Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:31779
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CWP No.2377 of 2025
Decided on: 31.07.2026
Jai Bharti
…….Petitioner
Versus
State of H.P. and another
Coram
… Respondents
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Ajay Mohan Goel, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?1 Yes
_____________________________________________________
For the petitioner
:
Mr. Kush Sharma, Advocate.
For the respondents
:
Mr. R.P Singh, Deputy Advocate
General.
Ajay Mohan Goel, Judge(Oral)
By way of this writ petition, the petitioner has, inter
alia, prayed for the following reliefs:“(A). That the entire service period rendered on daily wage
basis till his regularisation may be treated as on regular b
asis on the service period from w.e.f.14.07.2015 to
14.07.2018 on contract basis followed by his regularisation
from due date for all intent and purpose and with
allconsequential benefits and further to pay all the arrears
consequent upon such regularisation of service with
seniority.
(B) To issue a writ of mandamus to direct the respondents to
count the entire service period of petitioner from the date of
initial appointment w.e.f 14.07.2015 towards seniority,
pension, promotion and for all intent and purposes with all
consequential benefits.
(C) That the respondent may further be directed to grant
the benefits of revised pay scales as per new revised
service pay Rules as applicable in the State from due date
Whether reporters of the local papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
2. 2026:HHC:31779
with will arrears along with interest.”
2.
Brief facts necessary for the adjudication of this writ
petition are that the husband of the petitioner died in harness
while serving as a Horticulture Extension Officer on 07.11.2013.
The petitioner was offered appointment against the post of Clerk
on compassionate basis vide order dated 13.07.2015 (Annexure P2) on daily wage basis and she joined as such on 14.07.2015. Her
services were regularised on 01.10.2020. By way of this petition,
the petitioner claims that in the light of the fact that when she
was appointed on compassionate basis, as there was no provision
in the Recruitment and Promotion Rules of appointment on daily
wage basis, her appointment on the said post from 14.07.2015 to
14.07.2018 be treated to be on regular basis.
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that this
issue is no more res integra,
as the Hon’ble Coordinate Bench of
this Court in CWP No.8032 of 2021 titled Vikas Kumar vs State
of Himachal Pradesh & Others and others connected
matters, decided on 23.06.2025 has been pleased to hold that
persons, who are recruited before the 2019 Policy of Appointment
on Compassionate Basis came into force, shall be deemed to have
been appointed on regular basis from their initial date of
appointment. He has made available for the perusal of the Court,
3. 2026:HHC:31779
the judgment passed by the Hon’ble Coordinate Bench.
4.
On the other hand, learned Deputy Advocate General
has argued that the petitioner was offered compassionate
appointment on daily wage basis and it was clearly mentioned in
the appointment letter that her appointment was on daily basis.
She accepted the appointment without any protest and served as
such till her services were regularized in the year 2020. He
submitted that as the petitioner acquiesced
to the terms and
conditions under which the appointment was offered to her, the
present writ petition is not maintainable, as the petitioner cannot
now be allowed to seek the relief as prayed for by her.
5.
Having heard learned counsel for the petitioner as also
learned Deputy Advocate General, this Court is of the considered
view that the present writ petition deserves to be allowed.
6.
The prayer of the petitioner is that the service
rendered by her on daily wage basis till her regularization as a
Clerk be treated as regular. Indeed, this issue is no more res
integra, as the Hon’ble Coordinate Bench of this Court in
No.8032 of 2021 titled
CWP
Vikas Kumar vs State of Himachal
Pradesh & Others and other connected matters decided on
23.06.2025, while dealing with this issue in a very very
comprehensive manner, has been pleased to pass a detailed
4. 2026:HHC:31779
judgment, relevant portion, whereof, is being quoted herein
below:“18.Before considering merit in the aforesaid submissions of learned
Additional Advocate General and Mr. Mukul Sood, Advocate, it is
once again noticed at the cost of repetition that notification dated
13.04.2007, whereby common R&P Rules for the categories of
Clerk/Steno-Typist and Statistical Assistant came to be notified, no
provision has been made to offer appointment to Class-IV
employees on contract basis, meaning thereby all the arguments
raised by the counsel, named hereinabove, are not applicable in the
case of such of the petitioners, who have been offered appointment
on daily wage basis against Class-IV post. As far as petitioners, who
have been given appointment against Class-III post on daily wage
basis are concerned, this Court is of the view that though common
R&P Rules, 2007 which came to be notified vide communication
13.04.2007 provide for appointment on contract basis qua Class-III
post, but it is not in dispute that policy of 1990 for appointment of
kiths and kins of deceased employees on compassionate ground,
which subsequently came to be amended in 2019, nowhere
provided for appointment on daily wage basis be it Class-III and
Class-IV employee.”
19.Interestingly,
though
respondents
by
way
of
notification
dated 13.04.2007 promulgated common R&P Rules, 2007 for the
categories detailed hereinabove, prescribing therein that Class-III
posts shall be filled up on contract basis, but failed to amend policy
of 1990 for compassionate appointment thereby prescribing that
with the promulgation of common R&P Rules, 2007 all the
appointments on compassionate grounds in terms of policy of 1990
now shall be made on contract basis. Respondent-State failed to
bring change in 1990 policy, which otherwise had become
5. 2026:HHC:31779
necessary pursuant to promulgation of common R&P Rules 2007,
notified vide notification dated 13.04.2007. If the policy of 1990 for
appointment on compassionate ground is read in its entirety, it
nowhere suggests that Class-III & IV posts on compassionate
ground, shall be filled up on contract basis, rather it came to be
incorporated
in
the
aforesaid
policy
that
appointment
on
compassionate ground can be made only to the lowest rung of
Class-IV and Class-III posts. The compassionate employment can
be given against Class-III posts on contract basis, in case the
applicant has requisite qualifications prescribed for job as per R&P
Rules. It also provided that in case the deceased was a daily wage
worker, the employment assistance shall be given on daily wage
basis only. For the first time, it came to be incorporated in the policy
of 2019 that compassionate employment against Class-IV posts will
only be on daily wage basis, meaning thereby all appointments
given against Class-IV post prior to afore date were essentially
required to be made on regular basis. As far as appointment against
Class-III posts is concerned, though vide common R&P Rules, 2007
notified vide notification 13.04.2007, Government decided that all
Class-III posts shall filled up on contract basis but till the year 2019,
no change/amendment was carried out in policy of 1990, which
nowhere speaks of appointment against Class-III posts on contract
basis. Even in 2019 policy word “can” has been used, meaning
thereby in appropriate cases appointment against Class-III post on
compassionate ground can be made on regular basis also. At this
stage, it would be profitable to reproduce para-4 of revised policy for
providing compassionate employment to the eligible dependants of
the deceased employees of the State Government herein below:“4. Post to which such appointment can be made:-
6. 2026:HHC:31779
The compassionate appointment is to be provided basically in the
department to which the deceased Govt. employee or the medically
retired government employee belonged, subject to fulfillment of
minimum educational qualifications and such skills as are prescribed
for the post. In exceptional cases, where the post does not exist in
the Department concerned, the said Department may recommend
appointment in another department, to the Finance Department,
subject to availability of vacancies in the concerned Department. On
receiving the request, Finance Department will send the matter to
the concerned Department to consider the appointment. The
appointment on compassionate grounds can be made only to the
lowest rung of Class –IV and Class-III posts. The compassionate
employment can be given against Class-III posts on contract basis,
in case the applicant has requisite qualifications prescribed for the
job as per R&P Rules. In case the deceased was a daily waged
worker,
the
employment
assistance
shall
be
given
on
daily wage basis only. Compassionate employment to be given
against on Class-IV posts will only be on daily wage basis. Under no
circumstances, appointment(s) should be made against Class-III
posts, which require technical/professional qualifications.”
20. Leaving everything aside, this Court is of the view that though
with the issuance of notification dated 13.4.2007, Government of
Himachal Pradesh decided to fill up the posts of Class-III on contract
basis, but since amendment in that regard in the policy of
1990 for compassionate appointment came to be incorporated in
2019 policy, all the appointments given prior to afore date, be it
Class-III and Class-IV are/were essentially on regular basis, as has
been otherwise held by Hon'ble Apex Court in Lekh Ram’s
case(supra).
7. 2026:HHC:31779
21. Consequently, in view of the above, this Court finds merit in the
present
petitions
and
accordingly
same
are
allowed
and
appointment given to the petitioners on compassionate grounds
from the date of their initial appointment shall be deemed to have
been given on regular basis. Further in terms of law laid down by
Hon'ble Apex Court in Lekh Ram’s case (supra) and in CWP No.
7556 of 2022, titled Rahul Attri and another vs. State of Himachal
Pradesh and others, and CWPOA No. 2343 of 2020 titled Vikram
Singh Vs. Himachal Road Transport Corporation along with
connected matters, petitioners shall be entitled to all consequential
benefits. Pending applications, if any, also stand disposed of.”
7.
Therefore,
in the light of the said judgment of the
Hon’ble Coordinate Bench as this issue is no more res integra that
appointment against Class-III Post on compassionate basis, in the
absence of provision in the Recruitment and Promotion Rules that
such an appointment should have been on daily wage basis,
should have been offered on regular basis, this petition is allowed
by holding that the act of the respondents of engaging the
petitioner
initially on 14.07.2015 to 14.07.2018 on daily wage
basis as bad.
8.
Accordingly, the respondents are directed to treat the
petitioner as a regular incumbent from the initial date of her
appointment,
i.e.
14.07.2015
for
all
intents
and
purposes,
including seniority and monetary benefits, save and except that
8. 2026:HHC:31779
the monetary benefits shall be notional as from the date of initial
appointment as up to three years preceding the date of filing the
writ petition. Petition stands disposed of, so also pending
miscellaneous applications, if any.
(Ajay Mohan Goel)
Judge
July 31, 2026
(meera)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review