Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
!"
!
%
%
%
! $
! #! !
!
&
$ '( )* (+,-,) .
01) ( ) .
/ /
/ /
(-(23( ) .
! $4
/
/
/ /
/
/// (',',) (2 5
4 !
4 4
!"
/// (-0)
(-(23( ) .
!
! $
/ /
( '-
/
/// (',',) (2 5
4 !
4 4
!" ! $ !
/// (-0)
(-(23( ) .
!4 "
/ /
( '-
/
! $! $!
/// (',',) (2 5
4 !
4 4
!" ! $ !
/// (-0)
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
( '-
&
(-(23( ) .
!4 "
/ /
/
! $! $!
/// (',',) (2 5
4 !
4 4
!" ! $ !
/// (-0)
( '-
/ /
/
(-(23( ) .
4! "
!6 !4 4! !"
!6 !4 4!" !
/// (',',) (2 -
4 !
4 4
!"
/// (-0)
!
Present :
.
7"6
/
$ 4/ " ! $8!
Mr. Kulwinder Bhargav, Advocate,
Mr. Jashan Deep Singh Bains, Advocate, and
Mr. Robin Arora, Advocate,
for the petitioner(s) in CRM M 66839 2025.
Mr. Mansur Ali, Sr. Advocate, with
Mr. Vaibhav Garg, Advocate, and
Ms. Amarpreet Kooner, Advocate,
for the petitioner(s) in CRM M 35908 2025;
CRM M 60536 2025; and CRM M 61811 2025.
Mr. Mukesh Singla, Advocate,
(Through Video Conference)
for the petitioner(s) in CRM M 66761 2025.
Mr. Saurav Verma, Addl. A.G. Punjab and
Mr. Mohit Kapoor, Sr. DAG, Punjab.
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
( '-
Mr. P.S. Ahluwalia, Sr. Advocate, (Amicus) with
Mr. Udaiveer Sidhu, Advocate,
Mr. Simarpreet Sekhon, Advocate,
Ms. Isha Mehta, Advocate, and
Mr. Akash Gahlawat, Advocate.
$ 4/ " ! $8! 9 /
2 1
Giving rise to a question as to whether an FIR can be quashed
and/or a final report be filed by the Police for offences under the Mines and
Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957 (hereinafter referred to as
the Act of 1957) in light of the bar under Section 22 of the Act of 1957 and
effect of Section 21(6) thereof, these five petitions are being decided by a
common judgment.
Facts involved in the respective petitions are extracted as under:
.
2.1
: ,-; 4, :; 5-/ 4' '( )* < = >.
Challenge in the above petition is to the FIR bearing No.165
dated 24.08.2020, registered under Section 21 (1) of the Act of 1957, read
with Sections 279, 379 and 188 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860, Section 51(b)
of the Disaster Management Act, 2005 and Section 3 of the Epidemic Diseases
Act, 1897 (Challan presented for offences only under Section 21(1) of the Act
of 1957), registered at Police Station Garhshankar, District Hoshiarpur, along
with the final report and including the order dated 01.08.2025, whereby their
application for discharge had been dismissed and charge has been framed for
offences under Sections 21(1) of the Act of 1957 and Section 379 and 411 of
the IPC.
2.2
The aforesaid FIR had been registered on the allegation that while
patrolling in the area of City Garhshankar, an information was received
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
regarding certain tippers illegally loaded with sand having been stopped near
the Anandpur Sahib Road. Acting upon the said information, the police seized
the tipper bearing registration No. PB 09 X 6953, which was found to be
loaded with sand and was being driven by the petitioner herein. The ownership
of the said tipper was disclosed to be that of one Karnail Singh. The petitioner
failed to produce any valid permit or authorization to carry out mining
operations or to transport sand, hence, the FIR was registered. The petitioner
was arrested and was eventually released on regular bail. Investigation was
completed whereupon final report under Section 173 Cr.P.C. was filed on
07.12.2022 for commission of offence only under the Act of 1957. Thereafter,
the petitioner moved an application seeking discharge which was dismissed.
Charges were framed not only for offence under the Act of 1957 but also for
offences under Sections 379 and 411 of the Indian Penal Code.
.
!
! $
4 54/ 4 !
!" ! $
!
3.1
Challenge in the case is to the FIR No.0043 dated 13.06.2024,
registered under Section 21(1) of the Act of 1957 at Police Station Talwara,
District Hoshiarpur, along with the final report filed under Section 173 Cr.P.C.
3.2
The above case was registered on the complaint of Sandeep
Kumar, Sub Divisional Officer cum Assistant District Mining Officer, Sub
Division, Dasuya, made to the effect that illegal mining activities were being
carried out near Master Stone Crusher situated in village Alera, over the
Panchayat land. Upon verification of the complaint, it was found that the
owner of the stone crusher had undertaken illegal mining operations in excess
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
of and also in violation of the permissions granted, thereby attracting the penal
provisions of the Act of 1957. Upon completion of the investigation, the police
filed the final report on 27.04.2025, the quashing whereof is sought in the
present case.
.
!4 "
! $ ! $ !
54/ 4 !
!" ! $
!
4.1
Seeking quashing of FIR No.0133 dated 29.08.2023, registered
under Section 21(1) and 4(1) of the Act of 1957, at Police Station Nangal,
District Rupnagar along with the final report filed for offences under the Act
of 1957 as well as under Section 379 of the IPC as well as the order dated
30.04.2025 framing charge against the petitioners, Nasib Chand and Sohan
Singh, the instant petition has been filed.
4.2
As per the allegations, during a surprise inspection conducted at
the Swan river (Nadi) in village Bhalan, three tippers were found engaged in
illegal mining activities and were sought to be seized at the spot. On noticing
the presence of the mining team, the operator of the machinery and the drivers
of the tippers fled from the site along with the machinery. However, the
porcelain machine was stopped at a distance of approximately 100 to 120
meters from the Swan river. Upon further inspection, it was found that an
illegal mining, to the extent of nearly 25,000 cubic feet, had been carried out
at the site. Three tippers which were found, were without number plates and
were also seized from the spot. Upon completion of the investigation, the final
report was filed and charges were subsequently framed under above offences.
.
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
!4 "
! $ ! $ !
54/ 4 !
!" ! $
!
5.1
The above petition has also been filed by Nasib Chand son of
Ram Lal and Ram Dass son of Karam Chand (petitioner Nasib Chand is also
an accused in CRM M 60536 of 2025 above) seeking quashing of the FIR
bearing No.0138 dated 12.09.2023, registered under Section 21(1) and 4(1) of
the Act of 1957 at Police Station, Nangal, Roparnagar, along with the final
report and the order framing charge.
5.2
The above FIR was got registered by one Manreet Singh, Mining
Inspector care of Sub Divisional Officer, Nangal, who submitted a complaint
to the effect that during inspection and checking of stone crushers, evidence
of unauthorized and illegal mining was found on land situated near Bhalla
Stone Crusher and Shri Ram Crusher to the extent of approximately 6,25,000
cubic feet. The final report was filed on completion of investigation and
eventually charge was framed. Aggrieved thereof, the instant petition has been
filed.
. 4! "
!6 !4 4!"! ! 54/ 4 !
6.1
!6 !4 4! !"
!"
Seeking Quashing of FIR No.42 dated 13.05.2022, registered
under Section 21(1) of the Act of 1957, at Police Station Targarh, District
Pathankot along with all the consequential proceedings including trial pending
in case bearing No.CHA/44/2025 titled as State of Punjab Vs. Sarabjeet
Singh, is prayed for.
6.2
The FIR in question had been registered on the complaint of
Sukhdeep Singh Junior Engineer cum Mining Inspector, Kathua Sub Division
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
made to effect that illegal mining was noticed in the area of Chak Kusalya in
the Ravi River. Investigation was conducted by the police officials and a final
report filed. The application for discharge submitted by the petitioner was
dismissed and charge was framed for commission of offence under Section
21(1) of the Act of 1957.
6.3
Mr. P.S. Ahluwalia, Senior Advocate, had been appointed as an
Amicus to assist the Court.
4 !
6#
7.1
The respondent State had filed its status report in the matter of
Manpreet Singh and others Vs. State of Punjab bearing No.CRM M 35908 of
2025 wherein they have defended their action.
7.2
A separate reply had also been filed by way of an affidavit of
Sandeep Kumar, Sub Divisional Officer cum District Mining Officer in
CRM M 35908 2025 defending the FIR that had been registered and reliance
has been placed on Section 21(6) of the Act of 1957. The relevant extract
thereof reads thus:
4. That the present petition under Section 528 of the Bharatiya
Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS) is not maintainable. The
FIR No. 0043 dated 13.06.2024 (Annexure P,1) registered under
Section 21(1) of the Mines and Minerals (Development and
Regulation) Act, 1957 (MMDR Act) has been lawfully lodged
after due compliance of procedure. The petitioner seeks quashing
of proceedings without any valid legal ground, which is
impermissible in law. It is well settled by the Hon'ble Supreme
Court in State of Haryana v. Bhajan Lal, AIR 1992 SC 604, and
reiterated in Neeharika infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. v. State of
Maharashtra, 2021 SCC OnLine SC 315, that inherent
jurisdiction for quashing FIRs must be exercised sparingly, only
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
in the rarest of rare cases. The present case does not fall within
any exceptional category.
5. That moreover, petitioner has deliberately concealed material
facts relating to illegal mining, actual facts of the case are that a
video complaint of Manoj Kumar having Mobile No.
8264511314 resident of village Palahar, Talwara had been
received to Sandeep Kumar, Sub Divisional Officer,cum,
Assistant District Mining officer, Dasuya Water Drainage,cum,
Mining Sub Division, Dasuya i.e. respondent no. 2 and while
taking action on it, field staff, police party and officer of revenue
department inspected the spot under leadership of Sub Divisional
Officer, Mining Sub Division Dasuya i.e. respondent no. 2. The
site of the spot is situated adjacent to Master Stone crusher
village Alera and its coordinates are 31.873446, 75.947841. The
mining has been done from 2 killas of land at the site. Ex.
Sarpanch village Amroh, Samiti Member Naresh Kumar son of
Late Sh. Ranjit Singh and Suresh Kumar son of Sh. Jagdish Ram
informed that said mining has been done by Master Stone
Crusher village Alera and said land is panchayat land.
Therefore, after conducting investigation, appropriate legal
action under section 21 (1) of Mines and Minerals Act, 1957 was
initiated against owner of above said land, owner of Master
Stone crusher and accused guilty of mining.
6. The inspection reports, and evidence collected clearly
establish the violation. Suppression of facts disentitles the
petitioner to any equitable relief. That FIR No. 0043 dated
13.06.2024, registered at Police Station Talwara, District
Hoshiarpur, Punjab, under Section 21(1) of the Mines and
Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957 ("MMDR
Act"), was registered strictly in accordance with law, following
due inspection, verification by officials of the Mining Department
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
and Police authorities. The FIR discloses a clear cognizable
offence under Section 21(1) of the MMDR Act.
7. That the petitioners' contention that the Police had no
authority to register FIR No. 0043 is legally unsustainable.
Section 21(6) "Notwithstanding anything contained in the Code
of Criminal Procedure, 1973, an offence under sub,section (1)
shall be cognizable".
Section 22 of the MMDR Act expressly makes offences
cognizable, authorising Police to register FIRs. Section 22,
MMDR Act, 1957:
22. Cognizance of offences. No court shall take cognizance of any
offence punishable under this Act or any rule made thereunder
except upon complaint in writing made by a person authorised in
this behalf by the Central Government or the State Government."
A bare reading shows that Section 22 creates a bar only at the
stage of cognizance by the Court, not at the stage of registration
of FIR or investigation by the Police. It only bars the Court from
taking cognizance except on a complaint by the authorised
officer; it does not restrict Police from registering FIRs and
investigating cognizable offences. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in
State (NCT of Delhi) v. Sanjay, (2014) 9 SCC 772, has
categorically upheld this principle.
8. That it is most respectfully submitted that the petitioners have
failed to establish any ground whatsoever warranting
interference by this Hon'ble Court in exercise of its inherent
jurisdiction under Section 482 CrPC (Section 528 BNSS). The
impugned FIR (Annexure P,1) was registered on the basis of a
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
joint inspection conducted by the Mining Department and Police
authorities,
which
clearly
revealed
large,scale
illegal
excavation, lifting, and transportation of minor minerals from an
area falling outside the leasehold premises of M/s Masters Stone
Crusher, of which the petitioners are partners. The offence was
thus cognizable and punishable under Section 21 of the Mines
and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957, read
with Sections 379 and 120,B of the Indian Penal Code (now
Section 303 and 320 of BNS respectively).
9. That the reliance placed by the petitioners upon Section 22 of
the MMDR Act is wholly misconceived and misplaced. The said
provision merely restricts the taking of cognizance by the Court
except upon a written complaint by an authorised officer and
does not bar the registration of an FIR or investigation by the
police. This legal position stands conclusively settled by the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in State (NCT of Delhi) v. Sanjay (2014)
9 SCC 772, and consistently followed thereafter, holding that
police authorities are competent to investigate offences involving
theft and illegal transportation of minerals, even when such acts
simultaneously constitute a violation under the MMDR Act.
10. That it is further submitted that the impugned police report
under Section 173 Cr.P.C. (Annexure P,2) has been submitted
after completion of a fair, transparent, and lawful investigation,
supported by seizure memos, inspection reports, witness
statements, and departmental verification. The material collected
during investigation establishes a clear prima facie case against
the petitioners. It is settled law that at the stage of quashing, this
Hon'ble Court is not required to evaluate the sufficiency or
correctness of evidence, nor to conduct a mini,trial. The factual
defences raised by the petitioners such as the issue of
demarcation, ownership, or the validity of site reports are all
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
matters of evidence which can only be adjudicated during trial
and not at this preliminary stage.
11. That the argument of the petitioners that only proceedings
under Rule 85(5) of the Punjab Minor Mineral Rules, 2013 could
have been initiated, is legally untenable. The said Rule pertains
merely to assessment and recovery of royalty or price of illegally
extracted minor minerals and operates independently of the
penal provisions under the MMDR Act. Administrative or fiscal
remedies do not exclude criminal prosecution where the act
complained of constitutes an offence punishable under law. The
proceedings under the MMDR Act and the Rules are
complementary and not mutually exclusive.
12. That it is evident that the present petition is a clear attempt
by the petitioners to misuse the extraordinary jurisdiction of this
Hon'ble Court to pre,empt the lawful process of investigation and
trial. The allegations of mala fides or procedural irregularities
are vague and baseless, unsupported by any material. The
petitioners have sought to give a civil colour to acts that are
manifestly criminal in nature, involving illegal extraction and
removal of public resources, causing financial loss to the State
exchequer.
13. That the trial proceedings are lawfully ongoing. Challan was
presented on 27.04.2025, and prosecution evidence is pending.
Once charges are framed, interference by this Hon'ble Court
under Section 482 CrPC (Section 528 BNSS) is not maintainable
except EATUNER in the rarest of rare cases, which is not made
out here. The proper remedy for the accused is to contest the
trial.
14. That in view of the above, the FIR No. 0043 dated 13.06.2024
the pending trial proceedings are perfectly lawful, valid.
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Learned counsel for the parties are ad idem that since the issue
involved in these petitions are primarily legal, the factual aspects need not be
gone into, as the same would give rise to disputed questions of fact.
!
9.1
"
!6
Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner(s) contend
that the FIR could not have been registered by the police in view of the
specific prohibition under Section 22 of the Act of 1957. It is submitted that
only a complaint could have been filed in the matter by a person authorized
by the Government in terms of Section 22 of the Act of 1957. It is contended
that since cognizance of the offence could have been taken only upon a
complaint filed by an authorised person, the trial Court has erred in taking
cognizance of the offence and framing the charges. The order dismissing the
application for discharge and thereafter framing of a charge is hence illegal
being without jurisdiction, hence, non est and unsustainable in the eyes of law.
9.2
An additional argument has been raised on behalf of counsel for
the petitioners that in certain cases, charges under Section 379 of the Indian
Penal Code have also been framed. It is contended that the offence under
Section 379 IPC is triable only by a Court of Magistrate, however, the
jurisdiction of the Court of Sessions is attracted by virtue of the notification
issued by the Government of Punjab in respect of offences under the Act of
1957, notifying the Court of Sessions as a Special Court under Section 30 B
of the Act of 1957.
9.3
In support of their case, counsel for the petitioners have placed
reliance on the judgment of
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
!!
wherein Section 22 of the Act of 1957 has been
interpreted and it was held that a person cannot be prosecuted except on a
complaint made by an authorized officer. Relevant extract thereof, as relied
by the petitioner(s), are reproduced as under:
68. There cannot be any dispute with regard to restrictions
imposed under the MMDR Act and remedy provided therein. In
any case, where there is a mining activity by any person in
contravention of the provisions of Section 4 and other sections of
the Act, the officer empowered and authorized under the Act shall
exercise all the powers including making a complaint before the
jurisdictional magistrate. It is also not in dispute that the
Magistrate shall in such cases take cognizance on the basis of the
complaint filed before it by a duly authorized officer. In case of
breach and violation of Section 4 and other provisions of the Act,
the police officer cannot insist Magistrate for taking cognizance
under the Act on the basis of the record submitted by the police
alleging contravention of the said Act. In other words, the
prohibition contained in Section 22 of the Act against
prosecution of a person except on a complaint made by the officer
is attracted only when such person sought to be prosecuted for
contravention of Section 4 of the Act and not for any act or
omission which constitute an offence under Indian Penal Code.
69. However, there may be situation where a person without any
lease or licence or any authority enters into river and extracts
sands, gravels and other minerals and remove or transport those
minerals in a clandestine manner with an intent to remove
dishonestly those minerals from the possession of the State, is
laible to be punished for committing such offence under Sections
378 and 379 of the Indian Penal Code.
xxx
xxx
xxx
72. After giving our thoughtful consideration in the matter, in the
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
light of relevant provisions of the Act vis,à,vis the Code of
Criminal Procedure and the Indian Penal Code, we are of the
definite opinion that the ingredients constituting the offence
under the MMDR Act and the ingredients of dishonestly
removing sand and gravel from the river beds without consent,
which is the property of the State, is a distinct offence under
the IPC. Hence, for the commission of offence under Section
378 Cr.P.C., on receipt of the police report, the Magistrate
having jurisdiction can take cognizance of the said offence
without awaiting the receipt of complaint that may be filed by the
authorized officer for taking cognizance in respect of violation of
various provisions of the MMRD Act. Consequently the contrary
view taken by the different High Courts cannot be sustained in
law and, therefore, overruled. Consequently, these criminal
appeals are disposed of with a direction to the concerned
Magistrates to proceed accordingly.”
9.4
Reliance has also been placed on the judgment of the Supreme
Court in the matter of "
%&'
()
#
$
$
(! relevant extracts whereof read thus:
10. Having heard learned counsel for the parties and having
perused the relevant provisions of the law as also the judicial
pronouncements, we are of the view that the High Court has not
committed any error in not quashing the order passed by the
learned Magistrate and not quashing the criminal proceedings
for the offences under Sections 379 and 414. It is required to be
noted that the learned Magistrate in exercise of the suo motu
powers conferred under Section 156(3), Cr.P.C., 1973 directed
the concerned Incharge/SHO of the police station to
lodge/register the crime case/FIR and directed initiation of
investigation and directed the concerned Incharge/ SHO of the
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
police station to submit a report after due investigation.
Applying the law laid down by this Court in the cases
referred to hereinabove, it cannot be said that at this stage the
learned Magistrate had taken any cognizance of the alleged
offences attracting bar under Section 22 of the MMDR Act. On
considering the relevant provisions of the MMDR Act and the
Rules made thereunder, it cannot be said that there is a bar
against registration of a criminal case or investigation by the
police agency or submission of a report by the police on
completion of investigation, as contemplated by Section 173,
Cr.P.C., 1973
10.1 At this stage, it is required to be noted that as per Section
21 of the MMDR Act the offences under the MMDR Act are
cognizable.
10.2 As specifically observed by this Court in the case of Anil
Kumar (supra), 'when a Special Judge refers a complaint for
investigation under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C., 1973 obviously,
he has not taken cognizance of the offence and, therefore, it
is a precognizance stage and cannot be equated with post
cognizance stage'.
10.3 Even as observed by this Court in the case of R.R. Chari
(supra), even the order passed by the Magistrate ordering
investigation under Section 156(3), or issuing a search
warrant for the purpose of the investigation, he cannot be
said to have taken cognizance of the offence. As observed by
the Constitution Bench of this Court in the case of A.R.
Antulay(supra), filing of a complaint in court is not taking
cognizance and what exactly constitutes taking cognizance is
different from filing of a complaint. Therefore, when an order
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
is passed by the Magistrate for investigation to be made by
the police under Section 156(3) of the Code, which the
learned Magistrate did in the instant case, when such an
order is made the police is obliged to investigate the case and
submit a report under Section 173(2) of the Code. That
thereafter the investigating officer is required to send report
to the authorised officer and thereafter as envisaged under
Section 22 of the MMDR Act the authorised officer as
mentioned in Section 22 of the MMDR Act may file the
complaint before the learned Magistrate along with the
report submitted by the investigating officer and at that stage
the question with respect to taking cognizance by the learned
Magistrate would arise.”
9.5
Reliance is also placed on the judgment of a Coordinate Bench
of this Court in the matter of *+ ,
( /
!
1 2
* +
$+
-
'#.#.
. The relevant extract thereof reads thus:
–
10. This Court is of the view that the very registration of
FIR (supra) is bad in the eyes of law as per the statutory
provisions of the MMDR Act. Cognizance of an offence under the
said Act can only be taken up on a criminal complaint filed by
the officer authorized under the MMDR Act in this regard. In
view of the above discussion, this Court is of the considered
opinion that the police has no power either to investigate,
prosecute or deal with any offence either under the MMDR Act.
11. In view of the discussion above, the present petition is
allowed and FIR No.178 dated 25.10.2017 registered under
Section
21(1) Mines
and
Minerals (Development
and
Regulation) Act, 1957 (hereinafter MMDR Act ) at Police
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Station Ajnala, District Amritsar (Rural) and all subsequent
proceedings arising therefrom are hereby quashed. Hence, the
present petition is disposed of accordingly.”
9.6
Further reliance is placed on the judgment in the matter of "
$+
-
-
+
1 3 ,4
'#.#. 12 .
1 2. The
relevant extract thereof reads thus:
A perusal of Section 22 of the Act brings out that an
offence punishable under Section 21 of the Act is a non,
cognizable offence. To put it otherwise cognizance of an offence
punishable under Section 21 of the Act can be taken only on
complaint in writing to be filed by the authorised person. To
clarify further, an F.I.R cannot be recorded in respect of an
offence punishable under Section 21 of the Act. In Harmela Ram
Versus State of Haryana (supra), a similar situation arose and
this Court quashed the FIR and proceedings arising therefrom
by observing that the offence being non,cognizable, FIR in the
matter could not be recorded and continuance of the proceedings
arising therefrom would be an abuse of process of law and the
Court. It has been contended on behalf of the respondent,State
that offence of Section 379, IPC, being a cognizable offence, FIR
has been rightly recorded even though another offence which
happens to be non cognizable is involved. I regret my inability to
subscribe to the view put forth on behalf of the respondent,State.
It is not in dispute that offence of Section 379, IPC, is a simple as
offence of theft and the theft of sand or other minerals is governed
by the provisions of the Act, which is a special statute. The matter
being regulated by a special statute, provisions of general law
have to give way to the provisions of said Act. This was so held
by this Court in M/s Mahalakshmi Spinners Ltd. Versus State of
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Haryana, 2007(1) R.C.R.(Civil) 381, Raman Kapila and another
Versus State of Punjab 2012(4) R.C.R.(Criminal )634 and
Rakesh
Kumar
Versus
State
of
Haryana
2011(3)
R.C.R(Criminal) 629. Nothing to the contrary has been shown
during the course of hearing. That being so, the offences of
Section 379, IPC, could not be included in the First Information
Report and allowing the proceedings under that provision,
would, in disputably amount to an abuse to the process of law
and the Court and shall be vexations. The consequence that
follows is that the only offence that could be said to have been
committed by the petitioners under falls Section 21 of the Act
which would be a non,cognizable offence in terms of Section 22
of the Act and, as such, the FIR recorded in the matter deserves
to be quashed. In the consequence, I accept the petition and
quash the F.I.R No.9 dated 17.02.2013 recorded under Section
379, IPC, and Section 21 of Mines and Minerals (Regulation &
Development) Act, 1957, (Annexure P1) with all the proceedings
emanating therefrom.”
9.7
Reliance is also placed on the judgment of the Supreme Court in
the matter of " ,
*+5
2 ' '
' +
6+
+
& 7
1/(, pertaining to the Transplantation
of Human Organs Act, 1994, containing similar provisions. The relevant
extract thereof reads thus:
15. TOHO being a special statute, Section 4 of the Code,
which ordinarily would be applicable for investigation into a
cognizable offence or the other provisions, may not be
applicable. Section 4 provides for investigation, inquiry, trial,
etc. according to the provisions of the Code. Sub,section (2)
of Section 4, however, specifically provides that offences under
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
any other law shall be investigated, inquired into, tried and
otherwise dealt with according to the same provisions, but
subject to any enactment for the time being in force regulating
the manner or place of investigating, inquiring into, tried or
otherwise dealing with such offences. TOHO being a special Act
and the matter relating to dealing with offences thereunder
having been regulated by reason of the provisions thereof, there
cannot be any manner of doubt whatsoever that the same shall
prevail over the provisions of the Code.
16. The investigation in terms of Section 13(3)(iv) of
TOHO, thus, must be conducted by an authorized officer. Nobody
else could do it. For the aforementioned reasons, the officer
incharge of the Gurgaon Police Station had no other option but
to hand over the investigation to the appropriate authority.
17. The respondent has been constituted under the Delhi
Special Police Establishment Act, 1946. In terms of the
provisions of the said Act, the authorities specified therein could
make investigation in connection with a complaint. The mode and
manner in which the investigation could be carried out have been
laid down in the Act and/ or the manual framed thereunder.
xxx
xxx
xx
20. It is a well,settled principle of law that if a special
statute lays down procedures, the ones laid down under the
general statutes shall not be followed. In a situation of this
nature, the respondent could carry out investigations in exercise
of its authorization under Section 13(3)(iv) of TOHO. While
doing so, it could exercise such powers which are otherwise
vested in it. But, as it could not file a police report but a complaint
petition only; Sub,section (2) of Section 167 of the Code may not
be applicable. The provisions of the Code, thus, for all intent and
purport, would apply only to an extent till conflict arises between
the provisions of the Code and TOHO and as soon as the area of
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
conflict reaches, TOHO shall prevail over the Code. Ordinarily,
thus, although in terms of the Code, the respondent upon
completion of investigation and upon obtaining remand of the
accused from time to time, was required to file a police report, it
was precluded from doing so by reason of the provisions
contained in Section 22 of TOHO.”
9.8
Reliance is also placed on similar orders passed by certain other
High Courts as well. The same are, however, not being extracted to avoid
repetition.
!
10.1
"
!6
$
4 !
On the other hand, counsel for respondent State has also placed
reliance on the judgment of the Supreme Court in the matter of
$
!! , to defend the State
action. They further submit that the judgments passed by the Coordinate
bench of this Court in the matter of *+ ,
* + (supra) as well as "
(supra) have not taken into consideration the judgment in the matter of
" ,
*+5
(supra) and have wrongly placed reliance on the judgment of
*+5
' + (supra).
10.2
It is submitted that in so far as the judgment in the case of
*+ ,
* + (supra) is concerned, the Hon ble Single Judge has made a
reference to Section 21(1) of the Mines and Minerals (Development and
Regulation) Act, 1957, however, the effect and import of Section 21(6) of the
said Act have not been adverted to or analysed. On this premise, it is
contended that the said judgment would be rendered per incuriam for having
failed to take a material statutory provision into consideration. A similar
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
submission is advanced with respect to the judgment in the matter of "
(supra). It is contended that while Section 21 of the Act of 1957,
including sub section (6) thereof, stands reproduced in the said judgment,
there is no discussion, interpretation, or construction of the said provision, nor
any examination or consideration of its impact on Section 22 of the Act of
1957.
10.3
It is contended that in view of the settled position in law, the FIRs
in question could have been duly got registered and the final report could have
been filed by the police authorities.
10.4
It is contended that the allegations, as borne out from the record,
clearly disclose the commission of cognizable offences in the present cases
and that the bar under Section 22 of the Mines and Minerals (Development
and Regulation) Act, 1957 operates only at the stage of taking cognizance by
the Court and not at the anterior stage of registration of the FIR or the conduct
of investigation by the police. It is argued with vehemence that the FIRs had
been registered on the basis of the reports submitted by the police
officials/authorized officials of the Department of Mining reporting illegal
excavation, lifting and transportation of minor mineral from the river
beds/areas falling outside the leased premises.
10.5
It is argued that specific objections raised by the petitioner(s)
while seeking discharge were dealt with and rejected by the Courts and
charges were framed thereafter, hence, prima facie case was found to be made
out at the time of framing of the charge. It would thus not be appropriate to
go into the relevance and merit of the evidence collected as the same would
amount to judging the evidentiary value of the material collected during the
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
course of investigation. The same would give rise to disputed questions of fact
that should not be gone into by this Court, at this stage and should be left to
trial.
4 "
11.1
4 "#
!
Mr. P.S. Ahluwalia, Senior Advocate, (learned Amicus) submits
that similar provisions exist in a number of statutes and such analogous
provisions have been examined, interpreted and applied to by the Courts.
11.2
Reference is made to the scheme of offences against public
tranquility under the Indian Penal Code, 1860, and to the analogous
procedural bar contained in Section 195 of the Code of Criminal Procedure,
1973. Reference is also drawn to the provisions of the Pre Conception and
Pre Natal Diagnostic Techniques (Prohibition of Sex Selection) Act, 1994,
inasmuch as Sections 27 and 28(1) thereof incorporate provisions of a similar
nature, prescribing a specific mode for initiation of proceedings and taking of
cognizance.
11.3
He also makes a reference to the judgment of the Division Bench
of the Allahabad High Court in the matter #8 #
$
# 0 :
$
! (
%4
!1 /!
2.
The relevant paragraphs of the same are extracted as under:
10. The offences alleged against the petitioner are under four
enactments, The Indian Penal Code, The Prevention of Damage
to Public Property Act, 1984, The Mines and Minerals
(Development and Regulation) Act, 1957 and the U.P. Minor
Minerals (Concession) Rules, 2021.
xxx
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
xxx
xxx
14. The allegation in the FIR is that mining has been carried out
in an area beyond the lease granted to the petitioner. It is
therefore, an offence under Section 4(1) of the Mines and
Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957 (hereinafter
referred to as “the Act, 1957”), which reads as follows:,
Section 4. Prospecting or mining operations to be under
licence or lease.
(1) [No person shall undertake any reconnaissance,
prospecting or mining operations in any area, except under
and in accordance with the terms and conditions of a
reconnaissance permit or of a prospecting licence or, as the
case may be, of a mining lease, granted under this Act and the
rules made thereunder]:
Provided that nothing in this sub,section shall affect any
prospecting or mining operations undertaken in any area in
accordance with terms and conditions of a prospecting
licence or mining lease granted before the commencement of
this Act which is in force at such commencement.
Provided further that nothing in this sub,section shall apply
to any prospecting operations undertaken by the Geological
Survey of India, the Indian Bureau of Mines, the Atomic
Minerals Directorate for Explorations and Research of the
Department of Atomic Energy of the Central Government, the
Directorates of Mining and Geology of any State Government
(by whatever name called), and the Mineral Exploration
Corporation Limited, a Government Company within the
meaning of clause (45) of Section 2 of the Companies Act,
2013 (18 of 2013) and any such entity that may be notified for
this purpose by the Central Government.”
(1A) No person shall transport or store or cause to be
transported or stored any mineral otherwise than in
accordance with the provisions of this Act and the rules made
thereunder.
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
(2) No [ reconnaissance permit, prospecting licence or
mining lease] shall be granted otherwise than in accordance
with the provisions of this Act and the rules made thereunder.
(3) Any State Government may, after prior consultation with
the Central Government and in accordance with the rules
made under section 18, [ undertake reconnaissance,
prospecting or mining operations with respect to any mineral
specified in the First Schedule in any area within that State
which is not already held under any reconnaissance permit,
prospecting licence or mining lease.”
xxx
xxx
xx
16. Even more importantly sub,section 6 of Section 21 provides
that
notwithstanding anything contained in the Code of
Criminal Procedure, 1973(2 of the 1974), an offence under sub,
section 1 shall be cognizable.”
17. This subsection 6 has been incorporated by Act No.37 of 1986
w.e.f. 10.02.1987.
18. Section 22 of this Act of 1957 provides that no Court shall
take cognizance of any offence punishable under this Act or any
Rule therein except on a complaint in writing by a person
authorized in this behalf by the Central Government or State
Government.
19. It would be relevant to note that Section 22 is a provision,
which has existed in the Act since its promulgation in the year
1957. Sub,section 6 of Section 21, noticed above, has been
incorporated w.e.f. 10.02.1987.
20. Under the circumstances, therefore, Section 22(6) is an
exception to the general provision mentioned Section 22,
regarding offence under the Mines and Minerals (Development
and Regulation) Act, 1957. The offences alleged under the
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
impugned FIR are under Section 4(1) and 4(1,A) of the Act 1957.
The same therefore, are cognizable offences in view of Section 6
of Section 21. Therefore, the petitioner cannot derive any benefit
from Section 22 of the Act and an FIR with regard to an offence
under Section 4(1) or 4(1,A) of the Act can be lodged, as they are
cognizable offences in view of Section 21(6).
11.4
Reference is also made to judgment rendered by a Coordinate
Bench of this Court passed in the matter
$+
- -
'#.#
2( ( .
+;
2(
.
The relevant extract thereof reads thus:
(14). Section 22 of the Act of 1957, which is necessary in the
context of the present dispute, is reproduced as under:,
22. Cognizance of offences: No court shall take cognizance
of any offence punishable under this Act or any rules made
thereunder except upon complaint in writing made by a
person authorised in this behalf by the Central Government
or the State Government.”
xxx
xxx
xxx
(22). I am of the considered view after carefully going through
the judgement of the Supreme Court rendered in Jayant etc and
State of NCT Delhi (supra) that registration of the FIR and
further investigation in the matter by the police is not barred by
any provisions of Act of 1957 including Section 22 thereof even
if the offence under IPC is not there but only under the Act of
1957 is involved. The bar is only qua taking of cognizance as per
Section 22 of the Act of 1957 and therefore, it would be of vital
importance to notice that when or at what stage of the case it can
be said that the Court has taken cognizance of the offence. In
normal criminal parlance it is taken that cognizance of the
offence starts when the Court applies its mind to proceed further
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
against an accused but this view was delineated by the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in
Naryandas Bhagwandas Madhavdas Vs.
State of West Bengal, AIR, 1959, SC,1118”, wherein it was said
that taking of cognizance of an offence would depend upon the
facts and circumstances of each case and it is only when a
Magistrate applies its mind for proceedings under Section 200
Cr.P.C or under Chapter XVII then it can positively be stated that
he had applied his mind therefore had taken cognizance. Though
there is no defining of the word as to when the cognizance is
considered to have been taken in the Cr.P.C neither there is any
intend to define by the legislation but it can be clearly seen that
any Magistrate had taken cognizance of an offence under Section
190 (a) of Cr.P.C he must not have applied its mind to the
contents of complaint/case/report but must have done so for the
purpose of proceeding in a particular way as indicated in the
subsequent provision of Chapter XIV i.e. Section 200 Cr.P.C and
thereafter, sending a report under Section 202 Cr.P.C.
xxx
xxx
xxx
(25). Therefore, the position is that though in respect of an
offence under the Act of 1957, the FIR can be registered and
investigation can be conducted; however, cognizance would be
taken of the complaint by one person only as mentioned in
Section 22 thereof. In the case in hand when the FIR was got
registered, the stage might not have reached for lodging of the
complaint since, it was under the consideration under the Act of
1957.
(26). In the light of the above discussion and in view of the
various judicial pronouncement by the Hon'ble Apex Court from
time to time has hold that FIR even for the offence committed
under the Act of 1957 can be registered and investigated by the
Police, whereas cognizance of the same can be taken only on the
complaint presented by the authorized officer as stipulated under
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Section 22 thereof. Even a report under Section 173 Cr.P.C is to
be filed once an FIR is registered but the same should be along
with the complaint presented by the Competent Authority under
Section 22 of the Act of 1957.
xxx
xxx
xxx
(28). Hence, the registration of the FIR and subsequent conduct
of investigation along with final report submitted to the Court
under Section 173 Cr.P.C is though held to be legal but
proceedings beyond the stage of taking cognizance are hereby
ordered to be quashed. The trial Court is at liberty to proceed the
trial after taking cognizance of the complaint if any made by the
authorized officer under Section 22 of the Act of 1957.
xxx
xxx
xxx
(35). There is no dispute to the settled proposition of law that
taking cognizance is judicial application of mind to the contents
of the complaint/report for the first time as was enunciated in
R.R. Chari Vs. State of Uttar Pardesh,AIR 1951 SC207 and
Bhushan Kumar and others Vs. State (NCT of Delhi) and another
, (2012) 5 SCC 424. Cognizance is an act of the Court which has
not been defined in Cr.PC and for this reason a look needs to be
made at certain provisions of Chapter XIV of Cr.PC, which deals
with conditions requisite for initiation of proceedings. Section
190 thereof empowers a Magistrate to take cognizance upon
receiving a police report of such facts to which he applies his
mind and if he is of the opinion that there is sufficient ground for
proceeding he shall proceed further by issuing warrants to the
accused. This is the stage when he applies his mind which could
be conclusively said to be cognizance taken by the Magistrate. In
this regard, observations made by the Apex Court in “S.K. Sinha,
Chief Enforcement Officer Vs. Video Con International and
Ors.” (2008) 2 SCC 492 could be quoted hereinbelow:,
19. The expression “cognizance” has not been defined in
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
the Code. But the word (cognizance) is of indefinite import.
It has no esoteric or mystic significance in criminal law. It
merely means “become aware of” and when used with
reference to a court or a Judge, it connotes “to take notice
of judicially”. It indicates the point when a court or a
Magistrate takes judicial notice of an offence with a view
to initiating proceedings in respect of such offence said to
have been committed by someone.
20. “Taking cognizance” does not involve any formal
action of any kind. It occurs as soon as a Magistrate
applies his mind to the suspected commission of an offence.
Cognizance is taken prior to commencement of criminal
proceedings. Taking of cognizance is thus a sine qua non
or condition precedent for holding a valid trial.
Cognizance is taken of an offence and not of an offender.
Whether or not a Magistrate has taken cognizance of an
offence depends on the facts and circumstances of each
case and no rule of universal application can be laid down
as to when a Magistrate can be said to have taken
cognizance.”
xxx
xxx
xxx
(38). In view of the case law discussed hereinabove and
examination of facts and material on record, I without any
hesitation hold that the cognizance taken by the Magistrate in
FIR No.133 dated 16.08.2014, Police Station Kurali, SAS Nagar
(Mohali) suffers from illegally since it can be taken only on a
complaint filed by the authorized officer as stipulated in Section
22 of the Act of 1957. Hence, the proceedings only from the date
of taking cognizance by the trial Court in FIR No.133 dated
16.08.2014, Police Station Kurali, SAS Nagar (Mohali) are
hereby ordered to be quashed since there is no bar for
registration of FIR and conducting of investigation by the police
as per Section 22 of the Act of 1957.
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
11.5
Reference is also made on the judgment of the Supreme Court in
the matter of
*+5
1&
. The relevant paragraphs are extracted as under:
51. A plain reading of Section 195 of the Cr.P.C. would indicate
that no Court can take cognizance of an offence punishable under
Section 186 of the I.P.C., except upon a complaint in writing of
the public servant concerned or of some other public servant to
whom he is administratively subordinate. The opening words of
the Section are "No Court shall take cognizance), and
consequently, the bar created by the provisions is against taking
of cognizance by the Court. There is no bar against the
registration of a criminal case or investigation by the police
agency or submission of a report by the police on completion of
the investigation, as contemplated by Section 173 of the Cr.P.C.
xxx xxx xxx
55.
In
$+
-7 '
%&'
/
!(/, this Court further stated that Section 195(1)(b)(ii) of the
Cr.P.C. cannot be seen as prohibiting the entertainment of, and
investigation into the offence(s) by the police. The bar comes into
operation only when the Court intends to take cognizance of the
offence under Section 190 Cr.P.C. In other words, the statutory
power of the police to investigate under the Cr.P.C. is not in any
way controlled or circumscribed by Section 195 Cr.P.C. The
legal position was elaborated in the following words: ,
"2. We are unable to sustain the impugned order of the
High Court quashing the F.I.R. Lodged against the
respondents alleging commission of offences under
Sections 419, 420, 467 and 468 I.P.C. by them in course of
the proceeding of a civil suit, on the ground that Section
195(1)(b)(ii) Cr.P.C. prohibited entertainment of and
investigation into the same by the police. From a plain
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
reading of Section 195 Cr.P.C. it is manifest that it comes
into operation at the stage when the Court intends to take
cognizance of an offence under Section 190(1) Cr. P.C.;
and it has nothing to do with the statutory power of the
police to investigate into an F.I.R. which discloses a
cognizable offence, in accordance with Chapter XII of the
Code even if the offence is alleged to have been committed
in, or in relation to, any proceeding in Court. In other
words, the statutory power of the Police to investigate
under the Code is not in any way controlled or
circumscribed by Section 195 Cr.P.C. It is of course true
that upon the charge,sheet (challan), if any, filed on
completion of the investigation into such an offence the
Court would not be competent to take cognizance thereof
in view of the embargo of Section 195(1)(b) Cr. P.C., but
nothing therein deters the Court from filing a complaint
for the offence on the basis of the F.I.R. (filed by the
aggrieved private party) and the materials collected
during investigation, provided it forms the requisite
opinion and follows the procedure laid down in section
340 Cr.P.C. [...]"
(Emphasis supplied)
xxx
xxx
xxx
0+
59. We may summarize our final conclusion as under:
(i) Section 195(1)(a)(i) of the Cr.P.C. bars the court from
taking cognizance of any offence punishable under Sections
172 to 188 respectively of the I.P.C., unless there is a
written complaint by the public servant concerned or his
administrative superior, for voluntarily obstructing the
public servant from discharge of his public functions.
Without a complaint from the said persons, the court would
lack competence to take cognizance in certain types of
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
offences enumerated therein.
(ii) If in truth and substance, an offence falls in the category
of Section 195(1)(a)(i), it is not open to the court to
undertake the exercise of splitting them up and proceeding
further against the accused for the other distinct offences
disclosed in the same set of facts. However, it also cannot
be laid down as a straight,jacket formula that the Court,
under all circumstances, cannot undertake the exercise of
splitting up. It would depend upon the facts of each case, the
nature of allegations and the materials on record.
(iii) Severance of distinct offences is not permissible when
it would effectively circumvent the protection afforded by
Section 195(1)(a)(i) of the Cr.P.C., which requires a
complaint by a public servant for certain offences against
public justice. This means that if the core of the offence falls
under the purview of Section 195(1)(a)(i), it cannot be
prosecuted by simply filing a general complaint for a
different, but related, offence. The focus should be on
whether the facts, in substance, constitute an offence
requiring a public servant's complaint.
(iv) In the aforesaid context, the courts must apply twin
tests. First, the courts must ascertain having regard to the
nature of the allegations made in the complaint/FIR and
other materials on record whether the other distinct
offences not covered by Section 195(1)(a)(i) have been
invoked only with a view to evade the mandatory bar of
Section 195 of the Cr.P.C. and secondly, whether the facts
primarily and essentially disclose an offence for which a
complaint of the court or a public servant is required.
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
(v) Where an accused is alleged to have committed some
offences which are separate and distinct from those
contained in Section 195. Section 195 will affect only the
offences mentioned therein. However, the courts should
ascertain whether such offences form an integral part and
are so intrinsically connected so as to amount to offences
committed as a part of the same transaction, in which case
the other offences also would fall within the ambit of Section
195 of the Cr.P.C. This would all depend on the facts of each
case.
(vi) Sections 195(1)(b)(1)(i) & (iii) and 340 of the Cr.P.C.
respectively do not control or circumscribe the power of the
police to investigate, under the Criminal Procedure Code.
Once investigation is completed then the embargo in
Section 195 would come into play and the Court would not
be competent to take cognizance. However, that Court could
then file a complaint for the offence on the basis of the FIR
and the material collected during investigation, provided
the procedure laid down in Section 340 of the Cr.P.C. is
followed.
60. In view of the aforesaid, we dispose of this petition leaving it
open to the petitioner to raise the contention as regards the bar
of Section 195 of the Cr.P.C. before the trial court if at all, at the
end of the investigation, chargesheet is filed for the offences
enumerated above in the FIR.”
11.6
He further submits that a Division Bench of this Court in the
matter of 4
< 3
$+
-
12( , which is
in relation to the provisions under the Pre Conception and Pre Natal
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Diagnostic Techniques (Prohibition of Sex Selection) Act, 1994, has held that
the FIR cannot be quashed solely on the ground that the Court cannot take
cognizance of the offence except on a complaint submitted by the appropriate
authority. The relevant extract thereof reads thus:
1. The petitioners who are doctors have filed the present
petition under section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure,
1973 (CrPC for short) seeking quashing of FIR No.53 dated
20.1.2014 (Annexure P,1) registered against them for the
offences punishable under Sections 4, 5 and 6 of the
Preconception and Prenatal Diagnostic Techniques (Prohibition
of Sex Selection) Act, 1994 ('Act' for short) and Rules 9 (4) and 9
(6) of the Preconception and Prenatal Diagnostic Techniques
(Prohibition of Sex Selection) Rules, 1996 ('Rules for short)
registered at Police Station Civil Lines, Karnal. The case has
been registered against the petitioners on the basis of a letter
dated 19.1.2014 addressed by the District Appropriate Authority
(Preconception and Prenatal Diagnostic Techniques),cum,Civil
Surgeon, Karnal (Appropriate Authority for short) to the SHO,
Police Station Civil Lines. Karnal.
xxx xxx xxx
10. According to the petitioners, they had not committed any
offence and rather being renowned doctors had contributed to
the society in the field of health by adhering to the law. A
reference has been made to Section 28 of the Act and on the
strength of the same, it is submitted that only a complaint could
be filed and there is no provision under the Act for registration
of an FIR; besides, the said provision envisages that a show
cause notice of fifteen days is mandatory to a person sought to
be prosecuted.
xxx xxx xxx
The learned Single Judge considered the matter and was
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
of the view that two sections of the Act i.e. one saying that the
offences under the Act are cognizable and the other saying that
cognizance of the offence could be taken on a complaint made by
the Appropriate Authority would require determination by a
Larger Bench on the following legal points:,
(1) Whether FIR for the offences committed under this Act can
be registered on the complaint of Appropriate Authority and
can be investigated by the Police?
(2) Whether the report under section 173 CrPC, 1973 along
with the complaint of an Appropriate Authority can be filed to
the Court?
(3) Whether no FIR can be lodged nor the offences can be
investigated by the Police and only complaint by the
Appropriate Authority directly to the Court lies?
xxx xxx xxx
22. The provisions of Section 28 of the Act envisage that no Court
is to take cognizance of offence under the Act except on a
complaint made by the persons enumerated in clause (a) thereof.
Besides, clause (b) envisages that a complaint may also be made
by a person who has given notice of not less than fifteen days in
the manner prescribed, to the Appropriate Authority, of the
alleged offence and of his intention to make a complaint to the
Court.
xxx xxx xxx
Cognizance in respect of an offence under Section 188 IPC in
view of section 195 (1) (a) (1) CrPC, 1973 can be taken on a
complaint in writing of that Court or by such officer of the Court
as that Court may authorize in writing in this behalf, or some
other Court to which that Court is subordinate. It was held by the
Division Bench of this Court that investigation can be carried out
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
by the police on a First Information Report in respect of a
cognizance offence. The police could investigate into the offence
under Section 188 IPC being a cognizable offence but the Court
could not take cognizance except on a complaint of a public
servant.
xxx xxx xxx
49. In the circumstances, it may be noticed that in fact the taking
of cognizance of the offence under the Act can be said to be
barred except on a complaint made by the Appropriate Authority
concerned, or any officer authorized in this behalf by the Central
Government or State Government, as the case may be or the
Appropriate Authority, or a person who has given not less than
fifteen days' notice in the manner prescribed, to the Appropriate
Authority, of the alleged offence and of his intention to make a
complaint to the Court as provided for in terms of Section 28 of
the Act. However, the offences under the Act being cognizable,
non, bailable and non,compoundable in terms of Section 27, the
investigation of the same by the police would not per se be
barred.
50. In the present case, there is no proceeding pending in any
Court at this stage. In fact in the reply that has been filed by the
State, it is stated that the matter is still under investigation and
therefore, the petition for quashing the FIR is not maintainable.
Therefore, the stage for taking cognizance of the offence by the
Court has not yet reached. The taking of cognizance of the
offence by the Court is normally when the Court applies its mind
to the facts of the case, which is primarily at the stage of framing
charges; can be registered and investigation conducted;
however, cognizance can only be taken on the complaint of any
of the persons as mentioned in Section 28 of the Act. The stage
for filing the complaint has not yet reached in the present case as
the matter is stated to be still under investigation, Therefore, at
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
this stage the FIR is not liable to be quashed on the ground that
the Court cannot take cognizance except on the complaint in
writing of the Appropriate Authority.
xxx xxx xxx
69. In the circumstances, the questions as formulated in the
reference are answered in the following manner, that:,
(1) FIR for the offence committed under the Act can be
registered on the complaint of the Appropriate Authority
and can be investigated by the Police: however, cognizance
of the same can be taken by the Court on the basis of a
complaint made by one of the persons mentioned in Section
28 of the Act
(2) A report under section 173 CrPC, 1973 along with the
complaint of an appropriate authority can be filed in the
Court. However, cognizance would be taken only the
complaint that has been filed in accordance with Section 28
of the Act
(3) FIR can be lodged and offences can be investigated by
the Police but cognizance only of the complaint is to be
taken by the Court.
70. The matter shall be placed before the learned Single Bench
for further contention, if any, raised by the petitioners.”
11.7
Reliance is also placed on the Division Bench judgment of this
Court in the matter of "
$+
-
' '
21 , wherein reliance had been placed by the Division bench on the
judgment in the matter of
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
$+
-
'
/
' '
$
1!(. The relevant extract thereof reads
thus:
18. Thus, we are of the opinion that the investigations can be
carried out by the police on a First Information Report in respect
of a cognizable offence. The police could investigate into the
offence under section 188 of the Indian Penal Code being a
cognizable offence but the Court could not take cognizance
except on a complaint of a public servant. The process adopted
by the respondent is in tune with such interpretation. The bar
under section 195(1)(a) of the Code is only against the Court
taking cognizance of the matter except on a complaint by a public
servant. In the instant case, a public servant, in fact, moved the
Court to take cognizance of the matter and, therefore, it cannot
be said that there is any infraction of the provisions of Section
195(1)(a) of the Code.
11.8
He has also referred to three judges’ judgment of the Supreme
Court in the matter of $
' '
:
*
arising out of
%
;
/
. The relevant extract thereof read thus: –
( %+
=
## ' %0
76. Section 22 of the MMDR Act stipulates that no Court shall
take cognizance of any offence punishable under this Act or
Rules, except upon a complaint made in writing by a person
authorised on that behalf by the Central or the State Government.
It has been contended by the appellant that before the Special
Court (Sessions Court) took cognizance of the offence, no
complaint was filed by the authorised person.
77. In State (NCT of Delhi) v. Sanjay, (2014) 9 SCC 772, the
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
principal question which was formulated for the decision of a two
judge Bench was whether the Magistrate has the power to take
cognizance of the offence upon a police report without a
complaint from the authorised person under Section 22 of the
MMDR Act. Justice MY Eqbal, delivering the judgment for the
two,judge Bench, held that Section 22 only bars the prosecution
and cognizance of offences for contravention of Section 4 of the
MMDR Act without a written complaint and not for offences
under the provisions of the IPC. The court also noted the object
and policy underlying the MMDR Act in the context of
environmental protection. The Court observed:
"62, Sub,section (1,A) of Section 4 of the MMDR Act puts a
restriction in transporting and storing any mineral otherwise
than in accordance with the provisions of the Act and the
Rules made thereunder. In other words no person will do
mining activity without a valid lease or licence. Section 21 is
a penal provision according to which if a person contravenes
the provisions of sub,section (1,A) of Section 4, he shall be
prosecuted and punished in the manner and procedure
provided in the Act. Sub,section (6) has been inserted in
Section 4 by amendment making the offence cognizable
notwithstanding anything contained in the Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1973, Section 22 of the Act puts a restriction on
the court to take cognizance of any offence punishable under
the Act or any Rule made thereunder except upon a complaint
made by a person authorised in this behalf. It is very
important to note that Section 21 does not begin with a non
obstante clause. Instead of the words "notwithstanding
anything contained in any law for the time being in force no
court shall take cognizance....". the section begins with the
words "no court shall take cognizance of any offence.
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
[...]
70. There cannot be any dispute with regard to restrictions
imposed under the MMDR Act and remedy provided therein.
In any case, where there is a mining activity by any person in
contravention of the provisions of Section 4 and other
sections of the Act, the officer empowered and authorised
under the Act shall exercise all the powers including making
a complaint before the Jurisdictional Magistrate. It is also
not in dispute that the Magistrate shall in such cases take
cognizance on the basis of the complaint filed before it by a
duly authorised officer. In case of breach and violation of
Section 4 and other provisions of the Act, the police officer
cannot insist the Magistrate for taking cognizance under the
Act on the basis of the record submitted by the police alleging
contravention of the said Act. In other words, the prohibition
contained in Section 22 of the Act against prosecution of a
person except on a complaint made by the officer is attracted
only when such person is sought to be prosecuted for
contravention of Section 4 of the Act and not for any act or
omission which constitutes an offence under the Penal
Code."
In view of the above discussion, the Court held: ,
(i) The ingredients constituting an offence under the MMDR
Act and the ingredients of the offences under the IPC are
distinct; and
(ii) For the commission of an offence under the IPC, on
receipt of a police report, the Magistrate having jurisdiction
can take cognizance without awaiting a complaint by the
authorized officer. A complaint is required in terms of Section
22 only for taking cognizance in respect of a violation of the
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
provisions of the MMDR Act.”
11.9
#
He also refers to the judgment in the matter of "
$
%&'
( The relevant extract
of the same reads thus:
3.3 That thereafter the private appellants and others
approached the High Court to quash the aforesaid FIRs
registered against them for illegal mining/transportation of sand
by submitting the applications under Section 482, Cr.P.C., 1973.
It was mainly contended on behalf of the private appellants and
other violators that in view of Bar under Section 22 of the MMDR
Act, the order passed by the learned Magistrate directing to
register the FIRs is unsustainable and deserves to the quashed
and set aside. It was also contended on behalf of the private
appellants and other violators that once there was compounding
of offence in exercise of powers under Rule 53 of the 1996 Rules
and the violators paid the amount determined by permitting them
to compound the offence, thereafter the Magistrate was not
justified in directing to initiate fresh proceedings which would be
hit by the principle of "double jeopardy". That by the impugned
common judgment and order, the High Court has dismissed all
the aforesaid applications relying upon the decision of this Court
in the case of Sanjay (supra).
xxx xxx xxx
7.4 Thus, as held by this Court, the prohibition contained in
Section 22 of the MMDR Act against prosecution of a person
except on a written complaint made by the authorised officer in
this behalf would be attracted only when such person is sought
to be prosecuted for contraventions of Section 4 of the MMDR
Act and not for any act or omission which constitutes an offence
under the Penal Code.
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
xxx xxx xxx
8. However, it is required to be noted that in the case of Sanjay
(supra), this Court had no occasion and/or had not considered
when and at what stage the bar under Section 22 of the MMDR
Act would be attracted. The further question which is required to
be considered is, when and at what stage the Magistrate can be
said to have taken cognizance attracting the bar under Section
22 of the MMDR Act?
8.1 While considering the aforesaid issue, Section 22 of the
MMDR Act is required to be referred to, which is as under:
xxx xxx xxx
Reading the aforesaid provision would show that cognizance of
any offence punishable under the MMDR Act or the Rules made
thereunder shall be taken only upon a written complaint made by
a person authorised in this behalf by the Central Government or
the State Government. Therefore, on a fair reading of Section 22
of the MMDR Act, the bar would be attracted when the
Magistrate takes cognizance.
xxx xxx xxx
10. Having heard learned counsel for the parties and having
perused the relevant provisions of the law as also the judicial
pronouncements, we are of the view that the High Court has not
committed any error in not quashing the order passed by the
learned Magistrate and not quashing the criminal proceedings
for the offences under Sections 379 and 414. It is required to be
noted that the learned Magistrate in exercise of the suo motu
powers conferred under Section 156(3), Cr.P.C., 1973 directed
the concerned Incharge/ SHO of the police station to
lodge/register the crime case/FIR and directed initiation of
investigation and directed the concerned Incharge/ SHO of the
police station to submit a report after due investigation.
Applying the law laid down by this Court in the cases referred to
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
hereinabove, it cannot be said that at this stage the learned
Magistrate had taken any cognizance of the alleged offences
attracting bar under Section 22 of the MMDR Act. On
considering the relevant provisions of the MMDR Act and the
Rules made thereunder, it cannot be said that there is a bar
against registration of a criminal case or investigation by the
police agency or submission of a report by the police on
completion of investigation, as contemplated by Section 173,
Cr.P.C., 1973.
10.1 At this stage, it is required to be noted that as per Section
21 of the MMDR Act the offences under the MMDR Act are
cognizable.
10.2 As specifically observed by this Court in the case of Anil
Kumar (supra), 'when a Special Judge refers a complaint for
investigation under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C., 1973 obviously, he
has not taken cognizance of the offence and, therefore, it is a
precognizance stage and cannot be equated with postcognizance
stage'.
10.3 Even as observed by this Court in the case of R.R. Chari
(supra), even the order passed by the Magistrate ordering
investigation under Section 156(3), or issuing a search warrant
for the purpose of the investigation, he cannot be said to have
taken cognizance of the offence. As observed by the Constitution
Bench of this Court in the case of A.R. Antulay(supra), filing of a
complaint in court is not taking cognizance and what exactly
constitutes taking cognizance is different from filing of a
complaint. Therefore, when an order is passed by the Magistrate
for investigation to be made by the police under Section 156(3)
of the Code, which the learned Magistrate did in the Instant case,
when such an order is made the police is obliged to investigate
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
the case and submit a report under Section 173(2) of the Code.
That thereafter the investigating officer is required to send report
to the authorised officer and thereafter as envisaged under
Section 22 of the MMDR Act the authorised officer as mentioned
in Section 22 of the MMDR Act may file the complaint before the
learned Magistrate along with the report submitted by the
investigating officer and at that stage the question with respect
to taking cognizance by the learned Magistrate would arise.
xxx xxx xxx
13. After giving our thoughtful consideration in the matter, in the
light of the relevant provisions of the MMDR Act and the Rules
made thereunder vis a vis the Code of Criminal Procedure and
the Penal Code, and the law laid down by this Court in the cases
referred to hereinabove and for the reasons stated hereinabove,
our conclusions are as under:
i) that the learned Magistrate can in exercise of powers under
Section 156(3) of the Code order/direct the concerned Incharge/
SHO of the police station to lodge/register crime case/FIR even
for the offences under the MMDR Act and the Rules made
thereunder and at this stage the bar under Section 22 of the
MMDR Act shall not be attracted;
ii) the bar under Section 22 of the MMDR Act shall be attracted
only when the learned Magistrate takes cognizance of the
offences under the MMDR Act and Rules made thereunder and
orders issuance of process/summons for the offences under the
MMDR Act and Rules made thereunder;
iii) for commission of the offence under the IPC, on receipt of the
police report, the Magistrate having jurisdiction can take
cognizance of the said offence without awaiting the receipt of
complaint that may be filed by the authorised officer for taking
cognizance in respect of violation of various provisions of the
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
MMDR Act and Rules made thereunder; and
iv) that in respect of violation of various provisions of the MMDR
Act and the Rules made thereunder, when a Magistrate passes an
order under Section 156(3) of the Code and directs the concerned
Incharge/ SHO of the police station to register/lodge the crime
case/FIR in respect of the violation of various provisions of the
Act and Rules made thereunder and thereafter after investigation
the concerned Incharge of the police station/investigating officer
submits a report, the same can be sent to the concerned
Magistrate as well as to the concerned authorised officer as
mentioned in Section 22 of the MMDR Act and thereafter the
concerned authorised officer may file the complaint before the
learned Magistrate along with the report submitted by the
concerned investigating officer and thereafter it will be open for
the learned Magistrate to take cognizance after following due
procedure, issue process/summons in respect of the violations of
the various provisions of the MMDR Act and Rules made
thereunder and at that stage it can be said that cognizance has
been taken by the learned Magistrate.
v) in a case where the violator is permitted to compound the
offences on payment of penalty as per sub,section 1 of Section
23A, considering subsection 2 of Section 23A of the MMDR Act,
there shall not be any proceedings or further proceedings against
the offender in respect of the offences punishable under the
MMDR Act or any rule made thereunder so compounded.
However, the bar under subsection 2 of Section 23A shall not
affect any proceedings for the offences under the IPC, such as,
Sections 379 and 414 IPC and the same shall be proceeded with
further.”
11.10
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Attention of this Court is also drawn to the judgment of the
Supreme Court in the matter of
/
' '
$+
$
-
'
1!( Relevant para No.2 of the same
reads thus:
2. We are unable to sustain the impugned order of the High
Court quashing the FIR lodged against the respondents alleging
commission of offences under Sections 419, 420, 467 and 468
IPC by them in course of the proceeding of a civil suit, on the
ground that Section 195(1)(b)(ii) CrPC prohibited entertainment
of and investigation into the same by the police.
From a plain reading of Section 195 CrPC it is manifest
that it comes into operation at the stage when the court intends
to take cognizance of an offence under Section 190(1) CrPC; and
it has nothing to do with the statutory power of the police to
investigate into an FIR which discloses a cognizable offence, in
accordance with Chapter XII of the Code even if the offence is
alleged to have been committed in, or in relation to, any 9
proceeding in court. In other words, the statutory power of the
police to investigate under the Code is not in any way controlled
or circumscribed by Section 195 CrPC. It is of course true that
upon the charge,sheet (challan), if any, filed on completion of the
investigation into such an offence the court would not be
competent to take cognizance thereof in view of the embargo
Section 195(1)(b) CrPC, but nothing therein deters the court
from filing a complaint for the offence on the basis of the FIR
(filed by the aggrieved private party) and the materials collected
during investigation, provided it forms the requisite opinion and
follows the procedure laid down in Section 340 CrPC. The
judgment of this Court in Gopalakrishna Menon v. D. Raja
Reddy¹ on which the High Court relied, has no manner of
application to the facts of the instant case for there cognizance
was taken on a private complaint even though the offence of
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
forgery was committed in respect of a money receipt produced in
the civil court and hence it was held that the court could not take
cognizance on such a complaint in view of Section 195 Cr.P.C.”
11.11
Referring to the above, it is submitted that the legal position
stands authoritatively explained, in the context of similar provisions and
proceedings under different Statutes, wherein the underlying legal principle is
identical. He submits that it has been consistently held that the statutory bar is
imposed only on the Court to take cognizance of the offence and does not
fetter the power of the police to register an FIR or to carry out investigation
in accordance with law. The Magistrate, however, is precluded from acting
upon such report for the purpose of taking cognizance in the absence of a
complaint as mandated by the statute.
11.12
Thus, it is submitted that the procedure delineated by the
Supreme Court permits the registration of an FIR and authorises the police to
carry out investigation in accordance with law. Upon completion of the
investigation, a report may also be prepared and placed before the competent
Court, with a copy thereof being furnished to the officer duly authorised under
the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957. The
authorised officer is thereafter required to institute a complaint in terms of the
said Act, wherein such final report may be annexed as material in support of
the allegations and be relied upon as evidence for the purpose of prosecuting
the offender.
11.13
He submits that the single Judge(s) of this Court have failed to
take note of the correct position of law in the matters of *+ ,
and "
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
* + (supra)
(supra), and have not examined the scope of Section 21 (6)
along with Section 22 of the Act of 1957.
12.1
I have heard the learned counsel for the parties as well as learned
amicus and have gone through the documents appended with the present
petition and the judgments referred to above.
12.2
It emerges from the facts of the case that police have,
undisputedly, registered the FIRs, in relation to the cognizable offences not
only under the Act of 1957 but also under the general penal laws and thereafter
filed the final report on conclusion of investigation. In some cases, the FIR
was registered on the complaints by the officials of the Mining Department
(authorized officer). It is further undisputed that the procedure as delineated
for institution of the ‘complaint’ was not adhered to and that, notwithstanding
the same, the Court proceeded to take cognizance in some cases and framed
charges against the accused.
Before proceeding further, it would be relevant to refer to certain
statutory provisions under the procedural and substantive laws to appreciate
the issue.
$
!6
$
2. Definitions.—In this Code, unless the context otherwise
requires,—
xxx
xxx
xxx
(c) “cognizable offence” means an offence for which, and
“cognizable case” means a case in which, a police officer may,
in accordance with the First Schedule or under any other law for
the time being in force, arrest without warrant;
(d) “complaint” means any allegation made orally or in writing
to a Magistrate, with a view to his taking action under this Code,
that some person, whether known or unknown, has committed an
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
offence, but does not include a police report. Explanation.—A
report made by a police officer in a case which discloses, after
investigation, the commission of a non,cognizable offence shall
be deemed to be a complaint; and the police officer by whom such
report is made shall be deemed to be the complainant;
4%$ >' ?&&
& @<'#% &<
< 4> $<3& > %
< & > &A% >
4>&' $<:>'
“154. Information in cognizable cases.—(1) Every information
relating to the commission of a cognizable offence, if given orally
to an officer in charge of a police station, shall be reduced to
writing by him or under his direction, and be read over to the
informant; and every such information, whether given in writing
or reduced to writing as aforesaid, shall be signed by the person
giving it, and the substance thereof shall be entered in a book to
be kept by such officer in such form as the State Government may
prescribe in this behalf:
Provided that if the information is given by the woman
against whom an offence under section 326A, section 326B,
section 354, section 354A, section 354B, section 354C, section
354D, section 376, [section 376A, section 376AB, section 376B,
section 376C, section 376D, section 376DA, section 376DB],
section 376E or section 509 of the Indian Penal Code (45 of
1860) is alleged to have been committed or attempted, then such
information shall be recorded, by a woman police officer or any
woman officer:
Provided further that—
(a) in the event that the person against whom an offence
under section 354, section 354A, section 354B, section
354C, section 354D, section 376, [section 376A, section
376AB, section 376B, section 376C, section 376D, section
376DA, section 376DB], section 376E or section 509 of the
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Indian Penal Code (45 of 1860) is alleged to have been
committed or attempted, is temporarily or permanently
mentally or physically disabled, then such information
shall be recorded by a police officer, at the residence of
the person seeking to report such offence or at a
convenient place of such person’s choice, in the presence
of an interpreter or a special educator, as the case may be;
(b) the recording of such information shall be video
graphed;
(c) the police officer shall get the statement of the person
recorded by a Judicial Magistrate under clause (a) of sub,
section (5A) of section 164 as soon as possible.
(2) A copy of the information as recorded under sub,
section (1)shall be given forthwith, free of cost, to the
informant.
(3) Any person aggrieved by a refusal on the part of an
officer in charge of a police station to record the
information referred to in sub,section (1) may send the
substance of such information, in writing and by post, to
the Superintendent of Police concerned who, if satisfied
that such information discloses the commission of a
cognizable offence, shall either investigate the case himself
or direct an investigation to be made by any police officer
subordinate to him, in the manner provided by this Code,
and such officer shall have all the powers of an officer in
charge of the police station in relation to that offence.
xxx
xxx
xxx
156. Police officer’s power to investigate cognizable
case.—(1) Any officer in charge of a police station may,
without the order of a Magistrate, investigate any
cognizable case which a Court having jurisdiction over the
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
local area within the limits of such station would have
power to inquire into or try under the provisions of
Chapter XIII. (2) No proceeding of a police officer in any
such case shall at any stage be called in question on the
ground that the case was one which such officer was not
empowered under this section to investigate. (3) Any
Magistrate empowered under section 190 may order such
an investigation as above,mentioned.”
4%$ >' ?
<#$3%&
< #%A&
'% >
“200. Examination of complainant.—A Magistrate taking
cognizance of an offence on complaint shall examine upon oath
the complainant and the witnesses present, if any, and the
substance of such examination shall be reduced to writing and
shall be signed by the complainant and the witnesses, and also
by the Magistrate:
Provided that, when the complaint is made in writing, the
Magistrate need not examine the complainant and the
witnesses—
(a) if a public servant acting or purporting to act in the
discharge of his official duties or a Court has made the
complaint; or
(b) if the Magistrate makes over the case for inquiry or
trial to another Magistrate under section 192:
Provided further that if the Magistrate makes over the case
to another Magistrate under section 192 after examining the
complainant and the witnesses, the latter Magistrate need not re,
examine them.”
!
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
???5
6!
$
xxx
xxx
xxx
465. Finding or sentence when reversible by reason of error,
omission or irregularity.—(1) Subject to the provisions
hereinbefore contained, no finding, sentence or order passed by
a Court of competent jurisdiction shall be reversed or altered by
a Court of appeal, confirmation of revision on account of any
error, omission or irregularity in the complaint, summons,
warrant, proclamation, order, judgment or other proceedings
before or during trial or in any inquiry or other proceedings
under this Code, or any error, or irregularity in any sanction for
the prosecution, unless in the opinion of that Court, a failure of
justice has in fact been occasioned thereby.
(2) In determining whether any error, omission or irregularity in
any proceeding under this Code, or any error, or irregularity in
any sanction for the prosecution has occasioned a failure of
justice, the Court shall have regard to the fact whether the
objection could and should have been raised at an earlier stage
in the proceedings.”
xxx
6!
21. $
4 ! $
! 9
xxx xxx
!64 $ 5 6
! $
.―
xxx
xxx xxx
“(6) Notwithstanding anything contained in the Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1973 (2 of 1974), an offence under sub,section (1)
shall be cognizable.
22.
B
0 .―No court shall take cognizance of
any offence punishable under this Act or any rules made
thereunder except upon complaint in writing made by a person
authorised in this behalf by the Central Government or the State
Government.
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
xxx
14.1
xxx
xxx
It is evident from the above that in a cognizable offence, there are
certain powers conferred on the investigating agency and procedure for
regulation of such powers is specified in ‘Chapter XII’ Cr.P.C., which also
provides the safeguards for the accused. On the other hand, a complaint, as
defined under Section 2 (d) Cr.P.C., is to be instituted as per ‘Chapter XV’
Cr.P.C.
14.2
It is only after a final report as per ‘Chapter XII Cr.P.C.’ (in a
cognizable offence), or a complaint having been instituted as per ‘Chapter
XV’ Cr.P.C. that the question of commencement of proceedings before a
Court arises. The aspect of ‘cognizance’ is dealt with at the stage of ‘Chapter
XVII’ Cr.P.C. The bar of cognizance prescribed under Section 22 of the Act
of 1957, has been applied in the context of ‘the Court’, hence, such a bar
would not be applicable at a stage prior to the stage of cognizance.
14.3
There can be no assumption that the Legislature was unaware of
the expression used or of the separate procedure applicable to each
proceedings, hence, both the clauses need to be harmoniously interpreted and
applied.
14.4
In order to appreciate the controversy, it thus becomes necessary
to examine the effect and interplay of Section 21 (6) with Section 22 of the
Act of 1957. Undisputedly, Section 21 (6) of the Act of 1957 makes the
offence cognizable, hence, as per law, an FIR can be registered and the
investigation can be undertaken by the investigating agency. The proposition
also stands fully settled by the Supreme Court in a catena of judgments
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
including the judgments in the matter of
:
*+5
(supra), $
(supra) as well as in the matter of Jayant Vs. State of Madhya
Pradesh. The position in law thus needs no reiteration about the competence
and jurisdiction of the investigating agency/police official to register an FIR,
conduct investigation and to prepare a final report. It is only upon the
conclusion of investigation that section 22 of the Act of 1957 becomes
applicable. A plain reading of the Section 22 reveals that although it opens
with a “non obstante clause”, however, the limitation imposed thereby is
consciously and deliberately confined to the power of “Court” to take
cognizance of the offence and not to the authority of ‘any person’ or
‘investigating agency.’ Had the Legislature intended imposition of a universal
and non discriminatory prohibition encompassing investigation, registration
of FIRs or submission of final report, the statutory bar under Section 22 of the
Act of 1957 would not have been qualified to taking of cognizance by the
Court alone and instead there would have been a sweeping bar. The legislative
wisdom underlying the provision clearly reflects a conscious demarcation
between the investigative domain of the police and the jurisdictional threshold
at which the Court may take cognizance. The restriction is thus designed to
regulate and limit the exercise of judicial power at the stage of cognizance,
while simultaneously preserving the statutory authority of the investigating
agency to act in respect of cognizable offences.
14.5
The Legislature has thus devised a two step process for
proceeding in offence(s) under Act of 1957. At the first stage, by expressly
declaring the offences to be cognizable, the Legislature has empowered the
police not merely to register an FIR but also to follow the procedure for
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
conducting investigation in the matter as prescribed for cognizable offences
and thus carry out searches and seizures, effect arrests and detain persons,
secure and preserve seized minerals or material and produce the accused and
the case property before the competent forum, without being constrained by
the procedural limitations applicable to non cognizable offences. In this
manner, the investigating agency has been equipped with an effective
enforcement tool to promptly and efficaciously deal with violations of the
statute. At the same time, the Legislature was also cognizant of the fact that
offences under special Statutes often involve technical, regulatory, and
domain specific considerations requiring specialised knowledge in relation
thereto. Hence, at the second stage of taking of cognizance of the offence by
the Court, the legislature has applied a statutory filter by mandating that
prosecution of the case must be only through the process of the department
i.e. by way of a complaint by an authorized person. The underlying object
seemingly being that the competent authority under the special Statute be fully
apprised of all the material that may have been collected by the investigating
agency and is afforded an opportunity to scrutinise, evaluate and ascertain
such evidence in the light of the regulatory framework of the special statute.
The ‘authorized person’ is thereafter within liberties to take recourse to all/any
such measures as are prescribed therein. Hence, assuming that in a specific
circumstances, the special statute confers upon the competent authority the
power to compound such offences at the departmental level, such notices may
be issued by the authorized person and /or he may institute a complaint. The
aforesaid prohibition is also intended to operate as a safeguard for a person
accused of having committed an offence under the special statute.
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
14.6
The purpose behind imposing such a prohibition is to safeguard
the individuals from frivolous or vexatious prosecution at the hands of
mischievous persons. The statutory embargo thus serves as an essential
protective shield against abuse of the criminal process and unwarranted
harassment of individuals. The Statute thus mandates that complaints for
commission of the offences under the Act of 1957 should be routed only
through the competent authorities designated under the special Statutes.
14.7
The position thus acts as checks and balances. Vesting of an
absolute power solely and exclusively in the departmental domain may give
rise to a cartelized unholy relationship between the wrong doer and the
watchdog. Similarly, even the police was also not intended to be given
unbridled sweeping powers in such matters which are more often revenue
centric. Hence, the Supreme Court took care of both the aspects in the matter
of "
*+5
(supra) and struck a balance while keeping a check on both
the agencies viz the police as well as the department.
14.8
The Division Bench categorically held that upon completion of
investigation, the investigating agency is required to submit its final report
along with the evidence collected to the authorized representatives/agents
under the Special Act and may also forward the said report to the Illaqa
Magistrate. I am of the opinion that the aforesaid procedural requirement
needs to be mandatorily complied with and that the final report by the police
should necessarily be forwarded also to the Illaqa Magistrate for record, lest
any mischief is committed by the colluding Departmental officials. In the
event of any such collusion or dereliction, an unquestionable record would be
readily
available
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
with
the
Illaqa
Magistrate
for
initiation
of
departmental/penal proceedings against the erring officials. The said
procedural safeguard can effectively redresses the possibility of any unholy
nexus.
14.9
At the same time, a mere submission of the final report has not
been applied as an expression of empowering the Illaqa Magistrate/the Special
Judge to take cognizance of an offence qua which prohibition has been
prescribed. The law does not pre empt presumption of commission of an
offence and such prima facie presumption may only be drawn after a
complaint by an authorized person.
14.10
Further, the legal position as emerging from the judgment of the
Supreme Court in the matter of $(3(
2 @<A 2 -<02
(although in
context of Section 195 of the Cr.P.C.), specifically holds that a statutory
prohibition on taking of cognizance by a court cannot be invoked to interdict
either the registration of the FIR or the conduct of investigation by the police
and that the aforesaid exercise can be undertaken by the law enforcement
agencies. The Supreme Court has hence recognised that such preliminary and
investigative steps fall within the lawful domain of the investigating and law
enforcement agencies and are not eclipsed by the bar operating at the stage of
cognizance.
15.1
The aforesaid principle had earlier been iterated and applied, in
the specific context of the Act of 1957, by the Supreme Court, in the matter
of
2 ((0 4/ 8) (B 2 -<02 ) after making a specific reference to the
judgment of 4
= B @<A 2 -<02 ), to hold that Section 22 of the Act of
1957 imposes a restriction only on the power of the Court to take cognizance
and not on the authority of the police to register an FIR or to undertake
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
investigation. It is specifically held therein that Section 22 of the Act of 1957
is intended to restrict the jurisdiction of the Court and not to curtail the
statutory powers of the police and that while the police are competent to
investigate allegations of contravention of the Act of 1957 and to submit a
final report upon completion of such investigation, a police officer cannot
insist that the competent Court should take cognizance of offences under the
Act solely on the basis of such final report. The above said position in law
was later reiterated in the matter of
B
' 5-/ 4' '( )*
;B
(-;
(supra).
15.2
The same now leads to an inextricably linked issue where
offences under other penal Statutes may also have been committed along with
offences under the Act of 1957. The issue which thus comes up for
consideration of this Court is as to whether, in such circumstances, the Illaqa
Magistrate or the competent Court would be justified in framing charges in
respect of such other offences and whether it would be competent to take
cognizance thereof or whether the statutory bar engrained under Section 22 of
the Act of 1957 would still get attracted.
15.3
While deriving strength from the judgments of the Supreme
Court referred to above, in such an eventuality, the Illaqa Magistrate/special
Court is required to undertake an exercise with respect to the nature of the
offences committed, the evidence collected and the essential ingredients
specified for such offences. Where the nature of the allegations and the
evidence so collected are such that they do not admit of segregation, and are
incapable of being split up so as to give rise to an independent cause of action,
distinct from the offence under the Act of 1957 and where such allegations
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
are found to be intrinsically intertwined with the said offence, the bar under
Section 22 of the Act of 1957 would nonetheless operate.
15.4
In such cases, the predominant nature of the allegations must
necessarily be examined. A recourse to the provisions of the general law
would not be permitted solely to override the prohibition imposed by the
special statute. The invocation of general penal provisions, in the face of an
express statutory embargo, would thus defeat the legislative intent and
safeguard under Section 22. However, in circumstances where the material on
record discloses the commission of other offences, that are truly distinct,
independent, and severable from the offence under the Act of 1957, the bar
under Section 22 would not per se interdict the Court from proceeding in
accordance with law.
15.5
To illustrate, where there is an over extraction of the mineral in
excess of the permissible limit and for which the royalty has not been paid,
such conduct may, in a given case, also amount to commission of offences
under the general provisions of IPC/BNS, 2023, however, such acts remain
intrinsically intertwined with and form an integral part of the offence pre
dominantly under the domain of the Act of 1957. In such a situation, the
offence, though clothed with additional penal consequences under the general
law, continues to be governed by the special statute and the statutory bar under
Section 22 would remain operative. At the same time, there may also be a
situation where the accused person, in the course of committing an offence
under the Act of 1957, may have committed other acts such as theft of tippers
or loading machinery or may have caused death or bodily injury to another
person during the course of the illegal mining operation. Such acts, though
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
occurring in the course of the commission of an offence under the Act of 1957,
are distinct, independent and severable offences in themselves. They are not
integrally intertwined with the offences under the special statute but are
merely connected as part of the same transaction in a factual sense. In such an
eventuality, the bar under Section 22 of the Act of 1957 would not be extended
so as to provide an immunity from the prosecution for such independent
offenses except on a complaint filed by the authorized person. Such an
exercise, however, is required to be undertaken by the competent Court and
the Statute nowhere debars the Court from proceeding to frame charges in
respect of other distinct and independent offences.
16.1
It is also noticed that in case bearing No(s).CRM M 61811 2025,
CRM M 60536 2025 and CRM M 66839 2025, the charges have been
framed against the petitioners therein for offence under the Act of 1957 as
well as for offences under the IPC and in case bearing No.CRM M 66761
2025, the charges have been framed for the commission of offence under the
Act of 1957. The issue that, therefore, arises for consideration is whether, in
the facts and circumstances of the present cases, the said action of the Court
in framing charges under the general penal statute is legally sustainable or
whether the same is liable to be set aside.
16.2
The preposition of law as above also requires to be examined
from the perspective of Section 465 Cr.P.C. The position in law needs no
elaboration that an order/sentence or judgment would not be set aside on an
irregularity unless the same has occasioned a failure of justice. The provision
embodies the legislative intent that criminal proceedings should not be
rendered vulnerable to technical lapses unless they strike at the fairness of the
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
process or cause real prejudice to the accused.
16.3
This Court is thus required to examine as to whether the order
framing charge in the present cases is a mere procedural irregularity, curable
under law or a foundational illegality and would thus occasion a failure of
justice.
16.4
While under the ordinary circumstances, a person may not be in
a position to impugn an order framing charge solely because it has been done
by a superior Court as it may not reflect substantive injustice, however, where
the issue fundamentally is as regards the maintainability of proceedings itself,
an illegality in framing charge becomes substantial and goes to the root of the
matter.
16.5
The prohibition under Section 22 of the Act of 1957 being
absolute, the statutory protection cannot be eroded merely because the Special
Court has proceeded to frame charges. Permitting such an act would amount
to obliterating the legislative intent and rendering it otiose thereby erasing the
legislation and validate an illegality. The defect in the present case is not one
of a mere error in the exercise of jurisdiction, rather, it is a fundamental error
of competence, maintainability and cognizance. Once the initiation of the
proceeding itself has been held to be not maintainable and in violation of law,
the consequential orders flowing therefrom would not be accorded judicial
protection. To sustain such proceedings would be to countenance an action
beyond the spirit of the law. The provision of Section 465 Cr.P.C. thus would
not be construed so as to erode or override an express statutory prohibition.
16.6
It is also required to be kept in mind that procedural laws are
hand maiden of justice. The saving clause under Section 465 Cr.P.C. is
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
designed to prevent miscarriage of justice on account of inconsequential or
immaterial procedural lapses where no real prejudice has occasioned. It
cannot be elevated to an enabling provision to validate proceedings that are
illegal or to eclipse a substantive statutory enactment. The said provision is to
safeguard the judicial time and prevent reversal of proceedings on
technicalities, where the trial is otherwise fair and lawful. It does not operate
as a shield to protect proceedings that suffer from a illegality or are void ab
initio. To apply the provision otherwise would be to subvert the legislative
intent and undermine the rule of law itself.
16.7
It is further evident in some cases a challenge to the proceedings
has been filed belatedly and further proceedings may have been undertaken in
the interregnum. However, once this Court has held that the proceedings were
beyond law, the protection afforded under the Statute would not be denied.
The error being fundamental and the defect being incurable, the burden and
responsibility falls upon the Court to ensure that the defect is remedied at the
first available opportunity instead of investing further judicial time in a
wasteful final outcome.
17.1
Having considered that the law does not impose an absolute bar
on the splitting up of offences, where such offenses are distinct and
independent and do not form an integral part of the same transaction, the
impugned orders framing charge have been examined in light thereof. I find
that no such exercise has been undertaken by the Court in the present set of
cases. Apparently, the Court proceeded with the framing of the charges
assuming the jurisdiction in the matter and taking cognizance of the case. Such
an approach, on the face of it is in conflict with the settled position of law
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
governing the limits of jurisdiction and the procedure to be followed before
cognizance can be lawfully taken.
In view of the above, it is held as under:
(i)
That the prayer of the petitioners in so far as the plea of seeking
quashing of the FIR as well as the final report in light of Section
22 of the Act of 1957, is concerned, the said prayer is dismissed
in the light of Section 21 (6) read with the judicial
pronouncements in the matter of
(ii)
B
' 5-/ 4' '( )*
;B
(-; (supra)
The orders dated 01.08.2025 passed in CRM M 66839 2025
titled Jagdish Singh Vs. State of Punjab framing charge against
the petitioner therein for offences under Sections (21)(1) of the
Act of 1957 and Sections 379 and 411 of the IPC and the order
dated 30.04.2025 passed in CRM M 60536 2025 titled as Nasib
Chand and another Vs. State of Punjab and another framing
charge against the petitioners therein as well as the order framing
charge dated 12.08.2025 passed in CRM M 61811 2025, are,
however, liable to be set aside for being in violation of law;
(iii)
The authorized person, if so advised, may file a complaint before
the competent Court whereupon further proceedings shall be
undertaken by the competent Court, as per law;
(iv)
The judgment in the matter of Kulwant Kaur (supra) relied upon
by the counsel for the petitioners is per incuriam as it fails to take
note of the provisions contained under Section 21 (6) of the Act
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
of 1957 and also the judicial pronouncements of the Supreme
Court of India on the subject.
The CRM M 66839 2025; CRM M 60536 2025; CRM M
61811 2025 and CRM M 66761 2025 are thus partly allowed. CRM M
35908 2025 is disposed of in above terms.
Pending misc. application(s), if any, shall also stand(s) disposed
of accordingly.
A photocopy of this order be placed on the files of connected
cases.
< 2B
2 = 2)2
/
:
:
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.01.13 18:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
;
-
$ 4/ " ! $8!
$
)C 8
)C 8
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review