Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
$~J* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Judgment delivered on: 23.07.2026
+
W.P.(C) 9014/2011
JAGANNATH TIKARAM MAHAVAR
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Hrishikesh Baruah with Mr.
Utkarsh Dwivedi, Mr. Kumar Kshitij
and Mr. Anurag Mishra, Advocates.
versus
OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LTD AND ANR
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Chetan Sharma, ASG with Mr. S.
Sirish Kumar, Mr. Amit Gupta, Mr.
R.V. Prabhat, Mr. Vinay Yadav, Mr.
Shubham Sharma, Mr. Naman and Mr.
Vikram Aditya Singh, Advocates for
R-1.
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANUP JAIRAM BHAMBHANI
J U D G M E N T
ANUP JAIRAM BHAMBHANI J.
By way of the present writ petition filed under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India, the petitioner inter-alia seeks issuance of the writ
of mandamus, directing the respondent No.1 corporation to notionally
promote the petitioner to the post of Group General Manager of
respondent No.1 corporation with effect from 02.01.2003 and grant to the
petitioner all consequential benefits arising therefrom.
2.
Notice on this petition was issued on 23.12.2011; pursuant to which
counter-affidavit dated 21.09.2012 was filed by respondent No.1
corporation. Since respondent No.2 is a pro-forma party, no pleadings
Signed By:VIKAS
RAWAT
Signing
Date:23.07.2026 14:34
W.P.(C) 9014/2011
on its behalf were required. Rejoinder dated 04.03.2013 was also filed
by the petitioner. Written submissions have also been filed on behalf of
both contesting parties.
3.
The court has heard Mr. Hrishikesh Baruah, learned counsel appearing
for the petitioner; as well as Mr. Chetan Sharma, learned Additional
Solicitor General appearing for respondent No.1 corporation, at length.
BRIEF FACTS
4.
The brief factual background necessary for deciding the present petition
is set-out below:
4.1.
The petitioner was working with respondent No.1 corporation
since 14.07.1975 as an Assistant Engineer (Mechanical) (E-1
level) and was promoted to the post of General Manager
(Mechanical) (E-7 level) with effect from 01.01.1997.
4.2.
The next promotion for the petitioner was to the post of Group
General Manager (E-8 level).
4.3.
The Board Sub-Committee on Departmental Promotions of
respondent No.1 (‘Board Sub-Committee’), also called the
Departmental Promotion Committee or ‘DPC’, convened on
11.12.2002 and 26.12.2002 to empanel candidates for the post of
Executive Directors/Group General Managers. On 26.12.2002,
the Executive Committee of respondent No.1 held a meeting and
decided the postings of 25 candidates out a total of 31 empaneled
candidates. However, the petitioner, along with 5 others, was not
promoted to the post of Group General Manager.
4.4.
Subsequently however, on 10.03.2006, the petitioner was
promoted to the post of Group General Manager (E-8 level).
Signed By:VIKAS
RAWAT
Signing
Date:23.07.2026 14:34
W.P.(C) 9014/2011
4.5.
The petitioner’s essential grievance is that he ought to have been
promoted on 02.01.2003; and is accordingly seeking notional
promotion w.e.f. 02.01.2003 and all consequential benefits arising
therefrom.
4.6.
Despite repeated representations to various authorities, the
petitioner’s grievance of alleged wrongful delay in granting him
promotion was not addressed by the requisite authorities, leading
to the filing of the present petition.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE PETITIONER
5.
In the above backdrop, Mr. Hrishikesh Baruah, learned counsel
appearing for the petitioner has made the following essential
submissions:
5.1.
It has been submitted that the petitioner has had a successful
career, being regularly promoted at the first opportunity; and has
even been awarded by respondent No.1 corporation for his
performance in the course of his tenure.
5.2.
Placing reliance on the Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited
Modified
Recruitment
&
Promotion
Regulations,
(‘Regulations’), learned counsel has submitted that Regulation
7(1) thereof envisages the constitution of a ‘Promotion
Committee’ responsible for considering all cases relating to
promotions. It has been pointed-out that Regulation 7(6) provides
that the promotion committee must submit recommendations on
the basis of ‘merit’ (where the criterion for promotion is merit)
and ‘seniority’ (where the criterion for promotion is senioritycum-fitness); and Regulation 7(7) empowers the Appointing
Signed By:VIKAS
RAWAT
Signing
Date:23.07.2026 14:34
W.P.(C) 9014/2011
Authority to consider the recommendations made by the
promotion committee and pass orders as per the authority’s
discretion. It has been submitted that in case the Appointing
Authority does not accept the recommendations made by the
promotion committee, the Appointing Authority is required to
record the reasons for its decision in writing. Counsel has further
relied upon Regulations 7(8), 7(11) and 7(25)(a), which also
govern the process of promotion.
5.3.
It has been submitted that the proposed criteria for selection of
Executive Directors/Group General Managers was, that first a
‘Preliminary Eligible list’ was to be prepared in order of merit, for
consideration of candidates for the post. The preliminary eligible
list would comprise of the names of individuals who score at least
70% of a maximum of 30 marks i.e., 21 marks; which list would
then be put-up before the Board for approval. Thereafter, the
Executive Committee would rate the candidates in the preliminary
eligible list on a 3-point scale, and after taking an average of 10
attributes set-out in a list, a ‘final eligible list’ was to be prepared.
This final eligible list of candidates, as recommended by the
Executive Committee, was to be then placed before the
Departmental Promotion Committee (‘DPC’) final consideration
and selection.
5.4.
It is the petitioner’s case that this stage-wise process was not
followed by respondent No.1 corporation. It has been argued that
after the preliminary eligible list, a final eligible list is required to
be prepared, which renders the preliminary list irrelevant; and that
Signed By:VIKAS
RAWAT
Signing
Date:23.07.2026 14:34
W.P.(C) 9014/2011
therefore, the reliance placed by respondent No.1 on the
‘preliminary eligible list’ as the ‘merit list’ is completely
misconceived.
5.5.
It has been submitted that as recorded in the meeting of the Board
Sub-Committee, the DPC gave their final recommendations on
11.12.2002 and 26.12.2002; and in the said recommendation list,
the petitioner’s name appeared at Serial No. 3 in the category of
Group General Manager (E-8 level). Therefore, it is the
petitioner’s contention, that as per the ‘merit list’ prepared in
terms of the recruitment rules, the petitioner’s name was at Serial
No. 3 as per his merit. It is further asserted, that as per Regulation
7(7),
the
Appointing
Authority
has
to
consider
the
recommendations of the DPC. It is the petitioner’s submission,
that in the present case, the DPC recommendations were duly
approved by the Chairman & Managing Director of respondent
No.1 corporation (‘CMD’ or ‘CMD-ONGC’); which in turn
implies that the petitioner’s position at Serial No. 3 of the merit
list was duly recommended and approved by the Appointing
Authority.
5.6.
It has been argued that on 02.01.2003 the Executive Committee of
respondent No.1 (which, according to the petitioner, is neither the
DPC
nor
the
Appointing
Authority)
issued
an
order
communicating the postings and assignments of persons who were
on the merit list; but no promotion or posting order was given to
the petitioner despite the fact that the petitioner was at Serial No.3
on the merit list and a total of 29 other individuals were promoted
Signed By:VIKAS
RAWAT
Signing
Date:23.07.2026 14:34
W.P.(C) 9014/2011
and assigned to various posts. According to the petitioner, of these
29 individuals, 23 were junior to him. It has been vehemently
argued, that this was in complete violation of the recruitment
rules; and therefore, aggrieved by this action, the petitioner made
several representations to the higher authorities from 12.02.2005
onwards.
5.7.
It has further been argued, that the Executive Committee could not
have subverted the recommendations of the DPC; and since the
Appointing Authority had accepted the recommendations of the
DPC,
the
Executive
Committee
was
bound
to
issue
promotion/assignment orders in terms of the recommendation
made by the DPC as approved by the Appointing Authority.
Relying on Union of India & Ors vs. Sangram Keshari Nayak 1,
it has been submitted that a person whose promotion has been
approved has a right to be promoted in terms of the merit list. It
has been further submitted that any digression from that principle
reflects favouritism and discriminatory behaviour, and moreover,
it was not within the remit of the Executive Committee to negate
a duly approved promotion. It has been further argued, that the act
of not promoting the petitioner resulted in hostile discrimination
against him, which is violative of his rights guaranteed under Part
III of the Constitution of India, as held in Major General H. M.
Singh, VSM vs. Union of India and Anr.2. Emphasis has also
been placed on Rule 19B(iii)(a) of the Oil and Natural Gas
(2007) 6 SCC 704, para 12
(2014) 3 SCC 670, paras 22 & 25
Signed By:VIKAS
RAWAT
Signing
Date:23.07.2026 14:34
W.P.(C) 9014/2011
Corporation Limited Service Rules, 1995 (‘Service Rules’), to
submit that the said rule specifies that the DPC shall prepare a list
on the basis of merit; and that promotions can only be made from
such list in the order in which the names have been arranged.
5.8.
It has been submitted that since the petitioner belongs to a
Scheduled Caste, aggrieved by the aforesaid action, vidé letter
dated 27.01.2006 the petitioner approached the National
Commission for Scheduled Castes (‘NCSC’) with his grievance.
Referring to the Minutes of the Meeting dated 11.11.2008, it has
been pointed-out that upon considering the petitioner’s grievance,
Chairman NCSC questioned the CMD-ONGC and Director (HR)
about the case and recorded the following observations:
“5. After having the submission by the petitioner, the
Hon’ble Chairman in his chamber asked the CMD-ONGC
and Director (HR), ONGC about the case. The petitioner
handed over a copy of his complete case papers to CMDONGC. The Chairman asked the CMD-ONGC that while in
January 2007 officials from ONGC had shown other
documents to Commission instead of original proceedings
where different facts are revealed. CMD-ONGC submitted
that promotion were made on the basis of relative marks and
since Shri Mahavar scored low marks; he could not be given
promotion.
“6. Petitioner submitted that DPC once approved,
promotions are to be given in the order of names in the panel.
He submitted that ONGC Service Rules, Promotion
Regulations and Govt. instructions on DPC promotion which
are also adopted in ONGC promotion regulation mandate
that promotion are to made from the panel prepared by DPC
in the same order. Hon’ble Chairman observed that it is
apparent that wrong has been done by ONGC and desired
ONGC to take corrective action to rectify it. The CMD-
Signed By:VIKAS
RAWAT
Signing
Date:23.07.2026 14:34
W.P.(C) 9014/2011
ONGC promptly agreed and assured that it will be done
today itself i.e. on 11-11-08. Shri Mahavar was advised to
meet and apprise his case to CMD as per the convenience of
the CMD, ONGC.”
5.9.
(emphasis supplied)
In light of the above, it has been submitted that the NCSC had
recommended that respondent No.1 must rectify its impugned
actions, and the CMD-ONGC had agreed to do so promptly. It has
been submitted however, that despite the assurance given by the
CMD-ONGC to the Chairman NCSC, no action was taken to
remedy the wrong done to the petitioner. Subsequently, the
Chairman of the NCSC changed, whereupon respondent No.1
shifted its stand; and vidé letter dated 17.11.2008 addressed by
respondent No.1 corporation to the section officer of NCSC, they
took the stand that pursuant to the meeting held on 11.11.2008,
the petitioner was given a patient hearing and that the petitioner
“was apparently satisfied with management view” and that the
case may be treated as settled.
5.10. It has been argued, that subsequent to the aforementioned letter
dated 17.11.2008 sent by respondent No.1, the petitioner made a
representation dated 08.07.2009 to respondent No.1 vehemently
denying the apparent settlement mentioned in that letter,
reiterating that the petitioner was not satisfied by the
management’s view and that no corrective action had been taken
by respondent No.1.
Signed By:VIKAS
RAWAT
Signing
Date:23.07.2026 14:34
W.P.(C) 9014/2011
5.11. Relying on State Bank of India vs. The National Commission for
Scheduled Castes and Ors. 3 , it has been submitted that a Coordinate Bench of this court has held that the recommendations
made by NCSC should not be ignored.
5.12. It has been further submitted, that curiously, thereafter the NCSC
also ‘reviewed’ its own decision, and in an order recorded at the
proceedings held on 01.11.2011 the NCSC closed the matter
noting that “… no deviation of rules was reported. Hence the
matter is closed”. Relying on IIT, Delhi vs. National Commission
for SC & ST & Anr. 4, it has been argued that the NCSC has no
power to review its own decision in terms of Article 338(8) of the
Constitution of India.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF RESPONDENT NO.1
6.
Contesting the writ petition, Mr. Chetan Sharma, learned Additional
Solicitor General appearing for respondent No.1 corporation has made
the following principal submissions:
6.1.
At the outset, it has been argued that the present petition is
infructuous, since the petitioner superannuated on 31.12.2011
from the post of Executive Director (E-9 level), which is the
highest post to which an executive can be promoted in respondent
No.1 corporation, and which post is just below the level of the
Board of Directors. The present petition has been described as
‘luxury litigation’ and an ‘academic exercise’.
2016 SCC OnLine Del 5217, para 12
2004 (74) DRJ 109, paras 13 & 18
Signed By:VIKAS
RAWAT
Signing
Date:23.07.2026 14:34
W.P.(C) 9014/2011
6.2.
It has further been argued, that as can be seen from the records,
the petition is also barred by gross delay and laches, which
disentitles the petitioner from claiming any relief under Article
226 of the Constitution of India. It has been submitted that vidé its
letter dated 21.12.2005, respondent No.1 had declined the
petitioner’s representation dated 12.02.2005; and that therefore,
any alleged cause of action had arisen on that date i.e., 21.12.2005;
however, the petitioner chose to approach this court only in 2011,
for which reason the present petition should be held as being
barred by delay and laches.
6.3.
Additionally, it has been submitted that the petitioner had already
availed an equally efficacious alternative remedy by filing a
complaint on identical facts before the NCSC on 27.01.2006,
seeking the same relief as in the present petition. It is pointed-out
that the said proceedings were concluded by the NCSC vidé
communication dated 15.03.2007 with the following finding:
“…… the action taken by the ONGC is in order and is
in the larger overall interest of the company and the Nation
and the ONGC has taken decision in accordance with the
prevailing policies and guidelines.”
6.4.
It has been submitted that owing to the aforesaid decision, vidé a
handwritten letter dated 01.06.2007 addressed to the Chairman
NCSC, the petitioner expressed that he had decided not to pursue
the case and to close his complaint, stating as follows:
“Sir,
I do not wish to follow up the case further & hence
further action in this case may be stopped/closed.”
Signed By:VIKAS
RAWAT
Signing
Date:23.07.2026 14:34
W.P.(C) 9014/2011
6.5.
It has been further submitted that thereafter, on the petitioner’s
insistence, the complaint was even re-opened by the NCSC on
06.10.2007; but after rehearing the case at length, the Chairman,
NCSC disposed-of the complaint vidé order dated 01.11.2011
opining that the promotions made at respondent No.1 in 2003:
“ … … have been made as per rules and no deviation
of rules was reported.”
6.6.
It has been argued that the petitioner is indulging in forumshopping, since the aforementioned order dated 01.11.2011 of the
NCSC has attained finality, and has not been challenged by the
petitioner even in the present petition. Furthermore, it has been
pointed-out that the present petition has been filed in the same
month in which the petitioner superannuated i.e., in December
2011.
6.7.
It has been further submitted that the petitioner is also disentitled
from getting any relief in the present proceedings since the
petitioner had lodged an FIR dated 04.04.2012 in Mumbai under
the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of
Atrocities) Act 1989, in which the allegations were substantially
identical to those in the present petition and in the complaint made
before the NCSC. It has been argued that the petitioner’s approach
of seeking parallel relief from different forums, through different
proceedings, also disentitles him from being granted any relief in
the present writ proceedings.
6.8.
Additionally, it has been submitted that the petition is liable to be
dismissed for the reason that the petitioner has failed to make the
Signed By:VIKAS
RAWAT
Signing
Date:23.07.2026 14:34
W.P.(C) 9014/2011
officers of respondent No.1 corporation who would be affected by
the decision, as party-respondents, thus denying them of the
opportunity of being heard; which is yet another ground for
dismissal of the present petition.
6.9.
It has been argued that even on merits, the petition is
misconceived and unsustainable, since no rule or regulation was
violated, nor has the petitioner been discriminated against in any
manner. It has been submitted that promotions are required to be
made at respondent No.1 corporation in terms of Rule 20(2) of the
Service Rules and the relevant provisions of the Regulations,
inter-alia Regulations 7(1), 7(4), 7(6), 7(7), 7(8) and 7(11)(iii) of
the Regulations which read as follows:
“ 7. Filling up of vacancies by promotion:
“(1) All promotions to posts shall be considered by
a Promotion Committee duly constituted by the
Appointing Authority in accordance with the orders
issued by the Corporation from time to time and it
shall consist of not less than three members.
*****
“(4) In cases where the criterion for promotion is
merit, the Promotion Committee, before selecting the
employees:
(a) shall consider the service records and
annual confidential reports;
(b) may hold a written examination or
practical test or interview or any combination
of these;
(c) Shall follow the procedure for determining
merit as laid down by the Corporation at least
two months in advance of the date of the said
selection.
*****
Signed By:VIKAS
RAWAT
Signing
Date:23.07.2026 14:34
W.P.(C) 9014/2011
“(6) The Promotion Committee shall submit its
recommendation to the appointing authority after
arranging the names in order of merit in cases where
merit is the criterion and in order of seniority in cases
where seniority-cum-fitness is the criterion.
“(7) The appointing authority shall consider the
recommendations of the Promotion Committee and
pass such orders as it thinks fit:
Provided that where the appointing authority does
not accept any recommendation of the Promotion
Committee, it shall record the reasons therefore in
writing.
“(8) After issue of promotion orders according to
the availability of vacancies, the names of remaining
candidates shall be kept in the list for further use to fill
up vacancies which may arise in future:
Provided that the period of validity of the said list
shall be six months from the date of its acceptance by
the appointing authority.
*****
“(11) The promotions will be carried out on the
following three criteria:*****
(iii)(b) Merit Promotion by Selection–Corporate
Promotions (E-5 level and above):
(1) The promotions at Corporate level (E-5 level
and above) are based on Merit and
quantification scheme.
(2) The marks awarded for quantification,
experience, PARs, and performance in the
interview.
(3) The qualifying marks are 60% in the interview
as well as overall for general candidates and 40%
for SC/ST candidates.”
(emphasis supplied)
Signed By:VIKAS
RAWAT
Signing
Date:23.07.2026 14:34
W.P.(C) 9014/2011
6.10. It has been submitted that in accordance with the above referred
scheme for promotions at respondent No.1, first, the Executive
Committee assesses the potential of the executives eligible for
occupying key positions; and based on this assessment and other
transparent criteria as prescribed, a list of qualifying candidates is
prepared and presented before the DPC. The DPC then makes its
recommendations; and the Executive Committee is authorised to
release a list of promotions against suitable vacant positions to
which the recommended executives may be posted in order of
merit. Accordingly, it is the Executive Committee that decides the
suitability of the empaneled candidates for promotion against
vacant positions from the list of recommendations made by the
DPC. It is argued that since these positions are at the senior-most
levels, particular care is exercised in filling these positions.
6.11. It has been further submitted that in its 92nd Meeting held on
30.05.2002, the Board of Directors of respondent No.1
corporation approved the criteria for selection for the post of
Executive Director (E-9 level) and Group General Manager (E-8
level), which criteria were adopted and applied in the meeting of
the Board Sub-committee or DPC held on 11.12.2002 and
26.12.2002 for empanelling candidates for the posts of Executive
Director and Group General Manager. It has been submitted that
in accordance with the laid-down criteria, the DPC decided that
even though the selected executives were being empaneled, their
promotions would be released by the Executive Committee
Signed By:VIKAS
RAWAT
Signing
Date:23.07.2026 14:34
W.P.(C) 9014/2011
subject to vacancies and suitability of the empaneled executives,
within the approved Corporate Rejuvenation Campaign structure.
6.12. It has been argued that for promotion to the post of Group General
Manager, two lists of preliminary eligible officers were prepared
and those names were considered by the DPC. Further, in the list
of preliminary eligible officers upto 01.01.1997, the officers who
had scored at least 70% of 30 (maximum) marks were included
for consideration for the post of Executive Director or Group
General Manager. This preliminary eligible list was drawn-up in
order of merit/ranking. It has been argued that the petitioner had
scored only the bare minimum of 21 marks specified for
consideration for promotion, which is why his name was at Serial
No. 43 in a list consisting of 46 candidates. Against 25 available
vacancies, the DPC recommended 31 candidates for empanelment
for the post of Group General Manager. It has been further argued
and clarified, that the list being referred to by the petitioner, in
which his name appears at Serial No. 3 was the list drawn-up in
order of seniority and not merit.
6.13. Furthermore, it has been argued that the executives empaneled by
the DPC for the post of Group General Manager were for the
composite requirement of all functional disciplines, like Geology,
Reservoir, Geophysics, Chemistry, Finance, Human Resources,
Mechanical Engineering, Drilling, Production etc., which require
varied competencies for each discipline. Hence, even though
several executives were empaneled for promotion, only those with
suitable competencies for the vacant positions were promoted,
Signed By:VIKAS
RAWAT
Signing
Date:23.07.2026 14:34
W.P.(C) 9014/2011
which can be substantiated by the empanelment of 31 executives
against 25 positions. It was also decided by the DPC, that while
the selected executives were being empaneled, promotions would
only be made subject to the availability of vacancies and
suitability of the executive as per specific assignments within the
approved Corporate Rejuvenation Campaign structure.
6.14. It has been further argued that the Executive Committee released
25 promotions to the E-8 level from the empaneled list, taking into
account the merit of the executives, and based on the marks/rank
secured. It is clarified that the petitioner belonged to the
mechanical engineering discipline, where the number of
recommended candidates exceeded the vacancies available for
that discipline. It has been submitted that there were 6 General
Managers from different disciplines, (including the petitioner’s
discipline), who could not be posted against the vacant posts and
remained on the panel in terms of Regulation 7(8).
6.15. It has been argued that since the petitioner, who was a mechanical
engineer, had secured only the minimum qualifying marks i.e., 21
marks, he was placed almost towards the bottom of the
preliminary eligible list; and all other executives who were
promoted in the mechanical engineering discipline had better
performance appraisal ratings than the petitioner, for which reason
they were promoted in accordance with Regulation 7(6).
6.16. It has been submitted, that for the aforementioned reasons the
petitioner could not be promoted in the year 2003.
Signed By:VIKAS
RAWAT
Signing
Date:23.07.2026 14:34
W.P.(C) 9014/2011
6.17. It is clarified however, that the petitioner was eventually promoted
to the post of Group General Manager w.e.f. 10.03.2006; and
subsequently, to the post of the Executive Director w.e.f.
16.05.2008, which is the highest executive level post in
respondent No.1 corporation, just below the position of the Board
of Directors. The petitioner superannuated from the post of
Executive Director on 31.12.2011.
REJOINDER SUBMISSIONS BY PETITIONER
7.
In rejoinder, learned counsel for the petitioner has made the following
additional submissions to specifically address the contentions raised on
behalf of respondent No.1:
7.1.
With respect to respondent No.1’s contention that the present
petition is infructuous, since the petitioner has long retired from
the post of Executive Director, it has been submitted that the
petition was filed prior to the petitioner’s retirement, and he is
challenging the action of respondent No.1 in not promoting the
petitioner w.e.f. 02.01.2003 to the post of Group General
Manager. It has been argued that the petitioner is entitled, in law
and in equity, to all benefits that would have accrued to him if he
had been promoted to the said post with effect from the said date.
It has been submitted that the petitioner's claim to receive those
benefits from the back date, based on a notional promotion from
the said date, still survives; and the petition is therefore not
infructuous.
7.2.
With respect to respondent No.1’s contention that the petition
suffers from delay and laches, it has been submitted that the
Signed By:VIKAS
RAWAT
Signing
Date:23.07.2026 14:34
W.P.(C) 9014/2011
petition was filed on 21.12.2011 raising the petitioner’s grievance
about a promotion which was not granted on 21.12.2005, and the
interim period of 06 years is fully explicable, and therefore, the
petitioner cannot be blamed for not having approached the court
earlier. It has been submitted that since the petitioner approached
the NCSC on 27.01.2006 but his case before the NCSC was
closed only on 01.11.2011, the cause of action for filing the
present writ petition arose only thereafter. It has been argued that
the cause of action to file the present writ petition arose only after
the petitioner had exhausted all statutory and Constitutional
remedies available to him. In support of this submission the
petitioner has placed reliance on Raghubir Jha vs. State of Bihar
& Ors. 5; Jogi Jha vs. State of Bihar & Anr. 6 and S.S. Rathore vs.
State of Madhya Pradesh 7. Furthermore, relying on State of U.P.
& Ors. vs. Raj Bahadur Singh & Anr. 8 it has been argued that, in
any case, no limitation period is prescribed in law for filing a writ
petition.
7.3.
Accordingly, it has been argued, that it is only the issue of laches
that needs to be examined; and whether the petition suffers from
laches of the kind that would disentitle him from claiming relief.
7.4.
Even in regard to the issue of laches, it has been argued, that there
are no laches on the petitioner’s part in filing the present petition,
since Articles 335 and 338 of the Constitution of India provide a
1986 (Supp) SCC 372, para 2
1995 Supp (4) SCC 400, para 2
(1989) 4 SCC 582, paras 17, 18, 20 & 22
(1998) 8 SCC 685, para 2
Signed By:VIKAS
RAWAT
Signing
Date:23.07.2026 14:34
W.P.(C) 9014/2011
separate mechanism to investigate and inquire into complaints
relating to the rights and safeguards available to persons
belonging to a Scheduled Caste. The argument is that the inquiry
conducted under those statutory mechanisms form part of the
remedies available to a public servant under the relevant service
rules; and therefore, the cause of action for filing the present writ
petition arose only after the dismissal/closure of the case by the
NCSC. i.e. on 01.11.2011; and the petitioner filed the present
petition promptly thereafter on 21.12.2011.
7.5.
It has been argued that there has been no delay on the petitioner’s
part in seeking redressal of his grievances at any stage, neither
before the departmental authorities of respondent No.1, nor before
the NCSC, nor even before this court. It has been submitted that
therefore, the present petition does not suffer from any delay or
laches.
7.6.
Insofar as respondent No.1's contention that the petitioner has
already availed his equally efficacious remedy before the NCSC,
and since that body has not considered it fit to grant him any relief
the matter should be deemed to be closed, the petitioner has
submitted that the NCSC only gives ‘recommendations ’and does
not pronounce ‘decisions’ in cases placed before it. For explaining
the role of the NCSC under Article 338 of the Constitution, the
petitioner has placed reliance on Union of India & Anr. vs.
National Commission for Scheduled Castes & Anr.9, where it
2014 SCC OnLine Del 3324, paras 16, 17
Signed By:VIKAS
RAWAT
Signing
Date:23.07.2026 14:34
W.P.(C) 9014/2011
was held that the NCSC is not an adjudicatory body; and that its
reports are only recommendatory in nature and cannot be equated
with decrees/orders passed by civil courts. It is pointed-out that
the said judgment also holds that the NCSC’s reports are not an
alternative to the hierarchical judicial system. Furthermore, it has
been argued that in Dr. Jaishri Laxmanrao Patil vs. Chief
Minister & Ors 10 the Supreme Court has also held that the reports
made by the NCSC are subject to judicial scrutiny.
7.7.
With respect to respondent No.1’s contentions relating to the
merits of the petitioner’s case, it has been argued that respondent
No.1 has made a misleading submission that the petitioner’s name
figured at Serial No. 3 in order of seniority and not merit. It has
been submitted that the Minutes of Meeting of the DPC held on
11.12.2002 and 26.12.2002 show that the list drawn-up by the
DPC was in order of merit. It has been argued that the preliminary
eligible list, which was drawn based on seniority, was superseded
when the DPC made a list in accordance with Regulation 7(6) and
Rule 19B(iii)(a). It has been argued that respondent No.1’s claim
that there was no suitable vacancy in the petitioner’s discipline,
viz., mechanical engineering, is also false and incorrect. It has
been further argued, that the vacancies available were only as per
merit, and ordinarily for E-8 level posts, there are no disciplinespecific vacancies. It has been argued that respondent No.1’s
refusal to grant promotion to petitioner in 2003 was in violation
(2021) 8 SCC 1, para 513
Signed By:VIKAS
RAWAT
Signing
Date:23.07.2026 14:34
W.P.(C) 9014/2011
of Rule 19B(iii)(a) of the Service Rules and Article 16 of the
Constitution of India.
DISCUSSION & CONCLUSIONS
8.
Upon a conspectus of what has been stated in the pleadings before this
court, and based on the submissions made by learned counsel appearing
for the parties, in the opinion of this court, the following considerations
are relevant for deciding the present case:
8.1. The petitioner, who has been in service of respondent No.1
corporation since 14.07.1975 and was promoted to the level of
General Manager (Mechanical) (E-7 level) with effect from
01.01.1997, is challenging the timing of his further promotion to the
post of Group General Manager (E-8 level) in the corporation.
8.2.
It is the petitioner’s case that though he was promoted to the post
of Group General Manager w.e.f. 10.03.2006, he should have been
granted that promotion w.e.f. 02.01.2003. It is the petitioner’s
contention that he fulfilled all criteria that were required for his
promotion in 2003 itself. He further contends that since he did not
get his promotion from 02.01.2003, he should now be granted
notional promotion from that date alongwith all consequential
benefits, since he was wrongfully denied promotion from the said
earlier date.
8.3.
Considering the large number of persons that respondent No.1
corporation employs, the corporation has a detailed and complex
promotional policy governed inter-alia by the ONGC Modified
Recruitment and Promotion Regulations, 1980 and ONGC
Limited Service Rules, 1995, which have been referred to
Signed By:VIKAS
RAWAT
Signing
Date:23.07.2026 14:34
W.P.(C) 9014/2011
respectively as ‘Regulations’ and ‘Service Rules’ in this
judgment.
8.4.
It is pertinent to note that Rule 20(2) expressly says that
“Promotion shall be made in accordance with the relevant
provisions in the ONGC Modified Recruitment and Promotion
Regulations 1980.”
8.5.
It is the undisputed position that the petitioner’s case is covered
by Regulations 7(6), 7(7), 7(8) and 7(11) and by Rule 20(2). The
relevant Regulations and Rules have been extracted above. The
scope, purport and operation thereof are paraphrased hereinafter.
8.6.
Regulation 7(1) provides that all promotions at respondent No.1
corporation would be considered by a Promotion Committee to be
constituted by the Appointing Authority in accordance with orders
issued from time-to-time by respondent No.1.
8.7.
Operationalising this rule, the Appointing Authority (in this case
the Chairman & Managing Director) constitutes a Board Subcommittee of Departmental Promotions, also called the
Departmental Promotion Committee or the DPC, which is tasked
inter-alia with the role of vetting candidates for promotion within
the various departments of the corporation.
8.8.
The DPC draws-up a list comprising its recommendations for
promotion and forwards it to the Appointing Authority in two
forms: one, in order of merit for posts for which merit is the
Signed By:VIKAS
RAWAT
Signing
Date:23.07.2026 14:34
W.P.(C) 9014/2011
criterion for promotion; and two, in order of seniority for posts for
which seniority-cum-fitness are the criteria.11
8.9.
The Appointing Authority is then required to consider the
recommendations of the DPC and pass such orders as it thinks fit.
If
the
Appointing
Authority
does
not
accept
any
recommendation(s) of the DPC, they are required to record
reasons for such non-acceptance in writing. 12
8.10. Promotion orders are finally issued subject to availability of
vacancies, and the names of officers who are not promoted are
kept in a list for filling-up vacancies that may arise in the future.13
Such a list is however valid only for a period of 06 months from
the date of its acceptance by the Appointing Authority, unless that
period is extended by the said authority. 14
8.11. Promotions to E-5 level and above are to be “merit promotion by
selection”.15
8.12. Under Regulation 7(11)(iii)(b) the scheme for merit promotion by
selection is further parsed-out in the following words, which bear
repetition:
“(11) The promotions will be carried out under
following three criteria:*****
“(iii)(b) Merit Promotion by Selection – Corporate
Promotions (E-5 level and above):
Regulation 7(6), ONGC Modified Recruitment and Promotion Regulations, 1980
Regulation 7(7), ONGC Modified Recruitment and Promotion Regulations, 1980
Regulation 7(8), ONGC Modified Recruitment and Promotion Regulations, 1980
ibid.
Regulation 7(11)(iii)(b), ONGC Modified Recruitment and Promotion Regulations, 1980
Signed By:VIKAS
RAWAT
Signing
Date:23.07.2026 14:34
W.P.(C) 9014/2011
(1)
The promotions at Corporate level (E-5
level and above) are based on Merit and qualification
scheme.
(2)
The marks are awarded for quantification,
experience, PARs and performance in the interview.
(3)
The qualifying marks are 60% in interview
as well as over all for general candidates and 40% for SC/ST
candidates.”
9.
The petitioner’s name was considered for promotion to the post of Group
General Manager by the DPC at its meetings held on 11.12.2002 and
26.12.2002 in the backdrop of the aforementioned policy and procedure
of ‘merit promotion by selection’. The petitioner has obtained the
minutes of the said meetings through RTI/other official channels. Copies
of the minutes have been appended to the petition.
10. In the “Preliminary Eligible list of GMs upto 01.01.1997 secured at least
70% of 30 maximum marks” drawn-up by the DPC for considering
promotions to the post of Group General Manager, the petitioner’s name
stood at Serial No.43 out of 46 candidates, since he had secured 21
marks, which was the minimum number of marks that he needed to score
to be on that list.
11. On considering his candidature at the meeting of the DPC held on
11.12.2002 and 26.12.2002, the DPC placed the petitioner’s name at
Serial No.3 for substantive promotion to Group General Manager (E-8
level) with the following opening narration as contained in the minutes
of the said meetings:
“1. The following criteria for selection has been adopted on
the basis of approval accorded by the Board in the 92nd meeting held
on 30th May 2002-
Signed By:VIKAS
RAWAT
Signing
Date:23.07.2026 14:34
W.P.(C) 9014/2011
a) … …
*****
e) Executives securing at least 70% of 30 maximum marks
i.e. 21 marks will form the “preliminary eligible list” to
be put up before the DPC in order of seniority.
*****
“3. The DPC decided that while selected executives are being
empanelled, promotions are to be released with the approval of the
Executive Committee, subject to availability of vacancies and
suitability of empanelled executives for specific assignments within
the approved CRC structure.
“4. DPC specifically advised that assignments/positions are
not to be created merely to accommodate any empanelled executive.
******
“9. The following executives are recommended for
empanelment as per the criteria mentioned above. The inter-se
seniority of the executives will be maintained on promotion.”
(emphasis supplied)
12. Some confusion has arisen essentially for the reason that the corporation
drew-up two separate lists:
12.1.One, the “Preliminary Eligible list of GMs upto 01.01.1997 secured
at least 70% of 30 maximum marks for consideration for the post
of ED/GGM”, which was based on the number of marks awarded
to the various officers based on their merit, wherein the petitioner
stood at Serial No. 43 out of a total of 46 candidates; and
12.2.Two, the empanelment list which was part of the “Proceedings of
meeting of the Board Sub Committee on Departmental Promotions
on 11th & 26th December, 2002 to empanel candidates for the post
of Executive Directors and GGMs”, which list was derived after
shortlisting candidates from the ‘preliminary eligible list’, and
which showed their names arranged in order of their inter-se
Signed By:VIKAS
RAWAT
Signing
Date:23.07.2026 14:34
W.P.(C) 9014/2011
seniority in the corporation, wherein the petitioner was placed on
Serial No. 3 out of 31 empaneled officers on the basis of his
seniority.
13. The aforesaid two lists were not independent of each other, and the
second list based on inter-se seniority was derived from the first list,
which was based on merit. As per policy, in relation to an E-8 level post,
an officer is to be promoted based on merit, without however upsetting
the inter se seniority of two officers who may be of the same merit. The
petitioner’s argument that once the ‘final eligible list’ is drawn-up, it
renders the ‘preliminary eligible list’ irrelevant, is accordingly
misconceived and cannot be accepted. The second list referred to above
is intended only to reflect the inter-se seniority; however this list does
not efface the clear requirement of regulation 7(11)(iii)(b), which
mandates that promotions to posts of level E5 and above are to be made
on the basis of merit.
14. The petitioner's name appears at Serial No. 3 in the list arranged as per
his seniority. However, promotion to the level of Group General
Manager (E-8 level) was required to be made on the basis of merit; and
based on merit the petitioner was placed at Serial No. 43. Furthermore,
the corporation has explained that there were 25 vacancies at the relevant
time, against which a list of 31 officers had been empaneled for
promotion. To be sure, not only the petitioner, there were also 5 other
officers who did not get promoted.
15. Respondent No.1 has also clarified that all officers promoted in the
mechanical engineering discipline had better performance appraisal
ratings and marks compared to the petitioner.
Signed By:VIKAS
RAWAT
Signing
Date:23.07.2026 14:34
W.P.(C) 9014/2011
16. It may further be observed, that in the opinion of this court, it is sound
policy that promotions to the level of Group General Manager (E-8 level)
be made on the basis of merit, since those positions are positions of high
responsibility in the corporation. Merely because a list was also drawnup on the basis of inter-se seniority of the officers would not detract from
the policy of merit-based promotions.
17. In any case, subsequently the petitioner was promoted to the post of
Group General Manger E-8 level w.e.f. 10.03.2006; and he eventually
superannuated from the post of Executive Director (E-9 level) on
31.12.2011.
18. Upon a conspectus of the submissions made by learned counsel for the
parties, and upon a close analysis of the documents filed with the
petition, this court is persuaded to accept respondent No.1’s contentions.
19. As a sequitur to the above, this court does not find any merit in the
petitioner’s challenge.
20. In light of the view taken by this court above, it is not considered
necessary to delve into any of the other submissions made on behalf of
the parties, including the submission relating to the scope and ambit of
NCSC’s role in matters of promotions; or on the issue of delay or laches;
or on the matter of interference by the court in administrative matters,
including promotions.
21. The present writ petition is accordingly dismissed.
22. Pending applications, if any, also stand disposed-of.
JULY 23, 2026/ds
ANUP JAIRAM BHAMBHANI, J
Signed By:VIKAS
RAWAT
Signing
Date:23.07.2026 14:34
W.P.(C) 9014/2011
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review