Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
+
RFA 38/2020
IRFAN SAIFI
S/o Md. Ramjane,
R/o House No. 98, Village - Sirodhan,
PO: Mathrawali, PS-Dholana,
District-Hapur (UP).
Through:
.....Appellant
Ms. Surabhi Mahajan, Advocate
versus
1.
ASHOK BIDHURI
S/o Sh. Bhuie,
R/o H. No. Bhangar Mohalla (Bhangar Chowk),
Village-Madanpur Khadar,
PO Sarita Vihar, New Delhi.
2.
SH. KAMAL CHAUHAN
S/o Sh. Ranjit @ Khuda
R/o Chauhan Mohalla,
Village- Madanpur Khadar,
PO Sarita Vihar, New Delhi.
3.
MD. SHAHZAD
S/o Noor Mohammad @ Fatwa
R/o H. No.C-49, Gali No.6, Block-C,
Near Samosa Chowk,
Madanpur Khadar Extn. Pt-I,
PO Sarita Vihar, New Delhi.
Through:
.....Respondents
Appearance not given.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 09/04/2026 at 13:03:56
%
1.
ORDER
13.03.2026
Regular First Appeal under Section 96 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
1908 (CPC) has been filed on behalf of the Appellant against the Judgment
dated 27.09.2019, whereby the Suit of the Plaintiff for Declaration,
Injunction and Possession in respect of Suit Property admeasuring 300
square yards with built up construction situated in Khasra No. 731, Revenue
Estate of Madanpur Khadar (hereinafter referred to as the “Suit Property”),
has been dismissed on a preliminary issue about the maintainability of the
Suit.
2.
As per the Plaintiff/Appellant, he is the owner of the Suit Property
having purchased the same from one Rasheed S/o Babu vide notarized GPA,
Agreement to Sell, Deed of Will, Possession Letter and Payment Receipt,
etc., all dated 13.07.2013. Rasheed in turn, had purchased the property from
Mahabir Singh S/o Muse Ram vide two documents, one for 200 sq. yards,
and another for 100 sq. yards, through registered GPA, Agreement to Sell,
Will and receipt, all dated 03.02.2000.
3.
The Plaintiff stated that he had been residing in his native village and
used to frequently visit the Suit Property. On 01.01.2014 when he came to
the property to have a picnic party. However, on 03.01.2014 between 6.30
a.m. and 7.00 a.m., the Defendants came with gundas and forcibly entered
into the property. The Police was called and Defendant No. 4 asked the
parties to come to the Police Station. Later, the Plaintiff came to know that
Defendants No. 1 and 3 had forged documents in respect of the Suit
Property and were trying to sell the same.
4.
The Plaintiff thus, filed the Suit bearing No. 11056 of 2016 (initially
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 09/04/2026 at 13:03:56
the case had been filed before this Court bearing Suit No. C.S.(O.S.) No. 426
of 2014 but had thereafter been transferred to the District Court) for
Declaration to be declared as the owner of Suit Property; Decree of
possession against the Defendants, and also for injunction to restrain the
Defendants from creating the third-party interest in the Suit Property.
5.
The Defendants in their Written Statement, took the preliminary
objection that the Suit is not maintainable as Plaintiff is neither the owner
nor in possession of the Suit Property. He has no locus standi as the
documents on the basis of which he is claiming title over the Suit Property,
were forged and fabricated, as well as being unregistered, have no value in
the eyes of law.
6.
A further objection was taken that the Suit was bad for misjoinder of
parties as Defendant No.2 and Defendant No.3 had no concern with the
dispute. The Plaintiff had also not approached the Court with clean hands
since Defendant No.1 had purchased the Suit Property from Pushp Lata vide
notarised GPA, etc., on 30.12.2013, who in turn had purchased it from
Mahabir Singh vide registered documents dated 15.05.2000.
7.
On merits, all the averments made in the Suit, were denied.
8.
In the replication, the Plaintiff reaffirmed and reiterated that it being
an unauthorised colony, there are no fixed plot numbers, of which the
advantage is being taken by the Defendants.
9.
The formal issues were framed on 19.09.2016 as under:
(i)„Whether Plaintiff is entitled to Decree of declaration of ownership in
respect of Suit property, bearing no. Plot measuring 300 Sq. yards (Size
60 ft x 45 ft), with built up one room and boundary wall situated at
Kanchan Kunj, Madanpur Khadar, Extn. Part-II, falling in Khasra no.
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 09/04/2026 at 13:03:56
731 in Revenue State of Madanpur Khadar? OPP.‟
(ii) Whether Plaintiff is entitled for the Decree of Possession of Suit
Property? OPP.
(iii) Whether Plaintiff is entitled for Permanent Injunction thereby
restraining the Defendants for selling, transferring and creating any third
party interest in the abovesaid of the Suit Property? OPD.
(iv) Whether the Suit of the Plaintiff is liable to be dismissed as it is based
on forged and fabricated documents in respect of the Suit Property? OPD.
(v) Whether the Plaintiff has no cause of action against the Defendants in
filing the present Suit? OPD.
(vi) Relief.
10.
Issue No. 1 was treated as a preliminary issue.
11.
The learned District Judge, on the basis of record and after hearing the
arguments, concluded that the documents on the basis of which the Plaintiff
is claiming to be an owner, cannot be looked into against the Defendant and
therefore, the issue of maintainability of the Suit was decided against the
Plaintiff and was dismissed.
12.
Aggrieved by the said dismissal of the Suit, the present Appeal has
been filed.
13.
The grounds of Appeal are that the Judgment is bad in law and on
facts and is liable to be set aside. No fair chance has been given to the
Plaintiff to adduce the evidence to prove its case in accordance with law.
14.
It has not been appreciated that the Appellant who is a poor village
carpenter, had paid Rs.12 lakhs as consideration for purchase of Suit
Property. It has also not been considered that the site plan filed by the
Defendants/Respondents is entirely different from the one filed by the
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 09/04/2026 at 13:03:56
Appellant. It has not been appreciated that the Appellant has been forcibly
dispossessed from the Suit Property by the Respondents, in collusion and
connivance with the Police officials. The Appellant has been deprived of the
Suit Property which legally belonged to him, by the Respondents by illegal
and foul means. The facts and circumstances have not been correctly
appreciated. Hence, the prayer is made that the impugned Judgment be set
aside.
15.
The learned Counsel for the Appellant has essentially argued on the
similar lines as the grounds stated in the Appeal. It is submitted that the
Appellant had come into possession of the Suit Property by virtue of
Agreement to Sell, etc., dated 14.07.2013. The Respondents are claiming the
superior title on similar documents dated 30.12.2013. There is a discrepancy
in the description of the property and the site plan. The Plaintiff was in
legitimate possession of the Suit Property, though was illegally dispossessed
on 03.01.2014. His documents of title being prior to that of the Respondents,
he is entitled to the declaration; and at least protection of the possession as
sought in the Suit.
16.
Learned Counsel for the Respondents, who has appeared on an
advance Notice, stated that the original owner from whom the Plaintiff as
well as the Respondent has purchased the property is Mahabir.
The
Plaintiff/Appellant claimed that the property was sold by Mahabir to
Rasheed from whom the Plaintiff has purchased the property by virtue of
GPA, Agreement to Sell, etc., dated 14.07.2013.
17.
However, according to the Defendants, Mahabir Singh had sold the
property to Pushp Lata from whom it has been purchased by the Defendants
on 30.12.2013. It is asserted that the documents of the Respondents confer a
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 09/04/2026 at 13:03:56
valid title on him and he is in possession by virtue of these documents and
he cannot be dispossessed. It is further submitted that there are no
substantial grounds of challenge raised in the terms of the Appeal and it is
liable to be dismissed.
Submissions heard and record perused.
18.
Plaintiff / Appellant has filed the Suit seeking Declaration of
ownership, Injunction and Possession in respect of the Suit Property, on the
basis of Agreement to Sell, GPA, Will and Receipt dated 14.07.2014, having
purchased the property from one Rasheed, who had purchased the property
through GPA, etc. on 03.02.2000 from Sh. Mahabir Singh.
19.
On the other hand, Respondents were also claiming ownership in the
Suit Property on the basis of similar set of documents i.e. GPA, Agreement
to Sell, etc., having purchased the property from Pushp Lata on 30.12.2013,
who had in turn, purchased the property from Sh. Mahabir Singh on
15.05.2000.
20.
What thus, emerges from these rival documents of Appellant and
Respondents, is that both have allegedly purchased the Suit Property on the
basis of Agreement to Sell, GPA etc. and both trace their chain of ownership
from Mahabir Singh. The Documents placed on record further reflect that
Mahabir Singh purchased this property from Shiv Ram, through GPA dated
15.04.1999.
21.
Pertinently, in none of these two chains of documents, is there any
mention about who was the original owner or allottee of the Suit Property.
There being no complete chain of documents; neither the Appellant nor the
Respondents have any conventional document of Sale Deed in their favour,
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 09/04/2026 at 13:03:56
in their respective chain of documents of ownership.
22.
The next question is what is the evidentiary value of these documents,
executed in favour of the Plaintiff /Appellant and whether they create any
ownership right in respect of the Suit Property in favour of the Appellant.
The first document relied upon by the Appellant, is Agreement to Sell dated
14.07.2013, but it needs no reiteration that mere Agreement to Sell may
confer the right to get a Sale Deed executed or to seek Specific Performance
of Agreement to Sell, but per se, it does not create any right, title or interest
in the Suit property, in favour of the Appellant / Plaintiff.
23.
Likewise, Receipt and GPA, etc. may only be auxiliary documents in
respect of Agreement to Sell creating a right of getting a Sale Deed
executed, but they do not create any ownership right in favour of the
Plaintiff / Appellant and no Declaration of ownership on the basis of these
documents, can be made in favour of the Appellants.
24.
Section 54 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 (Hereinafter
referred to as “TPA”) provides that any transfer of ownership rights in any
Suit Property, can only be by way of Registered Sale Deed.
25.
In this regard, learned District Judge has rightly relied upon Suraj
Lamp & Industries Pvt. Ltd. vs. State of Haryana & Anr., SLP (C)
No.13917/2009, wherein it has been held that sale of an immovable property
can only be vide registered documents. Only legal proceedings, in which the
unregistered documents can be relied upon, are for Specific Performance of
contract, as per the amended Registration Act. Recognizing such a
transaction as that of Sale, would be ignoring the laws of the land and
accepting illegal / fraudulent transactions against the exchequer, as requisite
stamp duty has not been paid.
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 09/04/2026 at 13:03:56
26.
In the present case, as has been noted above, the same plot of land has
been exchanging hands from one party to other, on the basis of Agreement
to Sell, Receipt, etc., without there being any legal basis and without
establishing as to who is the legal owner of the Suit Property and whether
indeed any of the prior GPA Holders had any ownership right in the Suit
Property. It may be a hard case, where Plaintiff / Appellant may have
entered into some transaction, but the same is not in accordance with law
and he cannot take benefit of such documents.
27.
Defendants may also be having similarly inchoate documents, but it is
the Plaintiff herein, who is claiming right, title and interest in the Suit
Property. Learned District Judge has rightly held that the Plaintiff cannot be
held entitled to Declaration of ownership and this relief was rightly
declined.
28.
The next question, which may be of significance, is the right of
protection of possession on the basis of these documents. Section 53A TPA
recognizes the protection of possession, on the basis of these documents.
However, in order to claim protection, requisite documents through which
an interest is asserted to be created in the Suit Property, has to be necessarily
registered.
29.
Unfortunately, in the present case, neither the Agreement to Sell nor
Receipt are registered and therefore, no benefit of Section 53A TPA can be
claimed by the Appellant. Even otherwise, it is the admitted case of the
Appellant that he is not in possession of the Suit Property. He claims that he
was forcibly dispossessed on 04.01.2014 for which, he had even made a
Complaint to the Police. Once he has lost the possession, he is not even
entitled to protection of Possession or Permanent Injunction, when he has
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 09/04/2026 at 13:03:56
no documents of title / ownership in his favour.
30.
Learned District Judge has rightly, dismissed the Suit of Plaintiff /
Appellant.
31.
There is no merit in the Appeal, which is hereby, dismissed along
with pending Applications.
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
MARCH 13, 2026/N/R
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 09/04/2026 at 13:03:56
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review