Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:208
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
S.A. No. 83 of 2021
Jagdish Rana, aged about 68 years, S/o late Chetlal Rana, R/o village
Barkakala, P.S.+P.O Ichak, Dist- Hazaribagh.
…
…
Plaintiff/Appellant/Appellant
Versus
1. Basudeo Mahato S/o Late Luthan Mahato, age not known R/o villBarkakala, P.S+ P.O.- Ichak & Dist- Hazaribagh
2. Sona Mahato s/o Late Luthan Mahato, age not known R/o villBarkakala, P.S+P.O.- Ichak & Dist-Hazaribagh.
…
…
Defendants/Respondents/Respondents
3. Mosomat Dhani, aged - not known, w/o late Bhola Rana, R/o
village Barkakala, P.S.+P.O. Ichak, Dist- Hazaribagh
4. Manoj Kumar Rana, aged not known S/o late Bhola Rana, R/o
village Barkakala, P.S.+P.o. Ichak, Dist- Hazaribagh
5. Raj kumar Rana, aged- not known, S/o late Bhola Rana, R/o village
Barkakala, P.S. +PO Ichak, Dist- Hazaribagh
6. Jashwant Kumar Rana, aged not known, s/o late Bhola Rana, R/o
village Barkakala, P.S.+P.O. Ichak, Dist- Hazaribagh
7. Neman Rana, aged - not known, S/o late Chetlal Rana, R/o village
Barkakala, P.S. +Po Ichak, Dist- Hazaribagh
…
…
Plaintiffs/ Appellants/ Respondents
--CORAM :HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE ANUBHA RAWAT CHOUDHARY
--For the Appellant
: Mr. Ranjit Kr. Sinha, Advocate
: Mr. Onkar Nath Tiwary, Advocate
: Mr. S. Raza, Advocate
: Mr. Navneet Kumar, Advocate
For the Respondents
:
--17/06.01.2026
Heard the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant.
2.
This appeal has been filed against the judgment and decree
dated 30.06.2021 and 09.07.2021 respectively passed by learned
Principal District Judge, Hazaribagh in Civil Appeal (Title) No. 43 of
2019 whereby the learned 1st appellate Court dismissed the appeal and
affirmed the judgment and decree dated 08.05.2019 and 22.05.2019
respectively passed by learned Civil Judge (Jr. Division)-IV,
Hazaribagh in Title Suit No. 139 of 2013. The suit was dismissed, 1st
appeal was also dismissed and consequently, the plaintiff no.2 is the
appellant before this Court.
2026:JHHC:208
3.
Learned counsel for the appellant has submitted that the learned
trial court had primarily dismissed the suit by holding that there is no
valid cause of action. He has referred to I.A. No. 70 of 2026 filed
under Order XLI Rule 27 of the Code of Civil Procedure seeking to
adduce additional evidence before this Court and has submitted that
further case has been filed by the plaintiff who is the appellant before
this Court being Case No. 520 of 2023. He submits that said
proceeding under section 144 of Code of Criminal Procedure (in
short ‘Cr.P.C.’) was initiated on 29.12.2023 and the case number was
520 of 2023. The learned counsel submits that there is an Anchal Amin
report dated 26.12.2024 which is an important piece of evidence.
4.
Learned counsel for the appellant has also referred to another
I.A. No. 12328 of 2025 seeking to adduce additional evidence by
referring to order dated 17.02.2022 passed in case no. 16 of 2021 by
the Sub-divisional Magistrate, Sadar, Hazaribagh under section 147 of
Cr.P.C. and has submitted that the said case was dropped by the
authority by observing that the aggrieved parties may knock the door
of civil court of competent jurisdiction for redressal of their
grievances. The learned counsel has submitted that there is a valid
cause of action and therefore, the judgments passed by both the
learned courts holding that there was no valid cause of action, are
perverse and accordingly, a substantial question of law be framed
taking into account the aforesaid two petitions seeking to adduce
additional evidence.
5.
After hearing the learned counsel for the appellant, this Court
finds that the suit was instituted as back as in the year 2013 showing
the cause of action arose on 20.06.2013 and 05.12.2013. The plaintiff
claimed adjudication of right, title and possession over schedule-A
property and also made a prayer that Khas possession be given to the
plaintiff over schedule-B property which is part and parcel of
schedule-A property and it was prayed that the defendant be directed
not to put any illegal construction over schedule-B property.
6.
The learned trial court framed the following issues for
consideration:
2026:JHHC:208
“1. Whether the suit is maintainable in the present form?
2. Whether the plaintiffs have got valid cause of action for the
present suit?
3. Whether the suit is barred by law of Limitation and Adverse
possession?
4. Whether the suit is barred by Law of Estoppel, Waiver and
Acquiescence?
5. Whether the suit is barred by the provisions of Specific
Relief Act?
6. Whether the suit is barred for non-joinder of necessary
parties?
7. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled for decree of title and
confirmation of possession in their favour over Schedule-A
land as described in plaint and as prayed for?
8. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled for khas possession by
evicting the defendants from Schedule B lands and
demolishing the illegal construction at the cost of the
defendants.
9. Whether plaintiffs are entitled for relief as claimed for?
10. Whether plaintiffs are entitled for any other relief or
reliefs?”
7.
The learned trial court ultimately recorded that there was no
cause of action to file the suit and decided issue nos.1 and 2 against
the appellant/plaintiff. The learned court while deciding issue no. 1
and 2 referred to the discussions made with respect to issue no. 7. The
discussions under issue no.7 and issue nos. 1 & 2 are quoted as under:
“ISSUE No 7.
It is the case of the plaintiffs that the defendants' mother had
sold the land more fully described in Schedule B of the plaint
vide sale deed marked as Exhibit 1/b which the defendants do
not deny. However the plaintiffs claim that on 20.06.2013 the
defendant basudeo mahto began to lay foundation over the
Schedule b lands because of which a case with SDM,
hazaribagh was also instituted under Section 144 CrPC vide
Misc Case No. 194/13 wherein it is alleged that the defendants
in their show cause falsely claimed lands in plot no. 1322 and
when the case was dropped the defendant became emboldened
and started construction over schedule B lands on 05.12.2013
and hence the present suit was filed. The defendants seek
declaration over entire Schedule A land and have brought on
record various sale deeds through which they claim that they
have purchased the suit land. However the plaintiffs have
2026:JHHC:208
themselves submitted that the defendants have encroached
upon lands in Schedule B and not all lands of Schedule A.
A suit for declaration of title can be filed under Section 34 of
the Specific Relief Act, 1963 which provides that
"Discretion of court as to declaration of status or right.Any person entitled to any legal character, or to any right
as to any property, may institute a suit against any person
denying, or interested to deny, his title to such character
or right, and the court may in its discretion make therein a
declaration that he is so entitled, and the plaintiff need not
in such suit ask for any further relief: Provided that no
court shall make any such declaration where the plaintiff,
being able to seek further relief than a mere declaration of
title, omits to do so."
Therefore the suit to be maintainable the plaintiff has to allege
and prove that the defendant has denied or is interested in
denying the legal character or right to property before the
filing of the suit. A general declaration cannot be granted
unless it is sought against a person denying or interested in
denying the right or title of the plaintiff.
Hence the plaintiffs do not have any cause of action to seek
declaration over lands described in khata no. 42 plot no.
1341, khata no. 133 plot no. 1342 and khata no. 61 plot no.
1343 as they themselves have not made any submission with
respect to the fact of the defendants denied their title instead
the plaintiffs in para 11 have submitted that the defendants
made no claims over lands of plot no. 1341, 1342 and 1343
and a relief for declaration will not lie since the title of the
plaintiff is not disputed by the defendant as has been submitted
by the plaintiffs themselves and as to how a cloud of doubt has
been cast over their title.
Now coming to the question of whether the plaintiffs are
entitled to the relief of declaration over lands described in
Schedule A of the plaint which they claim have been denied by
the defendants in their show cause filed on Mutation case no.
194/2013. The plaintiffs have not brought on record any
documentary evidence to show that a show cause as
mentioned in para 11 of the plaint had been filed by the
plaintiff wherein they had denied the right of the plaintiff over
the lands described in Schedule A of the plaint. Further the
defendants have admitted the sale of 4 decimils of land by
their mother to the father of the plaintiff vide sale deed marked
as Exhibit 1/b, however they deny the plaintiffs submission
(para 5 of plaint) that their father Tukhari had been granted
2026:JHHC:208
only 6 decimils of land from the entire 48 decimils of land and
rest 42 was granted to Luthan Mahto as per a partition in the
year 1950. The plaintiffs have brought no documentary or oral
evidence of the partition on record in support of the same nor
the fact that the defendants now because of the alleged
partition owned no more lands in khata no. 71 plot no. 1322
as alleged by the plaintiffs. The defendants have denied the
partition and have submitted Exhibit A and A/1 showing
distribution of shares among him and his brothers, however
both the alleged partition deeds have been made after the
present suit was filed. Hence there is nothing on record to
show that the defendants have been illegally claiming any
right over property described in schedule B of the plaint as
submitted by the plaintiff. Hence this issue is decided against
the plaintiffs.
……….
ISSUE No 1 and 2 are taken up together for consideration
since they are corelated with each other and in the light of the
issue no. 7 discussed above it is apparent that the plaintiff had
no cause of action to institute the suit as cause of action itself
has not been established by the plaintiff and hence the suit is
not maintainable in its present form nor do they have a valid
cause of action.”
The plaintiffs filed appeal. The learned 1st appellate court
8.
framed following points for determination:
“(I)
Whether the plaintiffs are entitled for declaration of
title and confirmation of possession in their favour over
Schedule ‘A’ land as described in the plaint.
(II)
Whether the plaintiffs are entitled for Khas possession
by evicting the defendants from Schedule ‘B’ land and
demolishing the illegal construction at the costs of defendants.
(III)
Whether the plaintiffs have got valid cause of action
for the present suit.”
9.
While considering the point of determination no. (I), the
learned 1st appellate court also considered the provisions of section 34
and 35 of the Specific Relief Act and ultimately held that the suit was
not maintainable. The findings of the learned 1st appellate court are as
under:
2026:JHHC:208
“In the case in hand, simple perusal of plaint as well as
evidence brought on record by the plaintiffs, it is clear that
there is no whisper about the fact by the plaintiffs that how the
cloud has been casted by any act of the defendants qua the
first category of three piece of suit land i.e. land in plot
no.1341 Khata no. 42, Plot no. 1342 Khata no.133 and Plot
no.1343 Khata no.61. In view of legal discussion in preceding
paragraph, it is clear that to get the declaratory relief,
plaintiffs have, not only to brought on record the document
qua the ownership of the land rather it has to be brought on
record that his ownership or possessory right is disputed by
the defendants and regarding aforesaid three piece of suit
land, there is no material at all available on the record, which
could even remotely suggests that defendants have ever
disputed the title and/or possession of the plaintiffs qua the
aforesaid land. As such, as far as these piece of suit lands as
mentioned in Annexure 'A' of the plaint are concerned, I find
and hold that plaintiffs are not entitled to get declaration of
title and confirmation of possession qua the 0.06 acre of land
of plot no.1341 Khata no. 24 (vide Ext.1/a), 0.04 acre of land
of Plot no.1342 Khata no.133 (vide Ext.1/c) and 0.05 acre of
land of Plot no.1343, Khata no.61 (vide Ext.-1).
Now I would like to come to second category of land
of Annexure 'A' of plaint. I have discussed at length the
evidence brought on record by the plaintiffs and defendants
qua 0.04 acre of land of Plot no.1322, Khata no.71, in
preceding paragraphs. Now I would like to state that first
incident which allegedly casted cloud on the ownership, right
of plaintiffs qua the land of Plot no.1322 as narrated by
plaintiffs in their plaint is of 13.06.2013 and it is also stated
by plaintiffs that on account of that, they approached the
police station and initiated proceeding u/s 144 Cr.P.C before
ld. S.D.M., Hazaribag, but it is very strange that these two
papers i.e. complaint/application to the P.S. and proceeding of
144 Cr.P.C before ld. S.D.M, Hazaribag has not been brought
on record by the plaintiffs, reason best known to them.
Another alleged incident cited by plaintiffs is of 05.12.2013,
for which, it is stated that defendants started construction over
Khata no.71 Plot no.1322 and plaintiffs intimated the police
station, but that complaint/application which was given to
police station has also not been brought on record. These are
instances cited by the plaintiffs through which plaintiffs tried
to brought on record the fact that act of the defendants cast
cloud on the right, title and interest over 4 decimal of land of
Plot no.1322 Khata no.71. Per contra, defendants has stated
in written statement as well as evidence brought on record
2026:JHHC:208
from the mouth of the witnesses, that 4 decimal of land is in
possession of the plaintiffs and plaintiffs want to grab more
land, as such the present case has been filed before ld. court
below. In Hari Singh Munda & Ors. Vs Dondo Munda & Ors
case, issue before the Hon’ble Patna High Court was
“entitlement of further relief” of plaintiffs; whereas, in case
“Asstt. Branch Manager Vs Shanti Swarup Sharma” the
matter was related to resignation of plaintiffs. Therefore, ratio
of precedents relied upon by the appellants/Plaintiffs is not
applicable in the facts and circumstances of this case.
Ld. counsel for the Appellants during the course of
argument pointed out Section 34 of Specific Relief Act, 1963
and tried to convince this court that this provision speaks
about two sets of person against whom plaintiffs can bring suit
under this provision. First set of person is “who is denying,”
this makes reference for the present time denial and second set
of person is “who is interested to deny”, this makes reference
for the denial may be in future. This court is not convince with
the submission advanced by ld. counsel, on account of fact
that the explanation of Section-34 of Specific Relief Act, 1963
clarify, who is the person interested to deny. It says, “A
trustee of property is a “person interested to deny” a title
adverse to the title of someone who is not in existence, and
whom, if in existence, he would be a trustee.” Therefore,
denial by the defendant to any right as to any property of
plaintiff is actual and existing one and it cannot be for future
reference of time, meaning thereby, that defendant may deny
the right to the property of plaintiffs in future, cannot and
should not be a ground to bring suit under this provision
against the defendant. Ld. counsel for Appellants also urged
with full vigour that when plaintiffs brought on record four
sale deeds of suit lands and fact of ownership right and
possessory right to the suit property is not denied by the
defendants rather it is admitted by the defendants, then, there
is no reason before this court, in not allowing the present
appeal. Again, as far as this aspect is concerned, in preceding
paragraph, I have discussed at length that to get decree of
declaration of title from the court, plaintiff has to bring on
record denial on the part of defendants qua the right, title,
interest and/or possession of the property of plaintiff.
In view of aforesaid discussion, I am of considered
view that plaintiffs were not able to brought on record any
convincing material which could convince the court that acts
of the defendants created cloud on their right, title and interest
of plaintiffs in 0.4 decimal of land of Khata no.1322 Plot
no.71 and unless and until this fact has not been brought on
2026:JHHC:208
record which could genuinely indicate regarding the threat to
the right and title of the suit land of the plaintiffs, this
equitable relief ought not be granted by this court, therefore,
the plaintiffs are not entitled for declaration of title and
confirmation of possession in their favour over second
category of land of Schedule ‘A’ of the plaint which is also
included Schedule 'B' land.”
10.
The learned Court thereafter took up point of determination no.
(II) which was dealing with schedule-B property and ultimately held
that the plaintiffs failed to prove that the defendants encroached on
schedule-B land of the plaintiffs and constructed a small house. It was
held that the plaintiffs are not entitled for Khas possession by evicting
the defendants from schedule-B property. The findings are as under:
“…There is no probable evidence either oral or documentary
brought on record by the plaintiffs regarding manner and
extent of encroachment by the defendants in Schedule 'B' land
of the plaintiffs. From perusal of L.C.R it appears that at the
fag end of trial i.e. at the stage of final argument,
Plaintiffs/Appellants filed petition under Order 26 Rule 10A
C.P.C, 1908 for appointment of Commission but the same was
dismissed vide order dt. 22.04.219 and thereafter, the said
impugned
order
has
not
been
challenged
by
Appellants/Plaintiffs at any stage. In fact, plaintiffs failed to
prove that defendants encroached in the Schedule 'B' land of
plaintiffs and constructed small house. So I find and hold that
plaintiffs are not entitled for khas possession by evicting
defendants from Schedule 'B' land and demolishing the illegal
construction at the cost of defendants.”
11.
While considering the point of determination no. (III), the
learned 1st appellate court recorded that there is no valid cause of
action and ultimately, upheld the judgment of the learned trial court.
12.
This Court finds that both the learned courts have considered
the materials on record and have given concurrent findings, interalia,
regarding absence of cause of action to file the suit and have
dismissed the suit. The learned counsel for the appellant has not
pointed out any perversity in the matter of appreciation of evidence by
the learned courts. This court finds that no substantial question of law
is involved in this case.
2026:JHHC:208
13.
So far as additional evidences which are sought to be brought
on record by filing aforesaid interlocutory applications are concerned,
the same are relating to subsequent events after filing of the suit.
There can be no doubt that the cause of action with respect to a suit
has to be decided as it existed on the date of filing of the suit. Any
subsequent development giving rise to cause of action cannot be taken
into consideration in the present case. There is no substantial question
of law involved in this 2nd appeal which is hereby dismissed.
14.
I.A. No. 12328 of 2025 and I.A. No. 70 of 2026 seeking to
adduce additional evidence are also dismissed.
15.
Other pending interlocutory application, if any, is dismissed as
not pressed.
16.
Let this order be communicated to the learned court concerned
through ‘FAX/email’.
(Anubha Rawat Choudhary, J.)
Date of order:06.01.2026
Pankaj
Date of uploading:12.01.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review