The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
10. What Section 227 and 239 Cr.P.C contemplates is that if upon consideration of the record of the case and the documents submitted therein and after hearing submission of the accused and prosecution in his behalf, the judge considers that there is no sufficient ground for proceeding against the accused, the accused shall be discharged. At the stage of consideration of discharge under Section 227 Cr.P.C or 239 Cr.P.C as the case may be, the court is not prepared to undertake a threadbare analysis of the materials gathered by the prosecution. The court has only to see whether there are sufficient grounds to proceed against the accused and to see whether the materials are sufficient to enable the court to initiate a criminal trial against the accused.
11. In Yuvraj Laxmilal Kanther v. State of Maharashtra 2025 KHC OnLine 6231, the Hon’ble Apex Court held as follows: “16. S.227 CrPC deals with discharge. What S.227 CrPC contemplates is that if upon consideration of the record of the case and the documents submitted therewith and after hearing the submissions of the accused and the prosecution in this behalf, the judge considers that there is no sufficient grounds for proceeding against the accused, he shall discharge the Crl.R.P.No.857 of 2018 2025:KER:27406 accused and record his reasons for doing so. At the stage of consideration of discharge, the court is not required to undertake a threadbare analysis of the materials gathered by the prosecution. All that is required to be seen at this stage is that there are sufficient grounds to proceed against the accused. In other words, the materials should be sufficient to enable the court to initiate a criminal trial against the accused. It may be so that at the end of the trial, the accused may still be acquitted. At the stage of discharge, court is only required to consider as to whether there are sufficient materials which can justify launch of a criminal trial against the accused. By its very nature, a discharge is at a higher pedestal than an acquittal. Acquittal is at the end of the trial process, may be for a technicality or on benefit of doubt or the prosecution could not prove…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Crl.R.P.No.857 of 2018
2025:KER:27406
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE M.B. SNEHALATHA
THURSDAY, THE 27TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 6TH CHAITHRA, 1947
CRL.REV.PET NO. 857 OF 2018
AGAINST THE ORDER IN C.M.P.NO.3476/2017 OF JUDICIAL
MAGISTRATE OF FIRST CLASS, NEDUMKANDOM
REVISION PETITIONER/ACCUSED:
JACOB P.PAUL @ THAMPI
PULIYATHU HOUSE, PULIYANMALA KARA, UDUMBANCHOLA
TALUK, IDUKKI DISTRICT,
BY ADVS.
SRI.V.JOHN SEBASTIAN RALPH
SRI.K.J.JOSEPH ERNAKULAM
SRI.V.JOHN THOMAS
RESPONDENT/RESPONDENT:
STATE OF KERALA
REPRESENTED BY THE PUBLIC PROSECUTOR,
HIGH COURT OF KERALA, ERNAKULAM - 682 031.
BY SMT.MAYA M.N.-PUBLIC PROSECUTOR
THIS
CRIMINAL
REVISION
PETITION
HAVING
COME
UP
FOR
HEARING 13.3.2025, THE COURT ON 27.03.2025 DELIVERED THE
FOLLOWING:
Crl.R.P.No.857 of 2018
2025:KER:27406
CR
M.B.SNEHALATHA, J.
------------------------------------------Crl.R.P.No.857 of 2018
------------------------------------------Dated this the 27th March 2025
ORDER
This revision petition has been filed by the accused in
C.C.No.275/2016 on the file of the Judicial First Class Magistrate
Court, Nedumkandam challenging the order of dismissal of
C.M.P.No.3476/2017, which was a petition filed by the accused
under Section 239 of Cr.P.C seeking discharge.
2. In short, Prosecution case is as follows:
The accused was the contractor of the construction works of
Balagram-Anyartholu-Puliyanmala road. After the completion of
the work, he produced bills and encashed ₹7,88,557.95/- from
the office of the Block Panchayath. Subsequently, it was revealed
that the invoices produced by him purported to be that of Indian
Oil Corporation Ltd. and Bharat Petroleum Corporation Ltd. for
purchase of 55706.27 Kg. of bitumen were fake invoices and not
issued
from
Indian
Corporation Ltd.
Oil
Corporation
and
Bharat
Petroleum
Accused thereby committed the offences
punishable under Sections 465, 468, 471, and 511 of 420 IPC.
Crl.R.P.No.857 of 2018
2025:KER:27406
3. Accused filed C.M.P.No.3476/2017 before the trial
court contending that the allegations levelled against him are
false; that he presented the bills after completing the work and if
there was any foul play as alleged by the prosecution, it is for the
officials of the Indian Oil Corporation and BPCL to answer to it;
that without the knowledge and aid of the officials of the Indian
Oil Corporation, the bitumen cannot be delivered to a conveyance
contractor out of way and could not obtain an exit pass to deliver
such
huge
quantity
of
bitumen
outside
the
undertaking.
Therefore, according to the accused, he is in any way responsible
for the veracity of the bills supplied to him by the conveyance
contractor which in turn was issued by the officials of Indian Oil
Corporation or BPCL. Accused has used the bitumen for the work
and the work was completed in the prescribed standards and
there was no complaint regarding the quality of the work or
deviations from the conditions.
It is the conveyance contractor
who
bitumen
remitted
the
amount of
towards
Indian Oil
Corporation or BPCL, which is revealed through the bills attached
to the charges and it was the conveyance contractor who
supplied the consignment and the concerned bills, which was
presented before the Block Panchayath for accounting purposes.
Crl.R.P.No.857 of 2018
2025:KER:27406
The allegations against the accused are baseless.
The learned
Magistrate dismissed C.M.P.No.3476/2017 which is impugned
herein.
4. The learned counsel for the accused contended that
the prosecution has no case that the government sustained any
loss nor they have got a case that the quality of the work done by
the petitioner was poor. The learned counsel vehemently pointed
out that the accused claimed the amount only for the work
carried out by him. It was further pointed out that the bitumen
(tar) is a product which is available only in refineries and the
investigating officers purposefully omitted the officials to arraign
as accused and the petitioner was made as a scapegoat. There is
no case for the prosecution that 55706.27 Kg of tar was not
utilized for the work nor they have got a case that the accused
claimed the value of the bitumen without utilising the said
quantity for the work done by him. They have also no case that
the work was substandard or of inferior quality. The learned
counsel further contended that since the prosecution has no case
that the accused is a maker of the alleged false bills, the offence
of forgery cannot lie against the accused and the charge under
Sections 465, 468, 471 and 511 of 420 IPC will not lie against
Crl.R.P.No.857 of 2018
2025:KER:27406
the accused.
5. Per contra, the learned Public Prosecutor contended
that while disposing a petition under Section 239 Cr.P.C, the
court
has
to
consider
only
the
materials
placed
by
the
prosecution; that the ample materials have been collected by the
prosecution to substantiate the prosecution case and therefore,
the learned Magistrate was right in dismissing the petition
seeking discharge.
6. It is trite that what can be looked into by the court at
the time of exercising the power under Section 239 Cr.P.C, are
the contents of the final report and the documents sent along
with it under Section 173 Cr.P.C. It should not make a roving
enquiry into the pros and cons of the matters and weigh the
evidence if he is conducting the trial and therefore there are no
grounds to interfere with the order impugned.
7. A perusal of the prosecution records would reveal that
in the 161 Cr.P.C statement of CW11 who was the Terminal
Manager of Indian Oil Corporation, he has stated that the four
invoices dated 10.12.2005, 22.12.2005, 26.12.2005, 3.1.2006
produced by the accused for purchase of bitumen, purported to
be issued by the Indian Oil Corporation were not issued by the
Crl.R.P.No.857 of 2018
2025:KER:27406
Indian Oil Corporation and the same are forged invoices.
Likewise, CW12 namely the Marketing Coordination Manager of
Bharat Petroleum Corporation Ltd, (BPCL) has also stated in his
161 Cr.P.C statement that the two invoices dated 12.12.2005 and
12.12.2005 produced by the accused before the authorities for
the purchase of bitumen purported to be issued by BPCL are
bogus and not issued by BPCL.
8. In a catena of the decisions, the Hon'ble Apex Court
held that at the stage of considering an application for discharge,
the court must proceed on the assumption that the material
which has been brought on record by the prosecution is true and
evaluate the material in order to determine whether the facts
emerging from the material, taken on its face value, discloses the
existence of the ingredients necessary to constitute the offence
and at this stage the probative value of the materials has to be
gone into and the court is not expected to go deep into the
matter and hold that the materials would not warrant a
conviction.
9. Thus it is crystallised judicial view that at the stage of
considering an application under Section 239 Cr.P.C, the court
has to consider whether prima facie there are sufficient grounds
Crl.R.P.No.857 of 2018
2025:KER:27406
for proceeding against the accused. At that stage the court is not
expected to appreciate the evidence to conclude whether the
materials produced are sufficient or not for convicting the
accused.
10. What Section 227 and 239 Cr.P.C contemplates is
that if upon consideration of the record of the case and the
documents submitted therein and after hearing submission of the
accused and prosecution in his behalf, the judge considers that
there is no sufficient ground for proceeding against the accused,
the accused shall be discharged. At the stage of consideration of
discharge under Section 227 Cr.P.C or 239 Cr.P.C as the case
may be, the court is not prepared to undertake a threadbare
analysis of the materials gathered by the prosecution. The court
has only to see whether there are sufficient grounds to proceed
against the accused and to see whether the materials are
sufficient to enable the court to initiate a criminal trial against the
accused.
11. In Yuvraj Laxmilal Kanther v. State of Maharashtra
2025 KHC OnLine 6231, the Hon’ble Apex Court held as follows:
“16. S.227 CrPC deals with discharge. What S.227 CrPC
contemplates is that if upon consideration of the record of the
case and the documents submitted therewith and after hearing
the submissions of the accused and the prosecution in this
behalf, the judge considers that there is no sufficient grounds
for proceeding against the accused, he shall discharge the
Crl.R.P.No.857 of 2018
2025:KER:27406
accused and record his reasons for doing so. At the stage of
consideration of discharge, the court is not required to
undertake a threadbare analysis of the materials gathered by
the prosecution. All that is required to be seen at this stage is
that there are sufficient grounds to proceed against the
accused. In other words, the materials should be sufficient to
enable the court to initiate a criminal trial against the accused.
It may be so that at the end of the trial, the accused may still be
acquitted. At the stage of discharge, court is only required to
consider as to whether there are sufficient materials which can
justify launch of a criminal trial against the accused. By its very
nature, a discharge is at a higher pedestal than an acquittal.
Acquittal is at the end of the trial process, may be for a
technicality or on benefit of doubt or the prosecution could not
prove the charge against the accused; but when an accused is
discharged, it means that there are no materials to justify
launch of a criminal trial against the accused. Once he is
discharged, he is no longer an accused.”
12.
In the case at hand, the prosecution has produced
ample materials before the court which would make out a prima
facie case against the accused and this is not a case where the
accused is entitled to get an order of discharge under Section 239
Cr.P.C as rightly found by the learned Magistrate. Therefore, this
Court finds no reason to interfere with the order impugned.
Accordingly, the revision petition stands dismissed.
Sd/M.B.SNEHALATHA
JUDGE
ab
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review