Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Reserved on – 31.12.2025
Delivered on – 09.01.2026
HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND AT NAINITAL
Criminal Appeal No. 657 of 2019
Jalaluddin @ Manoj
….....Appellant
Versus
State of Uttarakhand
….….Respondent
Present:Mr. Dheeraj Joshi, Amicus Curiae.
Mr. Pankaj Joshi, AGA for the State.
JUDGMENT
Coram: Hon’ble Ravindra Maithani, J.
Hon’ble Ashish Naithani, J.
Per: Hon’ble Ravindra Maithani, J.
The instant appeal is preferred against the judgement
and order dated 23.10.2019/04.11.2019 passed in Sessions Trial No.
17 of 2016, State v. Jalaluddin @ Manoj, by the court of First
Additional District and Sessions Judge, Kashipur, District Udham
Singh Nagar. By it, the appellant has been convicted under Section
IPC
and
sentenced
to
life
imprisonment
and
a
fine
of
Rs. 20,000/- and in default of payment of fine, to undergo further
imprisonment for a period of two years.
2.
Briefly stated, the prosecution case is as follows. PW 1
Ram Avtar Singh lodged a first information report on 26.09.2015 at
08:15 a.m. at Police Station Kashipur, District Udham Singh Nagar.
According to it, on 22.09.2015, PW 2 Vijay Pal Singh (Home Guard)
and PW 3 Khemkaran (Home Guard) along with other Home Guards
were on security duty of Sugar Mill, Kashipur (“the Mill”). In the night
at about 10:45 p.m., they noticed four miscreants roaming around the
Mill. When PW 2 Vijay Pal Singh and PW 3 Khemkaran tried to stop
the miscreants, they pushed them and ran away. Both PW 2 Vijay Pal
Singh and PW 3 Khemkaran chased them, but in the process, one of
the miscreants fired at PW 2 Vijay Pal Singh by his country made
pistol, due to which, he fell on the ground. The miscreant could be
identified by PW 3 Khemkaran, who was the appellant Jalaluddin. The
FIR also records that earlier also a report of theft was lodged against
the appellant and others. Based on this report, Ex. A-1, chik FIR, Ex.
A-12 was recorded and Case Crime No. 283 of 2015 under Section 307
IPC was lodged against the appellant and others. The extract of GD is
Ex. A-13. The injured was taken to hospital. He was referred to higher
centre also. Subsequently, according to the prosecution case, on
26.09.2015, from the possession of the appellant, a country made
pistol along with cartridge case was also recovered, of which a recovery
memo, Ex. A-2 was recorded and a chik FIR under Section 25 of the
Arms Act, 1959 (“the Arms Act”) was recorded at Police Station
Kashipur, District Udham Singh Nagar. This chik FIR is Ex. A-10. The
Investigating Officer prepared a site plan of the incident and the place
of recovery. Thereafter, the Investigating Officer submitted a charge
sheet under Section 307 IPC against the appellant Jalaluddin and
Mintu Sagar.
3.
Based on the charge sheet submitted against Mintu
Sagar, the proceeding of Sessions Trial No. 210 of 2016, State v. Mintu
Sagar, was instituted. This Sessions Trial No. 210 of 2016 has also
been decided by the common impugned judgment. Charge sheet under
Section 25 of the Arms Act was also submitted against the appellant,
based on which separate Sessions Trial No. 18 of 2016, State v.
Jalaluddin, was lodged in the court of First Additional Sessions Judge,
Kashipur, District Udham Singh Nagar. Sessions Trial No. 18 of 2016,
State v. Jalaluddin was also decided along with Sessions Trial No. 17
of 2016, State v. Jalaluddin on 23.12.2019. In fact, the appellant has
been acquitted of the charge under Section 25 of the Arms Act. He has
only challenged his conviction under Section 307 IPC.
4.
On 21.03.2016, charge under Section 307 was framed
against the appellant Jalaluddin and co-accused Mintu Sagar, to
which they denied and claimed trial.
5.
In order to prove its case, the prosecution examined as
many as 11 witnesses, namely, PW 1 Ram Avtar Singh, PW 2 Vijay Pal
Singh, PW 3 Khemkaran, PW 4 Inspector Arun Kumar, PW 5 Madan
Narayan Joshi, PW 6 Dr. Vikas Gahlot, PW 7 SI Lakhan Singh, PW 8
constable Madan Singh, PW 9 HC Gaje Singh, PW 10 Dr. Shantanu
Sahu and PW 11 SI Prahlad Singh.
6.
The appellant was examined under Section 313 of the
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (“the Code”). According to him, he
has falsely been implicated. After hearing the parties, by the impugned
judgment and order, the appellant has been convicted under Section
307 IPC and sentenced as stated hereinbefore. It may be noted at this
stage, that co-accused Mintu Sagar has been acquitted of the charge
levelled against him under Section 307 IPC by the impugned judgment
and order.
7.
record.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
8.
Learned counsel for the appellant submitted that the
prosecution has not been able to prove the case beyond reasonable
doubt; PW 1 Ram Avtar Singh is the informant; he has not witnessed
the incident; he is not an eyewitness; PW 3 Khemkaran, according to
the FIR, is an eyewitness, but he has not supported the prosecution
case. There are great discrepancies in the statements of PW 2 Vijay Pal
Singh. It is argued that, in fact, there are a lot of contradictions in the
statements of the witnesses and the FIR; the FIR is delayed; the story
as narrated by the prosecution is self-contradictory; there are
contradictions in the statement of the witnesses as to whether
cartridge case was ever recovered from the place of incident or not; the
blood stained clothes of the injured was also not recovered from the
police. Therefore, it is argued that the appeal deserves to be allowed.
9.
On the other hand, learned State Counsel submits that
PW 2 Vijay Pal Singh is an injured; he has categorically stated that at
the time of incident, the appellant fired at him, due to which he
sustained injuries. It is argued that the injuries have been supported
by the medical evidence and the FSL report also confirms that the
country made pistol that was recovered from the appellant was fired
through. It is argued that the prosecution has been able to prove the
case beyond reasonable doubt.
10.
Before the arguments are appreciated, it would be apt to
examine as to what the witnesses have stated.
11.
PW 1 Ram Avtar Singh is the informant. He did not see
the incident as such. He has proved the contents of the FIR. According
to him, after the four persons were spotted by PW 2 Vijay Pal Singh
and PW 3 Khemkaran, who were patrolling in the Mill premises, they
tried to stop them, but all those four miscreants pushed these Home
Guards and tried to run away. According to this witness, in that
process, they fired at PW 2 Vijay Pal Singh, due to which PW 2 Vijay
Pal Singh fell on the ground. In second paragraph of his examinationin-chief, PW 1 Ram Avtar Singh tells that the fire was made by the
appellant, who was identified by another Home Guard and in FIR, it
records that PW 3 Khemkaran has identified the appellant. This
witness has proved the FIR, Ex. A-1. According to him, he did not see
the incident. In the last but one paragraph of his cross-examination,
he tells that the next day, from the place of incident, two live cartridges
of 315 bore were recovered.
12.
PW 2 Vijay Pal Singh is the injured. According to him, at
the time of incident, they spotted four persons in the Mill premises.
When this witness and PW 3 Khemkaran tried to stop them,
immediately the appellant fired at him. According to PW 2 Vijay Pal
Singh, he has identified the appellant. He states that the bullet hit him
on his stomach; his companions raised an alarm. He has identified the
appellant in the court. According to him, he was taken to hospital and
referred to other hospital as well.
13.
PW 3 Khemkaran has not supported the prosecution case
as such. According to him, at the time of incident, he had gone to
washroom, when he heard a fire shot; he came out and saw PW 2 Vijay
Pal Singh in the injured condition. According to him, he had seen the
person, who had fired while he was running. He also tells in his crossexamination that PW 2 Vijay Pal Singh did not tell him that it is the
appellant, who did fire at him. In fact, in his cross-examination made
on 29.07.2017, PW 3 Khemkaran tells that he was not present in
Kashipur on 22.09.2015.
14.
PW 4 Inspector Arun Kumar is the person, who has
allegedly recovered a country made pistol from the appellant on
26.09.2015. He has prepared the recovery memo of fire arm, etc.
15.
PW 5 Madan Narayan Joshi had investigated the case
pertaining to fire arm recovery from the appellant. He has proved the
charge sheet Ex. A-5. As stated, the appellant has already been
acquitted of the charge under Section 25 of the Arms Act, and the
State has not filed any appeal, therefore, the statements of PW 4
Inspector Arun Kumar and PW 5 Madan Narayan Joshi do not bear
any relevance for ascertaining the involvement of the appellant in so
far as the charge under Section 307 IPC is concerned.
16.
PW 6 Dr. Vikas Gahlot was posted at L.D. Bhatt
Government Hospital, Kashipur on 22.09.2015. According to him, at
11:10 p.m. on that date, the injured PW 2 Vijay Pal Singh was brought
before him. He had examined him. This witness has proved the injury
report, Ex. A-6.
17.
PW 7 SI Lakhan Singh is the Investigating Officer of the
case. He has prepared the site plan. He arrested the appellant. He
proved those documents, including charge sheet, Ex. A-9. He has also
stated that the weapon of offence was got recovered from the appellant
by PW 4 Inspector Arun Kumar. He has stated about it. But, as stated,
the case pertaining to recovery of fire arm has already been lost by the
State and they are not in appeal.
18.
PW 8 constable Madan Singh has proved the chik FIR
and extract of general diary with regard to the 25 Arms Act, that was
lodged against the appellant on 26.09.2015.
19.
PW 9 HC Gaje Singh has proved the chik FIR and extract
of general diary under Section 307 IPC against the appellant.
20.
PW 10 Dr. Shantanu Sahu was posted at Himalayan
Hospital, Jollygrant, Dehradun on 23.09.2015. He has stated that
there were fire arm wounds on the injured PW 2 Vijay Pal Singh; he
was operated upon. He has proved the original documents with regard
to treatment of PW 2 Vijay Pal Singh, Ex. A-14 to Ex. A-18.
21.
PW 11 SI Prahlad Singh has stated about arrest of co-
accused Mintu Sagar, who has already been acquitted.
22.
As stated, PW 1 Ram Avtar Singh is not an eyewitness.
He has not seen the incident. PW 2 Vijay Pal Singh tells that he was
fired by the appellant and he sustained injury. There is an injury
report, which supports that, in fact, PW 2 Vijay Pal Singh did sustain
fire arm injury on that date. The question is - who did it?
23.
Charge sheet was submitted against the appellant and
one Mintu Sagar. Mintu Sagar has already been acquitted for the
charge under Section 307 IPC. The appellant has also been acquitted
for the charge under Section 25 Arms Act.
24.
According to the FIR, PW 2 Vijay Pal Singh and PW 3
Khemkaran were on security duty in the Mill premises at the relevant
time. They spotted four miscreants, tried to stop them, but they ran
away after pushing these witnesses and when chased, one of them
fired at PW 2 Vijay Pal Singh. The FIR records that, in fact, due to fire,
PW 2 Vijay Pal Singh fell on the ground and PW 3 Khemkaran could
identify the person, who shot at PW 2 Vijay Pal Singh. But, in his
evidence, PW 2 Vijay Pal Singh has not stated so. According to him,
they spotted four persons and tried to stop them and immediately the
appellant fired at him. He has not stated that the appellant and his
companions were running away and when they were chased, the
appellant fired at him. In his cross-examination PW 2 Vijay Pal Singh
tells that he had caught hold of the appellant and then he was fired at.
He also tells that PW 3 Khemkaran was also trying to catch him. He
also tells in his cross-examination, in the last page, that he had a
scuffle with the appellant, when he was fired at. As stated, this is not
the case in the FIR.
25.
PW 3 Khemkaran has not supported the prosecution
case. He says that he was in the washroom, when he heard a fire arm
shot. According to him, PW 2 Vijay Pal Singh did not tell him that the
appellant did fire at him.
26.
PW 7 SI Lakhan Singh is the Investigating Officer of the
case. In page 2, 2nd paragraph of this examination-in-chief, he admits
that no cartridge case was recovered from the place of incident. He
also tells that no blood stained clothes or blood stained soil were ever
taken into custody. Why? It is also one of the basic principles of the
criminal jurisprudence that any defect in the investigation does not
affect the merit of the case.
27.
PW 7 SI Lakhan Singh submits that no cartridge case
was ever recovered from the place of incident. PW 1 Ram Avtar Singh,
in his last but one paragraph of cross-examination tells that two live
cartridges of 315 bore were recovered from the place of incident on the
next day. Where are those cartridge cases? They have not been
produced. Interestingly, PW 2 Vijay Pal Singh, in page 4 of his
examination-in-chief tells that he was fired by 12 bore gun.
28.
The factum of recovery of cartridge case is much
doubtful. As stated, on the one hand, according to PW 2 Vijay Pal
Singh, he was fired by 12 bore gun, but according to PW 1 Ram Avtar
Singh, the next day, they could recover two live cartridges of 315 bore.
But, according to PW 7 SI Lakhan Singh, no cartridge case was ever
recovered. Although, at this point, learned State Counsel submits that,
according to PW 7 SI Lakhan Singh, cartridge case was not recovered;
he has not stated about live cartridges. But, the fact remains that even
those live cartridges were never produced before the court by the
prosecution. The recovery memo is not before the Court. How could
PW 1 Ram Avtar Singh say that two live cartridges of 315 bore were
recovered from the place of incident on 23.09.2015?
29.
FIR in the instant case was lodged by PW 1 Ram Avtar
Singh. The incident allegedly took place on 22.09.2015 at 10:45 p.m.
The FIR was lodged on 23.09.2015 at 09:15 a.m. at Police Station
Kashipur, which is at about a distance of 1/2 km. from the place of
incident. It is definitely delayed. Has the delay been explained?
30.
Learned State Counsel submits that the injured had
sustained injuries; he was taken to hospital; in that process, the delay
took place. But, PW 1 Ram Avtar Singh has not explained as to why
the FIR was delayed. He tells that the injured PW 2 Vijay Pal Singh
was firstly taken to Government hospital; thereafter, he was taken to
Jeevan Rekha Hospital and thereafter to Dehradun Hospital. This
witness has not stated that he had gone to Dehradun and in that
process, delay took place.
31.
What is important is that PW 7 SI Lakhan Singh in his
statement at 2nd paragraph, page 2, states that they did receive the
information in the night itself and the case was lodged in the morning.
This is very important. This is also important that the place of the
incident, which is the Mill premises, is at a distance of 1/2 km. from
the Police Station Kashipur. Which information did PW 7 SI Lakhan
Singh receive in the night of 22.09.2015 and where is that
information? If the information was received in the night of 22.09.2015
itself, that could be treated as an FIR. Why that FIR has been
concealed? Was it in writing or oral, recorded in general diary? Nothing
has been explained. If according to PW 7 SI Lakhan Singh, the
Investigating Officer, the information was received in the late night of
22.09.2015, why the case was lodged in the morning? These all factors
were to be clarified by the prosecution. But, the prosecution has not
been able to clarify these factors. It, in fact, doubts the prosecution
case.
32.
PW 3 Khemkaran has not supported the prosecution
case. PW 1 Ram Avtar Singh, the informant, is not an eyewitness. The
only evidence available is the statement of the injured PW 2 Vijay Pal
Singh. His statement is inconsistent with the averments of the FIR,
with regard to the genesis of the incident and the identification of the
appellant. According to PW 7 SI Lakhan Singh, police had received the
information in the night of 22.09.2015 itself, but that information has
not been placed. It is concealed. Was it a written information, oral
information, recorded in general diary entry, etc.? Because, the
information that was received at the police station on 22.09.2015 in
the night could have been treated as FIR. The FIR was lodged after
about 10 hours at police station, which is at a distance of about 1/2
km. from the place of incident. It is definitely delayed. These all
circumstances definitely doubt the prosecution case.
33.
In view of the discussions made above, this Court is of
the view that the prosecution has not been able to prove the charge
against the appellant under Section 307 IPC. Accordingly, the appeal
deserves to be allowed and the impugned judgment and order deserves
to be set aside.
34.
The appeal is allowed.
35.
The appellant is acquitted of the charge under Section
307 IPC.
36.
The judgement and order dated 23.10.2019/04.11.2019
passed in Sessions Trial No. 17 of 2016, State v. Jalaluddin @ Manoj,
by the court of First Additional District and Sessions Judge, Kashipur,
District Udham Singh Nagar is modified to the extent indicated above.
37.
The appellant is in jail. Let he be set free forthwith, if not
wanted in any other case. He shall furnish personal bond and two
sureties each of the like amount, to the satisfaction of the court
concerned under Section 437A of the Code within a period of one
month from today.
38.
Let a copy of this judgment along with lower court record
be sent to the court concerned.
(Ashish Naithani, J.)
09.01.2026
Avneet/
(Ravindra Maithani, J)
09.01.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review