case, the points for
determination, the decision thereon, and the reasons for such
decision. It should be a self-contained document from which it
should appear as to what were the facts of the case and what
was the controversy which was tried to be settled by the court
and in what manner.
“Points for Determination” – Meaning and Role
21. The points for determination in a judgment are essentially
the legal and factual issues the court must resolve. They
correspond to the issues framed during trial (Order XIV), but in
the judgment they are stated as the point(s) to be decided. In
-6Rameshwar Dayal v. Banda (dead) through his LRs and
Another5,
the
Apex
Court
explained
that
‘points
for
determination’ in Rule 4(1) are obviously nothing but ‘issues’
contemplated by Rules 1 and 3 of Order XIV. In practice, the
trial court first frames issues (points of controversy) after
examination of pleadings, the judgment then recites these as
“points for determination” and answers them. These points
focus the judgment on the exact matters in controversy
between the parties. By explicitly listing points, the judgment
guides the parties and the Appellate court to see what
questions were in contest. The court must give its finding on
each point. Order XX Rule 5 CPC further reinforces this: if
issues have been framed in the suit, the court “shall state its
finding or decision, with reasons, upon each separate issue”,
unless deciding one issue resolves the suit. Thus, points for
determination ensure that every controverted issue addressed.
A judgment that omits discussion of issues in dispute is
defective. It was held that a Small Causes Court judgment
which has not even stated the points for determination and
given a finding thereon, is obviously not a judgment within the
meaning of Section 2(9) of CPC.
22. Points for determination are the court’s restatement of the
disputed questions (issues) that were placed before it, and the
judgment must answer each. They serve to concentrate the
court’s reasoning and ensure completeness of adjudication.”
10.
As per the mandate of the judgment as passed by the
Hon’ble Apex court, the true scope for framing issues is that evidence
let in on issue on which the parties actually went to trial should not be
the foundation for decision of another and different issue, which was
not present to the minds of the parties and on which they had no
opportunity of producing evidence. Relying upon the judgment in
Sayeda Akhtar vs. Abdul Ahad, (2003) 7 SCC 52, it was held that
-7the omission to frame an important issue may sometimes cause
prejudice to parties resulting in failure to lead evidence on the point.
Therefore, the judgments which have been passed by the learned
courts below must be in conformity with the provision of the Code.
Thus, provision of Order XX Rule 4 of CPC comes into picture.
11.
Settlement of issues and determination of suit on issues of
law or on issues agreed upon has been provided in Order XIV of
C.P.C., which reads as follows:
“1. Framing of issues.-(1) Issues arise when a material
proposition of fact or law is affirmed by the one party and
denied by the other.
(2) Material propositions are those propositions of law or fact
which a plaintiff must allege in Order to show a right to sue or a
defendant must allege in Order to constitute his defence.
(3) Each material proposition affirmed by one party denied by
the other shall form the subject of distinct issue.
(4) Issues are of two kinds:
(a) issues of fact,
(b) issues of law.
(5) At the first hearing of the suit the Court shall, after reading
the plaint and the written statements, if any, and 1[after
examination under rule 2 of Order X and after hearing the
parties or their pleaders], ascertain upon what material
propositions of fact or of law the parties are at variance, and
shall thereupon proceed to frame and record the issues on
which the right decision of the case appears to depend.
(6) Nothing in this rule requires the Court to frame and record
issues where the defendant at the first hearing of the suit
makes no defence.”
12.
Issues are to be framed with regard to those pleadings
which are asserted by one party and denied by the other. It is true that
-8merely non-framing of a particular issue would not be fatal for the
adjudication of the case. However, in the case at hand, no issues at all
have been framed. This Court is in agreement with the contention as
raised by the learned counsel for the appellant that since no issue has
been framed, the judgments and decrees as passed are not
sustainable.
13.
The learned counsel for the respondents fairly admits the
legal proposition of law and submitted that the matter can be relegated
to the court of learned trial court to decide the case afresh by affording
an opportunity to the parties.
14.
In view of the mandate as laid down by the Hon'ble Apex
court, this Court has no other option but to quash and set aside the
judgments and decrees as passed by the learned courts below by
relegating the parties to the court of learned Civil Judge, Court No. 2,
Paonta Sahib, District Sirmaur, H.P., with a direction to consider and
decide the case afresh. Ordered accordingly.
15.
The parties undertake to appear before the learned trial
court on 18.11.2026. It is made clear that learned trial court shall issue
notice to the respondents and grant them time for completion of
pleadings. After the completion of the pleadings, learned trial court
shall frame appropriate issues and afford an opportunity to the parties
to lead evidence and thereafter shall proceed to decide the case
finally.
-916.
With these observations, the present appeal stands
disposed of along with pending application(s), if any.
October 27, 2026
(vt)
(Romesh Verma)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review