Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
UKHC010173732022
2026:UHC:7196-DB
HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND AT NAINITAL
JUSTICE SHRI MANOJ KUMAR TIWARI
AND
JUSTICE SHRI PANKAJ PUROHIT
Writ Petition Service Bench No. 657 of 2022
13 August, 2026
Jagdish Prasad Bhatt & others
Versus
State of Uttarakhand & others
--Petitioners
--Respondents
---------------------------------------------------------------------Presence:-
Mr. Yogesh Pant, Advocate for the petitioners, through video
conferencing.
Mr. S.S. Chaudhary, Standing
Uttarakhand/respondent no. 1.
Counsel
for
the
State
of
Mr. Rajesh Sharma, Advocate for respondent no.2.
---------------------------------------------------------------------JUDGMENT: (per Hon’ble Justice Sri Manoj Kumar Tiwari)
Delay Condonation Application (IA/2/2025)
1.
Delay Condonation Application (IA/2/2025) is
allowed. Delay in filing the substitution application is
condoned.
Substitution Application (IA/3/2025)
2.
Prayer for substitution is not opposed by
learned counsel for respondents, therefore, IA/3/2025 is
allowed.
3.
Amended memo of parties be filed within 48
hours.
4.
in
Petitioners were appointed as Logging Officer
Uttar
Pradesh
Forest
Corporation,
which
was
established under U.P. Forest Corporation Act, 1974.
Upon State Reorganisation, effective from 09.11.2000,
petitioners became employees of Uttarakhand Forest
UKHC010173732022
2026:UHC:7196-DB
Development Corporation. Petitioners, who retired from
Uttarakhand
Forest
Development
Corporation
have
challenged Government Order dated 30.12.2016 insofar
as it has fixed a cap regarding the amount payable as
gratuity. The said Government Order, which is issued in
respect of State employees, provides that maximum
amount, which can be paid as death-cum-retirement
gratuity, would be Rs. 20 lacs.
5.
Petitioners contend that the ceiling imposed by
State Government regarding amount of gratuity is unjust
and
unreasonable.
It
is
further
contended
that
petitioners are protected by proviso to Section 74(1) of
U.P. Reorganisation Act, 2000, therefore, their service
conditions cannot be altered without previous approval of
the Central Government and Central Government has not
approved
the
impugned
decision
taken
by
the
Uttarakhand Government. It is further contended on
behalf of the petitioners that impugned decision taken by
the State Government, is violative of Section 69 of U.P.
Reorganisation Act also. Section 74(1) and Section 69 of
U.P. Reorganisation Act, on which reliance is placed by
petitioners’ counsel, are reproduced below for ready
reference:“74. Other provisions relating to services.—(1)
Nothing in this section or in section 73 shall be deemed
to affect on or after the appointed day, the operation of
the provisions of Chapter I of Part XIV of the
Constitution in relation to determination of the
conditions of service of persons serving in connection
with the affairs of the Union or any State:
Provided that the conditions of service applicable
immediately before the appointed day in the case of any
person deemed to have been allocated to the State of
Uttar Pradesh or to the State of Uttaranchal under
Section 73 shall not be varied to his disadvantage
except with the previous approval of the Central
Government.
UKHC010173732022
2026:UHC:7196-DB
69. Special provisions relating to retrenchment
compensation in certain cases.—Where on account
of the reorganisation of the existing State of Uttar
Pradesh under this Act, any body corporate constituted
under a Central Act, State Act or Provincial Act, any cooperative society registered under any law relating to
co-operative societies or any commercial or industrial
undertaking of that State is reconstituted or reorganised
in any manner whatsoever or is amalgamated with any
other
body
corporate,
co-operative
society
or
undertaking, or is dissolved, and in consequence of
such reconstitution, reorganisation, amalgamation or
dissolution, any workman employed by such body
corporate or in any such co-operative society or
undertaking, is transferred to, or re-employed by, any
other body corporate, or in any other co-operative
society or undertaking, then, notwithstanding anything
contained in section 25-F or section 25-FF or section 25FFF of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 (14 of 1947),
such transfer or re-employment shall not entitle him to
any compensation under that section:
Provided that—
(a) the terms and conditions of service applicable to the
workman after such transfer or re-employment are not
less favourable to the workman than those applicable to
him immediately before the transfer or re-employment;
(b) the employer in relation to the body corporate, the cooperative society or the undertaking where the
workman transferred or re-employed is, by agreement
or otherwise, legally liable to pay to the workman, in the
event of his retrenchment, compensation under section
25-F or section 25-FF or section 25-FFF of the Industrial
Disputes Act, 1947 (14 of 1947) on the basis that his
service has been continuous and has not been
interrupted by the transfer or re-employment.”
6.
Learned State Counsel submits that Section 74
is contained in Part-VIII of U.P. Reorganisation Act, 2000,
which is applicable only to persons who are serving in
connection with the affairs of the Union or any State and
whose service conditions are governed by the Rules
framed under proviso to Article 309 of the Constitution of
India. He submits that petitioners on the other hand,
were appointed in a statutory Corporation established
under U.P. Forest Corporation Act, 1974 and they retired
from a statutory Corporation established under the same
Act and they never enjoyed the status of a Government
servant, therefore, Section 74(1) of U.P. Reorganisation
Act is not applicable to them. He further submits that the
UKHC010173732022
2026:UHC:7196-DB
cap fixed by Government Order dated 30.12.2016 does
not amount to alteration in the service conditions of the
petitioners to their disadvantage, therefore, the challenge
to the said Government Order by the petitioners, is
without
any
substance.
He
further
submits
that
conditions of service can be, said to be varied to the
disadvantage of an employee, if he is divested of a benefit,
which was assured to be given to him by mentioning in
the appointment order or in the Service Rules/Standing
Orders. He submits that there is no averment in the
entire writ petition regarding any assurance given to
petitioners in respect of the amount payable as gratuity.
He further submits that the State Government has taken
a informed policy decision having regard to various
aspects and the policy decision of the Government is
interfereble only if it is in violation of any law. He further
submits that Section 69 of U.P. Reorganisation Act is also
not attracted in the case of the petitioners.
7.
Learned counsel appearing for Uttarakhand Forest
Development Corporation, by referring to the counter
affidavit dated 09.05.2023 filed by Mr. Mahesh Chandra
Arya, Regional Manager, Kumaon, submits that it is not
the first time that the cap was fixed on the amount
payable as gratuity. He submits that earlier the cap was
fixed at Rs. 3.5 lacs, which was increased to Rs. 10 lacs
vide Government Order dated 27.10.2008. He further
submits that by the impugned Government Order,
cap on the amount payable as gratuity was increased
from Rs. 10 lacs to 20 lacs. Thus, he submits that
decision taken by the State Government, as contained in
Government Order dated 30.12.2016 is beneficial for the
employees, as they can get gratuity upto Rs. 20 lacs as
against Rs. 10 lacs, which was admissible as per the
earlier Government Order. He further submits that cap
was always fixed on the amount payable as gratuity;
petitioners never challenged the cap fixed by Government
Orders issued from time to time and they have challenged
UKHC010173732022
2026:UHC:7196-DB
the decision taken by State Government to raise the cap
from Rs. 10 lacs to 20 lacs only upon their retirement
from service. He also reiterates that protection of Section
74 is available only to persons, who are serving in
connection with the affairs of the Union or State.
8.
This Court do not find any reason to interfere
with the policy decision taken by the State Government,
as contained in Government Order dated 30.12.2016.
Interference with a policy decision is permissible only if it
violates any express provision of law. Since petitioners
were not serving in connection with the affairs of Union
or the State Government and their service conditions
were not governed by rules framed by State Government
under proviso to Article 309 of Constitution of India,
therefore,
reliance
upon
Section
of
U.P.
Reorganisation Act is clearly misplaced.
9.
Even otherwise also, in the absence of any
stipulation in the appointment order/service regulations
applicable to the petitioners that there will be no cap on
the amount, which can be paid as gratuity to them, the
decision taken by the State Government does not amount
to alteration in conditions of service of the petitioners.
10.
The counter affidavit filed by the employer of
petitioners reveals that there was always a cap on the
maximum amount payable as gratuity to Government
servants and by the impugned Government Order, that
cap was increased from Rs. 10 lacs to Rs. 20 lacs.
11.
This Court finds substance in the contention
raised by learned State Counsel that silence on the part
of
the
petitioners
all
these
years,
even
though
Government Orders, earlier issued from time to time
provided a ceiling on the amount payable as gratuity,
amounts to acquiescence and petitioners cannot now be
permitted to turn around to challenge the decision taken
by State Government in 2016, whereby maximum limit of
gratuity was increased from Rs. 10 lacs to Rs. 20 lacs.
UKHC010173732022
2026:UHC:7196-DB
Section 69 of U.P. Reorganisation Act is also not attracted
to the case in hand, as petitioners retired from the post of
Regional Manager or other equivalent executive positions
in Uttarakhand Forest Development Corporation while
Section 69 protects only the workman of a body
corporate,
cooperative
society
or
Government
undertaking. Section 69 provides that if on account of
Reorganisation of the existing State of Uttar Pradesh, any
body
corporate,
commercial/industrial
cooperative
undertaking
of
society
or
the
is
State
reconstituted/ amalgamated/ dissolved and the workman
employed in such body corporate, cooperative society or
undertaking is transferred to or re-employed by any other
body corporate, then notwithstanding anything contained
in relevant provisions of Industrial Disputes Act, 1947,
such transfer or reemployment shall not entitle the
workman to any compensation.
12.
Even otherwise also, Section 69 is meant to
deal with different contingency, which was never faced by
petitioners and there was no occasion for paying
retrenchment compensation to them.
13.
This Court is of the considered opinion that the
cap fixed by State Government by impugned Government
Order does not amount to alteration in conditions of
service of the petitioners to their disadvantage as such
cap was fixed in Government Orders issued from time to
time earlier also. Moreover, benefit of Section 74 is
available only to State employees; while, petitioners are
not the State employees.
14.
Thus, there is no scope for interference in the
matter. The writ petition fails and is dismissed.
(Pankaj Purohit, J.)
(Manoj Kumar Tiwari, J.)
13.08.2026
Navin
NAVEEN CHANDRA
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND, ou=HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND,
2.5.4.20=3be23325146e76a0642bdf4943fb9046f487df006da82a131bb4e4403d3c0a1
5, postalCode=263001, st=UTTARAKHAND,
serialNumber=18167EEFB5CA8CFFD421A103819DA875643AF56D653D095C6ED9A86
DAAB21CE5, cn=NAVEEN CHANDRA
Date: 2026.08.14 17:15:47 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review