Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:7989DB
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
F.A. No. 330 of 2023
Jahanara Khatoon @ Jahan Ara Khatoon, aged about 42 years, wife of
Md. Asif Ali, resident of village Mazhartola, PO: Borio, PS: Borio (J),
District Sahibganj
..… Defendant/Appellant
Versus
Md. Asif Ali, aged about 45 years, son of late Fakhruddin, resident of
village Sakin Kulipara, PO: Sahibganj, PS Sahibganj (T), District
Sahibganj.
…… Plaintiff/Respondent
------CORAM: HON’BLEMR. JUSTICE SUJIT NARAYAN PRASAD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY PRASAD
------For theAppellant
: Mr.Gautam Kumar, Advocate;
Ms. Savita Kumari, Advocate
For the Respondent
: Mr. Sabya Sanchi, Advocate;
Mr. Rakesh Kumar, Advocate
--------Dated: 20thMarch, 2026
1.
The instant appeal under Section 19(1) of the Family Court Act, 1984is
directed against the judgment dated 15.7.2023 and decree dated
28.7.2023, passed by the learned Principal Judge, Family Court, Sahibganj
in Original Suit No. 63 of 2022, whereby and whereunder, the judgment
has been passed with the decree of restitution of conjugal rights in favour
of the plaintiff and against the defendant.
2.
The brief facts of the case leading to filing of the petition filed under
Section 281 of the Mohammedan Law by the plaintiff/respondent needs to
be referred herein which are as under:
The Nikah between the parties was solemnized on 22.3.2015
according to Muslim rites and rituals. After marriage, the defendant came
to her matrimonial house. After sometime of the marriage the wife started
harassing the plaintiff physically and mentally and gradually she made
F.A. No. 330 of 2023
2026:JHHC:7989DB
illicit relationship with one Mantu Shing @ Ravi Shankar Singh. It is
further stated that on 24.07.2016, the defendant went to her maike after
taking money, clothes and jewellaries. Even though, he forgave her all the
evils the plaintiff states that he made efforts to bring back the wife but to
no avail. The plaintiff is still ready to keep his wife. He had gone to the
parental house of the defendant on 20.02.2022 and requested her to live
with him but the defendant assaulted him with fist and slaps. The plaintiff
had gone to the parental house of the defendant on 24.07.2016,
13.03.2022 and 14.03.2022 in order to bring her back. The plaintiff is still
ready to keep his wife-defendant but the defendant is adamant and
reluctant to come back. It is alleged that the wife-defendant left the
husband-plaintiff without any reasonable cause and despite efforts refused
to come back. The cause of action for the suit arose on 14.03.2022 when
the defendant-wife refused to co-habit with the husband-plaintiff without
any lawful cause.
Arguments advanced on behalf of the appellant:
3. The learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant has submitted that
the judgment and decree passed by the learned Family Judge on the basis of
consideration of five witnesses, namely, PW-1 Md.Asif Ali, PW-2 Md.Yasim
Alam @ Golu, PW-3 Md. Sayeed, PW-4 Md.Jeb Alam and PW-5 Md.Imam
Hussan.
4. It has further been contended that while passing the judgment and decree the
learned
family
judge
has
not
provided
any
opportunity
to
the
defendant/appellant to defend the case as she has never received any notice and
she had no knowledge about the present case.It has been submitted that
F.A. No. 330 of 2023
2026:JHHC:7989DB
although notices have been issued twice but only on the basis of tracking report
the notice has been acceptedto be validly served and the learned Family Judge
has held the proceeding to be ex-parte by making a remark that even after
issuance of notice upon the defendant-appellant herein, the defendant did not
appear.
5.
It has further been contended that the learned Family Judge has taken the
issue very casually and without ascertaining the proper service report and even
by not asking the party to go for the substituted service of notice, has held the
proceeding to be ex-parte and passed the impugned judgment/decree contrary
to her interest and, as such, vital rights have been taken away from the
defendant-appellant
to
defend
herself.
Therefore,
the
impugned
judgment/decree is fit to be quashed and set-aside.
Arguments advanced on behalf of the respondent:
6. While on the other hand, the learned counsel for the respondent-husband has
submitted that twice steps have been taken by the learned family judge. The
notice has also been sent through Speed Post, the tracking report has been
placed before the learned Family Judge and the learned Family Judge based
upon that tracking report which has substantiated the service of notice, has
accepted the notice to be validly served, hence, held the proceeding to be exparte and, thus, it is incorrect on the part of the appellant to take ground that
holding the proceeding to be ex-parte, suffers from an error.
7. The learned counsel for the respondent-husband has further submitted that
the learned Family Judge has passed the judgment/decree after taking into
F.A. No. 330 of 2023
2026:JHHC:7989DB
consideration the evidence of five witnesses and, hence, the same suffers from
no error.
Analysis:
8. This Court has heard the learned counsel for the appellant andthe respondent
and gone through the findings recorded by the learned Family Judge in the
impugned judgment, trial court records including the order-sheets based upon
whichthe leaned Family Judge has accepted that the notice has been validly
served upon the defendant/appellant and decided the Suit ex-parte.
9. Since the appeal has been filed on limited ground of holding the proceeding
to be ex-parte and, as such, this court is not going upon the testimony of the
witnesses rather thought it proper to consider the rival submissions made on
behalf of the parties, in order to reach to the conclusion as to whether holding
the proceeding to be an ex-parte against the defendant, the appellant herein, is
just and proper.
10. It is evident from the order dated 22.3.2022 passed in Original Suit No. 63
of 2022 which is the date of filing of petition under section 281 of the
Mohammedan Law filed for restitution of conjugal rights.
11. The matter was posted on 2.4.2022 for hearing on the point of admission.
The matter was heard on 2.4.2022 and the case was admitted with a direction to
post the matter on 2.5.2022 for filing requisites.
12. The notice was issued on 26.6.2022 upon the opposite party, the appellant
herein, but as per the service report the said notice has returned un-served. As
such, the fresh notice was directed to be issued with a direction to file fresh
requisites. The matter was directed to be posted on 15.7.2022.
F.A. No. 330 of 2023
2026:JHHC:7989DB
13. Fresh notice was issued in pursuance of the order dated 26.6.2022. It is
evident from the order dated 15.7.2022 that an attendance has been filed on
behalf of the plaintiff, the appellant herein with tracking report of the notice.
14. The said tracking report has been accepted by the learned family judge by
recording the order that notice has been delivered to the opposite party with a
remark that opposite party is not yet present in the court. The matter has been
directed to be listed on 3.8.2022 for ex-parte evidence. The matter thereafter
was proceeded ex-parte.
15. The respondent-plaintiff to the suit was allowed to examine witnesses and
after hearing the argument the judgment/decree has been passed, the subject
matter of the present appeal.
16. It is also settled that the Court is required to issue notice for the purpose of
securing appearance of the concerned parties. The procedure to secure
appearance is provided under Order V of the Code of Civil Procedure,
1908. Section 18 of the Family Courts Act, 1984 provides the applicability of
the procedural law as available in the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908.
17. The requirement, as per the law as provided under the Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908 for the purpose of securing the appearance of the parties, it is
the duty of the court to take all effective measures to secure the appearance of
the parties concerned, i.e. by issuance of notice through registered post or
through ordinary process and if on the basis of the settled procedure as laid
down for securing the appearance, even the parties are not appearing, then the
order is to be passed that too on the basis of application which is to be made by
the party to go for the substituted service of notice through paper publication.
F.A. No. 330 of 2023
2026:JHHC:7989DB
18.This Court is conscious with the settled position of law that the ex-parte
hearing is the requirement as per the statute but before reaching to such
conclusion, it is bounded duty of the concerned court to take effective steps for
service of notice upon the concerned party so that the appearance must be
secured. However, even if effective service of notice is being taken but the
concerned party has chosen not to appear then the recourse is to be taken by
switching over from the mode of service of notice by way of paper publication.
19. Thereafter, the court is to post the matter for ex-parte hearing on the
principle that if the party, even after service of the notice, has chosen not to
appear then the other party why to suffer.But it is also equally settled that
before switching over to the mode of substituted service of notice, the court has
to wait for the service of notice and the same is to be based upon the valid
report of the process server, so as to take a final call to allow the party
concerned to go for the substituted service of notice.
20. We are of the view that the tracking report cannot justify proper service of
notice. Even accepting that tracking report was placed before the concerned
court then also it was the bounden duty of the learned Family Judge, being the
court of law, to go to serve the notice through the jurisdictional police station
for the purpose of ascertaining the fact about the service of notice. The another
undisputed process, in a case of non-appearance in a situation where the
appearance is being evaded then also the court of law is to go for the
substituted service of notice by publishing the contents of the case at the place
where the concerned party is residing. It is only thereafter the concerned court
being adjudicator of the issue is supposed to come to the conclusion of deemed
service of notice upon the opposite party.
F.A. No. 330 of 2023
2026:JHHC:7989DB
21.There is wide difference in between valid service and deemed service and
before reaching to the conclusion of deemed service all the parameters laid
down in the Code of Civil Procedure strictly to be adhered to. If there will be
any bypass of the process and in absence thereof any adjudication is being
made then it is nothing but miscarriage of justice.
22. It requires to refer herein that the primary function of a Court is to
adjudicate the dispute between the parties on the basis of substantial justice. A
court's duty is to deliver substantial justice, meaning ensuring fair outcomes
based on merits. Laws of procedure are meant to regulate effectively, assist and
aid the object of doing substantial and real justice and not to foreclose even an
adjudication on merits of substantial rights of citizens under personaland other
laws. The procedure has always been viewed as the handmaid of justice and not
meant to hamper the cause of justice or sanctify the miscarriage of justice.
23. The Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Sugandhi v. P. Rajkumar, (2020)
10 SCC 706 has specifically observed that the procedure is the handmaid of
justice. Procedural and technical hurdles shall not be allowed to come in the
way of the court while doing substantial justice. If the procedural violation
does not seriously cause prejudice to the adversary party, courts must lean
towards doing substantial justice rather than relying upon procedural and
technical violation, relevant paragraph of the aforesaid order is being quoted as
under:
"9. It is often said that procedure is the handmaid of justice.
Procedural and technical hurdles shall not be allowed to come in the
way of the court while doing substantial justice. If the procedural
violation does not seriously cause prejudice to the adversary party,
F.A. No. 330 of 2023
2026:JHHC:7989DB
courts must lean towards doing substantial justice rather than relying
upon procedural and technical violation. We should not forget the fact
that litigation is nothing but a journey towards truth which is the
foundation of justice and the court is required to take appropriate
steps to thrash out the underlying truth in every dispute. Therefore,
the court should take a lenient view when an application is made for
production of the documents under sub-rule (3)."
24. In the case of Jasraj Inder Singh v. Hemraj Multanchand,(1977) 2 SCC
155 the Hon'ble Apex court has observed that "Justice is truth, is beauty and
the strategy of healing injustice is discovery of the whole truth and
harmonising human relations. Law's finest hour is not in meditating on
abstractions but in being the delivery agent of full fairness. This divagation is
justified by the need to remind ourselves that the grammar of justice according
to law is not little litigative solution".
25. Justice is nothing but a manifestation of the truth. It is truth which
transcends every other action and when procedural law stands in the way of the
truth, the Court must find a way to circumvent it. Similarly, when substantive
law, as it appears, does not facilitate the emergence of the truth, it is the
paramount duty of the Court to interpret the law in light of its teleos. Such an
exercise is warranted in a higher degree, particularly while considering a social
welfare legislation, reference in this regard be made to the judgment passed by
the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Om Prakash @ Israel @ Raju @ Raju
das Vs. Union of India & Anr. 2025 INSC 43.
26. Further it needs to refer herein that the case which is related to the
matrimonial dispute concerning annulment of marriage or divorce proceeding
F.A. No. 330 of 2023
2026:JHHC:7989DB
is a serious matter and it connects entire life of husband and wife against whom
a decree for declaration of nullity or divorce has been sought. In the said
matter, the court should not follow mechanical approach rather the court should
take all statutory provision into account which is expected for appearance of
the party.
26. This Court is dealing with the issue of matrimonial dispute where the
valuable right to defend is available to the opposite party to the Suit and if the
procedure which has been adopted by the learned Family Judge, putting the
case for ex-parte proceeding and thereafter passing the judgment /decree, will
be approved then it is nothing but miscarriage of justice so far as the appellantwife is concerned who is the defendant to the Suit.
28. This Court, based upon the aforesaid as has been referred hereinabove that
the appellant being the wife and a contesting party upon whom the allegation
has been levelled by filing an application under the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955,
and as such, she ought to have given all effective opportunities to contest the
case by taking effective measures for the purpose of securing her appearance.
29. This Court, in exercise of the appellate jurisdiction, is of the view that the
learned Family Judge while posting the matter for ex-parte hearing has not
taken the proper recourse for appearance of the opposite party available in the
statute and has erred in passing the impugned judgment and decree. As such,
the impugned judgment and decree needs interference on the ground of
providing an opportunity to the defendant /wife to defend herself (the appellant
herein).
F.A. No. 330 of 2023
2026:JHHC:7989DB
30. Accordingly, the impugned judgment dated 15.7.2023 and decree dated
28.7.2023 passed by the learned Principal Judge, Family Court, Sahibganj in
Original Suit No. 63 of 2022 are hereby quashed and set-aside.
31.In consequence thereof, the Original Suit No. 63 of 2022 is restored to its
original file.
32. The learned counsel(s) appearing for both the parties have undertaken to
put their appearance before the learned Principal Judge, Family Court,
Sahibganj within three weeks from the date of receipt of the copy of this order.
33. The learned Principal Judge, Family Court, Sahibganj is directed to decide
the issue on its own merits within six months taking into consideration the fact
that the Suit is of the year 2022.
34. Accordingly, the instant appeal is allowed and disposed of.
35. Pending IA(s), if any, stands disposed of.
(Sujit Narayan Prasad, J.)
(Sanjay Prasad, J.)
Jharkhand High Court
Dated:20.3.2026
KNR/A.F.R.
Uploaded On: 30 /03/2026
F.A. No. 330 of 2023
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review