Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
$
%
"
"#
& !
!
"
' %
! "#$%
&
'
Digitally signed
by VARSHA N
RASALKAR
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
(
)
*
)
)
#
)
)
!"$$$
*
+! " $#
,
)
*
! "#$%
(
-2-
)
*
! "#$%
!
)
*
)
! "#$%
**
'
(
&
'
)
)
##
(
*
*
)
##"
(
*
-
*
)
)
)
) )
, $! #$$!
)
)
!
)
.
)
+
(
*
)
#, $% #$##
)
)
.
*
)
)
+*
)
)
/
)
012 34515167 12 8194: ;< 504 345151674= 244>17? @ A=15
68 B@7:@BC2 ;< A@< 68 @ :1=4D5167 56 EC@20 012 7@B4 17
6A:<
4?1254= B@175@174: ;< 504 =42367:475
6!
#
=421:475 68
5 12 504 D@24 68 504 345151674= 50@5 04 12 @
7:1 56A7 @7: 04 12 @ ;C217422B@7
@926
-3-
17F69F4: 17 369151D@9 @D51F15142 @7: D6BBC715< 24=F1D42
345151674= @926 @D51F49< 3@=51D13@542 17 504 96D@9 ;6:<
494D51672 @7: 3@=91@B475@=< 494D51672 )4 @926 4236C242
504 4D676B1D@99< A4@>4= 24D51672 68 504 26D145<
5 12
D67547:4: 50@5 :C4 56 012 3@=51D13@5167 17 369151D2 @7:
4236C217? 3C;91D D@C24 504=4 12 369151D@9 =1F@9=<
04 =1F@9
369151D1@72 0@F4 5@=?454: 01B :C4 56 A01D0 345151674= 0@2
;447 1B391D@54: 17
D=1B17@9 D@242
D67547:4: 50@5 6C5 68 504
)6A4F4=
15 12
D=1B17@9 D@242 345151674= 0@2
;447 @DEC1554: 17 674 68 504 D@242 @7: 504 =4B@1717?
D@242 0@F4 ;447 A150:=@A7 ;< 504
0@2
5@54
$
6F4=7B475
,
012 ;417? 504 25@54 68 @88@1=2 345151674=G2 7@B4
;447
=4?1254=4:
B@175@174:
;<
=42367:475
6A:<
6!
4?1254=
8C=504=
D67547:4: 50@5 504 345151674= 0@2 ;447 D67517C6C29< 3C5
67 2C=F4199@7D4 ;< 504 3691D4 @C506=15142
)12 8@B19<
B4B;4=2 @=4 @926 D67517C6C29< B67156=4: @7: 06C7:4: ;<
504 3691D4 @C506=15142 :C=17? 84251F@92 @7: 494D51672
F14A 68 @99 5012 345151674= B@:4 @ =43=42475@5167 56 504
-4-
3691D4 @C506=15142 67 #, $% #$## 56 =4B6F4 012 7@B4 8=6B
6A:<
4?1254=
423154
2C;B15517? 2CD0 @ =43=42475@5167
345151674=
76 @D5167 0@2 ;447
5@>47 ;< 504 =42367:4752 @7: 504 3691D4 @C506=15142 0@F4
D67517C4: 504 7@B4 68 345151674= 17 504
6A:<
4?1254= A1506C5 86996A17? 3=634= ?C1:491742 9@1: :6A7 ;<
6C=5
5 12 8C=504= D67547:4: 50@5 67 #"
# #$#
A047 504 345151674= @33914: 86= 012 3@2236=5 56 ?6 56 069<
319?=1B@?4
C5 504 3@2236=5 @C506=15142 >435 504 2@B4 67
069: D1517? 50@5 504 345151674=/2 7@B4 12 86C7: 17 504
6A:<
4?1254= B@175@174: @?@1725 01B
5 12
D67547:4: ;< 94@=74: D6C7249 86= 504 345151674= 50@5
:423154 @99 5012 D6721:4=17? 504 D6BBC715< 24=F1D4: ;< 504
345151674=
6F4=7B475 68
01B @2 504 B4B;4= 68
1H@<@3C=@
125=1D5
@=7@5@>@ 0@2 @3361754:
@E8
:F126=<
6BB15544
5 12 @926 D67547:4: 50@5 345151674= 12 @ 9@A+
@;1:17? D151I47 @7: C774D422@=19< 012 7@B4 0@2 ;447
17D9C:4: @5 504 1725@7D4 68 =1F@9 369151D@9 3@=5142 17 504
-5-
6A:<
5@7:17?
%%
4?1254=
=:4=
A01D0 12 1994?@9 @7: D675=@=< 56
$!% 68 504
@=7@5@>@
691D4
@7: 6504= 3=6F121672 D675@174: 504=417
@7C@9
5 12 @926
D67547:4: ;< 94@=74: D6C7249 50@5 504 =42367:4752 0@F4
765 86996A4: 504 3=17D13942 17 504
@=7@5@>@
691D4
5@7:17?
=:4=
$!%
@7C@9 @7: B4D0@71D@99< 504< 0@F4
3@224: @7 6=:4= =4?1254=17? 504 7@B4 68 504 345151674= 17
504 =6A:< 20445 A01D0 12 F169@51F4 68
672515C5167 68 7:1@
4?1254=
% @7: #
04=486=4 04 244>2 56 @996A 504
34515167 @7: D6724EC4759<
6A:<
=51D942
=4B6F4 012 7@B4 8=6B 504
04 D6C7249 @926 D67547:2 50@5 504
=42367:475 3691D4 0@F4 765 86996A4: 504 ?C1:491742 9@1:
:6A7 ;< 5012
6C=5 17 504 D@24 68
=436=54: 17
!
94@=74:
::15167@9
6F4=7B475
:F6D@54 =43=4247517? 504
5@54 2C25@172 504 1B3C?74:
6=:4=
217D4
@7:
D67547:2
50@5
24F4=@9
D@242
A4=4
=4?1254=4: @?@1725 504 345151674= @7: 04 A@2 :45=1B475@9 56
-6-
504 1754=425 68 504 34@D4 @7: 5=@7EC1915< 68 504 26D145< 012
7@B4 A@2 =4?1254=4: 17 504
6A:<
4?1254= @7: 17
@DD6=:@7D4 56 504 3691D4 B@7C@9 504 345151674= A@2 ;417?
B67156=4: 9@A8C99<
04=4 12 76 1994?@915< D6BB1554: @7:
504=4 12 76 F169@5167 68 @7< =C94 9@A @D5 6= 3=6D4:C=4 26
@926 504 ;=4@D0 68 @7< D672515C5167@9 3=6F121672 )4 @926
D67547:2 50@5 504 HC:?B475 =4914: ;< 504 345151674= 17 504
D@24 68
'2C3=@( 12 BCD0 9@54= 50@7 504
=4?125=@5167 68 504 7@B4 68 345151674= 17 504 =6A:< 20445
@7: 15 A6C9: 765 D6B4 56 012 ;474815
04=486=4 04 244>2
:12B122@9 68 5012 34515167
"
0@F4 04@=: 94@=74: D6C7249 86= 504 345151674=
@7: 94@=74:
::15167@9
6F4=7B475
:F6D@54 86= 504
5@54
5 12 @ 8C7:@B475@9 =C94 68 9@A 50@5 A047 @
34=267 12 1B391D@54: @2 @ =6A:< 204454= ;< 17D9C:17? 012
7@B4 17 504 9125 68 =6A:< 20445 504 67C2 12 C367 504
5@54
56 86996A 504 :C4 3=6D4:C=4 D6754B39@54: C7:4= 504
=494F@75 =C942 @7: =4?C9@51672
7 504 3=42475 D@24 504
-7-
@=7@5@>@
691D4
@7C@9 B6=4 234D181D@99< 504
6A:142 B@175@174: 17 6=:4=
4?1254= 68
$!% A01D0 :4@92 A150
01256=< 204452 @7: =6A:< 204452 @7: 47=699B475 6=
=4?125=@5167 68 34=2672 17 504 2@1: 20445 86= =4?1254= 86=
D67517C6C2 B67156=17? ;< 504 3691D4 @C506=15142
86996A4:
5@7:17?
68 =6A:142
=:4=
12 765
$!% :4@92 A150 =4?125=@5167
04 :481715167 3=6F1:4: 12 50@5 @ =6A:< B@< ;4
:48174: @2 @ ?C7:@ @7: 17D9C:42 @ 06691?@7
56C?0
F@?@;67: 6= @7< 34=267 A06 12 :@7?4=6C2 56 3C;91D 34@D4
@7: 5=@7EC1915<
04=4 @=4 B@7< 86=B2 68 =6A:12B A01D0
@=4 :42D=1;4: 504=417 @7: 504 3=6D422 @7: 3=6D4:C=4
D6754B39@54: 56 ;4 B@175@174: 17 :1884=475 3@=52 7@B49<
@=5
@=5
@7:
@=5
A01D0 ?6F4=7 504 B@17547@7D4
68 @ =4?1254= @7: 504 7@B42 68 504 =6A:142 17 5041=
=4234D51F4 3@=52
5 12 504 :C5< @7: 6;91?@5167 D@25 C367
504 =42367:4752 A01D0 12 765 635167@9 56 86996A 504 :C4
3=6D4:C=4 D6754B39@54: C7:4= 504 25@7:17? 6=:4=2 68 504
@=7@5@>@
34=267
691D4
@7C@9
=6A:<
A0194 4754=17? 504 7@B4 68 @
20445
@7:
504=4
@=4
D4=5@17
-8-
3=6D4:C=42 56 ;4 B@7:@56=19< 86996A4: ;486=4 4754=17? 504
7@B42
2 D67547:4: ;< 94@=74: D6C7249 86= 504 345151674=
504 3=6D422 @7: 3=6D4:C=4 @2 D6754B39@54: C7:4= 504
25@7:17?
=:4=
$!% 68 504
@=7@5@>@
691D4
@7C@9
0@2 765 ;447 86996A4: @7: B4=49< ;4D@C24 04 A@2
17F69F4: 17
A01D0
D=1B17@9 D@242 04 0@2 ;447 8=@B4: 6C5 68
17 674 68 504 D@242 345151674= 12 @DEC1554: @7:
6504=2 @=4 A150:=@A7 ;< 504
5@54
5 12 @926 D67547:4:
50@5 506C?0 504 345151674= 0@2 B@:4 @ =43=42475@5167 56
=42367:475
@C506=15142
@854=
@DEC155@9
#, $% #$## 504 =43=42475@5167 0@2 765 ;447 D6721:4=4:
@7: 4F47 @854= 504 @DEC155@9 04 0@2 ;447 2CBB674: 56
HC=12:1D5167@9
3691D4
25@5167
86=
C774D422@=<
1754==6?@5167 A047 504=4 12 76 D@24 347:17? @?@1725 01B
5 A6C9: ;4 =494F@75 56 4J5=@D5 3@=@?=@30
68 504 HC:?B475 68
1F12167
!"
=436=54: 17 #$
%&&
47D0 68 5012
6C=5 17 504 D@24
"
'
(
A04=417 504
1F12167
-9-
47D0 :4@95 A150 21B19@= 2C;H4D5 B@554= A01D0 =4@:2 @2
C7:4=
!
"
#
#
%
&'(
$
#
)
$
#
%
)
* )
$
&'(
#
+
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
#
)
)
)
)
,
)
#
-
%
5@7:17? 6=:4=
@7C@9
%%
$!% 68
@=7@5@>@
12 4J5=@D54: ;496A
&'( . / 0
#
)
)
.2/
3+
/
!
,
691D4
- 10 -
/ 6
#
)
)
#
/
)
/
!
)
)
,
+
)
+
)
))
/*
,
,
/
,
/
.7/ 6
#
#9
)
;
%
:
.</ . / %
&&
)
#
)
)
)
. / %
)
8"
)
=
:
)
. / %
#
)
>% #
)
>
+
.'/
.?/ %
$
+* #
)
$
#
)
)
- 11 -
!
:
)
. / @
)
#
)
#
)
$
.A/
#
)
)
)
)
)
)
"
)
*
)
)
.(/ $
"
*
#
)
#
#
:
)
)
"
)
*
* $
#
#
. &/
)
#
)
#
#
.
)
/ @
)
#
+
$
!
8:8
)
)
$
- 12 -
!
. 2/ @
+
8:8
@
)
!
$
. 7/ %
8:8
)
!
)
)
)
+* #
. </
$
)
+
)
)
)
. '/ B
!
)
C
./
)
!
#
. /
))
)
2(<
4 .
. /
#
!
/,
- 13 -
(2 . / .)/ .1/
(?7
. /
D
#
. #/ 0
!
) #
C
&A . /
,
.#/ 0
& 4
.# / 0
&4
.# / 0
,
)
# / EC
'?
#
#
)
D
''
!
. C/ 0
(?7,
'&( 6
# +
. ?/ E#
)
E
"
:
)
)
#
+
)
+ +
#
)
)
!
)
+
.
/ @
#
$
)
)
"
#
#
. A/
)
&?
)
3+
/
2/ %
%
)
- 14 -
7/ 5
)
)
</ %
)
'/
?/ $
F
/%
A/
!
. (/ 6
)
)
#
)
)
#
!
$
)
7 F14A 68 504 767+D6B391@7D4 68 504 3=6D4:C=4
D6754B39@54:
@=7@5@>@
-
C7:4=
691D4
5@7:17?
=:4=
$!% 68 504
@7C@9 @7: 767+D6721:4=@5167 68 504
=43=42475@5167 ?1F47 ;< 504 345151674= 3C=2C@75 56 012
@DEC155@9 5012
6C=5 12 68 504 6317167 50@5 504 345151674=
0@2 B@:4 6C5 @ F@91: D@24 56 D6721:4= 8@F6C=@;9<
DD6=:17?9<
3@22 504 86996A17?
04 A=15 34515167 12
))
- 15 -
04 1B3C?74: 6=:4= 68 634717?
4?1254= 17 504 7@B4 68 504 345151674=
:@54:
,
$! #$$!
=42367:475
6A:<
B@175@174:
;<
6 ! 12 04=4;< EC@204:
04 =42367:4752 @=4 04=4;< :1=4D54: 56
=4B6F4 504 7@B4 68 504 345151674= 8=6B 504
6A:<
4?1254= B@175@174: ;< 504B
A15017 @ 34=16: 68
A44>2 8=6B 504 :@54 68
=4D4135 68 D4=51814: D63< 68 504 6=:4=
1F
1;4=5<
06A4F4=
=42367:475
=424=F4:
5@54 56 3=6D44: 17 @DD6=:@7D4
A150 9@A @?@1725 504 345151674= 18 @5 @99 @7<
D@24 12 B@:4 6C5 @7: A0194 :617? 26 504<
20@99 25=1D59< 86996A 504 ?C1:491742 9@1: :6A7
;< 5012
6C=5 17 504 D@24 68
=436=54: 17
'
)
!)*
!
&
"
(
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review