Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 03
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
BA No. 59 of 2023
Date of Decision: 15.12.2023
Shri. Jahangir Alom
Vs.
State of Meghalaya
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
: Mr. B. Deb, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. H. Kharmih, Addl. P.P with
Mr. H. Abraham, GA
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
1.
Heard Mr. B. Deb, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner/accused who has submitted that an FIR dated 20.06.2023 was
lodged before the Officer-in-Charge, Khliehriat Police Station, East
Jaintia Hills District by one ABSI W. Lamare wherein, on reliable
information received by the police that two drug peddlers are travelling
in a Tourist Taxi carrying a consignment of illegal contraband, the same
to be delivered to the petitioner herein and one Shahnowar Ali at
Guwahati, on a check post being erected the vehicle in question being
No. NL 07 T 0815 (Tata Winger) was intercepted at BMS Fuel Station,
Nongsning. On a search being conducted from the vehicle, about 200
soap cases containing yellowish-orange powder were found concealed
in various hidden compartments in the vehicle, preliminary test of the
powder giving a positive result for heroin. The total gross weight of the
said powder comes to 2.738 kg.
2.
Upon registration of a criminal case being Khliehriat P.S
Case No. 8(6) 2023 under Section 21(c)/29 NDPS Act, the two persons
were arrested. In course of investigation, Shri. Jahangir Alom the
petitioner herein was also arrested having been named by the coaccused as one of the main persons involved in the said drug peddling
operation. On completion of the investigation, the Investigating Officer
has filed the charge sheet on 06.09.2023 finding a prima facie case
under section 21(c)/29 NDPS Act well established against the petitioner
and other co-accused.
3.
The learned counsel has again submitted that in the process
of arrest of the petitioner, the concerned authorities have breached a
number of mandatory procedures, one of which is evident on perusal of
the arrest memo, wherein at the time when the petitioner herein was
arrested, one witness was present, however, the said witness is a police
personnel whereas the mandate of law as indicated in the case of D.K.
Basu v. State of West Bengal, (1997) 1 SCC 416 at para 35(2), wherein
the provision of Section 41B (b)(i) Cr.P.C, which provides that a
memorandum of arrest shall be attested by at least one witness who is a
member of the family of the person arrested, has been restated, has also
not been complied with.
4.
Another contention raised by the learned counsel is that the
alleged seizure of the contraband drugs was about 2.738 kg of heroin.
The sample collected was only from Ex-A1-3.34 gms, Ex-B1-3.55 gms,
Ex-C1- 3.54gms and Ex-D1-3.54 gms, the total sample collected being
7.75 gms. The sample of the contents of all the soap boxes seized was
not taken and as such, the alleged seized contraband is only of an
intermediate quantity and not of a commercial quantity, the provision of
Section 37 of the NDPS Act is therefore not attracted, further submits
the learned counsel. The case of Naim Khan v. The State of Madhya
Pradesh, wherein vide order dated 05.12.2022, the Hon‟ble High Court
of Madhya Pradesh in Misc. Criminal Case No. 56923 of 2022
pertaining to a prayer for grant of bail of an accused in connection with
a case under the NDPS Act, has taken into account the argument of the
applicant therein, when it was pointed out that the procedure adopted by
the concerned police authority in the process of sampling is contrary to
the relevant rule, particularly Standing Order No. 01 of 1989 dated
13.06.1989. On this ground, bail was granted.
5.
In continuation of his contention on the issue of sampling
and the procedure thereof, the learned counsel has cited the provisions
of Narcotic Drug and Psychotropic Substances (Seizure, Storage,
Sampling and Disposal) Rules, 2022 and has referred to Rules 3, 10(1)
and 11 of the same to say that the procedure prescribed therein has not
been followed by the arresting authorities in the case where the
petitioner was arrested.
6.
Another limb of argument advanced by the learned counsel
in support of his case is that the alleged contraband drug has not been
seized from his possession and as such, as was held in the case of State
of Delhi v. Ram Avatar alias Rama, (2011) 12 SCC 207, wherein at
para 28 of the same, it was held that to secure conviction under Section
21 of the NDPS Act, possession of the illicit article is a sine qua non,
and also on a similar view held by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in the
case of Noor Aga v. State of Punjab & Another, (2008) 16 SCC 417 at
para 59 of the same, the petitioner is entitled to be enlarged on bail,
submits the learned counsel.
7.
It is also the submission of the learned counsel that the
petitioner was arrested only on the basis of the statement of the co-
accused in this case and such statement made before the police cannot
be taken cognizance of as was held in the case of Tofan Singh v. State
of Tamil Nadu, reported in (2021) 4 SCC 1, wherein the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court has held that Officers who are invested with powers
under Section 53 of the NDPS Act are “Police Officer” within the
meaning of Section 25 of the Evidence Act, as a result of which any
confessional statement made to them would be barred under the
provisions of Section 25 of the Evidence Act and the same cannot be
taken into account in order to convict an accused under the NDPS Act.
8.
Yet again, the learned counsel has submitted that the
petitioner was arrested on the basis of the confession of the co-accused
and also that there is evidence that he was possessing two sim cards by
which he used to communicate with the co-accused. However, the said
sim cards and the mobile phone were never seized from the possession
of the petitioner. Thus, there is no reasonable ground for believing that
the petitioner has abetted or conspired in the commission of the alleged
crime. The case of State of Kerala v. Rajesh reported in (2020) 12 SCC
122 was cited by the learned counsel in this regard, wherein at para 21
of the same, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court has observed that “the
expression „reasonable grounds‟ means something more than prima
facie grounds. It contemplates substantial probable causes for believing
that the accused is not guilty of the alleged offence…”
9.
On the applicability of Section 37 of the NDPS Act as far as
the case of the petitioner is concerned, the learned counsel has cited the
case of Narcotics Control Bureau v. Mohit Aggarwal, 2022 SCC
OnLine SC 891 and has referred to para 15 & 16 of the same which
reads as follows:
“15. We may clarify that at the stage of
examining an application for bail in the
context of the Section 37 of the Act, the Court
is not required to record a finding that the
accused person is not guilty. The Court is also
not expected to weigh the evidence for
arriving at a finding as to whether the
accused has committed an offence under the
NDPS Act or not. The entire exercise that the
Court is expected to undertake at this stage is
for the limited purpose of releasing him on
bail. Thus, the focus is on the availability of
reasonable grounds for believing that the
accused is not guilty of the offences that he
has been charged with and he is unlikely to
commit an offence under the Act while on
bail.
16. Coming back to the facts of the instant
case, the learned Single Judge of the High
Court cannot be faulted for holding that the
appellant- NCB could not have relied on the
confessional statements of the respondent and
the other co-accused recorded under Section
67 of the NDPS Act in the light of law laid
down by a Three Judges Bench of this Court
in Tofan Singh (supra), wherein as per the
majority decision, a confessional statement
recorded under Section 67 of the NDPS Act
has been held to be inadmissible in the trial of
an offence under the NDPS Act. Therefore,
the admissions made by the respondent while
in custody to the effect that he had illegally
traded in narcotic drugs, will have to be kept
aside. However, this was not the only material
that the appellant- NCB had relied on to
oppose the bail application filed by the
respondent.
The
appellant-NCB
had
specifically stated that it was the disclosures
made by the respondent that had led the NCB
team to arrive at and raid the godown of the
co-accused, Promod Jaipuria which resulted
in the recovery of a large haul of different
psychotropic substances in the form of tablets,
injections and syrups. Counsel for the
appellant-NCB had also pointed out that it
was the respondent who had disclosed the
address and location of the co-accused,
Promod Jaipuria who was arrested later on
and the CDR details of the mobile phones of
all co- accused including the respondent
herein showed that they were in touch with
each other.”
10.
On the basis of the submission made before this Court, the
learned counsel has submitted that the petitioner may be enlarged on
bail with any conditions as deem fit and proper to be imposed by this
Court.
11.
Mr. H. Kharmih, learned Addl. PP while opposing the
prayer made by the petitioner has submitted that the petitioner has a
criminal antecedent, inasmuch as, he was earlier involved in a case in
the Court of the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Goalpara District of Assam
being GR-2278/2016. Though he was acquitted by the court vide order
dated 04.03.2023, however, the case involved not only Section 324 IPC,
but also the provision of Section 22 of the NDPS Act.
12.
As far as this instant case is concerned, the learned Addl. PP
has submitted that a perusal of the case diary which was produced
before this Court today, would show that the co-accused had implicated
the petitioner in the case, inasmuch as, it was in the statement of one of
the co-accused that he has met the petitioner herein on one occasion in
the month of March, 2023 at Guwahati, wherein 20(twenty) soap cases
of heroin were delivered to the petitioner near a shopping mall and also
another 80(eighty) soap cases of heroin was also delivered to the
petitioner in the parking lot of the shopping mall. As far as this case is
concerned, the fact that a seizure of 2.738 kg of heroin which has been
properly accounted for cannot be denied by the petitioner and also the
fact that the petitioner as is evident from the CDR (Call Details Report)
of the phone calls made between the petitioner and the co-accused, the
petitioner may not be allowed to be released on bail.
13.
This Court has carefully considered the case in hand and the
contention as well as the submission by the respective counsel for the
parties and has come to the understanding that a case of seizure of
alleged contraband drugs being heroin weighing about 2.738 kg was
seized from a vehicle, whereupon the occupants of such vehicle were
arrested on a case under the NDPS Act being registered.
14.
That in course of investigation, the petitioner herein was
also arrested, the Investigating Officer having found a credible link
between the petitioner and the co-accused persons in the commission of
the offence alleged, is a matter of record. However, the petitioner has
maintained that he is innocent and not at all involved in the commission
of the said offence and has therefore approached this Court for grant of
bail.
15.
From the submission of the learned counsel for the
petitioner, what could be understood is that objection has been made on
technical grounds, inasmuch as, the alleged wrongful application of the
procedure as far as the seizure and the sampling process of the seized
contraband substance by the arresting authority would enable the
petitioner to be enlarged on bail. A number of decisions, mostly of the
Apex Court has been cited by the learned counsel for the petitioner to
press home the point that factually, there has been a breach of
procedure, wherein the manner in which the sample was collected from
the seized material was not done so according to the proper and legal
format, and on this ground alone, bail ought to have been given to the
accused person therein and by extension to the petitioner herein.
16.
This Court has no quarrel with the proposition set out in the
said authorities cited, but is of the opinion that the ground of defence on
such count can only be made in course of trial when evidence is led and
the prosecution as well as the defence have had the opportunity to place
before the court their respective case on this point. As far as the same
being the consideration for grant of bail, this Court is of the opinion that
the totality of the facts and circumstances has to be taken into account
before any effective order is passed.
17.
What is pertinent herein is that admittedly, the case was one
under Section 21(c) of the NDPS Act which speaks of, inter alia,
possession involving commercial quantity of contraband substances or
drugs and as far as the issue of bail is concerned, the provision of
Section 37 NDPS Act comes into play.
18.
Section 37 1(b)(ii) speaks of a situation where bail cannot be
granted for an offence involving commercial quantity unless the Court
is satisfied that there are reasonable grounds for believing that the
accused person is not guilty of such offence and that he is not likely to
commit any offence while on bail.
19.
The involvement of the petitioner in the case cannot be ruled
out at this point of time, though it is reiterated that it would be a matter
of evidence in course of trial for the petitioner to prove his innocence,
however, at this juncture, this Court is not convinced that he is not
guilty of the offence alleged.
20.
Under the circumstances, this petition is found to be devoid
of merit, the same is hereby dismissed and stands disposed of. No costs.
21.
The case diary produced before this Court is hereby returned
to the learned Addl. PP.
Judge
Meghalaya
15.12.2023
“D. Nary, PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review