Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
+
W.P.(C) 12950/2019, CM APPL. 52788/2019
JEET SINGH
.....Petitioner
Through:
Mr. Kanwar Udai Bhan Singh
Sehrawat, Advocate.
versus
AIRPORTS AUTHORITY OF INDIA AND ORS .....Respondents
Through: Ms. Sweety Singh, Advocate for R-2.
Mr. Rishi Kapoor and Mr. Azad
Bansala, Advocates for R-1.
Mr. R.K. Dhawan, SC with Ms. Nisha
Dhawan, Mr. Pawan Karan Das, Mr.
V.K. Teng and Mr. K.R. Madhar,
Advocates for R-3.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV NARULA
ORDER
27.01.2026
%
1.
The present writ petition assails the order dated 28 th September, 2016
passed by the Nodal Officer-cum-Additional District Magistrate, whereby
the request of the Petitioners for allotment of separate individual
rehabilitation plots under the scheme framed for the displaced residents of
Village Nangal Dewat was rejected. The controversy arises out of the
acquisition of abadi land for the development of Palam Airport and concerns
the entitlement of the Petitioners to individual alternative plots on the basis
of their alleged independent holdings and inherited shares.
W.P.(C) 12950/2019
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 04/02/2026 at 13:15:31
2.
The present Petitioners are the legal representatives of late Jeet Singh,
who was one of the sons of Surta S/o Siria. Surta was the recorded owner in
the acquisition record. The claim to an individual alternative plot is traced
through Jeet Singh, and not through Surta. References to “predecessor”
hereafter are to Jeet Singh unless the context indicates otherwise.
3.
The Petitioners trace their claim to holdings and structures in Khasra
Nos. 1243 (old abadi) and 1259/1 (extended abadi). It is asserted that late
Surta @ Surat Singh, S/o Siria, was the recorded owner in possession of
land measuring 1015.17 sq. yds. The Petitioners further rely upon entries
reflecting that Jeet Singh (also described in certain structure entries as Jeet
Ram S/o Surta) had an independent 1/6th share of 75.5 sq. yds in Khasra No.
1243, and that his name figured separately in the Survey Report and Naksha
Muntazamin. As regards another family member, it is asserted that he was in
occupation of a dwelling unit admeasuring 66 sq. yds in the same khasra and
held an independent electricity connection. On this basis, the Petitioners
contend that each claimant ought to be assessed separately, by adding (i) the
claimant’s independent holding and (ii) the claimant’s proportionate share in
the father’s holding, and thereafter allotting separate alternative plots to each
eligible claimant.
Prior proceedings and the remit to the Nodal Officer
4.
The Petitioners had earlier approached this Court by W.P.(C)
303/2007, assailing the order dated 10th November, 2006 by which the
Nodal Officer had rejected the request for allotment of separate alternative
plots in individual names. By the order passed in the said writ petition, this
Court partly accepted the challenge, holding that where the name of a
claimant figured in the Survey Report and the claimant was shown to have
W.P.(C) 12950/2019
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 04/02/2026 at 13:15:31
an independent holding, the claimant’s share in the father’s holding had to
be added to such independent holding in terms of the guidelines approved by
this Court on 18th May, 2005. In the earlier proceedings, the claim advanced
on behalf of Satbir Singh (another son of Surta) was rejected, and no relief
was granted in his favour. The Nodal Officer was directed to undertake the
computation exercise and proceed accordingly.
5.
The present petition is directed against the order dated 28 th
September, 2016 passed thereafter. That order proceeds on the footing that,
by reason of the later Division Bench decision in LPA No. 429/2007 titled
Airport Authority of India v Nirmala Devi & Ors.,1 the question of
entitlement to an “individual” alternative plot cannot turn merely on the
appearance of a name in the Survey Report or Naksha Muntazamin. The
impugned order applies the requirement laid down by the Division Bench
which, in substance, requires the claimant to establish a triad: (i) separate
mention in the Survey Report, (ii) separate mention in the Naksha
Muntazamin, and (iii) separate assessment and award of compensation in the
Award in respect of the land underneath the super-structure said to have
been raised by the claimant.
6.
On that approach, the Nodal Officer recorded, inter alia, that: (a) the
name of Jeet Singh does not appear separately in the Survey Report in
respect of land in Khasra Nos. 1243 or 1259/1; (b) the Naksha Muntazamin
(land) reflects assessment of compensation in the name of Surta S/o Siria;
(c) although a structure entry at Sr. No. 252 reflects the name “Jeet Ram S/o
Surta” (stated by the Petitioners to refer to Jeet Singh), there is no separate
assessment of compensation in the Award for the land underneath such
W.P.(C) 12950/2019
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 04/02/2026 at 13:15:31
structure; and (d) the claimants have not complied with the requirement of
handing over vacant physical possession of the earlier allotted plot.
Submissions
7.
Counsel for the Petitioners submits that the impugned order defeats
the remit of this Court in the earlier round. It is urged that, while disposing
of W.P.(C) 303/2007, this Court had already taken note of the Petitioner Jeet
Singh’s separate reflection in the contemporaneous records, including the
Survey Report and the Naksha Muntazamin, and had held that once such
separate mention and independent holding are shown, the proper method is
to add the Petitioner’s independent holding to his proportionate share in the
father’s holding for determining the size of the alternative plot. The
Petitioners contend that the Nodal Officer has, instead, adopted a
mechanical approach of treating the family as one unit, which is the very
approach that had been faulted earlier.
8.
It is further urged that the impugned order proceeds on an incorrect
factual foundation. According to the Petitioners, the material placed earlier
indicated that the Petitioner’s name was reflected in the Naksha Muntazamin
in relation to assessment of compensation. The Petitioners allege that this
has been sidelined through reliance upon a Tehsildar’s report which, in their
submission, does not correctly reflect the underlying primary documents.
They also rely on the pleaded circumstance that Satbir Singh had a dwelling
unit and an independent electricity connection, which, according to them,
corroborates the case of separate occupation and separate entitlement.
9.
The Petitioners also submit that the Nodal Officer has over
emphasised the Award entry. They argue that a person’s eligibility cannot be
Decided on 19th February, 2013
W.P.(C) 12950/2019
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 04/02/2026 at 13:15:31
negated merely because the compensation in the Award was recorded in the
name of a predecessor, particularly where the holdings devolved by
succession and the revenue records were mutated after the death of the
recorded owner. Their case is that the rehabilitation scheme was intended to
address genuine abadi occupants and not to exclude heirs on account of the
manner in which compensation happened to be booked at the time of
acquisition.
10.
The Petitioners also contend that the requirement of handing over
possession of any earlier allotted plot has been invoked against them
unfairly. They submit that their claim is for correct computation and
separate allotment in terms of the governing guidelines, and that the
authority ought to have first determined entitlement in accordance with the
judicial directions and thereafter dealt with any ancillary compliance
requirement in a fair and practicable manner.
Submissions on behalf of the Respondents
11.
Per contra, counsel for the Respondents submits that the petition seeks
a factual reappreciation of record in writ jurisdiction. It is urged that the
rehabilitation framework is record-driven, and that for an individual
alternative plot, the claimant must satisfy the criteria crystallised in the
judicially approved guidelines as later clarified by the Division Bench. The
Petitioners cannot rest their claim merely on a separate mention in the
Survey Report or Naksha Muntazamin. Where an individual plot is claimed
on the footing of an independent super-structure, the scheme administered as
per judicial directions, requires corresponding recognition in the Award
through separate compensation for the land underneath that super-structure.
This is said to be the controlling distinction between joint entitlement of
W.P.(C) 12950/2019
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 04/02/2026 at 13:15:31
heirs and an individual allotment.
12.
The Respondents submit that the Nodal Officer has acted strictly in
accordance with the framework crystallised by the Division Bench. It is
contended that the rehabilitation scheme is entirely record-driven and that
entitlement to an individual alternative plot must be demonstrable from the
contemporaneous acquisition record. Reliance is placed on the additional
affidavit and the translated extracts to emphasise that, in respect of Khasra
Nos. 1243 and 1259/1, the land compensation entries in the Survey Report,
Naksha Muntazamin (land), and the Award stand in the name of Surta S/o
Siria alone. The Respondents assert that Jeet Singh is not reflected as a
separate landholder or as a recipient of separate land compensation in the
Award.
13.
It is further submitted that although a structure entry at Sr. No. 252
reflects the name “Jeet Ram”, there is no corresponding assessment of
compensation for the land underneath such structure in his name. According
to the Respondents, the Division Bench has made it clear that a mere
appearance in the structure column, unaccompanied by separate land
compensation in the Award, does not satisfy the eligibility test for an
individual allotment.
14.
The Respondents also submit that the Petitioners’ reliance on
subsequent mutation entries is misplaced. Mutation, in their submission,
addresses inter se recognition of succession in revenue records and does not
displace the acquisition-time record which forms the basis of rehabilitation
entitlements. They contend that accepting post-acquisition mutations as a
substitute for the Award-based requirement would introduce inconsistency
and unequal treatment among similarly placed claimants.
W.P.(C) 12950/2019
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 04/02/2026 at 13:15:31
15.
On the Petitioners’ reliance upon the earlier order in W.P.(C)
303/2007, the Respondents submit that the earlier directions were to
compute entitlement in accordance with the governing guidelines. They
contend that the later Division Bench decision, which the Nodal Officer has
applied, binds the administrative process and ensures uniformity across the
category of claims. The Nodal Officer, according to the Respondents, has
therefore correctly reviewed the claim through the updated and binding
criteria rather than treating the earlier observations as a final factual
determination insulated from subsequent clarifications of law.
16.
The Respondents also submit that the Petitioners have not complied
with the requirement of handing over vacant possession of any earlier
allotted plot. They contend that a claimant cannot retain the benefit already
extended and simultaneously seek a fresh configuration resulting in multiple
or individual allotments. On that footing, they urge that the impugned
rejection is justified both on eligibility as well as on compliance.
Scope of interference
17.
The impugned order is an administrative determination rendered
under a court-approved rehabilitation framework. Judicial review in such a
setting does not operate as an appeal on facts. The task is to examine
whether the authority applied the correct legal yardstick, considered the
material placed before it, and reached a conclusion that is not vitiated by
perversity, patent disregard of binding directions, or manifest error apparent
on the face of the record. A writ court does not re-weigh the underlying
evidentiary material to reach its own preferred factual conclusion merely
because a different view is possible.
18.
On the pleadings and the record placed, the following questions arise
W.P.(C) 12950/2019
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 04/02/2026 at 13:15:31
for determination:
(i)
whether, in undertaking the exercise pursuant to the order passed in
W.P.(C) 303/2007, the Nodal Officer was bound to confine himself to the
earlier understanding of the guidelines, or was required to apply the
principles subsequently clarified by the Division Bench in LPA No.
429/2007;
(ii)
whether the insistence upon separate assessment of compensation in
the Award for the land underneath the super-structure constitutes an
incorrect application of the governing legal framework; and
(iii)
whether the factual findings recorded in the impugned order suffer
from perversity, manifest error, or patent disregard of the primary record so
as to warrant interference in writ jurisdiction.
Analysis
19.
The Petitioners’ argument, in substance, proceeds on the footing that
the order passed in W.P.(C) 303/2007 conclusively determined their
entitlement and left no scope for further scrutiny of the underlying record.
That submission cannot be accepted. The earlier order did not declare an
absolute right to an individual allotment; it directed the Nodal Officer to
undertake the exercise of computation in accordance with the governing
guidelines. Such a computation necessarily presupposes satisfaction of the
eligibility conditions under the scheme as judicially interpreted. The
direction to compute did not dispense with, or override, the requirement that
the claimant satisfy the documentary criteria governing individual
entitlement.
20.
The decision of the Division Bench in Airport Authority of India
(LPA No. 429/2007) is pivotal. The Division Bench was concerned with the
W.P.(C) 12950/2019
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 04/02/2026 at 13:15:31
precise difficulty that arises where multiple members of the same family
claim individual alternative plots on the basis of separate super-structures
raised upon land recorded in the name of a common predecessor. In order to
prevent duplication of benefit against the same acquired holding and to
ensure uniformity in application of the scheme, the Court clarified that a
mere separate mention in the Survey Report or Naksha Muntazamin would
not suffice. Entitlement to an individual alternative plot would arise only
where there was corresponding and separate assessment of compensation in
the Award for the land underneath the super-structure. This requirement is
not an administrative embellishment introduced by the Nodal Officer; it
flows directly from the binding interpretation of the scheme by the Division
Bench.
21.
The affidavit filed on behalf of AAI further explains the
administrative context in which the Division Bench treated the Award as the
decisive checkpoint. It is stated that, in village Nangal Dewat, compensation
for land was consolidated and disbursed to the person recorded in the
revenue entries, whereas certain individuals were assessed separately only in
respect of super-structures. The affidavit also asserts that if the Petitioners’
predecessor had been recognised as holding land in the old Lal Dora in his
own right, a corresponding reflection would ordinarily be found in the
extended abadi revenue records. However, according to the Respondents,
those records consistently reflect the name of Surta S/o Siria and not that of
Jeet Singh. This explanation underscores the rationale for the Division
Bench’s insistence upon separate assessment of land compensation in the
Award: it operates as an objective documentary safeguard to distinguish
between mere structure assessment and independent land entitlement.
W.P.(C) 12950/2019
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 04/02/2026 at 13:15:31
22.
Once the governing framework clarified by the Division Bench is kept
in view, the focus of the inquiry becomes narrow and documentary. The
question is not whether a separate structure existed, whether electricity stood
in an individual’s name, or whether family members were in separate
occupation. The determinative issue is whether the contemporaneous
acquisition record recognises, for compensation purposes, the land beneath
the asserted super-structure as a separately assessable unit in the claimant’s
name.
23.
However, it is not even the Petitioners’ case that separate land
compensation was awarded in the name of Jeet Singh. Their submission
rests primarily on the alleged appearance of the predecessor’s name in the
Survey Report and Naksha Muntazamin, an assertion which is itself disputed
in the additional affidavit filed by Respondent No. 2 on the ground of
mistranslation and misidentification. Even assuming that the survey-related
entry is correctly read in the Petitioners’ favour, no separate assessment of
land compensation in the Award in the name of Jeet Singh has been
demonstrated from the record. In terms of the binding formulation of the
Division Bench, that deficiency is fatal to the claim for an individual
alternative plot.
24.
The Petitioners’ reliance on mutation entries effected after the death
of Surta does not cure the deficiency. The rehabilitation entitlement in
question is not a general incident of succession; it arises under a structured
scheme anchored to the contemporaneous acquisition record. Subsequent
mutations may regulate inter se civil rights among heirs, but they do not
displace the eligibility markers fixed at the time of acquisition, particularly
the requirement of separate assessment of land compensation in the Award.
W.P.(C) 12950/2019
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 04/02/2026 at 13:15:31
25.
The affidavit filed on behalf of AAI further states that no ownership
or partition document has been produced in the name of the Petitioners or
their predecessor, and that the land continues to stand in the name of the
grandfather. Whether or not separate super-structures were raised by other
family members, the absence of separate land recognition in the acquisition
record is precisely the situation for which the Division Bench clarified that
structure assessment alone cannot ground an individual allotment.
26.
The Petitioners also rely upon submission recorded in the earlier
round of proceedings that the predecessor’s name appeared in the Naksha
Muntazamin. Even assuming such a submission was made, the entitlement
under the scheme must ultimately be tested against the primary acquisition
record. The decisive inquiry is what the Survey Report, Naksha Muntazamin
and the Award, read together, demonstrate regarding separate assessment of
compensation for the land beneath the asserted super-structure. The material
placed before this Court does not disclose any clear and independent
assessment of land compensation in the name of the Petitioners or their
predecessor.
27.
There is also another impediment recorded in the impugned order.
The order notes that the claimants did not hand over vacant physical
possession of the earlier allotted plot, and that they expressed inability to do
so. The Division Bench framework contemplates surrender of the jointly
allotted plot before any reconfiguration into individual plots, since
individual allotment necessarily reduces the area notionally attributable to
the joint allotment and prevents double benefit. The Petitioners have not
placed material to show compliance, or to establish that the Nodal Officer
recorded this aspect on an incorrect factual basis. In any event, the relief
W.P.(C) 12950/2019
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 04/02/2026 at 13:15:31
sought would necessarily entail reconfiguration of the earlier allotment. The
scheme does not contemplate such reconfiguration except on strict
satisfaction of eligibility conditions and compliance requirements.
Conclusion
28.
In that view, the essential eligibility condition for an individual
alternative plot is not shown to be satisfied. For the reasons set out above, no
ground is made out to interfere with the impugned order. The writ petition is
dismissed. Pending applications, if any, also stand disposed of.
SANJEEV NARULA, J
JANUARY 27, 2026
nk
W.P.(C) 12950/2019
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 04/02/2026 at 13:15:31
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review