Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.01
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
Arb.P.No.1/2022
Date of Order: 18.04.2022
Jaguar Overseas Limited
Coram:
Vs.
Union of India & anr
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sanjib Banerjee, Chief Justice
Appearance:
For the Petitioner
For the Respondents
: Mr. P Chauhan, Adv. with
Ms. P. Biswakarma, Adv
: Dr. N. Mozika, ASG with
Ms. S. Rumthao, Adv.
i) Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii) Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes
Yes/No
JUDGMENT: (Oral)
There is consensus between the parties as to the existence of an
arbitration agreement that covers the disputes that have arisen between
them and that there are live claims to be carried to an arbitral reference.
2.
The arbitration agreement is found in Clause 70 of the general
conditions governing contracts pertaining to the Military Engineering
Services. The clause is set out:
“70. Arbitration–All disputes, between the parties to the
Contract (other than those for which the decision of the C.W.E.
or any other person is by the Contract expressed to be final and
binding) shall, after written notice by either party to the
Contract to the other of them, be referred to the sole arbitration
of a Serving Officer having degree in Engineering or
equivalent or having passed final/direct final Examination of
sub-Division II of Institution of Surveyor (India) recognised by
the Govt. of India to be appointed by the authority mentioned
in the tender documents.
Unless both parties agree in writing such reference shall
not take place until after the completion or alleged completion
of the Works or termination or determination of the Contract
under Condition Nos. 55, 56 and 57 hereof.
Provided that in the event of abandonment of the Works
or cancellation of the Contract under Condition Nos. 52, 53 or
54 hereof, such reference shall not take place until alternative
arrangements have been finalised by the Government to get the
Works completed by or through any other Contractor or
Contractors or Agency or Agencies.
Provided always that commencement or continuance of
any arbitration proceeding hereunder or otherwise shall not in
any manner militate against the Government’s right of
recovery from the Contractor as provided in Condition 67
hereof.
If the Arbitrator so appointed resigns his appointment or
vacates his office or is unable or unwilling to act due to any
reason whatsoever, the authority appointing him may appoint a
new Arbitrator to act in his place.
The Arbitrator shall be deemed to have entered on the
reference on the date he issues notice to both the parties, asking
them to submit to him their statement of the case and pleadings
in defence.
The Arbitrator may proceed with the arbitration, exparte,
if either party, inspite of a notice from the Arbitrator fails to
take part in the proceedings.
The Arbitrator may, from time to time with the consent
of the parties, enlarge, the time for making and publishing the
award.
The Arbitrator shall give his award within a period of six
months from the date of his entering on the reference or within
the extended time as the case may be on all matters referred to
him and shall indicate his findings, along with sums awarded,
separately on each individual, item of dispute. The arbitrator
shall give reason for the award in each and every case
irrespective of the value of claims or counter claims.
The venue of Arbitration shall be such place or places as
may by fixed by the Arbitrator in his sole discretion.
The Award of the Arbitrator shall be final and binding
on both parties to the Contract.”
3.
Though the relevant clause provides for the arbitral reference
to be taken up by a sole arbitrator who would be a serving officer having
a degree in engineering or equivalent and would be appointed by the
authority mentioned in such regard in the tender documents, the Union
concedes that in view of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 as it
now stands after the amendment effected in October, 2015, a serving
officer of the MES can no longer take up the reference. The petitioner has
suggested that any retired Judge or active counsel may be appointed as
arbitrator and a particular name has also been indicated. However, the
Union submits that the Ministry of Defence has prepared a panel of
arbitrators who are not serving officers and have no relationship with the
Ministry of Defence. The Union suggests that any of the independent
persons named in the Ministry’s panel be appointed as sole arbitrator,
subject to the other terms and conditions of the arbitration agreement
embodied in Clause 70 of the general conditions.
4.
Section 12(1)(a) of the Act, as amended, obliges a person upon
being approached to be an arbitrator to disclose the circumstances which
may give rise to justifiable doubts as to his independence or impartiality.
More importantly, Section 12(5) of the Act prohibits the appointment of
a person as an arbitrator who falls under any of the categories specified in
the Seventh Schedule to the Act which has been inserted by the 2015
Amendment.
5.
It may do well to notice sub-section (5) of Section 12 of the
Act in its entirety:
“(5). Notwithstanding any prior agreement to the contrary, any
person whose relationship, with the parties or counsel or the
subject-matter of the dispute, falls under any of the categories
specified in the Seventh Schedule shall be ineligible to be
appointed as an arbitrator:
Provided that parties may, subsequent to disputes having arisen
between them, waive the applicability of this sub-section by an
express agreement in writing.”
6.
The first of the several categories under the heading
“Arbitrator’s relationship with the parties or counsel” set out in the
Seventh Schedule is as follows:
“The arbitrator is an employee, consultant, advisor or has any
other past or present business relationship with a party.”
7.
In the context of the degree of impartiality that the amended
provisions of the said Act seek to put in place, a person empanelled as an
arbitrator by any party has, per force, to be seen as having a business
relationship with such party within the meaning of the category quoted
above from the Seventh Schedule.
8.
Partiality or bias is a state of mind and it is well-nigh
impossible to prove or establish latent or patent bias just as it is to
demonstrate active or underlying partiality. As a consequence, the
experience that is law lays down the test in such regard to be: whether
the circumstances exist that may give rise to a justifiable doubt as to the
independence or impartiality of the person concerned. As a consequence,
reasonable possibility of bias or likelihood of partiality would suffice.
Obvious bias or apparent partiality need not be demonstrated; and, it is
of no relevance in the present context, particularly since the prohibition
operates at the inception.
9.
It is only human that a person, who stands to obtain monetary
benefits by taking up an arbitral reference, may be favourably inclined
towards the party that has empanelled him so that his name continues to
appear in the panel and there are possibilities of future appointment.
There is no doubt that it will play at the back of the mind of an
empanelled arbitrator that if a punitive or heavy award is made against
the party that has empanelled him, even if the party which has
empanelled him is deserving of the same, the arbitrator’s name may not
figure in the panel in future. Similarly, at the other end of the spectrum,
an empanelled arbitrator may subconsciously award more heavily in
favour of the party that has empanelled him to stand a better chance to be
retained on the panel. Once such reasonable possibility arises, it amounts
to a justifiable doubt as to the independence or impartiality of the person
concerned.
10.
The creation of a panel of arbitrators by a government
employer for the contractor to choose therefrom cannot, by itself, be said
to be useless altogether. However, in the light of the Proviso to Section
12(5) of the Act that speaks of a post-dispute waiver of the applicability
of the Seventh Schedule by the other party, the panel can only be of
relevance if the other party to the arbitration agreement accepts one of the
persons named in the panel to take up the reference.
11.
It is significant that the relevant Proviso specifically refers to
the waiver being at a stage when the disputes have already arisen. This
will preclude the appointment of an arbitrator named in the arbitration
agreement whose appointment would otherwise fall foul of the Seventh
Schedule. Pre-dispute concurrence as to the personnel of the arbitrator
will not prevent a party to an arbitration agreement objecting to the
agreed arbitrator taking up the reference if any of the conditions
enumerated in the Seventh Schedule fastens to such named arbitrator.
Further, since the word used in the relevant proviso is “waive”, such
waiver has to be a conscious relinquishment of a known right; in the
sense that it must be an overt act of relinquishment rather than a passive
act as in acquiescence.
12.
Once the contractor, as in this case, does not accept the names
on the panel, the panel can no longer be enforced; as there will always be
a justifiable doubt as to the independence or impartiality of a person
whose name has been included in such panel of possible arbitrators. In
the present case, however, the Union does not object to any retired Judge
of a High Court being appointed as arbitrator.
13.
Since the petitioner has suggested the name of Justice B.D.
Agarwal (retired), a former Judge of the Gauhati High Court, and no
express objection regarding such choice has been indicated by the Union,
the disputes and differences that have been arisen between the parties and
that are covered by the arbitration agreement between them are referred
to the sole arbitration of Justice B.D. Agarwal (retired) in accordance
with the arbitration agreement and subject to the conditions indicated
therein.
14.
Nothing in this order will prevent the parties from raising
objections as to the arbitrability of any claim or the extent thereof and it
will be open to the arbitrator to decide all legal and factual issues that
arise in accordance with law and guided by the arbitration agreement
between the parties.
15.
Arb.P.No.1 of 2022 is disposed of.
16.
There will be no order as to costs.
(Sanjib Banerjee)
Chief Justice
Meghalaya
18.04.2022
“Lam DR-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review