Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of Decision: 20th January, 2026
%
+
ARB.P. 1574/2025
JCC INFRAPROJECTS BIL JV
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Susshil Daga and Mr. Chitransh
Mathur, Advocates
Mob: 9829689999
Email: susshil@amicuslegal.in
versus
NORTH
WESTERN
RAILWAY
JAIPUR
RAJASTHAN
THROUGH GENERAL MANAGER & ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Ms. Arunima Dwivedi, CGSC with
Ms. Monalisha Pradhan and Ms. Priya
Khurana, Advocates
Mob: 9810916537
Email: arunima.associate@gmail.com
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MINI PUSHKARNA
MINI PUSHKARNA, J (ORAL):
1.
The present petition has been filed on behalf of the petitioner under
Section 11(6) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (“Arbitration
Act”) seeking appointment of a Sole Arbitrator in terms of Clause 24.3 of
the Engineering, Procurement and Construction (“EPC”) Agreement dated
30th September, 2022, entered between the parties for the ―Major
Upgradation of Gandhi Nagar – Jaipur Railway Station‖.
2.
The petitioner, i.e., JCC Infraprojects BIL (JV), is a joint venture,
engaged in the execution of works through competitive tenders floated by
various governmental agencies.
Digitally Signed
By:HARIOM SHARMA
19:42:57
ARB.P. 1574/2025
3.
The respondent no. 1 is responsible for the overall administration,
construction and operations of the North-Western Railway Zone, whereas,
respondent nos. 2 and 3 are officials of North-Western Railway, Rajasthan,
directly connected with the process of inviting competitive bids, finalisation
of the Contract Agreement and providing complete facilities required for
execution of work related to this Agreement.
4.
The respondent no. 2 issued a Notice Inviting Tender (“NIT”) bearing
no. NWR-SC-EPC/GADJ-T-921 dated 30th April, 2022 for procurement of
work in relation to the ―Major Upgradation of Gandhi Nagar – Jaipur
Railway Station‖.
5.
The petitioner participated in the bidding process and was issued a
Letter of Acceptance dated 20th August, 2022, after which the EPC
Agreement dated 30th September, 2022 was executed between the parties
thereafter.
6.
Disputes have arisen between the parties under the EPC Agreement.
7.
It is submitted that under the EPC Agreement, the Arbitration Clause,
i.e., Clause 24.3, prescribes a three-tier dispute resolution mechanism, i.e.,
conciliation, adjudication by a Dispute Adjudication Board and arbitration
by a Standing Arbitral Tribunal.
8.
It is submitted that the petitioner, in good faith, has on multiple
occasions invoked the said mechanism and attempted to resolve the disputes
amicably, through representations, conciliatory correspondence and
participation in conciliation proceedings. However, such efforts have
yielded no resolution.
9.
Conciliation between the parties failed. Further, the petitioner, in
good faith also sought initiation of the process for constitution of the
Digitally Signed
By:HARIOM SHARMA
19:42:57
ARB.P. 1574/2025
Dispute Adjudication Board and the Standing Arbitral Tribunal. However,
both the processes have remained wholly non-functional and ineffective.
10.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that on account of the
failure of the initial two-tiers of the dispute resolution mechanisms, the
petitioner issued a Notice dated 01st August, 2025, under Section 21 of the
Arbitration Act, invoking arbitration as per the Arbitration Clause, i.e.,
Clause 24.3 of the EPC Agreement.
11.
Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the respondents submits
that the present petition is not maintainable on account of the multi-tier
dispute resolution mechanism under Clause 24 of the EPC Agreement,
which envisages conciliation and thereafter resolution of disputes by way of
Dispute Adjudication Board, and subsequently through Standing Arbitral
Tribunal.
12.
It is submitted that the competent authority duly nominated the
Dispute Adjudication Board vide letter dated 21st July, 2025, however, the
petitioner, instead of making their submissions, sent the Notice dated 01 st
August, 2025, under Section 21 of the Arbitration Act. Furthermore, the
Dispute Adjudication Board is currently seized with the matter, and the
arbitral mechanism cannot be approached without completing the mandate
of resolution of disputes through the Dispute Adjudication Board.
13.
In rejoinder, learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the
objection regarding constitution of Dispute Adjudication Board is
misplaced, as the Dispute Adjudication Board was required to be constituted
within 90 days from the date of the EPC Agreement between the parties.
14.
As regards formation of Standing Arbitral Tribunal, learned counsel
appearing for the petitioner submits that the same is unilateral, unfair and
Digitally Signed
By:HARIOM SHARMA
19:42:57
ARB.P. 1574/2025
contrary to law, and therefore, is hit by the judgement of the Supreme Court
in the case of Perkins Eastman Architects DPC and Another Versus HSCC
(India) Limited, (2020) 20 SCC 760. Further, reliance is also placed upon
the judgement of this Court dated 07th October, 2024 in ARB. P. 1493/2024,
titled as ―Jhajharia Nirman Ltd. Versus South Western Railways Through
Dy. Chief Engineer/IV Construction”.
15.
Thus, it is submitted that the process of formation of the Standing
Arbitral Tribunal raises justifiable doubts as to the fairness of the
proceedings. Therefore, it is prayed that an independent Sole Arbitrator be
appointed to resolve the disputes between the parties.
16.
I have heard learned counsels for the parties and perused the record.
17.
At the outset, this Court notes that vide order dated 14th January,
2026, this Court had directed that the Dispute Adjudication Board
constituted by the respondents shall not proceed further with the matter, till
further directions from this Court are issued. The order dated 14th January,
2026, is reproduced as under:
―xxx xxx xxx
1. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that in the present case,
the objection taken by the respondent that a Disputes Adjudication
Board ("DAB"), has been constituted is totally misplaced. He
submits that the DAB was required to be constituted within 90 days
from the date of the Agreement between the parties, as per the
contractual terms.
2. He submits that Clause 24.3.1, pertaining to a Standing Arbitral
Tribunal ("SAT") is hit by the judgment of the Supreme Court in the
case of Perkins Eastman Architects DPC & Am. Versus HSCC
(India) Ltd., AIR 2020 SC 59.
3. He further relies upon the judgment dated 07th October, 2024,
passed in ARB. P. 1493/2024, titled as "Jhajharia Nirman Ltd.
Versus South Western Railways Through Dy. Chief Engineer/IV
Construction".
4. He further submits that a rejoinder has been filed on behalf of the
Digitally Signed
By:HARIOM SHARMA
19:42:57
ARB.P. 1574/2025
petitioner.
5. However, the same is under objection. Let steps be taken to have
the objections removed and to have the rejoinder placed on record.
6. If the only objection is with regard to the delay in filing said
rejoinder, the said delay stands condoned.
7. Learned counsel for the respondents seeks time to address
arguments.
8. Considering the submissions made before this Court, it is directed
that the DAB constituted by the respondents shall not proceed
further with the matter, till further directions from this Court.
9. Accordingly, at request, re-notify on 20th January, 2026.
xxx xxx xxx‖
(Emphasis Supplied)
18.
As per the scheme of the EPC agreement between the parties, dispute
resolution in Clause 24 initially provides for conciliation of disputes under
Clause 24.1, which reads as under:
―xxx xxx xxx
―24.1 Conciliation of Disputes
24.1.1 All disputes and differences of any kind whatsoever arising out
of or in connection with the contract, whether during the progress of
the work or after its completion and whether before or after the
determination of the contract, shall be referred by the Contractor to
the "Authority" through ''Notice of Dispute" provided that no such
notice shall be served later than 30 days after the date of issue of
Completion Certificate by the Authority Engineer. Authority shall,
within 30 days after receipt of the Contractor's ''Notice of Dispute",
notify the name of conciliator(s) to the Contractor. In case Authority
fails to fix Conciliator within 30 days, Contractor shall be free to
approach Dispute Adjudication Board (DAB) for adjudication of
Dispute.
24.1.2 The Conciliator(s) shall assist the parties to reach an amicable
settlement in an independent and impartial manner within the terms of
contract. If the parties reach agreement on a settlement of the dispute,
they shall draw up and sign a written settlement agreement duly
signed by Authority Engineer, Contractor and conciliator(s). When
the settlement agreement is signed, it shall be final and binding on the
parties. The conciliators shall be paid fee as fixed by Ministry of
Railways time to time, which shall be shared equally by the parties.
Digitally Signed
By:HARIOM SHARMA
19:42:57
ARB.P. 1574/2025
24.1.3 The parties shall not initiate, during the conciliation
proceedings, any reference to DAB or arbitral or judicial proceedings
in respect of a dispute that is the subject matter of the conciliation
proceedings.
24.1.4 The conciliation shall be carried out as per ―The Arbitration
and Conciliation Act, 1996‖ and the proceedings may be terminated
as per Section 76 of the above Act.‖
xxx xxx xxx‖
19.
This Court records that the said conciliation process has already failed
on 30th May, 2024, though, formal Declaration in this regard was issued by
the respondents subsequently on 20th September, 2024 and 04th March, 2025.
20.
The EPC Agreement between the parties further envisages a Dispute
Adjudication Board in Clause 24.2, relevant portion of which, reads as
under:
―xxx xxx xxx
24.2 Dispute Adjudication Board (DAB)
24.2.1 A dispute/s if not settled through conciliation, shall be referred
to DAB. The DAB shall consist of a panel of three Retired Railway
Officers not below senior administrative grade (SAG). The DAB shall
be formed within 90 days of signing of Contract Agreement. For this
purpose, the Authority will maintain a panel of DAB members. The
complete panel, which shall not be less than five members, shall be
sent by Authority to the Contractor to nominate one member of the
DAB from the panel as Contractor‘s nominee within two weeks of
receipt of the panel. On receipt of Contractor‘s nominee, the Authority
shall nominate one member from the same panel as Authority's
nominee for the DAB. Both above nominees shall jointly select
presiding member of the DAB from the same panel.
xxx xxx xxx
24.2.6 DAB proceedings shall be conducted as decided by the DAB.
The DAB shall give its decision within 90 days of a Dispute referred
to it by any of the Parties, duly recording the reasons before arriving
at the decision. The DAB shall decide the issue within terms and
conditions of the contract. This time limit shall be extendable subject
to the Parties mutual agreement.
xxx xxx xxx‖
Digitally Signed
By:HARIOM SHARMA
19:42:57
ARB.P. 1574/2025
21.
As per the aforesaid Clause, a dispute which has not been settled
through the conciliation process, shall be referred to Dispute Adjudication
Board, which shall consist of a panel of three retired Railway Officers.
Further, Clause 24.2.1 envisages that the Dispute Adjudication Board shall
be formed within 90 days of signing the EPC Agreement. However, the
same has admittedly not been done by the respondents in the present case. It
is to be noted that the Dispute Adjudication Board was constituted only on
11th June, 2024. Hence, the constitution of the Dispute Adjudication Board
was itself belated, and not in terms of the agreement between the parties.
22.
Furthermore, as per Clause 24.2.6, the Dispute Adjudication Board
shall give its decision within 90 days of a dispute being referred to it. As per
the facts on record, the petitioner submitted its Statement of Claims before
the Dispute Adjudication Board on 9 th June, 2025, whereupon, the Dispute
Adjudication Board was mandatorily required under Clause 24.2.6 to render
its decision within 90 days, i.e., by 07th September, 2025. Clearly, the
decision as regards the dispute referred to it, has not been given by the
Dispute Adjudication Board within the time stipulated as per the EPC
Agreement between the parties.
23.
This Court further notes that re-nomination of one of the members of
Dispute Adjudication Board was done by the respondents vide letter dated
21st July, 2025. However, no meeting of the said Dispute Adjudication
Board took place. It is only during the pendency of the present proceedings,
that the first meeting of Dispute Adjudication Board was fixed on 04 th
December, 2025. The order passed by the Dispute Adjudication Board in
this regard, reads as under:
Digitally Signed
By:HARIOM SHARMA
19:42:57
ARB.P. 1574/2025
24.
Perusal of the aforesaid clearly shows that despite re-constitution of
Digitally Signed
By:HARIOM SHARMA
19:42:57
ARB.P. 1574/2025
the Dispute Adjudication Board in July, 2025, the first meeting of the
Dispute Adjudication Board was fixed only on 04th December, 2025, long
after the expiry of the contractual mandate and that too after filing and
issuance of notice by this Court in the instant petition.
25.
Therefore, the whole purpose and object of referring the dispute to the
Dispute Adjudication Board stands defeated, and the said process has been
rendered nugatory in view of the prolonged delay. Further, given the
excessive time taken, the reference to the Dispute Adjudication Board, has
become a futile exercise.
26.
In this regard, this Court refers to the judgment of this Court in the
case of Jhajharia Nirma Ltd. Versus South Western Railways through Dy.
Chief Engineer/IV Construction & Connected matter, 2024 SCC OnLine
Del 7133, wherein, while dealing with a similar clause in relation to
resolution of dispute by the Dispute Adjudication Board, it has been held as
follows:
―xxx xxx xxx
17. Further, the constitution of the DAB in the present case was
belated and not within the timeframe stipulated in the Contract
Agreement. In terms of the Contract, the DAB was to be formed
within the 90 days of signing of the contract agreement. Admittedly,
the same was not done.
18. In numerous judicial precedents, this Court has taken the view
that any pre-condition in an arbitration agreement obliging one of
the contracting parties to either exhaust the pre-arbitral amicable
resolution avenues or to take recourse to Conciliation are directory
and not mandatory.
19. In this regard, reference may be made to Oasis Projects
Ltd. v. National
Highway
&
Infrastructure
Development
Corporation Limited, (2023) 1 HCC (Del) 525, wherein the Court
has observed as under:
“12. The primary issue to be decided in the present
petition is, therefore, as to whether it was mandatory for the
Digitally Signed
By:HARIOM SHARMA
19:42:57
ARB.P. 1574/2025
petitioner to resort to the conciliation process by the Committee
before invoking arbitration. Though Article 26.2 clearly states
that before resorting to arbitration, the parties agree to explore
conciliation by the Committee, in my opinion, the same cannot be
held to be mandatory in nature. It needs no emphasis that
conciliation as a dispute resolution mechanism must be encouraged
and should be one of the first endeavours of the parties when a
dispute arises between them. However, having said that,
conciliation expresses a broad notion of a voluntary process,
controlled by the parties and conducted with the assistance of a
neutral third person or persons. It can be terminated by the parties
at any time as per their free will. Therefore, while interpreting
Article 26.2, the basic concept of conciliation would have to be
kept in mind.‖
[Emphasis supplied]
21. This Court in Subhash Infraengineers (P) Ltd. v. NTPC Ltd., 2023
SCC OnLine Del 2177 has held as under:—
“21. In this regard, it is relevant to note that in terms of
Section 62(3) of the Act, it is open for a party to reject the
invitation to conciliate. Further, in terms of Section 76 of the Act,
the conciliation proceedings can be terminated by a written
declaration of a party and there is no legal bar in this regard. In
the present case, Clause 7.2.5 of the GCC expressly provides that
―parties are free to terminate Conciliation proceedings at any
stage as provided under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act,
1996.‖
***
28. In the present case, the clause/pre arbitral
mechanism contemplates mutual consultation followed by
conciliation. As noticed in Abhi Engg. and Oasis Projects,
conciliation is a voluntary process and once a party has opted
out of conciliation, it cannot be said that the said party cannot
take recourse to dispute resolution through arbitration.‖
xxx xxx xxx‖
(Emphasis Supplied)
27.
In this context, reference may also be made to the judgment in the
case of Coach Com Versus DME its Sole Proprietor Smt. Lalita Devi
Sureka, Northern Railway, 2025 SCC OnLine Del 8055, wherein the
Court, while holding that reference to pre-arbitral mechanisms, including a
Digitally Signed
By:HARIOM SHARMA
19:42:57
ARB.P. 1574/2025
Dispute Adjudication Board, would be a futile exercise, and appointed an
Arbitrator for adjudication of disputes between the parties therein, held as
follows:
―xxx xxx xxx
9. In Jhajharia Nirman v. South Western Railways, 2024 SCC OnLine
Del 7133, a Coordinate Bench of this Court, dealing with a
similar arbitration clause in a Railway Contract, has observed that
any pre-condition in an arbitration agreement binding one of the
contracting parties to either exhaust the pre-arbitral amicable
resolution procedures or to take recourse to conciliation are
directory, and not mandatory in nature.
10. In view of the facts noted above, in my view, the reference of the
dispute between the parties to the conciliation and thereafter DAB
would be an exercise of futility.
11. In the aforesaid facts and circumstances, this Court is of the
view that the present petition is not premature and a Sole Arbitrator
is required to be appointed to adjudicate the disputes between the
parties.
xx xxx xxx‖
(Emphasis Supplied)
28.
Therefore, the contention of the respondents that the proceedings
before the Dispute Adjudication Board be allowed to be culminated, finds
no favour with this Court, and the said contention is accordingly, rejected.
29.
Furthermore, the EPC Agreement between the parties provides for
arbitration proceedings to be conducted by an Arbitral Tribunal consisting of
a panel of three retired Railway Officers. Clause 24.3 of the EPC Agreement
between the parties in this regard, reads as under:
―xxx xxx xxx
―24.3 Standing Arbitral Tribunal
24.3.1 The arbitration proceedings shall be conducted as per ―The
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996‖. The Arbitral Tribunal shall
consist of a panel of three Retired Railway Officers not below senior
administrative grade (SAG). The Standing Arbitral Tribunal shall be
Digitally Signed
By:HARIOM SHARMA
19:42:57
ARB.P. 1574/2025
formed within 90 days of signing of Contract document. For this
purpose, the Authority shall maintain a panel of arbitrators. The
complete panel, which shall not be less than five members, shall be
sent by Authority to the Contractor to nominate one arbitrator from
the panel as Contractor's nominee within two weeks of receipt of the
panel. On receipt of Contractor's nominee, the Authority shall appoint
above Contractor's nominee as well as another from the same panel
as Authority‘s nominee as arbitrators. Both above arbitrators shall
jointly select presiding arbitrator from the same panel.
24.3.2 If the Contractor fails to select the Contractor's nominee from
the panel within two weeks of the receipt of the said panel, the
Authority shall, after giving one more opportunity to contractor to
nominate one as Contractor's nominee within next two weeks, appoint
two arbitrators from the same panel. Both above arbitrators shall
jointly select presiding arbitrator from the same panel.
24.3.3 If one or more of the Arbitrators appointed refuses to act as
Arbitrator, withdraws from his office as Arbitrator, or vacates his
office or is unable or unwilling to perform his functions as Arbitrator
for any reason whatsoever or dies or in the opinion of the Authority
fails to act without undue delay, the parties shall terminate the
mandate of such arbitrator and thereupon new arbitrator shall be
appointed in the same manner, as the outgoing arbitrator had been
appointed.
24.3.4 Before start of arbitration proceedings, each appointed
arbitrator shall give the following certificate to the Authority and the
Contractor:
―I have no any past or present relationship in relation to the subject
matter in dispute, whether financial, business, professional or other
kind. Further,
I have no any past or present relationship with or interest in any of the
parties whether financial, business, professional or other kind, which
is likely to give rise to justifiable doubts as to my independence or
impartiality in terms of The Arbitration and Conciliation Act. 1996.‖
24.3.5 In the specific cases of any misconduct by any of the members
of the TRIBUNAL, the parties shall have the right to specifically bring
it to the notice of the TRIBUNAL such conduct, through a statement
filed with necessary documents in proof of such misconduct and the
TRIBUNAL, after taking NOTICE of such conduct initiate the
replacement of the member concerned, in the same manner the
member to be replaced was appointed.
Digitally Signed
By:HARIOM SHARMA
19:42:57
ARB.P. 1574/2025
24.3.6 Each party has to prepare and furnish to Standing Arbitral
Tribunal and other party, once in a every six months, an account
giving full and detailed particulars of all claims, which even after
decision of DAB are unsettled, to which the parties may consider
themselves entitled to during the last preceding six months. If any
dispute has arisen as regards execution of the works under the
contract, while submitting the said half yearly claims, the parties shall
give full particulars of such dispute in the said submission. After
signing Contract agreement, within 6 months, the parties shall submit
all the claims from date of award of contract in first submission of
claims.
24.3.7 The said communication will be the reference of the dispute to
the ARBITRAL TRIBUNAL appointed under the present agreement.
24.3.8 The parties shall submit all the relevant documents in support
of their claims and the reasons for raising the dispute to the
TRIBUNAL.
24.3.9 The said claims of the parties so referred to ARBITRAL
TRIBUNAL so far it relates to the disputed claims, shall be treated as
Statement of Claims of the parties and the ARBITRAL TRIBUNAL
shall call upon the other party to submit its reply. The ARBITRAL
TRIBUNAL after giving an opportunity of being heard to both the
parties, decide the dispute within a period of Four months from the
date of communication of the dispute under clause 24.3.6 above. The
Arbitral Tribunal will pass a reasoned award in writing, while
deciding the Dispute. Once the award is declared, the Arbitral
Tribunal cannot review the same except what is permissible in terms
of provisions contained in Arbitration and Conciliation Act. The
parties shall be entitled to the remedies under the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act 1996 or any amendment thereof.
24.3.10 The parties agree that all the claims of any nature
whatsoever, which the parties may have in respect of the work of the
preceding six months, should be made in the said Statements of half
yearly claims. If the parties do not raise the claim, if any, arising from
the work done in the preceding six months in the statement of half
yearly claim, to Standing Arbitral Tribunal, the parties shall be
deemed to have waived and given up the claims. The ARBITRAL
TRIBUNAL shall not entertain such disputes, which have not been
raised in the statement of half yearly Claim before the Standing
Arbitral Tribunal and such claims will stand excluded from the scope
Digitally Signed
By:HARIOM SHARMA
19:42:57
ARB.P. 1574/2025
of arbitration and beyond the terms of reference to the ARBITRAL
TRIBUNAL.
24.3.11 The parties agree that where the Arbitral award is for
payment of money, no interest shall be payable on the whole or any
part of the money for any period till the date on which the award is
made.
24.3.12 The obligation of the Authority and the Contactor shall not be
altered by reasons of arbitration being conducted during the progress
of work. Neither party shall be suspended the work on account of
arbitration and payments to the contractor shall continue to be made
in terms of the contract and/or as awarded (except when Award is
challenged in the Court in which case the payments would be as per
the court's orders )
24.3.13 The ARBITRAL TRIBUNAL shall remain in force during the
entire period the PRINCIPAL CONTRACT is in force and until the
closure of the PRINCIPAL CONTRACT with the final no claim
certificate, which will be filed with ARBITRAL TRIBUNAL.
24.3.14 The Arbitral Tribunal shall conduct the Arbitration
proceedings at [Delhi] or any other convenient venue which shall be
decided by Tribunal in consultation with both parties.
24.3.15 The cost of arbitration shall be borne equally by the
respective parties. The cost shall inter-alia include fee of the
arbitrators as per the rates fixed by the Indian Railways from time to
time.
24.3.16 It is a term of this contract that the Contractor shall not
approach any Court of Law for settlement of such disputes or
differences unless an attempt has first been made by the parties to
settle such disputes or differences through conciliation, DAB and
Standing Arbitral Tribunal.
24.3.17 Even in case arbitration award is challenged by a party in the
Court of Law, 75% of award amount, pending adjudication by Court
of Law, shall be made by party to other party. In case payment is to be
made by Authority to Contractor, the terms & conditions as
incorporated in the Ministry of Railways letter No.
2016/CE(I)/CT/ARB/3(NITI Aayog)/Pt. dated 08th Mar, 2017 as
amended time to time shall be followed. However, in case Contractor
has to pay to the Authority, then 75% of the award amount shall be
Digitally Signed
By:HARIOM SHARMA
19:42:57
ARB.P. 1574/2025
deducted by the Authority from the running bills or other dues of the
Contractor, pending adjudication by Court of Law.
24.3.18 The contract shall be governed by the law for the time being
in force in the Republic of India. In case of any disputes/differences
resulting in court cases between Contractor & Authority, the
jurisdiction shall be of Courts at [Delhi] only.‖
xxx xxx xxx‖
30.
Reading of the aforesaid Clause shows that the said Clause
contemplating appointment of Arbitrators from a panel of retired Railway
Officers, is not in consonance with the settled position of law as laid down
by the Supreme Court in the case of Perkins Eastman Architects DPC and
Another Versus HSCC (India) Limited, (2020) 20 SCC 760, which
prohibits unilateral control or interest in the appointment process by one
party, the relevant portion of which, reads as under:
―xxx xxx xxx
21. But, in our view that has to be the logical deduction from TRF
Ltd. [TRF Ltd. v. Energo Engg. Projects Ltd., (2017) 8 SCC 377 :
(2017) 4 SCC (Civ) 72] Para 50 of the decision shows that this Court
was concerned with the issue, ―whether the Managing Director, after
becoming ineligible by operation of law, is he still eligible to nominate
an arbitrator‖ The ineligibility referred to therein, was as a result of
operation of law, in that a person having an interest in the dispute or
in the outcome or decision thereof, must not only be ineligible to act
as an arbitrator but must also not be eligible to appoint anyone else
as an arbitrator and that such person cannot and should not have any
role in charting out any course to the dispute resolution by having the
power to appoint an arbitrator. The next sentences in the paragraph,
further show that cases where both the parties could nominate
respective arbitrators of their choice were found to be completely a
different situation. The reason is clear that whatever advantage a
party may derive by nominating an arbitrator of its choice would get
counter-balanced by equal power with the other party. But, in a case
where only one party has a right to appoint a sole arbitrator, its
choice will always have an element of exclusivity in determining or
charting the course for dispute resolution. Naturally, the person who
has an interest in the outcome or decision of the dispute must not
have the power to appoint a sole arbitrator. That has to be taken as
Digitally Signed
By:HARIOM SHARMA
19:42:57
ARB.P. 1574/2025
the essence of the amendments brought in by the Arbitration and
Conciliation (Amendment) Act, 2015 (3 of 2016) and recognised by
the decision of this Court in TRF Ltd. [TRF Ltd. v. Energo Engg.
Projects Ltd., (2017) 8 SCC 377 : (2017) 4 SCC (Civ) 72]
xxx xxx xxx
23. Sub-para (vii) of the aforesaid para 48 lays down that if there are
justifiable doubts as to the independence and impartiality of the
person nominated, and if other circumstances warrant appointment
of an independent arbitrator by ignoring the procedure prescribed,
such appointment can be made by the Court. It may also be noted
that on the issue of necessity and desirability of impartial and
independent arbitrators the matter was considered by the Law
Commission in its Report No. 246. Paras 53 to 60 under the heading
―Neutrality of Arbitrators‖ are quoted in the judgment of this Court
in Voestalpine Schienen GmbH v. DMRC [Voestalpine Schienen
GmbH v. DMRC, (2017) 4 SCC 665 : (2017) 2 SCC (Civ) 607] , while
paras 59 and 60 of the Report stand extracted in the decision of this
Court in Bharat Broadband Network Ltd. v. United Telecoms
Ltd. [Bharat Broadband Network Ltd. v. United Telecoms Ltd., (2019)
5 SCC 755 : (2019) 3 SCC (Civ) 1] . For the present purposes, we
may rely on para 57, which is to the following effect: (Voestalpine
case [Voestalpine Schienen GmbH v. DMRC, (2017) 4 SCC 665:
(2017) 2 SCC (Civ) 607], SCC p. 681, para 16)
―16. … ‗57. The balance between procedural fairness and
binding nature of these contracts, appears to have been tilted
in favour of the latter by the Supreme Court, and the
Commission believes the present position of law is far from
satisfactory. Since the principles of impartiality and
independence cannot be discarded at any stage of the
proceedings, specifically at the stage of constitution of the
Arbitral Tribunal, it would be incongruous to say that party
autonomy can be exercised in complete disregard of these
principles — even if the same has been agreed prior to the
disputes having arisen between the parties. There are certain
minimum levels of independence and impartiality that should
be required of the arbitral process regardless of the parties'
apparent agreement. A sensible law cannot, for instance,
permit appointment of an arbitrator who is himself a party to
the dispute, or who is employed by (or similarly dependent on)
one party, even if this is what the parties agreed. The
Commission hastens to add that Mr P.K. Malhotra, the ex officio
member of the Law Commission suggested having an exception
for the State, and allow State parties to appoint employee
Digitally Signed
By:HARIOM SHARMA
19:42:57
ARB.P. 1574/2025
arbitrators. The Commission is of the opinion that, on this
issue, there cannot be any distinction between State and nonState parties. The concept of party autonomy cannot be
stretched to a point where it negates the very basis of having
impartial and independent adjudicators for resolution of
disputes. In fact, when the party appointing an adjudicator is
the State, the duty to appoint an impartial and independent
adjudicator is that much more onerous — and the right to
natural justice cannot be said to have been waived only on the
basis of a “prior” agreement between the parties at the time of
the contract and before arising of the disputes.’ ”
24. In Voestalpine [Voestalpine Schienen GmbH v. DMRC, (2017) 4
SCC 665: (2017) 2 SCC (Civ) 607], this Court dealt with
independence and impartiality of the arbitrator as under: (SCC pp.
687-88 & 690-91, paras 20 to 22 & 30)
―20. Independence and impartiality of the arbitrator are the
hallmarks of any arbitration proceedings. Rule against bias is one
of the fundamental principles of natural justice which applied to
all judicial and quasi-judicial proceedings. It is for this reason
that notwithstanding the fact that relationship between the parties
to the arbitration and the arbitrators themselves are contractual
in nature and the source of an arbitrator's appointment is
deduced from the agreement entered into between the parties,
notwithstanding the same non-independence and nonimpartiality of such arbitrator (though contractually agreed
upon) would render him ineligible to conduct the arbitration. The
genesis behind this rational is that even when an arbitrator is
appointed in terms of contract and by the parties to the contract,
he is independent of the parties. Functions and duties require
him to rise above the partisan interest of the parties and not to act
in, or so as to further, the particular interest of either parties.
After all, the arbitrator has adjudicatory role to perform and,
therefore, he must be independent of parties as well as impartial.
The United Kingdom Supreme Court has beautifully highlighted
this aspect in Hashwani v. Jivraj [Hashwani v. Jivraj, (2011) 1
WLR 1872 : 2011 UKSC 40] in the following words : (WLR p.
1889, para 45)
‗45. … the dominant purpose of appointing an arbitrator or
arbitrators is the impartial resolution of the dispute between
the parties in accordance with the terms of the agreement and,
although the contract between the parties and the arbitrators
would be a contract for the provision of personal services, they
Digitally Signed
By:HARIOM SHARMA
19:42:57
ARB.P. 1574/2025
were not personal services under the direction of the parties.‘
21. Similarly, Cour de Cassation, France, in a judgment delivered
in 1972 in Consorts Ury [Fouchard, Gaillard, Goldman on
International Commercial Arbitration, 562 [Emmanuel Gaillard &
John Savage (Eds.) 1999] {quoting Cour de cassation [Cass.]
[Supreme Court for judicial matters] Consorts Ury v. S.A. des
Galeries Lafayette, Cass. 2e civ., 13-4-1972, JCP, Pt. II, No. 17189
(1972) (France)}.], underlined that:
‗an independent mind is indispensable in the exercise of judicial
power, whatever the source of that power may be, and it is one of
the essential qualities of an arbitrator‘.
22. Independence and impartiality are two different concepts. An
arbitrator may be independent and yet, lack impartiality, or vice
versa. Impartiality, as is well accepted, is a more subjective
concept as compared to independence. Independence, which is
more an objective concept, may, thus, be more straightforwardly
ascertained by the parties at the outset of the arbitration
proceedings in light of the circumstances disclosed by the
arbitrator, while partiality will more likely surface during the
arbitration proceedings.
***
30. Time has come to send positive signals to the international
business community, in order to create healthy arbitration
environment and conducive arbitration culture in this country.
Further, as highlighted by the Law Commission also in its report,
duty becomes more onerous in government contracts, where one of
the parties to the dispute is the Government or public sector
undertaking itself and the authority to appoint the arbitrator rests
with it. In the instant case also, though choice is given by DMRC to
the opposite party but it is limited to choose an arbitrator from the
panel prepared by DMRC. It, therefore, becomes imperative to
have a much broadbased panel, so that there is no
misapprehension that principle of impartiality and independence
would be discarded at any stage of the proceedings, specially at the
stage of constitution of the Arbitral Tribunal. We, therefore, direct
that DMRC shall prepare a broadbased panel on the aforesaid
lines, within a period of two months from today.‖
xxx xxx xxx‖
(Emphasis Supplied)
31.
Further, the Five Judge bench of the Supreme Court in the case of
Digitally Signed
By:HARIOM SHARMA
19:42:57
ARB.P. 1574/2025
Central Organisation for Railway Electrification Versus ECI SPIC SMO
MCML (JV) A Joint Venture Company, (2025) 4 SCC 641, while holding
that appointment of arbitrators from a panel of potential arbitrators is against
the principle of equal treatment of parties, and any unilateral appointment is
violative of Article 14 of the Constitution, held as follows:
―xxx xxx xxx
J. Conclusion
170. In view of the above discussion, we conclude that:
170.1. The principle of equal treatment of parties applies at all
stages of arbitration proceedings, including the stage of appointment
of arbitrators;
170.2. The Arbitration Act does not prohibit PSUs from empanelling
potential arbitrators. However, an arbitration clause cannot
mandate the other party to select its arbitrator from the panel
curated by PSUs;
170.3. A clause that allows one party to unilaterally appoint a sole
arbitrator gives rise to justifiable doubts as to the independence and
impartiality of the arbitrator. Further, such a unilateral clause is
exclusive and hinders equal participation of the other party in the
appointment process of arbitrators;
170.4. In the appointment of a three-member panel, mandating the
other party to select its arbitrator from a curated panel of potential
arbitrators is against the principle of equal treatment of parties. In
this situation, there is no effective counterbalance because parties do
not participate equally in the process of appointing arbitrators. The
process of appointing arbitrators in CORE [Central Organisation
for Railway Electrification v. ECI-SPIC-SMO-MCML (JV), (2020)
14 SCC 712] is unequal and prejudiced in favour of the Railways;
170.5. Unilateral appointment clauses in public-private contracts are
violative of Article 14 of the Constitution;
170.6. The principle of express waiver contained under the proviso to
Section 12(5) also applies to situations where the parties seek to
waive the allegation of bias against an arbitrator appointed
unilaterally by one of the parties. After the disputes have arisen, the
parties can determine whether there is a necessity to waive the nemo
judex rule; and
170.7. The law laid down in the present reference will apply
Digitally Signed
By:HARIOM SHARMA
19:42:57
ARB.P. 1574/2025
prospectively to arbitrator appointments to be made after the date of
this judgment. This direction applies to three-member tribunals.
xxx xxx xxx‖
(Emphasis Supplied)
32.
Thus, a similar clause in relation to the three-tier dispute resolution
mechanism and for appointment of arbitrators from the panel of the
respondents, as existing in the present case, was dealt with by this Court in
the case of Jhajharia Nirman Ltd. (Supra), wherein, holding that the
procedure as contemplated in the said clause does not meet the requirement
of law, it was held as follows:
―xxx xxx xxx
24. Even as regards the second objection, it is notable that this Court
has had occasion to consider the arbitration agreement involving an
appointment procedure similar to the one prescribed in the present
case. The arbitration Clause in the present matter stipulates that the
Arbitral Tribunal will consist of three retired railway officers of at
least Senior Administrative Grade (SAG) and the Authority will
maintain a panel of at least five arbitrators. The panel will be sent to
the contractor, who must choose one arbitrator as their nominee
within two weeks. The Authority will then appoint the contractor's
nominee and another from the same panel as its own nominee.
These two arbitrators will jointly select a presiding arbitrator from
the same panel. Further, it is provided that the contractor does not
select a nominee within the given two weeks, the Authority will give
an additional two weeks. If the contractor still fails to nominate, the
Authority will appoint two arbitrators from the panel, and they will
jointly select the presiding arbitrator.
25. It has been held in a catena of judgments that the above
mentioned appointment procedure does not meet with the
requirement of law. In Margo Networks Pvt. Ltd. v. Railtel
Corporation of India Ltd., 2023:DHC : 4596, it was held as under:
(i) In the context of appointment procedure contemplating
appointment out of panel of arbitrators maintained by one of the
contracting parties, it is mandatory that the panel should be
sufficiently broad-based, failing which the appointment
procedure does not meet with the requirements of law.
Referring Voestalpine Schienen Gmbh v. Delhi Metro Rail
Corporation Ltd., (2017) 4 SCC 665, it was held that an arbitrator
Digitally Signed
By:HARIOM SHARMA
19:42:57
ARB.P. 1574/2025
panel must be broad-based, and not restrictive. This requirement
was found to be not fulfilled where the panel comprised solely of
ex-employees of a party.
(ii) A valid appointment procedure must be balanced and not
confer excessive say or authority on one of the parties to the
arbitration, as regards constitution of the arbitral tribunal. An
appointment procedure which contemplates that one party
appoints two out of three members of the arbitral tribunal, the
appointment procedure contravenes this requirement.
xxx xxx xxx‖
(Emphasis Supplied)
33.
Therefore, in view of the aforesaid, the appointment of arbitrators as
per Clause 24.3 of the EPC Agreement and conduct of arbitration
proceedings by an Arbitral Tribunal consisting of a panel of three retired
Railway Officers, cannot be held to be valid.
34.
Reference may also be made to the judgment of this Court in the case
of Kalpataru Projects International Limited Versus Northern Railway,
2026 SCC OnLine Del 110, wherein, this Court while considering a similar
clause held that the same was not in consonance with the principles of
independence and impartiality of arbitrators. Further, there is no bar to
appointment of a Sole Arbitrator to adjudicate the disputes between the
parties, where the arbitration agreement provided for a Tribunal of three
members. Thus, this Court held as follows:
―xxx xxx xxx
12. The position of law is, thus, clear that even in cases, where there
is a three member panel, an Arbitration Clause mandating the other
party to select its Arbitrator from a curated panel of potential
Arbitrators, is against the Principle of Equal Treatment of Parties.
Accordingly, it is evident that the Arbitration Clause detailing the
procedure for appointment of the Arbitral Tribunal, i.e., Clause 24.1
in the present case cannot be sustained, and would be invalid.
13. In the present scenario, when the Arbitration Clause, i.e., Clause
24.1 of the Agreement between the parties is unsustainable, this
Digitally Signed
By:HARIOM SHARMA
19:42:57
ARB.P. 1574/2025
Court is not powerless to pass an order for appointment of an
Arbitrator to make appropriate alternative arrangements to give
effect to the Arbitration Clause. Thus, in the case of Singh Builders
Syndicate v. Union of India, 2006 SCC OnLine Del 389, this Court
held that the Court has power to appoint a Sole Arbitrator where
Court doubts the impartiality of the designated authority and the
Arbitrator. In the said case also, the Arbitration Clause envisaged an
Arbitral Tribunal consisting of three employees of the authority in
question. Considering the facts and circumstances of the said case,
the Court appointed an independent Sole Arbitrator, by holding as
follows:
―xxx xxx xxx
11. I may say at the outset that in view of provisions of Section
11(4), (5) & (6) of the Act, normally the procedure that has to
be followed for appointment of an arbitrator should be the one
which is agreed to between the parties. [See: J.L. Prasad v. The
General Manager, Southern Railway, Chennai, (2002) 1 Arb LR
584, National Thermal Power Corporation Ltd. v. Raghul
Constructions Pvt. Ltd., AIR 2005 Ker 115]. In the instant case,
as per the procedure prescribed in clause 64 of the general
terms and conditions of the contract; for the purpose of
nominating its arbitrator, the petitioner has to choose one name
out of the list for appointment forwarded by the General
Manager. This is the procedure which was followed in the first
instance when application filed by the petitioner (AA No.
202/2000) was disposed of vide order dated 11th November,
2002. Even when the nominee of the petitioner resigned, in
subsequent applications filed by the petitioner, again, direction
was given by this court to follow the said procedure.
12. However, the petitioner now wants an independent
arbitrator to be appointed on the ground that the respondent
has lost its right to suggest the names. Under certain
circumstances, notwithstanding the aforesaid procedure, the
court has power to appoint its arbitrator.
13. Some of the circumstances which can be culled out from
the case law, are the following:
(a) Where the designated authority fails to appoint the
arbitrator.
xxx xxx xxx
(b) Where the court doubts the impartiality of the designated
authority and the arbitrator, the court can appoint an
Digitally Signed
By:HARIOM SHARMA
19:42:57
ARB.P. 1574/2025
independent arbitrator. This happened in the case of Interstate
Construction v. NPCC Construction reported as 2004 3 RAJ
672 (Del.) wherein the court observed as under;
―It is this type of conduct and dealing which sometimes
compels a Court to override clauses in an agreement
which waive objection as to impartiality of the
Arbitration on the grounds that he is an officer of one of
the parties to the dispute.‖
(c) In peculiar circumstances where the court is faced with a
move which is not covered by the provisions of the Act, this
situation occurred in the case of Sushil Kumar Rant v. Hotel
Marina reported as (2005) 81 DRJ 533 and the Division Bench
appointed an independent arbitrator by observing as under:
―We are conscious of the position that arbitration
admits of least judicial intervention and the manner in
which an arbitrator is to be appointed. But we are faced
with an impasse which is neither covered by the
provisions of the Arbitration Act, nor any precedent.
This, if left unattended would have the natural
consequence of leaving the dispute between the parties
unresolved which would be contrary to the spirit and
intent of the Arbitration Act. It would, therefore, require
to be broken which can be only done by the appointment
of an impartial arbitrator. This may not be technically or
strictly in tune with the provisions of the Act which do
not provide for such tike eventualities but it is surely
dictated by the interests of justice. Therefore to promote
and secure the interests of Justice, it would be
appropriate to set aside the impugned order and appoint
an independent arbitrator.‖
14. Keeping in view the aforesaid legal position in mind, I am of the
opinion that in the present case also time is ripe for constituting an
independent arbitral tribunal by this court. The arbitration clause
contains a peculiar procedure for appointment of arbitrators. In the
event of dispute, the General Manager, Railways has a right to
appoint its arbitrator. In so far as nominee of the contractor is
concerned, he is given choice of limited nature. There is no complete
freedom given to him in this behalf. The General Manager,
Railways is required to send a panel of more than three names of
Gazetted railway offices of one or more departments of the Railways
to the contractor. The contractor is given an option to suggest to the
General Manager one name out of the said list who shall then be
Digitally Signed
By:HARIOM SHARMA
19:42:57
ARB.P. 1574/2025
appointed by the General Manager as the contractor's nominee.
Thus even the contractor's nominee has to be the officer of
Railways. The two arbitrators have to nominate the third arbitrator,
called umpire, who is also to be a gazetted railway officer. Thus the
tribunal consists of two/three arbitrators and all are the
Government/railway officers.
xxx xxx xxx‖
(Emphasis Supplied)
14. The aforesaid judgment of this Court was upheld by the Supreme
Court in the case of Union of India v. Singh Builders
Syndicate, (2009) 4 SCC 523, wherein the Supreme Court held as
follows:
―xxx xxx xxx
14. It was further held in Northern Railway case [(2008) 10
SCC 240 : (2008) 11 Scale 500] that the Chief Justice or his
designate should first ensure that the remedies provided under
the arbitration agreement are exhausted, but at the same time
also ensure that the twin requirements of sub-section (8) of
Section 11 of the Act are kept in view. This would mean that
invariably the court should first appoint the arbitrators in the
manner provided for in the arbitration agreement. But where
the independence and impartiality of the arbitrator(s)
appointed/nominated in terms of the arbitration agreement is
in doubt, or where the Arbitral Tribunal appointed in the
manner provided in the arbitration agreement has not
functioned and it becomes necessary to make fresh
appointment, the Chief Justice or his designate is not
powerless to make appropriate alternative arrangements to
give effect to the provision for arbitration.
xxx xxx xxx‖
(Emphasis Supplied)
15. This Court followed the aforesaid judgment of the Supreme
Court, in the case of Twenty-Four Secure Services Pvt.
Ltd. v. Competent Automobiles Company Limited, 2024 SCC
OnLine Del 4358, and proceeded to appoint a Sole Arbitrator even
when the Arbitration Clause stipulated reference to arbitration by
three arbitrators, each party having the authority to appoint a
nominee Arbitrator, when the parties were unable to agree on
appointment of a Sole Arbitrator. Thus, in the said case it was held as
follows:
―xxx xxx xxx
Digitally Signed
By:HARIOM SHARMA
19:42:57
ARB.P. 1574/2025
22.
In Union
of
India
(UOI) v. Singh
Builders
Syndicate, (2009) 4 SCC 523 the High Court rejected the
contention on behalf of the Government that the Court was
not vested with any powers to appoint a Sole Arbitrator in
distinction to the Arbitration Agreement which provided for
the Tribunal of three members. The Apex Court upheld the
order of this Court appointing a Sole Arbitrator by observing
that the appointment of the Sole Arbitrator was valid.
xxx xxx xxx‖
xxx xxx xxx‖
(Emphasis Supplied)
35.
Accordingly, this Court finds no impediment in appointing a Sole
Arbitrator to adjudicate disputes between the parties.
36.
Considering the aforesaid, the dispute between the parties arising out
of the EPC Agreement is referred to the Arbitral Tribunal, comprising of a
Sole Arbitrator. The following directions are issued in this regard:
i.
Justice Rekha Palli, (Retd.), former Judge, Delhi High Court, (Mobile
No.: 9810012120) is appointed as a Sole Arbitrator to adjudicate the
disputes between the parties.
ii.
The remuneration of the Arbitrator shall be in terms of Schedule IV of
the Arbitration Act.
iii.
The Arbitrator is requested to furnish a declaration in terms of Section
12 of the Act prior to entering into the reference. In the event there is
any impediment to the Arbitrator’s appointment on that count, the
parties are given liberty to file an appropriate application before this
Court.
iv.
It shall be open to the respondent to raise counter-claims, if any, in
arbitration proceedings.
v.
It is made clear that all the rights and contentions of the parties,
including, the arbitrability of any of the claims and/or counter-claims,
Digitally Signed
By:HARIOM SHARMA
19:42:57
ARB.P. 1574/2025
any other preliminary objection, as well as claims on merits of the
dispute of either of the parties, are left open for adjudication by the
learned Arbitrator.
vi.
The parties shall approach the Arbitrator within two (2) weeks from
today.
37.
Needless to state, nothing in this order shall be construed as an
expression of this Court on the merits of the case.
38.
The petition is disposed of in the aforesaid terms.
MINI PUSHKARNA, J
JANUARY 20, 2026/sk/au
Digitally Signed
By:HARIOM SHARMA
19:42:57
ARB.P. 1574/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review