Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:43114
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH SHIMLA
CMPMO No. 801/2025
Reserved on: 21.09.2026
Decided on: 05.10.2026
Ishwar Singh (deceased) through LRs
…..Petitioners
Versus
Roshan Lal
….Respondent
______________________________________________________________
Coram:
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Romesh Verma, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?1
For the Petitioners:
Mr. Bimal Gupta, Sr. Advocate with Ms.
Kusum Chaudhary, Advocate.
For the Respondent:
Mr. Tara Singh Chauhan, Sr. Advocate
with Mr. Surya Chauhan, Advocate
Romesh Verma, Judge
The present petition arises out of the order, dated
26.09.2025, as passed by the learned Senior Civil Judge,
Bilaspur, District Bilaspur, H.P., whereby the objections, as
filed by the judgment debtor came to be dismissed and the
execution
petition, as filed by the decree holders,
has also
been dismissed.
1Whether reporters of the local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Yes.
The facts as emerge in the present case are that the
decree holders/petitioners, filed a civil suit No. 86/1 of 1998 for
dismantling of the structure constructed on the suit land by the
judgment
debtor/respondent
and
handing
over
the
vacant
possession to the plaintiff. The judgment and decree dated
20.07.2005, as passed by the learned trial Court, reveals that the
decree holder had filed a suit for permanent prohibitory injunction
against the defendant to restrain him from raising construction over
the suit land comprised
in Khasra No. 380/259 and Khasra No.
385/260, comprised in Khewat No. 10, Khatoni No. 10, situated in
Up-Muhal Nihal, District Bilaspur, over which he had constructed
his house and in addition to that, Khasra No. 373/259 was kept
vacant, while Khasra No. 394/260 was being used as common path.
It was contended by the decree holder that the defendant
had encroached over path comprised in Khasra No. 394/260 and
started digging over Kharsa No. 380/259, belonging to the plaintiff,
for constructing pillars of the house. Though, initially, suit as filed by
the decree holder came to be dismissed by the learned trial Court,
however feeling dissatisfied, he preferred an appeal in the Court of
learned District Judge, Bilaspur. The learned first Appellate Court,
vide its judgment and decree, dated 02.09.2006 in Civil Appeal No.
66 of 2005, decreed the suit as filed by the decree holder. The decree
as passed by the learned trial Court was set aside, and it was held
that the decree holder is entitled to possession of the suit land
measuring 36 square
meters area encroached
upon by the
defendant, and further, he was restrained from interfering in the
remaining vacant possession. The suit came to be decreed by the
learned first Appellate Court by passing a decree of vacant
possession to the extent of 36 square meters as per the Tatima
attached with the demarcation report in the said suit.
It is an admitted fact that the defendant preferred a
regular second appeal before this Court, and the said appeal also
came to be dismissed. Thereafter, the decree holder instituted the
execution petition under Order 21 Rule 32 of CPC for dismantling of
the structure to the extent of 36 square meters on the basis of the
decree, as passed by the learned District Judge, Bilaspur, on
02.09.2006. In the execution petition, it was prayed that that
structure over 36 square meters of the suit land, as mentioned in
Tatima attached with the demarcation report in the land comprising
Khasra No.380/259/1 measuring 15 square meters and Khasra No.
385/260/1 measuring 21 square meters and vacant possession be
handed over to the decree holder.
In the execution petition, warrant of possession was
issued against the judgment debtor in terms of the decree. For the
execution of the decree, local Commissioner was appointed to
execute the warrant of possession. Before the warrant could be
executed, the parties entered into a compromise on 15.11.2018. The
said agreement was placed on record by the Local Commissioner,
who had gone to execute the decree.
The parties had undertaken by virtue of the agreement
to fulfill terms and conditions,
as specified therein, instead of
enforcing the decree. It was incorporated in the agreement that in
order to have cordial relation between the parties, judgment debtor
agreed to pay a sum of Rs. 4 lakh to the decree holder, for which he
issued cheque No. 673635 dated 15.11.2018 for a sum of Rs. 3 lakh
to be encashed immediately, and the other cheque No. 673636 of Rs.
1 lakh to be encashed on 10.01.2019. Further, the J.D./respondent
was required to construct a concrete cement wall from the bottom of
the cantilever on or before 10.04.2019, as per the satisfaction of the
decree holder, with regard to length, breadth, and height and space
to be occupied by the wall.
When the agreement was placed before the learned
executing Court, though the J.D./respondent
submitted to the
Court that in terms of the agreement, he has complied with the
same, however, the said fact was specifically denied by the decree
holder.
In order to resolve the issue, the learned executing Court
issued commission vide its order dated 02.04.2022 appointing Mr.
Vijay Thakur, Advocate, to visit the spot and report compliance. As
per the report of Mr. Vijay Thakur, Advocate, he returned the finding
to the effect that he was not competent to report regarding the
nature of the construction of the retaining wall. Thereafter, on the
basis of the application, which was filed to appoint another Local
Commissioner, Junior Engineer of H.P. Public Works Department
was directed to visit the spot and to file his report. The Junior
Engineer in his report stated that he dismantled the portion of the
wall in question covering an area of 1 meter in length, 15 centimeter
thick, but could not find any steel in the same and he concluded
that local material, i.e. Murram, has been used for the construction.
Therefore, it is not an RCC wall.
To the said report, the J.D./respondent filed the
objections, wherein it was stated that the report as submitted by the
Junior Engineer is not proper, legal and effective in the eyes of law.
As per the J.D./respondent, the Local Commissioner, in order to
verify the quality of strength and material, dismantled/dug in the
gap in each portion of the constructed portion, dismantled about 01
meter length and 15 centimeter thick, and found that the steel bar in
the Danga has not been utilized, whereas local material in the
disputed wall has been used. It was further stated that when the
J.D./respondent started raising construction of RCC Danga for
safety of his house, at the relevant time, decree holder did not make
any objection in that regard and the concrete wall is good in
compression and strength, as the same is around about 2 ½ feet
wide.
It is the case of the objector/J.D. that he is not a
professional Junior Engineer, but he is promoted by the Department
from labour class to Junior Engineer. Further, he is not having
degree and diploma in Civil Engineering, which clearly shows that
his unprofessional work during inspection of the disputed wall
caused great loss to the J.D. It was stated in the objection that the
report of the Local Commissioner is not based on the real facts, but
is imaginary one. Therefore, fresh Local Commissioner be appointed
by appointing Executive Engineer or Assistant Engineer of the HP
Public Works Department, Bilaspur, by directing him to visit the spot
and to inspect the disputed wall and report to the Court.
The said objections were duly replied by the decree
holder and all the averments as made in the objection were
specifically refuted and denied. As per the decree holder, Local
Commissioner had visited the spot and checked the quality and
material used in the construction of the disputed wall. As per decree
holder, it was found that ‘murram’ material has been used while
raising the construction of wall and even the steel has not been used
in the same. The Local Commissioner found that the steel bar has
not been used while raising the Danga. Therefore, it was denied that
the J.D. has complied with the terms and conditions of the
agreement dated 15.11.2018. It was stated that Junior Engineer is
an expert and he was appointed with the consent of both the parties,
therefore,
there
is
no
question
of
appointing
fresh
Local
Commissioner.
The learned Executing Court, vide its impugned order
dated 26.09.2025, while dismissing the objections as filed by the
judgment debtor also dismissed the execution petition as filed by the
decree holder on the ground that no further proceedings can be
undertaken beyond the scope of decree.
Feeling dissatisfied, the decree holder/petitioner has
approached this Court by assailing the impugned order passed by
learned executing Court.
It is contended by Mr. Bimal Gupta, learned Senior
Advocate, duly assisted by Ms. Kusum Chaudhary, Advocate, for the
petitioners that the impugned order as passed by the learned
executing Court is erroneous and liable to be quashed and set aside.
He has submitted that learned executing Court has not appreciated
the point in controversy and has closed the execution petition in a
very casual and routine manner. He
has urged that the present
petitioner/decree holder is fighting for his cause for the last more
than 28 years and he is being harassed by the respondent/J.D. on
one pretext or the other. He has contended that the Courts are
meant to impart substantial justice and should not decide the cases
on mere technicalities. He has submitted that after accepting the
present petition, the impugned order is liable to be quashed and set
aside and the executing Court be directed to execute the decree in its
letter and spirit.
On the other hand, Mr. Tara Singh Chauhan, learned
Senior Advocate, duly assisted by Mr. Surya Chauhan, Advocate, has
defended the impugned order. He has submitted that the learned
executing Court has rightly decided the point in controversy and
there is no illegality or perversity in the same. He has submitted that
the judgment debtor/respondent, in compliance to the agreement
which was entered between the parties, has fulfilled the terms and
condition thereof in its letter and spirit and nothing remains to be
done by the J.D., and since the decree stands fully satisfied,
therefore, the present petition deserves to be dismissed.
I have heard the learned counsel for the parties and have
also gone through the records of the case carefully.
The petitioner/plaintiff had instituted the suit for
permanent prohibitory injunction seeking to restrain the defendant
from raising construction over the suit land, over which the plaintiff
had constructed his house, in addition thereto, Khasra No. 373/259
had been kept vacant, and Khasra No. 394/260 was being used as
common path. It was stated by the plaintiff in the said suit, which
was filed in the year 1998, that the defendant had encroached over
the path comprised in Khasra No. 394/260 and then he had started
digging over Khasra No. 380/259 belonging to the plaintiff for raising
the construction of the pillars of his house. Though, initially, the suit
came to be dismissed by the learned Trial Court, thereafter, the
appeal which was preferred by the plaintiff/decree holder in the
Court of learned District Judge was allowed vide judgment and
decree dated 02.09.2006 in Civil Appeal No. 66 of 2005, whereby,
after setting aside the decree of the learned trial Court, the plaintiff
was held entitled for decree of possession of the suit land measuring
36 square meters as encroached upon by the defendant/J.D. and
further, the J.D. was restrained from interfering over the suit land in
any manner.
The suit was decreed for vacant possession of 36 square
meter on the strength of the Tatima attached with the demarcation
report. Thereafter, admittedly, the defendant/J.D. preferred regular
second appeal before this Court that also came to be dismissed by
this Court.
In the execution, when the warrant of possession was
issued by the learned executing Court, on 15.11.2018, parties
entered into an agreement, whereby it was agreed upon by the LRs of
decree holder, Ishwar Singh, and the J.D. that the J.D. shall make
payment of Rs. 3 lakh, which shall be immediately encashed by the
decree holders, and thereafter, cheque amounting to Rs.1 lakh will
be encashed on 10.01.2019 in favour of the decree holder. In the
said agreement, it was agreed upon by the J.D. that he shall
construct a cement wall/Danga, (RCC wall/Danga) from the bottom
of the cantilever on or before 10.04.2019. Further, it was agreed
upon that the J.D. shall not raise any other construction, save and
except the concrete cement wall/Danga. The J.D. shall construct
RCC wall/Danga as per the directions of the decree holder with
respect to length, breadth, height, and space which will be occupied
by the reinforced concrete cement wall/Danga (RCC wall/Danga).
Clause 6 of the agreement reads as under:“That the second party will withdraw the petition which is
pending before the executing court, Civil Judge (Sr. Div.),
Bilaspur, H.P. when the first party has complied with all the
terms and conditions mentioned above. Further, if the first
party fails to comply with the above mentioned terms and
conditions as agreed between the first party and second party
the amount which is paid by the first party through the cheque
in favour of the second party will be forfeited and the executing
proceeding will continue against the first party.:
When the warrant of possession was issued by the
learned executing Court, before the decree could be executed, the
parties entered into an agreement, and the said agreement was
placed on record by the local Commissioner, who had visited the spot
to execute the same. Initially, the Court had appointed Mr. Vijay
Thakur, Advocate, as Local Commissioner for seeking compliance in
order to resolve the controversy between the parties. However, he
reported that he is not competent to report regarding the nature of
the construction of the retaining wall. Therefore, he submitted the
report to the Executing Court. Thereafter, in another application,
Junior Engineer, HP Public Works Department, was appointed as a
Local Commissioner to visit the spot and report compliance with
respect to the resolving of the issue inter se the parties.
The copy of the report, dated 07.03.2024 as submitted
by the said Junior Engineer has been placed on record at page 23 of
the paper-book. He had sought permission from the Court that a
small portion of the wall is required to be dismantled, but the J.D.
has refused for the dismantling of the said Danga, raising safety
concern. Thereafter, after seeking permission from the Court on
03.04.2024, the Local Commissioner filed his report, which reads as
under:-
“As per order of this Hon'ble Count dated 18/01/2004 and
further dated 7-3-2004, I went to the disputed spot with
labour in the presence of both parties. The wall as measured
is 11.80 mts. in length and 3.30 mts. in height constructed at
spot.
It is further submitted that in the presence of both the parties
five Nos. different portion of said wall has been been
dismantled/digging in gaps for cheek the steel and each
portion dismantled
about (1.00 mts in length and 15 cm
thick). But steel has has not been found in wall/ danga. Local
material (muram) has been used for the construction of wall. It
is not RCC wall at site.
It is therefore report submit for kind information please.”
In the report, it was submitted by the Junior Engineer,
H.P. Public Works Department, that while raising the construction,
steel has not been found in the wall/Danga, and local material,
(Murram), has been used for the construction of the wall and as per
his report, the wall as constructed is not a RCC wall at site.
It has been contended by the learned Senior Counsel for
the J.D./respondent that since, as per the terms and condition of the
agreement, his client has paid the entire agreed amount of Rs.4
lakhs to the present petitioner/decree holder, and the said fact has
been duly acknowledged by the decree holder, therefore, the present
proceeding have been initiated just to harass the J.D. for nothing.
On
the
other
hand,
it
is
case
of
the
decree
holder/petitioner that the payment of Rs.4 lakh was a condition
precedent in order to fulfill the terms and conditions of the
agreement, which have been incorporated in the agreement,
especially in clauses 3 and 6 thereof.
As per Clause 3 of the agreement, the J.D. had agreed to
raise the construction of a wall/Danga, (RCC wall/Danga), from the
bottom of the cantilever on or before 10.04.2019. It was agreed that
the RCC wall/Danga shall be constructed as per the directions of the
decree holder with regard to the length, breadth, height, and space
which will be occupied by the said reinforced concrete cement
wall/Danga.
It is the grievance of the present petitioner/decree holder
that the judgment debtor has not complied with the terms and
conditions of the agreement and has not raised RCC wall/Danga on
the spot and has constructed a wall by using local material,
(Murram), which is in violation to the spirit of the agreement.
The learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner has
vehemently harped on clause 6 of the agreement, whereby it has
been categorically stated that the decree holder shall withdraw the
petition which is pending before the Executing Court, when the first
party complies with all the terms and conditions as stipulated in the
agreement. In the said clause, it has further been stipulated that in
case J.D. fails to comply with the terms and conditions of the
agreement, in that event, the decree holder shall be entitled to forfeit
the said amount, and the execution proceedings shall continue
against the J.D.
It has been contended by the learned Senior
Counsel that since condition No. 3 of the agreement has not been
complied with by the judgment debtor, therefore, the impugned order
by closing the execution petition is bad in the eyes of law.
From the perusal of the impugned order, it is apparent
on the face of record that primarily, the learned executing Court has
been swayed away by the fact that since a sum of Rs.4 lakh has been
received by the decree holder, therefore, nothing remains to be done
in the present proceedings, and based upon that, it closed the
execution petition.
This Court is not in agreement with the findings as
recorded by the learned executing Court. The Court has to maintain
balance between the parties and is of the considered opinion that the
decree holder is fighting for his cause for the last more than 28
years. The LRs of decree holder were kind enough to compromise the
matter with the J.D. after obtaining the decree of possession to the
extent of 36 square meters. Despite entering into an agreement and
despite of the fact that the decree holder, after being successful from
this Court, in order to resolve the issue, entered into an agreement
with the J.D./respondent, this Court has to see the agreement in its
totality in conjunction with the pleadings and other material placed
on record. Merely the fact that a sum of Rs.4 lakh has been paid to
the decree holder will not absolve the J.D. from his part of
performance. The learned executing Court has not discussed or
touched the other points as raised by the decree holder/petitioners
in the impugned order.
There is a specific report of the Local Commissioner,
dated 03.04.2024 which is appended with the present petition at
page 24, whereby it has been observed by the Local Commissioner
that in order to check the steel, small portion of the Danga was
dismantled, but no steel was found in the wall. As per the report, for
raising the construction of the wall, local material/Murram has been
used for the construction, and there is no RCC wall at site.
This Court is in agreement with the submission of the
learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners, whereby in clause 3 of
the agreement, it has been stipulated that the J.D. shall construct a
cement wall/Danga, (RCC wall/Danga), from the bottom of the
cantilever on or before 10.04.2019. Further, there is a condition that
the J.D. shall raise RCC wall/Danga as per the direction of the
decree holder. There is a categorical stipulation in the agreement
whereby the J.D. was required to construct RCC wall on the spot.
The
consideration
learned
report
of
executing
Court
the
Commissioner
Local
has
not
taken
into
in
true
its
perspective. Neither it has discussed the report of the Local
Commissioner, nor it has bothered to deal with the same.
In order to maintain balance between the parties, it was
incumbent
upon
the
executing
Court
to
have
taken
into
consideration the entire material placed on record and thereafter to
have rendered the findings either way. This Court is of the
considered opinion that the learned executing Court has not passed
a speaking order and has not dealt with all the issues which were
raised by the respective parties, including the petitioners.
Mere payment of Rs. 4 lakh to the decree holder will not
absolve the J.D. from performing his part of the agreement, as the
raising of RCC wall/Danga was a sine qua non in conjunction with
the payment of Rs.4 lakh to the decree holder. But the impugned
order does not deal with those issues as raised by the petitioners,
and this Court is of the opinion that the agreement which was
entered between the parties has not been dealt with by the learned
executing Court in its true perspective, as a result of which the
impugned order is not sustainable as no reasons have been
assigned.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in Maya Devi (dead)
through LRs vs. Raj Kumari Batra (dead) through LRs, (2010) 9
SCC 486 has held as under:“24. In Union of India & Ors. v. Jai Prakash Singh & Anr.
2007 (10) SCC 712, reasons were held to be live links
between the mind of the decision maker and the
controversy in question as also the decision or conclusion
arrived at.
30. Recording of reasons in cases where the order is
subject to further appeal is very important from yet
another angle. An appellate Court or the authority ought
to have the advantage of examining the reasons that
prevailed with the Court or the authority making the
order. Conversely, absence of reasons in an appealable
order deprives the appellate Court or the authority of that
advantage and casts an onerous responsibility upon it to
examine and determine the question on its own. An
appellate Court or authority may in a given case decline to
undertake any such exercise and remit the matter back to
the lower Court or authority for a fresh and reasoned
order. That, however, is not an inflexible rule, for an
appellate Court may notwithstanding the absence of
reasons in support of the order under appeal before it
examine the matter on merits and finally decide the same
at the appellate stage. Whether or not the appellate Court
should remit the matter is discretionary with the appellate
Court and would largely depend upon the nature of the
dispute, the nature and the extent of evidence that may
have to be appreciated, the complexity of the issues that
arise for determination and whether remand is going to
result in avoidable prolongation of the litigation between
the parties. Remands are usually avoided if the appellate
Court is of the view that it will prolong the litigation.”
The
Hon’ble
Supreme
Court
in
Assistant
Commissioner, Commercial Tax Department, Works Contract
and Leasing, Kota vs. Shukla and Brothers, (2010) 4 SCC 785
has held as under:“19. Besides referring to the above well-established principles,
it will also be useful to refer to some text on the subject. H.W.R.
Wade in the book "Administrative Law, 7th Edition, stated that
the flavour of said reasons is violative of a statutory duty to
waive reasons which are normally mandatory. Supporting a
view that reasons for decision are essential, it was stated:".....A right to reasons is, therefore, an indispensable part of a
sound system of judicial review. Natural justice may provide
the best rubric for it, since the giving of reasons is required by
the ordinary man's sense of justice...
.....Reasoned decisions are not only vital for the purposes of
showing the citizen that he is receiving justice: they are also a
valuable discipline for the tribunal itself....."
28. The order in the present case is as cryptic as it was in
the case of Sunil Kumar Singh Negi (supra). Being a
cryptic order and for the reasons recorded in that case by
this Court which we also adopt, the impugned order in the
present appeal should meet the same fate.”
Without going into the merits of the main case, this
Court is of the considered opinion that the impugned order is liable
to be quashed and set aside by relegating the parties to the learned
executing Court, who shall decide the case afresh on the material
placed on record by passing a speaking order after affording an
opportunity to the respective parties. Ordered accordingly.
Consequently, after setting aside the impugned order as
passed by learned executing Court, the parties are relegated to the
learned executing Court with a direction to it to decide the case
afresh in view of the observations made hereinabove.
Parties are directed to appear before the learned
executing Court on 16.10.2026.
The instant petition is disposed of, in the aforesaid
terms. Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
05.10.2026
(pankaj)
(Romesh Verma)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review