Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CGHC010423452025
2026:CGHC:34472-DB
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
CRA No. 2104 of 2025
Jaylal Korwa S/o Munna Korwa Aged About 59 Years (57 In Copy Of
Judgment) Occupation Farmer / Labor, R/o Village Petla- Gomhapara, P.S.
Sitapur, District : Surguja (Ambikapur), Chhattisgarh
... Appellant
versus
State Of Chhattisgarh Through Police Station Sitapur, District : Surguja
(Ambikapur), Chhattisgarh
--- Respondent
(Cause title taken from Case Information System)
For Appellant
:
Mr. Chetan Singh Chauhan, Advocate
For Respondent/State
:
Mr. Shaleen Singh Baghel, Govt. Advocate
Hon'ble Shri Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
Hon'ble Shri Ravindra Kumar Agrawal, Judge
Judgment on Board
Per Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
06/08/2026
1.
The present appeal has been listed for consideration on I.A. No. 1 of
2025, which is an application for suspension of sentence and grant of
bail. Considering the fact that the appellant is in jail since 24.06.2020,
VED
PRAKASH
DEWANGAN
Digitally
signed by
VED
PRAKASH
DEWANGAN
Date:
2026.08.19
10:48:46
+0530
with the consent of the parties, the appeal is being heard finally.
Accordingly, the I.A. No. 1 of 2025 is disposed of.
2.
Present is a criminal appeal under Section 415(2) of the Bhartiya
Nagrik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 against the impugned judgment of
conviction and sentence dated 13.04.2023, passed by the learned
Sessions Judge, Surguja (Ambikapur), in Sessions Case No. 79 of
2020, whereby the appellant has been convicted for the offence
under Section 302 of IPC and sentenced for R.I. for life with fine of
Rs. 1000/-, in default of payment of fine, additional R.I. for three
months.
Conviction
U/s. 302 of the IPC
3.
Sentence
Life imprisonment with fine of Rs.
1000/-, in default of payment of fine,
additional R.I. for 3 months.
The case of the prosecution in brief is that, on 21.06.2020, the
complainant Manoj Yadav (PW-1) lodged a merg intimation (exhibit
P-1) at police station Sitapur that he took the deceased and her
husband to his house at village Dhodhegaon as labourer. On
19.06.2020, he left them at village Petla. On 20.06.2020, they again
came back to village Dhodhegaon and after putting their luggage in
their room, they had gone for a walk towards vicinity. When they had
not returned, their whereabouts could not be found. On 21.06.2020,
the village Sarpanch informed that the dead body of his labourer is
lying in front of the house of Kampa Nagwanwhi. He saw the dead
body and informed it to the police. During the merg inquiry inquest
(exhibit P-10) of the dead body of the deceased was prepared in
presence of the witnesses, who noticed injuries on her body and
therefore, the dead body of the deceased was sent for its
postmortem to Community Health Centre, Sitapur. Dr. Martin Nikunj
(PW-7) conducted postmortem of the dead body of the deceased and
gave his report (exhibit P-15). While conducting the postmortem, the
doctor noticed various injuries on her body and opined that the
deceased died due to shock resulted from head injuries. Her death is
homicidal in nature.
4.
Spot map (exhibit P-2) was prepared by the police and exhibit P-4
was prepared by the patwari. Blood stained and plain soil have been
seized vide seizure memo (exhibit P-7). Statement of the witnesses
have been recorded and then the FIR (exhibit P-19) was registered
against the appellant for the offence under Section 302 of IPC. The
appellant was arrested on 24.06.2020 and his memorandum
statement (exhibit P-6) was recorded. Based on his memorandum
statement, the t-shirt has been seized vide seizure memo (exhibit P8). The mangalsutra of the deceased, broken pieces of bangles, one
torch and one wooden club have also been seized from the spot vide
seizure memo (exhibit P-17). The wooden club was sent for query
report of the doctor, who gave his report (exhibit P-16) and opined
that the injuries found on the body of the deceased would have been
caused by the said wooden club. The blood stained and plain soil,
wooden club seized from the spot, clothes of the deceased and
t-shirt of the appellant were sent for its chemical examination to
Regional FSL Ambikapur, from where report (exhibit P-22) was
received and blood was found on the wooden club seized from the
spot and t-shirt of the appellant.
5.
After completion of usual investigation, charge sheet for the offence
under Section 302 of IPC against the appellant was filed before the
learned Judicial Magistrate First Class, Sitapur. The case was
committed to the court of learned Sessions Judge, Surguja,
Ambikapur for its trial. The learned trial Court framed charge against
the appellant under Section 302 of IPC. The denied the charge and
claimed trial.
6.
In order to prove the charge against the appellant, the prosecution
has examined as many as 14 witnesses. Statement of the appellant
under Section 313 CRPC has also been recorded in which he denied
the circumstances that appears against him, pleaded innocence and
submitted that he has been falsely implicated in the offence.
7.
After appreciation of oral as well as documentary evidence led by the
prosecution, the learned trial Court has convicted and sentenced the
appellant as has been mentioned in the earlier part of this judgment.
Hence this appeal.
8.
Learned counsel for the appellant would submit that the prosecution
has failed to prove its case beyond reasonable doubt. There are
material omissions and contradictions in the evidence of the
prosecution witnesses and their statements are inconsistent. There is
no eyewitness to the incident and the case of the prosecution is
based on the circumstantial evidence. Although the prosecution’s
case is based on last seen evidence, however the said circumstance
of last seen have also not been proved by the prosecution. There is
no motive proved by the prosecution to commit the murder of the
deceased. Even no weapon of offence has been seized from the
appellant. The chain of circumstances have not been proved and
there are various missing links. The learned trial Court relying upon
the uncorroborated evidence and the conduct of the appellant that he
also ran away from the place after the incident, therefore, by drawing
presumption against the appellant, he has been convicted. He would
also submit that the dead body was found in an open place and in
view of the evidence produced by the prosecution, the same are not
sufficient to hold him guilty. Therefore, the appeal may be allowed
and the appellant may be acquitted.
9.
On the other hand, learned counsel for the State opposes the
submissions made by learned counsel for the appellant and has
submitted that there is sufficient evidence available in the case
against the appellant that he committed the murder of the deceased
Sampatti Korwa, who was the wife of the appellant. The appellant
was last seen with the company of the deceased. Thereafter, the
appellant went absconding and the dead body of his wife was found
on the road. Post occurrence conduct of the appellant is also
suspicious. On the t-shirt of the appellant blood has been found int
eh FSL report, for which there is no explanation. He would also
submit that when both of them left the house together then it is for
the appellant to explain as at what point of time, he departed her
company. On these circumstances, form a complete chain pointing
towards guilt of the appellant for commission of murder of his wife.
The judgment passed by the learned trial Court is well reasoned and
does not require any interference.
10.
We have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
record with utmost circumspection.
11.
So far as the homicidal death of the deceased is concerned, the
defence have not specifically denied the homicidal death of the
deceased. The prosecution relied upon the evidence of Dr. Martin
Nikunj (PW-7), who conducted the postmortem of the dead body of
the deceased. He stated in his evidence that on 21.06.2020, the
dead body of the deceased was brought before him and he
conducted its postmortem and found lacerated wound on his right
side of forehead. Another lacerated wound on right temporal region,
ecchymosis present on left cheek, right buttock and back side. All
injuries were antemortem in nature and he opined that the deceased
Sampatti died due to shock resulted from head injuries, which is
homicidal in nature and he proved it in homicidal report (exhibit P15). In his cross-examination, he admitted that the injuries found on
the body of the deceased, could have also been caused by dashing
in hard object or fall on the hard and rough surface. He did not found
any alcohol contents in the abdomen of the deceased. Relying upon
the evidence of the doctor, who conducted the postmortem, the
learned trial Court held that the death of the deceased was
homicidal, which in the opinion of this Court does not suffer from any
perversity or illegality.
12.
So far as the involvement of the appellant in the offence in question
is concerned, we again examined the evidence. The case of the
prosecution is based on the last seen evidence, presence of blood in
the t-shirt of the appellant and his post occurrence conduct and nonexplanation of the circumstances, under which his wife is found to be
in homicidal death.
13.
PW-1, Manoj Kumar Yadav is the person in whose property the
appellant and the deceased were employed as a labourer. He stated
in his evidence that the appellant and the deceased were with him
and they came there just a day before the date of incident. On
20.06.2020, he took them to village Dhodhegaon and after putting
their luggage in the house, they went for a walk towards vicinity. He
searched them up to 9-10 PM in the night, but there whereabouts
could not be found. In the next morning, his driver Guleshwar
informed him that the dead body of his labourer is lying near the
house of Kampa Nagwanshi. When he went there, he found that it
was the dead body of the deceased Sampatti Korwa. He tried to
search the appellant, but his whereabouts could not be found and
then he lodged merg intimation (exhibit P-1). Though this witness has
turned hostile, but he supported that both the appellant and
deceased went together from their house and thereafter, the
deceased was found dead and the appellant was missing. Though in
cross-examination, he stated that the relation between the appellant
and the deceased were good and there was no quarrel between
them, but the evidence of this witness supported the fact that, both of
them were together, when they left their house.
14.
PW-2 is Duryodhan Yadav, who is the father of PW-1/Manoj Yadav.
He stated in his evidence that his son Manoj Yadav took the
appellant and the deceased for work of labourer just a day before the
date of incident and in the next morning, the dead body of the
deceased was found in front of the house of Kampa Nagwanshi,
since the appellant was not present there, they suspected that he
committed her murder. This witness has also declared hostile,
however from the evidence of this witness, the conduct of the
appellant surfaced that he was absconding.
15.
PW-4 Sushila Minj has stated that the appellant and the deceased
both had come to village Dhodhegaon for their work. On 21.06.2020,
on receiving information of the incident, she too had gone there and
saw the dead body of the deceased. At some distance of the dead
body, the wooden club, her clothes, broken pieces of bangles,
mangalsutra and torch were lying. Police also reached there. Since,
she also not supported the prosecution case, leading question has
been asked by the prosecution. However, nothing specific in her
evidence either in support of the prosecution or in defence.
16.
PW-5, Ajay Korwa is the son of the appellant, who turned hostile and
not supported the prosecution’s case.
17.
PW-11, Rajesh Minj has stated in his evidence that, on the date of
incident, when he was going towards his field, he saw the dead body
lying near the house of Kampa Nagwanshi and her other wearings
were lying there. When he called Manoj Yadav, he identified the dead
body and informed that she had come along with the appellant for
working in her field. He participated the police investigation and
witness of memorandum and seizure. However he turned hostile and
has not supported the memorandum and seizure.
18.
PW-12, Alrik Lakra, PW-13, Anup Kumar Ekka, and PW-14, Manish
Dhurve are the Inspector of Police, who conducted part of the
investigation and proved the same on their part of investigation,
which they conducted.
19.
From the aforesaid evidence, it is quite vivid that, a day before the
date of incident, the appellant and the deceased came to village
Dhodhegaon and after putting their luggage in their house, they
proceeded towards vicinity for walking. In the very next morning, the
dead body of the deceased was found in front of the house of Kampa
Nagwanshi in injured condition and the appellant was absconding,
who could be arrested only on 24.06.2020. there is no explanation
from the appellant, as to when he departed from the company of the
deceased and how his wife is found injured. His post occurrence
conduct is also relevant in the present case as their present with the
deceased at the time of the incident is established by the
prosecution.
20.
The circumstance of last seen also assumes significance in the
present case. From the evidence of PW-1 Manoj Kumar Yadav,
which, despite the witness having been declared hostile, remains
intact to the extent that the appellant and the deceased had come
together to village Dhodhegaon and, after keeping their luggage in
the house, had proceeded together towards the vicinity for a walk.
The evidence further establishes that thereafter the deceased was
found dead on the following morning, whereas the appellant was not
found at the place and remained untraceable until his arrest on
24.06.2020. Thus, the presence of the appellant and the deceased
together immediately prior to the occurrence stands established. The
fact that the appellant was the husband of the deceased and was
admittedly accompanying her shortly before her death assumes
considerable significance in the facts of the present case.
21.
It is true that the circumstance of last seen, by itself, may not
invariably be sufficient to record a finding of guilt unless the proximity
of time between the accused being last seen with the deceased and
the death of the deceased is so close as to rule out the possibility of
intervention by any other person. In the present case, however, the
appellant and the deceased were together when they left their house
on the evening of 20.06.2020, the appellant was thereafter found
missing, and the dead body of the deceased was discovered in the
very next morning. No material has been brought on record to
indicate that, during the intervening period, the deceased had parted
company with the appellant and was seen alive in the company of
any other person. Further, the appellant has offered no explanation
as to when or in what circumstances he parted company with the
deceased. Therefore, the circumstance of last seen, when
considered along with the subsequent conduct of the appellant and
the other circumstances proved by the prosecution, constitutes a
relevant incriminating circumstance against him.
22.
In the case of “Rohtash Kumar v. State of Haryana” 2013 (14) SCC
434, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has held that:“32. In cases where the accused was last seen
with the deceased victim (last seen together
theory) just before the incident, it becomes the
duty of the accused to explain the circumstances
under which the death of the victim occurred.
(Vide Nika Ram v. State of H.P. 1 and Ganeshlal v.
State of Maharashtra2.)
33. In Trimukh Maroti Kirkan v. State of
Maharashtra3 this Court held as under: (SCC p.
694, para 22)
"22. Where an accused is alleged to have
committed the murder of his wife and the
prosecution succeeds in leading evidence
to show that shortly before the commission
of crime they were seen together or the
offence takes place in the dwelling home
where the husband also normally resided, it
has been consistently held that if the
accused does not offer any explanation
how the wife received injuries or offers an
explanation which is found to be false, it is
a strong circumstance which indicates that
he is responsible for commission of the
crime." (See also Prithipal Singh v. State of
Punjab 31.)
34. Thus, the doctrine of "last seen together"
shifts the burden of proof on the accused,
requiring him to explain how the incident had
occurred. Failure on the part of the accused to
furnish any explanation in this regard, would give
rise to a very strong presumption against him.
23.
The post-occurrence conduct of the appellant also assumes
significance in the facts and circumstances of the present case. It is
not a case where the appellant, after finding his wife lying in an
injured condition, made any attempt to inform the owner of the
1(1972)2 SCC 80
2(1992)3 SCC 106
3(2006)10 SCC 681
property, the villagers, the police or any other person regarding the
incident or sought medical assistance for her. On the contrary,
immediately after the occurrence, the appellant was found missing
from the place where he and the deceased had stayed together,
while the dead body of the deceased was discovered in the vicinity
on the following morning. The appellant remained unavailable and
could be apprehended only on 24.06.2020. Such conduct,
particularly when the appellant was admittedly in the company of the
deceased shortly before the occurrence, is a relevant circumstance
against him. His conduct after the occurrence is inconsistent with the
conduct ordinarily expected from a husband who had discovered his
wife lying injured or dead and, therefore, lends corroboration to the
other incriminating circumstances appearing against him.
24.
Mere abscondence, by itself, cannot be treated as conclusive proof of
guilt. However, in the present case, the abscondence of the appellant
is not being considered in isolation. It has to be appreciated along
with the established circumstance that the appellant and the
deceased were last seen together shortly before the occurrence, the
deceased was thereafter found dead with injuries, and the appellant
failed to furnish any plausible explanation as to when and under what
circumstances he parted company with the deceased or how she
sustained the fatal injuries. The silence of the appellant in respect of
facts especially within his knowledge, coupled with his conduct of
leaving the place of occurrence and remaining unavailable thereafter,
constitutes an additional incriminating circumstance which, when
considered cumulatively with the other circumstances proved by the
prosecution, points towards his involvement in the commission of the
offence.
25.
The facts of the present case can be connected with the principle laid
down in Rohtash Kumar (supra), inasmuch as the present case also
involves the circumstance of the appellant having been last seen in
the company of the deceased shortly before the occurrence, followed
by his unexplained absence from the place of occurrence and his
failure to explain the circumstances in which he parted company with
the deceased. The subsequent conduct of the appellant is therefore
not being considered in isolation, but in conjunction with the
established circumstance of last seen and the other incriminating
circumstances on record. As held by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Rohtash Kumar (supra), where the accused was last seen with the
deceased immediately before the incident, it becomes incumbent
upon him to explain the circumstances under which the death
occurred, and failure to furnish such explanation constitutes a strong
incriminating circumstance. In the present case also, the appellant
has failed to offer any plausible explanation as to when and under
what circumstances he parted company with the deceased, while his
subsequent
abscondence
and
other
conduct
lend
further
corroboration to the prosecution case.
26.
The presence of blood on the t-shirt of the appellant is also a
significant incriminating circumstance against him. The said t-shirt
was seized pursuant to the memorandum statement of the appellant
and, upon chemical examination, blood was found on it as per the
FSL report (Exhibit P-22). The appellant has not offered any
explanation whatsoever as to how blood came to be present on his tshirt, particularly when the deceased, who was last seen in his
company, was subsequently found dead with injuries. The absence
of any plausible or reasonable explanation from the appellant
regarding the presence of blood on his wearing apparel assumes
considerable significance, especially in the backdrop of the other
circumstances
proved
by
the
prosecution.
Thus,
the
said
circumstance provides further corroboration to the prosecution case
and strengthens the chain of circumstances pointing towards the
involvement of the appellant in the homicidal death of the deceased.
27.
The another aspect of the case that the witnesses have been
declared hostile, however, before declaring them hostile,they
sufficiently supported the prosecution’s case regarding last seen and
conduct of the appellant. In the case of Rohtash Kumar (supra) the
Hon'ble Supreme Court has also considered the reliability of the
evidence of hostile witnesses and has been held that:“25. It is a settled legal proposition that evidence
of a prosecution witness cannot be rejected in
toto, merely because the prosecution chose to
treat him as hostile and cross-examined him. The
evidence of such witnesses cannot be treated as
effaced, or washed off the record altogether. The
same can be accepted to the extent that their
version is found to be dependable, upon a careful
scrutiny thereof.
26. In State of U.P. v. Ramesh Prasad Misra 4 this
Court held, that evidence of a hostile witness
would not be rejected in entirety, if the same has
4(1996)10 SCC 360
been given in favour of either the prosecution, or
the accused, but is required to be subjected to
careful scrutiny, and thereafter, that portion of the
evidence which is consistent with either the case
of the prosecution, or that of the defence, may be
relied upon.
27. Therefore, the law permits the court to take
into consideration the deposition of a hostile
witness, to the extent that the same is in
consonance with the case of the prosecution, and
is found to be reliable in careful judicial scrutiny.”
28.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of K.P. Tamilmaran v. The
state By Deputy Superintendent of Police 2025 Livelaw (Sc) 493
has observed that:“36. It is though trite and much overstated but the
maxim "falsus in uno, falsus in omnibus, is not
applicable to our criminal justice system. It is for
the Court to distinguish the wheat from the chaff
while dealing with the depositions of a hostile
witness. Courts can rely upon that part of the
deposition
of
a
hostile
witness
which
is
corroborated by other evidence on record. This
Court in Bhajju v. State of Madhya Pradesh
(2012) 4 SCC 327 discussed the worth of the
evidence of a hostile witness in the following
words:
"36. It is settled law that the evidence of
hostile witnesses can also be relied upon
by the prosecution to the extent to which it
supports the prosecution version of the
incident. The evidence of such witnesses
cannot be treated as washed off the
records, it remains admissible in trial and
there is no legal bar to base the conviction
of the accused upon such testimony, if
corroborated by other reliable evidence…"
If part of the evidence of a hostile witness
corroborates with other reliable evidence, then
that part of the evidence is admissible. Once a
prosecution witness has been declared hostile
and then cross-examined by the prosecution,
then it is for the Court to evaluate the veracity of
the testimony. There can be several reasons for a
witness to turn hostile and the court must also
look into these factors while evaluating the
evidence given by a hostile witness. It is an
uncomfortable reality in our criminal Courts for a
prosecution witness to turn hostile. But then the
purpose of a Trial Court is to go to the truth of the
matter. Whatever evidence is there before the
Court must be examined, tested, corroborated
(whenever necessary), before a verdict can be
finally given.
29.
In view of the foregoing discussion, this Court is of the considered
opinion that the prosecution has succeeded in establishing a
complete and unbroken chain of circumstances against the appellant.
The circumstance of last seen, the subsequent abscondence and
post-occurrence conduct of the appellant, coupled with his failure to
offer any plausible explanation as to when and under what
circumstances he parted company with the deceased and presence
of blood in the t-shirt of the appellant, constitute relevant and
incriminating circumstances pointing towards his involvement in the
homicidal death of his wife. Accordingly, this Court finds no infirmity
or perversity in the judgment of conviction and sentence passed by
the learned trial Court warranting interference in the present appeal
and the appeal filed by the appellant is hereby dismissed.
30.
The appellant is reported to be in jail since 24.06.2020. He shall
serve the entire sentence as awarded by the learned trial Court.
31.
Registry is directed to send a copy of this judgment to the concerned
Superintendent of Jail where the appellant Jaylal Korwa undergoing
his jail sentence to serve the same on the appellant informing him
that he is at liberty to assail the present judgment passed by this
Court by preferring an appeal before the Hon’ble Supreme Court with
the assistance of High Court Legal Services Committee or the
Supreme Court Legal Services Committee.
32.
Let a copy of this judgment and the original records be transmitted to
the trial Court concerned forthwith for necessary information and
compliance.
Sd/(Ravindra Kumar Agrawal)
Judge
ved
Sd/(Ramesh Sinha)
Chief Justice
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review