Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of Decision: 12th January, 2026
%
+
C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 44/2024 & I.A. 33003/2024
ITC LIMITED
.....Appellant
Through: Mr. Gaurav Pachnanda and Mr. J. Sai
Deepak, Senior Advocates with Ms. Meenakshi
Ogra, Mr. Tarun Khurana, Mr. Tapan Shah, Mr.
Udbhav Gady and Mr. Samrat S. Kang,
Advocates.
versus
THE ASSISTANT CONTROLLER OF PATENTS AND DESIGNS
AND ANR
.....Respondents
Through: Ms. Nidhi Raman, CGSC with Mr.
Om Ram and Mr. Arnav Mittal, Advocates for
R-1.
Ms. Swati Mittal, Ms. Manisha Singh, Mr. Abhai
Pandey, Mr. Manish Aryan, Ms. Meenakshi
Chotia, Mr. Nishant Rai and Ms. Akhya Anand,
Advocates for R-2.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE JYOTI SINGH
JUDGEMENT
JYOTI SINGH, J. (ORAL)
1.
This appeal is filed by the Appellant under Section 117A of The
Patents Act, 1970 (‘1970 Act’) challenging order dated 08.04.2024 passed
by Assistant Controller of Patents and Designs (‘Controller’), whereby postgrant opposition filed by the Appellant against Patent No. 377333 has been
rejected.
Digitally Signed
By:KAMAL KUMAR
18:40:09
C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 44/2024
2.
To the extent necessary, case of the Appellant is that Appellant is a
conglomerate having diversified presence in inter alia packaged foods,
personal care, education and stationery, cigarettes and cigars, hotels, agribusiness etc. with considerable goodwill and reputation, operating in the
country for more than 100 years. Appellant is also engaged in research and
development of cigarette products and has access to the latest technology for
cigarette manufacturing and is involved inter alia in the area of technology,
to which impugned patent relates. Respondent No. 2 is PHILIP MORRIS
PRODUCTS S.A. and Respondent No. 1 is the Controller, vested with
powers to discharge functions as per Section 73(2) and Section 73(3) of
1970 Act.
3.
It is stated in the appeal that Respondent No. 2 was granted Patent No.
377333 titled ‘NON-TOBACCO NICOTINE CONTAINING ARTICLE’.
on 20.09.2021 on application No. 201617006134 and the same was
published in the Patent Office Journal dated 24.09.2021. Post-grant
opposition was filed by the Appellant under Section 25(2) of 1970 Act on
23.09.2022, to which reply statement was filed by Respondent No. 2 on
22.11.2022. Opposition Board rendered its recommendations on 15.05.2023.
Hearing was fixed by the Controller for 10.11.2023, on which date the
Appellant and Patentee were heard and thereafter the post-hearing
submissions were filed by Respondent No. 2 on 24.11.2023 and by the
Appellant on 27.11.2023. On 08.04.2024, impugned order was passed by the
Controller rejecting the post-grant opposition and maintaining the patent.
4.
Assailing the impugned order dated 08.04.2024, Mr. Gaurav
Pachnanda, learned Senior Counsel for the Appellant strenuously urges that
a plain reading of the order reflects that the same is a ‘copy-paste’ of the
Digitally Signed
By:KAMAL KUMAR
18:40:09
C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 44/2024
contents of written submissions filed by Respondent No. 2 and there is no
independent application of mind or analysis of the grounds of opposition
raised by the Appellant in the post-grant opposition. To demonstrate this
illustratively, attention of the Court is drawn to paragraphs 65 onwards of
the impugned order, which contain the purported analysis, wherein the
Controller has dealt with teachings of prior-art documents D1-D7 and has
refused to accept that the impugned patent is obvious and lacks inventive
step under Section 25(1)(ja) of 1970 Act. Contents of paragraph 75 of the
impugned order, it is urged, are verbatim copy of the written submissions of
Respondent No. 2 in the context of opposition under Section 25(2)(f) read
with Section 3(e) of 1970 Act that the subject claim is not an invention. The
argument is that the order reflects total non-application of mind and lack of
independent analysis, which is not expected of quasi-judicial authorities.
5.
It is further urged that the Controller has mechanically and without
application of mind placed reliance on analysis and recommendation by the
Opposition Board given on 15.05.2023, without appreciating that the
Board’s report suffers from grave factual and legal errors. It is pointed out
that under the heading ‘Controller’s Inferences/Analysis’, Controller has in
paragraph 72 simply extracted paragraphs from the report and expressed his
agreement with the opinion of the Board on opposition under Section
25(2)(e) of 1970 Act. In the two sub-paragraphs of para 72 as also in
paragraph 73, while the the impression given is that
Board’s
recommendations are being independently analysed and the observations are
Controller’s own observations, the fact to the contrary is that these
paragraphs are verbatim copy-paste of Board’s recommendations. Basis
these alleged observations, Controller has concluded in paragraph 73 albeit
Digitally Signed
By:KAMAL KUMAR
18:40:09
C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 44/2024
erroneously that documents D1 to D7 either alone or in any possible
combination could not solve the problem in the patent and therefore, fail to
teach or suggest all features of claim 1 of the impugned patent. Owing to the
copy-paste, several factual omissions and errors, which form the basis of
recommendations of the Opposition Board can be glaringly seen as forming
the basis of rejection of opposition under Section 25(2)(e) of 1970 Act.
6.
Learned Senior Counsel submits that the copy-paste mechanism has
resulted in the impugned order being passed without application of mind and
mechanically and this is a reason enough to set aside the same. It is
submitted that as a quasi-judicial authority, dealing with matters of
grant/refusal of patents, the Controller is expected to act independently and
apply himself to the facts and material before him at all stages i.e. pre-grant,
grant/refusal of patent as also post-grant opposition. Post-grant opposition is
a serious stage in a patent process, as in a given case it is possible that the
patent may have been granted erroneously. Reliance is placed on the
judgments of this Court in Synthes GMBH v. Controller General of
Patents, Designs and Trademarks and Another, 2023 SCC OnLine Del
2729; and Huhtamaki Oyj and Another v. Controller of Patents, 2023 SCC
OnLine Del 3272; where the Courts set aside the impugned orders passed
by the Controllers only on the ground that the orders were merely cut-copypaste with no independent analysis or reasoning with serious observations
on the manner in which the Controllers were routinely passing orders
without reasons and/or even minimal application of mind.
7.
Without prejudice to the aforesaid argument, it is argued that even on
merits, the impugned order deserves to be set aside since the impugned
patent is obvious and does not involve any inventive step, which is evident
Digitally Signed
By:KAMAL KUMAR
18:40:09
C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 44/2024
from prior-arts D1-D7. The impugned patent discloses: (i) an aerosolgenerating rod comprising a sheet of non-tobacco material where the sheet is
gathered and circumscribed by a wrapper such that the sheet extends along
substantially the entire length and across substantially the entire transverse
cross-sectional area of the aerosol-generating rod; (ii) the sheet of nontobacco material is crimped and comprises a plurality of ridges or
corrugations substantially parallel to the cylindrical axis of the aerosolgenerating rod; (iii) the sheet of non-tobacco material comprises a sorbent
substrate, a nicotine salt and an aerosol-former; (iv) the sorbent substrate is a
sheet of non-tobacco cellulosic-based material and the nicotine salt and the
aerosol-former are coated or adsorbed onto the sheet of non-tobacco
cellulosic-based material in; (v) a ratio of aerosol-former to nicotine salt in
the sheet of non-tobacco material being between 3:1 and 10:1 in; and (vi) a
non-combustible smoking article like e-cigarette. Controller has completely
overlooked that D2 categorically states that proportion of humectants i.e.,
aerosol former such as glycerol is desirably in the range of 1% to 3%,
preferably 1.5% to 2.5% and the proportion of nicotine (nicotine salts such
as sulphate, citrate, malonate, malate etc.), when used is desirably in the
range of up to 2% and preferably 0.5% to 1.5%. Simple mathematical
conversion of ranges disclosed by D2 to ratios between the humectant and
nicotine/nicotine salt would evince that prior-art document D2 inherently
and by necessary implication teaches to use aerosol former and nicotine in
the claimed ratio though described in percentages, which when converted,
fall in the range of the ratios in the impugned patent and therefore, rejection
of opposition owing to lack of inventive step suffers from legal infirmity. D2
also categorically teaches to prepare a cellulosic paper and then to
Digitally Signed
By:KAMAL KUMAR
18:40:09
C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 44/2024
coat/impregnate the same with the additive comprising aerosol former and
nicotine/nicotine salt in ratio of 1:1 to 5:1.
8.
It is argued that the impugned patent is obvious and lacks inventive
merit as inter alia D1 relates to rods comprising a gathered sheet of
homogenised tobacco material for use in smoking articles, smoking articles
comprising such rods and methods for forming such rods. Comparison of D1
and impugned patent shows that D1 discloses an aerosol-generating rod
comprising a gathered sheet of homogenised tobacco material, wherein the
gathered sheet comprises one or more aerosol-formers circumscribed by a
wrapper and gathered sheet extends along substantially the entire length of
the rod and across substantially the entire transverse cross-sectional area of
the rod and the sheet is crimped and comprises plurality of ridges or
corrugations substantially parallel to the cylindrical axis of the aerosolgenerating rod. The difference resides in the composition of the rod i.e., use
of non-tobacco cellulosic material but this is already well-known in the art.
D1 teaches the use of non-tobacco fibres such as cellulose and the use of
aerosol formers and humectants in the context of impugned patent. The
prior art clearly teaches the draw backs of using tobacco substrate and
motivates the use of cellulosic sheet material as tobacco substitute in
smoking articles.
9.
It is urged that D2 discloses a tobacco substitute comprising a
combustible material together with minor proportions of flavouring and
other modifying agents, wherein the combustible material is cellulosic in
nature. D2 also teaches the use of humectants such as glycerol and nicotine
salt in the cellulosic formulation. D2 also teaches proportion of glycerol and
nicotine salt in the formulations:
Digitally Signed
By:KAMAL KUMAR
18:40:09
C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 44/2024
“The proportion of humectants is desirably in the range of 1 % to 3 %,
based on the total airdry weight of the tobacco substitute
The proportion of nicotine, when used, is desirably in the range of up to 2
%, based on the weight of the cellulose”
10.
Further, D2 teaches saturating/coating of the additives onto the
cellulosic paper as in the impugned patent and Example 4 of D2 teaches the
dipping of cellulosic paper into nicotine solution to form impregnated paper
which are then formed into cigarettes. Illustratively, D3 discloses smoking
material for use as substitute for tobacco prepared from natural leaf tobacco
and D4 relates to a tobacco substitute material made principally from
oxidized cellulose gauze or pulp and teaches the use of humectant in order to
prevent the tobacco substitute from drying out unduly. D4 also teaches the
impregnation of the cellulose sheets with additives. Submissions are also
made on the prior arts D5 and D6. The argument is that impugned patent is
obvious and lacks inventive step in light of D1 to D6 and starting from D1, a
person skilled in the art, with a view to develop a non-tobacco aerosolgenerating rod shall be motivated to replace the tobacco sheets with a
tobacco substitute comprising cellulosic sheets comprising nicotine salt and
aerosol formers in desired proportion, coated or absorbed onto the sheet of
non-tobacco cellulosic-based sheet read together with the teachings of D2 or
D2 and D5 or D2, D3/D4 and D5 or D2, D3/D4, D5 and D6 or D2, D3, D4,
D5 and D6.
11.
It is further argued that the impugned patent falls within the mischief
of Section 2(1)(ja) being devoid of inventive step, which requires that the
invention should be a technical advancement over the prior art or it should
show economic significance or both and should not be obvious to a person
Digitally Signed
By:KAMAL KUMAR
18:40:09
C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 44/2024
skilled in the art. The impugned patent is obvious to a person skilled in the
art and does not involve either technical advancement or any economic
significance. The patent also comes under the mischief of Section 3(e),
which states that “a substance obtained by a mere admixture resulting only
in the aggregation of the properties of the components thereof or a process
for producing such substance”, is not patentable under 1970 Act. The
claimed aerosol-generating rod comprises a sheet of non-tobacco material
comprising a sorbent substrate, a nicotine salt and an aerosol-former. The
sorbent substrate is defined as a sheet of non-tobacco cellulosic-based
material. The ratio of the aerosol-former to nicotine salt in the sheet of nontobacco material has been further defined in claim 1 as between 3:1 and
10:1. The components of cellulosic substrate, nicotine salt and aerosol
former and their combination for use in smoking articles is well known in
the art (D2-D6). Also, desired proportion of these components is known.
The sheet of non-tobacco material in the claimed aerosol-generating rod is
nothing but a mere admixture of components. Patentee has failed to provide
any experimental data in the impugned specification to demonstrate the
synergy between the components. There is also no data in the impugned
specification to show the effect of various combining ratios of aerosolformer to nicotine salt. In light of these grounds, learned Senior Counsel for
the Appellant submits that this is a fit case for remand to the Controller for
re-consideration of the post-grant opposition, after granting hearing to the
parties and looking into their oral/written submissions and the material on
record, including prior-arts D1-D7.
12.
Counsel for the learned Controller submits that the impugned order is
a well-reasoned, detailed and speaking order, passed after independent
Digitally Signed
By:KAMAL KUMAR
18:40:09
C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 44/2024
application of mind and analysis, after considering all documents on record,
including recommendations of the Opposition Board and detailed
arguments, written and oral, advanced by the Appellant and the patentee.
Appellant failed to discharge the burden that the patent deserves to be
revoked under Section 25(2) of 1970 Act. Controller carefully analysed all
prior-art documents D1-D7 and concluded that D1 to D7 either alone or in
any possible combination could not solve the problem in the impugned
patent and fail to teach or suggest all features of claim 1 of impugned patent
and hence the ground under Section 25(2)(e) was not sustainable.
13.
It is argued that the Controller correctly held that the invention
involved an inventive step. The inventive concept of granted claims does not
reside in any single feature but resides in the specific and new combination
of multiple features, which were not taught by the prior art and this specific
combination of features was not obvious. Prior arts like D2 to D4 relate to
combustible cigarettes and address a different technical problem i.e.,
controlling combustion and thus teach away from the claimed invention,
which is a heated, non-combustible system and a person skilled in the art
would not be motivated to look to these documents.
14.
It is further argued that even the closest prior arts D1 and D7 do not
render the invention obvious inasmuch as D1 discloses a homogenised
tobacco material and not a non-tobacco cellulosic substrate and fails to
disclose the use of nicotine salt or the specific 3:1 or 10:1 ratio. D7 makes
no mention of nicotine salts or of non-tobacco cellulosic substrate. D5
teaches casting a homogeneous slurry from the claimed invention, which
requires coating or absorbing the active ingredients onto a separate sorbent
substrate and this difference in the process results in a different product
Digitally Signed
By:KAMAL KUMAR
18:40:09
C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 44/2024
structure i.e., homogeneous vs. non-homogeneous and a different technical
effect i.e., faster release kinetics, which is not taught by D5. Appellant’s
argument that D2 discloses the claimed 3:1 to 10:1 ratio is fallacious.
Firstly, this strange method of calculating percentages and converting to
ratios was never raised before the Controller and secondly, the calculation is
flawed as it improperly conflates humectant for moisture retention in a
combustible product with aerosol-former for aerosol generation in a heated
product. Hence, the ground that the patent is obvious and lacks inventive
step is untenable in law.
15.
It is submitted that the Controller is right in concluding that invention
is saved from Section 3(e) of 1970 Act inasmuch as the granted claims are
for an article i.e., an “aerosol-generating rod” (claim 1) and a “system”
(claim 10) and not a “substance”. Controller righlty agreed with patentee’s
submission, which he is entitled to, that the invention was not a simple
admixture but was a meticulously crafted article with specific structural
limitations (gathered, crimped sheet) wherein the components (substrate,
nicotine salt, aerosol-former) work inter-dependently to achieve a
synergistic technical effect. This effect includes achieving rapid and
complete release of nicotine at low temperatures (120 O C to 140O C) without
the “dry puff” associated with prior art e-cigarettes. Controller correctly
observed that “the combination of a cellulosic substrate onto which a
nicotine salt and aerosol former are added is not disclosed in the cited prior
art documents” and “the desired proportion...is also not known”. Once the
combination and proportion are novel, invention cannot be a “mere
admixture” of known components. Hence, no ground is made out in the
appeal, warranting interference in the impugned order.
Digitally Signed
By:KAMAL KUMAR
18:40:09
C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 44/2024
16.
Learned counsel appearing for Respondent No. 2/patentee opposes the
appeal and submits that the impugned order is a well-reasoned and speaking
order, wherein the Controller has analysed each feature of independent claim
with respect to all grounds of opposition and documents cited therein. The
allegation that the order is a ‘copy-paste’ is baseless. Controller was bound
to take note of the submissions of the patentee and this cannot be construed
as if there is no independent analysis. All prior-art documents D1 to D7,
have been seen and accorded due consideration, both when read individually
and in combination. Agreeing with the patentee cannot imply that there is no
independent application of mind.
17.
It is inter alia argued that the invention claimed in the subject patent
had several essential features as can be seen from the claim specification and
provides technical advancement over prior art as follows:“a. End user will not have to handle liquid formulations as the nicotine
and aerosol former are coated onto sorbent substrate.
b. Use of nicotine salts may produce a nicotine-bearing aerosol at low
temperatures making the use of cumbersome aerosol generating device to
generate an aerosol with high levels of nicotine redundant.
c. Longer shelf-life than conventional e-cigarettes as nicotine used in salt
forms is more stable than the liquid freebase nicotine used in e-cigarettes.
d. The content of nicotine in the aerosol-generating article can be adjusted
and tailored by adjusting the content of nicotine salt.
e. By selecting specific cellulose based non-tobacco materials for the
sheet, it is also possible to tailor other geometric parameters (e.g., the
sheet thickness) as well as the tensile strength of the sheet in ways that
may not be possible with homogenized tobacco materials.
f. By collective structural and compositional modification, the associated
electronic nicotine delivery systems are able to provide nicotine level
similar to that of tobacco cigarette smoking without drawing deeper and
longer puffs thus addressing the phenomena of “dry puff”.”
Digitally Signed
By:KAMAL KUMAR
18:40:09
C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 44/2024
18.
It is urged that the Controller rightly concluded that there were key
differences between the prior-art documents D1 to D7 and the impugned
patent and the same can be summarized as follows:-
Digitally Signed
By:KAMAL KUMAR
18:40:09
C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 44/2024
Digitally Signed
By:KAMAL KUMAR
18:40:09
C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 44/2024
Digitally Signed
By:KAMAL KUMAR
18:40:09
C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 44/2024
Digitally Signed
By:KAMAL KUMAR
18:40:09
C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 44/2024
Digitally Signed
By:KAMAL KUMAR
18:40:09
C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 44/2024
19.
Learned counsel strenuously argues that Appellant has failed to prove
and discharge its burden as to why and how a person skilled in the art would
arrive at the invention in the subject patent, by the teachings of D1-D7,
taken individually or in combination. Appellant is resorting to a hindsight
analysis for determining the inventive steps, which is against the law as held
by this Court in Hoffmann-La Roche Ltd. & Anr. v. Cipla Ltd., 2015 SCC
OnLine Del 13619. To question the inventive step involved, Appellant
proceeds backwards from first obtaining the knowledge of the subject
invention and then looking for individual components of the subject
invention in different documents, bereft of context. This is mere mosaicing
of documents without any suggestion in any document as to which other
feature can be arrived at for making the subject invention obvious. The
hindsight approach has been recently also negated by this Court in the case
of Avery Dennison Corporation v. Controller of Patents and Designs, 2022
SCC OnLine Del 3659.
Digitally Signed
By:KAMAL KUMAR
18:40:09
C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 44/2024
20.
It is further argued that in order to establish a prima facie case of
obviousness, 3 criteria must be met: (a) prior art reference or references
must teach or suggest all the claim limitations; (b) there must be some
suggestion or motivation, either in the references themselves or in the
knowledge generally available to one ordinary skilled in the art to modify
the reference or to combine the teachings in the references; and (c) there
must be a reasonable expectation of success. For showing obviousness, it
must be shown that the person skilled in the art would have some apparent
reason to combine the known elements in the fashion claimed and there
must be a reasonable expectation of success. Further, mere disclosure of
individual generic elements on the basis of functional similarities in the prior
art references, would not motivate a skilled person to combine the elements
in a specific manner to arrive at an arrangement which would exhibit an
improved technical effect.
21.
It is submitted that neither D1 nor D7 teach the configuration and
structural features of the aerosol generating rod as claimed in the subject
patent. D6 does not teach the significance of crimping of sheets and D2-D4
do not teach use of non-tobacco cellulosic based sheet comprising nicotine
salt and humectants (aerosol formers) in desired proportion, coated or
absorbed onto the sheet of non-tobacco cellulosic-based material for an
aerosol-generating rod. A person skilled in the art with a view to develop a
non-tobacco aerosol generating rod shall not be motivated to replace the
tobacco sheets with a tobacco substitute comprising cellulosic sheets
comprising nicotine salt and aerosol formers in desired proportion, coated or
absorbed onto the sheet of non-tobacco cellulosic-based sheet read together
with the teachings of D2 or D2 and D5 or D2, D3/D4 and D5 or D2, D3/D4,
Digitally Signed
By:KAMAL KUMAR
18:40:09
C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 44/2024
D5 and D6 or D2, D3, D4, D5 and D6 or in any other combination. Thus,
the subject patent is neither obvious for a person skilled in the art nor lacks
inventive merit in view of the teachings of D1, D2, D3, D4, D5, D6 and D7
either alone or in combination and the ground of opposition under Section
25(2)(e) of 1970 Act is wholly misplaced.
22.
It is further submitted that recourse to Section 3(e) of the 1970 Act by
the Appellant is equally misplaced. Section 3(e) bars from patenting “a
substance obtained by a mere admixture resulting only in the aggregation of
the properties of the components thereof or a process for producing such
substance”. Language of claims 1-9, reflects that the aerosol-generating rod
is not arrived at by merely “mixing” the required components to form an
“admixture” and instead it is meticulously crafted to achieve specific
structural features, where each component is interrelated and the
interrelation was recognized not only by the Controller but also the
Appellant, while referring to opposition relating to Section 3(f). For the
same reason, there can be no quarrel with claim 10 which is directed to a
system and claims 11-12 directed to heated aerosol-generating articles. Even
otherwise, the components of the aerosol-generating rod of the subject
patent clearly have a synergistic effect that is not a mere admixture.
23.
Heard learned Senior Counsel for the Appellant and counsels for the
Respondents.
24.
The first and foremost objection of the Appellant is that the impugned
order is a cut-copy-paste of the written submissions of the patentee and the
opinion of the Opposition Board and there is no independent application of
mind and analysis of the grounds of opposition raised comprehensively in
the post-grant opposition by the Appellant. Arguments have been addressed
Digitally Signed
By:KAMAL KUMAR
18:40:09
C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 44/2024
on merits also, which have been very briefly captured above.
25.
Broadly understood, the preliminary submission of the Appellant is
that a bare perusal of impugned order dated 08.04.2024 shows that it
substantially reproduces the written submissions of the patentee and
recommendations of the Opposition Board and while that may be so, there is
no independent application of mind and analyses to the grounds raised in the
post-grant opposition, the material on record such as the prior art documents.
Mr. Pachnanda, has laboured hard to demonstrate the ‘cut-copy-paste’ by
taking the Court through various paragraphs of the impugned order and then
comparing with the written submissions of the patentee and the report of the
Opposition Board. For ready reference and better appreciation, the tabular
representation in the appeal is extracted hereunder, only by way of
illustration:-
Digitally Signed
By:KAMAL KUMAR
18:40:09
C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 44/2024
Digitally Signed
By:KAMAL KUMAR
18:40:09
C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 44/2024
Digitally Signed
By:KAMAL KUMAR
18:40:09
C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 44/2024
Digitally Signed
By:KAMAL KUMAR
18:40:09
C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 44/2024
Digitally Signed
By:KAMAL KUMAR
18:40:09
C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 44/2024
Digitally Signed
By:KAMAL KUMAR
18:40:09
C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 44/2024
26.
From a close reading of the impugned order, this Court finds merit in
the preliminary submission of the Appellant. Reading of the impugned order
shows that substantial part of the order is a cut-copy-paste and a verbatim
reproduction of the written submissions filed by the patentee. While the
impression given in the order is that under the heading ‘Controller’s
Inferences/Analysis’, the Controller has independently analysed the grounds
taken by the Appellant in the post-grant opposition, as rightly flagged by the
Digitally Signed
By:KAMAL KUMAR
18:40:09
C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 44/2024
Appellant, in effect it is not so. Paragraph 63 contains reference to Section
2(1)(ja) of 1970 Act and Manual for Patent office practice procedure
describing steps for evaluating the inventive steps. Paragraph 64 contains
references to the judgments. Paragraphs 65 to 71 incorporate references to
the prior-art documents D1-D7 and their teachings. Paragraph 72 is only an
extract of part of the recommendation of the Opposition Board. Albeit the
two sub-paragraphs of paragraph 72, according to the Respondents are
observations of the Controller on his independent analyses, but a close
perusal shows otherwise as these are recommendations of the Board taken
verbatim from the Report. It is thus clear that there is no independent
application of mind by the Controller and consequently, no independent
analysis on the grounds raised in the post-grant opposition.
27.
In the earlier part of this order, Court has referred to some of the
broad contentions of the Appellant raised in the post-grant opposition with a
view to show that detailed grounds of opposition were taken by the
Appellant. However, unfortunately, none of these have been independently
considered by the Controller and the order is nothing but a reproduction of
patentee’s written submission with sprinkling of recommendations of the
Opposition Board. This Court in Synthes (supra) and Huhtamaki Oyj
(supra) has seriously condemned the manner in which the Controllers are
passing the orders relating to patents. Courts have observed that the
impugned orders are merely cut and paste and while this is itself disquieting,
the Court may not have taken a serious note, had the Controllers
condescended to supplement the cut and pasted paragraphs with their own
reasoning, displaying some minimal application of mind, which was sadly
lacking.
Digitally Signed
By:KAMAL KUMAR
18:40:09
C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 44/2024
28.
Yet again, this Court is faced with another order where the Controller
has taken no pains to independently analyse the grounds taken in the postgrant opposition and has merely copy pasted. As rightly observed in Synthes
(supra), this is nothing but a total mockery of the exercise of functions
vested in quasi-judicial authorities in the Office of Controller General of
Patents. Grant of patent is indeed a very serious matter, especially,
considering the time ordinarily taken in granting patents. In a given case, an
opposition can include serious and genuine grounds for revocation.
However, if the Controller does not exercise the powers vested in him, in the
manner required in law, the result invariably will be that Courts will have no
option but to remand the matters, compelled by the fact that they are
unreasoned and non-speaking. This would be detrimental to the interest of
the patentee/objectors as also public interest as many genuine inventions
will remain a piece of paper and will not inure to anyone’s benefit. In the
present case, it pains the Court to remand the matter to the Controller, owing
to the fact that patent has been granted in favour of Respondent No. 2 on
20.09.2021.
29.
In light of the fact that the impugned order lacks independent analysis
and application of mind to the grounds taken by the Appellant in the postgrant opposition, the impugned order dated 08.04.2024 passed by the
Controller, rejecting the post-grant opposition is quashed and set aside and
the matter is remanded back for reconsideration, however, only from the
stage of hearing final arguments of the concerned parties. Needless to state
the Controller will look into the written submissions already on record
before the Controller and pass a reasoned and speaking order after taking
into consideration the arguments of the parties, both oral and written and in
Digitally Signed
By:KAMAL KUMAR
18:40:09
C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 44/2024
accordance with law.
30.
It is made clear that this Court has not expressed any opinion on the
merits of the case. The order will be passed as expeditiously as possible and
not later than eight weeks from the date the hearing concludes.
31.
The appeal is allowed to the aforesaid extent and disposed of along
with the pending application.
JYOTI SINGH, J
JANUARY 12, 2026/RW
Digitally Signed
By:KAMAL KUMAR
18:40:09
C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 44/2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review