Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 32ee I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
FRIDAY. THE SIXTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE E.V. VENUGOPAL
WRIT PETITION NO: 38805 OF 2025
Betwee n:
Jangati Vijay, S/o: J. Rama Shekar. Aged about 45 years, Occ: Business,
Rl/o Flat No 804, Tower No 12, Pra)ay fVega Polis, near Gokul Plots, KPHB,
Kukatpally, Hyderabad 500 085
.PETITIONER
AND
The State of Telangana, Represented by The Principal Secretary Home
Department, Dr. BR Ambedkar, Telangana Secreteriait, Tank Bund Road,
Hyderabad
2. Alwal Traffic Police Station, Represented By the lnspector, Alwal,
Secunderabad
3. The Sub lnspector of Police, Alwal Traffic Police Station, Secunderabad
4. N Sai Ram Rao, S/o: N Narendar Rao, Aged about 33 years, Occ: Business,
R/o H No 6-48, Ramayampet l\4andal, Venkatapur, Medak District, Telangana
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 o{ the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased
to issue a writ order or direction more the nature of a Writ of Mandamus declaring
the action of offr-cial respondents more particularly that of respondents 2 and 3, in
seizing my Mahindra make XUV 500 vehicle bearing registration No TS 0B FY 5298,
on ground of drunkenness of 4th respondent, while driving the same on 1010712025
in terms of Traffic Violation A 8080P without even giving it to the custody of Court
contrary to the orders of this Honorable Court in WP No s 164712021 and batch
wherein this Honorable Court has affirmatively held that the official respondents lack
any power to seize vehicles in case of drunken driving as being illegal, arbitrary,
Unconstitutional, being violative of Articles 14, 1 I and 3004, and consequently
direct respondents 2 and 3 to release the vehicle.
lA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to direct
the respondents 2 and 3, to release my Mahindra make XUV 500 vehicle bearing
registration No TS 0B FY 5298 pending the disposal of main petition.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI IMMANENI RAMA RAO
Counsel for the Respondent Nos.1 to 3: GP FOR HOME
Counsel for the Respondent No.4:--The Court made the following: ORDER
,,/
TN TIIE HIGH COTIRT FOIT TIIE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAI)
THE HONOURABI,E SRI JUSI'TCE E.V.VENUGOPAL
WRIT PETITION No.38805 of 2025
DATE:06.02.2026
Between:
Mr. Jangati Vijay.
. ..
Petitioncr
ANt)
The State of Telangana,,
Rep by its Principal Secretary,
[{ome Department,
TS Secretariat buildings,
Hyderabad and 3 others.
.. ,
Respondents
ORDER
Tl.ris writ petition is filed seeking lollowing relief:
".. .to issue a writ, order or direction more thc naturc of a
Writ of Mandamus declanng thc action ol ollicial
respondents more particularly that of respondents 2 and 3
in seizing my Mahindra make XUV 500 vehicle hearing
registration No.TS 08 FY 5298 on ground of dmnkcnness
of 4th respondent, while driving the same on 10107 /2025
in terms of Traffic Violation A 8080P without even giving
it to the custody of Court contrary to the orders of this
Honorable Court in W.P.No. 16471202 I and batch wherein
this Honorable Court has alfirmatively held tirat the
olficial respondents lack any power to seize vehicles in
casc of drunken driving as being iilegal, arbitrary,
Unconstitutional being violative of Articles 14, 19 and
i00A and consequently direct respondents 2 and 3 to
release the vehicle ..."
2.
Learned counsel lor the petitioner submits that the petitioner is
the ou,ner of Mahindra XIIV 500 vehicle bearing No.-l-S Oti IrY 5298 and
the said vehicle was seized by official respondents on the ground that
respondent No.4 was drunk while driving the vehicle ol the petitioner.
He lirrther subrnits that in similar circumstances, this Court has
disposed of a batch of writ petitions vide W.P.No. 1647 ol 2021 and
batch wherein a detailed order has been passed giving various
directions to the Police authorities stating that official respondents
Iack power to seize vehicles in case of drunken driving and thus, seeks
to pass appropriate orders in terms of the said order.
l.
Learned Assistant Government Pleader for Home basing on the
rvnttcn instructions from respondent No.3 submits that respondent
No.4 is involved in four drunk and drive cases in which three cases
were booked and challans were generated against the subject vehicle
bearir.rg No.TS08FY5298 and that the petitioner or respondent No.4
have not approached respondent Nos.2 & 3 with relevant documentary
,/
evidence since the date of hold ol the said vehicle. He would further
submit that the petitioner knowingly handcd over the said i,ehicle to
rcspondcnt No.4 and encouraged thc crimc. He further submits that
the respondent police
are
implemcnting the ordcr passed
l
W.P.No. 1647 of 2021 and batch and hencc, seeks to dismiss this rvrit
petltlon
4.
Having heard the learned counscl lor the petitioncr and learned
Assistant Govemmcnt Pleader for Revenue and upon perusal ol the
material available on rccord, it is noticcd that the co-ordinate Bench of
this Court in W.P.No. 1647 of 2021 and batch has passed a detailed
order by considering the relevant provisions ol Motor Vehiclcs Act,
1988, the Central and the Telangana State Motor Vehicle Rules, 1989
and also the Judgrnent of Hon'ble Apex Court in P.NKaushal Vs.
Union of India (1978 3 SCC 558) the operative portitrn of rvhich
reads as follows:
7. CONCLUSION:
i) This Court has previously held that under the M.V. Act, the Police
Officen do not have power to take custody of the vehicle driven under
intoxicated condition and directed the authorities / officials who havc
custody ofthe vehicle in question to release the same on production of
r:crtificatc of registration relating to the said vchicle and on production
o 1' proof of
idcntity and also a valid driving license.
ri) Irr i'ieri'of the abovc said discussion and the rclevant provisions
arrd also considering the principle laid down by the Apex Court as
rvcll as this Court. tl.ris Court is of the considered view that the
tollorvinq directions are required to be issued to the Police Authorities
to be follorvcd:
a) ll'thc dnvcr / rider of the vehicle is lound under the influence of'
,\lcohol. he,/she should not be allowed to drive the vehicle- However,
il'the policc finds othcr person accompanying the driver/rider not in
irrtoxieated condition and having a vatid driving license, shall permit
such pcrson to drivc the vehiclc without seizing/ detaining the vehicle,
subject to Section - 202 of the M.V. Act, 1988;
h) ll thcrc- rs no othcr person other than the person who drives thc
i chiclc- in an intoxicated condition, then the concemed Police Offrcer
or thc intoxicated driver shall immediately inform any nearest relative
or liiend to take bar:k the custody ofthe vehicle;
c) I1' no onc comes to take back the custody of the vehiclq then the
concemcd Police Official shall temporarily take possession of the
vchicle, and keep the vehicle in a nearest police station or any other
appropriale authorized place for safe custody. However, it is madc
)
clcar that the Police do noI have power to detain / seize vehicle on the
ground that its driver/rider drove it in an intoxicatcd condition
d) T'he Police or any other Official who has thc custody of such vehiclc
shall release the same either to the owner or any authorized pcrson orr
production of certificate of registration (RC) ofthc said vehicle, proof
of identity and a valid driving license;
e) If the concemed Police come to a conclusion that prosecution ofdriver
or owner or both is neccssary, he shall file charge sheet against
hirn/them before the concemed Magistrate within thrce (03) days from
the date of seizure of vehiole. The vehicle shall be releascd by the
t
Officer who detained it after prosecution is completed under
intimation to the concerned Regional Transport Authorities;
0 Leamed Magistrates are directed to receive the cl.rarge sheets within
threc (03) days from the datc ofseizure in compliance of Rulc - 448-,4
(iv) of the Telangana State Motor Vehicles Rules, 1989 if thc charge
sheets are otherwise in order.
g) The Police Officers of the State are directed to strictly follow the
procedure laid down under Rule - 448-n of the T.S. Motor Vehicles
Rules, 1989.
h) If no one claims the custody of vehicle, the police shall take necessary
steps in accordance with law;
I
i) Any brcach of the above directives will amount to Contempt
and
rlecessary ptoceer'lings rvill bc initiated
against the concerned Police'
iii) with tlte above dircctions' this batch of
Writ Petitions is disposed oL
5.
Accortlingty, this rvrit petition is disposcd of
order in W.P.No.1647 of 2021 and batch'
in terms of thc
There shall be no order as to
costs.
Miscellarreotts pctitions pending, il any, shall
stand closed
SD/.C.DEEPIKA
ASSISTANTREGISTRAR'-1.--//TRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER
To,
. The Principal Secretary Home Department, The State of Telangana, Dr. BR
Ambedkar, Telangana Secretariat, Tank Bund Road, Hyderabad
2. The lnspector. Alwal Traffic Police Station, Alwal, Secunderabad
3. The Sub lnspector of Police, Alwal Traflic Poiice Station, Secunderabad
4. One CC to Sri lmmaneni Rama Rao, Advocate TOPUCI
5. Two CCs to GP for Home, High Court for the State of Telangana, at
Hyderabad [OUTI
Two CD Cooies
t' 6.{qL,
Atong dith the copy of the date 2g.1o.2}21in W.P. 1647 OF 2021
l
HIGH COURT
DATED:0610212026
ORDER
WP.No.38805 of 2025
STA
FEB 202$
!
\\
\
DISPOSING OF THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
o
l( t_.-.. . , - -_-"
:i+
c)
HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE K. I,AKSHMAN
\yRIT PETIT'ION Nos.1647. 1564. 2677, 3677. 4333. 4633. 4662.
473r. 4905. 5313. 5346. 5724. 5775, 5784. 7t 55, 72s6.7303. 127ts.
l5:106 . 16106. 161 07. r 6t43, 161 65, 203.18. 20660,22040.22354.
2263 7 22652 2274 t. 23399 23s89 24389. 25129 25316 25795
25tt55. 25887. 26208. 26221 ANI) 2(1274 OF 2021
CONIMON ORDER:
Heard Mr. B. Shravanth Sanker, leamed counsel representing MrP. Shashi Kiran, Mr. Thomas Joseph Lloyd, Mr. Nikhilesh Thogari, Mr.
K.W.J. Bose, Mr. Ganapathi Kolli. Mr.P.V.S.K. Chakravarthy, Mr. M.
Praveen Kumar, Mr. G.S. Prasen. Mr. V.T. Kalyan, Ms. G. Jyothsna
Devi, Mr. Metru Shankar, Ch. Ravinder, Mr. R. Mangulal, Mr. Lokesh
Phanidra Bonthu representing I\4/s. Mithra Law Firm, Ms. C. Sunitha
Kumari, Mr.P. Shravan Kumar Goud, Mr. Swamy Botla, Praveen
Bonkuri, Mr. Kandadi Mahender Reddy and Mr. K. Venu Madhav, Mr.
K. Mukhendu Kaushik and Mr. Bharath Chandra Madas, leamed counsel
appearing on behalf of the respective petitioners, and Mr. T. Srikanth
Reddy, learned Government Pleader lor Home appearing on behalfofthe
respondents.
2. The challenge, in this entire batch of writ petitions, is to the
power of Police Officers !o seize the vehicle from its driver/ rider, who is
in an intoxicated condition.
3. The learned counsel appearing on behalf of their respective
petitioners have made their submissions extensively. The leamed
Govemment Pleader for Home has also made submissions referring to
various provisions of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (for short 'Act,
I
- KL.J
tYPNo 1647 of202l &batch
1988'), the [ndian Penal Code, 1860 (for short 'lPC') and the law laid
down by this Court etc.
4. COMMON CONTENTIONS OF THE PETITIONERS:
i) Thc police have no powcr to seize the vehicle from its
drivers/riders who are in an intoxicated condition- N4oreover, the Police
Officers are detaining the vehicles for days together and not releasing the
same even after producing ccnificate of registration, identity proof and
driving licenses etc. On account of the same, owners of the vchicles are
sut'fering. Thus, thc said act on the part of the Police is illegal.
ii) Mr. Sravanth Shankar, Ieamed counsel representing Mr.
P. Shashi Kiran, learned counsel lor the pctitioner in W.P. No.1647 ol
2021, filed a compilation consisting of arguments in brief, list of dates,
relevant provisions of law and copies ol relevant judgments. He has
extensively argued referring to various provisions oIthe M.V. Act-
iii) Referring to Sections 1858,207 and 19 (0 and 216 of the
Central Motor vehicles Rules. Mr. Ch. Ravinder, leamed counsel, would
submit that the police have no power tb delain the vehicles seized from
the person who drives it in an intoxication condition. Mr. Prasad
Kandadi also supplemented the said submissions.
5. CANTENTIOI{S ON BEIIALF OF RESPONDENTS:
i) Mr. T. Srikanth Reddy, learned Govemment Pleader for Home
would submit thar Section - 185 of the Act, 1988 deals with driving of a
vehicle by a drunken person or by a person under the influence of drugs,
KL.J
W.P.No.1647 of 2021 & batch
and according to the said provision, whoever, while driving, or
attempting to drive, a motor vehicle, has, in his blood, alcohol exceeding
30 mg. per 100 m[. ofblood detected in a test by a breath analyzer, or is
under the influence of a drug to such an extent as to be incapable of
exercising proper control over the vehicle, shall be punishable for the
first oflence with an imprisonment lbr a term which may extend to six
months, or with fine which may extend to rwo thousand rupees, or with
both.
ii) According to him, once the Police Officer finds a person
driving the vehicle in an intoxication condition and there is no other
person to drive the vehicle, police are seizing the vehicle and releasing
the same either to the owner of the vehicle,or his,/her authorized person
on producing proper proof of identification and valid driving license.
Thus, according to him, Section - 185 of the Act, 1988, is only an
enabling provision which thc police are invoking.
iiD Referring to Section - 206 (4) of the Motor Vehicles
Amendment Act, 2019 (for short 'Amendment Act, 2019'), the leamed
Govemment Pleader would submit that Section - 206 deals with the
power ofpolice offtcer to impound the document, and as per sub-Section
(4) of Section - 2O6 of the Amendment Act,2019, a police of{icer or
other person authorized in this behalf by the State Govemment shall, if
he has reason to believe that the driver of a motor vehicle has committed
an offence under any of Sections - 183, 184, 185, 189, 190, 194C, 194D,
or 194F. seize the driving license held by such driver and forward it to
.l
KL,J
fi'.P.No 1647 of)021 & batch
the licensing authority for disqualification or revocation proceedings
under section 19, provided that the person seizing the license shall give to
the person sun'endering the license a temporary acknow'ledgement
thcrcfor. but such acknowledgement shall not authorize the holder to
drive untii the license has becn returned to him.
iv) Rct'ening to Section - 2O7 (l\ of the Act, 1988, the leamed
Govemment Pleader would contend that the Police Officer has the power
to seize and dctain the vehicles uscd without certitlcate of registration,
permit, etc.
v) The learned Government Pleadcr would also contend that the
Police Olficer has the power to arrest without warrant. However, he
would fairly submit that Police Officers do not have the power to detain
or seize a lehicle from a person who drives it in an intoxicated condition.
According to him, the provisions under the M.V. Act, 1988 are enabling
provisions. The police officers are detaining the vehicles from persons
driving them in an intoxicated condition as there is no other person to
drive the vehicle with valid license and without being intoxicated.
vi) According to the leamed Government Pleader, as per the
directions of this Court and the Hon'ble Supreme Court, the police
authorities have been taking all necessary steps to decrease the death
rates caused on accounl of accide-nfs while drivingthe vehicley in an
intoxicated condition. The vehicles are being detained in public interest
and are being kept in proper places including nearest Tralfic Police
Stations for safe custody. In view of the same, there is no intention on
KL,J
ll/.P.No.1647 ol2021 & batch
the part of the police to harass the petitioners by detaining their vehicles
as alleged.
vii) With the said contentions, the leamed Govemment Pleader
sought to dismiss the writ petitions by issuing necessary directions
keeping in view lhe safety ofcitizens.
6, ANALYSIS AN'D FINDINC OF THE COTJRT:
i) In view of the aloresaid rival submissions, to decide the /rs in
the present batch of writ petitions, it is apt to ref'cr to ceflain provisions of
the Act, 1988, the Telangana Motor Vehicles Rules, 1989 and the Central
Motor Vehicles Rules, 1989, which are as under:
MOTOR VEHCII,ES ACT, 1988
Section - 3. Necessity for driving licence.
(1) No person shall drive a motor vehicle in any public
place unless he holds an effective driving licence issued
to him authorising him to drive the vehicle; and no
person shall so drive a transport vehicle lother than a
motor cab or molor cyclel hired for his own use or
rented under any scheme made under sub-section (2) of
section 75 unless his driving licence specifically entitles
him so to do.-
(l) x x x x x
(2) The conditions subject to which sub-section (l) shall
not apply to a persorr receiving instructions in driving a
motor vehicle shall be such as may be prescribed by the
Central Government."
*Section - 4. Age limit in conuection rvith driving of
motor vehicles.
(1) No person under the age ofeighteen years shall drive
a motor vehicle in any public place:
.
I
'
i
I
I
I
I
-
KL.J
WP.Na.l647 of 2021 & barch
Provided that a motor cycle with engine capacity not
exceeding 50cc may be driven in a public place by a
person after altaining the age ofsixteen years-
(l) Subject to the provisions of scction 18, no person
undcr lhe age of twent-v years shall drive a hanspon
vehicle in any public place.
(l) No leamer's licence or driving licence shall be
issued to any person to drive a vehicle of the class to
*'hich he has nade an application unless he is eligible to
drive that class ofvehicle under this section."
*Scction - 19. Power of licensing authority to
disqualifl' from holding a driving licence or revoke
such liccnce.-
tl) If a licensing authority is satisfied, aftcr giving the
holder of a driving licence an opportunity of being
heard, that hc
(a) to(e)xxxxx
(t) has committed any such act which is likely to cause
nuisance or danger to the public, as may be prescribed
b1' the C'entral Government, having regard to the objects
ot this Act; or
"Scction - 39. Necessity for rcgistratio[.-No person
shall drive any motor vehicle and oo owner of a motor
vehicle shall cause or permit the vehicle to be driven in
any public place or in any other place unless the vehicle
is registered in accordance with this Chapter and the
certificate of registration of the vehicle has not been
suspended or cancelled and the vehicle carries a
registration mark displayed in the prescribed manner:
Provided that nothing in this section shall apply to a
motor vehicle in possession of a dealer subject to such
conditions as may be prescribed by the Central
Government."
'Section - 66. Necessity for permits.-
'7
KL,J
W.P.N,.l647 of202l & batch
(1) No owner ofa motor vehicle shall use or permit rhe
use of the vehicle as a aansport vehicle in any public
place whether or not such vehicle is actually carrying
any passengers or goods save in accordance with the
conditions of a pennit gralted or countersigned by a
Regional or State Transport Authority or ar), prescribed
authority authorising him the use of the vehicle in that
place in the mannry in which the vehicle is being used:
Provided that a stage c:uriage pemit shall, subject to
any conditions that may be specified in the permit,
authorise the use olthe vehicle as a contract carriage:
Provided funher that a stdge carriage permit may.
subject to any conditions that may bc specified in the
pennit, authorise the use of the vehicle as a goods
carriage either when carrying passengers or [ot:
Provided also that a goods carriage permit shall,
subject to any conditions that may be specified in the
permit, authorise the holder to use the vehicle for the
carriage of goods for or in connection with a kade or
business carried on by him.
Provided also that where a transport vehicle has been
issued an permit or permits, as rvell as a licence under
this Act, such vehicle may be used eithcr under the
permit, or permits, so issued to it, or under such licence,
at the discretion ofthe vehicle owner.
(2) xxxxx
(3) xxxxx
(4) xxxxx"
Section - 185. Driving by a drunkeu person or by a
person under the influence of drugs.-Whoever, while
driving, or attempting to drive, a urotor vehicle,(a) has, in his blood, alcohol exceeding 30 mg.
per 100 ml. of blood detected in a test by a
i
I
I
KL,J
W.P Nt,.1647 of2021 & batch
breath analyser or in any other test including a
laboratory test, or
(b) is under this influence of a drug to such an
cxtenr a\ ro be incapable of cxercising proper
control or,cr thc vehicle,
shall be punishable for the first offence with
imprisonment for a term which may extend to six
m(,nths, or u,ith fine of ten thousand rupees, or with
both; and for a second or subsequent offence, with
irnprisorunent for a term rvhich may extend to two
ycars. or s'ith fine o[ fifteen thousand rupees, or with
hoth "
"Section - 202. Power to arrest without warrant.-
(llA police oflicer in uniform may arrest rvithout
\!3rrant an) p!'rson $ho in his presence commits an
of'l'cnce puoishablc under section 184 or section 185 or
section 197:
Provided that any person so arrested in connection with
an offence punishable under section 185 shall, within two
hours of his arrest, be subjected to a medical examination
refcrred to in sections 201 and 204 by a registered
rnedical practitioncr failing which he shall be released
from custody.
(2) A police oflicer in uniform may arrest rvithout
warrant any person, who has committed an offeoce under
this Act, if such person refuses to give his name and
ad&ess.
(3) A police officer arresting without wan-ant the driver
of a motor vehicle shall if the circumstances so require
take or cause to be taken any steps he may consider
proper for the temporary disposal of the vehicle."
"Section 203. Brerth tests-( I ) xxxxx
(2) xxxxx
KL,J
Il/.P.No.1647 of202l & batch
(3) If it appears to a police officer in uniform, in
coosequence of a breath test carried out by him on
any person under sub-sectiou (1) or sub-section (2)
that the device by means of which the test has been
carried out indicates the presence of alcohol in the
person's blood, the police officer may arrest that
person without warrant except while that person is
at a hospital as an indoor patient."
"Section -206. Power of police officer to impound
document.-
(l) xxxxx
(2) xxxxx
(3) A police officcr or othsr person seizing a licence
under sub-section (2) shall give to the person
surrendering the licence a temporary acknowledgment
therefor and such acknowledgment shall authorise the
holder to drive until the licence has been rehrmed to him
or until such date as may be specified by the police
officer or other person in the acknowledgment
whichever is earlier:
Provided that if any Magistrate, police officer or other
person authorised by the State Govemment in this
behalf is, on an application made to him, satisfied that
the licence cannot be, or has not been, rerumed to th€
holder thereof before the date specified in the
acknowledgment for any reason for which the holder is
not responsible, the Magistate, police officer or other
person, as the case may be, may extend the period of
authorization to drive to such date as may be specified
in the acknowledgment.
(4) A police officer or other person authorised in this
behalfby the State Covernment shdll, if he has reason to
believe that the driver of a motor vehicle has committed
an offence under any of sectioas 183, 184, 185, 189,
190, 194C, 194D, or 194E, seize the driving licence
I
I
I
I
l0
KL.J
W.P.N1.l647 oI202l & batch
held by such driver and forward it to the licensing
authority for disqualification or revocation proceedings
under section 19.
Provided that tlre person seizing the licence shall give
to thc person surrcndering thc licence a temporary
acknowledgement thcrefor. but such acknowledgement
shall not authorise thc holder to drive until the licence
has hccn rerumed to hinr. '
It is relevant to notc that this rvas brought into existence by way of an amendment
Act l2 of 2019 s.e.t 01.09.2019.
"Section 207. Power to detain vehicles used without
ccrtificate of registration permit, etc.
(l) Any police officer or other person authorised in this
behalftry thc State (iolemrnent may, if he has reason to
believc that a motor vehicle has been or is being used in
contravention of thc provisions of scction 3 or section 4
or scction 39 or without the permit requfud by sub-
section(l)of section 66 or in contravention of any
condition of such pennit relating to the route on which
or the area in which or the purpose for which the vehicle
may be used, seize and detain the vehicle, in the
prcscribcd manner and for this purpose take or cause to
be taken any steps he may consider proper for the
lemporary safe custody of the vehicle:
Provided that where any such oflicer or person has
reason to believe that a motor vehicle has been or is
being used in contravention of section 3 or section 4 or
without the permit required by sub-section (1) ofsection
66 he may, instead of seizing the vehicle, seize the
certificate ol registration of the vehicle and shall issue
an acknowledgrnent in respect thereof.
(2) Where a motor vehicle has been seized and detained
under sub-section (l ), the owner or person in charge of
the motor vehicle may apply to the fiansport authority or
ll
KL,J
WP.No.l617 of 2021 & batch
any officer authorised in this behalf by the State
Govemment together with the relevant documents for
the releasc of the vehicle and such authority or olficcr
may, aftcr verification of such documents, by order
relcase the vehicle subject to such conditions as thc
authorit_v or officer may deem ht to impose."
t' III.] CE \TRAI, N,! o 1' OR \TTII(]I,ES RULIiS. 1989
"Rule - 21. Porvers of licencing authority to
disqualify.-
(l) to ( l5) xxxxx
(
l6) Driving vehicle while under the influence of drink
or drugs-"
'IEI \\(;,\\1 S TATI.: \tO',rOR vEIIICI-US Rt't.ES. 1989
''Rule - 44t1. Porvcrs to detain vehicles:- Olllcer of the
Transpon l)epartnlent not belou' the rank of Assistanl
Motor Vehicles luspector and every Police Officer not
belou thc rank of Circle Inspector of Police are
authorised to exercise powers under Section 207."
"Rule - 418-4.. Procedure of seizing and detaining a
Motor Vehicle :- When a motor vehicle is scized and
detained bl any officer referred to Rule in 448, he shall
take the follorving steps :-
(i) anangernents shall be rnade for temporary safe
custody ol the motor vehicle in the nearest Police
Station or at any appropriate place;
(ii) the fact of scizure and detention shall be irtformcd
without delay to the Secretary, Regional Transpon
Authority of the region and the Secretary, Regional
Transport Authority ol the region to which the motor
vehicle belongs;
(iii) the officer who seized and detained the motor
vehicle may release the vehicle of the offence for which
it is seized and detained are compounded under Section
t2
KI.J
W.P.N1.l647 of202l & batch
200 under intimation lo the Sccretarics of Regional
Trxnsporl Authodties mentioned in Clausc (ii);
(ir t rrtcre prosoculion of the drirer or o\\rer or both is
rec.ssarr'. chargc shects against thctn shall be hled
br-li,re the crrncenrcd Magistrate \.!'ithitl three da1's from
thc datc ol seizure antl tlrc lnotor rehicle shall be
released bt the Officer rvho detained it after the
pr()\ccution is cornpletcd under intimation to Secretaries
of RcAonal I ransporl Audrorities rnentioned in Clause
(iii );
(r I \lalrazor ofthc vehicles is to bc carried out notifying
its crrndition ol cach t.vre litted and pans rvhich are
casilv rernuvablc, replaceable and tarnperable, viz.,
battcrics, fucl-purnp, Dl namo, Deltrential, cnginc, extra
liglrts etc. and loose pans. Stepney tyrcs and tools and a
copl ol'it is to bc delircred to thc periou from whom it
is seized. duly signed."
".1{8-lJ. Rclcasc of seized antl dctuincd lehicles :-
(l) An application lbr rclease of a vehicle scized and
dctai[ed und!'r sub-seclion (l) ol Scction 207 shall be in
tirc lorru of .r mcrnorantlurn in duplicate u,ith relevant
drrcumcnts dul] enclosing a lee olrupecs trventy five.
(2)
.[he
Secrctary. Regional Transpon Authorit-v. of the
Rcgion sha)l be enlcrtain application for release of
vehicles seizcd and detained by his subordinate officers:
Provided that application shall be made to the
Deputy Transport Conrmissioner in the case of check
made by the Secretary, Regional Transport Authority in
the cadre of Regional Transport Officer and the Transport
Comrnissioner. if
the Secretary, Regional Transport
Authority is of the Deputy Transpon Commissioner or
Joint Transpon Commissioner."
l3
KI.J
ll.P.No.1647 of 2021 & batch
ii) In view ofthe above, as pert Section - 185 (b) of the Act, 1988
whoever, while driving, or attempting to drive, a motor vehicle, is under
the influence of a drug to such an extent as to be incapable ol exercising
proper control over the vehicle, is punishable. Therefore, driving a
vehicle in an intoxicated condition is an offence. Thus, a person in an
intoxicated condition is baned lrom driving a vehicle.
iii) As pcr Section - 202 (1) of the Act, 1988, a police officer in
uniform may arrest any person without a warrant who in his presence
commils an ofl'ence punishablc under Section - 184 or Section - 185 or
Section - 197. As pcr sub-section (2) of Section 202 a police o{Ecer in
uniform may arrest any person without warrant who has commifted an
offence under the Act, 1988 if such person refuses to give his name and
address. As per sub-section - i of Section 202 of the Act, a police officer
arresting the driver of a motor vehicle without a warrant shall if the
circumstances so require take or cause to be taken any steps he may
consider proper for the temporary disposal of the vehicle. Therefore, if
the police officer finds a person driving the vehicle in an intoxicated
condition and if he/she considers that such person is not capable of
driving the vehicle under such condition, helshe may detain or take steps
for the temporary disposal of the vehicle. In other words, the police
officer has the power to detain / seize the vehicle and keep the same in
safe custody till the owner of the vehicle or hiVher authorized person
approaches the police oflicer with a valid driving license, identity proof
and certilicate of registration.
l4
KL,J
W.P.No 1647 of202l & barch
iv) As per section - 206 (3) of the Act, 1988, a police offrcer
arresting the driver of a motor vehicle without a warrant shall if the
circumstances so required lake or cause lo be taken any steps he may
consider appropriate lbr thc ten.rporary disposal of the vchicle. As pcr
Section - 207 (l) ol the Act. 1988. any police officer or other person
authorised in this behall by the State Government may, il he has reason
to believe that a motor vehicle has becn or is being used in contravention
ofthe provisions ol Section - J or Section - 4 or Section - 39 or without
the pennit required undel sub-section (l) of Seetion - 66 or in
contravention or any condition ol such pennit relating to the route on
which or the area in which or the purpose for which the vehicle may be
used, seize and detain the vchicle, in the prescribed manner and for this
purpose take or cause t<.r be taken any steps he/she may consider proper
for the temporary safc custtrdy ofthe vehicle.
v) Section - 3 ofthe Act, 1988, deals with the necessity ofholding
a driving licence. Section - 4 of tlre Act, 1988 deals with the age limit in
connection with driving ol'motor vehicles. Section - 39 deals with the
necessity for registration of motor vchicles. Section - 66 of the Act,
1988, deals with the necessity for obtaining permits. Therefore, the
Police Offrcer or any other person authorized by the State Govemment
may arrest or detain the vehicle on the gound that driver of the vehicle
does not have a driving license, is under age, vehicle is without a
certificare ofregistration and driving was without
per Section - 207 of the Act, l9gg, the police
valid permit. Thus, as
Officer does not have the
l5
KL.J
ll/.P.No.1647 of 202 I & batch
power to detain/seize the vehicle on the ground that the driver/rider ofthe
vehicle is loudd in an intoxicated condition.
vi) Section - l9 of thc Act, 1988 deals with the power ol licensing
authoritv to disqualily a person tiom holding a driving licence or revoke
such licence, and as per sub-section (l) (0, a driving license can be
cancelled or revoked by the authority ifa person has committed any such
act which is likely to cause nuisance or danger to the public, as may be
prescribed by the Central Govcrnmcnt, having regard to the objects of
this Act. Tlierefore, as pcr thc said sub-section, thcre is no power vested
in the Policc Officer to detain or seize the vehiclc on the ground that the
driver/rider of the vehicle is lound in an intoxicated condition.
vii) Rule - 2l of the Central Motor Vehicles Rules, 1989 deals
with powers of licensing authority to disqualify, and as per sub-rule (16),
licensing authority has the power to disqualily a person driving vehicle
while under the influence of drink or drugs. Therefore, as per the said
rule also, the Police Officer or Licensing Authority does not have the
power to seize/detain the vehicle on the ground that the person driving
the vehicle was in intoxicated condition.
viii) Rule - 448 of the T.S. Motor Vehicles Rules, 1989 deals with
the powers to detain vehicles, and as per which, Ofticer of the Transport
Department not below the rank of Assistant Motor Vehicles Inspector
and every Police Officcr not below the rank of Circle lnspector of Police
are authorised to exercise porvers undcr Section - 207. Rule - 448-4 of
l6
KL,J
W.P.N,.l617 of 2021 & batch
the said Rules deals with procedure of seizing and detaining a Motor
Vehicle. As per sub-rule - (iv) ol'Rule - 448-A when a motor vehicle is
seized and detained by any ofticer rcfcn-ed to Rule - -148, he/she shall
take stel)s wherr- prosecutiorr ol thc rlr ir cr or owner or both is neccssary.
charge sheets against them shall hc lilcd belirre the concemed Magislrate
u'ithin three days frorn the date oI seizure and the motor vehicle shall be
releascd by the Officer who detained it aticr the prosccution is conrplcted
under intimation to Secrctaries ol Rcgional Transport Authorities
mentioned in Clause - (iii). Rule - .148-8 deals with the release of the
seized and detained vehicles. Thus. as per Rule - 4484 of the Rules.
Assistant Motor Vehicles Inspector and cver-v Police Otllccr not bclow
the rank of Circle Inspector ol Policc are authorized lo erercise porvers
under Section - 207. As pcr rule - 4.f8-A(iv). duty cast upon the O[1icer
to filc charge sheets within thlee davs fiom the date of seizure and the
lnotor vehicle shall be releascd by thc Officer u'ho detaiued it alier the
prosecution is completed.
ix)
The above said provisions rvould reveal thal the Police
Officers do not have the power to detain/seize the vehicles on the ground
that the person driving the vehicle rvas found in an intoxicated condition.
However, the said provisions are enabling provisions. For instance, a
person drives the vehicle alone and Police Offrcer finds him in an
intoxicated condition and that such person is unable to drive the vehicle,
rhen the police Officer has the power to
registration and can detain/seize
seize the certificate of
the vehicle and keep it in
a nearest
t7
KL.J
tI'.P.No.1647 of2021 & batch
police statior/appropdate place for safe custody. At the same time, it is
the duty of the Police Officer to release thc said vehicle either to the
owner or to any authorized pcrson who is not in dmnken condition and
who is in a position 1o drivc ttrc vehicle and holds a valid license. [l there
are two persons prescnt in the car, the person driving the vehicle fbund in
an intoxicated condition and the other pcrson has a valid driving license
and is found not in intoxicated condition and in a position to drive the
vehicle, then the police shall not scizeldetain the r ehicle and pennit the
other person to drivc the vehiclc. The intontion ol thc Legislature is to
reduce the accidents and deaths that ma,v'. be caused due to driving of
vehicles in intoxicated condition. and it is not the intention to harass the
owners of the vehicles by detaining the vehicles [br days together.
Therefore, the police olticers have to str ictly follow the said lar.v and the
provisions of the Act.
x) The Police Officers do not have the porver to detain/seize the
vehicles under Sections - 19 (l) (t), 185, 206, 207 ol'the Act, 1988 and
Rule - 2t (16) of the Central Rules. They have to release the vehicle in
terms of Rule - 448A of the T.S. Motor Vehicles Rules. 1989.
xi) It is relevant to note that the Apex Court by considering the
steep increase in the accidents and deaths due to driving of vehicles by
the drivers in intoxication condition has issued several directives in S.
Rajaseekaran v. Union of Indiar.
'. (2018) li scc 516
I
llr
KL,J
W.P.N,.l647 of202l & batch
xii) A Division Bench of Madras High Court had also an occasion
to deal with the seizure ofvehicles on drunk and drive in Manikandan v.
P. Palani2 and gave cerlain directions including a direction that the
police shall seize take custody of the vehiclcs trl' drunk drivers as pcr
Section - 202 (i) ol'Motor Vehicles Act. As stated atrovc. Section - 102
(3) ol'thc Act, 1988 deals with disposal of vehicle by Police Otliccr
arresting a person without warrant the driver ol a motor vchicle shall il
the circumslances so require. But. as per the said pror ision. therc is no
pou'el vested in the Police Officer ttr detain I scize the vehicle on thc
ground that thc driver ofthe vehicle is found in intoxicated condition.
xiii) During the course of argunrcnts, it rvas brought to the notice
of this Court that leamed Magistrates ate not rcceiving thc charge sheets
filed u,ithin threc (03) days from the date of seizurc and that they are
retuming the same on flimsy grounds. It was also brouglrt to the notice
of this Courr that on thc instructions of the DCP (1'ratlic). Cyberabad. the
Policc Of-ticers are not releasing the vehicles despite ordcrs of this Court
and also despite production of original certificate of registration (RC) and
valid license.
xiv) An interesting issue was brought to the notice of this Court
during the course of arguments that during review meetings, the Senior
Oflicials of the State are building up pressure on the o{ficials ol the
Prohibition & Excise Department, Telangana State, to collect
revenue by sale of liquor. At the
2.
Judgemenr in C.M.A. No.47O
same time, rhe Senior Officials
of20l E decided on I2.03.2020
more
of the
l9
KL,J
W.P.No.1647 of2a2l & barch
Police Department, during the review meetings, are building up pressure
on their Officials to collect m(lre revenue through 'drunk & drive' by
imposing challans. Thus, the Statc is building up pressurc on both the
Depatments to collect morc revcnue by rvay ol'salc of liquor as rve[[ as
imposition ofchallans during 'drunk & drive'. The said approach ofthe
State is not appfeciable. In lie[ ()f lhe salne, it is apt to refir to the
observations made by the Hon'ble Supremc Courr in paragraph Nos.2l,
72 and 23 in P.N. Kaushat v. Union of Indias. which is as under:
*21. George Bemard Sharv, a provocativc
teetotaller, used tart words of trite rvisdom.
"If a natural choicc between drun&enness and
sobriety were possible, I would leave the people
free to choose. tsut then I see an enomrous
capitalistic orgaoisatioo pushing drink under
people's noses of ercry comer and pocketing the
price while leaving me and others to pay the
colossal damages, then I am prepared to smash
that organisation and make it as easy for a poor
man to stay sober, if he wants to as it is for his
dog."
Alcohol robs you of that last inch of efficiency
that makes the difference between first-ratc afld
second-rate.
I don't drink beer-first, because I don't like it; and
second, because my profession is one that obliges
me to keep in
critical training, and beer is fatal bo& to training
and to criticism.
only teetotallers can produce the best and satrest
ofwhich they are capable.
r. (1978) 3 scc 558
ka.J
W.P.N1.1647 of202l & batch
Drinking is the chloroform that enables the poor
to endure the painful operation of living.
lt is in the Iast degree disgraceful that a man
cannot pro vide his oum genuine courage and
high spirits witlrout drinl.
I should be utterly ashamed if rny soul had
shnvelled up to such an extent that I had to go out
and drink a whrsky. (Repon ofthe srudy Team on
Prohibition Vo..l p.346)
22. The constitutional test of reasonableness,
built into Art. l9 and of arbitrariness implicit in Art.
14. has a relativist touch. We have to view the impact
of alcohol and temperance on a given society; and for
us. the degree of constitutional restriction and the
strategy of meaningful enforcement will naturally
depend on the Third World setting, the ethos of our
people, the economic compulsions of today and of
human tomorrow. Societal realities shape social
justice. While the universal evil in alcohol has been
indicated the particularly pemicious consequence of
the drink evil in [ndia may be useful to R r rernember
while scanning the. rationale of an Indian temperance
measure. Nearly four decades ago, Gandhiji,
articulating the inarticulate millions' well- being,
wrote:
Thc most that tea and coffee can do is to cause a
linle extra expelse, but one of the most greatly
felt evils of the British Rule is the importation of
alcohol.. that enemy of mankin4 that curse of
civilisation-in some form or an other. The
measure of the evil wrought by this borrowed
habir will be p.operly gauged
-1'e
rne
i: totd rhar rhe enemy lxs
teDgth and breadth
by the reader when
spread throughour
of lodia, in splte of
the
2t
KL,J
tlr.P.No.l647 of 2021 & batch
religious prohibition for even the touch ofa bottle
containiD.g alcohol pollutes the Mohammedan,
according to his religion, and dre religion of the
Hindu strictly prohibits the use of alcohol in any
form rrhatever, and yet alar I rhe C,r\cn)ml'nt. it
seems, instead of stoppiog, is aiding and abcttiug
the spread of alcohol. The poor there, as
eveq,rrhere, are the greatest sutferers. [t is they
who spend what little they eam in buying alcohol
instead ofbuying good food and ot]rer ncceriarics
lt is that rvretched poor man who has to stan.e his
family, who has to break the sacred trusl of
looking after his children, if any. in order ro drink
hirnself into misery and premature dcath. llere be
it said to the credit of Mr. Caine, the ex-Member
for Barrow, that, he undaunted, is still carrying on
his admirable crusade against thc spread of thc
cvi[, but what can the energy of one man,
however, powerful, do against the inaction of an
apathetic and dormant Govemrnent. (fhe
Collected Works of Mahatma Gandhi pp.29-30)"
23.
Parenthetically speaking, many of thcse
thoughts may well be regarded by Gandhians as an
indictment of govemmental policy even to-day."
(llntphasis supplied)
xv) It is also apt to reler'sayings' ol Famous i[en with rcgard to
the prohibition, which is as under:
20. tn this couoEy, great value is attached to the sayings of
geat meo. Their sayings cao be collected aod can form the
basis of education. A few illustrations will not te without
interesL The educatoE will be well advised to collect such
saying as they are bound to appeal to aloost every body.
Dr- Adrm Clirk
"ln the bottle, discootent seeks fo. comfort; cowardice for
courage; bashfulness for confidence; sadness for joy: and all
find ruin."
I
I
I
2)
KL'J
|Y.P.M.l647 of 2021 & batch
Sir Andrew dark
"As t lookcd at the hospital wards today aod saw that sever out
of tcn owed their diseases to alcohol. I could but lament that the
tcaching about this question was not more direct, more decisive,
more home-thrusting than ever it had been. Can I say to you any
\r'ordi rt.onger than ihesel It is rhcn I myself rhink ofall rhis
that I am disposed to give up e\erylhing and to go fonh upon a
Holy Crusadc, preachig to all men."
Thomas Edison
"Thomas Edison. the great inventor had a firm faith in a saloonless country aod a0 alcohol-&eed world."
Mahatma Gandhi
"lf I s'cr have an opportunity to rule lndia, in my first halfhour
I t^ ill rl.,i.' up all lhc r,r,ldy ihopr without compensation.
And I arr rnuch nrore againsl cigar and cigarcttes than against
drink. llut do not nrakc thc mistake that between drink and
tobac.o. drink is a lcsser evil. No. lfcigarette is Beelzebub, then
drink ii Satan
I hold drink to be more damnable thao thieving aod per{raps
eve prostitution. Is it not often the pareqt to both I ask you to
join thc country in swecping out of existeoce the driok reveoue
and abolishing the liquor shops.
I et mc. thcrefore, re-dcclare my faith in undiluted prohibition
bcfore I laod myself in deeper water. IfI was appointed dictator
for onc hour for all India, the first thitrg I would do would be to
close without compcnsation all tie liquor shops, destroy all the
toddy palms such as I know them io Cujaiat, compcl factory
owners to produce humane conditioos for their workmen aod
open refrestrnent aod recreatioo rooms where these wo*meo
would get ionocenr drinks and equally iooocent amusements. I
would close down the factories if the owoers pleaded for waot
offunds."
Crant
"Give mc the sober man, the absolute teetot4ller every time. He
is dependable. If I had the geatest appoitrtive powers io the
colntry. oo man would get even the smallert appoiotueot tom
me unlcss he showed proof of his absolute teetotalism. If I
could, by offering my body a sacrifice, I'd thaok the Almig[ty
for the privilege ofdoing it."
Abrah.m Lincoln
KL,J
W.P.No.l647 of202l & batch
"Whereas the usc of iotoxicatiog liquor as a bevcrage is
productive of pauperism, degradatioo and crime, and belicving
it is ou. duty to discouragc that which produces more cvil than
good, we, therctbre, pledge ourselves to abstain from thc usc of
iotoxicating liquor as a bevemge.
'fhe use ofalcohol beverages has any dcfenders but no dctence.
Lincolo in hi; lamous Washington's binhday addrcss said:
"Wheder or not the world would b€ vastly benefited by a
lotal and final banishme[t from i( ofall intoxicating drinks
seems to me not now an open question. Three-fourths of
mankind confess the affirrrative wirh their lips, and I
believe all the rest acknowledge it in their hearts".
(timphasis Supplied)
xvi) In view ofthe above, it is the fundamental duty ofthe citizens
to take all precautions to avoid road accidents and deaths and also to
lollow the guidelines issued by the State and the Central Goverxnents
from time to time on 'road safety'.
7. CONCLUSION:
i) This Court has previously held that under the M.V. Act, the
Police Officers do not have power to take custody of the vchicle driven
under intoxicated conditioo and directed the authorities / officials who
have custody of the vehicle in question to release the same on production
of certificate of registration relating to the said vehicle and on production
ofproof of identity and also a valid driving license.
ii) In view ofthe above said discussion and the relevant provisions
and also considering the principle laid down by the Apex Court as well as
this Court, this Court is of the considered view that the following
directions are required to be issued to the Police Authorities to be
followed:
KCJ
I|/.P.N<'.1647 of 2021 & barch
(a) If' the driver / rider of the vehicle is found under the
influencc of Alcohol, helshe should not be allowed to drive
the vehicle. However, if the police finds other person
accornpanying rhe driver/rider not in intoxicated condition
and having a valid driving license, shall permit such person
to drive the vehicle without seizing/ detaining the vehicle,
subjcct t() Section - 202 of ths M.V. Act, 1988;
(b) If thcre is no other person other than the person who drives
the rehicle in an intoxicated condition, then the concemed
Policc Officcr or the intoxicated driver shall immediately
infonn any nearcst relative or friend to take back the custody
of the vchicle;
(c) If no one comes to take back the custody ofthe vehicle, then
the concemed Police Oflicial sha[[ temporarily take
possession of the vchicle, and keep the vehicle in a nearest
police station or any other appropriate authorized place for
safe custody. However, it is made clear that the Police do
not have power to detain / seize vehicle on the ground that
its driver/rider drove it in an intoxicated condition.
(d) The Police or any other Olficial who has the custody ofsuch
vehicle shall release the same either to rhe owner or any
authorized person on production of certificate of registration
(RC) of the said vehicle, proofof identity and a valid driving
license;
KL.J
W.P.Nq. l 647 0/202 1 & ba.ch
(e) If the concerned Police come to a conclusion that
prosecution ol driver or owner or both is necessary, he shall
file charge sheet against hin/them before the concerned
Magistrate within three (03) days from the date olseizure ol
vehicle. The vehicle shall be released by the Officer who
dctained it after prosecution is completed under intimation
to the concemed Regional Transport Authorities;
(D
Learned Magistrates are directed to receive the charge shects
within three (03) days from the date of seizurc in
compliance of Rule - 448-A (iv) of the Telangana State
Motor Vehicles Rules, 1989 if the charge sheets are
otherwise in order.
(g) The Police Officers of the State are directed to strictly
follow the procedure laid down under Rule - 448-A of the
T.S. Motor Vehicles Rules, 1989.
(h) [f no one claims the custody ofvehicle, the police shall take
necessary steps in accordance with law;
(i)
Any breach of the above directives will amount to Contempt
and necessary proceedings wilt be initiated against the
concerned Police.
iii) With the above directions, this batch of Writ Petitions is
disposed of.
iv) However, in the circumstances of the case, there shall be no
order as to costs.
l6
KL,J
W. P.No. l 647 of 202 1
& batch
As a sequel, the miscellaneous petitions, ifany, pending in the writ
petitions shall stand closed.
K. LAKSHMAN,J
29'r' October. 202 I
Note
l. L.R. Copy to bc marked
2. The Registrar (Judicial) is directed to circulale
a copy of this comrnon order to the DGP,
Telangana State as well as all the leamed Magistrates
in the State ofTelangana with inslructions to tbllow
the al'or.'.aid direitr(nr\. (lJ O.l\l..tr
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review