Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:MLHC:565
Serial No.01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
CRP No.23 of 2025
Date of order : 10.06.2026
Shri Jawhar T. Mordani,
S/o (L) Tikamdas T. Mordani,
R/o Oakland, Shillong – 793001,
East Khasi Hills District.
Meghalaya.
…..Petitioner
-VERSUSSmti. Sushila Devi Agarwal,
W/o Shri Ram Gopal Agarwal,
R/o G.S. Road,
Shillong – 793001.
East Khasi Hills District,
Meghalaya.
…..Respondent
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice B. Bhattacharjee, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
: Mr. S. Sen, Adv. With
Mr. S. Paul, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. R.K. Agarwal, Sr. Adv.
Dr. P. Agarwal, Adv.
Judgment and Order (Oral)
1.
Heard Mr. S. Sen, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner and Mr.
R. K. Agarwal, learned Senior counsel assisted by Dr. P. Agarwal, learned
counsel appearing for the respondent.
2026:MLHC:565
2.
By this revision petition, the petitioner has assailed the impugned order
dated 21.07.2025 passed in Misc. Case No. 76 (H) 2024 arising out of
Ejectment Suit No. 11 (H) of 2017 allowing the application of the respondent
under Order XVI Rule 1 Sub-Rule 3 read with section 151 of the Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908 (CPC).
3.
The brief facts of this case are that the respondent as plaintiff instituted
Ejectment Suit No. 11 (H) of 2017 against the petitioner before the Court of
the Assistant District Judge, Shillong. On 18.05.2023 the respondent filed an
application registered as Petition No. 117 of 2023 under Order XVI rule 1
Sub-rule 3 read with section 151 CPC for allowing the respondent to adduce
the evidence of one Shri. Ram Gopal Agarwal and Shri. Frank Kenneth
Lyngdoh whose names were not reflected in the list of witnesses submitted by
the respondent. The petitioner objected to the said prayer by filing a showcause. The learned Trial Court, after hearing the parties, dismissed the Petition
No.117 by the order dated 04.09.2023. The order dated 04.09.2023 was not
challenged before any higher forum. However, on 28.11.2024, the respondent
filed another application under Order XVI rule 1 sub-rule 3 read with section
151 CPC registered as Misc. Case 76 (H) of 2024 before the Trial Court for
allowing the respondent to adduce the evidence of abovenamed Shri. Ram
Gopal Agarwal by replacing (L) Harikishan Agarwal @ Harikishan Agarwala.
The petitioner filed his show-cause against the said application. The learned
Trial Court, after hearing the parties, allowed the same by the impugned order
dated 21.07.2025. Being aggrieved, the petitioner has preferred this revision
petition.
4.
The prime contentions raised in this revision petition appears to be
based on the principle of res judicata and question of non-consideration of
delay in filing the application seeking adduction of evidence of Shri. Ram
Gopal Agarwal. The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the Trial
Court resorted to improper exercise of jurisdiction by passing the impugned
2026:MLHC:565
order without adjudicating the specific issue of application of res judicata and
the question of inordinate delay in filing the application. He submits that once
the Trial Court by an earlier order dated 04.09.2023 had rejected the prayer
for adducing evidence of Shri. Ram Gopal Agarwal in exercise of its
jurisdiction under Order XVI rule 1 sub-rule 3 read with section 151 CPC, the
second application under the same provision of law in respect of the same
witness could not have been allowed. He further submits that the Trial Court
failed to exercise its proper jurisdiction by ignoring the question of delay
which was vital for considering the prayer made in the application. He,
therefore, submits that the learned Trial Court has committed a gross error in
passing the impugned order and prays that same may be set aside and quashed.
5.
The learned Senior counsel appearing for the respondent, on the other
hand, contends that the principle of res judicata has no application in the
present scenario as the matter concerns only procedural aspects and not the
substantial right of the parties. By referring to the provision of section 105
CPC and the decision of the Apex Court in Channappa (D) through LRs.
Versus Parvatewwa (D) through LRs, (2026) 0 INSC 343, he submits that the
impugned order cannot be considered to have attained finality and does not
tantamount to a final adjudication of rights. He submits that no prayer was
made by the respondent for obtaining any summons for attendance of any
witness and the learned Trial Court, being conscious of the fact, has allowed
to adduce evidence of Shri. Ram Gopal Agarwal not strictly in exercise of
jurisdiction under Order XVI rule 1 sub-rule 3, but in view of provision of
rule 1A of Order XVI which allows any party to bring any witness to give
evidence or to produce documents. He further submits that mentioning of
wrong provision or non-mentioning of a provision of law in an application
does not by itself invalidate an order and in support thereof he places reliance
on the decisions of P.K. Palanisamy Vrs. N. Arumugham and Anr, 2009 AIR
SCW 5385 and Usmaw Khwan Village Dorbar Vrs. State of Meghalaya, AIR
2026:MLHC:565
2026 Meghalaya 56. To impress upon this Court that the legislature did not
put a total prohibition on the party to produce the witnesses, he cites the
decision of Lalitha J. Rai Vrs. Aithappa Rai, (1995) 4 SCC 244. Further, the
decision of Nandi Infrastructure Corridor Enterprises Ltd. Vrs. B. Gurappa
Naidu, (2026) 0 INSC 434 is also placed into service to project limits of
jurisdiction of the High Court under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
He concludes by submitting that in view of the settled position of law, no
illegality can be attributed to the impugned order and the present revision
petition, being devoid of merits, is liable to be dismissed.
6.
Perusal of the materials on record reveal that the Misc. Case No. 76 (H)
of 2024 was filed by the respondent by invoking Order XVI rule 1 sub-rule 3
read with Section 151 CPC for allowing the respondent to adduce the evidence
of Shri. Ram Gopal Agarwal. An earlier application bearing Petition No. 117
of 2023 was also preferred by the petitioner under the above-mentioned
provision of law for adduction of evidence of Shri. Ram Gopal Agarwal and
another witness, which came to be rejected by the order dated 04.09.2023. The
order of rejection was not challenged before any other higher forum. Hence,
the Misc. Case No. 76 (H) of 2024 was the second application before the Trial
Court for allowing the petitioner to adduce evidence of Shri. Ram Gopal
Agarwal after rejection of the first one. The only difference between the two
applications is that while petition No. 117 of 2023 was filed by contending
that the name of Shri. Ram Gopal Agarwal was left out from the list of witness
due to bonafide mistake, the plea taken in the Misc. Case No. 76 (H) of 2024
was that as one witness in the original list of witnesses, namely, Shri.
Harikishan Agarwal passed away on 21.09.2023, he be replaced by Shri. Ram
Gopal Agarwal as a witness in the case. There appears no provision in Order
XVI rule 1 sub-rule 3 which deals with substitution of witness; it only deals
with the Court’s discretionary power to allow a party to call additional
witnesses who were not included in the original list, provided the party shows
2026:MLHC:565
sufficient cause for the omission. Hence, any permission granted by the Court
under the aforesaid provision of law has to be with regard to additional witness
and not substituted witness.
7.
Nothing has been brought into record to point out that the respondent
raised the plea of filing of Misc. Case No.76 (H) of 2024 under wrong
provision of law during the hearing of the application before the Trial Court.
The learned Trial Court, after hearing the parties, by relying on the proposition
of law laid down in the case of Mange Ram Vrs. Brij Mohan and Others
(1983) 4 SCC 36, allowed the respondent to adduce evidence of Shri. Ram
Gopal Agarwal. In the case of Mange Ram (Supra), the Apex Court held that
sub-rule 3 of rule 1 and rule 1A operate in two different areas and cater to two
different situations. Sub-rule 3 of rule 1 confers wider jurisdiction on the Court
to cater to a situation where the party has failed to name the witness in the list
and yet the party is unable to produce him or her on his own under rule 1A
and in such a situation the party of necessity has to seek the assistance of the
Court under rule 3 to procure the presence of the witness. In the present matter,
the respondent in Misc. Case No. 76 (H) of 2024 has nowhere made a
statement that Shri. Ram Gopal Agarwal was under her control and he would
be brought in the Court as a witness without seeking any assistance from the
Court.
8.
Although, interlocutory or procedural orders do not attract full statutory
application of res judicata under section 11 of the CPC, general principles of
res judicata apply across different stages of the same suit. If the first
application to summon a witness was heard on its merits and rejected because
of failure to show sufficient cause or on the ground of delay, a second
application repeating the same facts, logic or arguments cannot be filed.
9.
It is clear from the impugned order that the learned Trial Court did not
allow the application after being satisfied that sufficient cause was shown for
the omission to mention the name of Shri. Ram Gopal Agarwal in the original
2026:MLHC:565
list, but on the basis of the provision of rule 1A of Order XVI CPC. As there
remains no confusion that sub-rule 3 of rule 1 and rule 1A of rule XVI operate
in two different areas and cater to two different situations, the Misc. Case No.
76 (H) of 2024 could not have been decided by applying the underlying
principle of provision of rule 1A of Order XVI CPC.
10.
The authorities cited by the learned Senior Counsel do not deal with the
situation where a second application under Order XVI rule1 sub-rule 3 was
considered and allowed by the Court. The question of mention of wrong
provision of law and treating the application of the respondent under rule 1A
of Order XVI CPC or Section 151 CPC also does not arise as there is no legal
requirement of passing any prior order by the Court for bringing any witness
to give evidence or to produce documents without applying for summons in
terms of rule 1A of Order XVI.
11.
For what has been discussed above, the impugned order dated
21.07.2025 is set aside and quashed. The review petition is allowed without
prejudice to the right of the respondent under rule 1A of Order XVI CPC.
12.
No costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
10.06.2026
“Abhinandan,PS”
ABHINANDAN KUMAR
Date: 2026.06.11 14:07:32 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review