Judgments
LegalFirms.in Judgments · legalfirms.in/judgments/jaintia-hills-autonomous-district-council-vs-state-of-meghalaya-and-3-ors-20220803/ · Printed 21 Nov 2026
Civil

Jaintia Hills Autonomous District Council vs State of Meghalaya and 3 Ors.

Add to a compilation

Keep judgments in folders, mark the paragraphs you rely on, and print a compilation with an index. It comes with the Research and Advocate Pro judgment plans and with a campus licence. Sign in · See the plans

Court
Meghalaya High Court
Date
3 August 2022
Case No.
MC(WPC) 130/2022
Result
Disposed
Bench
W. Diengdoh
Cite this judgment
Citation
Link for your website or blog
Cite the court's own record or the law report in court filings.

The court's order

The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.

31. Accordingly, pending final disposal of the main petition, the prayer of the petitioner for stay of the operation of the impugned letter No. DCA.103/2016/387 dated 25.02.2022 and related order dated 12.07.2022 under Memo No. GEN.213/JHADC/C.GATE/2018/228 is hereby allowed.

32. This Misc. Case is hereby disposed of. Judge Meghalaya

Filed under

Constitution of India

Full Judgment Text

Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs, CC BY 4.0). The court's own copy is the authoritative text.

Serial No. 03 Supplementary List HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA AT SHILLONG MC[WP(C)] No. 130 of 2022 In WP(C) No. 273 of 2022 Date of Decision: 03.08.2022 Jaintia Hills Autonomous District Council, Jowai Vs. State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors. Coram: Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge Appearance: For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) : For the Respondent(s) : Dr. N. Mozika, Sr. Adv. with Mr. P. Nongbri, Adv. Mr. M.L. Nongpiur, Adv. Mr. A. Kumar, AG. with Mr. A.H. Kharwanlang, GA. Ms. S. Laloo, GA. Mr. S. Sahay, GA. i) Whether approved for reporting in Law journals etc.: ii) Whether approved for publication in press: Yes/No Yes/No ORDER (ORAL) 1. An Order dated 12.07.2022 passed by the District Magistrate, West Jaintia Hills District, Jowai whereby all the toll gates said to have been illegally erected by the petitioner herein on National Highways, State Highways and major District Roads within the jurisdiction of Jaintia Hills District are directed to be closed down was challenged by the petitioner in these proceedings. It may also be mentioned that the above mentioned order was pursuant to the communication No. DCA.103/2016/387 dated 25.02.2022 passed by the Joint Secretary to the Government of Meghalaya, District Council Affairs Department. 2. Since the check gates are operated by the petitioner at Mookyndur, Amlarem and Ratacherra in the Jaintia Hills District with the objective to detect, regulate and identify illegal trading by non-tribal commercial vehicles without any licence within the jurisdiction of the District Council, closing down of one of the said check gates at Mookyndur by the respondents herein is deemed to have been an act done illegally, arbitrarily and discriminatory which is liable to be interfered by this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. 3. Along with the writ petition filed, the petitioner has also filed this application for stay of the operation of the said impugned letter dated 25.02.2022 and order dated 12.07.2022 respectively. 4. The respondents seeking to oppose the prayer made in this application has filed an affidavit in this regard and accordingly, the matter is now heard by this Court. 5. Dr. N. Mozika, learned Sr. counsel for the petitioner has, at the outset referred to the Annexure R/6 of the affidavit filed by the respondent which is a copy of the letter No. DCA.103/2016/381 dated 09.12.2021 addressed to all the Deputy Commissioners of the Khasi Hills as well as Ri-Bhoi, directed specifically to the collection of taxes and tolls by the Traditional Institutions and KHADC and which letter points out that though, collection of taxes by the Autonomous District Councils is made as per the provision of paragraph 8 of the Sixth Schedule of the Constitution of India, yet the area of jurisdiction does not extend to National Highways and State Roads and has submitted that the petitioner has no issue with this particular communication. 6. However, as regard the reference of the respondents to ‘The Control of National Highways (Land and Traffic) Act, 2002,” the learned Sr. counsel has submitted that Section 38 of this Act speaks of the requirement of seeking permission from the Highway Administration before any construction is made on the National Highway. However, the impugned orders were issued by the District Council Affairs Department of the State which has no authority in this respect and nowhere was it mentioned that any complaint has been received from the Highway Administration in this regard. The issuance of the impugned orders is therefore an act of malice in law, it was asserted. 7. The learned Sr. counsel has maintained that the check gate of the petitioner was not erected on the National Highway, but about 15 meters from the same on the lay bye and as such, there is no question of violation of the said Control of National Highways (Land and Traffic) Act, 2002. 8. Again, while referring to Annexure R/9 of the affidavit which is a copy of the minutes of a meeting held on 23.06.2022 to discuss the issue with regard to establishment of toll gates by District Councils and Traditional Institutions, which meeting was chaired by the Hon’ble Chief Minister, the learned Sr. counsel has submitted that in the said minutes, it was recorded that the Chairman has assured that the Government is not interfering in the collection of tax and fees by the District Councils and other Traditional Institutions, but not on National highway, State highways and major PWD roads, which is exactly what the petitioner has maintained when it was asserted that the concerned check gate was not situated on the National Highway. 9. Finally, the learned Sr. counsel has submitted that the facts and circumstances of this case are covered by the judgment in the case of Shri Maiantis Mawlot v. Khasi Hills Autonomous District Council & Ors whereby, vide order dated 27.09.2016, a coordinate bench of this Court has held that “…This Court is clearly of the view that when the Council has the power to make regulations for control of trading by the non-tribals within its jurisdiction as per Paragraph 10 of the Sixth Schedule to the Constitution, the power to appoint an Officer, Staff and/or Agent to achieve the objects of regulations is inherent and innate therein. It remains trite that a power to do something essential for the proper and effectual performance of work which the statute has in contemplation may be implied [vide: Asstt. Collector of Central Excise Vs. National Tobacco Co. of India Ltd.: (1972) 2 SCC 560]; and that an express grant of statutory powers carries with it, by necessary implication, the authority to use all reasonable means to make such grant effective [vide: Sakiri Vasu (supra))]. Thus, looking to the nature and purport of the powers conferred by Paragraph 10 of the Sixth Schedule, there is hardly any reason to take exception against engagement of an Agent by the Council to identify and check the trading by non-tribals traders. However, the concerned Agent as also the principal i.e., KHADC shall have to remain within the confines of the powers available in law and cannot exceed the same in any manner…..” Again, this Court in the case of Shri Eddystone Shylla v. State of Meghalaya in W.P(C) No 286 of 2018, which is a case involving the same issue as in the case of the petitioner herein and also with regard to the same check gate, that is, Mookyndur, this Court vide order dated 17.08.2018 in related MC[WP(C)] No. 143 of 2018, has, upon hearing the parties therein, stayed the operation of the impugned orders therein. 10. This Court was also led to the order dated 16.02.2022 passed by a coordinate bench of this Court in the case of Ridalin Law v. Jaintia Hills Autonomous District Council & Ors in WP(C) No 29 of 2022 which is a case wherein a dispute has arisen as between the bidders called upon to run the self-same check gate at Mookyndur and vide the aforesaid order, the Court has directed that the respondents therein shall not proceed with the settlement of the said check gate and that the same shall be done departmentally, which implies that the JHADC runs the said check gate which was done so until it was interrupted by the implementation of the impugned orders herein. 11. Mr. A. Kumar, learned Advocate General speaking on behalf of the State respondents has submitted that the first objection to this miscellaneous petition is whether the petitioner has the legal authority to set up such check gates? 12. Referring to paragraphs 11, 12 and 13 of the main writ petition, the learned AG has submitted that apparently, the petitioner claimed that the source of authority flows from the provisions of “The Jaintia Hills Autonomous District (Trading by Non-Tribal) Regulation, 2011 and Regulation 2015” and on perusal of the provisions of the said Regulation, nowhere is it provided that the District Council has been empowered to set up check gates. 13. In this regard, the case of Sdangyoo L. Dkhar v. State of Meghalaya 2016 SCC Online Megh 78 was referred to, to submit that in this case, the petitioner therein with the intention to stop the alleged leakage of royalty/revenue and illegal transportation of coal has set up check gates within the jurisdiction of the Khasi Hills Autonomous District Council. This Court has observed that interfering with the movement of vehicle for the purpose of checking and imposing fees thereon have been done without any sanction of law and consequently, the action of the State authorities to stop such activities have been held to be legal. 14. It is further submitted that the above mentioned judgment has been upheld by a Division Bench of this Court in Writ Appeal No. 52 of 2016 reported in 2017 SCC SCC Online Megh 313. 15. Again the case of Tangkham M.Sangma v. State of Meghalaya 2015 SCC Online Megh 93 wherein a Division Bench of this Court in a case of collection of toll as regard forest produce in the Garo Hills District has not interfered with the action of the authorities who have stopped the petitioner therein from operating such toll gate on the ground that he lacks the authority to do so. 16. On this point, the learned AG has submitted that under the rules and regulations, there is no authority given to the petitioner to run the check gate and that too on the National Highway. 17. Another point raised is that the petitioner has violated the provisions of “The Control of National Highway (Land and Traffic) Act, 2002” by setting up the said check gate within 15 meters of the National Highway. Sections 23 of the said Act has deemed that Highway land is the property of the Central Government and Section 24 provides for prevention of occupation of highway land. The fact that the petitioner has set up the check gate 15 meters from the National Highway is also violative of Section 28 which says that no person shall have right to a Highway either through any vehicle or on foot except by permission from the Highway Administration which permission was not found with the petitioner. 18. The last point raised is with reference to the minutes of the meeting held on 23.06.2022 wherein, it is seen that the petitioner was duly represented by the Chief Executive Member and Executive Member and in which meeting the main issue discussed is the complaints raised by many groups/authorities to the act of stopping of vehicles by the District Council and Traditional Bodies at the National Highway for collection of toll. The proceedings of the said meeting would show that such acts have been viewed as not authorized by law nor is it in conformity with the rights of the citizen as guaranteed by the Constitution and consequently, all such check gates/toll gates on the National Highway, State Highways and major PWD roads are directed to be closed down. 19. It is therefore submitted that the petitioner has not been able to make out a prima facie case, nor is there balance of convenience in his favour to entitle him to interim relief. 20. In reply, the learned Sr. counsel for the petitioner has submitted that the impugned order has to be considered as it is, that is, it has to be assessed on the basis of the reasoning given in the said order and that cannot be expanded or supplemented by affidavits. This has the authority of the law laid down in the case of M.S.Gill [Mohinder Singh Gill v. Chief Election Commissioner, (1978) 1 SCC, 405] 21. It is further submitted that the only issue raised in the impugned orders is that the check gate of the petitioner is on the National Highway. There is nothing mentioned that the petitioner does not have the power or the authority to set up the said check gates. In fact, the relevant letter of 09.12.2021(supra) has recognized that the Autonomous District Councils (the petitioner being one of them) have the power under paragraph 8 of the Sixth Schedule of the Constitution of India to collect taxes, but the same cannot be extended to National Highways and State Highways and PWD roads. This was also confirmed by the statement of the Hon’ble Chief Minister through the minutes of the said 23.06.2022(supra). meeting held on 22. As to the reliance of the learned AG on the case of Sdangyoo L. Dkhar (supra), the learned Sr. counsel for the petitioner has submitted that the issue raised in that case is with regard to the checking of collection of Royalty by the District Council which has set up a parallel check gate to that of the DMR check gate. This Court has held that the District Council is not empowered to run such check gate as it is the duty of the Government to collect royalty and is not the business of the District Council to do so. 23. In the case of Maiantis Mawlot (supra) this Court has made its view clear that the Council has the power to make regulations for control of trading by non-tribals within its jurisdiction as per paragraph 10 of the Sixth Schedule to the Constitution which can be distinguished from the case of Sdangyoo L. Dkhar. 24. This Court has given thoughtful consideration to the submission and contention raised by the parties herein. The short question to be answered is whether the petitioner is entitled to a stay of the operation of the impugned order pending hearing of the matter. 25. The State respondent has contended that the petitioner has no prima facie case since the very authority to set up such check gate is questionable as the petitioner is not empowered by law even under relevant provisions of the Jaintia Hills Autonomous District (Trading by NonTribal) Regulation, 2011 and 2015 respectively. The authority in the case of Sdangyoo L. Dkhar (supra) and also the case of Tangkham M. Sangma (supra) was put forward by the State respondents to say that the act of the petitioner in setting up the said check gate is per se illegal. 26. The other aspect of the matter is that the petitioner has violated the relevant provision of the Control of National Highways (Land and Traffic) Act, 2002 and as such, cannot assert that there is balance of convenience in its favour. 27. In the opinion of this Court, the petitioner has been able to refute the contention raised by the State respondents, inasmuch as, the fact that an assertion has been made that there is no legal provision for the petitioner to set up the said check gate, in the case of Maiantis Mawlot (supra), this Court has held that the power to make regulation for control of trading by non-tribals flows from the provision of paragraph 10 of the Sixth Schedule to the Constitution. It was further held that the power to appoint an officer, staff and/or Agent to achieve the objects of regulations is inherent and innate therein. Therefore, it cannot be said that prima facie the petitioner has no legal jurisdiction to set up the said check gate. 28. Again, on the contention of the State respondents that the case of the petitioner is hit by the authority in the case of Sdangyoo L. Dkhar (supra), this Court in the case of Maiantis Mawlot (supra) has observed as follows: “In the order dated 03.05.2016 in WP(C) No. 18 of 2016 as referred by the learned Sr. GA, this Court was essentially concerned with the alleged setting up of “KHADC Mineral Transport Challan Check Point/Royalty Check”; and with reference to the law applicable, this Court did not approve the attempt on the part of the KHADC to recover fees from the vehicles carrying minerals and subjecting them to checking/verification for the purpose of share of royalty. The said decision, essentially concerning Paragraph 9 of the Sixth Schedule to the Constitution as regards share of royalties, will not have a direct bearing on the question involved in the present matter…..” This, has accordingly answered the legal aspect of the matter which in the opinion of this Court is the correct approach as far as this instant case is concerned. 29. On the alleged violation of the provisions of “The Control of National Highway (Land and Traffic) Act, 2002” this Court is in agreement with the argument raised by the petitioner to say that the question of whether the check gate of the petitioner is on the National Highway or beyond it can be ascertained only when the entire matter is heard as that is the crux of the problem in these proceedings. Prima facie, it cannot be said that the petitioner has set up the said check gate on the National Highway. It may also be mentioned that the Highway Administration ought to have raised an objection or file a complaint if such act of violation within its jurisdiction has been committed. There is no record of such complaint at this juncture. 30. On an overall consideration of the matter, this Court is convinced that the petitioner has a prima facie case and the balance of convenience lies with it and if the impugned orders are not kept in abeyance, irreparable loss and injury would be caused to it. 31. Accordingly, pending final disposal of the main petition, the prayer of the petitioner for stay of the operation of the impugned letter No. DCA.103/2016/387 dated 25.02.2022 and related order dated 12.07.2022 under Memo No. GEN.213/JHADC/C.GATE/2018/228 is hereby allowed. 32. This Misc. Case is hereby disposed of. Judge Meghalaya 03.08.2022 “D. Nary, PS”

This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.

Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong? Request a review

All Meghalaya HC judgments →