Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 12th May, 2026
Pronounced on: 30th July, 2026
%
+
RFA 53/2025, CM APPL. 3441-3443/2025
MRS JAISHREE GUPTA
W/o Mr. Arvind Kumar Gupta
R/o C-403 Vikas Puri, New Delhi.
.…Appellant
Through: Mr. Sanjay Kumar, Advocate
versus
RELIANCE SECURITIES LIMITED
Office 1001, Faiz ROAD
Karol Bagh, New Delhi.
Through: None.
.…Respondent
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M
E N T
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
1.
The present Regular First Appeal under Section 96 of the Code of
Civil
Procedure,
has
been
preferred
on
behalf
of
the
Appellant/Plaintiff, Mrs. Jaishree Gupta, assailing the Judgment dated
11.10.2023 passed by the learned Additional District Judge, Delhi whereby
the Suit for Mandatory Injunction and Recovery instituted by the Appellant
was decreed in part, to the extent of directing the Respondent to pay a salary
for the period of seven months and fifteen days along with interest at the
rate of 7% per annum, while declining the principal relief of reinstatement
in service.
2.
The Plaintiff/ Appellant had filed CS DJ No. 610118/2016
Mandatory Injunction seeking
reinstatement to
for
her service and for
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:44:52
RFA 53/2025
Recovery of Rs. 9,42,150/- towards salary from February, 2012 till the actual
date of reinstatement, along with interest at the rate of 18% per annum and
compensation.
3.
Briefly stated, the case of the Appellant/Plaintiff was that she had
joined the Respondent Company on 23.09.2010 pursuant to Letter of
Appointment of even date, as Regional Head (Grade E-8(a)), Delhi in the
Sales and Distribution Department, at a gross annual pay of Rs. 18,00,000/-.
She was initially placed on probation, for a period of six months.
4.
The Plaintiff claimed that during the course of her employment, she
discharged her duties with sincerity and devotion, on account of which she
came to be recognised by the Respondent, for her performance. Vide Letter
dated 02.06.2011, of the Chief Executive Officer of the Respondent
Company, she had been rated as a "Good Performer" for the period 2010–
2011 and was awarded a Performance Linked Incentive of Rs. 11,438/-.
5.
The services of the plaintiff were confirmed as Regional Head vide
Letter dated 10.06.2011, with effect from 01.04.2011. She continued to be
posted at the Karol Bagh office, Delhi of the Respondent.
6.
The Respondent vide Letter dated 15.07.2011, communicated to the
Appellant that her performance for the period had again been rated as
"Good", and her fixed Cost to Company was revised from Rs. 18,00,000/per annum to Rs. 18,84,300/- per annum with effect from 01.04.2011.
7.
The Plaintiff through her Letter dated 02.11.2011, sought transfer and
was transferred from the Sales and Distribution Department to the
Corporate Sales Department as Assistant Vice President – Corporate Sales,
with effect from 01.11.2011, reporting to one Sh. Ashok Chhangani.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:44:52
RFA 53/2025
8.
In the month of November 2011, the Appellant conceived and in the
mid of November 2011, she orally intimated her senior officers of the
Respondent Company, about her pregnancy. Thereafter, vide e-mail dated
12.12.2011, she informing that her expected date of delivery was in March,
2012 and sought sanction of maternity leave from the Human Resources
Department of the Respondent. The Respondent, vide reply e-mail of the
same date, asked her to furnish a doctor's Certificate confirming the
pregnancy and informing that maternity leave could be availed only three to
four weeks, prior to the expected date of delivery.
9.
The Appellant averred that from the point of intimation of her
pregnancy, the attitude of her senior officers underwent a change, and she
was subjected to harassment, on one pretext or the other. She approached
her seniors, including Sh. Santosh Unikkat and Sh. Vikrant Gugnani, for
sanction of maternity leave, but no approval was forthcoming.
10.
The Appellant further averred that on 04.02.2012, one Sh. Sunil
Somarajan of the Human Resources Department directed her to complete
her exit formalities. Prior thereto, vide Letter dated 24.01.2012, the
Respondent had terminated the services of the Appellant with effect from
30.01.2012, on the purported ground of non-performance.
11.
It was submitted that at the time of the termination of her services, the
Appellant was in an advanced stage of pregnancy, her expected date of
delivery being in March, 2012, and she was thus, deprived of her maternity
benefits. A daughter was born to her, on 02.03.2012.
12.
The Appellant asserted that the Letters of appreciation, confirmation
and enhancement of Cost to Company issued in her favour by the
Respondent, in close proximity to the date of termination, belied any claim
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:44:52
RFA 53/2025
of non-performance, and that the termination was in truth, a device to
disentitle her from the maternity benefits to which she would otherwise,
have been entitled.
13.
The Appellant thus, instituted the Suit on 13.09.2012, seeking a
decree of Mandatory Injunction directing the Respondent to reinstate her in
service on the same designation and salary, along with Recovery of Rs.
9,42,150/- towards salary for the months of February, 2012 to July, 2012
and salary up to the actual date of reinstatement, along with interest at the
rate of 18% per annum and compensation.
14.
The Respondent/Defendant in its Written Statement averred that the
services of the Appellant were governed by the terms and conditions of the
Letter of Appointment dated 23.09.2010; and in view of Clause 9(j) thereof,
the Courts at Mumbai, being the location of the headquarters of the
Respondent Company, alone had jurisdiction to entertain the dispute. It was
further contended that the Suit had not been properly valued for the
purposes of Court fees.
15.
On merits, the Respondent asserted that the performance of the
Appellant in her role as Regional Head at Delhi, had been below
expectations from the very inception, and that her confirmation had been
withheld beyond the probation period and was ultimately granted with effect
from 01.04.2011, only with a view to afford her an opportunity to improve.
It was asserted that despite repeated warnings issued through various e-mails
between May, 2011 and December, 2011, the performance of the Appellant
did not improve; that she had been placed under a Performance
Improvement Plan; and that she had been shifted from Sales and
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:44:52
RFA 53/2025
Distribution to Corporate Sales in November, 2011, as a second opportunity,
with reduced targets, which too, she failed to meet.
16.
The Respondent denied that the service of the Appellant was
terminated on account of her pregnancy or with a view to deny her maternity
benefits. It was stated that vide e-mail dated 12.12.2011, the Appellant had
been called upon to furnish a doctor's Certificate confirming her pregnancy,
which she failed to do. The termination of her services vide Letter dated
24.01.2012, was solely on the ground of non-performance, in exercise of the
powers reserved under Clause 8(c) of the Letter of Appointment, and had no
connection whatsoever with the intimation of her pregnancy.
17.
The Appellant/Plaintiff, in her Replication, reiterated the averments
made in the Plaint and denied the case set up by the Respondent in the
Written Statement.
18.
From the pleadings of the parties, the learned Trial Court, vide Order
dated 29.01.2013, framed the following Issues:
i.
Whether this court has territorial jurisdiction to entertain and
try suit? OPP.
ii.
Whether the suit has been valued correctly for the purpose of
court fee and sufficient court fee is affixed on the plaint? OPP.
iii.
Whether the plaintiff was an under performer/ zero performer
employee of the defendant leading to her termination from
service? OPD.
iv.
Whether the plaintiff is entitled to decree of mandatory
injunction of reinstatement in service? OPP.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:44:52
RFA 53/2025
v.
Whether the plaintiff is entitled to recover the suit amount from
the defendant with interest? OPP.
vi.
19.
Relief."
Issues no. 1 and 2 were treated as preliminary issues and were
decided vide Order dated 17.01.2014 in favour of the Appellant, holding that
the Courts at Delhi possessed the requisite territorial jurisdiction to entertain
and try the Suit and that the Suit had been correctly valued for the purposes
of Court fees. The said findings attained finality and are not in issue in the
present Appeal.
20.
The Plaintiff examined herself as PW-1, and deposed on similar lines
as the assertions made in the plaint. She proved the documents pertaining to
her appointment, transfer and termination, as Ex. PW1/2 to Ex.PW1/9
21.
PW-2, Sh. Arvind Kumar Gupta, the husband of the Appellant,
tendered his evidence by way of affidavit
22.
PW-3, Sh. Jatin Sharma, Computer Operator from the Medical
Record Department of Sri Balaji Action Medical Institute, Paschim Vihar,
through whom the medical records pertaining to the delivery of the child
came to be proved.
23.
The Respondent/defendant
examined DW-1,
Sh. Atul Kumar
Sharma, its Authorised Representative and Relationship Manager. He
proved the series of e-mails purporting to reflect warnings issued to the
Appellant regarding her performance, as Ex.DW1/3 to Ex.DW1/13, along
with the Certificate under Section 65-B of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872
Ex.DW1/15, and the Termination Letter dated 24.01.2012 Ex.DW1/14.
24.
The learned Trial Court, upon appreciation of the pleadings and the
evidence led by the parties, held that the electronic evidence sought to be
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:44:52
RFA 53/2025
proved by the Respondent through DW-1, could not be read in evidence for
want of a valid Certificate under Section 65-B Indian Evidence Act, 1872,
and that the Respondent had thereby failed to establish that the Appellant
was an under-performer/zero-performer employee. It was further held that
in the overall facts and circumstances, and having regard to the proximity
between the intimation of pregnancy on 12.12.2011 and the Termination
Letter dated 24.01.2012, it was probable that the Respondent had terminated
the services of the Appellant in order to avoid the grant of maternity
benefits.
25.
The learned Trial Court accordingly, held that the termination of the
services of the Appellant was in breach of the contract of employment.
However, it was observed that contracts of employment are not liable to be
specifically enforced, and that the appropriate remedy for such breach was
damages. The Respondent was directed to pay to the Appellant salary for a
period of seven months and fifteen days, as per her last drawn salary,
being 45 days' salary in lieu of notice and six months' salary in lieu of
maternity benefits, along with interest at the rate of 7% per annum from
the date of accrual till the date of realisation, along with costs.
26.
Aggrieved by the Judgment dated 11.10.2023 as it declined the relief
of reinstatement in service and confined the monetary decree to seven
months and fifteen days' salary along with interest at the rate of 7% per
annum, the Plaintiff/Appellant has preferred the present Appeal.
27.
The grounds of challenge, are that though the learned Trial Court
has returned findings in favour of the Appellant that the Respondent had
failed to establish the case of non-performance and the services of the
Appellant had been terminated with a view to deny her the maternity
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:44:52
RFA 53/2025
benefits to which she was otherwise entitled, the relief of reinstatement in
service, which was the principal relief prayed for in the Suit, has been
erroneously declined.
28.
Further, the learned Trial Court has failed to appreciate that having
been arbitrarily dismissed from services on account of her pregnancy, the
Appellant was entitled to be reinstated on the same designation and at the
same salary along with all consequential benefits, and that the false
allegations of poor performance levelled against her, have caused irreparable
damage to her career and reputation in the Corporate Sector, for which no
compensation whatsoever has been granted.
29.
Also, the interest awarded at the rate of 7% per annum as against the
rate of 18% per annum prayed for, is not commensurate with the wrong
committed by the Respondent.
30.
The Appellant has thus, sought
reinstatement in service and
enhanced interest as well as the Compensation.
Submissions heard and Record perused.
31.
Admittedly,
the
Appellant/Plaintiff
was
appointed
by
the
Respondent/Defendant Company as Regional Head in the Sales and
Distribution department at Delhi, vide Letter of Appointment dated
23.09.2010, Ex. PW1/2, on a gross annual pay of Rs. 18,00,000/-. Her
services were confirmed with effect from 01.04.2011 vide Letter dated
10.06.2011, Ex. PW1/4. Her performance was consistently rated as "Good"
in the Letters dated 02.06.2011, Ex. PW1/3, and 15.07.2011, Ex. PW1/5.
32.
Upon the Appellant intimating about her pregnancy to the Human
Resources Department of the Respondent, on 12.12.2011 and seeking
sanction of maternity leave, her services were terminated vide Letter dated
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:44:52
RFA 53/2025
24.01.2012, Ex. PW1/9, on the purported ground of non-performance,
with effect from 30.01.2012.
33.
The findings given by the learned Trial Court on Issues no. 3, 4 and
5, to hold the termination of the services of the Appellant to be in breach of
the contract of employment, have not been assailed by the Respondent by
way of any Cross-Objections, and have, accordingly, attained finality inter
se the parties.
34.
The questions, therefore, which arise are considered as under:
I. Whether the Plaintiff was entitled to reinstatement in service:
35.
The nature of the employment between the parties, as disclosed by the
Letter of Appointment dated 23.09.2010, Ex. PW1/2, is of relevance. The
Letter of Appointment reflects that the Plaintiff was engaged as Regional
Head (Grade E-8(a)), in the Sales and Distribution Department of the
Respondent Company, on a gross annual pay of Rs. 18,00,000/-. The service
conditions of the Appellant were, accordingly, governed exclusively by the
terms of the said Letter of Appointment and no statutory framework
operated upon her employment.
36.
The Appellant was subsequently transferred, vide Letter dated
02.11.2011, Ex. PW1/6, to the Corporate Sales department as Assistant Vice
President – Corporate Sales.
37.
Section 14 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963 embodies the principle
that a contract which is in its nature determinable, or a contract which is
dependent on the personal qualifications of the parties, cannot be
specifically enforced. A contract of employment squarely falls within the
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:44:52
RFA 53/2025
said description, being a contract of personal service, in the classical
sense.
38.
The Supreme Court in Maharashtra State Cooperative Housing
Finance Corporation Ltd. v. Prabhakar Sitaram Bhadange, (2017) 5 SCC
623, has considered this very question and held that the relief of
reinstatement amounts, in substance, to the specific enforcement of a
contract of personal service, and cannot be granted where the employment is
not governed by any statutory framework. It was observed that in such
cases, the appropriate remedy for a breach lies in an award of damages, and
not in a direction restoring the employer-employee relationship.
39.
The rationale underlying the said principle has been articulated by the
Supreme Court in State Bank of India v. S.N. Goyal, (2008) 8 SCC 92,
wherein it was held that where the relationship of master and servant is
purely contractual, the contract of personal service is not specifically
enforceable, having regard to the bar contained in Section 14 of the Specific
Relief Act, 1963, and the aggrieved employee must be relegated to a claim
for damages.
40.
The three well-recognised exceptions to the said rule, namely, cases
involving a public servant governed by Article 311 of the Constitution of
India, a workman under the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, and an employee
of a statutory body whose service conditions are governed by statute, are not
attracted to the present case.
41.
The Appellant, having been employed as Regional Head and
thereafter as Assistant Vice President – Corporate Sales at a gross annual
pay of Rs. 18,00,000/-, was an officer in a managerial position, and not a
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:44:52
RFA 53/2025
"workman" within the meaning of Section 2(s) of the Industrial Disputes
Act, 1947.
42.
The Respondent Company, being a private company incorporated
under the Companies Act, engaged in the business of financial broking and
distribution, is not a statutory body. The contract of employment between
the parties, being a contract of personal service in the private domain, was
not amenable to specific enforcement, and no decree of Mandatory
Injunction directing reinstatement could have been granted by the learned
Trial Court.
43.
The relief of reinstatement in service was, therefore, rightly declined
by the learned Trial Court, and no interference is warranted in the said
conclusion.
II. Whether the monetary relief of Compensation is rightly granted:
44.
The learned Trial Court, having found that the termination of the
services of the Appellant was essentially to avoid payment of Maternity
leave Benefits, has directed the Respondent to pay to the Appellant salary
for a period of six months, in addition to 45 days salary in lieu of Notice
period as per her last drawn salary, as damages for the said breach.
45.
Clauses 8(c) and 8(d) of the Letter of Appointment dated
23.09.2010, Ex. PW1/2, which governed the termination of the services of
the Appellant, are extracted hereunder for ready reference:
"c. Your services are liable to be terminated without any
notice or salary in lieu thereof for misconduct, without
being exhaustive and without prejudice to the general
meaning of the term "misconduct" in the case of reasonable
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:44:52
RFA 53/2025
suspicion of misconduct, disloyalty, commission of an act
involving moral turpitude, any act of indiscipline or
inefficiency.
d. On satisfactory completion of the probation period and
after your confirmation in writing except for the reasons
mentioned in this appointment letter, your services can be
terminated by giving notice of 45 days in writing or
payment of salary, in lieu thereof on either side."
46.
The damages awarded by the learned Trial Court are constituted of
two components: firstly, 45 days' salary, for the Notice Period under Clause
8(d), and secondly, a further six months' salary, having regard to its finding
that the termination of the services of the Appellant was effected essentially
with a view to deprive her of the maternity benefits, which she would
otherwise, have received.
47.
It is settled law that upon a breach of a contract of employment by an
employer, the aggrieved employee is entitled to damages under Section 73
of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, the measure whereof is ordinarily the
salary payable during the period of notice stipulated in the contract of
employment.
48.
The Supreme Court, in S.S. Shetty v. Bharat Nidhi Ltd., AIR 1958 SC
12, has held that where the contract of employment provides for termination
by a stipulated period of Notice, the damages awardable on wrongful
termination, are ordinarily confined to the salary that would have been
payable during the said notice period, and no more, on the reasoning that
the Notice period represents the reasonable time within which the employee
may be expected to secure alternative employment.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:44:52
RFA 53/2025
49.
The Letter of Appointment dated 23.09.2010, Ex. PW1/2, in the
present case, contemplated termination on 45 days' prior notice or salary in
lieu thereof, under Clause 8(d). The measure of damages ordinarily
awardable, on the strict application of the principle in S.S. Shetty (supra),
would have been confined to 45 days' salary.
50.
The Ld. Trial Court therefore, justly granted 45 days salary, in lieu of
the Notice Period.
51.
The learned Trial Court, having returned a finding that the
termination of the services of the Appellant was effected to deprive her of
the maternity benefits which she would otherwise have received, has, in the
exercise of its discretion, awarded a further six months' salary in addition to
the Notice component.
52.
The Appellant had projected the emoluments payable to her on the
basis of the Cost to Company figure of Rs. 18,84,300/- per annum reflected
in the Letter dated 15.07.2011, Ex. PW1/5. The said contention, however,
does not commend itself to this Court. The Cost to Company is a notional
aggregate of all direct and indirect components of an employee's
remuneration, inclusive of retirement benefits, allowances, perquisites and
other components not paid in hand, and is not to be equated with the salary
actually drawn by the employee.
53.
The Appellant, in her cross-examination dated 10.02.2016, has herself
admitted:
"My salary was Rs.1,57,000/- per month."
54.
The learned Trial Court has correctly taken the last drawn salary of
the Appellant and not on the notional Cost to Company figure. No infirmity
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:44:52
RFA 53/2025
attaches, in calculating the quantum of compensation/Damages, on the basis
of her last drawn salary.
55.
So far as the grievance of the Appellant as to loss of career and
reputation is concerned, it is pertinent to refer to her admissions in the crossexamination dated 01.09.2018, wherein she has herself admitted that she has
been working for her livelihood after the termination of her services by the
Respondent; she stated thus:
"It is correct that I have been working for my livelihood after
the termination of my services by the defendant. (Vol. I am
working only part time.) I am an income tax payee."
56.
The Appellant has further admitted, in her cross-examination dated
01.09.2018, her association with Globe Capital Markets Ltd., having stated:
"I am the authorized persons of Globe Capital Markets ltd.
It is correct that the official address of the authorized
person of Globe Capital Markets is C-403, Vikas Puri, New
Delhi."
57.
Pertinently, the said address, namely, C-403, Vikas Puri, New Delhi,
is the residential address of the Appellant as disclosed in the Memo of
Parties in the Plaint, and in the Letter of Appointment dated 23.09.2010, Ex.
PW1/2. It reflects that either she had opened her own business or was
working from home. It is established that she has been working for gain,
since her exit from her job.
58.
Pertinently, no specific claim on the said head was made in the Plaint,
and no evidence was led at the trial in support of the quantum of such loss.
Rather, from her own admissions in the cross-examination, it has emerged
that soon after her leaving the job, she was working gainfully. It is settled
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:44:52
RFA 53/2025
law that damages for loss of reputation and career, are in the nature of
special damages, and must be specifically pleaded and proved. In the
absence of any specific pleading and proof of the quantum of such loss, and
her own admissions, no special damages have been rightly granted.
59.
The Appellant has further assailed the rate of interest of 7% per
annum awarded by the learned Trial Court, and has sought enhancement
thereof to 18% per annum.
60.
The award of interest under Section 34 of the Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908 is a matter of judicial discretion, to be exercised having
regard to the facts and circumstances of the case. The rate of 18% per annum
prayed for by the Appellant has no contractual foundation, the Letter of
Appointment dated 23.09.2010, Ex. PW1/2, containing no stipulation as to
any such rate of interest.
61.
The interest awarded at the rate of 7% per annum from the date of
accrual till the date of realisation, being a discretion exercised on relevant
considerations, does not call for any interference in the exercise of the
appellate jurisdiction of this Court.
Conclusion:
62.
In view of the foregoing discussion, the learned Trial Court, having
found the termination of the services of the Appellant vide Letter dated
24.01.2012, Ex. PW1/9, to be in breach of the contract of employment, has
correctly declined the relief of reinstatement in service, and has correctly
confined the monetary relief of Damages/Compensation to salary for a
period of seven months and fifteen days, as per the last drawn salary of the
Appellant, along with interest at the rate of 7% per annum from the date of
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:44:52
RFA 53/2025
accrual till the date of realisation. The impugned Judgment and Decree dated
11.10.2023, calls for no interference and is accordingly upheld.
63.
The Appeal is, accordingly, dismissed. No order as to costs.
64.
Pending Application(s), if any, are disposed of, accordingly.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
JULY 30, 2026/RS
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:44:52
RFA 53/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review