Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Judgment reserved on: 26.02.2026
Judgment pronounced on: 20.03.2026
Judgment uploaded on: 20.03.2026
+
W.P.(C) 1144/2026 and CM APPL. 5589/2026
ITGOA & ORS.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Nitesh Kumar Singh, Mr.
Mangesh Nayak & Mr.
Devender Singh, Advs.
versus
UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
Through:
.....Respondents
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KSHETARPAL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT MAHAJAN
JUDGMENT
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.:
1.
Through the present Writ Petition the Petitioners assail the
order dated 28.08.2025 passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal,
Principal Bench, New Delhi in Original Application No. 1705/2022
[hereinafter the „Impugned Order‟], whereby the Petitioners‟ claim for
pay parity between Private Secretaries and Senior Private Secretaries
serving in the Income Tax Department under the Central Board of
Direct Taxes, Ministry of Finance and their counterparts in the Central
Secretariat Stenographers‟ Service [hereinafter referred to as „CSSS‟]
came to be dismissed.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:19:58
2.
The Petitioners‟ case advanced on behalf of Private Secretaries
and Senior Private Secretaries serving in the Income Tax Department
is that the cadre represented by them had historically been treated at
par with its counterpart in the CSSS and that, despite the asserted
similarity in recruitment and duties, it thereafter came to be subjected
to differential pay treatment.
3.
The learned Tribunal, however, declined relief. It observed that
while parity may have existed historically, the divergence in pay
scales affirmed by successive Pay Commissions was rooted in the
distinction between Secretariat and non-Secretariat establishments.
Finding that such classification was based on expert recommendations
and lacked any illegality, the Tribunal upheld the Department of
Expenditure‟s order dated 07.01.2022, whereby the representation of
the Petitioners seeking pay parity with their counterparts in the CSSS
was rejected.
4.
The controversy traces its origin to the claim that the
stenographic cadre in subordinate offices had, for a considerable
period, been placed on a footing of parity with the corresponding
cadre in the CSSS. According to the Petitioners, this position came to
be altered in the course of successive Pay Commission revisions,
beginning with the Fourth Pay Commission, and the divergence
became more pronounced upon the grant of higher pay scales to
CSS/CSSS with effect from 15.09.2006.
5.
A central plank of the Petitioners‟ case is that recruitment to the
relevant stenographic posts is conducted through a common
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:19:58
competitive examination by the Staff Selection Commission. It is their
case that candidates selected through this process may thereafter be
appointed either in Secretariat establishments or in field offices, and
that the subsequent divergence in pay scales amounts to an
impermissible post-recruitment classification unsupported by any
material functional dissimilarity.
6.
Seeking restoration of parity, the Petitioner-association
addressed representations to the competent authorities, relying upon
the asserted historical equivalence, the common source of recruitment,
the overlap in duties, and the observations of the Sixth Central Pay
Commission regarding the role of field offices. These representations
culminated in the order dated 07.01.2022 issued by the Department of
Expenditure, Ministry of Finance, whereby the claim was rejected on
the ground that the pay scales applicable to Secretariat/Headquarters
establishments of the Government of India were not applicable to
offices functioning outside the Secretariat.
7.
Aggrieved by the aforesaid rejection, the petitioners approached
the learned Tribunal in O.A. No. 1705/2022. The challenge before the
learned Tribunal was founded principally on the common source of
recruitment through the Staff Selection Commission and the asserted
similarity in duties. The petitioners contended that the continuance of
differential pay treatment between the stenographic cadre in the
Income Tax Department and their counterparts in the CSSS lacked a
constitutionally sustainable basis.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:19:58
8.
The learned Tribunal was not persuaded to accept the said
contention. It was noticed that the Petitioners‟ own case was that
parity had existed up to the Third Central Pay Commission and that
the divergence emerged thereafter, beginning with the Fourth Pay
Commission
and
continuing
through
the
subsequent
Pay
Commissions. It took note of the Respondents‟ stand that a distinction
between Secretariat and non-Secretariat establishments had been
maintained in matters of pay structure and that such distinction stood
expressly reflected in the recommendations of the Sixth Central Pay
Commission. The Tribunal further observed that while the
Commission recognised the importance of field offices and adverted
to the desirability of parity between similarly placed personnel in field
offices and the Secretariat, it had at the same time made it clear that
such parity would remain absolute only up to the grade of Assistant
and that, beyond that level, complete parity might neither be possible
nor justified, having regard to hierarchy, career progression,
functional considerations, and broader service relativities.
9.
Proceeding on the above basis, and on the settled principle that
matters of pay fixation lie primarily within the domain of expert
bodies, the Tribunal found no illegality in the order dated 07.01.2022
of the Department of Expenditure. The Tribunal also placed reliance
on the decision of the Supreme Court in Union of India and Ors. v.
Manoj Kumar & Ors1, and accordingly, dismissed the Original
Application. Aggrieved thereby, the Petitioners have preferred the
present Writ Petition.
[2021] 8 S.C.R. 1161
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:19:58
10.
The issue that arises for consideration is whether the learned
Tribunal committed any legal infirmity in declining to interfere with
the denial of pay parity claimed by Private Secretaries and Senior
Private Secretaries serving in the Income Tax Department vis-à-vis
their counterparts in the Central Secretariat Stenographers‟ Service.
11.
The controversy falls to be examined in the light of the settled
principles governing judicial review in matters of pay fixation, the
relevance of the historical parity asserted by the petitioners, and the
legal sustainability of the distinction maintained between Secretariat
and
non-Secretariat
establishments,
as
reflected
in
the
recommendations of the Sixth Central Pay Commission.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE PETITIONERS:
12.
Learned counsel appearing for the Petitioners submits that the
Impugned Order proceeds on an erroneous appreciation of both the
factual foundation of the claim and the principles governing pay
parity. It is contended that the claim advanced by the petitioners is not
founded merely on identity of nomenclature, but on the asserted
historical parity between the cadre of Private Secretaries and Senior
Private Secretaries in the Income Tax Department and the
corresponding cadre in the Central Secretariat Stenographers‟ Service
(CSSS).
13.
It is further urged that recruitment to the relevant stenographic
posts is conducted through a common competitive examination by the
Staff Selection Commission, with identical qualifications and skill
requirements at the stage of entry, and that candidates so recruited
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:19:58
may thereafter be posted either in Secretariat establishments or in
subordinate offices. According to the petitioners, the subsequent
divergence in pay scales is thus the result of a post-recruitment
classification founded solely on the fortuity of placement,
notwithstanding the asserted similarity in recruitment and duties.
14.
Learned counsel also submits that the duties performed by the
cadre represented by the Petitioners are substantially similar to those
discharged by their counterparts in the CSSS and that no material
distinction in the functional profile of the two cadres has been shown
so as to justify differential pay treatment. In this regard, reliance is
placed on the comparative job profile table.
15.
It is lastly urged that the observations of the Sixth Central Pay
Commission, recognising the importance of field offices and
describing them as being at the cutting edge of administration, lend
support to the claim for parity rather than to its denial. Reliance is also
placed on decisions of the Supreme Court, in Union of India v.
D.G.O.F. Employees Association2 and Union of India v. Rajesh
Kumar Gond3 to contend that a long-standing parity, once recognised,
could not have been disturbed without a constitutionally sustainable
basis.
ANALYSIS AND FINDINGS:
16.
The controversy must now be examined in the light of the
settled principles governing claims of pay parity. A claim of parity
2023 INSC 995
2014 (13) SCC 588
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:19:58
cannot be adjudged on the simplistic premise that similarity of
designation, or even a broad overlap in duties, must necessarily result
in identity of pay scale. The doctrine of “equal pay for equal work”,
though firmly embedded in service jurisprudence, has never been
treated as a rule of mechanical application. The equation of posts for
the purposes of pay determination depends upon a constellation of
factors, including the source and mode of recruitment, qualifications
prescribed, the nature and quality of duties performed, the degree of
responsibility attached to the post, avenues of promotion, hierarchical
placement, and the larger administrative setting in which the post
operates.
17.
It follows that the burden lies upon the party asserting parity to
demonstrate that the posts sought to be equated are substantially
identical in their essential incidents. The Court does not presume
comparability merely because the nomenclature of the posts is similar,
nor can broad assertions of functional resemblance suffice. Unless the
factual foundation discloses equivalence in the material attributes
relevant to pay determination, the grant of parity would rest not on
adjudication but on mere assumption.
18.
There is a further limitation which must govern the exercise.
Matters relating to pay fixation and equation of posts lie preeminently within the domain of expert bodies and the executive. A
writ court does not function as a pay-fixation authority. Judicial
review in such matters is confined to examining whether the
classification adopted is manifestly arbitrary, founded on no
intelligible criterion, or otherwise vitiated by patent illegality. Where
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:19:58
the distinction drawn rests on relevant service considerations and
bears a rational nexus to the object sought to be achieved, judicial
restraint is not merely a matter of prudence but a doctrinal necessity.
19.
The Supreme Court in State of Bihar & Ors. v. The Bihar
Secondary Teachers Struggle Committee, Munger & Ors4 has
reiterated that the doctrine of “equal pay for equal work” is neither
abstract nor capable of mechanical application. Its invocation depends
upon a demonstrable equivalence in the material and structural
attributes of the posts concerned. The equation of posts and
determination of pay structures being matters of technical and policy
evaluation ordinarily entrusted to expert bodies, a writ court ought not
to substitute its own assessment merely on the basis of similarity in
designation or duties.
20.
The contention of the Petitioners founded on historical parity
must, therefore, be approached with circumspection. Historical parity
is not an irrelevant circumstance; it may furnish contextual
background and may justify scrutiny where the departure appears
arbitrary. However, past parity does not operate as an immutable
command. Historical parity cannot be invoked to fossilize a pay
structure or to preclude a conscious re-evaluation by an expert body
on altered service conditions or broader administrative considerations.
The true inquiry is not whether divergence has occurred, but whether
that divergence is legally arbitrary.
[2019] 7 S.C.R. 738
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:19:58
21.
Examined in the above doctrinal setting, the Petitioners‟ case
rests on three principal circumstances: historical parity, common
recruitment, and asserted functional overlap. These circumstances do
not, by themselves, furnish a sufficient legal basis for directing parity
of pay between two distinct categories of employees, namely,
Headquarters/Secretariat employees and non-Secretariat employees.
22.
The central difficulty in the Petitioners‟ case lies in the fact that
the distinction between Secretariat establishments and non-Secretariat
or field formations is not shown to have been introduced casually, nor
devised merely to defeat the present claim. The material noticed by
the Tribunal indicates that this distinction formed the subject of
express consideration before the Sixth Central Pay Commission. The
Pay Commission in its report observed that while field establishments
operate at the cutting edge of administration, parity between
Secretariat and field offices would remain absolute only up to the
grade of Assistant, and that beyond that level, complete parity might
neither be possible nor justified, having regard to hierarchy, career
progression, and service relativities.
23.
The significance of that qualification cannot be understated.
The Petitioners cannot be permitted to selectively appropriate the
Commission‟s observations favourable to field offices while
disregarding the specific limitation by which those observations were
expressly qualified. Expert recommendations must be viewed as an
integrated whole; they cannot be dissected so as to retain only those
segments that support the claim of the Petitioners.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:19:58
24.
The correctness of this approach, as noticed by the learned
Tribunal, finds support in the decision of the Supreme Court in Union
of India & Ors. v. Manoj Kumar & Ors (Supra). The Supreme Court
in Manoj Kumar has held that where the Pay Commission, having
adverted to the disparity between Secretariat and non-Secretariat
organisations, consciously framed separate recommendations, a
judicial direction granting absolute parity would render such
recommendations otiose.
25.
By seeking continuation of parity beyond the level consciously
recognised by the Pay Commission, the Petitioners essentially invite
this Court to substitute its own evaluation for that of the expert body.
Such an invitation must be declined in the interest of judicial restraint.
26.
The attempt of the Petitioners to distinguish Manoj Kumar
(Supra) on the ground that it arose in a different service context does
not materially advance their case. While parity claims are necessarily
service-specific, the principle emerging from the decision, that courts
ought not to efface a distinction consciously preserved by an expert
body, applies with equal force in the present case.
27.
The Petitioners have also placed emphasis on the circumstance
that recruitment to the entry-level posts is conducted through a
common competitive exam by the Staff Selection Commission.
However, the existence of a common recruiting agency and common
examination cannot, in law, be treated as a determinative test for pay
parity. The source of recruitment constitutes only one among several
factors relevant to the equation of posts. It cannot efface distinctions
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:19:58
arising from cadre deployment, functional setting, avenues of
promotion, organisational hierarchy, or the qualitative responsibilities
attached to the posts after appointment.
28.
The same reasoning applies to the submission founded on
historical parity. Service jurisprudence recognises that two cadres
may, at one point of time, have stood on a similar footing and yet
come to be treated differently as service structures evolve. Such
differentiation is not, by itself, constitutionally suspect. The inquiry
must always turn on whether the divergence rests on a rational basis.
In the present case, the divergence complained of is referable to the
distinction expressly noticed and maintained within the framework of
the Sixth Pay Commission‟s recommendations and the service
structure recognised therein.
29.
Reliance placed by the Petitioners on D.G.O.F. Employees
Association (Supra) does not carry their case further. That decision
arose in the context of employees serving in the Headquarters of the
Ordnance Factory Board, who were found to have enjoyed historical
parity with similarly placed headquarters staff in CSS/CSSS over
successive Pay Commissions, and where the High Court was held to
have merely corrected a discriminatory denial of the benefit of the
Sixth Central Pay Commission to such similarly placed headquarters
employees. In the present case, the controversy turns on the
distinction between Secretariat and non-Secretariat establishments, a
distinction expressly noticed and preserved in the recommendations of
the Sixth Central Pay Commission itself.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:19:58
30.
Nor does Rajesh Kumar Gond (Supra) advance the Petitioners‟
case. That decision turned on the circumstance that no material had
been placed before the Tribunal to demonstrate any meaningful
distinction in the functional requirements of the posts under
comparison. It was in that backdrop that the Tribunal granted relief,
the High Court affirmed the same, and the Supreme Court declined to
interfere. The present case stands on a different footing. Here, the
distinction between Secretariat and non-Secretariat establishments is
not left unsupported, but stands expressly recognised in the
recommendations of the Sixth Central Pay Commission and in the
service structure reflected therein. Rajesh Kumar Gond (Supra)
cannot, therefore, be read as laying down any general rule mandating
parity
across
Secretariat
and
non-Secretariat
establishments
irrespective of the governing service framework.
CONCLUSION:
31.
Viewed in its entirety, the Petitioners‟ case, founded on
historical parity, common entry-level recruitment, similarity of
designation, and an asserted overlap in functional duties, may furnish
a legitimate basis for administrative representation. It falls short,
however, of justifying a direction for pay parity in the face of a
distinction acknowledged and consciously preserved by the expert
body as part of the governing service structure.
32.
In view of the discussion aforesaid, the view taken by the
learned Tribunal warrants no interference.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:19:58
33.
The present Petition is, accordingly, dismissed. The pending
application also stands disposed of.
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.
AMIT MAHAJAN, J.
MARCH 20, 2026
sp/ad
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:19:58
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review