The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
46. On consideration of the various judicial pronouncements and on the basis of the dominant view taken in these decisions on the rights and liabilities of the co-sharers and their rights to raise construction to the exclusion of others, the following principles can conveniently be laid down:i) a co-owner is not entitled to an injunction restraining another co-owner from exceeding his rights in the common property absolutely and simply because he is a co-owner unless any act of the person in possession of the property amounts to ouster prejudicial or adverse to the interest of the co-owner out of possession. ii) Mere making of construction or improvement of, in, the common property does not amount to ouster. (iii) If by the act of the co-owner in possession the value or utility of the property is diminished, then a co-owner out of possession can certainly seek an injunction to prevent the diminution of the value and utility of the property. (iv) If the acts of the co-owner in possession are detrimental to the interest of other co-owners, a co-owner out of possession can seek an injunction to prevent such act which is detrimental to his interest. (v) before an injunction is issued, the plaintiff has to establish that he would sustain, by the act he complains of some injury which materially would affect his position or his enjoyment or an accustomed user of the joint property would b…
47. The discretion of the Court is exercised to grant a temporary injunction only when the following requirements are made out by the plaintiff :(i) existence of a prima facie case as pleaded, necessitating protection of the plaintiff’s rights by issue of a temporary injunction; (ii) when the need for protection of the plaintiff’s rights is compared with or weighed against the need for protection of the defendant’s right or likely infringement of the defendant’s rights, the balance of convenience tilting in favour of the plaintiff; and (iii) clear possibility of irreparable injury being caused to the plaintiff if the temporary injunction is not granted. In addition, temporary injunction being an equitable relief, the discretion to grant such relief will be exercised only when the plaintiff’s conduct is free from blame and he approaches the Court with clean hands.” In Ajay Kumar Vs. Ishwar Dutt4, it was held that when a co-sharer himself raises a construction over the joint land, when a cosharer does not object to raising of construction over the joint land by some other co-owners, then, he cannot seek to restrain one specific co-owner from raising construction over part of suit land, CMPMO No. 555 of 2018, decided on 03.09.2021. ( 2026:HHC:48483 ) more so, when the construction being raised by that particular coowner is over a portion, which, as per the revenue record, is in his po…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
( 2026:HHC:48483 )
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH SHIMLA
CMPMO No. 647 of 2026.
Decided on : 3rd November, 2026
Jagat Ram
...Petitioner.
Versus
Heeru Ram
....Respondent.
Coram:
Ms. Justice Jyotsna Rewal Dua, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?1
For the Petitioner:
Mr. Sudheer Thakur, Senior Advocate
with Mr. Karun Negi, Advocate.
For the respondent:
Nemo.
Jyotsna Rewal Dua, Judge.
A civil suit was instituted by the petitioner under Sections
38 and 39 of the Specific Relief Act for permanent prohibitory
and
mandatory injunction against the respondent/defendant. Along with the
civil suit, an application under Order 39, Rules 1 and 2 of Civil Procedure
Code (CPC) for temporary injunction was also moved. The application was
allowed by the learned Trial Court on 12.05.2026 by directing the parties
to maintain status quo qua nature, possession and construction over the
suit land. The respondent/defendant’s appeal against the aforesaid order
was allowed by the learned District Judge on 27.10.2026, thereby
dismissing the application moved by the petitioner/plaintiff under Order
Whether reporters of the local papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
( 2026:HHC:48483 )
39, Rules 1 and 2 read with Section 151 CPC.
Feeling aggrieved, the
plaintiff has taken recourse to this petition.
2.
In the application moved under Order 39, Rules 1 and 2,
read with Section 151 CPC, the petitioner inter-alia claimed that: (i) Suit
land comprised in khata/khatauni number 49 min/57 min, khasra number
579/78, measuring 00-15 -05 Bigha, situated at Mauza Jadla, Hadbast No.
446, Up-Tehsil Krishangarh, District Solan, was joint amongst the
petitioner, respondent and other co-sharers; it had not been partitioned
by metes and bounds. (ii) Respondent/defendant had already constructed
his house over part of the suit land. He, thereafter, had started digging
the vacant portion/common courtyard over the suit land by raising pillars
for fresh construction. The courtyard/common vacant land had been
continuously used by the parties for family functions/common ingress and
egress to their respective houses. (iii) No co-sharer had any right to raise
construction over any portion of the joint land without the consent of the
other
co-sharers
and
without
lawful
partition.
(iv)
Despite
petitioner/plaintiff's repeated requests, the respondent/defendant had
continued with the construction.
The stand taken by the respondent/defendant was that:
(i) Suit land was jointly owned by the parties in the revenue records; all
three co-sharers of the suit land i.e. petitioner, respondent and one other
( 2026:HHC:48483 )
co-sharer, namely, Shyam Lal were owners in equal shares of 5 biswas
each. They were in separate and specific possession on the spot pursuant
to an oral/private partition amongst themselves. (ii) The petitioner/plaintiff
had already occupied more than his share over the suit land by raising
construction and fencing a courtyard over the joint land. The petitioner
had covered land measuring 6 biswa 6 biswansi i.e. more than his share of
5 biswas. Whereas, respondent/defendant was in possession of only 3
biswa 6 biswansi out of his total 5 biswas of share and out of that portion
in possession of the respondent, he had raised construction over land
measuring 1 biswa, 2 biswansi only. (iii) Respondent's stand was that open
land was in front of his house where he was raising construction; it had
been in his possession and within his share. He denied the same being a
common courtyard as alleged by the petitioner/plaintiff. (iv) The
respondent/defendant also relied upon a map and tatima prepared by
one Shri Gurmail Singh, a registered Civil Draftsman. As per the
respondent, in terms of this site plan prepared on the spot, the map
depicted the respective possession of all the co-sharers; the place where
the construction was being raised fell within the possession of the
respondent/defendant.
Respondent/defendant
also
urged
that
continuation of the ad-interim order granted by the learned Trial Court on
02.04.2026 was causing irreparable loss and injury to him.
( 2026:HHC:48483 )
3.
Learned Trial Court, after taking into consideration the
respective stand of the parties, allowed the application by confirming the
ad-interim order dated 02.04.2026, directing the parties to maintain status
quo regarding nature, possession and construction over the suit property
vide order dated 12.05.2026. While allowing the application, learned Trial
Court held that the photographs placed on record along with the
application
demonstrated
excavation
activity
at
the
spot;
the
respondent/defendant's admission that he intended to raise construction
on the spot was also kept in view. It was then held that in case respondent
was permitted to raise construction over the disputed portion, the same
would change the nature of the property and may further complicate their
rights, which may result in multiplicity of proceedings and creation of
complications regarding possession and equities.
Respondent/defendant’s appeal against the aforesaid
order has been allowed by the learned District Judge on 27.10.2026.
In the above background, the petitioner/plaintiff has come
up in this petition against the order dated 27.10.2026 passed by the
learned District Judge.
4.
Heard and considered the case file.
( 2026:HHC:48483 )
4(i).
It will be appropriate to notice the legal position applicable
to the issue involved in this petition:-
Payar Singh Vs. Narayan Dass and others2, the
In
respondents pleaded themselves to be in settled separate
possession of joint land in family partition over which they were
raising construction. They also took up a stand that petitioner had
also constructed his house over the land in his possession. The Court
upheld the contentions of the respondents. Following observations
made in the judgment are material :“12. The respondents in the written statement have specifically pleaded
that
parties
are
in
separate
possession
under
family
arrangement. The petitioner has also constructed his house on
the joint land. It is not the stand of the petitioner that respondents
are raising construction on an area which is more than their
share. The case of the respondents is that petitioner has
constructed his house on a better portion of the land. The under
construction house of the respondents is away from the National
Highway 21 whereas the house of the petitioner abuts N. H.21.
The respondents have placed on record on the file of revision
photographs construction of under construction house of the
respondents. The photographs indicate sufficient gap between the
already constructed house of petitioner and under construction
house of the respondents over which even slab has been placed. It
is the case of the respondents in written statement that they are in
(2010)3 Shimla L. C. 205
( 2026:HHC:48483 )
separate possession of the land in family arrangement. This fact
has not been denied by filing replication. The respondents are
claiming possession over the suit land under family arrangement
i.e. with the consent of the petitioner over which they are raising
construction. The respondents have thus established prima facie
case, balance of convenience, irreparable loss in their favour. In
these circumstances, no fault can be found with the impugned
judgment. In revision the scope is limited as held in The Managing
Director (MIG) Hindustan Aeronautics Ltd. Balanagar, Hyderabad
and another Vs. Ajit Prasad Tarway, Manager (Purchase and
Stores) Hindustan Aeronautics Ltd. Balanagar, Hyderabad, AIR
1973 SC 76. The suit is for permanent prohibitory and mandatory
injunction. The rights of the parties will be decided in the suit. It
has not been established that the view taken by the learned
District Judge does not emerge from the material on record.”
In Ashok Kapoor Vs. Murtu Devi3, following principles
were culled out after considering several judgments on the inter-se
rights and liabilities of co-sharers :“41. The exposition of law as enunciated in the various judgments
referred above including those of this High Court, insofar as the
rights and liabilities of the co-owners is concerned, gives rise to
the following propositions:1.
A co-owner has an interest in the whole property and also
in every parcel of it.
2.
Possession of joint property by one co-owner is in the eye
of law, possession of all even if all but one are actually out
of possession.
(2016)1 Shim. L.C. 207,
( 2026:HHC:48483 )
3.
A mere occupation of a larger portion or even of an entire
joint property does not necessarily amount to ouster as
the possession of one is deemed to be on behalf of all.
4.
The above rule admits of an exception when there is ouster
of a co-owner by another. But in order to negative the
presumption of joint possession on behalf of all, on the
ground of ouster, the possession of a co-owner must not
only be exclusive but also hostile to the knowledge of
either as, when a co-owner openly asserts his own title and
denies that of the other.
5.
Passage of time does not extinguish the right of the coowner who has been out of possession of the joint
property except in the event of ouster or abandonment.
6.
Every co-owner has a right to use the joint property in a
husband like manner not inconsistent with similar rights
of other co-owners.
7.
Where a co-owner is in possession of separate parcels
under an arrangement consented by the other co-owners,
it is not open to any body to dispute the arrangement
without the consent of others except by filing a suit for
partition.
8.
The remedy of a co-owner not in possession, or not in
possession of a share of the joint property, is by way of a
suit for partition or for actual joint possession, but not for
ejectment. Same is the case where a co-owner sets up an
exclusive title in himself.
9.
Where a portion of the joint property is, by common
consent of the co-owners, reserved for a particular
common purpose, it cannot be diverted to an inconsistent
user by a co-owner, if he does so, he is liable to be ejected
( 2026:HHC:48483 )
and the particular parcel will be liable to be restored to its
original condition. It is not necessary in such a case to
show that special damage has been suffered.
46. On consideration of the various judicial pronouncements and on
the basis of the dominant view taken in these decisions on the
rights and liabilities of the co-sharers and their rights to raise
construction to the exclusion of others, the following principles
can conveniently be laid down:i)
a co-owner is not entitled to an injunction restraining
another co-owner from exceeding his rights in the
common property absolutely and simply because he is a
co-owner unless any act of the person in possession of the
property amounts to ouster prejudicial or adverse to the
interest of the co-owner out of possession.
ii)
Mere making of construction or improvement of, in, the
common property does not amount to ouster.
(iii)
If by the act of the co-owner in possession the value or
utility of the property is diminished, then a co-owner out of
possession can certainly seek an injunction to prevent the
diminution of the value and utility of the property.
(iv)
If the acts of the co-owner in possession are detrimental to
the interest of other co-owners, a co-owner out of
possession can seek an injunction to prevent such act
which is detrimental to his interest.
(v)
before an injunction is issued, the plaintiff has to establish
that he would sustain, by the act he complains of some
injury which materially would affect his position or his
enjoyment or an accustomed user of the joint property
would be inconvenienced or interfered with.
( 2026:HHC:48483 )
(vi)
the question as to what relief should be granted is left to
the discretion of the Court in the attending circumstances
on the balance of convenience and in exercise of its
discretion the Court will be guided by consideration of
justice, equity and good conscience.
47.
The discretion of the Court is exercised to grant a temporary
injunction only when the following requirements are made out by
the plaintiff :(i)
existence of a prima facie case as pleaded, necessitating
protection of the plaintiff’s rights by issue of a temporary
injunction;
(ii)
when the need for protection of the plaintiff’s rights is
compared with or weighed against the need for protection
of the defendant’s right or likely infringement of the
defendant’s rights, the balance of convenience tilting in
favour of the plaintiff; and
(iii)
clear possibility of irreparable injury being caused to the
plaintiff if the temporary injunction is not granted. In
addition, temporary injunction being an equitable relief,
the discretion to grant such relief will be exercised only
when the plaintiff’s conduct is free from blame and he
approaches the Court with clean hands.”
In Ajay Kumar Vs. Ishwar Dutt4, it was held that when a
co-sharer himself raises a construction over the joint land, when a cosharer does not object to raising of construction over the joint land
by some other co-owners, then, he cannot seek to restrain one
specific co-owner from raising construction over part of suit land,
CMPMO No. 555 of 2018, decided on 03.09.2021.
( 2026:HHC:48483 )
more so, when the construction being raised by that particular coowner is over a portion, which, as per the revenue record, is in his
possession alongwith others and when the plaintiff has not been
shown in possession of this specific portion of land.
Placing reliance upon various authorities, defendants in
Smt. Vyasa Devi Vs. Harish Kumar5 were permitted to undertake
construction inter-alia on the gro.und that the plaintiff had also
carried out construction on the joint land. Material observations
made by the Court on facts are as under :“10. The facts involved in the case have been narrated by me
hereinabove and the same are not being repeated for the sake of
brevity. It is not in dispute that the parties are co-sharers of the
suit land but the petitioners herein are recorded to be in
possession of the portion of the suit land in issue alongwith other
co-sharers. It is further not in dispute that the respondents herein
are not recorded to be in possession of the suit land. It is also not
in dispute that the respondents herein have also carried out
construction activities by raising constructions over the joint land,
as is evident from the record. In these circumstances, this Court is
of the considered view that the petitioners herein, who besides
being the co-owners of the suit land are also recorded to be in
possession thereof, cannot be estopped from raising construction
pending the adjudication of the civil suit. It is settled law that
injunction cannot be granted against a co-sharer and further as
the respondents herein themselves have constructed their houses
over the joint suit land, in these circumstances, they cannot be
permitted to restrain other co-sharers, i.e. present petitioners,
from doing so. The construction, which is being carried out by the
petitioners, however obviously shall be subject to the final
CMPMO No. 77 of 2021 decided on 22.12.2021.
( 2026:HHC:48483 )
adjudication of the suit as also partition proceedings, if any, and
if the area upon which construction being carried out by the
present petitioners ultimately falls in the share of the plaintiffs in
partition proceedings, then, of course, consequences will ensue.
However, this does not means that till the suit land is partitioned,
the petitioners herein should be restrained from raising
construction over the parcel of the suit land in their possession.”
Chanchal Kumar Vs. Prem Parkash & Anr.6 was a case
where plaintiff was one of the co-sharers over the suit land. He raised
construction and filed suit for prohibitory injunction to restrain the
respondents from raising construction on the vacant portion of land. The
Court held that :“…..Once, plaintiff himself raised construction over one portion of
the land, it is not understood, how he could raise objection, if any,
qua the construction on the other portion of land, by the
defendants, who are admittedly co-owners of suit land to the
extent of one half share. Needless to say, applicant, while seeking
relief of injunction is required to show that he/she has a prima
facie case in his/her favour and balance of convenience also lies
in his/her favour, but, in the instant case, aforesaid basic
ingredients/conditions are totally missing, rather, very conduct of
the plaintiff suggests that he wants to take advantage of the
situation.”
4(ii).
Learned District Judge has categorically observed that
plaintiff had admitted in his rejoinder about the suit land having been
orally partitioned on the spot and all co-sharers being in specific
possession of their respective portions. I have gone through the rejoinder
which has been appended herewith as Annexure P-8, wherein the plaintiff
CMPMO No. 522 of 2016, decided on 29.11.2018.
( 2026:HHC:48483 )
pleads that “It is admitted to the extent that on the spot the suit land has been
orally partitioned and all the co-sharers are in their specific possession on the
spot.” The learned Appellate Court has justly held that though such an
arrangement would not necessarily establish a legally effected partition by
metes and bounds, however, it is a material circumstance for determining
actual possession of the parties and their entitlement to interlocutory
relief. Intrinsically related is the construction admittedly carried out by the
petitioner/plaintiff
over
the
suit
land
(joint
property).
The
respondent/defendant has pleaded that petitioner/plaintiff occupies
approximately 6 biswa 3 biswansi against his share of 5 biswas. Learned
District Judge has further held that the site plan produced by the plaintiff
depicts an enclosed portion marked B-1, measuring 93.22 sq. m. Though,
this would be required to be proved in evidence in accordance with law,
the existence of separate residential houses over different portions of suit
land has not been disputed by the petitioner/plaintiff and has justly been
taken into consideration by the Appellate Court. As against the plaintiff's
construction and occupation over 6 biswa 3 biswansi of suit land, the
respondent/defendant claims to be in possession of 3 biswa 6 biswansi. As
per the respondent/defendant, he has constructed upon 1 biswa 2
biswansi and possesses a vacant portion measuring 2 biswa 4 biswansi in
front of his house. His total share comes to 5 biswas.
The
( 2026:HHC:48483 )
respondent/defendant had prima facie substantiated his plea by placing
on record tatima and site plan prepared after spot measurements by a
registered Draftsman. Though, these documents are also required to be
proved in accordance with law, the learned District Judge justly gave them
due credence vis-a-vis plaintiff's own admission regarding separate
possession of the parties over the suit property.
4(iii).
It is well settled that there is no prohibition against
construction by a co-sharer over the joint land. The important factor that
needs to be considered in that situation is whether the proposed
construction would interfere with the settled possession of the co-sharers,
their lawful rights, whether that would diminish the utility of the property,
or any prejudice will be caused to the co-sharers. Plaintiff has already
raised construction over his share in the suit land. He has admitted
separate possession of the parties. His assertion that construction
intended to be raised by the respondent/defendant is over a common
courtyard or passage is not demonstrated. Prima facie case does not exist
in favor of the petitioner/plaintiff. There is nothing on record to establish
that construction will obstruct plaintiff's access and disturb his settled
possession or will prejudice his rights. Learned Appellate Court has justly
given due credence to the plaintiff's conduct, having himself raised
construction over joint land and occupied a separate portion, which
( 2026:HHC:48483 )
according to the respondent/defendant, is much more than plaintiff's
share in the joint land. Plaintiff cannot, without demonstrating
corresponding
prejudice,
seek
to
prohibit
the
defendant
from
constructing upon the portion as per his share. Balance of convenience is
also not in favor of the plaintiff.
5.
In view of the above, I do not find it to be a case requiring
interference with the impugned order passed by the learned District
Judge. Accordingly, the instant petition is dismissed. It is however clarified
that observations made above shall remain confined to the adjudication of
this petition and shall not be construed as an opinion on the merits of the
matter as also shall have no bearings whatsoever on the orders that may
be passed in the partition proceedings statedly pending between the
parties.
Jyotsna Rewal Dua
Judge
3rd November, 2026.
(jai)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review