Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2024:MLHC:1032-DB
Serial No.01
Supp. List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WA. No. 34 of 2023
Date of Decision: 14.11.2024
JC-361315Y Sub Maj CLK (Retd),
Radha Krishna Nair KM
Son of K Madhavan Nair
Aged 61 years
Resident of Electupara (PO),
Pathanamthitta District,
Kerela – 689656.
…Appellant
-Versus1.
The Union of India
Represented by the Secretary
Govt. of India,
Ministry of Home Affairs,
New Delhi -110 001.
2.
The Director General,
Head Quarter,
Directorate General of Assam Rifles,
Laitkor, P.O. Happy Valley,
East Khasi Hills, Meghalaya.
3.
The Brigadier (Personal)
Head Quarters,
Directorate General of Assam Rifles,
Laitkor, P.O. Happy Valley,
East Khasi Hills, Meghalaya.
2024:MLHC:1032-DB
4.
The Colonel (Administration),
Head Quarter,
Directorate General of Assam Rifles,
Laitkor, P.O. Happy Valley,
East Khasi Hills, Meghalaya.
…Respondents
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H.S.Thangkhiew, Judge
Hon’ble Mr. Justice B.Bhattacharjee, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Applicant(s) :
Mr. M.Chanda, Adv.
Mr. M.L.Nongpiur, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Mr. R.Debnath, CGC.
:
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Yes/No
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
Per H.S.Thangkhiew, Judge
1.
The instant writ appeal has been preferred against the judgment and
order dated 13-12-2022, whereby the learned Single Judge, by the said
judgment had dismissed WP(C). No. 128 of 2017.
2024:MLHC:1032-DB
2.
The brief facts of the case are that the appellant, as writ petitioner,
had approached this Court against the denial of promotional benefits upto
the rank and status of Second-in-Command (2IC) at par with other Central
Paramilitary Forces, which is stated to be in violation of the judgment and
direction dated 23-08-2012, passed in WP(C). No. 277 (SH) of 2010. The
grounds for assailing the impugned judgment and order dated 13-12-2022, is
that the denial of promotional avenues from Clerical Cadre in Assam Rifles
upto the rank of 2IC at par with other Central Paramilitary Forces, which
has implemented only a portion of the judgment and order dated 23-082012, is arbitrary and liable to be interfered with.
3.
Mr. M. Chanda, learned counsel for the appellant has submitted that
in the judgment and order dated 23-08-2012, passed in WP(C). No. 277
(SH) of 2010, this Court had directed for parity in respect of rank, structure
and pay of the Assam Rifles Clerical Cadre at par with other Central Police
Organisations by introducing the rank of Assistant Sub-Inspector (Warrant
Officer) at the entry grade with effect from 01-01-1996. He further submits
that this order was challenged before the Supreme Court, but the same was
dismissed by order dated 17-11-2015, which upheld the order of the learned
Single Judge dated 23-08-2012. The learned counsel submits that the
grievance that remains is that promotional benefits upto the rank of Second-
2024:MLHC:1032-DB
in-Command has been denied on the ground that the Assam Rifles has
maintained parity in the upper line of the rank structure only upto Subedar
Major. It is argued that the learned Single Judge has failed to appreciate that
the phrase ‘rank structure’ included all ranks including the rank of 2IC as
available in other Central Police Organisations since the phrase ‘rank
structure’ has been specified by the words ‘at par with other CPOs’. The
learned counsel submits that the order dated 23-08-2012, has not mentioned
about any specific rank, nor excluded the rank of 2IC in its judgment.
4.
It has been further contended that the learned Single Judge failed to
appreciate that the decision of the Ministry of Home Affairs denying the
benefit of promotional avenues upto the rank of 2IC has amounted to an
interference with the order dated 23-08-2012, especially when such
direction is contained in para 14 of the said judgment thereof. It is also
asserted that learned Single Judge failed to appreciate the denial of equal
opportunity of promotion to the appellant upto the rank of 2IC, amounts to
denial to bring parity in respect of status, rank structure and pay of the
Assam Rifles Clerical Cadre at par with other CPOs.
5.
Mr. R.Debnath, learned CGC appearing for the respondents,
maintains that as per the judgment dated 23-08-2012, the rank of Warrant
Officer was introduced and all consequential benefits such as rank, revision
2024:MLHC:1032-DB
of pay and allowance including arrears was paid to all affected persons
including the petitioner herein. With regard to the question of denial of
promotional avenues, it has been submitted that the grant of parity in the
ranks as per the other CPOs, has no connection with the rationalization of
Officer (Grade A) ranks of the Assam Rifles, nor does it provide for an
automatic avenue for promotion to personnel who are within Group B for
promotion to Group A Officer Cadre, as both Groups are governed by
separate recruitment rules. He submits that the only way for personnel from
the Clerical Cadre to be considered for promotion to the rank of Assistant
Commandant and onwards to Deputy Commandant, Second-in-Command
(2IC) and then Commandant, is by way of a limited departmental
competitive examination which ensures that an Officer is fairly selected
from any trade including Clerical Cadre. He further submits the petitioner,
having enrolled as a ministerial staff (in Group B or C), now holding the
post of Subedar (Clerk), his next promotion will be as Subedar Major in
Group B as per the existing recruitment rules and therefore, his claim for
promotion to Group A Officer Cadre, is against the existing norms and
cannot be accepted. It is also added by learned counsel that the issue of
promotional avenues for personnel from the clerical cadre in the Assam
Rifles had received the attention of the Ministry of Home Affairs and in
reply to a query thereto, the Assam Rifles had communicated by referring to
2024:MLHC:1032-DB
the judgment dated 23-08-2012, to state that the operative part of the said
judgment only refers to parity of rank and pay structure at par with other
CPOs, by introducing the rank of Assistant Sub-Inspectors (Warrant Officer)
at the entry grade and not for grant of promotional avenue upto the rank of
2IC.
6.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and studying the
impugned order of the learned Single Judge, it is noted that the point in
issue has been duly considered and carefully examined by the learned Single
Judge as to whether the petitioner who is serving as a Subedar (Clerk) can
be considered for promotion through the normal channel upto the rank of
2IC. It is also noted that the learned Single Judge has narrated and
illustrated the sequence and the chain of events as they have unfolded,
whereby the rank and pay structure in the Assam Rifles Clerical Cadre was
brought in parity with other CPO/CAPF/CPMF with the introduction of the
rank of Warrant Officer (Assistant Sub-Inspector) at the entry grade. It is
also seen that the learned Single Judge has noted that the Assam Rifles as
well as other CPOs including the CRPF are governed by their respective
recruitment rules, which have provided for the manner and procedure of
promotion from the ranks which defers from each other.
2024:MLHC:1032-DB
7.
The findings of the learned Single Judge contained in paragraphs 25,
26 and 27 which are relevant are reproduced herein under:
“25. However, as submitted by the learned CGC,
over and above this, the Assam Rifles as well as
the other CPOs including the CRPF are governed
by their respective Recruitment Rules indicating
the pattern and procedure of promotion in the
ranks, which differs from each other. A
comparative table of this has been set out by the
respondents at para 53 (c) of the affidavit-inopposition which is reproduced below as:
S/N
o
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
(e)
(f)
CAPFs
Assam Rifles
Constable
Head Constable
Asst Sub Inspector
Sub Inspector
Inspector
Assistant
Commandant
i) 50% direct entry
ii) 17.5% LDCE
iii)32.5%
Local
Promotion
Rifleman
Havildar
Warrant Officer
Naib Subedar
Subedar
Capt/Asst Comdt
i) 80% deputation
from Indian Army
ii) 20% from LDCE
26. Again, it is to be noted that the learned
CGC has submitted that in the Assam Rifles, there
are different sets of Recruitment Rules for
personnel who are under Group B & C which is
the clerical cadre and those under Group A which
is the Officers cadre as indicated at para 16
above. This being so, admittedly, the petitioner
falls under Group B & C and the post of Secondin-Command (2IC) is found in Group A.
Therefore, there is no linear avenue of promotion
from the rank of Havildar (Clk) in Group B & C to
the post of Commandant in Group A. This does
not mean that the promotional avenue has been
stopped or blocked altogether since personnel in
2024:MLHC:1032-DB
the clerical cadre are eligible to be promoted and
to come over to the ranks found in Group A,
albeit, after successfully competing or being found
suitable within the 20% quota for Limited
Departmental Competitive Examination (LDCE).
27. Since it has been established that there exist
two categories of cadre in the Assam Rifles, that
is, Officers cadre and Clerical cadre, the relevant
order of this Court in WP(C) No. 277(SH) of 2010
dated 23.08.2012, particularly at para 14 clearly
indicates that parity of rank and pay structure of
the Assam Rifle is to be affected only in the
‘Clerical cadre’ and there is no mention of
‘Officers cadre’ in the said order”.
8.
On consideration of the totality of the facts and circumstances of the
case, especially on the point that is well defined as given in the chart which
has been reproduced in the judgment of the learned Single Judge, reflecting
the fact that post of 2IC is a Group A post, governed by the Assam Rifle’s
own recruitment or selection procedure, there is no infirmity in the order of
the learned Single Judge and accordingly, the instant appeal being without
any merit is dismissed.
(B.Bhattacharjeee)
Judge
SAMANTHA ANNA LIYA
RYNJAH
Date: 2024.11.14 16:43:46 IST
(H.S.Thangkhiew)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review