Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Judgment reserved on: 22.12.2025
Judgment pronounced on: 09.01.2026
Judgment uploaded on: 09.01.2026
+
MAT.APP.(F.C.) 433/2025, CM APPL. 81004/2025 & CM
APPL. 81005/2025
JAGMEET CHOPRA
.....Appellant
Through: Appellant in-person.
versus
BASANT SAWHNEY
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. Vaibhav Sharma, Ms.
Urvashi Sharma and Mr.
Vinayak Gautam, Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KSHETARPAL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HARISH VAIDYANATHAN
SHANKAR
JUDGMENT
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.
1.
Through the present Appeal, the Appellant-father assails the
correctness of the order dated 15.12.2025 [hereinafter referred to as
‘Impugned Order’] passed by the learned Family Court, Patiala House
Courts, New Delhi, whereby the Family Court, in exercise of its
discretionary jurisdiction, allowed the application moved on behalf of
the Respondent-mother seeking modification of the earlier order dated
14.11.2024 and, accordingly, modified the visitation arrangement by
directing that the Appellant shall meet the minor daughter on the 2nd
and 4th Saturday of every month at Ambience Mall, Vasant Kunj,
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:48:55
MAT.APP. (F.C.)433/2025
Delhi at 6:00 pm, for a duration of one hour, along with provision for
video calls on 1st and 3rd Friday of every month at 6:00 pm, for a
duration of 20 minutes, while keeping the remaining conditions of the
earlier order intact.
2.
The short issue which arises for consideration in the present
Appeal is whether the learned Family Court committed any
jurisdictional error or material irregularity in modifying the interim
visitation arrangement, by reducing the extent and frequency of
visitation, in exercise of its discretionary powers, keeping in view the
welfare of the minor daughter as the paramount consideration?
FACTUAL MATRIX
3.
In order to appreciate the controversy involved in the present
Appeal, the relevant facts, shorn of unnecessary details, may be
briefly noticed. The marriage between the parties was solemnized on
28.10.2019 and out of the said wedlock, a daughter was born on
23.01.2021. Subsequently, marital discord arose between the parties,
leading to the initiation of family court proceedings, inter alia, with
respect to custody and visitation of the minor daughter.
4.
Initially, the Family Court on 31.07.2023, passed a detailed
order regulating the visitation of the Appellant-father with the minor
daughter. The order provided a structured visitation schedule, the
details of which were later modified, after deliberation and
consideration, on 14.11.2024. By the said order dated 14.11.2024, the
Family Court recorded that the Appellant-father was permitted to meet
the minor daughter at Ambience Mall, Vasant Kunj, Delhi at 6:00 pm
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:48:55
MAT.APP. (F.C.)433/2025
on Sunday, Wednesday and Friday of every week, for a limited
duration of one hour on each occasion. It was further directed that the
Respondent-mother would bring the child to the designated play area
on the 3rd Floor of Ambience Mall and remain at a reasonable distance
of 50 meters, so as to enable interaction between the Appellant and the
minor daughter in a non-intrusive environment. The arrangement was
expressly framed as an interim measure, subject to further orders of
the Court.
5.
Despite the interim visitation arrangement of 14.11.2024,
disputes between the parties persisted. On 14.12.2024, an altercation
arose between the Appellant and the mother of the Respondent at the
shared household. It was contended on behalf of the Respondent that
the Appellant and his family members had carried tools to the
premises and attempted to break open the doors, incidents which were
allegedly witnessed by the minor daughter. FIR No. 0076 dated
29.01.2025 was registered with respect to the said incident, which
remained under investigation at the relevant time.
6.
Further incidents were alleged by the Respondent on
24.05.2025 and 10.07.2025, including disconnection of electricity,
tampering with CCTV cameras, and removal of an iron gate at the
shared residence. Complaints and applications under the Protection of
Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 [‘PWDV Act’], were filed
in respect of these events, and certain interim notices were issued by
the learned Additional Sessions Judge [‘ASJ’].
7.
The Family Court, on 15.12.2025, while considering the
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:48:55
MAT.APP. (F.C.)433/2025
Respondent’s application for modification, noted the above incidents
and, relying on the alleged conduct of the Appellant and his family
members, modified the visitation arrangement. By the Impugned
Order, the Court directed that the Appellant-father would meet the
minor daughter only on the 2nd and 4th Saturday of each month at 6:00
pm in Ambience Mall, Vasant Kunj, Delhi for a duration of one hour.
In addition, provision for video calls on 1st and 3rd Friday of each
month at 6:00 pm for 20 minutes was also allowed. The remaining
conditions of the order dated 14.11.2024 were retained.
8.
Aggrieved thereby, the present Appeal was filed by the
Appellant.
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
9.
The Appellant-father contended that:
i.
The Family Court failed to consider the fact that there has
been no significant change in circumstances since the order dated
14.11.2024. It was asserted that the visitation arrangement, which
was arrived at after mutual consent, should not have been
modified without any substantial change in the facts of the case.
ii.
The reduced visitation schedule in the Impugned Order is
not in the best interest of the minor daughter, as it impedes the
child's relationship with the father, thus denying the child the
opportunity to have a meaningful connection with both parents. It
was submitted
that any modification of the visitation
arrangement should be done only on the basis of clear and
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:48:55
MAT.APP. (F.C.)433/2025
compelling evidence of the child’s welfare being at risk.
iii.
The Family Court failed to give due consideration to the
emotional bond that exists between the child and the father. The
reduction in visitation, according to the Appellant, would result
in the alienation of the child, which could have long-term
negative effects on the child’s psychological development.
10.
Per contra, learned counsel for the Respondent, who appears on
advance notice, contended that:
i.
The Family Court worked on the principle of paramount
consideration in the welfare of the child as there have been serious
allegations and incidents concerning the Appellant's behavior, which
have impacted the child’s welfare. These incidents include alleged
illegal breaking into the shared household, threats, and disturbances
witnessed by the minor daughter, leading the Respondent to feel
concerned about the child's safety during the visits.
ii.
The minor daughter is presently of school-going age and is in
her formative years, requiring stability, routine, and adequate time for
academic engagement as well as co-curricular activities. The earlier
visitation arrangement, which required the child to attend multiple
physical meetings during the week for limited durations, entailed
repeated travel and disruption of the child’s daily schedule. In such
circumstances, the modification of visitation, by reducing the
frequency of physical interaction while retaining avenues for regular
contact, was urged to be better aligned with the child’s overall welfare
and developmental needs.
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:48:55
MAT.APP. (F.C.)433/2025
iii.
The Appellant’s conduct, including violations of protection
orders and court directions, has demonstrated a lack of regard for the
welfare of the child and the safety of the Respondent.
ANALYSIS & FINDINGS
11.
This Court has considered the rival submissions advanced by
the Appellant and learned counsel for the Respondent and perused the
material on record in the context of governing principles applicable to
interim visitation. It is well settled that, in matters concerning custody
and visitation, the welfare of the minor child is the paramount
consideration, overriding all other considerations, including the
convenience or preference of either parent. The Court must ensure that
the child’s physical safety, emotional well-being, and opportunities for
healthy development are safeguarded, while promoting meaningful
contact with both parents wherever possible. Any modification of
visitation rights must, therefore, be guided by evidence demonstrating
a clear need for change in order to protect the child’s welfare, rather
than on speculative or minor disputes between the parents.
12.
At the outset, it is appropriate to refer to the relevant paragraphs
of the detailed order dated 31.07.2023, which was passed in the
factual context then prevailing and formed the basis for the evolving
visitation arrangements. The same reads as under:
“45. It is true that mother can better understand the touch but mother
is not infallible. Hence, not every thing what respondent says would
be believed or acted upon……….
46.
As on day petitioner stands on better footing qua his desire to
meet the child because allegation against him has already been
investigated by an independent agency and nothing direct or
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:48:55
MAT.APP. (F.C.)433/2025
circumstantial evidence was found to prosecute him except for the
statement of the respondent………
47.
In the context of family law, the welfare of the child is of
paramount importance. Courts are duty bound to ensure that the best
interest of the child are safeguarded while deciding matters relating to
custody and visitation. Undisputedly, the minor daughter is at a tender
age where the presence and care of both parents are crucial for her
overall development. One has got to recognize the significance of the
child's bond with each parent and acknowledge the importance of
fostering a healthy relationship between the child and both parents.
Given that investigation agency have not found by any credible
evidence to substantiate the allegation of the respondent rather their
report suggest allegation to be motivated and this court also on
independent assessment of the material placed on record by the
respondent, has prima facie not found any truth in the allegation of
the respondent and feels that fatherly act of love of the petitioner is
being painted wrongly. It has to be kept in mind that child's sexual
abuse is very grave offense but it is equally graver to paint an
innocuous act of father to be so, that too against his own child.
48.
A child has right to get love, care and affection of both
parents. No parent has right to deny the child of his/her right to get
love, affection and care of other parent because father has some
grievance against mother or vice versa or has some misunderstanding
against each other.
49.
Thus, enforcing the right of the child this court directs
respondent to let the child to be with her father/petitioner everyday for
two hours from 5 PM to 7 PM in the park near their residence of the
parties as both parties are residing within distance of 100 meters.
Since child is of very tender age therefore mother would be around
but since she is likely to raise objection every now and then therefore
though she would be around but must be fifty meters away from the
child when it meets her father so that child has unhindered access to
her father. Respondent is better advised to send her maid to be around
the child with clear instruction not to interfere in the meeting of the
child with petitioner. Respondent is directed to co-operate so that this
order of the court is complied with in letter and spirit……………”
xxx
13.
xxx
xxx
Further, it would be also be appropriate to reproduce the
relevant paragraphs order dated 14.11.2024, which was sought to be
modified vide the Impugned Order. The same reads as under
“….............Ld. Counsel for the respondent has submitted that he and
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:48:55
MAT.APP. (F.C.)433/2025
respondent are very much aware that visitation of the petitioner with
the child cannot be suspended for unlimited period as that may
amount to alienation , therefore, he has submitted that limited
visitation be permitted either through video conferencing or under the
supervision of the Local Commissioner for reduced duration. He has
further submitted that since current pollution level in Delhi has
touched the alarming situation so visitation be changed from park to
elsewhere.
Ld. Counsel for the petitioner has submitted that respondent be
directed to handover the custody of the child for one hour because
petitioner is living in the same vicinity and therefore, it cannot be
inconvenient for the petitioner, respondent as well as for the child.
However, after much deliberation and consideration, it has been
agreed between the parties that the petitioner shall meet the child in
the nearby mall i.e. Ambience Mall, Vasant Kunj at 6:00 PM on
Sunday, Wednesday and Friday of every week. The visitation shall be
for one hour. Respondent will drop the child at the play area on the
3rd Floor of Ambience Mall and respondent shall stand atleast 50
meters away so that petitioner and child meet exclusively for one
hour.
None of the parties shall take photographs and videography of the
meeting, however, petitioner is permitted to click one or two
photographs of the child. In case child wishes to move around in the
same floor with petitioner or vice versa it will not be prevented by the
respondent. It is expected that both parties will cooperate with each
other so that meeting happens. If any dispute with respect to
interpretation of the order arises, both parties will interpretate [sic]
the order in the manner which propagate meeting between the
petitioner and the child. The meeting shall start from 17.11
.2024…….”
14.
A perusal of the record demonstrates that the interim visitation
arrangement was thoughtfully structured with due regard to the
paramount welfare of the minor daughter. The arrangement ensured
that the Appellant-father had meaningful contact with the minor
daughter in a safe, neutral, and non-intrusive environment, while
simultaneously safeguarding the child’s emotional well-being and
physical safety. Subsequent to the order dated 14.11.2024, certain
incidents and disputes arose which were brought to the attention of the
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:48:55
MAT.APP. (F.C.)433/2025
Family Court and were material in its decision to modify the visitation
schedule. These incidents include:
i.
On 14.12.2024, an alleged altercation occurred at the
shared household between the Appellant and the mother of the
Respondent, where it was asserted that the Appellant and his
family members carried tools and attempted forcible entry, with
the minor daughter allegedly witnessing the events. FIR No.
0076 dated 29.01.2025 was registered and remained under
investigation.
ii.
On 24.05.2025, electricity supply to the shared residence
was disconnected, CCTV cameras were tampered with, and an
iron gate installed outside the residence was cut open and
removed.
iii.
On 10.07.2025, the outer padlock of the iron door was
removed and CCTV cameras were disabled using black tape.
These acts were alleged to have caused obstruction and insecurity
for the Respondent and the minor daughter.
iv.
Related applications filed under the PWDV Act, and
notices issued by the learned ASJ highlighted the emergent
nature of some of these events, reflecting concerns for the safety
of both the Respondent and the minor daughter.
15.
The Family Court, taking note of the aforesaid incidents,
observed that the conduct of the Appellant and his family members, if
established, could materially affect the welfare and emotional wellSignature Not Verified
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:48:55
MAT.APP. (F.C.)433/2025
being of the minor daughter. Exercising its discretionary jurisdiction,
the Court modified the visitation arrangement by reducing the
frequency of physical meetings, while at the same time permitting
controlled video interaction. The rationale was to balance the
Appellant-father’s right to maintain meaningful contact with the
paramount requirement of safeguarding the child’s safety, stability,
and emotional security. It is well settled that the power to modify
visitation
arrangements is
not to be exercised
merely on
considerations of convenience or routine parental disagreement, but
only where circumstances are demonstrated to have a material impact
on the welfare of the child.
16.
In assessing the competing contentions, this Court recognizes
that while a parent is entitled to regular and meaningful visitation,
such interaction must not expose the child to circumstances likely to
cause physical harm, emotional distress, or psychological instability.
The FIR dated 29.01.2025, placed on record before the learned Family
Court, as well as the allegations pertaining to disconnection of
electricity and tampering with CCTV cameras, indicate the existence
of continuing disputes which, if left unresolved, may have a bearing
on the child’s sense of security and well-being.
17.
The Impugned Order, therefore, continued to provide for
physical meetings on the 2nd and 4th Saturdays of each month, along
with video calls on the 1st and 3rd Fridays of each month, thereby
regulating the mode and frequency of interaction without terminating
or unduly restricting parental contact. The modification was protective
rather than restrictive aimed at ensuring the child’s safety, stability,
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:48:55
MAT.APP. (F.C.)433/2025
and emotional security in the context of ongoing disputes between the
parties, while providing adequate physical and virtual contact in a
manner that better aligns with the child’s academic and developmental
needs.
18.
It is also acknowledged that the Appellant-father has denied the
allegations levelled against him. However, at the stage of determining
interim visitation, the Court is not required to render definitive
findings on disputed facts. What is required is an evaluation of
whether the allegations and surrounding circumstances, taken
cumulatively, raise concerns that may have an adverse impact on the
child’s welfare. While the Appellant-father’s apprehension of parental
alienation is noted, the modification of visitation in the present case is
a protective measure, ensuring the child’s well-being while preserving
avenues for continued meaningful contact. Such an approach aligns
with the established principle that the welfare of the child must prevail
over all other considerations in matters of custody and visitation.
19.
Furthermore, it is a matter of record that approximately twenty
litigations are pending between the parties and their respective family
members, reflecting the acrimonious nature of their relationship. Such
multiplicity of proceedings demonstrates that the marital discord has
translated into prolonged adversarial litigation. While each party
asserts its legal rights, this Court cannot be unmindful of the fact that
sustained inter se conflict between parents has a direct bearing on the
emotional and psychological well-being of a minor child, particularly
one of tender age. During the formative years, a child requires
stability, emotional security, and an environment insulated, as far as
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:48:55
MAT.APP. (F.C.)433/2025
possible, from parental discord. The Courts exercising jurisdiction in
custody and visitation matters are therefore duty-bound to ensure that
the child does not become a casualty of ongoing disputes between the
parents.
20.
In the aforesaid conspectus, this Court finds no perversity,
jurisdictional error, or material irregularity in the exercise of
discretion by the Family Court while passing the Impugned Order.
The modification of the interim visitation arrangement was based on
relevant considerations arising subsequent to the order dated
14.11.2024, and is proportionate in nature, as it neither restricts
parental contact nor curtails communication, but appropriately
regulates the mode and frequency thereof. The Family Court, in
balancing the Appellant-father’s right to maintain meaningful contact
with the child against the paramount consideration of the child’s
welfare, acted within its discretionary powers. It is well settled that an
appellate court ought not to substitute its own view for that of the
court of first instance in matters of discretionary interim arrangements,
unless the decision is shown to be manifestly arbitrary or contrary to
the welfare of the child, which is not the case herein. Moreover, only
interim arrangement for visitation has been made which is open to
modification, change and, increased if circumstances permit.
CONCLUSION
21.
The Appeal is, accordingly, dismissed. The interim visitation
arrangement, as modified by the Impugned Order, shall continue to
operate until further orders of the competent court. The Family Court
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:48:55
MAT.APP. (F.C.)433/2025
shall ensure due and effective implementation of the visitation
arrangement in accordance with law. A copy of this judgment be
provided to both parties.
22.
It is reiterated that the visitation of the Appellant-father with the
minor daughter shall continue in a manner that prioritises the child’s
welfare, emotional stability, and overall well-being. Both parties are
directed to cooperate in facilitating the scheduled physical meetings
and video interactions in good faith, without creating any situation
likely to cause distress or discomfort to the minor daughter. Any
future modification of visitation rights shall be considered only upon a
clear and demonstrable change in circumstances having a bearing on
the welfare of the child.
23.
It is clarified that the observations made herein are confined
solely to the adjudication of the interim visitation arrangement and
shall not be construed as an expression on the merits of the pending
proceedings between the parties. Needless to state, in the event of any
material change in circumstances, either party shall be at liberty to
approach the Family Court for appropriate relief, which shall be
considered independently and strictly in accordance with law, keeping
the welfare of the minor daughter as the paramount consideration.
24.
Before parting, this Court deems it appropriate to observe that
both parents bear a shared responsibility to act with maturity, restraint,
and sensitivity, and to foster a healthy and positive environment for
the minor daughter, particularly during her formative years. The
Family Court may, if it so deems appropriate, explore the possibility
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:48:55
MAT.APP. (F.C.)433/2025
of counselling or mediation to assist the parties in evolving a more
harmonious co-parenting framework, so that the child’s best interests
are not eclipsed by continuing inter se disputes.
25.
All pending applications also stand dismissed.
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.
HARISH VAIDYANATHAN SHANKAR, J.
JANUARY 09, 2026
jai/pal
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:48:55
MAT.APP. (F.C.)433/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review