Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CRR-3384-2025 (O&M)
! ! "
JASKARAN SINGH
#
$ % #
&
'
&
(
)))))
! " #! !$
'
% &!
#
(((((
'
&
1.
(
*
+ , -.
The instant revision petition has been filed against the judgment
dated 07.03.2024 passed by the Judicial Magistrate First Class, Sri Muktsar
Sahib wherein the the petitioner has been convicted for a period of two years
with a fine of Rs. 1,000/- and in default of payment of fine, to further undergo
simple imprisonment for a period of 07 days as well as the judgment dated
13.11.2025 passed by the Sessions Judge, Sri Muktsar Sahib whereby his
appeal had been partly allowed and while maintaining the judgment of
conviction, the sentence had been reduced to one year.
2.
Briefly stated, the facts giving rise to the present proceedings are
that Complaint bearing CIS No. NIA/73/2021 was instituted by the
respondent–complainant, a non-banking finance company, against the
VISHAL SHARMA
2026.01.28 13:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
/0012/ ! 3 + 4#.
)
petitioner herein. The respondent–complainant averred that it is engaged in
the business of financing, leasing and hire purchase of machines and
equipment. It was averred that the petitioner approached the respondent–
complainant for financial assistance for purchase of a vehicle, namely TATA
LPT 2515 bearing registration No. RJ-04GA-0601, for his personal
requirements. Pursuant thereto, a loan agreement was executed between the
parties on 13.07.2018, whereunder a sum of Rs. 3,80,000/- was advanced to
the petitioner. The loan amount was agreed to be repaid in 36 equated monthly
instalments. According to the respondent–complainant, the petitioner
committed default in adhering to the terms and conditions of repayment and
failed to liquidate the outstanding dues despite repeated demands. Eventually,
towards discharge of his liability, the petitioner issued cheque No. 667443
dated 14.12.2020 for an amount of Rs. 3,80,000/- (representing the principal
amount) and a post-dated cheque No. 667444 dated 21.12.2020 for a sum of
Rs. 1,76,111/- towards overdue loan dues was issued.
3.
Upon presentation, both the cheques were dishonoured and
returned unpaid vide bank memos dated 15.12.2020 and 24.12.2020,
respectively, with the endorsement “Funds Insufficient”. The petitioner was
informed about the dishonour of the cheques and was called upon to clear the
outstanding liability; however, no payment was forthcoming. Consequently,
a legal notice dated 13.01.2021 was issued to the petitioner. Despite service
of the said notice, the petitioner failed to make payment within the stipulated
period, compelling the respondent–complainant to institute a complaint under
Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 before the Court of the
learned Illaqa Magistrate.
VISHAL SHARMA
2026.01.28 13:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
/0012/ ! 3 + 4#.
4.
*
Upon consideration of the preliminary evidence, the petitioner
was summoned vide order dated 23.02.2021.
5.
Notice of accusation was thereafter served upon him, to which
he pleaded not guilty, resulting in commencement of trial. The parties led their
respective evidence in support of their claims.
6.
Upon appreciation of the evidence and hearing the rival
submissions, the Judicial Magistrate First Class, Sri Muktsar Sahib, vide
judgment dated 07.03.2024, convicted the petitioner for the offence
punishable under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, and
sentenced him to undergo rigorous imprisonment for a period of two years.
7.
Aggrieved by the said judgment, the petitioner preferred an
appeal before the Court of the learned Sessions Judge, Sri Muktsar Sahib,
being Criminal Appeal No. 38 dated 06.04.2024. The said appeal was partly
allowed vide judgment dated 13.11.2025. While the finding of conviction was
affirmed, the sentence was modified and reduced from rigorous imprisonment
for a period of two years to rigorous imprisonment for a period of one year,
along with a fine of Rs. 1,000/-. Hence, the present petition.
8.
When the matter came up for hearing on 08.01.2026, Counsel for
the petitioner sought time to complete instructions as to whether the petitioner
would be inclined to clear the outstanding dues or not. Time was thus granted.
9.
On resumed hearing, Counsel for the petitioner contends that the
petitioner has expressed his inability to clear the dues.
10.
Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner contends
that the cheques in question were issued as security cheques and have been
misused by the respondent No.2-complainant. He further contends that a
VISHAL SHARMA
2026.01.28 13:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
/0012/ ! 3 + 4#.
+
matter of fact, the respondent has failed to lead any evidence as would show
that there was a default on the part of the petitioner in clearing the loan
account. In the absence of proof establishing the liability, the respondent could
not have present the cheques for encashment for the amount as filled up. It
thus submitted that both the Courts have fell in error in drawing adverse
inferences against the petitioner and in holding him guilty, despite the absence
of material evidence to substantiate the alleged default or liability.
11.
I have heard learned Counsel appearing on behalf of the
petitioner and have gone through the impugned judgments.
12.
So far as the contention of the petitioner that no evidence has
been led by the respondents to establish that there was a default of the loan
and hence the amount filled up in the cheque was incorrect is concerned, as
per the provisions contained in the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, there is
a presumption in favour of the holder of cheque that he is holder in due course
and that the petitioner had signed the aforesaid cheque amount after
acknowledging the liability towards.
13.
Learned counsel for the petitioner has failed to point to any
material, from the evidence led by the petitioner, or even from the crossexamination of the complainant’s witnesses, that no default had been
committed by him or that the statement of the loan account did not support
the amount mentioned in the cheque, or that the cheque was not in lieu of a
legally enforceable debt. It is well settled that the initial burden to rebut the
statutory presumptions under the Negotiable Instruments Act lies upon the
accused. Only if such initial burden is discharged, by leading evidence or
eliciting material admissions in cross-examination, does the onus shift back
VISHAL SHARMA
2026.01.28 13:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
/0012/ ! 3 + 4#.
upon the complainant to establish that there was a legally enforceable debt for
which the cheque was issued. In the present case, no such initial onus was
discharged by the petitioner. Neither during cross-examination nor by leading
defence evidence did the petitioner demonstrate that there was no liability. In
the absence of any such foundational material having been brought on record,
the argument sought to be raised on behalf of the petitioner cannot be
examined for the first time, at the stage of revisional jurisdiction.
14.
Furthermore, it has also emerged from the proceedings before the
trial Court that a default notice had, in fact, been issued to the petitioner and
the relevant documents evidencing such communication were duly served
upon him. This clearly establishes that the petitioner was aware of the
defaulted amount. The communication regarding default thus stood proved on
record. Additionally, when the statutory legal notice demanding payment was
served upon the petitioner, he did not, at any point in time, send a reply
disputing either the existence of liability or the quantum of the amount
mentioned therein.
15.
It is, therefore, evident that the plea now sought to be raised, that
the liability was not commensurate with the amount filled in the cheque, is an
afterthought and constitutes a new case altogether. Such a plea, having neither
been raised nor substantiated during the course of trial, would not be permitted
to be urged at the revisional stage, in the absence of any supporting evidence
or even a suggestion put to the complainant’s witnesses. Consequently, the
said contention does not merit acceptance.
16.
Adverting to the argument that the loan amount was never
disbursed to him, the same does not merit acceptance. A perusal of the record
VISHAL SHARMA
2026.01.28 13:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
/0012/ ! 3 + 4#.
,
reveals that no such plea was ever raised by the petitioner at any stage of the
trial, nor was any suggestion to that effect put to the witnesses during the
course of cross-examination. The said contention is, therefore, clearly an
afterthought and is being argued for the first time at this stage without any
tangible or supporting material. Such an argument, which finds no reflection
either in the defence set up before the trial Court or in the evidence led, would
not be permitted to be raised belatedly in revisional proceedings. The relevant
extract of the order passed by the Court of Sessions Judge reads thus:“11. Learned counsel for the appellant submitted that the
learned trial Court has wrongly passed the impugned judgment
of conviction and order of sentence dated 07.03.2024, without
appreciating the facts, whereas, the case of the complainant is
not proved. He further submitted that complaint was not
maintainable for want of document of incorporation of
respondent finance company. He further submitted that power of
attorney namely Kamal Parkash Sachdeva was not competent
witness as he was substituted later on. He further submitted that
prior to filing of complaint, no recovery notice was issued to the
appellant. It is further submitted that there is no document
regarding recovery proceedings with regard to vehicle. He
further submitted that no amount was due against the appellant
at the time of presentation of cheque and no cheque was issued
by the complainant and same are forged and fabricated. He
prayed that present appeal be accepted and accused/appellant be
acquitted of the notice of accusation.
Xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
18.
The contention of the learned counsel for the
appellant that no recovery notice was issued to the appellant
prior to the filing of the complaint and no document of recovery
proceedings regarding vehicle has been produced on record and
VISHAL SHARMA
2026.01.28 13:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
/0012/ ! 3 + 4#.
-
that of learned counsel for the respondent that present case is
criminal complaint and as such, recovery notice and document
of recovery proceedings were not necessary is considered. The
contention of the learned counsel for the appellant is without any
merit in it. It is settled proposition of law that civil as well
criminal proceedings can go simultaneously. The recovery notice
or recovery proceedings regarding the vehicle are relevant in a
case of civil nature for recovery if filed by respondent's company,
whereas in the criminal proceedings such as 138 NI Act, only
following ingredients were required:
1.
Issuance of cheque in order to discharge legal
enforceable debt;
2.
On presentation of same, the cheque was dishonored for
want of sufficient funds or for any other reason;
3.
Legal notice was given to the accused calling upon him to
make the payment;
4.
Accused failed to make the payment despite issuance of
legal notice.
In the present case, all the four aforementioned ingredients
are fulfilled. As such, there was no necessity to issue recovery
notice or start recovery proceedings prior to the filing of the
complaint. As such, this point is decided against the appellant
and in favour of the respondent.
Point no.4
19. The contention of learned counsel for appellant that
cheques are without any consideration and that of learned
counsel for the respondent that cheques have been issued to
discharge legally enforceable debt is considered. The contention
of the learned counsel for the appellant does not find merit in it.
In view of evidence of CW-1 Kamal Parkash Sachdeva, it stands
proved that appellant availed loan of Rs.3,80,000/- and in order
to discharge the legal enforceable debt, he issued cheque
VISHAL SHARMA
2026.01.28 13:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
/0012/ ! 3 + 4#.
.
No.667443 dated 14.12.2020 of Rs.3,80,000/- and cheque
No.667444 dated 21.12.2020 of Rs. 1,76,111/-, It also stands
proved that on presentation of cheque, the same were dishonored
vide memo Ex.C2 and Ex.C4. It also stands proved that appellant
failed to repay the amount despite issuance of legal notice Ex.C5
issued vide receipt Ex.C6.
20. Except for the denial by the appellant during his
statement under Section 313 Cr.P.C. that no amount was due,
there is nothing on record to disprove the oral and documentary
evidence lead by the respondent's company. There is no reply to
the legal notice Ex.C5 nor it has been alleged that no notice was
received by him. Failure on the part of the appellant-accused to
give reply to the notice leads to the inference that there is merit
in the case of the respondent. I further support my observations
on the basis of law laid down by Sanjabij Tari v. Kishore S.
Borcar, (SC): Law Finder Doc Id #2783882 2025(4)
RCR(Criminal) 420 Criminal Appeal No. 1755 of 2010.
D/d.25.09.2025, wherein it has been held in para No.29 and 30
as under:
"29. Furthermore, the fact that the accused has failed to
reply to the statutory notice under Section 138 of the NI
Act leads to an inference that there is merit in the
Appellant-Complainant's version. This Court in Tedhi
Singh vs. Narayan Dass Mahant, (2022) 6 SCC 735 has
held that the accused has the initial burden to set up the
defence in his reply to the demand notice that the
complainant did not have the financial capacity to advance
the loan. The relevant portion of the said judgment is
reproduced hereinbelow:"10.... The proceedings under Section 138 of the NI
Act is not a civil suit. At the time, when the
complainant gives his evidence, unless a case is set
up in the reply notice to the statutory notice sent,
VISHAL SHARMA
2026.01.28 13:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
/0012/ ! 3 + 4#.
/
that the complainant did not have the wherewithal,
it cannot be expected of the complainant to initially
lead evidence to show that he had the financial
capacity. To that extent, the courts in our view were
right in holding on those lines. However, the
accused has the right to demonstrate that the
complainant in a particular case did not have the
capacity and therefore, the case of the accused is
acceptable which he can do by producing
independent materials, namely, by examining his
witnesses and producing documents. It is also open
to him to establish the very same aspect by pointing
to the materials produced by the complainant
himself. He can further, more importantly, achieve
this result through the examination of the witnesses
of the complainant. Ultimately, it becomes the duty
of the courts to consider carefully and appreciate
the totality of the evidence and then come to a
conclusion whether in the given case, the accused
has shown that the case of the complainant is in peril
for the reason that the accused has established a
probable defence."
(emphasis supplied)
30. This Court in MMTC Ltd. and Another vs.
Medchl Chemicals & Pharma (P) Ltd. and Another, (2002)
1 SCC 234 has specifically held that when a statutory
notice is not replied, it has to be presumed that the cheque
was issued towards the discharge of liability."
21.
Further, the oral evidence of CW-1 finds corroboration in
view of documentary evidence viz. cheque No.667443 Ex.Cl,
return memos Ex.C2, cheque No.667444 Ex.C3, return memo
Ex.C4, legal notice Ex.C5, postal receipt Ex.C6. Both the
VISHAL SHARMA
2026.01.28 13:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
cheques were dishonored on account of Insufficient Funds, so it
/0012/ ! 3 + 4#.
can be presumed that cheques were issued by the appellant and
same bears his signature. Once, the signature on the cheque are
proved, presumption lies that cheques were issued in order to
discharge the legal enforceable debt.
Xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
25.
The contention of the learned counsel for the
appellant that cheques are forged and fabricated is also without
any merit in it. The appellant has not appeared into witness box
to prove the fact that both the cheques do not bear his signatures.
No reply to the notice was given. No expert has been examined
by the appellant to prove the fact that signatures on the cheques
are forged and fabricated. I further support these observations
on the basis of law laid down by Hon'ble Punjab & Haryana
High Court in case titled as Balvinder Singh Vs M/s Baisakhi
Ram Saina Ram, 2008 (2) R.C.R. (Civil) 467, wherein it was
observed in Para 12, as under:
"The defendant did take up the plea of forgery of the
pronote and the receipt but failed to examine any
Handwriting Expert. On account of non-examination of
such an expert, an adverse inference can be safely drawn
against the defendant that in case such an expert had been
examined, he would have deposed against him."
Thus, this point is decided against the appellant and in
favour of the respondent.
17.
A perusal of the judgment rendered by the learned Sessions Court
makes it abundantly clear that all the issues now sought to be reagitated by
the petitioner were duly considered and adjudicated upon and findings have
already been returned thereon. This Court, while exercising its revisional
jurisdiction, does not sit as a court of appeal so as to re-appreciate the evidence
or substitute its own opinion for that of the trial Court or the appellate Court.
VISHAL SHARMA
2026.01.28 13:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
/0012/ ! 3 + 4#.
Interference in revision is warranted only where there is a patent defect,
manifest illegality, material irregularity or perversity apparent on the face of
the record. In the absence of any such infirmity in the judgments under
challenge, this Court would ordinarily refrain from interfering with concurrent
findings of fact. It is also pertinent to note that the learned Additional Sessions
Judge, Sri Muktsar Sahib, has already extended due concession to the
petitioner by partly allowing the appeal and reducing the substantive sentence
from rigorous imprisonment for a period of two years to rigorous
imprisonment for a period of one year. In view of the aforesaid circumstances,
no further interference is called for in the exercise of revisional jurisdiction.
18.
Counsel for the petitioner has failed to refer to any illegality,
perversity or impropriety in the conclusions drawn by both the Courts and the
said conclusions cannot be faulted with.
19.
Consequently, I find that the petition lacks merit and the same is
accordingly dismissed.
20.
"" #
1 2 & ""!
3 ! " &!
4 5$ ' ! 6$ !
!"
'
+'
&
* ! "
7# #
7# #
VISHAL SHARMA
2026.01.28 13:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
!8 19 !
!;"
: 9
: 9
(
.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review